Lesson 2
Types of Investment Property
Land, residential, office, retail, industrial, mixed-use
Unimproved Land: Analyzing a Parcel
Location first, then zoning, environment, topography, and the bundle of rights
Raw land is where most commercial careers eventually lead, because every other property type started as a parcel somebody analyzed. Analyzing land is a different job from analyzing a building. A building shows you what it is. Land shows you almost nothing, and everything that decides its value sits in records, regulations, and soil.
There are many things to consider when analyzing a parcel of land. As with most categories of real estate, location is usually the first item considered. After location comes a long list of site considerations: zoning, environmental requirements, and the characteristics of the land itself, such as topography, which determines how much of the land is actually usable. All of these can affect whether an investor buys the property, and at what price.
When a parcel is analyzed it is usually surveyed, and it often receives an engineering or environmental report as well. A survey tells the buyer where the boundaries actually are. An engineering report tells the buyer what the ground will hold. An environmental report tells the buyer what is already in the ground and who is going to pay to take it out. A buyer who skips those three reports is buying a story rather than a parcel.
HIGHEST AND BEST USE
Once the reports are in, potential investors evaluate the property's highest and best use. Highest and best use is the legal use of a property that will yield its highest present value, meaning the greatest net return. The phrase gets used loosely in conversation. It has a precise meaning, and the precision is in four tests that all have to be satisfied at once.
Physically possible. The site can actually support the use. Topography, soil, drainage, and the shape of the lot all have to allow it. A steep, narrow, rock-bottomed parcel will not hold a distribution warehouse no matter how much the developer wants one there.
Financially feasible. The numbers work. The use can be built and operated at an acceptable return. A use that costs more to build than the finished property will ever be worth is not the highest and best use of anything.
Legally permissible. Zoning, environmental rules, and other regulations allow the use on this parcel. A use the municipality forbids is not a candidate, however profitable it would be. This is the test that sends the analysis to the zoning map.
Maximally productive, which is to say the most profitable. Of all the uses that survive the first three tests, the one producing the greatest net return is the highest and best use. The other qualifying uses are simply uses.
Work all four and the analysis stays honest. Skip one and you end up with a developer who has fallen in love with a project that zoning was never going to allow. A use that fails any single test is out, no matter how strongly it passes the other three.
All four tests, or it is not highest and best
SITE CONSIDERATIONS THAT SHAPE DEVELOPMENT
Beyond zoning and use, a short list of physical and regulatory considerations decides what can actually be built on a parcel and what it costs to build there. Each one of them has cost a developer a project somewhere.
Setbacks
Floor Area Ratio
Access and curb cuts
Utilities and sanitation
Green space
Sidewalks
A setback is the distance that a building, or the building area including parking, must be placed from a street, a property line, or an adjacent property. Setbacks are the reason a large lot can carry a small building. Subtract the front, rear, and side setbacks from a parcel and what is left is the buildable envelope, which is always smaller than the lot the buyer thought he was getting.
Floor area ratio, usually written FAR, is the total maximum size of a building permitted on a development, typically stated as a percentage of the total square footage of the property. Hypothetical. A parcel contains 20,000 square feet and the municipality permits a floor area ratio of 200 percent. The developer may build 40,000 square feet of floor area, in whatever number of floors the setbacks and height limits allow. Change the ratio to 100 percent and the same parcel carries 20,000 square feet.
Access roads and curb cuts cover two separate things. Access to the area the property sits in, and the actual access from the road onto the property. Most localities require approval of any curb cut, and engineers usually evaluate traffic patterns to determine where a curb cut may be located. A retail parcel that cannot get a curb cut where the traffic is has a value problem no amount of square footage fixes.
Utilities and sanitation services means access to water, electricity, gas, sewers, and waste removal. If the utilities are not on the property yet, the questions are how far away they are, what it costs the owner to bring them in, and what type of sanitation service is required. That cost lands on the buyer, and on a rural or edge-of-town parcel it can exceed the price of the land.
Green space is any vegetated land or water within or adjoining an urban area. It may include vacant land, rivers, playgrounds, or bike trails. Many local governments regulate the amount of green space that must be maintained as part of a land development, and that requirement comes straight off the buildable acreage.
Sidewalks are the last one and the one people forget. Many communities require developers to install sidewalks that extend across the entire frontage of a land site. Widths and materials vary from area to area. A long frontage is a marketing advantage and a construction bill at the same time.
THE BUNDLE OF RIGHTS UNDER A PARCEL
When a person purchases a parcel of land, he is actually acquiring a bundle of rights: possession, quiet enjoyment, disposition, exclusion, and control. Each right represents a separate and distinct interest and benefit derived from the ownership of property. Most people think of real estate as the land and maybe the bricks and mortar, which is to say the surface rights. There is much more to it than that, and that is one of the elements of real property that makes it such a unique commodity.
The other rights are the ones that decide land deals. Subsurface rights, which are the mineral rights. Air rights. Water rights. Each of them can be sold, leased, or reserved separately from the surface, and each of them can have been sold, leased, or reserved by somebody who owned the parcel decades before your seller did.
When an owner sells his land, he can only convey that which he still owns of the original bundle of rights. If a landowner sells a property whose mineral rights she previously leased or sold, only what she still controls may be sold. The new owner does not receive those previously sold mineral rights as part of the purchase of the fee simple ownership. Fee simple is the fullest ownership interest there is, and it is still only as full as what the seller had left to give.
That is the sentence to carry into a land closing. Fee simple does not mean everything. It means everything the seller still holds. The abstract of title is where the earlier conveyance shows up, and a buyer told that fee simple always includes the minerals has been told something that is not true.
NOTE: Two ideas on this screen get confused on exams because they both sound like limits on what can be built. Setbacks limit where the building sits. Floor area ratio limits how big the building is. A question that describes a distance from a lot line is asking about setbacks. A question that describes a percentage of the site's square footage is asking about FAR.
CAUTION: A licensee who tells a buyer what a zoning ordinance permits, or what an easement or a mineral reservation will allow, is giving legal advice. Your job is to know the vocabulary well enough to read the abstract, spot the reservation, and put the question in front of the buyer's attorney before the contract is signed.
Fee simple conveys only what the seller still owns
REMEMBER: Say the four tests of highest and best use out loud, in order. Then name the three kinds of rights that can be separated from the surface of a parcel.
Residential and Office Investments
The investor's goals never change: an acceptable return with minimized risk
Regardless of the type of property, the investor's goals remain the same. Generate an acceptable return on the investment, and minimize the risk in the transaction. Every property type in this chapter is a different way of trying to do those two things, and the differences between them are differences of management, of vacancy, and of who the buyer turns out to be.
RESIDENTIAL INVESTMENT PROPERTY
An investor in a residential property typically does not intend to live at the property. She buys it to rent to tenants for the production of income. Investors have an array of residential property to choose from, from single-family homes to large multi-family apartment buildings, and each one carries its own set of considerations.
Single-family homes are where many real estate professionals start their commercial careers, and where many beginning investors start theirs. The perceived advantages are real. Management requirements are comparatively small. The market for rental homes is stable. And a single-family house is a more liquid commodity than other types of investment property, because the pool of buyers includes everyone who wants a home as well as everyone who wants an investment.
The disadvantages are just as real and they are less obvious. The market value of a single-family investment property tends to be influenced by general market conditions rather than by the accepted methods of determining investment value, so the price is set by what homebuyers will pay rather than by what the rent supports. Single-family homes often cannot produce enough rental income to justify the price an investor has to pay to own them. And the occupancy is binary. A single-family residential property is either 100 percent occupied or 100 percent vacant.
Hypothetical. An investor buys a house that rents for 2,400 dollars a month, which is 28,800 dollars a year if the tenant never leaves. The tenant gives notice in March and the house sits empty through April and May while it is painted and re-listed. Two months at 2,400 dollars is 4,800 dollars gone, and the year's rent is 24,000 dollars rather than 28,800. The mortgage did not pause for those two months. That is what all-or-nothing occupancy means in a checkbook.
Small apartment buildings, meaning two to four units, are still relatively affordable and attractive in the marketplace. The advantage over a single-family house is that the risk of a full vacancy is somewhat diminished. In a building with two units, if one tenant moves out it is still 50 percent occupied and still bringing in some income. Run the same March vacancy through a two-family and the owner loses half the rent for two months instead of all of it.
Small multi-family brings considerations a single-family house does not have. Utility metering, and whether each unit is separately metered or the owner is buying heat for everybody. Maintenance of common areas. Tenant privacy and compatibility, because these tenants share walls and an entry. Soundproofing between units. And accessibility issues. None of those exist when one family occupies the whole building.
As the number of units in an apartment property increases, so do the management considerations and the complexity of the investment analysis. The basic principles do not change. The number of criteria that have to be analyzed does. Typical investors in large multi-family property are larger companies that are adept at acquiring and managing them, which is a polite way of saying the analysis is a full-time job.
The list for a large multi-family runs long. Market conditions and rent levels. Overall condition of the property. Amenities and services available to tenants. Parking. Maintenance and security of common areas. Rent control laws, which in New York can decide the whole deal. Insurability. And liability issues. An investor who has analyzed seven of those and skipped the eighth has not analyzed the building.
Occupancy risk falls as unit count rises
OFFICE BUILDINGS
An office building is simply a building that contains office space. The category is wider than the word suggests. Office properties range from former single-family homes converted into commercial space, to small buildings with a few suites, to large buildings in research office parks, to skyscrapers. When an office building is called a high-rise or a skyscraper is usually a question of the specific locality, not of a fixed height.
Office property can be highly specialized, and tenants often have very specific needs for this type of space. A law firm, a medical practice, and a software company want three different buildings. That is why the factors affecting the value of an office property run to a list rather than a formula.
Location comes first here as everywhere. Then compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act. Accessibility, meaning ingress, which is the way in, and egress, which is the way out. Visibility, both of the building and of the tenant's signage. Adequacy of parking, which for office property generally runs five to six cars per 1,000 square feet of floor space. General market conditions and rent levels. Common areas and facilities.
