Lesson 1
Condominium Ownership
A separate interest in a unit, combined with an undivided interest in everything shared
What a Condominium Owner Actually Owns
One deed conveys two interests at the same time
A condominium is property developed for co-ownership, where each co-owner has a separate interest in an individual unit combined with an undivided interest in the common areas. Most condominium developments are residential. They can also be commercial or retail. A condominium is real property, and the unit owner holds a fee simple deed to the individual unit.
Hold those two halves in your head, because one deed conveys both of them. The unit is the interior airspace of a specific apartment, owned individually. The common areas are everything else, owned by all the unit owners together as tenants in common. A condominium is structured, physically and legally, to combine individual ownership with co-ownership.
That structure is why condominiums are called non-controlling and are considered separate entities. The interior space of each unit is owned individually. The owner of unit 2B owns 2B and nobody else owns any part of it.
Chapter 7 gave you the ownership answer for a condominium in one line: fee simple in the unit, an undivided interest in the common areas, one deed for both. This chapter starts from that line and asks the questions a working agent actually gets asked. What are the common areas. Who pays for them. What happens when a neighbor stops paying. What transfers when the unit sells.
WHAT EVERYONE OWNS TOGETHER
Common areas, also called common elements, are the land and improvements in a condominium, planned unit development or cooperative that all residents use and own as tenants in common. The exterior of the buildings. The grounds and the landscaping. Lobbies, hallways, stairways and elevators where they are shared space. Streets, sidewalks and parking lots inside the development where they are not public streets. Laundry facilities. Recreational facilities such as a swimming pool, a gym or a party house.
Some condominiums and cooperatives also have limited common areas, which are owned by all but used by only one owner. A balcony that extends out into the air is owned by everyone and used by the owner of the apartment it hangs off. A designated parking space is the other standard example. The word designated, or the word assigned, is the tell. It says the space is exclusively for one owner's use even though every other unit owner owns the land under it.
Owned by all, used by one
Maintenance fees, also called common area expenses, are monthly fees paid by each condominium owner or cooperative shareholder for common area costs. Utilities. Management. Building maintenance and upkeep. The fees are typically based on the percentage of the undivided interest owned by each unit owner, so the owner of a larger unit with a larger percentage pays more. Unpaid maintenance fees can result in a lien against that specific unit.
That percentage is worth finding before you quote a maintenance number to a buyer. It was assigned when the condominium was created, it is written into the declaration, and it does not move because a unit changed hands. Two apartments on the same floor with different square footage carry different percentages, and the larger percentage carries the larger share of every common expense the building has.
Hypothetical. A buyer compares two units in the same Brooklyn condominium. The seventh-floor unit is a little larger than the fourth-floor unit and carries a larger percentage of the undivided interest. Her monthly common charge is higher for that reason alone, and so is her share of any special assessment the board levies for the roof. Nothing about the view or the finishes changed the number. The declaration did.
The fees also buy the insurance, and the insurance splits along the same line the deed does. Maintenance fees purchase hazard and liability insurance for the common areas of the property and the exteriors of the structures. Each individual unit owner buys insurance that covers only the interior of the unit and the owner's personal property. A buyer who assumes the building's policy covers her kitchen cabinets has misread what she bought.
WHEN AN OWNER DEFAULTS
This is the part of condominium ownership that reaches a real conversation with a real client. In the event of a default on the mortgage, an individual owner's lender can place a lien against that specific unit and its undivided interest in the common areas. If the lien holder forecloses, only that unit and its undivided interest are affected. The rest of the condominium is not. Property taxes are levied against each unit separately, so a neighbor's unpaid taxes stay a neighbor's problem.
The other half of the rule runs the same way. When a condominium unit is sold, the undivided interest in the common areas and membership in the owners association transfer automatically with it. An individual unit cannot be sold without transferring the interest in the common areas. There is no version of this deal where a buyer takes the apartment and leaves the hallway behind.
CAUTION: A first-time buyer will ask whether a neighbor's foreclosure can take the building down. For a condominium the answer is no, and you should be able to say why in one sentence: the lien attaches to that unit and its undivided interest, and nothing else. Hold that answer, because the answer for a cooperative is different, and the difference is the whole second half of this chapter.
The lien stops at the unit line
REMEMBER: Stand in a condominium lobby and name three things you are looking at. Which of the three did the buyer get a deed to, which does she own an undivided share of, and which one does she pay to insure?
Lesson 2
Creating & Running a Condominium
From the Horizontal Property Acts to a managing agent with keys to the boiler room
From Statute to Managing Agent
Condominium Act, Real Property Law Article 9-B
Condominium ownership does not happen on its own. A statute has to make it possible, because someone has to be able to say what a buyer owns when the thing being bought is a box of air on the ninth floor. Every state has passed laws that create the legal framework for the condominium form of ownership. Those laws are known collectively as the Horizontal Property Acts, and they make it possible to define actual ownership rights.
Defining the rights is what unlocks everything else. Once ownership of a unit can be described in law, a lender can write a mortgage on it and a tax authority can assess it. Without that framework there is no condominium market at all.
That is the practical reason the statute comes first on this screen. A lender will not lend against something the law cannot describe, and an assessor cannot bill something the law does not recognize. The Horizontal Property Acts made the description possible, and the mortgage and the tax bill followed.
New York's version has a name and a number. The Condominium Act, Article 9-B of the Real Property Law, is New York State's law governing the establishment of condominiums. Some of what it stipulates: condominium unit owners must comply with specific bylaws; copies of bylaws and floor plans must be made available to unit owners; information on the election of board managers and the duties of the board, through the bylaws, must be made available; and information on expenses charged to unit owners must be communicated.
Read that list as a disclosure list. Every item on it is something an owner is entitled to see. A board that refuses to produce the bylaws, or refuses to say what an assessment is for, has stepped outside the statute the condominium was created under. Owners are entitled to that information, and entitlement is the whole shape of the list.
THE FIVE STAGES, IN ORDER
Property can be developed as a condominium from the ground up, or an existing building can be converted to one. Either way the sponsor runs the process. The sponsor, also known as the developer, is the person, corporation or other entity that is part of the sale and development of the condominium or cooperative property.
Stage one is the filing. Sponsors begin by filing articles of incorporation, which define the condominium association as a corporate entity and provide some personal protection against legal liability. The sponsor then files a condominium declaration, files an offering plan, files bylaws, and establishes and records the CC&Rs. The declaration, the bylaws and the CC&Rs are the next screen, and the offering plan is the screen after it. They are the paper the building stands on.
Stage two is construction or conversion. The condominium is built, or an occupied rental building is converted under an eviction plan or a non-eviction plan.
Stage three is the certificate of occupancy. Stage four is the owners' association, made up of all unit owners, which elects a board of managers from among themselves. Stage five is the managing agent, whom the board usually hires to run the building day to day.
THE CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY
In New York, all buildings built after 1938 are required to have a permit called a certificate of occupancy, issued to the builder or developer after all inspections have been made and the property is deemed fit for occupancy. The certificate describes the legal use and occupancy of the building. Under New York's Uniform Fire Prevention and Building Code it is required for all work for which a building permit was required, and whenever the general occupancy classification for a building is changed.
In New York a certificate of occupancy is issued by the Department of Buildings. The developer or a representative contacts the department to schedule the necessary inspections, including electrical, plumbing and construction. The certificate can be issued only after the construction matches the submitted plans, all applicable laws, ordinances and regulations have been followed and approvals obtained, the necessary paperwork has been completed, and department fees have been paid.
A licensee selling new construction meets this certificate as a date on a calendar. Inspections get scheduled, inspections get failed, inspections get rescheduled, and the closing moves with them. When a buyer asks why her closing slipped again, the honest answer is often that the Department of Buildings has not signed off yet, and no amount of pressure on the sponsor changes that.
There are two types. A final certificate of occupancy and a temporary certificate of occupancy, the TCO. Both must be stamped DOB Certified to verify that they are an authentic Department of Buildings document, and the Department of Buildings holds the status of individual properties. Most residential transactions, condominium development included, carry a clause in the contract of sale stipulating that the property must be in compliance with the certificate of occupancy.
NOTE: There have been cases where developers obtained mortgage financing without a final certificate of occupancy. That remains the exception, because it is a large financial risk and it carries other problems besides. Treat a deal with no final certificate as the exception it is, and send your buyer to counsel.
THE BOARD'S POWER TO ASSESS
Once the owners elect the board, the board gets a power worth knowing. Through the power of the Condominium Act, the board of directors has the power to levy assessments to pay for maintenance fees. If a unit owner fails to pay an assessment, a lien may be placed against the unit by recording a certificate of lien. That is the enforcement mechanism behind every maintenance bill in the building.
Filing, building, C of O, board, agent
REMEMBER: Name the five stages in order without looking. Then say which stage the building you are standing in is at, and who is running it today.
The Declaration, the Bylaws and the CC&Rs
Three recorded documents and the board they create
Three documents govern a condominium, and they do three different jobs. The declaration says what the property is. The bylaws say how the association runs. The CC&Rs say what an owner may and may not do with the place. New licensees mix them up constantly, and a client asking whether she can paint her front door red is asking about exactly one of the three.
THE MASTER DEED, ALSO CALLED THE DECLARATION
State condominium laws require a condominium developer to prepare a master deed, also known as a condominium declaration. The sponsor files this document with the county auditor when the property is developed as, or converted to, a condominium.
