The Course · Chapter 18 Beta

Chapter 18: Property Management

In this chapter

  • Licensing in New York Know when managing property requires a salesperson or broker license, and the roles managers fill.
  • The general agency Explain why a property manager is a general agent, and the fiduciary duties owed to the owner.
  • The management agreement List what the written agreement covers, from authority and fees to reports and termination.
  • Budgets and reports Build an operating budget and read the reports owners rely on, including the rent roll.
  • Operations and risk Schedule the three types of maintenance, manage risk and insurance, and meet New York codes.
  • Marketing and leasing Advertise effectively, evaluate the cost, qualify tenants fairly, and handle evictions lawfully.

Lesson 1

The Property Manager's Role

More than collecting rent, custodian and supervisor of an owner's property

What a Property Manager Does

Managing the property of others for a fee is licensed activity in New York

A property manager is hired by a real property owner to administer, market and maintain property, especially rental property. The manager is the custodian and supervisor of somebody else's building.

Property management is the leasing or renting, or the offering to lease or rent, the real property of others for a fee, commission, compensation or other valuable consideration, pursuant to a property management employee contract. That definition is the licensing rule. To manage property in New York you must hold a real estate salesperson or broker license.

Managing others' property for compensation is licensed activity in New York.

Chapter 1 gave you the three elements that make an act licensed. For another. For compensation. And an act the statute lists. Renting and leasing are on that list, so a manager who rents apartments for owners and takes a fee has all three and needs the license. A building supervisor or maintenance worker employed by one owner, collecting rent or showing apartments for that owner, is outside the rule, and so is a salaried superintendent who earns no leasing commissions. Manage for the public, for fees, and the license is required.

THREE WAYS THE ROLE IS STAFFED

A property manager usually oversees a number of properties for various owners. A building manager manages just one building, and special-purpose facilities often keep one on staff. A resident manager represents a property management firm and may live on the premises of the building being managed. The three titles describe how the work is staffed.

The skills are the same whichever title you hold. Every manager needs an understanding of leasing regulations in order to collect rents, and enough construction knowledge to know whether routine maintenance was performed. The rest of the Department of State list is this chapter in miniature: supervising others, general accounting principles, monthly and yearly reports, building systems, landlord-tenant relations, leasing and space planning, advertising, codes and regulations at every level of government, union negotiations, purchasing, ecology, and appraisal, finance, depreciation and local market conditions.

Designations raise your knowledge, skill base and marketability. The Building Owners and Managers Association International awards the Real Property Administrator. The Institute of Real Estate Management, an affiliate of the National Association of REALTORS, awards the Accredited Residential Manager and the Certified Property Manager. The National Association of Residential Property Managers awards the Professional and the Master Property Manager.

NOTE: The licensing question on the exam always comes down to two questions. Who is being paid, and whose property is it? An owner renting her own building needs nothing. A bookkeeper posting rent payments needs nothing, because posting a payment is not leasing. A manager leasing for several owners for fees needs the license.

Custodian and supervisor of somebody else's asset

REMEMBER: Name the three staffing titles, then say which one can live in the building. Now say what all three have in common in New York.

Five Specialties, One Mission

Rent space effectively, maintain the property, comply with regulations, keep operating costs low

Whatever kind of tenant occupies the space, every property manager has the same mission. Market and rent the space effectively. Maintain the property. Comply with government regulations. Keep operating costs low. Five specialties change the work and leave the mission alone.

Commercial office. Office space runs from a single-story building to a high-rise complex. Learn the competing space in your area, set a base rent for a typical office in the building, then adjust the other offices against it. Negotiating an office lease is the most complex of the five, because remodeling, escalation clauses and the tenant's right to sublet are all bargaining points. Tenants who want special alterations usually pay for the work themselves, though an owner may pay rather than let the space sit empty.

Commercial retail. Strip shops are relatively easy and large shopping malls are not. Percentage leases are common, hours of operation and alterations may be restricted, and qualifying a retail tenant is more detailed because parking and customer traffic matter. Never place two stores selling the same goods side by side. An anchor tenant is a major department or chain store placed strategically within a shopping center to give maximum exposure to the smaller satellite stores around it.

Mall liability costs money. It is often hard to determine who is liable for an accident in a common area, such as the food court or a fountain. Liability insurance works best when the property manager, the owners, the tenants and the merchants are all co-insured. Notify the insurer immediately after any accident, because delay can cost the coverage.