The list continues into the things a tenant discovers after signing. Tenant profile, meaning who else is in the building. Ease of tenant improvements, usually shortened to TI, which is the work done to fit the space to the tenant. Type and adequacy of the mechanical systems. Special maintenance requirements. Security and lighting in the common areas. Staffing and management requirements. Appearance and market appeal. Ancillary services such as vending, an on-site cafeteria, or child care. And technology issues, such as cable lines, satellite, or fiber optics.
Take the parking figure seriously, because it is the one on this screen you can actually compute. Hypothetical. A tenant is looking at 12,000 square feet of office space. At five to six cars per 1,000 square feet, the building should be supplying somewhere between 60 and 72 spaces for that tenant's share of the lot. If the landlord is offering 30, the tenant's staff is parking on the street, and that is a conversation to have before the lease is signed rather than after.
THE OFFICE CLASS SYSTEM
In many markets, office buildings are rated or categorized by the building's class. The class is usually based on a combination of building characteristics: age, lease rates, architectural design, occupancy, location, tenant profiles, management, and building amenities and services. Four classes cover the market.
Class A buildings are usually the newest and most desirable buildings in a particular market, with the best design, superior construction, amenities, and features. These buildings command the highest rental rates and set the standard for the rest of the local market. When a broker in a market says what Class A rents are, everyone else prices against that number.
Class B buildings have good location, appearance, and amenities and are still desirable, but they are not quite the top of the market, primarily due to age. A Class B building is very often a former Class A building that has kept its bones and lost its newness.
Class C properties are older and still functionally viable, but not as favorably located or as well maintained. Tenants in Class C space are typically price-driven, which means the leasing conversation is about the rent number and very little else.
Class D buildings are the balance of the older, functionally obsolete buildings that need extensive renovation. These are prime candidates for rehabilitation projects or for teardown. A Class D building is usually sold on the value of the site and the shell rather than on the income it currently produces.
The classes are not a grading scale for quality alone. They describe where a building sits in its own market's hierarchy, which means the same building can move between classes over time without a brick changing. A Class A tower drops to Class B when two newer towers open down the street, and a Class C building becomes Class B after a renovation that resets its systems and its lobby. That movement is the reason rehabilitation projects exist, and it is a large part of what a commercial investor is buying when he buys an older building in a strengthening market.
Each community has its own standards for these designations, and this is the part students get wrong. Class is local. What might be a Class A building in one market might only be a Class B building in another. A twelve-story tower with a marble lobby is Class A in a small upstate city and an ordinary Class B address in Midtown Manhattan. Never quote a class across market lines.
NOTE: Two numbers from this screen turn up on exams and they are easy to swap. Office parking runs generally five to six cars per 1,000 square feet of floor space. Retail parking, which is on the next screen, runs generally three spaces per 1,000 square feet. Office is the bigger number because office workers arrive in the morning and stay.
CAUTION: Calling a building Class A because the owner calls it Class A is a misrepresentation waiting to happen. Class is a market judgment based on age, design, construction, location, amenities, and management. If you cannot name which of those characteristics put the building in the class you are quoting, do not quote the class.
Class is a local judgment, not a national grade
REMEMBER: Name the one occupancy fact that makes a single-family rental riskier than a two-family. Then name the four office classes in order and say which characteristic separates Class A from Class B.
Retail, Industrial, and Mixed-Use
Location, demographics, traffic, visibility, tenant mix, and about three parking spaces per 1,000 SF
Retail properties are diverse and unique compared with other types of real estate investment, and the range of property types available to investors is wide. In the retail market, the ability of a property to produce an acceptable income stream depends on a number of factors, and several of them exist nowhere else in real estate.
The location and the demographics of the customer base are critical. So are market appeal, access to public transportation, traffic flow, parking, visibility and signage, competition, tenant mix, and anchor tenants. Retail parking generally runs three spaces for each 1,000 square feet. A 30,000-square-foot strip center at that ratio wants about 90 spaces, and a center that cannot supply them will lose the tenants who need customers to arrive by car.
An anchor tenant is a magnet store strategically located in a shopping center to generate traffic for the smaller stores. That is the whole mechanism of a shopping center. The anchor does not merely occupy the largest space. It supplies the reason a customer drives to the property at all, and every smaller tenant is buying access to that customer when it signs its lease. Lose the anchor and the small tenants' sales fall even though nothing about their own stores changed.
Tenant mix is the companion idea. A center full of stores that all want the same customer at the same hour will underperform a center whose tenants draw at different times and for different reasons. Tenant mix and competition decide whether a retail property produces an acceptable income stream, and they are the two factors a buyer can most easily check before making an offer.
RETAIL PROPERTY BY PURPOSE AND SIZE
Retail investment property ranges from freestanding stores to enormous shopping malls. The classification below is by purpose and size, and the sizes are stated in gross leasable area. Learn the order of magnitude rather than the exact boundary. The exam asks which type is which, not whether a center is 99,000 or 101,000 square feet.
Strip center
Neighborhood center
Community center
Regional mall
Super regional or mega mall
Specialty or festival center
Power center
Outlet center
Strip centers typically contain a minimum of three stores with a total gross leasable area of up to 30,000 square feet. A wide range of tenants occupy them, providing goods such as groceries and services such as dry cleaning. This is the small commercial property most New York licensees will actually transact.
Neighborhood centers are typically built around a supermarket anchor tenant and range in size from 30,000 to more than 100,000 square feet. The supermarket is doing the work described above. Everything else in the center is renting proximity to a grocery run.
Community shopping centers have multiple anchor tenants providing a much wider range of goods and services, and range from 100,000 to 300,000 square feet. More than one anchor means more than one reason to drive there, which is why the center can support a wider tenant mix.
Regional malls provide a broad range of general merchandise, apparel, home furnishings, appliances, and electronics, as well as an array of services, restaurants, and recreational facilities. Enclosed or not, regional malls range in size from 250,000 to more than 900,000 square feet.
Super regional or mega malls are often built around three or more full-line department stores, plus many smaller stores offering nearly every good and service imaginable. They range in size from 500,000 square feet to well over 1.5 million square feet.
Specialty shopping centers are characterized by the lack of a traditional anchor tenant. Instead a group of tenants clustered together fills the role of the anchor. Festival centers are the best-known example: a mixed-use blend of specialty retail with a wide variety of restaurants and food vendors, a strong entertainment component, and sometimes hotel, convention, and meeting facilities.
Power centers take on the unique appearance of a cluster of very large big-box retailers on the same property, with few or no small stores. A power center is essentially several anchors and nothing in between, which changes the economics completely, because there are no small tenants paying for the traffic the big ones generate.
Outlet centers consist of several smaller stores that are attached, detached, or a combination of both. The stores are usually restricted to major name retailers and manufacturers selling merchandise considered seconds, irregulars, or discontinued lines at a discount.
INDUSTRIAL AND MANUFACTURING PROPERTY
Industrial real estate is a very broad category. It includes properties considered distribution, manufacturing, and research facilities. Unlike office space, this type of property is often purchased by an investor who will also use the property, because it often has highly specialized features. Industrial properties therefore must be assessed individually based on the intended use and on the property's overall adaptability.
Industrial property is typically handled by an industrial specialist or industrial broker who works exclusively in industrial properties. Institutional investors buy here too, including pension funds, life insurance companies, and real estate investment trusts. The property can be categorized by use or type: warehouse, service center, wholesale trade, distribution or transit warehouse, research and development center, and factory, whether light assembly, heavy assembly, or high tech.
Floor load capacity
Ceiling height
Clear span
Loading docks
Transportation access
Mechanical systems
Environmental concerns
Floor load capacity is how many pounds per square foot the floor can support. A tenant installing presses or racking needs that number before it needs the rent number. Ceiling height determines what processes or equipment can be used in the space, and a warehouse whose ceilings are two feet too low cannot rack to the height its operation was designed around.
Clear span is the open distance between inside faces of support members. It matters most for distribution warehouses and for manufacturing processes that need wide open space for large machinery, assembly lines, or conveyor belt systems. A column in the middle of a floor can make a building useless to a tenant who needs an uninterrupted run, and that is why clear span is quoted as a specification rather than described in words.
Loading docks, shipping, and receiving areas come next, along with accessibility and proximity to transportation: highways, railroads, airports, and shipping. Then the type and adequacy of the mechanical systems. Then environmental concerns, which for industrial property almost always require an environmental impact statement, usually shortened to EIS.
One more consideration belongs to industrial property and to almost nothing else. Community opposition. There may be resistance to certain types of industrial business that fall into the NIMBY category, which stands for Not in my back yard. A project can be physically possible, financially feasible, and legally permissible and still die at a public hearing.
Clear span is measured between the supports
MIXED-USE BUILDINGS AND LOFTS
Mixed-use buildings are those that do not fall into a single-use category. A mixed-use building might combine retail and office space on the first floor with residential on the floors above, or combine industrial, office, and retail. The possibilities and combinations are numerous and depend largely on local zoning laws and ordinances. In New York City in particular, mixed-use is the ordinary condition of a commercial street rather than an exception.
A common example of a mixed-use building is a loft. Loft buildings are characterized by the fact that most of the building's interior is left unfinished, or minimally finished. A loft building or loft space can also refer to an open space design of the tenant's usable area. Traditionally loft space was used for lower-cost or budget manufacturing and distribution operations.
Today lofts are often seen in older multi-story buildings that have been converted into multiple creative use designs for retail, restaurant, office, and residential areas. Because the space is unfinished, the rent rate for a loft lease is often lower than the rate for finished space. That is the trade the loft tenant makes. Lower rent per square foot, and the cost and the work of finishing the space falls on the tenant.
Mixed-use brings one practical complication every licensee meets sooner or later. One building, several uses, and the rules for each use are different. The retail space on the ground floor sits under commercial lease practice. The apartments above it sit under residential landlord and tenant law, and in New York City they may sit under rent regulation as well. A single owner is running two different legal regimes inside one set of walls, and an agent who treats the whole building as commercial will give that owner wrong advice about the upper floors.