The declaration does six things. It declares the property a condominium. It describes the land, the units and the improvements, often including land and floor plans of the buildings. It identifies the maximum number of units that can be in the development. It identifies the percentage of the undivided interest in the common elements assigned to each unit. It provides for the maintenance and upkeep of the common areas. And it provides for the establishment of a condominium association.
The fourth of those six is the one that follows an owner for as long as she owns the unit. The percentage of undivided interest assigned in the declaration is what her maintenance fee is calculated on and what her vote is weighted by. It was set before she ever saw the building.
Each unit owner is bound by the master deed. Each unit owner also has a unit deed, which documents ownership of that specific unit. Two deeds, two jobs. The master deed creates the condominium. The unit deed conveys one apartment inside it.
THE BYLAWS
Bylaws are the rules and regulations that govern the activities of the condominium and cooperative associations. They include the purpose of the building, the rules for elections and voting, and the frequency of board of directors or shareholders meetings. Bylaws also set the rules about when sponsors are required to turn over management of the condominium or cooperative to board members.
That last item is the one the Attorney General watches. According to the Attorney General's regulations, sponsors promise in the offering plan that they will give up control of the board of managers after they sell more than 50 percent of the common interest, or after five years have passed since the first closing, whichever comes first.
More than 50 percent sold, or five years
Read the rule with the words whichever comes first attached, because that is where the exam and the real dispute both live. A sponsor who has sold 60 percent of the common interest has passed the threshold. A sponsor six years past the first closing has passed the other one. Either one on its own ends sponsor control. Selling every last unit was never the standard.
THE CC&RS
Condominium developers also establish and record a declaration of covenants, conditions and restrictions, the CC&Rs, which creates a general plan of private restrictions for a subdivision. CC&Rs might stipulate that owners cannot paint their front doors certain colors, cannot install a satellite dish, can use only white holiday lights outside, or can have only a certain type of patio furniture.
The purpose of CC&Rs is to keep the community attractive and uniform and to protect its market value. For a condominium development, the CC&Rs dictate the rules unit owners and their guests are required to follow. They are binding on all unit owners and are usually enforced by the condominium association. Penalties for violating them can include fines, lawsuits by the condominium association, or forced compliance.
THE ASSOCIATION AND THE BOARD OF MANAGERS
A condominium's owners' association is made up of all unit owners. Every owner is a member by virtue of owning a unit. The association's board members, known collectively as the board of directors or the board of managers, are elected by association members and are responsible for following the condominium's bylaws and making decisions on behalf of the condominium owners.
The board is responsible for the common areas, including maintenance, repairs, utilities, taxes and insurance. Some issues are referred back to the association as a whole for a vote. The board of directors usually does not handle day-to-day duties. Most properties have a managing agent who directly oversees building activities, manages building staff and takes care of maintenance issues.
Hold on to the difference between CC&Rs and house rules, because they come back in the cooperative lesson and they are not the same animal. The CC&Rs are recorded, they run with the property, and the association enforces them against owners and guests. House rules are the building's own internal rules, and a board can amend them by a majority vote of the shareholders. Recorded restrictions are hard to change. House rules are not.
NOTE: Sort a client's question by which document answers it. What is my percentage and how many units are there: the declaration. When does the board meet and how is it elected: the bylaws. Can I put a satellite dish on my balcony: the CC&Rs. Who do I call about the broken elevator: the managing agent.
REMEMBER: A buyer hands you three documents from a condominium package. Which one tells her what her maintenance fee is based on, and which one tells her whether she can keep a kayak on the patio?
Reading an Offering Plan
The Martin Act, General Business Law Article 23
An offering plan, also called an offering statement, is a document provided by the sponsor that offers detailed information regarding the condominium or cooperative property being developed. According to the New York Attorney General's office, an offering plan must be developed and presented before a building is developed. The plan comes first. The building comes after.
Offering plans can be extensive documents. Floor plans, estimated expenses, building materials, and a great deal more. Sorting through one is slow work for the licensee and for the buyer, and it is a necessary step before making an offer. Suggest that your client review the details with an attorney.
One instruction carries more weight than everything else on this screen. Do not rely on word of mouth or advertising to explain the offering plan. If an amenity is not listed in the document, it may not be included in the unit. A rooftop gym the sales office mentions and the plan does not name is a rooftop gym your buyer may never see.
If it is not in the plan, it may not exist
SIX THINGS TO READ FOR
Special risks. There are risks a buyer runs if an offering plan for a building under construction is signed. Is the builder using the high-quality building materials described in the plan? Is the window model listed in the plan actually being installed?
Real estate tax validation. Each unit owner pays real estate taxes separately and can write off the interest on his taxes.
Floor plans. Due to construction variables, the layout and the square footage listed in the offering plan might not be exactly what the buyer receives. If the difference is considerable, the buyer could try to renegotiate price with the sponsor.
Estimated expenses. The offering plan gives an estimated cost of items such as utilities and other expenses. The buyer will not have exact knowledge of these costs until later in the process.
Hidden fees. Be aware of hidden fees on the project. Even if the Attorney General has approved the offering plan, that does not mean the price of the unit, the financial terms, or other aspects of the building have been approved.
Closing date. With new buildings, move-in dates have a tendency to slide, and offering plans usually provide room for construction delays. Advise clients to note defects and incomplete items on a list during the final walk-through before closing. If those items are not noted in writing, it may be more difficult for the buyer to get the issues resolved.
WHO REVIEWS THE PLAN
The Martin Act, Article 23 of the New York State General Business Law, applies to the sale of condominiums and cooperatives. It requires a full description of the property in the offering plan. The Attorney General's office regulates and reviews all plans.
Note what Attorney General review does and does not reach. It reaches disclosure. It does not bless a price. The hidden-fees item above says so directly, and a buyer who hears acceptance for filing and understands government approval of the deal has been left with the wrong idea.
WHEN THE PRICE GOES UP
It is not unusual for sponsors or developers to amend the original offering plan and raise prices on a condominium or cooperative as the building is constructed. A developer cannot change its offering plan on a whim. Offering plans in New York are highly regulated by the Attorney General's office, and any amendments to an offering plan are regulated too.
Prices often begin increasing from the time the land is purchased to the time the units are ready for occupancy, and there are ordinary reasons for it. Land prices, material costs and labor costs are always increasing, and developers raise unit prices to offset them. Developer costs work the other way early on: where there are heavy front-end costs, or financing is not secured until a certain number of units are sold, a developer may offer incentives or a first-look special preview, price the early units low, and raise prices once units start to sell. And popularity drives demand. Location, views and amenities all pull a price up.
The price of a condominium reflects what the market can bear, the same way the price of a house does. Different developers have different financing plans with the banks and partners backing their projects, so the reasons for raising prices are not consistent across the board. A seller's market may bring higher prices for developers because demand is high. A buyer's market may hurt them, because a glut of condominiums may be on the market.
Amendments matter to a buyer who signed early. A sponsor may amend the plan, the amendment is regulated, and the buyer needs to know what changed and when. That is another reason the offering plan belongs in front of an attorney rather than in a drawer.
NOTE: Acceptance for filing is not approval of the deal. That single idea is worth more on the exam and in the field than any other line on this screen, because it is the line a sales office will blur for you.
REMEMBER: Your buyer says the sales agent promised a roof deck. Name the one document you check, and say what you tell her if the roof deck is not in it.
Converting an Occupied Building
Eviction and non-eviction plans, and the tenants already living there
When a sponsor converts a building into a condominium or a cooperative, there are usually people living in it. Those people have leases, and some of them have rent regulation. The conversion has to deal with them before it can deal with anyone else. Sponsors offer them either an eviction plan or a non-eviction plan.
Tenants have rights, and certain requirements must be met before a sponsor can move forward with a development plan. Eviction plans also vary from building to building, so the plan in front of you governs the building in front of you.
A licensee runs into this from three sides at once. You may be marketing units in a converting building. You may be representing a buyer looking at an occupied apartment in one. And you may be standing in a hallway talking to somebody who has lived there twenty years and wants to know what is about to happen to him. The rules below decide all three conversations, and the third one is the one where a wrong answer does damage.
THE EVICTION PLAN
If a sponsor files an eviction plan and an existing tenant chooses not to purchase, the tenant may be evicted after a specific period of time. That is the whole point of the eviction plan, and it is why the threshold for declaring one effective is set high.
According to the New York Attorney General, for an eviction plan to be declared effective, 51 percent of the bona fide tenants in the occupancy of all the dwelling units, on the date the Attorney General accepts the offering plan for filing, must sign purchase agreements. Eligible senior citizens and disabled tenants are excluded from the calculation.
51 percent, signed purchase agreements
Three details inside that rule get tested. The percentage is of bona fide tenants in occupancy, not of units and not of everyone who ever lived there. The count is taken on the date the Attorney General accepts the offering plan for filing, so the population is fixed on a known date. And the exclusion of eligible senior citizens and disabled tenants changes the denominator, which means it changes the answer.
Hypothetical. A sponsor files an eviction plan on a building with 100 occupied dwelling units, and 12 of the households qualify as eligible senior citizens or disabled tenants. Those 12 come out of the calculation. The 51 percent is measured against the bona fide tenants in occupancy who remain in the count, not against the full 100 and not against the number of apartments in the building. Getting the denominator right is most of getting the answer right.