Residential. Single-family homes, apartments, condominiums and cooperatives, mobile home parks and retirement communities. Pricing and marketing are the keys, so read local supply and demand before setting a rent. Subsidized housing funded through HUD follows HUD rules and standards. Condominiums and cooperatives both have an owners' association, the board of directors or the board of managers, and the manager works with that board.

Special-purpose. Hotels, motels, theaters, schools, places of worship, housing for the elderly and planned unit developments. The design mirrors the activity inside, which is why a theater could never function as office space. Housing for the elderly covers independent living, assisted living and nursing homes, is highly competitive, and must be adapted to the people living in it. A planned unit development is a subdivision that may combine non-residential with residential uses, or depart from ordinary zoning and subdivision rules, and in some of them the lot owners co-own the recreational facilities as tenants in common.

Industrial. Manufacturing facilities and warehouses. Heavy equipment, truck traffic and storage mean industrial tenants are generally long-term and the space is built or altered for their use. Industrial space moves slowly and is often clustered in an industrial park. Net leases are the norm, so the tenant pays a greater share of the property expenses than most leases require, and performs its own maintenance.

NOTE: The exam separates four of them by one question. Who pays for what? Office tenants usually pay for their own alterations. Retail tenants often pay a percentage of sales. Industrial tenants pay expenses and their own maintenance under a net lease. Residential tenants pay rent and little else.

Same mission, five different buildings

REMEMBER: Pick the specialty you expect to work in. Name the one expense that specialty pushes onto the tenant, and name the one risk it pushes onto the owner.

Lesson 2

The Owner and the Management Agreement

A general agency, its written contract, and the money reports that flow from it

A General Agent in a Position of Trust

The agency the management agreement creates

The management agreement creates an agency. The owner is the principal, the manager is the agent, and the manager stands between the owner and the tenants. Duties run up to the owner. Authority runs down to the building.

A fiduciary is a person in a position of trust, held by law to high standards of good faith and loyalty. A property management company owes the property owner the same fiduciary duties owed to any client: obedience, loyalty, disclosure, confidentiality, accountability and reasonable care. Chapter 2 taught those six. Nothing about a management file softens any of them.

General agent, the manager

Special agent, a salesperson

A general agent is authorized to handle all of the principal's affairs in one area or in specified areas. A property manager is a general agent because of the sheer breadth of the duties performed. A salesperson on a single transaction is a special agent, with duties restricted to one area of performance. Breadth is the whole difference, and breadth is what the exam is testing.

Look at what the owner hands over. Select tenants and lease units. Sign leases. Set and collect rents. Handle security deposits. Initiate eviction proceedings. Hire staff and outside vendors. A salesperson finds a buyer for one house. A manager runs a building.

THE MANAGER’S THREE MAIN JOBS

Fulfill the goals and objectives of the owner. Understanding what the owner actually wants is the most important job a manager has. An owner holding a building for ten years wants different things from an owner planning to sell in eighteen months, and a budget built for the wrong one is a bad budget however neat the arithmetic.

Create income for the owner. An effective manager maximizes income and minimizes expenses, and reads the property inside the total real estate picture, because the real estate market has its own cycles alongside the general economy. Adjust what you control. Offer a free month of rent to draw renters in a tight market, and plan ahead rather than react.

Maintain or increase the property's value. Condition and management sustain what the asset is worth, and both show up in an appraisal.

CAUTION: The agency is general, so the exposure is general. When a manager signs a lease, the owner is bound by it. When a manager settles a vendor invoice, the owner pays it. Authority that broad is why any limit on it has to be written down.

Broad duties make the agency general

REMEMBER: Say the difference between a general agent and a special agent in one sentence. Then name the manager's first job, before income and before value.

Inside the Management Agreement

The written contract that governs the owner-manager relationship

The management agreement, also called the property management employee contract, governs the relationship between the property owner and the property manager. It details the manager's duties, responsibilities and compensation, and documents what the owner is responsible for. It is a contract and it should be signed by both parties.

Description of the property. An exact address must be part of the agreement, and sometimes a full legal description is necessary. Establish the perimeter too. Is the landscaping out front yours to manage? The gift shop in the lobby? The ancillary buildings? Anything excluded has to be written in, because an owner and a manager remember that conversation very differently a year later.

Length of agreement. The term varies from property to property and is negotiated between owner and manager. One year is common, and a longer term can be negotiated and the contract renewed once both sides are satisfied.