That is also why local zoning decides so much here. The possibilities and combinations are numerous and depend largely on local zoning laws and ordinances, which means the question of what may go in each part of a mixed-use building is answered by the municipality rather than by the owner's plans. Before a client buys a mixed-use building to change what is in it, the zoning has to say yes.
NOTE: Three vocabulary items from this screen show up on the exam as answer choices for each other. The anchor tenant is the magnet store that generates traffic. Clear span is the open distance between the inside faces of supports. Floor load is pounds per square foot. A question describing an open distance is asking about clear span, not about setbacks or curb cuts, which belong to land.
CAUTION: Industrial and retail are both specialist fields, and a licensee who takes an industrial listing without knowing what floor load, clear span, and EIS mean will misdescribe the property in the listing. Misdescribing a property is not a marketing problem. It is a misrepresentation, and the buyer who relies on it has a claim.
REMEMBER: Which retail type has no traditional anchor, and which one is nothing but anchors? Then say what clear span measures, and why a distribution tenant asks about it first.
Lesson 3
Owning, Leasing & the Commercial Lease
From full-service gross to absolute triple net
Buying Versus Leasing
Fee simple ownership or a leasehold interest, help the client weigh both
When business owners are deciding whether to buy or to rent commercial property, they must evaluate the relative merits of owning versus leasing. This is the first real question a commercial client brings you, and it usually arrives disguised as something else. I need about four thousand square feet near the Thruway. Whether the client should own those four thousand square feet or rent them is a separate question, and it is the one that decides the size of the deal.
OWNING: THE FEE SIMPLE ROUTE
Fee simple ownership is the fullest freehold interest in property. It includes all of the bundle of rights: possession, quiet enjoyment, disposition, exclusion, and control. A fee simple estate is inheritable and transferable, which means the owner can leave it to his children and can sell it to a stranger, and nobody's permission is required for either.
The advantages of owning are four. Tax savings. Income. Appreciation. Control of the property. Control is the one business owners describe in their own words rather than in those words. They mean nobody can raise their rent, nobody can refuse to renew, and nobody has to approve the loading dock they want to cut into the side of the building.
The disadvantages are six and they are all cash or time. Initial capital outlay, which is the down payment the business is no longer using for inventory or payroll. Financing, with everything a commercial loan asks of a small business. Liability. Management requirements. Legal compliance. And inflexibility, which is the mirror image of control. An owner who outgrows the building or wants to leave the market has to sell a building before he can move.
Owning: control, and the cost of control
LEASING: THE LEASEHOLD ROUTE
The alternative to acquiring fee simple ownership is obtaining a leasehold interest in the property. Leasing is the means of acquiring occupancy rights, and physical and partial economic use of property, for a specific period. The tenant does not own the real estate. The tenant owns a right to occupy and use it, for a term, on terms.
The advantages of leasing run to eight. Flexibility. Lower up-front cash requirement. Some tax relief, since property taxes, rent, and other expenses are deductible. Lower risk of obsolescence, because the tenant is not the one holding a building the market has moved past. Stability of costs. Mobility. Fewer management distractions. And a better return on inventory turnover, as opposed to tying up capital in ownership.
The last one is the argument a business owner usually finds decisive once someone puts it in front of him. Capital spent on a building is capital not working in the business. A retailer whose inventory turns four times a year is earning a margin on that money four times a year. The same money sitting in a down payment earns whatever the building appreciates, and it earns it once, at sale.
The disadvantages of leasing are six. Inability to take advantage of appreciation. Lack of control over the property. Lack of operational control and of the ability to make changes. Limited tax relief. Contractual penalties. And the plain fact that the actual total cost of leasing is often more expensive per square foot than ownership.
Read the last line of that list against the second advantage of leasing and the honest summary comes out. Leasing usually costs more per square foot over the long run and asks for much less money up front. Owning usually costs less per square foot over the long run and asks for a great deal of money up front. Which one is right depends entirely on what else the business needs that money to do.
TWO KINDS OF COMMERCIAL BUYER
When you work with commercial buyers you will hear the term amenity purchaser, and it is worth knowing how that differs from an investor. There is some overlap between the two. There is also a difference that decides what you show them, because an investor and an amenity purchaser will not find the same value in the same property.
The amenity purchaser is most likely an owner or user who is motivated to find a location from which to house and operate a business. This buyer values a property based on its ability to fulfill his specific business needs, and may be more concerned about factors such as space, location, and the potential for expansion. Ask an amenity purchaser about the cap rate and you will get a blank look. Ask him whether the ceiling is high enough for the equipment and you have his whole attention.
The investor desires to place money where it will earn more money. Investors value a property based primarily on its investment return, and are more concerned with vacancy rates and the income stream. An investor will buy a building he never intends to set foot in, in a city he has never visited, if the numbers work. The building is a vehicle for the return.
The same listing can be attractive to one and worthless to the other. A single-tenant building with a long lease to a strong tenant is an investor's property and is useless to an amenity purchaser who needs to occupy it next spring. A quirky building that fits one business perfectly is an amenity purchaser's property and a hard sell to an investor who has to imagine re-letting it.
Amenity purchaser occupies; investor collects
SALE-AND-LEASEBACK
Practically every aspect of a business operation can affect the own-versus-lease decision, and an agent should not narrow the possible solutions to a straight purchase or a straight lease. The ultimate goal is to make the client comfortable with the alternatives that best satisfy the requirements of his business, and there are arrangements that sit between the two.
A sale-and-leaseback is the best known of them. A company constructs a building that suits its needs, then sells the building to an investor, who becomes the landlord, and leases it back. The company keeps occupying the building it designed, and the capital that was locked in the real estate comes back onto its balance sheet as liquid assets it can invest in product or other resources rather than in bricks. There are tax advantages for both the company as lessee and the investor as lessor.
Notice what a sale-and-leaseback does to the two buyer types on this screen. It turns one property into an amenity for the occupant and an investment for the buyer at the same time. That is the kind of structure commercial practice rewards, and it is why this field asks for creativity rather than forms.
NOTE: The exam pairs amenity purchaser and investor in the same question almost every time. The amenity purchaser buys a home for the business and values space, location, and room to expand. The investor buys a return and values vacancy rates and the income stream. If the fact pattern tells you the buyer intends to operate out of the building, you are looking at an amenity purchaser.
CAUTION: An agent who presents only the two obvious choices has not done the analysis. The client asked for a place to run a business, not for a purchase or a lease. Sale-and-leaseback, a lease with a purchase option, and a ground lease are all answers to the same question, and one of them may be the answer that fits.
REMEMBER: Name two advantages of owning and two advantages of leasing without looking. Then say which of the two buyers on this screen would pay more for a building that fits one business perfectly and no other.
The Commercial Lease Spectrum
Gross at one extreme, triple net at the other, most deals land in between
Leases are binding contracts that set out the terms and conditions under which a space can be occupied by a tenant. Common lease terms include the rental payment, the permitted uses of the space by the tenant, who is responsible for maintenance and utilities, and how much, if any, the rent will increase over the term. Those four items are where almost all commercial lease negotiation happens.
The commercial lease spectrum is simply the wide range of possibilities that exist for constructing rental payment arrangements and cost recovery in different types of income property. A triple net lease is at one extreme of the spectrum. A gross lease, also called a full service lease, is at the other end. In between the two extremes is where most rental negotiations take place.
The spectrum is really a single question asked once: who pays the costs of owning this building. At one end, the landlord pays everything and charges a higher rent to cover it. At the other end, the tenant pays everything and the rent drops accordingly. Every lease you will ever read is somewhere on that line, and the rent number alone never tells you where.
Base rent is paid in every one of them
GROSS LEASES AND FULL SERVICE
A gross lease is a straightforward exchange of rent for occupancy. With a gross lease, also called a full service lease, the tenant pays a fixed rent while the owner or landlord pays all ownership expenses: property taxes, repairs, janitorial services, insurance, and sometimes utilities. The tenant writes one check and stops thinking about the building.
In a modified gross lease, tenants may be responsible for utilities, trash removal, and cleaning. The landlord pays the taxes, obtains damage and liability insurance, maintains the heating, ventilation, and air conditioning systems, usually shortened to HVAC, and provides security for the building. Modified gross is the most common arrangement in a great many office markets, and no two modified gross leases split the costs the same way.
A full service lease for an office building means the tenant's rent includes his pro-rata, or proportional, share of operating costs. That share is based on the percentage of the entire building's square feet the tenant occupies. A typical lease states an estimate for annual operating costs, and the rental payment is a monthly proration of that figure.
Then the year ends and the estimate is trued up against reality. The landlord totals the actual costs. If the actual costs are less than what the tenant paid, the tenant receives a credit throughout the coming year. If the actual annual costs are more than the estimate, the tenant will most likely receive a bill from the landlord for the unpaid excess. Hypothetical. A tenant's estimated share of operating costs for the year is 14,400 dollars, collected at 1,200 dollars a month inside the rent. The landlord's actual costs come to 15,600 dollars for that tenant's share. The tenant owes 1,200 dollars more, and it arrives as one bill in the first quarter of the following year.
Lease terms for office buildings are typically from one to ten years, but for a major tenant in some markets they can run as long as 40 years, with options to extend the term further. Besides options to extend, tenants occasionally negotiate provisions called accordion clauses, which give the tenant flexibility to expand and contract the amount of space occupied. An accordion clause is how a growing business signs a ten-year lease without betting the company on a headcount forecast.
NET LEASES AND THE THREE EXPENSES
A net lease is a lease for which the tenant pays some or all of the costs of ownership, except mortgage interest and principal, in addition to the agreed-upon rent. With net leases the property owner has shifted much of the risk of increased property costs onto the tenants, who get the additional tax benefit of the business expense. A net lease means lower rent for the tenant, and higher costs.
Net leases are categorized by the extent of the tenant's responsibility for three ownership costs, and only three. Taxes. Insurance. Common area maintenance, usually shortened to CAM. Common area maintenance is the cost incurred to provide for the shared areas of a commercial property, such as common utilities, cleaning, snow removal, and landscaping, and it is usually shared by all tenants on a pro-rata basis.