THE NON-EVICTION PLAN
If a sponsor files a non-eviction plan, non-purchasing tenants may be able to continue renting the unit. The threshold is lower and the test is different.
According to the New York Attorney General, for a non-eviction plan to be declared effective, at least 15 percent of the dwelling units must be sold to bona fide tenants or non-tenant purchasers who intend, or whose family members intend, to live in the unit. The percentage may include sales of vacant and occupied apartments.
Then comes the sentence that protects the tenant who stayed. An outside purchaser of an occupied apartment may not evict the tenant living in the apartment. The tenant may continue in occupancy as a rent-stabilized or rent-controlled tenant, paying rent to the outside purchaser or the sponsor, who must provide all the services required under applicable laws.
An investor buys the apartment, not possession
Hypothetical. A sponsor converts a Queens rental building under a non-eviction plan. An investor buys unit 4C with a rent-stabilized tenant of nineteen years still in it. The investor now owns the unit. The tenant stays, remains rent-stabilized, and pays the rent to the investor instead of to the old landlord. The investor owes that tenant every service the law required before the conversion. Nothing about the sale gave the investor a way to put the tenant out.
CAUTION: This is a screen where a careless sentence from a licensee does real harm to a real person. Telling an elderly renter in a non-eviction conversion that the new owner can put him out at the end of the year is wrong, and it is wrong to a tenant who has no reason to doubt you. If you do not know which plan a building is converting under, find out before you open your mouth.
The non-eviction plan is also the one a licensee is most likely to be marketing. Fifteen percent is a lower bar than fifty-one, and it can be met partly with vacant apartments, so more conversions run this way. That means more of your showings will be in buildings where somebody is still living in the apartment next door on a regulated rent, and where your investor buyer is buying an income stream rather than a place to move into.
The two numbers sit on different things and students reverse them under pressure. Fifty-one percent counts bona fide tenants in occupancy who sign purchase agreements, and it buys the sponsor the right to evict. Fifteen percent counts dwelling units sold to people who will actually live in them, and it buys the sponsor a conversion with the tenants still in place.
REMEMBER: Say which plan each number belongs to, out loud, before you move on. Then say what happens to a non-purchasing tenant under each one.
Testing the Market Before There Is a Plan
Cooperative Policy Statement #1 (CPS-1)
A sponsor with an idea and a piece of land wants to know whether anybody will buy before spending a year and a great deal of money producing an offering plan. New York lets the sponsor ask. The rules for asking are strict, and they are the rules a salesperson working a new development is most likely to break without meaning to.
Cooperative Policy Statement #1, also referred to as CPS-1, is applicable to cooperatives, condominiums and homeowners associations. It is used to test the market, explore the venture, and determine the needs to meet a variety of conditions.
Notice what the statement covers. Cooperatives, condominiums and homeowners associations, all three. A licensee who files CPS-1 in a mental drawer marked co-ops will miss it on the condominium project she is actually working on, and the condominium project is where new agents meet it.
HOW MARKET TESTING STARTS
The sponsor files an application to test the market with the Real Estate Financing section of the New York State Attorney General's Office. Market testing begins only after the sponsor receives a letter from the Attorney General stating that the application to test the market has been granted, or oral notification of acceptance. Nothing starts on the day the application goes in the mail.
An application to test the market will not be granted if the sponsor has submitted an offering plan for filing with the Attorney General. The two come in order. Test first, then file the plan. A sponsor who has already filed a plan has moved past the stage CPS-1 covers.
THE TWO ABSOLUTE PROHIBITIONS
No reservations, binding or non-binding, are accepted until an offering plan has been accepted for filing by the Attorney General. No deposits are accepted until an offering plan has been accepted for filing by the Attorney General.
Read both of those slowly, because the word non-binding is doing work. A licensee who believes a reservation is harmless because it binds nobody has misread the rule. The prohibition covers every reservation of either kind, and it covers every deposit, and it lifts only when the plan has been accepted for filing.
No reservations. No deposits. None.
EVERY ADVERTISEMENT GOES TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
All advertisements and advertising literature used by the sponsor need to be cleared by the Attorney General before use. All advertisements and advertising literature should contain the Attorney General's CPS-1 legend, and reference should be made to the Attorney General's CPS-1 advertising guidelines. Any proposed advertisement or advertising literature that was not part of the sponsor's original application to test the market should be submitted to the Attorney General at least 48 hours before the approval is needed.
That covers the material a salesperson invents on a Tuesday morning. A new social post, a new flyer, a new sign at the site. It was not in the original application, so it goes to the Attorney General with at least 48 hours to spare, and it carries the legend.
The sponsor's own application spells this out. It states that no advertisement or advertising literature, classified advertisements and signs exhibited at the site included, will be used unless first submitted to and cleared by the Attorney General, and that all of it will carry the CPS-1 legend. Copies of every proposed advertisement go in with the application, and so do the questionnaires and information cards prospective purchasers are asked to complete.
THE CLOCK
Two clocks run on a CPS-1 application and they start at different events. The first starts at acceptance and governs how long the sponsor may keep testing. The second starts at the granting of the application and governs when the sponsor has to swear to the Attorney General that nothing was sold. Keep them separate.
The application to test the market is effective for 120 days after acceptance. The Attorney General may extend the period for an additional 60 days if an application for extension is filed explaining why the test period was inadequate, and that application should be made at least seven days before the 120-day period expires.
There is a second date further out. The sponsor files an affidavit with the Attorney General on or by the 180th day following the granting of the application to test the market, stating that the sponsor has accepted no purchase agreements before the acceptance for filing of an offering plan by the Attorney General. Where the property sits outside New York, the affidavit covers purchase agreements from New York residents.
WHAT GOES IN WITH THE APPLICATION
The application to test the market is accompanied by a filing fee, a transmittal letter signed by the attorney who prepared the application and affirmed under penalty of perjury, a true copy of the sponsor's deed, option or contract to purchase land for the site if there is one, a true copy of the mortgage commitment of a lending institution if there is one, a copy of floor plans for the building, and a completed statistical information card. Homeowners association applications include site plans.
The attorney's transmittal letter affirms several things under penalty of perjury, including the street address and zip code and that the attorney has no actual knowledge of a violation of Article 23-A of the General Business Law.
The application itself describes the project in detail: the parcel and its exact location, the number and type of units and how many structures they sit in, the common elements down to the parking spaces and the pool and the lawns, whether the work is new construction or rehabilitation, and whether any part of the building is occupied by tenants now or expected to be. It also carries the sponsor's estimated purchase price, room count and estimated monthly maintenance for each unit. A sponsor tests a described building, priced and counted, down to the lawns.
$225
filing fee
by check payable to the Department of Law.
NOTE: Market testing gauges interest. It never sells. Every prohibition on this screen points the same direction, and the day a sponsor or a salesperson takes money or a signature during the test period is the day CPS-1 is violated.
REMEMBER: A sponsor in the CPS-1 phase asks you to take a small refundable deposit from an interested couple to hold a line number. What do you say, and which sentence of CPS-1 are you saying it from?
Lesson 3
Buying & Selling a Condominium
Letters of intent, lender scrutiny, flips, and the closing-cost gauntlet
Letter of Intent, Binding Contract, and the Lender
What each document obligates, and what a lender looks at
A developer may ask a buyer to sign a letter of intent to purchase a condominium unit. A letter of intent signifies that two or more parties agree to do business together. It is useful as a transaction develops because it often includes a specific time frame and a set of terms both parties can live with, and it is likely to be required when a buyer wants to reserve a specific unit.
The buyer will probably put down an initial deposit as well, often as little as $1,000. The buyer now has the right of first refusal on that unit. During this phase the buyer can terminate the agreement and still get the deposit back.
A right of first refusal is the right to have the first chance to buy or lease property if the owner decides to sell or lease it. On a new development it is what a reservation actually buys. The developer holds the unit for her because she has the first call on it. She can let that call go and take her money with her.
A letter of intent is usually non-binding. Read the fine print to be sure. A non-binding letter of intent most likely signifies the parties' intent to move forward with a transaction and is not meant to be enforceable. These letters may include information on the closing date, the purchase price, or other basic terms of the transaction. Just as the buyer is not obligated to purchase, the seller, which for a new condominium is probably the developer, is not obligated to firm pricing yet.
The deposit comes back during this phase
A binding contract is a valid contract that is enforceable. These contracts often contain more details of the transaction, such as conditions that must be met prior to closing. They usually require a sizable deposit, often 20 percent of the purchase price. A binding contract obligates the parties to complete the transaction or face breaching it. Some contracts allow a rescission period during which the buyer can withdraw from the contract without obligation.
So the gap between the two documents is the gap between a conversation and a commitment. One reserves a unit and returns the money if the buyer changes her mind. The other moves twenty percent of the price into escrow and holds her to the deal. When a buyer asks what she just signed, the honest answer starts by naming which of the two it is.
CAUTION: When a document was drafted by a developer, whether it is a letter of intent or a binding contract, potential buyers should consult an attorney with experience in this area. That advice is not a formality on new construction. The developer's lawyer wrote the paper, and nobody in the room represents your buyer until she hires someone.