Management authority. This clause says what the manager may do: select tenants and lease units, sign leases, set and collect rents, handle security deposits, initiate eviction procedures, and hire staff and outside vendors. Any limitation on the manager's authority must be indicated in the agreement. Some owners limit authority to a time frame, some to a dollar amount.

Management fee. There is no hard-and-fast way to compute it, because so many things affect a property's profitability. Work out your direct and indirect costs, then agree a figure with the owner. A flat fee is a specific amount paid at set increments. A percentage fee is based on the operation's gross collectible income, and it may instead be a fixed percentage of rent, or a bonus when a set number of leases is signed. Where two leasing agents work the property, the fee is sometimes split.

Insurance and risk management. Blanket the property against the greatest risks at the most economical rates, and insulate the owner from liability. Lesson 3 takes this apart.

Accounting responsibilities and reports. Set rents that cover every expense of operating the building and still return a profit, then state in the agreement when the property management report is distributed and to whom. Usually that is monthly.

Owner's responsibilities and objectives. Who oversees payroll and insurance, and what monthly, quarterly and yearly payments the manager has to make. These vary, so they get listed rather than assumed.

Termination. Spell out how and why the agreement may be terminated, including the manager's compensation for leases negotiated and contracts not yet executed if an owner cancels early.

CAUTION: A handshake is not a management agreement. Two clauses do the most work in a dispute and a handshake has neither: the limit on your authority and the terms of termination. An owner who never wrote down a dollar cap will remember one, and a manager who never wrote down a termination formula will be paid nothing for the leases signed in the last month.

In writing, signed by both, limits stated

REMEMBER: Eight components. Which one protects the owner from a manager who spends too much, and which one protects the manager from an owner who cancels too soon?

The Operating Budget

A one-year projection of income and expenses

Once the management agreement is signed, the manager builds the management proposal, the plan created by the property manager for overseeing the property. It contains a one-year operating budget, a five-year plan and a market analysis at the regional, neighborhood and property level. The market analysis is where economic factors, population, zoning and transportation get written down.

An operating budget projects the income and expenses of the property over a one-year period. Total income is gross rental income plus other income, less the losses from vacant space, evictions and uncollected rent. Fixed expenses do not vary with the occupancy level of the property, such as property taxes and insurance. Variable expenses depend on the occupancy level, such as repairs, maintenance, salaries and utilities. Net operating income is what is left after expenses are deducted.

SAMPLE ANNUAL OPERATING BUDGET, 35,000 SQ FT AT $23.50 / SQ FT

Potential gross income

$822,500

vacancy & collection loss (10%) − $82,250

Effective gross income

$740,250

total operating expenses − $277,900

Net operating income

$462,350

FIXED, same at any occupancy

Real estate taxes $91,350

Insurance $2,450

VARIABLE, follows occupancy

Utilities $81,900 · Maintenance $40,950 · Repairs $14,000 · Mgmt fees $8,400 · Other $1,750 · Reserves (5% of EGI, roof, HVAC) $37,100

Walk that budget from the top and you have the shape of every one you will ever read. Rentable area times rent per square foot gives potential gross income. Take out vacancy and collection loss and you have effective gross income. Take out operating expenses and you have net operating income. Chapters 19 and 20 turn net operating income into an investment number with capitalization rates and cash-on-cash returns.

Capital expenses improve the property and increase its value. Sometimes they are planned and sometimes something stops working, like a roof or an air conditioning unit. They are long-term investment components rather than regular maintenance, and large remodeling costs are often amortized over several years. The capital reserve budget carries the capital expenses that are not fixed, as an annual average cost of replacing building components. That is the $37,100 reserve line above.

A stabilized budget is the income and expenses averaged over a five-year period, the long-term forecast built on potential growth and market trends. It is what the owner reads when deciding whether to hold the building or sell it.

A budget comparison statement compares the actual working budget against the budget set at the beginning of the year, for the month and year to date. It confirms the trends that are holding and flags the lines that need extra work.

With the reports in hand, the manager makes recommendations. Add a pool to the apartment complex. Renovate the lobby. A recommendation is worth making when the numbers behind it are already on the desk.

NOTE: Booking a capital expense as routine maintenance is the classic budget error, and it distorts two reports at once. The operating budget shows an expense year that never happened, and the reserve budget shows money still there for a roof already replaced.

Income, minus vacancy, minus expenses

REMEMBER: The building is half empty. Which lines of the budget move with it, and which lines do not move at all?