Count the three and the names fall out. If the lease requires the tenant to pay one of these expenses, it is a single net lease, written N. If the tenant is required to pay any two of them, it is a net-net lease, also called a double net lease, written NN. If the tenant pays all three, it is a triple net lease, also called a net-net-net lease, written NNN, and sometimes referred to as an absolute net lease.
Mortgage interest and principal are the exception in every one of them. The tenant never pays the landlord's debt service. A net lease shifts the operating costs of ownership, not the financing of it.
Count the N's: one, two, or all three
Triple net leases are common for industrial commercial space where single tenants lease entire warehouses. The tenant takes responsibility for all expenses related to maintenance, repair, utilities, and taxes, and sometimes even the roof and the structure of the building, as well as the parking lots and the grounds upkeep. The rental payment to the landlord is much smaller on a per-square-foot basis, but the income to the landlord is usually dependable, without the vagaries of bills and unexpected costs.
Lease terms for warehouses and other general-purpose industrial properties can be as short as a few months for multi-tenant buildings, or as long as several decades for single-tenant facilities. A twenty-year absolute net lease to a creditworthy tenant is close to a bond with a building attached, and that is exactly how institutional investors price it.
Of course the terms of a lease are negotiable, so there is a myriad of commercial lease arrangements to suit individual circumstances. A modified net lease might make the landlord responsible for some property expenses, such as maintaining the building's exterior walls and foundation and any common areas like parking lots and main signage, while the tenant handles other expenses such as utility payments and trash removal, plus a pro-rata share of the property taxes and the CAM charges.
Because every element of a lease is negotiable, you should always read the entire lease carefully to examine its specific terms. That sentence sounds like boilerplate. It is the single most practical instruction in this chapter. The label on the front page of a commercial lease tells you roughly where on the spectrum the deal sits. The clauses inside tell you what your client is actually agreeing to pay.
NOTE: The exam reverses this one constantly. Under a triple net lease the tenant pays base rent plus taxes, insurance, and common area maintenance. The landlord does not pick those up. An answer choice that says the landlord carries the three expenses under a net-net-net lease has described a gross lease and put the wrong name on it.
CAUTION: A lower per-square-foot rent on a net lease is not a better deal by itself, and a client who compares two quotes on the rent number alone is comparing nothing. Add the taxes, the insurance, and the CAM to the net quote before you set it next to a full service number. Sometimes the net deal still wins. Sometimes it does not.
REMEMBER: Say what the tenant pays under each of the four lease types on this screen. Then name the one ownership cost a net lease never shifts to the tenant.
Percentage Leases and Ground Leases
Sharing the retail upside, and renting the dirt alone
Two lease structures sit outside the gross-to-net spectrum because they are built on a different idea. A percentage lease ties the landlord's rent to the tenant's sales. A ground lease separates the ownership of the land from the ownership of everything built on it. Both are common in commercial practice, and both produce exam questions that turn on a single sentence.
PERCENTAGE LEASES
A percentage lease is a gross or net lease in which the tenant pays a fixed monthly base rent as well as a percentage of gross sales achieved by the tenant over and above a predetermined level of sales known as the breakpoint. This type of lease is most commonly used for retail tenants. It allows the landlord to share in the tenant's success, and it may include a clause that allows the owner to reclaim the premises if gross sales fall below a specified point.
Notice what a percentage lease does to the relationship. In an ordinary lease the landlord wants rent paid and does not much care how the store performs. In a percentage lease the landlord has a direct financial interest in the tenant's sales, which is why a mall landlord cares about the tenant mix, the hours the store keeps, and the marketing the center does. The landlord is a partner in the upside and has written himself an exit if the downside arrives.
Base rent for retail is usually figured on an annual basis, paid on a monthly basis, and quoted on a per-square-foot basis. Keep those three straight when you quote a number. A retail tenant hearing thirty dollars a foot is hearing an annual figure, and what leaves his account each month is one twelfth of it.
THE BREAKPOINT
The breakpoint is the sales volume above which the tenant begins paying percentage rent. It is determined by dividing the annual base rent by the agreed-upon overage percentage. Divide. That one word is the whole arithmetic of this screen, and it is the most commonly missed calculation in commercial real estate.
Work the standard example. A jewelry store owner agrees to a base rent of 80,000 dollars per year, payable monthly, plus extras such as common area maintenance charges, security, and marketing. The owner also agrees to pay 8 percent overage. The breakpoint is the annual base rent divided by the overage rate: 80,000 dollars divided by .08 equals 1,000,000 dollars.
Now test that number, because testing it is what tells you the division was right. At exactly 1,000,000 dollars in sales, 8 percent of sales is 80,000 dollars, which is precisely the base rent. That is why this figure is called the natural breakpoint. It is the sales level at which the percentage rent the landlord would charge on total sales exactly equals the base rent the tenant is already paying. Below it the landlord keeps the base rent. Above it the landlord starts sharing.
If the jewelry store's annual sales exceed 1,000,000 dollars, each dollar of sales over the breakpoint costs the tenant another 8 percent in overage rent. Say the store has annual gross sales of 1.1 million dollars. Overage rent is payable on the 100,000 dollars above the breakpoint. Multiply: 100,000 dollars times .08 equals 8,000 dollars. The tenant's total rent that year is the 80,000 dollars of base rent plus 8,000 dollars of overage rent, which is 88,000 dollars.
Breakpoint = base rent divided by the rate
Now see what happens if you multiply instead of divide. Eighty thousand dollars times .08 is 6,400 dollars, and a licensee who hands the tenant that figure has just told a jewelry store that it owes percentage rent on everything it sells past 6,400 dollars. A jewelry store passes 6,400 dollars in sales in its first week. The overage would swallow the store. If a breakpoint you have calculated is smaller than the base rent, the arithmetic went the wrong way, and the sanity check takes two seconds.
Most retail tenants with percentage rent arrangements calculate the amount of pro-rata percentage rent due and pay it on a monthly basis, adjusting for any discrepancies at year end, when audited records are available. That is why a percentage lease always contains a records clause. The landlord's rent depends on the tenant's sales figures, so the landlord bargains for the right to see them.
Run one more to fix the method. A restaurant agrees to base rent of 150,000 dollars a year with a 5 percent overage. Divide: 150,000 divided by .05 equals 3,000,000 dollars, which is the breakpoint. Check it backwards: 5 percent of 3,000,000 dollars is 150,000 dollars, the base rent exactly. Now suppose the restaurant does 3.4 million dollars. The overage is 400,000 dollars above the breakpoint times .05, which is 20,000 dollars, and the total rent for the year is 170,000 dollars. Same two steps every time. Divide to find the line, multiply to find what is owed past it.
One more thing about the reclaim clause, because it is the part of a percentage lease a tenant reads last. The lease may allow the owner to reclaim the premises if gross sales fall below a specified point. A landlord in a shopping center is not only collecting rent. He is protecting the traffic that every other tenant in the center is paying for, and a store that stops drawing customers stops doing the job its space was leased to do.
GROUND LEASES
Ground leases, also referred to as land leases, enable tenants to lease only the land, often an unimproved parcel, and not any structures or improvements on the land. This type of lease is structured to separate the ownership of the land from the ownership of the buildings and improvements on the land. Rent therefore reflects only a base rental amount for the land alone.
A good long-term ground lease enables the tenant to have physical control over the parcel and then to finance improvements over the term of the ground lease, including the ability to amortize or depreciate those improvements. That is the point of the structure. A business that cannot afford to buy a corner can afford to lease the corner and build on it, and the landowner keeps an asset he never has to manage.
Most land leases are on an absolute net basis and require the tenant to pay all of the expenses normally associated with ownership of the land, such as property taxes, maintenance, and insurance. A ground lease tenant is, for practical purposes, an owner who pays rent. Everything an owner would carry, he carries.
Often the lease term for a ground lease takes the form of an initial term with several options to renew. An initial lease term could be ten years with four five-year options. Ten plus twenty is thirty, so that structure enables the tenant to control the property for at least 30 years. The length is not decoration. A lender will not finance a building on leased land unless the lease outlasts the loan, and the tenant cannot amortize or depreciate improvements over a term shorter than their useful life.
REVERSION AT EXPIRATION
Here is the sentence the whole ground lease turns on. Upon expiration of the ground lease, the land, and the building erected upon it, reverts to the landowner, not to the lessee. The tenant financed the building. The tenant built the building. The tenant depreciated the building. And at the end of the term the tenant walks away from the building, because the improvements go with the land.
That is not a trap hidden in the fine print. It is the deal, and it is why ground lease terms are long enough to let the tenant recover the cost of what he built before he loses it. A tenant on a ten-year ground lease who is told to build out lavishly because the building will be his to keep has been given advice that is the opposite of the law and the opposite of the lease.
Land and building both revert to the owner
NOTE: Two calculations from this screen appear on exams as each other's wrong answers. The breakpoint is base rent divided by the overage rate. The overage rent is the sales above the breakpoint multiplied by the overage rate. Divide to find the threshold. Multiply to find the money owed past it.
CAUTION: The ground lease reversion is the fact a licensee is most likely to get wrong in front of a client, because it feels unfair and because every instinct says a building belongs to whoever paid for it. Read the expiration clause with the client and say the sentence out loud. At the end of this term, the building goes with the land.
REMEMBER: A tenant pays 60,000 dollars base rent with a 6 percent overage. What is the breakpoint, and what is owed on 1.2 million dollars of sales? Then say who owns the building the day after a ground lease expires.
Lease Clauses, and Four Ways Out
Each and every clause is a negotiating point between landlord and tenant
Each and every clause of a lease is a negotiating point between a landlord and a tenant. That sentence is the frame for this entire screen. A commercial lease is not a form somebody fills out. It is a set of separately bargained provisions, and the ones below are the provisions that come up most often. They are not all-inclusive. They are the ones you will meet in your first year.