Hypothetical. A buyer signs a letter of intent on line 9C in a new Long Island City building, puts down a small deposit, and three weeks later her employer transfers her to Boston. She walks. Under a non-binding letter of intent she gets the deposit back, because during that phase she was not obligated to purchase. Change one fact, put her three weeks past a binding contract with twenty percent in escrow, and the conversation with her is a different conversation entirely.
BEFORE THE LENDER SAYS YES
Lenders have income parameters for cooperative and condominium admission. Acceptable and non-acceptable income. Earnings-to-debt ratios. Loan-to-value ratios, the LTV. A lender looks at a range of items on the loan application before deciding to make the loan, and income and assets are the two that decide most files.
An earnings-to-debt ratio measures what the borrower already owes against what the borrower earns. A loan-to-value ratio measures the size of the loan against the value of the property securing it. The finance chapters of this course work both ratios in detail. Here the point is narrower: these same parameters are applied twice on a cooperative or condominium purchase, once by the lender deciding whether to fund and once by a board deciding whether to admit.
The income a lender typically considers includes salary and commissions or bonuses. Other income can be counted as long as the applicant can prove it is permanent. Interest. Dividends. Capital gains. Alimony. Rental income. Trust funds. Social Security. Income from a business. The test on the second group is permanence, and permanence has to be documented rather than described.
Lenders also want to see assets that can be converted into cash. Stocks, bonds, mutual funds, T-bills, trust funds, collectibles, retirement assets and real estate. The lender is checking two things at once: that the buyer has money for the down payment and the closing costs, and that the buyer has something left afterward to guard against unexpected bills or a temporary loss of income.
That second purpose explains a question that annoys buyers. A file with exactly enough cash to close and nothing behind it is a thin file, and a co-op board will read it the same way a lender does. What looks like nosiness is the underwriter asking what happens in month four.
One practical note on submitting a letter of intent. The sponsor's sales office sets the form and the procedure, because the letter is the developer's document on the developer's project. Your part is to get the form and the deposit terms in front of your buyer's attorney before she signs, rather than after she has wired money.
REMEMBER: Your buyer signs a letter of intent on a new condominium and calls you a week later wanting out. What happens to the deposit, and which sentence of the document did you read before you answered?
Flipping, Title, and the Cost of Closing
The Closing Disclosure is required by the Truth in Lending Act and RESPA
Three words come up at condominium closings and they describe related but separate things. Flipping. Assigning a contract. Simultaneous closing. Get them straight before a client uses one of them at you.
Flipping means purchasing property and quickly reselling it for a profit, usually after fixing it up. Flipping is also called assigning a contract, which means assigning the purchase rights to a property or a condominium unit to another buyer before that property or unit is closed. Investors may want to flip condominium units pre-construction, which is the version this chapter cares about.
A simultaneous closing is a seller-financing technique in which the investor or seller creates a private mortgage note and then simultaneously closes with the buyer on the same day. The Department of Housing and Urban Development has regulations about predatory flipping with regard to Federal Housing Administration single-family mortgages.
RESPA is worth placing while it is in front of you. It applies to one- to four-family residences and condominiums that use federally regulated loans, and to loans made by lenders that invest more than $1 million in residential mortgages. Its purpose is comparison shopping, so a buyer can weigh the cost of services from different lenders and closing agents instead of accepting the first number she is handed.
Some developers do not allow flipping, and their reasons are commercial rather than legal. A developer does not want to compete against flippers for sales of the remaining condominium units. And while investors may let a unit sit empty, buyers who live on the property and maintain it keep driving the value up and attracting more people. Developers often prefer buyers to investors who intend to flip.
TITLE ISSUES ON A CONDOMINIUM
Three terms worth restating. Title is the actual lawful ownership of real property, and it refers to holding the bundle of rights conveyed. A title search is an inspection of the public record to determine all rights and encumbrances affecting the title to a piece of property. A deed is an instrument that conveys a grantor's interest, if any, in real property, and it is also known as a conveyance.
Because a condominium unit owner shares the common areas and holds an undivided interest in them, the sale of a unit sells the interest in the common areas too. Prior to closing, a title search is completed to resolve any issues the seller has with the title to the unit being sold. Any issues with title must be resolved before closing. Like all deeds, the deed of the condominium unit conveys title to real property, and at closing the title is sold and transferred to the buyer.
Title insurance is also required for condominiums. A title insurance policy protects the lender, and sometimes the property owner, against loss due to disputes over the ownership of a property and defects in the title that were not found during the search of the public record. Those defects could be liens or claims against title, and they may be recorded or unrecorded.
Resolve title before closing, every time
WHAT THE BUYER SEES AT CLOSING
The closing transaction for a condominium is similar to that for other residential property. The best way to evaluate closing costs is by looking at the Closing Disclosure, a document that presents a final, detailed account of a real estate transaction, listing each party's debits and credits and the amount each will receive or be required to pay at closing.
Closing Disclosures are required by the Truth in Lending Act and the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act, RESPA, and are prepared by closing agents, and in some cases by the creditor, to document the total amount of money owed to and by the seller and the buyer. RESPA was created so buyers can compare the cost of services from different lenders and closing agents.
Two more items belong in the closing conversation. Condominium owners cannot write off closing costs, and they can write off mortgage interest among other things, which is the ordinary advantage of owning over renting. And some condominium contracts contain a right of first refusal, the right to have the first chance to buy or lease property if the owner decides to sell or lease it. In a condominium that clause gives the association the first opportunity to purchase a unit when it comes up for sale.
The figures below are common New York estimates and nothing more. Costs vary from closing to closing, they move with the law and with the market, and your job is to advise clients to confirm them with an attorney rather than to quote them from memory.
SELECTED NEW YORK CLOSING COSTS
Cost
Who pays
Typical amount
Mansion tax
Buyer
1% of the ENTIRE purchase price when the price is $1 million or more
Mortgage tax
Buyer
Varies by jurisdiction and loan amount, in New York City, up to 2.8% of the loan
NYC transfer tax
Seller*
1% of sale price up to $500,000; 1.425% if $500,000 and over; plus $25 administrative fee
NYS transfer tax
Seller*
$4 per $1,000 of sale price, 0.4% of the purchase price
Title insurance
Buyer
≈ $450 per $100,000 (fee policy) + ≈ $200 per $100,000 of mortgage (loan policy)
Attorney fees
Each side
$1,600+ for the buyer; $1,500+ for the seller, advise clients to confirm costs with counsel
*Buying directly from the sponsor? The purchaser usually pays BOTH transfer taxes, plus the sponsor's attorney fees (≈$1,500) and a working-capital contribution (≈$1,000). Title issues must be resolved before closing, and some condo contracts give the association a RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL when a unit comes up for sale.
REMEMBER: A buyer asks what she will need on closing day beyond the down payment. Name the three costs on that list you would check with counsel before you say a number out loud.
Lesson 4
Cooperatives
You don't buy the apartment. You buy the corporation that owns it, one share at a time.
How a Cooperative Works
A corporation owns the building; the residents own the corporation
The purchase of a cooperative is different from other types of real estate transactions, and the difference starts at the top. Cooperatives, or co-ops, are buildings owned by corporations with the residents as shareholders. Each shareholder receives a proprietary lease on an individual unit and the right to use the common areas. A proprietary lease is an exclusive, longer-term lease given to a person who lives in and owns stock in a cooperative.
A co-op owner's shares are considered personal property. Title to the cooperative building is held by a corporation formed for that purpose, owned in severalty. One owner, the corporation, holds title to the whole building. The shareholder holds stock and a lease.
Like a condominium, a cooperative is a type of structured ownership known as a legal entity. Unlike a condominium, which is a non-controlling entity, a cooperative is member-controlled and owned. That single word, controlled, is the source of almost everything else in this lesson.
Work out who the landlord is and the rest of the structure falls into place. The corporation owns the building and grants the proprietary lease. The shareholder is the tenant under that lease. The shareholder also owns part of the corporation that granted it. A cooperative resident is on both sides of her own lease, which is why she votes for the board and why the board can set the terms she lives under.
WHAT EACH SHAREHOLDER PAYS, AND WHAT THAT EXPOSES
A cooperative shareholder pays a prorated share of the building's expenses, including property taxes for the whole building. There is no separate tax bill for apartment 6A. There is one tax bill for the building, and the shareholders carry it between them in their monthly maintenance.
That arrangement has a consequence a condominium owner never faces. If a resident does not pay her share of the expenses, the entire cooperative may be threatened with foreclosure. In a condominium, one resident's actions do not threaten the entire community. In a cooperative, the building carries one mortgage and one tax bill, and every shareholder is standing behind them.
One shortfall is everybody's problem
HOW A COOPERATIVE APARTMENT CHANGES HANDS
Even though shares rather than property are sold, the transaction is similar to the sale of real estate. The shares and the apartment are transferred to the purchaser along with an assignment of the proprietary lease. Three things move together: the stock, the lease and the apartment.
That package is what a buyer walks out with. No deed is delivered, because there is no deed to deliver. The corporation still holds title to the building, exactly as it did the day before, and what changed is who owns a block of its stock and whose name is on the lease for apartment 6A.
There is a limit on that transfer that has no equivalent in a condominium sale. The cooperative agreement may provide that a shareholder cannot transfer an interest without the other shareholders' consent. A seller who owns the shares outright still may not be free to hand them to whoever writes the largest check.