Reporting to the Owner, and the Rent Roll

Precise, regular communication of the property’s condition and finances

A property manager communicates precisely to the owner the condition and financial status of the property, and every report meets the criteria the owner and the manager agreed on. Four reports carry most of that communication.

The property management report tells the owner the status of the property: income, expenses and disbursements. The manager prepares it and usually distributes it monthly. The budget comparison statement sets actual against plan, for the month and year to date. The profit and loss statement is a brief statement issued at regular intervals: gross receipts, minus operating expenses, minus the total mortgage payment, plus the mortgage loan principal, equals net profit. The cash flow report is usually monthly and gives the owner a detailed financial picture of the property.

Income − Expenses − Debt Service = OPERATING CASH, the key line of the monthly cash flow report.

THE SUBJECT’S RENT ROLL

Unit

Monthly rent

Tenant

Term remaining

1-A

$1,375

Roberta Glass

5 months

1-B

$1,400

John Taylor

10 months

2-A

$1,250

Brady Hill

9 months

2-B

$1,300

Roger Stafford

36 months

A rent roll is a spreadsheet of key information about a property: the number of units, tenant names with apartment numbers, lease dates and the rent each tenant pays. It tracks vacancies and occupancies and keeps tabs on local rent rates. Read the one above as an owner would. Three leases end inside a year and one runs another three, so most of this building has to be re-rented or renewed within ten months.

The manager's office holds the paper behind all of it, and the most logical place for it is the building itself, out of space that carries a high rental value. Project bids are kept one year, correspondence three, expired insurance policies five, financial reports ten. Leases, canceled checks and receipts, profit and loss records and monthly income and expense reports are kept too, and coverage is checked regularly against expiration dates. Property records, including mortgage information, title, the legal description, the management contract and labor contracts, are kept as long as the owner has the property.

Never commingle

Keep personal and business funds strictly separate. Chapter 1 put commingling on the list of grounds for suspension or revocation, and a manager touches other people's money every month. Know enough about appraisal, finance, money markets, depreciation, financial trends and local market conditions to make the reports useful, because owners read them to decide when to sell and when to buy more.

CAUTION: A report the owner does not receive is not a report. The management agreement states when reports go out and to whom, and a manager who decides on his own that once a year is enough has breached the agreement and the duty of accountability in the same act.

Four reports, one rent roll, separate accounts

REMEMBER: Which report shows what was planned against what happened? Which one ends in operating cash? Then say the operating cash formula and the profit and loss formula out loud.

Lesson 3

Operations: Maintenance & Risk

Where the operating budget meets the boiler room

The Three Types of Maintenance

A large part of the operating budget, schedule it and control it

Maintenance costs are a large part of a property's operating budget, so they get scheduled and controlled rather than handled as they arise. Three types concern a property manager, and the exam separates them by what each is for.

Preventive maintenance is routine maintenance and inspections that keep equipment and the property in good working order. Scheduled inspections. Replacing parts before they fail. The service contract on the boiler. Corrective maintenance restores broken or failed equipment to a specified condition. Repair work is a less frequent expense, and it is the one that has to happen at a moment's notice, so line up qualified repair people before you need them. Cosmetic maintenance increases the property's appeal and attracts new tenants. New wallpaper in the lobby. Flowers planted along the walkway.

RUN IT LIKE A SYSTEM

Have a thorough understanding of the property. Keep a written inventory of property elements with maintenance records attached. Evaluate what maintenance costs and keep the necessary parts in supply. Determine who performs each job. Keep a detailed schedule for preventive work. Develop a list of qualified contractors and workers, keep records of the work performed, and keep records of competitive bids.

Most managers also supervise people. Depending on the size of the property, a manager may oversee an assistant property manager, a tenant services coordinator or an administrative assistant, and a large multiple-tenant facility may add maintenance and janitorial contractors, security and landscaping.

Know your building systems: electrical, structural engineering, waterproofing, plumbing, HVAC, gas, security, elevators and maintenance. A general understanding of those lets you plan preventive work, direct your staff and talk with contractors and builders. It also matters at appraisal, because the manager is the one who walks the appraiser through a building whose condition and system maintenance drive what it is worth.

NOTE: Cutting preventive maintenance is the fastest way to make a budget look better this quarter. It moves the money, it does not remove the work, and it converts a scheduled expense you chose into a corrective expense that chooses you.

Prevent, correct, and make it look good

REMEMBER: A boiler part replaced on schedule in September, and the same part replaced after a failure in January. Name both types, and say which one also cost you a tenant.