THE USE CLAUSE
The use clause specifically defines what type of business or use can be conducted by the tenant on the premises. A commercial lease for space in an office building might state that the leased premises will be used only for general business office purposes, and for no other use or purpose, or words of similar import or intent. The clause is common in leases for retail or commercial space, and mall leases may even state what type of products may or may not be sold by the tenant in that space.
The two sides want opposite things from it. Tenants usually want use clauses to be as flexible as possible so they can add other goods and services as the business changes. Landlords want to ensure that tenants do not compete with each other, so they want use clauses to be specific. A landlord who has promised the anchor grocery that nobody else in the center will sell prepared food has to write that promise into every other tenant's use clause.
And if the lease does not have a use clause, or does not state a specified purpose, the tenant may use the space for any lawful use. Silence favors the tenant here. That is worth knowing in both directions, because a landlord client who assumes a restrictive use is implied has assumed something the lease does not say.
ATTORNMENT
An attornment clause establishes tenancy with a new owner and defends current tenants against claims for rent from the former property owner. The clause provides that in the event of foreclosure or termination, the lease shall continue in force as if the new owner or mortgagee were the landlord, for a term equal to the unexpired term of the lease and upon the same terms and provisions.
Two protections sit in that one clause. The tenancy survives the change of ownership, so the tenant is not turned out because the landlord lost the building. And the tenant who has been paying rent to the new owner is protected against the old owner turning up to demand the same rent a second time.
ESTOPPEL
An estoppel certificate is a legal instrument that prevents a person from taking a position, denying a fact, or asserting a fact inconsistent with previous conduct or statements. In a lease context it is a signed statement of what the lease actually says and what the tenant actually owes. Most standard commercial leases contain a clause whereby all tenants agree to comply with a request to complete an estoppel document upon the landlord's request.
The reason is the sale of the building. An investor who purchases rental property may have the current tenants sign an estoppel certificate acknowledging their obligation to pay the agreed-upon rent and confirming the terms of their existing leases. The buyer is buying an income stream. The estoppel certificates are the tenants confirming, in writing, that the income stream is what the seller says it is. A lender making a loan against the building asks for the same thing for the same reason.
SUBORDINATION AND NONDISTURBANCE
When someone is purchasing commercial property, the lender may not be willing to accept the property as security for the loan if it is burdened by an existing leasehold interest with a higher claim against the real estate. A subordination agreement makes the existing lease junior to the new mortgage on the leased property. When a subordination clause is in the lease, the tenant grants a waiver of his priority in favor of the new lender in the event of foreclosure of the landlord's loan.
Understand what the tenant has just given up. Those rights of recovery and protection in the leasehold become subordinate to the rights of the lender, which means the lender could cancel the lease when taking over the building. A tenant who signed a ten-year lease, spent two hundred thousand dollars fitting out the space, and then subordinated without protection can be put on the street by a foreclosure that had nothing to do with him.
The tenant's protection against a subordination request is a nondisturbance agreement from the landlord's lender. This clause requires the lender to sign a document agreeing to honor and not terminate the tenancies of lessees who are current with their rent and who are complying with all provisions and obligations of their leases. Subordination is what the lender asks for. Nondisturbance is what the tenant asks for in return, and the two are almost always negotiated as one instrument.
Subordination goes down; nondisturbance protects
RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL
If a tenant thinks she may wish to buy the building or the property in the future, she may negotiate to have a right of first refusal clause placed in the lease. The clause is also called a right of preemption, and it does two things and only two.
It gives the tenant the right to have the first opportunity to buy or lease the property if the owner decides to put it up for sale or lease. And it cannot be exercised until the owner gets a bona fide offer from a third party. Once that offer exists, the owner must make the property available to the person holding the right at the same terms as the bona fide offer.
That second half is the one licensees get wrong. A right of first refusal is not an option to buy. The holder cannot walk up to the owner and demand to purchase the building today at a price of the holder's choosing. The right sleeps until a real third-party offer arrives, and then it wakes up and lets the holder match that offer. A tenant urged to exercise the right before the owner has even listed the property is being told to exercise something that does not yet exist.
Note two more things about it. A right of first refusal is an inheritable interest, so it does not die with the holder. And it creates a cloud on the title, so it should be recorded in the public record. Recording is what makes it bind a later buyer, and the cloud is what makes a seller's attorney ask about it early.
UTILITY CLAUSES
Utility expenses are often addressed by specific lease clauses. How they are handled depends in part on whether the lease is a full service lease or a triple net lease, though even in a full service lease utilities may be treated as a separate category. The monitoring of utility usage is generally done one of three ways.
Direct metering by the utility company, where each tenant is separately metered and pays the utility company itself. Sub-metering by the landlord, who pays the utility bill, monitors individual private meters, and bills the tenants. Or pro-rata, based on the percentage of space occupied. Direct metering gives the tenant the most control and the most exposure. Pro-rata gives the tenant the least of both, and it means a careful tenant subsidizes a wasteful neighbor.
THE GOOD-GUY CLAUSE
Leases often contain a rider known as a good-guy clause, which limits the liability of the personal guarantor for a tenant when a lease is terminated early. If the tenant defaults on the lease but is current on rent payments and surrenders the property in good condition, the landlord will not seek payment from the guarantor. A good-guy clause can be a single paragraph or a multi-page addendum.
Understand who this clause is really for. A small business tenant usually has to guarantee the lease personally, which puts the owner's own house behind the company's rent. A good-guy clause tells that owner that if the business fails and he behaves properly on the way out, pays what is owed through the surrender, hands back the keys, leaves the space in good condition, his personal liability ends there. It is one of the most heavily negotiated riders in New York City commercial leasing.
DISPOSING OF LEASED SPACE
The commercial leasing market is influenced by economic cycles, and the effect is most noticeable when the economy turns down. Tenants feel those shifts in their own businesses, and their space needs change accordingly. A tenant who has to downsize or close a local office needs to dispose of the leased space, and depending on the terms of the lease there are four options.
Close down. The tenant closes the operation but continues to pay the obligated rent until the end of the current term, and does not exercise the renewal option. Doing that eliminates the additional operating expenses of running the space. This option is viable only if a nominal amount of time is left on the term. If the lease still has several years to run, the tenant should explore another option.
Buyout. The tenant approaches the landlord with a buyout proposal, in the form of a lump sum paid to terminate the existing lease early. Consider a tenant at the end of the second year of a five-year lease who wants to close his business. The lease obligates him to pay 50,000 dollars per year, which is 4,167 dollars per month. Three years remain, so his remaining obligation is 150,000 dollars. He may offer the landlord a lump sum of one year's rent, 50,000 dollars, in exchange for being released from the remaining three years. Whether the landlord takes it depends on how quickly the landlord thinks the space can be re-let.
Sublease. The tenant subleases the space to another tenant, if the lease permits it. A sublease exists when a tenant leases his leasehold interest, in whole or in part, to another party. And here is the sentence that matters more than any other on this screen. The original tenant remains liable and is entirely responsible for lease payments and all other obligations. A sublease does not take the original tenant's name off the lease. It adds a name underneath it.
Assignment. The tenant assigns the lease when he no longer wishes to occupy the property. Assigning transfers the leasehold interest, rights, and obligations to another party, and a tenant holding a leasehold interest can sell that interest or give it away freely, provided the original lease provisions allow assignment. Upon transferring the leasehold interest the original tenant no longer makes lease payments, but may still be liable for rent and other obligations in the event the assignee defaults.
Sublease keeps you liable; assignment can too
NOTE: Sublease and assignment are the pair the exam loves, and the difference is not about who moves in. Under a sublease the original tenant stays fully and directly liable and keeps making the payments. Under an assignment the payments stop, but liability can come back if the assignee defaults. Neither one is a clean exit, and telling a client otherwise is a misrepresentation.
CAUTION: Four clauses on this screen can cost a tenant the space he paid to build out: the use clause that turns out to be narrower than his business, the subordination clause signed without nondisturbance, the assignment clause that forbids assignment, and the personal guaranty with no good-guy rider. Read all four before your client signs, and send him to his attorney with the specific paragraph numbers.
REMEMBER: A tenant asks you to get her out of three remaining years. Name the four options in order of cost to her, and say which two leave her still liable if the replacement tenant stops paying.
Lesson 4
Space, Rent & Escalations
Measure the space, do the math, protect the return
Usable vs. Rentable: Reading a Floor Plate
The tenant occupies usable space, but pays for rentable
Everything about commercial rent depends on how space is measured, and there are two measurements. A tenant occupies one number of square feet and pays rent on a different, larger number. Understanding space measurement is exceptionally important in commercial real estate, and a licensee who cannot explain the difference between the two numbers will eventually quote a client a rent that is wrong by tens of thousands of dollars a year.
PICTURE THE FLOOR
Stand in the elevator lobby of a typical office floor and look at what is there. Four tenant suites, one in each quarter of the floor. A core in the middle holding the elevators, the stairs, and the restrooms. A corridor running from the elevator lobby past every suite door. The lobby itself. That is the whole floor plate, and it divides into exactly two kinds of space.
Inside the suite doors is usable space. Outside them, in the core and the corridor and the lobby, is common space, used by two or more tenants and controlled by none of them. Add both together and you have the rentable area of the floor. The tenant's furniture goes in the first kind. The tenant's rent is calculated on a share of both.
RENTABLE, OR GROSS, SQUARE FOOTAGE
Rentable square footage is generally considered to be the total floor area of a building. This measurement, also called gross square footage, takes into account all tenant space as well as common areas and service areas: the lobby, corridors, elevators, restrooms, and stairwells, which are used by two or more tenants or by third parties and are not under the control of any one tenant.
Rentable square footage is the calculation used to determine the lease payment for many types of commercial property, including office and warehouse space. The tenant pays for a specific space and for a prorated share of the identified common areas. The landlord cannot rent the lobby to anyone, and the landlord still has to heat it, light it, clean it, and pay taxes on it. The cost of that space is recovered through everybody's rent.
An easy way to remember that rent payments are based on the gross, or rentable, square footage is to picture the word gross spelled with dollar signs where the letter S belongs. Money is paid for gross square footage. It is a silly mnemonic and it survives exam pressure, which is the only test a mnemonic has to pass.