Hypothetical. A shareholder on the eleventh floor stops paying maintenance after a job loss. Her arrears do not sit quietly in her own file. They come out of the money the corporation uses to pay the building's real estate taxes and the underlying mortgage, and if enough of that money goes missing the corporation is the one that falls behind. Everybody in the building is standing behind a bill that one apartment stopped contributing to.
Since 1996, married couples who own cooperatives can take title as tenants by the entirety. That lets them own the co-op with a 100 percent undivided interest, gives the spouses survivorship rights, and prevents one spouse from selling his own share without the consent of the other.
NOTE: Chapter 7 gave you the ownership answer: a co-op buyer receives shares of stock, which are personal property, and a proprietary lease, and no deed to the apartment exists for anyone but the corporation. This lesson takes that answer and asks what it costs you at a closing. Personal property is why there is nowhere to record the stock certificate, why the loan is not a mortgage, and why a board gets a vote on your buyer.
REMEMBER: A shareholder three floors up stops paying maintenance. Say in one sentence why that is your client's problem in a cooperative and not her problem in a condominium.
Financing a Co-op, and Reading Its Books
Share loan, flip tax, recognition agreement, and the due-diligence file
A cooperative buyer is buying stock, so the loan is not a mortgage. Co-op shareholders typically have a share loan, which is a co-op loan signifying that a buyer is purchasing shares in a corporation rather than a mortgage for ownership of property. The lender is lending against shares and a lease, which is why the lender takes possession of both after closing.
The share loan changes what a lender holds and when. On a condominium the lender records a mortgage against real property and the buyer walks away with a deed. On a cooperative there is nothing to record, so after closing the lender typically takes possession of the stock certificate and the proprietary lease and keeps them. Those two pieces of paper are the collateral.
Cooperatives often include a flip tax, which is a fee imposed by the co-op board on the seller for the transfer of ownership during the sale of the unit. The money goes to the cooperative, not to the city and not to the state. A seller who has budgeted for the transfer taxes and forgotten the flip tax gets an unpleasant number at the closing table.
That is why the flip tax belongs in a listing conversation rather than a closing conversation. It falls on the seller, it is set by the building, and it comes off the seller's proceeds. Ask about it while you are pricing the apartment, and send the seller to counsel with the building's documents in hand rather than quoting a figure yourself.
A flip tax is paid to the cooperative
A recognition agreement is an agreement between three parties, the lender, the co-op and the shareholder, that recognizes the rights of lenders who finance the shareholder. The agreement says that the lender, the co-op and the shareholder will all be notified in the event of default.
The point of that notice is money and time. It gives the lender time to pay past-due maintenance fees, if the lender wants to, in an attempt to avoid foreclosure. Foreclosure is an expensive prospect, and most co-op boards and lenders want to work with shareholders to avoid it. Recognition agreements are ordinary, current practice in cooperative lending, and a lender asking for one is asking for something routine.
THE DUE-DILIGENCE FILE
Before purchasing shares in a cooperative, buyers should read between the financial lines to make sure the co-op is in good financial standing. Prospective shareholders should look at bills that have not been paid and at uncollected maintenance fees. Those are signs that the building's finances may not be well managed. It is also a good idea to look at reserve funds and the co-op's underlying mortgage.
The Attorney General's regulations stipulate that every shareholder has the right to view the building's annual financial statement. A financial statement gives every tenant information on how the building's money is being managed. That is the first document in the file, and access to it is a right rather than a favor.
New York's Business Corporate Law requires co-op corporations to keep minutes of monthly board meetings. They can reveal reserve funds, the underlying mortgage, looming repairs, even noise or pet disputes.
Read the statement for what is missing as much as for what is there. Bills that have not been paid and maintenance fees the building has not collected are the two warning signs, and neither of them shows up as a headline. They show up as a receivable that keeps growing and a payables list that keeps aging.
The minutes and the statement answer different questions. The statement says what the building's money did last year. The minutes say what the board is worried about this year, including the maintenance and assessment history that tells a buyer how often the bill has gone up.
Reserve funds and the underlying mortgage deserve their own look. Either could be leveraged to pay for unexpected repairs or to finance capital improvements or renovations, and either route could increase maintenance fees. Co-op shareholders pay the underlying mortgage inside their monthly maintenance, so a large underlying mortgage is already sitting in the number your buyer thinks of as rent.
CAUTION: A client's lawyer should consult both the board minutes and the financial statement before a purchase of shares is made. Both. A buyer who reads only the statement sees a healthy year and misses the facade repair the board has been arguing about since March.
REMEMBER: Name the two documents your buyer's attorney reads before she signs, and say which one would have warned her about a coming assessment.
The Paper Trail of a Co-op Sale
Five documents that make or stall the closing
A cooperative sale runs on documents that have no counterpart in a condominium deal, because there is no deed and no recording office at the end of it. Five of them decide whether a closing happens on time.
STOCK CERTIFICATE AND PROPRIETARY LEASE
When a buyer purchases shares in a cooperative, a stock certificate and a proprietary lease are issued. There is no place to publicly record the stock certificate and the lease, so the original documents are needed for the transfer agent to complete the sale with the new buyer.
That is why a missing original stops a closing cold. A closing agent usually cannot close the sale without the actual documents, and a certificate or lease that cannot be produced might indicate that a lender is holding them as evidence of a lien. After closing, the lender typically takes possession of the stock certificate and the lease as collateral for the share loan.
No deed, no recording, so the originals rule
The transfer agent is the building's own record keeper for its stock. There is no county clerk in a cooperative sale, so the transfer agent cancels the seller's certificate, issues a new one to the buyer, and records the change on the corporation's books. A buyer who never sees a recording office still gets a chain of ownership. It just lives inside the corporation instead of in the public record.
THE CO-OP LIEN SEARCH
If liens exist against a co-op seller or her shares, they must be cleared before a new buyer can purchase the shares. During the purchase process the attorney for the co-op buyer will often complete a lien search to make sure there are no open liens against the seller or the seller's shares. That search is what keeps a smooth closing smooth.
THE OFFERING PLAN
As with condominiums, an offering plan for a cooperative is a document provided by the sponsor that offers detailed information regarding the property. Before a co-op closing, and in addition to reviewing the financial statements and the board minutes, the buyer's lawyer reviews the offering plan. After the lawyer has done the due diligence and is satisfied with the results, the contract can be signed. The order matters: review first, sign second.
HOUSE RULES
House rules are the rules and requirements established for condominium or cooperative tenants. They often address rules for common areas, parking, noise, pets and use of the recreation room. House rules are usually not drafted by an attorney and are not backed by a specific law, and they are expected to be followed. Board members can amend and change house rules if they have a majority vote from shareholders.
Know the house rules of any building your client is considering, because they can change the decision to buy. A dog lover would not want to buy shares in a cooperative that restricts pets, and finding that out after the board interview is finding it out too late.
House rules also connect to the interview on the next screen. A rule your buyer intends to live around is a rule the board will ask about, and the buyer who raises it first is in a far better position than the buyer the board catches. Reading the house rules early is how you find out what your client needs to say.
THE ALTERATION AGREEMENT
An alteration agreement is a written agreement, signed by co-op shareholder-tenants, before any renovations, modifications, repairs or alterations can begin. An agreement should be considered for structural and non-structural alterations alike.
It takes into account and provides regulations for demolition, especially with regard to uncovering and dealing with lead paint and asbestos. For electrical work, including hiring a licensed electrician. For plumbing, heating and HVAC, including hiring licensed contractors and making sure all installations are approved by the building engineer. For environmental issues. And for certificate of occupancy issues.
The Residential Management Council of the Real Estate Board of New York, along with the New York City Bar Association, developed a form that standardizes the alteration agreement.
A standardized form helps everybody. The building knows what it is getting, the shareholder knows what is expected, and the contractors know which sign-offs they need before they start. A shareholder handed a long agreement on the day work is due to begin should still send it to counsel, because the obligations in it survive the renovation.
CAUTION: The word before is the entire rule. The alteration agreement is signed before work begins, not filed afterward when a neighbor complains about the noise. A shareholder who starts demolition on a Saturday morning with no agreement in hand has a problem with the board, and the licensee who told her it was fine has a different problem.
REMEMBER: Which two of these five documents cannot be recorded anywhere, and what does that mean for the day your buyer closes?
The Board Package and the Interview
Co-op boards vote on every buyer
Another important part of a cooperative purchase, aside from the financing, is the board package. A board package is presented to the co-op, or sometimes condominium, board of directors, and it often includes financial qualifications, employment verification, letters of reference and other material requested by the board.
The buyer's real estate agent completes the board package or assists the buyer in completing it. The package then goes to the managing agent of the building, who confirms it is complete and does any necessary fact checking before forwarding it to the board of directors. That route matters. The package does not go straight to the board, and an incomplete package usually comes back from the managing agent rather than from anybody with a vote.
There is no standardized board package. Boards differ in how they want information presented and how many copies they need, so work with your client to follow the board's specifications exactly. All information must be supported by documentation.
Follow each board's specifications exactly
WHY THE BOARD ASKS FOR ALL OF IT
Remember what a cooperative is. If a resident does not pay his share of maintenance fees, the entire cooperative may be threatened with foreclosure. So the board wants to know up front whether a buyer will be financially responsible for the unit, and whether the buyer will be a good neighbor. Every item in the package answers one of those two questions.