Risk, Insurance, and the Codes

Identify, manage and minimize the potential risks on a property

Risk management is identifying, managing and minimizing the potential risks on a property. A manager does it for two reasons that pull the same way: protecting the building from loss, and insulating the owner from liability through the right insurance recommendations. Blanket the property with insurance covering the greatest risks at the most economical rates.

Coverage usually needs to reach damage from fire, flood, wind and other acts of nature; Workers' Compensation claims; liability for contractors; loss of income and loss of occupancy; equipment and machinery; and automobiles owned by and used for the property.

Minimize the risks you can fix, and for the ones you cannot, establish emergency and crisis plans. Those plans are coordinated with local government authorities, with security personnel and with the tenants themselves, because a plan the tenants have never heard of is not a plan.

NEW YORK CODES AND REGULATIONS

Understanding codes and restrictions is part of the job. In New York State the New York Multiple Dwelling Law is in effect, and three of its provisions work this way.

Oct–May

heat must be available

October 1 through May 31, under the NY Multiple Dwelling Law.

NY MULTIPLE DWELLING LAW

Each living unit: an operational carbon monoxide detector and an approved smoke detector

Lights of at least 40 watts in every rear, side, and front yard and court

Landlords must also comply with federal Fair Housing laws and the Americans with Disabilities Act, with local occupancy laws, with environmental laws setting requirements for trash disposal, with health and building department laws, and with zoning regulations. Chapter 11 carries fair housing in full, and a property manager makes more fair housing decisions in a month than most salespeople make in a year.

The baseline underneath all of it is short. Secure the premises for the enjoyment of the tenants. Keep them clean and free of garbage. Keep them safe. In practice that means stopping noisy parties, adding security features and lights where they are needed, and rearranging parking to make it safer.

Three more responsibilities close out the list. Union negotiations, because maintenance and building service staff may be unionized labor with different schedules than non-union staff. Purchasing, because managers buy supplies, write purchase orders and pay contractors. And ecology, because buildings are increasingly designed to be energy efficient, and saving the owner money on electricity, gas, water and landscaping is part of minimizing expenses.

CAUTION: Insurance is only as good as the notice you give. When an accident happens on the property, notify the insurance company immediately. Waiting until the repair is finished, or until the file looks tidier, can cost the owner coverage for that accident entirely.

Blanket the risk, then obey the code

REMEMBER: It is the fifteenth of October and the boiler is down. Name the law, name the date the heating season started, and name who the owner will be looking at.

Lesson 4

Leasing, Marketing, and Tenants

Filling the space, and keeping the people in it safe and treated fairly

Leasing Space, and Taking It Back

The lessee is the tenant; the lessor is the landlord

Leasing space produces the income the whole job depends on. The lessee is the tenant. The lessor is the landlord.

Before the lease is signed, make sure the layout suits the tenant. Can an advertising agency grow in the space if it lands a major account? Asking before signing is cheaper than a tenant who leaves in year two.

A BINDING LEASE INCLUDES

Names and signatures of all parties

Date the tenant can assume occupancy

Description of the space, address, unit numbers, a highlighted floor plan for commercial space

Terms: beginning and termination dates, the period covered

Valuable consideration, the exchange of promises, the rent amount, and when and where it is paid

Escalation clauses for automatic rent adjustments

All parties’ rights and obligations · restrictions on use

Illegal activity on the premises = grounds for immediate termination

Chapter 12 taught the lease as a contract. The most common leasehold estate is a tenancy, or estate, for years, which lasts for a definite period and ends automatically when the lease term is up. That is why a rent roll shows you in March which leases end in September.

CAUTION: The automatic ending is the estate rule. Since April 20, 2024, the Good Cause Eviction Law, Real Property Law Article 6-A, sits on top of it in New York City and in any locality that adopts it. The landlord of a covered unit may not remove a tenant or refuse to renew without good cause.

ACTUAL EVICTION

Actual eviction is the legal process of dispossessing or expelling someone from real property. It regains possession from a tenant unwilling to give it up, and managers reach for it on non-payment, broken rules or criminal behavior. Where the problem is rent delinquency, offer a grace period first. When eviction is unavoidable, work with an attorney who has performed evictions before.