USABLE, OR NET, SQUARE FOOTAGE
The usable square footage, also referred to as net square footage or carpetable square footage, is the amount of actual space within the perimeter of the tenant's premises. It is the floor area where the tenant can actually lay carpet and place furniture. This figure is critical, because it is the number that tells the tenant whether the space will meet her specific needs for furniture, equipment, and personnel.
Two clients ask two different questions about the same suite, and both are right to ask. The tenant's office manager asks how many desks fit, and the answer comes from usable square footage. The tenant's bookkeeper asks what the rent is, and the answer comes from rentable square footage. Give either of them the other one's number and you have created a problem that surfaces at the lease signing.
Usable holds furniture; rentable sets the rent
THE LOSS FACTOR, ALSO CALLED THE LOAD
To adequately cover a property owner's loss of rent on common areas that are not part of any tenant's usable square footage, lobbies, elevator shafts, stairwells, common restrooms, it is necessary to calculate the loss factor, sometimes called the load. The loss factor is a ratio of rentable space to usable space, and it has one formula.
Rentable square feet minus usable square feet, divided by rentable square feet, equals the loss factor. Take a building with 10,000 square feet of which 8,000 square feet are usable. Subtract: 10,000 minus 8,000 is 2,000. Divide: 2,000 divided by 10,000 is .20. The loss factor is 20 percent.
When a tenant's rent is calculated, that loss factor is added on to the usable space to account for the tenant's share of the common areas. The load is not a penalty and it is not a fee. It is the mechanism by which the cost of the corridor everybody walks down is divided among the people who walk down it.
BUILDING EFFICIENCY
The flip side of the loss factor is building efficiency, which is the ratio of usable square footage to rentable square footage. Usable square feet divided by rentable square feet equals building efficiency. Take the same building: 8,000 divided by 10,000 is .80, so the building is 80 percent efficient.
The two numbers always add to 100 percent, because they are describing the same floor from opposite ends. A 20 percent loss factor is an 80 percent efficient building. A 35 percent loss factor is a 65 percent efficient building. If a landlord quotes you efficiency and a competing landlord quotes you loss factor, subtract from 100 and you are comparing the same thing.
Efficiency and loss factor add to 100 percent
WHY YOU CONFIRM BEFORE YOU QUOTE
Be aware that there are a number of methods for calculating rentable and usable square footage, and they do not all produce the same answer. Some property owners or markets count the common areas used by tenants, such as the lobby and the restrooms, as part of rentable square footage, but do not count space taken up by critical structural elements such as fire stairs and elevators. Another property owner may treat the entire gross square footage of the building as rentable for the purpose of rent calculations.
The same question arises on the usable side. Is the space measured to the middle of an interior wall, or just to the wall surface? On a small suite that difference is trivial. On a full floor it is real money. Make sure you understand the elements of the calculation for each specific property before you put a number in front of a client.
That is the working habit this screen is really teaching. Before you quote rent on a commercial space, ask the landlord or the managing agent three questions. What is the usable area. What is the rentable area. And how was the rentable area measured. If the answer to the third question is vague, the first two numbers are not yet numbers you can repeat.
NOTE: The formula direction is the trap. Loss factor divides by rentable. Building efficiency divides by rentable as well, but the numerator changes: loss factor uses the difference between the two areas, efficiency uses the usable area alone. Dividing by usable produces a number that is not either one of them, and it is always one of the wrong answers.
CAUTION: Telling a tenant she pays rent only on her carpetable space is false and it is the single most damaging thing a new commercial agent says. Rent is paid on rentable square footage. If you quote a rent on the usable number, the actual lease will be higher than what you promised, and your client will have signed a lease based on your mistake.
REMEMBER: A suite has 9,000 rentable and 7,200 usable square feet. What is the loss factor, and what is the building efficiency? Say both numbers before you move on.
Doing the Rent Math
Every number a commercial client will ask you to defend
This screen is four calculations. Each one takes ten seconds with a calculator and each one is a number a commercial client will ask you to defend on the spot. Work them until you can do them out loud in a car, because that is where they usually get asked.
QUOTING RENT: ANNUAL, THEN MONTHLY
In most markets, annual base rent is typically calculated per square foot. If the rent is quoted as 8 dollars per square foot and the space contains 6,000 square feet, multiply to get the annual rent: 8 dollars times 6,000 square feet equals 48,000 dollars per year. Then divide by twelve to get the monthly payment: 48,000 dollars divided by 12 equals 4,000 dollars per month.
Two habits protect you here. The quoted figure is annual unless somebody says otherwise, and the square footage in that multiplication is rentable, not usable. Multiply the rate by the wrong area and the answer is off by the whole load. Read an annual quote as a monthly one and the answer is off by a factor of twelve, which is not the kind of error a client forgets.
THE LOSS FACTOR
A building contains 10,000 rentable square feet, of which 8,000 square feet are usable. The difference, 2,000 square feet, is common area. Divide the difference by the rentable area: 2,000 divided by 10,000 equals .20, a 20 percent loss factor. The flip side is building efficiency: 8,000 divided by 10,000 equals .80, an 80 percent efficient building.
WHAT A TENANT ACTUALLY PAYS
Now put a tenant in that building. She is leasing 2,000 usable square feet, and the landlord charges 22 dollars and 50 cents per square foot. The loss factor is added onto her usable space to account for her share of the common areas.
Multiply the usable area by the loss factor to find her share of the common space: 2,000 usable square feet times .20 equals 400 square feet of common area. Add that to her usable area: 2,000 plus 400 equals 2,400 rentable square feet. That 2,400 is the number the lease is written on.
Then multiply by the rate. 22 dollars and 50 cents times 2,400 square feet equals 54,000 dollars in annual rent, which is 4,500 dollars a month. Divide the annual rent by the space she can actually use and the deal shows its true price: 54,000 dollars divided by 2,000 usable square feet is 27 dollars per usable square foot. The quoted rate was 22.50. The rate on space she can put a desk in is 27.00.
Add the load, then multiply by the rate
A 20 percent loss factor means that for every 100 square feet the tenant pays rent on, only 80 square feet is space she can actually use. That is the sentence to say to the client, in those words, before she signs anything. It is not a complaint about the landlord. It is how commercial space is priced everywhere, and a tenant who understands it can compare two buildings properly instead of comparing two rate quotes.
Quote gross, explain net, and make sure the client knows which number you mean every single time you say a number. The word square feet by itself means nothing in a commercial conversation. Usable square feet and rentable square feet mean two different things, and the whole deal sits on the difference.
WORKING BACKWARDS
Clients do not always hand you the numbers in the order the formula wants them. Sometimes you are given the rentable area and the rate and asked what the tenant can actually use. Sometimes you are given the monthly payment and asked what rate the landlord is charging.
A landlord quotes 3,600 rentable square feet at 25 dollars per square foot. Multiply: the annual rent is 90,000 dollars, and the monthly payment is 7,500 dollars. If the building carries a 20 percent loss factor and the landlord built the rentable figure by adding the load to the usable area, then the usable area is the rentable figure divided by 1.20, which is 3,000 square feet. The tenant is paying on 3,600 and furnishing 3,000.
Now go the other way. A tenant tells you she pays 6,250 dollars a month on 2,500 rentable square feet. Multiply the monthly payment by twelve: 75,000 dollars a year. Divide by the rentable area: 75,000 divided by 2,500 is 30 dollars per square foot. That is the number to carry into a comparison with any other building, because it is the only number the two buildings state the same way.
WHEN YOUR NUMBER AND THE LANDLORD'S DISAGREE
It happens often, and it is almost never dishonesty. Measurement methods differ from owner to owner and from market to market, and two people applying two accepted methods to the same floor will produce two different rentable figures. What you do about it is simple and it is not optional. Ask the landlord or the managing agent, in writing, how the rentable area was calculated and what is included in it. Then quote the figure they stand behind, and tell your client where it came from.
NOTE: The exam gives you three of the four numbers and asks for the fourth. Rate times rentable area is annual rent. Annual rent divided by twelve is monthly rent. Difference divided by rentable is loss factor. Usable divided by rentable is efficiency. Write those four lines on your scratch paper before you read the question.
CAUTION: Never work a client's rentable figure on a napkin from memory. Adding the load to usable space is a two-step calculation and the first step is a multiplication people skip. Two thousand usable at a 20 percent load is 2,400 rentable, not 2,200. Get the number from the landlord in writing, then check it yourself.
REMEMBER: A tenant takes 5,000 usable square feet in a building with a 15 percent loss factor, at 30 dollars per square foot. What is the rentable area, the annual rent, and the monthly payment?
Lease Escalation Clauses
Escalators protect the owner's profit, and kick in after the base year
Leases often contain an escalation clause that allows the landlord to raise the rent at an agreed time during the term of the lease. These clauses, sometimes called escalators, protect a property owner's profit from rent, and in some cases prevent the erosion of the owner's expected return due to inflation. A ten-year lease at a fixed rent is a ten-year bet that costs will not rise. Nobody takes that bet, so leases contain escalators instead.
Everything on this screen answers one question. When the cost of running the building goes up, who pays the increase. The answers differ in mechanism and they all reach the same place, which is the tenant's check.
THE BASE YEAR
Escalators typically kick in after the base year identified in the lease. The base year, often the first year of the lease, establishes the operating expenses and taxes that everything afterward is measured against. It is the benchmark. Costs in any later year are compared to costs in the base year, and the increase is what gets passed along.
If there is no historical data supporting specific figures for those costs, the base year might not be the first year of the lease. A tenant in a new development signs a five-year lease. Since there is no operating history in a new building, the base year indicated in the lease might be year two, so the rent increases begin in year three. The tenant gets two years before any escalation, and the landlord gets a base year built on real numbers rather than on estimates.
By evaluating the costs in each comparison year against the cost of the same expenses during the base year, increases or decreases in those expenses can be calculated. The determination of the base year and its actual operating costs is what makes the tenant's pro-rata share calculable at all. Without an agreed base year there is nothing to compare the later years to.