WHAT THE PACKAGE CONTAINS
The purchase application form provides basic information, including the buyer's name, Social Security number and occupation, the name and phone number of the current landlord, length of residency in the current residence, broker and attorney names and contact information, the names of family members who will occupy the building, the number and types of pets, and the license plate numbers of the buyer's and occupants' automobiles.
The fully executed contract of sale is often prepared by the seller's attorney for the buyer's attorney. With the signing of the contract the buyer produces the down payment, which for co-ops can easily be 25 percent or more, and the down payment goes into escrow.
The financial statement typically asks about assets, liabilities and net worth, and buyers must provide documentation to verify the information. It could include real estate owned, retirement funds, cash on hand, bank statements, stocks and bonds owned, and other financial obligations. Suggest that clients rely on a financial professional to make sure this information is current.
Letters of personal reference give the board insight into the personality of the buyers and how well they will fit with the current owners. Several are usually required, and they should come from people the buyer has known for an extended length of time. An employment verification letter comes from the buyer's employer and verifies occupation and position within the company, length of employment and salary. Business letters of reference should come from business associates, supervisors or management the buyer has worked with closely, and they should carry specific information about the buyer.
Most boards expect to see three years of federal, state and city tax returns. The board wants to know that a potential buyer's taxes are paid on time and whether any tax-related issues exist that might affect the cooperative or the buyer's ability to pay maintenance fees or loan payments on time. Boards also run a credit check on each potential buyer, which requires the signing of a credit release form, and buyers are required to sign appropriate New York State disclosure forms, including the disclosure relating to lead-based paint and lead-based paint hazards.
THE INTERVIEW
Besides preparing a board package, prospective owners are required to interview with the co-op board, and a licensee can help prepare a shareholder-buyer for it. Boards usually hold interview meetings once a month, so buyers may have to wait for a monthly slot. Most boards expect to meet everyone who will be living in the co-op, children included. The board notifies the buyer or the agent and broker of the exact date and time.
Buyers should be prepared to handle personal and financial questions. A buyer should not speak poorly of current neighbors, landlords, jobs or financial situations, and it is imperative to be honest and forthcoming. The buyer should offer more than total financial disclosure and employment verification. Maybe the buyer runs a home-based business, owns a dog, or likes to practice guitar at home. Any of those might be prohibited, and they need to be discussed with the board.
CAUTION: Coaching a buyer to leave the dog or the home business out of the interview is the worst advice a licensee can give on this screen. Those are exactly the facts the board needs, and hiding them puts your client into a building whose rules she is already breaking on the day she moves in.
WHAT A BOARD MAY AND MAY NOT DO
Condominium owners and homeowners have no control over who becomes their new neighbor. Co-op boards generally have the ability to vote on whether to allow a particular person to buy into the cooperative. As long as the board does not discriminate against prospective buyers based on their membership in a protected class, it can approve or reject any candidate for a variety of reasons. The main purpose is to find a good fit for the building as a whole.
Case in Point. Several well-known people, Madonna and former President Richard Nixon among them, did not receive board approval to live in a specific co-op building. Why turn down someone like Madonna? Probably because the board wanted its residents to be able to get in and out of the building easily, and a famous resident brings paparazzi and fans into the lobby and around the entrances, making it loud, crowded and potentially unsafe much of the time. If Madonna or former President Nixon wanted to buy the house next door to yours, you would have no say and they could buy it. Owning shares in a cooperative is a different thing from owning actual property.
REMEMBER: A board rejects your client and gives no reason. Which single ground for rejection would make that decision unlawful, and what would you need before you said that word out loud?
Subletting, Sponsor Shares and Unsold Shares
Who lives in the building changes what the building is worth
Shareholders in a cooperative have a stake in the way subletting, sponsor shares and occupancy are handled. These considerations reach taxation, lending and future sales, which means they reach the price your seller gets.
In a sublease, a tenant transfers only part of his right of possession or other interest in leased property to another person for part of the remaining lease term. Typically a sublessee pays rent to a lessee, who then pays the lessor. In a sublease the original tenant is responsible to the owner for all provisions in the lease. The shareholder who sublets has not handed off the obligation. He has added a person to it.
THE PROPRIETARY LEASE DECIDES
Some cooperative buildings allow subletting and some do not. When a co-op board considers subletting, it starts with the proprietary lease. Some leases deny subletting. More often than not the lease gives the board the right to sublet. In buildings that do allow it there are usually specific policies and fees.
It is important to adhere to any bylaws regarding sublet fees. The rules vary, and many buildings require move-in and move-out fees, sublet fees and application fees.
Requirements vary from building to building too, and the common ones are worth naming. A shareholder must occupy a unit for a specific number of years before subletting is allowed. An apartment can be sublet only for a certain number of years. Only a certain number of units in the building can be sublet at one time. And there must be specific reasons for subletting, financial hardship being the usual example.
WHY BOARDS KEEP THE NUMBER LOW
People tend to like cooperatives because of the community feeling and the fact that renters are not constantly changing. If a building has enough sublets in it, it can begin to feel like a rental property instead of a home. There is a concern that people who sublet will not take care of the building as well as shareholders do, producing more wear and tear.
Boards also know that too many sublets can cause difficulty for the cooperative or for prospective buyers when it comes to borrowing money or refinancing. Consider a building that is 40 percent owner occupied, with the rest occupied by sublets, sponsors or investors. A bank may be hesitant to lend money to that cooperative at all, and hesitant to lend to potential new shareholders in it, because banks consider subletting a risk.
Set against that, a cooperative's shareholders do need to sublet from time to time. A job moves. Many boards understand that and permit subletting on their own terms. Managed correctly, subletting can actually provide extra revenue for the building for improvements or for the reserve fund. It is a fine line for all the parties involved.
Occupancy is a lending question
SPONSOR SHARES
Sponsors must give up control of the board after five years or after 50 percent of the shares in the building are sold. Most sponsors comply with the directions laid out in the original offering plan, and the building eventually converts to the board.
The problem case is a sponsor who ignores the offering plan and stops selling shares. If the rental market is good, some sponsors want to keep their shares and sublet them instead. Others do not want to give up control of the board, because giving it up means they can no longer nominate their own members. Some sponsors also do not take the same care of repairs and maintenance. All of that makes it more difficult for current shareholders to sell. Usually there are no problems with original sponsors, and board members should still make sure sponsors follow through on their obligations.
SOLD SHARES AND WHO OCCUPIES THEM
It seems logical that a cooperative building with 100 percent occupancy would be the best scenario for banks and shareholders alike. A lot depends on who owns the shares that have been sold and who is living in the units. Full occupancy made up of sublets and investors is a different building, to a lender, than full occupancy made up of resident shareholders. Sometimes it is in the best interest of banks, boards and potential shareholders to keep subletting at a low percentage of the building's occupancy while still allowing the option for shareholders who need it.
THE HOLDER OF UNSOLD SHARES
The holder of unsold shares is an investor in a co-op building who is not using it as a primary residence. The holder of unsold shares, like the original sponsor, is typically exempt from the usual fees, including flip taxes and subletting fees. The holder of unsold shares can also sell or sublet a unit to whomever they want without board approval.
That is a genuine exemption and not a loophole, which makes it one of the easiest things in this chapter to misread in the field. An investor who holds that status and sublets three units without asking the board is doing something the proprietary lease allows.
Designation is the hinge, and it costs the sponsor something. A sponsor who designates a buyer as the holder of unsold shares hands over the exemptions and keeps a responsibility, so the decision is not automatic and a buyer should not assume it was made.
Case in Point. Sponsor Nicholas sold to investor and shareholder John. Both knew John was not planning to live in the building and bought shares for investment purposes. John assumes that because he is not taking up residence he has the same rights and exemptions Nicholas had. Does he? It depends. The proprietary lease defines the unsold shares. Just because John owns unsold shares does not mean he is considered the holder of unsold shares. Nicholas may need to designate John as the holder of unsold shares, and what that means is that Nicholas would have to cover John if financial issues arise.
REMEMBER: An investor tells you he never pays the flip tax. What one fact do you need to establish before you decide whether that is a violation or a right?
Lesson 5
Condops, and Choosing Between
A hybrid born of the tax code, and the condo-vs-co-op decision every buyer faces
The Condop and the 80/20 Rule
Section 216 of the Internal Revenue Code
A condop is a building that has been divided into at least two condominiums. The first is the co-op residential units, which together are considered one condominium unit. The second is the professional and commercial unit. That is the definition, and it is worth memorizing in those words because the term gets used for something else entirely.
The term condop has been misused, with many people believing that a condop is simply a co-op that lacks the rules and the board approval requirements. The word means something narrower. A condop keeps the cooperative and wraps a condominium structure around it.
WHAT AN OWNER IN A CONDOP BUYS
When a condop is purchased, owners still purchase shares in a corporation rather than real property. In that way a condop is like a cooperative, and everything you learned about shares, proprietary leases, boards and maintenance still applies to the person living on the eighth floor. A condop is also like a condominium, since the residential co-op units are incorporated into one condominium unit inside a larger condominium structure.
Take a ten-story condop made up of three condominium units. An underground garage is one condominium unit. Commercial space on the first floor is a second condominium unit. The residential co-op apartments above are the third. The residents upstairs are shareholders in a corporation. The corporation's apartments, all of them together, are one unit in a three-unit condominium.