On a covered unit the court must find a ground Real Property Law §216 lists: unpaid rent, an uncured lease violation, nuisance, illegal use, refusal of access, the owner's own use, demolition, withdrawal from the market, or refusal of reasonable lease changes. Rent owed from an unreasonable increase does not count. An increase above the local rent standard, 5 percent plus the change in the Consumer Price Index and never more than 10 percent, is presumed unreasonable. Every lease, renewal and eviction notice carries the state's Good Cause notice. Landlords with ten units or fewer, owner-occupied buildings of ten units or fewer, regulated units and buildings with a certificate of occupancy issued on or after January 1, 2009 are among the exemptions.

CONSTRUCTIVE EVICTION

Constructive eviction runs the other direction. It is a landlord's act, or failure to act, that interferes with the tenant's quiet enjoyment or makes the property unfit for its intended use, to such an extent that the tenant is forced to move out. To claim it, the tenant must actually vacate the property. A tenant who complains about no heat for a month and stays has no claim. A tenant who packs up and leaves over it does.

Self-help eviction is illegal

A self-help eviction, sometimes called a lock-out or a freeze-out, is a landlord using physical force or other means to get rid of a tenant instead of going through the legal process. For a residential landlord in New York it is illegal to threaten the tenants, to change the locks, to shut off utility services, or to introduce noise or other nuisance to make them leave. Some commercial leases do include a clause letting the landlord retake possession without going to court if the tenant defaults, and that is why the commercial and residential answers to the same fact pattern differ.

CAUTION: An owner will suggest every item on that list over the phone, calmly. Changing the locks on a tenant three weeks behind in rent is a self-help eviction, and the manager who does it acted as the owner's general agent, which puts both of them in it.

Legal process only, and the tenant must vacate

REMEMBER: Say the difference between actual and constructive eviction in one sentence each. Then say the one thing a tenant must do before claiming the second one.

Marketing the Space, Qualifying the Tenant

Size the campaign to the vacancy

A solid marketing plan attracts tenants, and a good campaign reaches a pool of preferred tenants rather than simply a lot of people. Assess supply and demand and size the effort to it. A high vacancy rate calls for an aggressive campaign. One vacancy in a high-demand market calls for very little.

Word of mouth works, and current tenants are an excellent source of referrals, so offer a bonus for good ones. For print, pick the publications the target audience reads; classified ads cost less and display ads hit harder. Signs give the kind of unit, the management firm and a phone number. Brochures carry brief copy, good photos and a clean layout.

Direct mail sends fliers to prospective tenants and targeted brokers, cheaper and more casual than a brochure. Online means a website with easy-to-navigate photos and information. A press release suits a property with special features, and a publication that runs it with a photo costs almost nothing.

Marketing space is expensive, so owners want to know what it bought. Track how each prospective tenant heard about the unit, what each effort cost, and how many prospects it produced.

$80

cost per prospect

Take an $800 ad. Ten people walked through the space before the lease was signed, and $800 divided by ten prospects is $80 per prospect. Now add the cost of the empty space. A unit sat vacant two weeks with one $100 classified ad each week, which is $200 in advertising. The space rents for $3,000 a month, so $36,000 a year, divided by 52 weeks is $692.31 a week, and two weeks empty is $1,384.62 in lost income. The two empty weeks cost $1,584.62, not $200. Vacancy is the expensive half.

QUALIFYING TENANTS

Use a standard lease application for every applicant. The detail in it gives an objective basis on which to evaluate every potential tenant, and the same form every time is what makes the evaluation equal and fair. A typical application asks for identity, every anticipated occupant, contact information, employment, previous residences with rent and reason for leaving, credit history and references. Most carry a section the applicant signs authorizing the manager to investigate credit, criminal and rental history.

An applicant cannot be denied because of membership in a protected class. Chapter 11 carries the protected classes federally, under the New York State Human Rights Law and under the New York City Human Rights Law. A manager in New York City works under all three. Lawful reasons to turn an applicant down: a criminal record, unless that is a protected class where the property sits; an eviction or a history of late rent; income that will not reasonably support the rent and ordinary living expenses; a bankruptcy or a history of unpaid bills.

Source of income, ECOA

The federal Equal Credit Opportunity Act prohibits discriminating against someone based on the source of their income, and it applies to leasing residential property. Income from regular and continuing public assistance is equal to any other stable income. Reliable alimony, child support or separate maintenance also count, an applicant is not required to disclose them, and an applicant who exercises that good faith right of nondisclosure cannot be discriminated against for it.

All advertising must comply with federal, state and county law and with city civil rights and fair housing guidelines. Display ads carry the equal housing logo and every ad must be non-discriminatory.