THE PRO-RATA SHARE
Much commercial property includes common space and amenities shared by all the tenants, who are expected to pay for their share of the property's expenses. Some leases determine that share of common expenses on a pro-rata, or proportional, basis of the building's total area. The tenant's usable area divided by the building's total usable area equals the pro-rata share.
Work it. A tenant occupies 10,000 square feet of a 40,000 square foot building. Divide: 10,000 divided by 40,000 equals .25. The tenant's pro-rata share is 25 percent, and the tenant is expected to pay 25 percent of the building's shared expenses. Hypothetical. The building's operating costs run 80,000 dollars above the base year figure. Twenty-five percent of 80,000 dollars is 20,000 dollars, and that is what lands on this tenant.
The statement of the base year, the operating costs, and the proportionate share should always be clearly defined in a lease, to avoid misunderstandings between tenants and landlords. That is not legal caution for its own sake. Those three numbers together are the formula that decides what the tenant owes every year after the first, and a lease that leaves any one of them vague has built an argument into itself.
Base year, operating costs, proportionate share
PASS-THROUGHS AND THE EXPENSE CAP
Many leases allow landlords to pass along unexpected increases in operating costs to tenants. Those charges are referred to as pass-throughs. A lease may provide that the landlord agrees to operating costs up to a maximum rate per square foot, or a maximum dollar amount of certain operating expenses, with the remainder being passed through to the tenants.
In theory tenants may be subject to an unlimited number of added expenses that could be passed through by their landlords. That is the risk a pass-through clause creates, and a tenant on a long lease has no way to forecast it. So tenants often negotiate a lease clause that places a maximum on their expense liabilities. That clause is called an expense cap, or an expense ceiling, and it is the tenant's answer to an open-ended pass-through.
THE TAX STOP
Insurance and ad valorem property taxes are often handled in the same manner as other operating expenses. A separate clause in the lease may refer to a negotiated amount at which the owner's contribution to property taxes stops. If property taxes were 4 dollars per square foot and the owner had a stop of 3 dollars per square foot, the owner would pay 3 dollars per square foot and the tenants would pay the 1 dollar per square foot above it.
Put a tenant under that clause. A tenant with 2,400 rentable square feet pays 1 dollar per square foot above the stop, which is 2,400 dollars for the year, or 200 dollars a month added to the rent. Insurance is frequently handled the same way, with its own stop. The tenant's rent is stable. The tenant's total occupancy cost is not, and the difference between the two is what the stop measures.
STEP INCREASES
With a negotiated contractual step or bump increase, the base rent is scheduled to step up or bump up by a predetermined negotiated percentage or a pre-established dollar amount, no matter what happens to actual operating expenses. This arrangement is also known as a graduated lease. The increases are commonly effective on each anniversary of the lease or at the beginning of each calendar year.
A step increase is the only escalator on this screen that is knowable in advance. Hypothetical. A tenant signs at 54,000 dollars a year with a 3 percent annual step. Year two is 54,000 times 1.03, which is 55,620 dollars. Year three is 55,620 times 1.03, which is 57,288 dollars and 60 cents. Both parties can write those figures down on the day of signing.
That certainty has a financing consequence worth knowing. Landlords often find that lenders are more willing to finance buildings with the income certainty of step increases than with the fluctuations of indexed increase methods. A lender underwriting a building wants to know what the income will be in year seven, and a step schedule answers the question.
INDEX LEASES AND THE CPI
An adjustment mechanism frequently used in the commercial rental market is to link the escalation clause to a readily available index based on changes in the marketplace. The most commonly used index is the Consumer Price Index, usually shortened to CPI. The CPI is an index published monthly by the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics, and it is considered by many to be the basic indicator of inflation in the U.S.
CPI calculations exist for the United States as a whole, and for regions, states, and even individual markets, so a lease can be tied to the index that actually describes the tenant's economy. By basing rental increases on the increase or decrease in the CPI, landlords and tenants can be reasonably sure that the amount of rent being paid at the beginning of the lease retains its effective purchasing power, no matter what happens to the value of the dollar.
PORTER'S WAGE ESCALATION
The Porter's Wage Escalation Formula is used in many New York City buildings, and it is the one escalator on this screen that is local to this state. It ties the rent escalation to the wages of the building's cleaning and building maintenance personnel, who are called porters. The formula provides that the tenant's rent will increase a specific amount per square foot for a specified increase in the porters' hourly wages.
The logic is that labor is the largest single operating cost in a serviced office building, so the porters' wage rate is a reasonable proxy for the whole cost of running the building. A tenant signing a New York City office lease should expect to see this clause, should ask what the current porter wage rate is, and should ask what happens to the rent per square foot for each increment that rate rises.
Notice what the porter's wage formula has in common with the CPI clause, and how it differs. Both are index leases in substance, because both tie the rent to an outside number neither party controls. The CPI measures prices across an economy. The porter's wage measures the cost of the labor in this one building's own service contract. The second is closer to the landlord's actual costs, which is why New York City landlords prefer it, and it is also the one a tenant from out of state will never have seen before.
PUTTING THE ESCALATORS TOGETHER
A single commercial lease will usually carry several of these at once, and they stack. A tenant can be paying a step increase on base rent, a pro-rata share of operating expenses above the base year, a pass-through subject to a cap, and a share of taxes above a stop, all in the same year, all as separate line items. That is why the total occupancy cost of a space is never the rent quote, and why comparing two buildings means comparing the whole structure rather than the first number.
So the practical instruction is a list of questions rather than a formula. What is the base year, and why that year? What is my pro-rata share, and how was it calculated? What can be passed through, and is there a cap on it? Is there a tax stop or an insurance stop, and at what figure? Does the base rent step, and by how much? Is anything tied to an index or to the porter's wage? Six questions, asked before signing, and the answers are the real rent.
NOTE: Two escalators sound alike and are not. A step or bump increase raises the rent by a fixed percentage or dollar amount regardless of what expenses actually do. An index lease raises the rent by whatever the index did. The step is certain and may be wrong. The index tracks reality and cannot be forecast.
CAUTION: A tenant who negotiates hard on the base rent and signs the escalation clause without reading it has negotiated the smallest number in the lease. Over a ten-year term the escalators frequently move more money than the starting rent does. Ask for the base year, the pro-rata share, the pass-through language, the cap, and the stop, every time.
REMEMBER: A tenant occupies 8,000 square feet of a 32,000 square foot building. What is the pro-rata share? Then name the New York City escalator that is tied to a wage rate rather than to a price index.
Commercial Commissions
Paid at closing or in installments, type, amount, and timing are always negotiable
There are no fixed or established commission schedules. In fact, any attempt or effort by a group of real estate practitioners to create a standard commission schedule would be construed as a violation of the antitrust laws. That is the rule, it applies to commercial practice exactly as it applies to residential practice, and it is the most serious thing on this screen.
Read the rule for what it actually prohibits, which is the agreement, not the number. A single brokerage may set whatever rates it likes. What no group of competitors may do is agree among themselves on what to charge, publish a recommended schedule for the group to follow, or pressure each other into a common rate. A printed schedule handed around a trade-group breakfast with a request that everyone adopt it is exactly the conduct the antitrust laws were written for.
In commercial real estate, fees may be paid when the transaction closes or in installments, as with a long-term lease. The type and amount of compensation and the payment schedule are always negotiable, and negotiating them is part of taking the engagement. A commercial agent who never discusses how she will be paid until the deal is done has left the most important term of her own contract to chance.
No group may set a schedule of rates
COMMISSION ON A COMMERCIAL SALE
A fixed percentage is the arrangement most licensees already know. The negotiated commission rate is applied to the actual sale price of the property. Sale price times commission rate equals commission. Nothing about that formula is different in commercial work, except the size of the numbers it operates on.
A graduated percentage adjusts the rate to the property's sale price, so the rate steps down as the price rises. A schedule might read 7 percent on the first 500,000 dollars, 6 percent on the next 500,000 dollars, and 5 percent on anything over 1 million dollars. Hypothetical, using that schedule on a 1.4 million dollar sale. Seven percent of 500,000 dollars is 35,000 dollars. Six percent of the next 500,000 dollars is 30,000 dollars. Five percent of the remaining 400,000 dollars is 20,000 dollars. Add them: 85,000 dollars in total commission, which works out to a blended rate of about 6.07 percent on the whole price.
Work a graduated schedule in layers and it stays simple. Work it as a single rate on the whole price and you will be wrong every time. A seller looking at that example may well ask why the rate falls on the upper layers, and the answer is that the work of selling a property does not grow in step with its price.
A fixed fee is a set dollar amount paid for the performance of specific real estate services. To be paid, the fee arrangement generally requires the successful completion of the transaction. The fee does not move with the price, which suits a client who wants a known cost and suits a broker who knows what the work will take.
A retainer or hourly fee is the arrangement that surprises people coming from residential practice. A retainer paid in advance, or a fee based on the hours worked to perform specified tasks, may be paid even when transactions do not close. This is lawful and it is ordinary in commercial work. A warehouse user who hires a broker to run a six-month site search across three counties is buying the search, and the broker is entitled to be paid for performing it whether or not the user ends up buying anything.
COMMISSION ON A COMMERCIAL LEASE
A lump sum commission is paid either at the time the lease is executed, meaning signed by both landlord and tenant, or upon the tenant taking occupancy of the leased premises. This commission is often based on a percentage of the total rental value of the lease, which is known as the aggregate lease amount.
Hypothetical. A tenant signs a five-year lease on 2,400 rentable square feet at 22 dollars and 50 cents per square foot. Annual rent is 54,000 dollars, so the aggregate lease amount over five years is 270,000 dollars. A commission negotiated at 4 percent of the aggregate lease amount is 10,800 dollars. Change the term to ten years and the aggregate doubles, which is why lease commissions on long terms are frequently paid in installments rather than all at once.
A per-square-foot fee bases the commission on a dollar amount per square foot of leased space. A flat fee is a fixed dollar amount for leasing the space regardless of square footage. And a procurement fee is a fee typically paid for finding space for a tenant. Procurement fees are often fixed fees, though they can be percentage based.