Count the layers in that building, because the exam likes to blur them. There are nine floors of apartments and there is one condominium unit above the first floor, not nine. The corporation is the unit owner of that third condominium unit, and the residents own the corporation. Individual apartments sit inside the corporation, a layer below the condominium line. Everything a shareholder holds is a share and a lease, exactly as in any other cooperative.
So a buyer looking at a condop apartment still buys shares, still signs a proprietary lease, still assembles a board package, and still sits for an interview if the building requires one. The condominium structure sits above her, between the cooperative and the commercial tenants. It changes the building's tax picture. It does not change what she owns.
Shares upstairs, condominium skeleton around it
WHY ANYONE BUILDS IT THIS WAY
There are several reasons for converting a building into a condop, and the main reason involves Section 216 of the Internal Revenue Code, commonly referred to as the 80/20 rule.
The 80/20 rule says that no more than 20 percent of the co-op's yearly income can come from non-shareholder sources, in order for individual shareholders to continue to be able to write off yearly taxes and mortgage interest. Non-shareholder sources include retail or other commercial tenants.
Turn the rule around and it reads the way the exam asks it. At least 80 percent of the cooperative's yearly income has to come from the shareholders themselves. Cross the line in the other direction and the loss does not fall on the corporation. It falls on every individual shareholder, who loses the yearly tax and mortgage-interest write-offs that made buying worth doing.
So a cooperative with a large ground-floor retail rent has a problem. Splitting the commercial space off into its own condominium unit takes that rent out of the cooperative's income, and the shareholders keep their deductions. That is the engine behind the whole arrangement.
Hypothetical. A twelve-story cooperative has a bank branch and a pharmacy on the ground floor, and the rent from those two tenants has grown until it is well past a fifth of everything the corporation takes in. The corporation is not fined. Nothing is seized. The shareholders simply lose the yearly tax and mortgage-interest write-offs they have been taking, and they lose them individually, on their own returns. The building's good fortune on the ground floor became a tax problem on the eighth floor.
Passive commercial income is what the rule is aimed at. Rent from a retail or other commercial tenant is income the cooperative earns from somebody who is not a shareholder, and it is exactly the kind of income that pushes a building over the line. That is why a co-op board weighing a large ground-floor lease has to run the arithmetic before it signs anything.
TWO PITFALLS BEFORE CONVERTING
A cooperative considering a condop conversion to get out from under the 80/20 rule should weigh two things. The cost of conversion can be very expensive and not worth it. And once the commercial space is sold, the co-op board may lose control over it, and any tenant could move in. If that tenant is loud and disruptive it could upset shareholders and eventually decrease the value of the condop.
That second pitfall is the one boards underestimate. The rent problem gets solved on the day of the conversion. The neighbor problem arrives later, and it arrives permanently, because the board sold away its say over who occupies the space.
NOTE: The exam asks the 80/20 rule from both ends. At least 80 percent from shareholders, no more than 20 percent from non-shareholder sources. Same rule, two phrasings, and the consequence is always the shareholders' individual write-offs rather than a penalty on the building.
REMEMBER: A co-op board wants to lease half its ground floor to a supermarket. What is the first question you ask about the building's income, and who pays the price if the answer is wrong?
Condominium or Cooperative
Same skyline, two different things to own
Everything in this chapter comes down to one question asked twice. What does the buyer own, and who controls what happens next? Run a condominium and a cooperative through those two questions and every other difference falls out of the answers.
THE CONDOMINIUM
A condominium unit is real property. The buyer receives a fee simple deed to the unit plus an undivided interest in the common areas, held with the other owners as tenants in common. One deed conveys both, and the unit cannot be sold without the common interest.
A condominium is non-controlling. Owners have no say over who buys the apartment next door. At most, some condominium contracts give the association a right of first refusal when a unit comes up for sale, which is a chance to buy rather than a chance to veto.
A condominium purchase is financed with a mortgage. Each unit is taxed separately, and owners write off their own mortgage interest. A default and its liens stay with the single unit, so one owner's failure never threatens the building. Monthly maintenance fees, the common charges, cover common-area expenses and the insurance on the common areas and exteriors.
THE COOPERATIVE
A cooperative interest is personal property. The buyer receives shares of stock in the corporation that owns the building, plus a proprietary lease on the unit. The corporation holds title to the building in severalty.
A cooperative is member-controlled. A board package, an interview and a board vote decide who buys in, and a board may reject a candidate for a wide range of reasons, never for membership in a protected class.
A cooperative purchase is financed with a share loan, and a recognition agreement ties the lender, the co-op and the shareholder together so all three learn about a default. Shareholders pay a prorated share of building-wide expenses and taxes, so one shareholder's default can threaten the entire cooperative with foreclosure. Maintenance includes the underlying mortgage, and the board may charge a flip tax to the seller at resale.
WHAT IT FEELS LIKE ON THE WAY IN
The buying process splits along the same line. A condominium buyer goes from letter of intent or offer to a binding contract, to a lender, to a title search, to a closing where a deed is delivered and recorded. A cooperative buyer goes from contract to a board package assembled with the licensee's help, through the managing agent, to a board interview, to a vote, and then to a closing where a stock certificate and a proprietary lease change hands and the lender takes both.
The money splits too. A condominium buyer pays common charges and gets a separate tax bill for her own unit. A cooperative shareholder pays maintenance, and inside that maintenance are her share of the building's real estate taxes and her share of the underlying mortgage. Two monthly numbers that look similar on a listing sheet are carrying very different things.
Deed and common charges, or shares and maintenance
Hypothetical. Two buyers, same block, same price. One closes on a condominium in the morning and leaves with a deed she records that afternoon. The other closes on a cooperative in the afternoon and leaves with a stock certificate and a lease that her lender takes for safekeeping, after a board she had to persuade voted her in. Both of them will tell their friends they bought an apartment. Only one of them bought real property.
One thing works the same way in both, and clients still ask about it. In a condominium and in a cooperative alike, the monthly fees buy hazard and liability insurance for the common areas and the exteriors of the structures, and the individual resident buys insurance covering only the interior of the unit and her own personal property. The form of ownership changes almost everything on this screen. It does not change that split.
NOTE: Sort every exam question in this chapter by four words. Deed, real property, common charges and right of first refusal point to a condominium. Shares, proprietary lease, maintenance and board approval point to a cooperative. A question that mixes the two columns is testing whether you know which column each word came from.
REMEMBER: A client asks which one she should buy. Say the difference in two sentences, one for each form of ownership, and then say whose decision the choice actually is.
Session Summary
Six things to carry out of this chapter
A condominium is property developed for co-ownership, with each co-owner holding a separate fee simple interest in an individual unit combined with an undivided interest in the common areas, owned with the other unit owners as tenants in common. New York's Condominium Act is Article 9-B of the Real Property Law. Common areas are what all residents use and own together; limited common areas are owned by all and used by one, such as a balcony or a designated parking space. Maintenance fees follow each unit's percentage of undivided interest and buy insurance for the common areas and the exteriors, while each owner insures the interior of the unit. Unpaid fees, mortgage defaults and property taxes all stay with the single unit.
A condominium is created by a sponsor. The sponsor files articles of incorporation, files the condominium declaration or master deed with the county auditor, files an offering plan, files bylaws and records the CC&Rs. A certificate of occupancy follows the inspections and is issued by the Department of Buildings, in a final version or a temporary one, both stamped DOB Certified. The owners' association of all unit owners then elects a board of managers, which usually hires a managing agent. The board may levy assessments under the Condominium Act, and an unpaid assessment can become a lien recorded by certificate of lien. Sponsor control of the board ends when more than 50 percent of the common interest is sold or five years after the first closing, whichever comes first.
The Attorney General is the gatekeeper for every offering. The Martin Act, Article 23 of the General Business Law, requires a full description of the property in the offering plan and puts every plan under Attorney General review and regulation, amendments included. Acceptance for filing is not approval of the price or the financial terms. CPS-1 lets a sponsor test the market for 120 days after acceptance, extendable by 60 days, with no reservations of any kind and no deposits until an offering plan is accepted for filing, and with every advertisement cleared by the Attorney General and carrying the CPS-1 legend. Converting an occupied building takes an eviction plan, effective at 51 percent of bona fide tenants in occupancy signing purchase agreements, or a non-eviction plan, effective at 15 percent of dwelling units sold to people who will live in them.
A condominium deal moves from a letter of intent to a binding contract. The letter of intent is usually non-binding, carries a small deposit the buyer gets back if she walks during that phase, and gives her a right of first refusal on the unit. The binding contract is enforceable, usually takes a sizable deposit often around 20 percent, and obligates both parties. Flipping is assigning a contract, the sale of purchase rights before the unit closes, and a simultaneous closing pairs a private mortgage note with a same-day closing. Title issues are resolved before closing, the Closing Disclosure required by the Truth in Lending Act and RESPA sets out every debit and credit, and some condominium contracts give the association a right of first refusal on a resale.
A cooperative is a building owned by a corporation that holds title in severalty, with residents as shareholders. The shares are personal property, and each shareholder holds a proprietary lease on a unit and the right to use common areas. Purchases are financed with a share loan under a recognition agreement among lender, co-op and shareholder. Shareholders pay a prorated share of the whole building's expenses and taxes, so one default can expose the entire cooperative. The buyer's lawyer reads the financial statement, the board minutes and the offering plan before the contract is signed. Boards vet buyers through the board package and the interview, receive the package through the managing agent, may charge a flip tax to the seller, set sublet terms through the proprietary lease, and may reject any candidate except on the basis of a protected class. A holder of unsold shares is typically exempt from flip taxes and sublet fees and may sell or sublet without board approval.