In New York City the FARE Act, Local Law 119 of 2024, in effect since June 11, 2025, decides who pays the leasing fee. A manager or broker who rents or lists a unit for the owner is the landlord's agent and may not charge the tenant any fee related to the rental. A tenant may still hire and pay her own broker. Every tenant fee goes clearly in the listing, and the tenant signs an itemized written disclosure of those fees before signing the lease.

CAUTION: Turning down an applicant because her steady income is public assistance is not a judgment call about risk. Regular public assistance is stable income under the ECOA, and refusing it is the source-of-income violation the rule was written for. An owner's preference for payroll checks is no defense, and following an owner's unlawful instruction is not obedience.

Every applicant, the same form, the same questions

REMEMBER: Your ad cost $600 and eight people toured the unit. What is your cost per prospect, and what is the number you still have not counted?

Chapter 18 Summary

The six things to carry out of property management

Licensed activity. Leasing or renting the real property of others for a fee, pursuant to a property management employee contract, requires a New York salesperson or broker license. The manager is custodian and supervisor of the owner's property, as a property manager over several owners' buildings, a building manager over one, or a resident manager who may live on site. A salaried employee of a single owner earning no leasing commissions is outside the rule.

A general agent. The management agreement creates an agency in which the owner is the principal and the manager is the general agent, authorized to handle all of the principal's affairs in specified areas. That breadth separates the manager from a salesperson, a special agent restricted to one area. The manager is a fiduciary owing obedience, loyalty, disclosure, confidentiality, accountability and reasonable care. Three jobs, in order: fulfill the owner's goals, create income, maintain or increase value.

The management agreement. Written and signed by both parties. Property description, length, management authority and every limit on it, the fee flat or as a percentage of gross collectible income, insurance, accounting and reports, the owner's responsibilities, and termination including compensation for leases negotiated and contracts not yet executed.

The money. Potential gross income, less vacancy and collection loss, gives effective gross income. Less fixed expenses such as taxes and insurance, and variable expenses such as utilities, maintenance and repairs, gives net operating income. Capital expenses sit in the capital reserve budget, the stabilized budget averages five years, the budget comparison statement sets actual against plan. Profit and loss is gross receipts less operating expenses less the total mortgage payment plus loan principal. Income minus expenses minus debt service equals operating cash. Reports are usually monthly, the rent roll tracks units and terms, and personal and business funds never mix.

Operations. Preventive maintenance replaces parts before they fail, corrective maintenance restores what has already failed, cosmetic maintenance sells the building. Risk management means blanket coverage at economical rates, emergency plans for the risks you cannot fix, immediate notice to the insurer. Under the New York Multiple Dwelling Law, heat must be available from October 1 through May 31, each living unit needs an operational carbon monoxide detector and an approved smoke detector, and yards and courts need lights of at least 40 watts.

Leasing and marketing. Seven advertising channels, measured by cost per prospect and by the rent lost while a unit sits empty. Fair-housing-compliant ads with the equal housing logo. A standard application for every applicant, lawful denial grounds, and the ECOA rule that regular public assistance counts as stable income. Actual eviction goes through the legal process, constructive eviction requires the tenant to vacate, and self-help eviction is illegal for a residential landlord. In New York City a covered unit needs good cause to evict or refuse renewal, and the landlord's agent may not charge the tenant a fee.

Six ideas, one building, somebody else’s money

REMEMBER: Which of the six could you not explain to an owner across a kitchen table right now? Go back to that screen before you take the quiz.

YOU BE THE JUDGE · ISSUE-SPOTTING CHALLENGE

The Fordham Road Fiasco

Dario, a salesperson at Beaumont Property Group, lands the management of a 44-unit walk-up on Fordham Road and the Mosholu Mews strip center. He and the owner shake hands on the arrangement, “we'll paper it later”, and Dario gets to work. Swamped in leasing season, he brings in his cousin Manny, who holds no license of any kind, to show apartments, negotiate rents, and sign tenants for a cut of each lease. The owner told Dario to clear any repair over $2,500 in advance; when the parapet needs $18,000 of work, Dario signs the contract himself rather than bother him.

Dario deposits each month's rent collections into his personal checking account, “one account is simpler”, and decides the owner needs a property management report just once a year. When the roof finally gives out, he replaces it for $60,000 and books it in the operating budget as a routine maintenance expense. Presenting that budget, he assures the owner that if occupancy dips he can “trim the fixed costs, taxes and insurance scale down with fewer tenants.”