A condop is a building divided into at least two condominiums, the residential co-op units together forming one condominium unit and the professional and commercial space forming another. It exists because of Section 216 of the Internal Revenue Code, the 80/20 rule: no more than 20 percent of the cooperative's yearly income may come from non-shareholder sources, or individual shareholders lose their yearly tax and mortgage-interest write-offs. Conversion can be expensive, and once the commercial space is sold the board may lose control over who occupies it.
The vocabulary is half the exam, so carry the pairs. Declaration and unit deed. Bylaws and house rules. Common areas and limited common areas. Common charges and maintenance. Mortgage and share loan. Deed and stock certificate. Eviction plan and non-eviction plan. Condominium and condop. In each pair the two words look interchangeable and are not, and a question that swaps one for the other is testing exactly that.
Two habits carry more weight in this chapter than any single fact. The first is sending documents to counsel. The offering plan, the letter of intent, the binding contract, the financial statement, the board minutes, the alteration agreement and the house rules all belong in front of an attorney, and your job is to get them there rather than to interpret them. The second is checking which stage a building is at before you say anything about it, because market testing, an accepted offering plan, a sponsor-controlled board and an owner-controlled board each permit a different set of sentences.
REMEMBER: Which of these six could you not explain to a buyer standing in a lobby right now? Go back to that lesson before you take the quiz.
YOU BE THE JUDGE
The Sutton Place Shuffle
Priya, a salesperson at Meridian Realty, is marketing The Selwyn, a new Sutton Place condominium whose sponsor holds an accepted application to test the market, and nothing else on file with the Attorney General. When a couple falls for unit 9C, Priya signs them to a binding reservation and banks their $5,000 check “to hold the line.” She launches a brand-new Instagram campaign she wrote that morning, no CPS-1 legend, never submitted to the Attorney General, and closes every pitch with the rooftop gym she hears the sponsor is “definitely adding,” though no gym appears anywhere in the draft offering plan.
Across town she shows a resale condo to a first-time buyer, warning him that “if any neighbor stops paying their mortgage, the bank can foreclose on the whole building.” At an occupied rental her sponsor client is converting under a non-eviction plan, she tells an elderly renter that once an investor buys his apartment, “the new owner can put you out at the end of the year.” In a seven-year-old condominium where the sponsor still names the board despite having sold 60% of the common interest, she assures the owners' association that “the sponsor keeps control until every unit sells.” And when her Selwyn buyer wavers after signing a non-binding letter of intent with a $1,000 deposit, she warns him the deposit is “gone the minute you walk.”
Prepping a co-op buyer in Carnegie Hill for the board, Priya coaches: “Don't mention the goldendoodle or the eBay business in the second bedroom, what they don't know can't hurt you.” When the board rejects a different client, she shrugs, “Boards can turn you down for your race or your religion, it's their building, it's all legal.” Her buyer's lender asks for a recognition agreement; Priya says “co-ops don't do those anymore, skip it.” At closing she hands the new shareholder a sledgehammer: “Kitchen demo starts Saturday, your apartment now, no paperwork needed.”
Her last stop is a struggling co-op on First Avenue, where she urges the board to lease the entire second floor, nearly 40% of the building's income, to a supermarket, assuring shareholders that “rental income never touches your tax deductions.” On the way out she meets an investor who bought the sponsor's remaining shares and was formally designated the holder of unsold shares; he mentions he sublets his three units without board approval and has never paid a flip tax or sublet fee. Priya makes a note to report him to the managing agent.
Twelve violations are buried in that story, and one lawful act has been planted to catch you out. Work it the way you would work a file rather than the way you would take a test.
Read it once for the story and mark nothing. Read it a second time with a pen and mark every sentence that made you pause, without deciding yet whether the sentence is a violation. Then go back through this chapter and name the rule each marked sentence touches. A sentence you cannot attach to a rule is a sentence you are guessing about.
FIVE THREADS RUN THROUGH THESE FACTS
The first thread is what a sponsor may do before an offering plan exists. Read the first paragraph again with the CPS-1 screen open beside it. Ask what stage the Selwyn is at, what that stage permits, and what it forbids in words that leave no room. Then ask a separate question about the same paragraph: where does a buyer learn what a building will actually contain, and what is the standing instruction about anything a sales office says that the document does not.
The second thread is what a condominium owner owns and what that exposes. One sentence in the second paragraph describes a consequence of default. Decide which form of ownership that consequence actually belongs to. It belongs to one of the two forms in this chapter and not to the other, and the whole difference sits in whether the lien stops at the unit line.
The third thread is what a conversion does to the people already living in the building. Name the plan the sponsor filed, then find the sentence in this chapter that says what an outside purchaser of an occupied apartment may and may not do. The answer does not depend on how long the tenant has left on a lease.
The fourth thread is sponsor control and the letter-of-intent phase, and both are numbers problems. One sentence claims a control rule with the wrong threshold in it. Another claims a deposit is forfeited. Go find the actual threshold, and go find the sentence about what the buyer holds during the letter-of-intent phase, and compare them to what Priya says out loud.
The fifth thread is the cooperative. Four separate statements in the third paragraph touch four separate rules: what a candidate owes the board in an interview, what grounds a board may never use, what a lender is entitled to ask for on a share loan, and what has to be signed before anybody swings a hammer. Take them one at a time. Three of the four are things Priya said, and one of them is something she handed over.
Then the last paragraph, which carries two items and they pull in opposite directions. One is a percentage problem with a tax consequence that lands on individual shareholders. The other is the planted lawful act, and finding it is the harder half of the exercise, because an accusation made too quickly is its own kind of problem for a licensee.
ONE TEST THAT SORTS MOST OF THEM
For every sentence Priya says out loud, ask what would have to be true for it to be accurate, and then ask whether the story gives you that fact. Most of her statements are rules stated wrongly rather than lies about the facts. She describes a threshold that does not exist, a protection that does not apply, a document that is not required, a consequence that belongs to the other form of ownership. The facts in the story are usually fine. The law attached to them is not.
That distinction is worth practicing because it is the same distinction a complaint turns on. A licensee who gets a fact wrong can correct it. A licensee who tells a consumer what the law is, wrongly, has said something the consumer relied on, and reliance is what makes it actionable.
HOW TO WORK THE MARKED SENTENCES
Put every marked sentence in one of three piles. Clearly a violation. Clearly lawful. Cannot tell from these facts. The third pile teaches you the most, because for every item in it you have to name the one missing fact that would move it into another pile. A licensee who can name the missing fact is a licensee who knows what to ask for.
Then argue the other side of whichever item you were least sure about. Say it out loud, in full sentences, as though Priya is across the table and has a reason for everything she said. If you cannot build that argument at all, go back and read the screen the rule came from, because you have memorized a phrase rather than learned a rule.
Notice also who Priya is talking to in each scene, because the audience changes the weight of the mistake. A sponsor client can hire lawyers. An owners' association can read its own offering plan. A first-time buyer and a long-term elderly renter cannot check anything she tells them, and they have no reason to think they need to. Two of the statements in this story are made to people in exactly that position.
Watch for the moment the harm stops being technical. Several of these acts break a filing rule and cost the sponsor a delay. At least two of them land on a person who has no way to check what Priya told them, and those are the ones that turn into complaints. When you rank your findings, rank them by who gets hurt rather than by which rule has the longest name.
When you have a list, go back and put a name on each item. Not a summary. A name. CPS-1 reservations and deposits. CPS-1 advertising clearance. Offering plan amenities. Condominium default and the lien. Non-eviction plan protections. Sponsor board turnover. The letter-of-intent phase and the deposit. Board interview disclosure. Protected-class discrimination. The recognition agreement. The alteration agreement. The 80/20 rule. The holder of unsold shares. If you cannot name an item that way, you have not finished spotting it, because a name is what you would write in a file note and it is what an exam answer has to look like.
Count your list before you compare it to anything. Twelve violations and one lawful act is thirteen sentences that should end up on a page. A list of nine means you missed four. A list of sixteen means you have flagged something lawful as a violation, and the thing you flagged is almost certainly the planted one. Both errors matter, and the second one matters more in practice than students expect.
NOTE: If your answer to an issue is a rule with no facts attached, you have not spotted an issue. You have recited a rule and hoped it fit. Name the fact first, then name the rule it breaks, then say who the rule was protecting.
Name the fact, then name the rule
One more pass before you stop. Go back to the first paragraph and count how many separate rules the sponsor's own position triggers, before Priya says anything at all. The stage a building is at changes what every sentence spoken about it is allowed to claim, and that is the habit this exercise is really building.
Finish with the sentence you would actually have said. Pick the three scenes you found hardest and write the correct version of Priya's line for each one, in the words you would use standing in that hallway or that lobby. Short sentences. No hedging. That rewrite is the real product of this exercise, because on the job you will never be asked to name a violation. You will be asked a question, and you will have about four seconds to answer it.
REMEMBER: Of the twelve, which one would you have made yourself on a busy Tuesday? That is the screen to reread tonight.