To hit his numbers, Dario cancels the boiler service contract and the scheduled fall inspection, “we'll fix it if it breaks.” It breaks on November 12, and the building has no heat for nineteen days while he shops for the cheapest repair; the tenant in 3-C packs up and moves out for good. The tenant in 4-B, three weeks behind on rent, comes home to new locks and no running water. At Mosholu Mews, a hardware store defaults; Dario invokes the commercial lease's clause allowing the landlord to retake possession without going to court, and re-lets the space.

In April a shopper slips at the fountain in the Mews' common area; Dario waits six weeks to tell the insurance company, until the repaving is finished. Back at the walk-up, he turns down an applicant when he sees that her steady, continuing income is public assistance, “the owner prefers payroll checks.”

Twelve violations are buried in that story, and one lawful act has been planted in it to catch you out. Work it the way you would work a file rather than the way you would take a test.

Read it once for the story and mark nothing. Read it again with a pen and mark every sentence that made you pause, without deciding yet whether it is a violation. Then name the duty, the rule or the law each marked sentence touches.

Four threads run through the facts. Who may perform a licensed act and under what written authority. What the manager owes the owner and does with the owner's money. How a budget tells the truth about fixed costs, variable costs and capital expenses. What a manager may and may not do to a building and to the people in it.

Dario is not a villain in any paragraph. He is busy, and every shortcut saves him an afternoon. Almost every violation in the story began as a reasonable-sounding decision made under time pressure, which is how these things happen in a real office.

Two sentences turn on accounting rather than law. One describes a budget treatment that is simply wrong, and the other states the relationship between occupancy and expenses backwards. Neither announces itself. Check any sentence in which Dario explains a number to the owner, because a confident explanation of a wrong number is still a wrong number.

One act in this story is lawful, and it sits directly beside acts that are not. Finding it is the harder half of the exercise, because it looks exactly like the thing this chapter told you never to do. The difference is a single fact about the property it happened on. A manager who cannot tell a permitted act from a violation is no safer than one who commits them.

Sort the marked sentences into three piles. Clearly a violation. Clearly lawful. Cannot tell from these facts. The third pile teaches the most, because for every item in it you have to name the missing fact that would move it into one of the other two. Naming that fact is the skill, and it is how a good file gets built.

Then argue the other side of the item you were least sure about, out loud and in full sentences, as though Dario is across the table with a reason for everything he did. If you cannot build that argument, go back and read the screen the rule came from, because you have memorized a phrase rather than learned a rule.

Watch the date in the third paragraph. New York attaches a rule to it, and the number of days that follow it is not incidental detail. This chapter gave you that rule twice.

NOTE: If your answer to an issue is a rule with no facts attached, you have not spotted an issue. You have recited a rule and hoped it fit. Name the fact first, then name the rule it breaks.

Name the fact, then name the rule

Check yourself

10 questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see whether it is right and why.

Key terms

Property manager
A licensed general agent who leases, maintains and operates real property for owners for compensation; may be a property, building or resident manager.
Management agreement
The written, signed contract between owner and manager setting the property, term, authority and its limits, fee, insurance, reporting and termination.
Operating budget
A one-year projection of income and expenses: gross income − vacancy = effective gross income; − fixed and variable expenses = net operating income.
Capital reserve budget
The annual amount set aside for long-term replacements such as a roof or HVAC system.
Stabilized budget
A five-year forecast averaging income and expenses to show long-term trends.
Rent roll
The schedule of units, tenants, lease dates and rents used to track occupancy and collections.
Preventive maintenance
Scheduled inspection and servicing that keeps equipment working and replaces parts before failure.
Anchor tenant
A major department or chain store placed in a shopping center to draw traffic to the smaller satellite stores.
Escalation clause
A lease provision that automatically adjusts rent, often for taxes or operating costs.
Actual eviction
The legal process by which a landlord regains possession from a tenant for non-payment or lease violations.
Self-help eviction
A landlord's use of lock-outs, utility shut-offs or force instead of legal process; illegal in New York.
Multiple Dwelling Law
The New York statute governing multi-family buildings: heat from October 1 to May 31, CO and smoke detectors in every unit, yard lighting, and repair duties.

Practise this chapter

Flashcards (free) Practice exam

Read Chapter 18 in the Book

The Book comes with the Salesperson pass ($39 for 3 months).

A study course, in beta. This is not a New York State Department of State approved qualifying course, and the time you spend here does not count toward the 77 hours you need for a salesperson license. Take the 77-hour course at a DOS-approved school; use this to learn the material and to review it. · Powered by License to Earn LLC