WHAT TO SETTLE BEFORE YOU START
Three things get agreed in writing before the work begins. What type of compensation this is, whether percentage, fixed, per square foot, retainer, or some combination. What the amount or the rate is. And when it is payable, which on a long-term lease may be a schedule of installments running over years rather than a single payment at signing.
Leave the three unsettled and you have done months of work on a handshake. Get all three right and the compensation conversation is finished before the negotiation starts, which is where a commercial client would rather have it.
NOTE: The antitrust question shows up on the exam as a scene rather than as a rule. A group of brokers circulating a recommended commission schedule, agreeing on a floor, or urging each other to stop undercutting is an antitrust violation. It does not become lawful because the schedule is called a recommendation, because the property is commercial, or because nobody signed anything.
CAUTION: A retainer that is payable whether or not a transaction closes is lawful, ordinary, and easy to mistake for something improper. What makes it lawful is that it is disclosed, agreed in writing, and paid for services actually performed. What would make it a problem is charging it without an agreement, or charging it for work nobody did.
REMEMBER: Say the four ways a commercial sales commission can be structured and the four ways a lease commission can. Then say what makes a circulated commission schedule unlawful, in one sentence.
Session Summary
The six things to carry out of Chapter 19
Six ideas hold this chapter together. If you can say all six without looking, you are ready for the quiz and for the issue-spotting case that follows it.
ONE FIELD, ONE MEANING
Commercial real estate and investment real estate refer to the same thing: property that is used for investment purpose. The definition follows the buyer's intention rather than the building's shape, so a single-family home bought to produce a return is commercial real estate, and the same house bought to live in is not. Nearly any type of property can be commercial: unimproved land, residential property, office buildings, retail, industrial and manufacturing property, and mixed-use buildings. Only about two of every ten licensed agents practice in this field, which leaves it a wide-open specialty.
NO SPECIAL LICENSE
Practicing commercial real estate does not require a special license or special coursework. The New York broker's or salesperson's license is all-encompassing and permits brokerage of practically any type of real estate. The basic provisions of agency law, contract law, real property law, license law, and civil rights and fair housing law are almost identical in commercial and residential practice. The Civil Rights Act of 1866 prohibits public and private racial discrimination in any property transaction in the United States and covers all property, real or personal, residential or commercial, improved or unimproved. The federal Fair Housing Act reaches residential property, vacant land intended for housing, and commercial housing such as apartment complexes of more than four units. The Americans with Disabilities Act has a tremendous impact on commercial property, especially on accessibility and accommodation.
KNOW EVERY PROPERTY TYPE
Unimproved land is analyzed for location first, then zoning, environment, and topography, and valued at its highest and best use: the legal use yielding the highest present value, so long as it is physically possible, financially feasible, legally permissible, and maximally productive. A land buyer acquires a bundle of rights, and a seller conveys only what he still holds, so mineral rights sold off years ago never pass with a later fee simple purchase. Residential investment runs from single-family houses, which are either 100 percent occupied or 100 percent vacant, through two-to-four unit buildings to large multi-family. Office buildings grade from Class A down to Class D, and the class is a local judgment. Retail runs from the strip center up to the super regional mall, organized around anchor tenants that generate traffic for the smaller stores. Industrial property is assessed on floor load, ceiling height, clear span, docks, and transportation access, almost always needs an environmental impact statement, and often meets NIMBY opposition. Mixed-use buildings combine uses under local zoning, and a loft's unfinished interior is why loft rent is lower than the rent on finished space.
OWN OR LEASE
Owning brings tax savings, income, appreciation, and control, against a capital outlay, financing, liability, management, compliance, and inflexibility. Leasing brings flexibility, mobility, lower up-front cash, stable costs, and fewer management distractions, against no appreciation, limited control, limited tax relief, contractual penalties, and a total cost per square foot that often exceeds ownership. The amenity purchaser is an owner-user looking for a home for the business and values space, location, and room to expand. The investor places money where it will earn more money and values return, vacancy rates, and the income stream. A sale-and-leaseback serves both at once, and an agent who offers only a straight purchase or a straight lease has narrowed the client's choices too soon.
THE LEASE SPECTRUM
The spectrum runs from gross, also called full service, where the landlord pays the ownership expenses and charges a higher rent, to triple net, also called absolute net, where the tenant pays taxes, insurance, and common area maintenance on top of base rent and the rent per square foot is lower. Single net is any one of the three expenses, net-net is any two, net-net-net is all three, and mortgage principal and interest never move to the tenant. A percentage lease adds a share of gross sales above the breakpoint, and the breakpoint is base rent divided by the overage rate. A ground lease rents the land alone, usually on an absolute net basis and usually long enough to finance and depreciate improvements, and at expiration the land and the building erected on it revert to the landowner. Clauses to know by name: use, attornment, estoppel, subordination and nondisturbance, right of first refusal, utility metering, and the good-guy rider. And four ways out of a lease: close down, buyout, sublease, which leaves the original tenant fully liable, and assignment, which can still reach the original tenant if the assignee defaults.
MEASURE, THEN ESCALATE
Rent is quoted and paid on gross, or rentable, square footage, which includes the tenant's share of lobbies, corridors, elevators, restrooms, and stairwells. Usable, or net, or carpetable square footage is the space inside the tenant's own walls. Loss factor is rentable minus usable divided by rentable, and building efficiency is usable divided by rentable, so a 20 percent loss factor describes an 80 percent efficient building. The load is added to usable space to find the rentable area the lease is written on. Escalators start after the base year and include the tenant's pro-rata share of expenses, pass-throughs limited by an expense cap, a tax or insurance stop, fixed step or bump increases that make a graduated lease, index leases tied to the Consumer Price Index, and in many New York City buildings the porter's wage escalation formula. Commissions are negotiated deal by deal in every form, and no group of practitioners may set a schedule.
Six ideas, and three formulas under them
THE VOCABULARY YOU NOW OWN
Run the list and check that each word has a definition attached rather than a feeling. Highest and best use. Setback. Floor area ratio. Bundle of rights. Anchor tenant. Clear span. Floor load. Loft. Amenity purchaser. Investor. Sale-and-leaseback. Gross lease. Modified gross. Net, net-net, net-net-net, absolute net. Common area maintenance. Percentage lease. Breakpoint. Overage. Ground lease. Use clause. Attornment. Estoppel. Subordination. Nondisturbance. Right of first refusal. Good-guy clause. Sublease. Assignment. Rentable square footage. Usable square footage. Loss factor. Building efficiency. Base year. Pro-rata share. Pass-through. Expense cap. Tax stop. Step increase. Graduated lease. Index lease. Consumer Price Index. Porter's wage escalation. Aggregate lease amount. Procurement fee.
That is what this chapter was for. The law of commercial real estate is almost entirely law you already knew from residential practice. What kept eight of ten licensees out of this field was the list above, and you have just been through all of it.
WHAT COMES NEXT
Chapter 20 takes the other half of DOS Subject 16 and turns to the numbers. Why an investor chooses real estate at all. Risk and where it comes from. Liquidity and marketability, and why real estate is illiquid. Leverage, and how borrowed money turns a return into a larger return or into a loss. Then the cash flow model itself: the reconstructed income and expense statement, net operating income, debt service, before-tax and after-tax cash flow, capitalization rates and the income-rate-value relationship, and the depreciation deduction working behind all of it.
The two chapters fit together in one sentence. Chapter 19 taught you what the property is and how the lease is written. Chapter 20 teaches you what the property earns and what the investment is worth. An agent who knows the first half can describe a building. An agent who knows both halves can tell a client whether to buy it.
NOTE: Three calculations from this chapter appear on almost every commercial question set. Loss factor equals rentable minus usable over rentable. Breakpoint equals base rent divided by the overage rate. Pro-rata share equals the tenant's area over the building's area. Write the three formulas down before you read the first question.
CAUTION: The two facts most often stated backwards in practice are on this screen. A triple net tenant pays the taxes, the insurance, and the CAM, not the landlord. And at the end of a ground lease the building goes to the landowner, not to the tenant who built it. Say both of them out loud correctly once before you take the quiz.
REMEMBER: Which of these six could you not explain to a client over the phone right now, without notes? Go back to that screen before you take the quiz.
YOU BE THE JUDGE · ISSUE-SPOTTING CHALLENGE
The Garment District Gamble
Everything up to this screen was rules. This is the part of commercial practice the rules do not do for you.
Nobody in this business hands you a violation with a label attached. You get a file, most of it ordinary, and the skill is noticing the one fact that is not. In commercial work the noticing is harder than it is in residential, because half the mistakes are arithmetic and arithmetic looks confident. A wrong breakpoint and a right breakpoint are printed in the same font.
HOW TO WORK A COMMERCIAL FACT PATTERN
Read the story once for the story, without a pen. Then read it again with a pen and mark every place somebody states a rule, states a number, or makes a promise. Do not decide yet whether any of them is wrong. Just mark them. Most students who miss issues miss them because they started judging on the first pass and stopped reading.
Then run four passes over what you marked, in this order. Four passes takes longer than one and finds more, because each pass looks for a different kind of error and none of them is distracted by the others.
First, the license and civil rights pass. Did anyone claim a credential? Did anyone's decision turn on a client's or customer's race, or on any other protected characteristic? Did anyone say a civil rights or accessibility law does not reach commercial property? The 1866 Act covers all property, real or personal, residential or commercial, improved or unimproved. The ADA falls hardest on commercial property, especially on accessibility and accommodation. And there is no commercial endorsement in New York for anyone to hold.
Second, the arithmetic pass. Rework every number in the story yourself, with a calculator, and write your figure next to theirs. Rentable equals usable plus the load. Breakpoint equals base rent divided by the overage rate. Loss factor equals rentable minus usable divided by rentable. Pro-rata share equals the tenant's area over the building's area. If a figure in the story does not come out when you compute it, that is not a rounding difference. That is the issue.
The arithmetic pass has a second half that students skip. When a number fails, ask which way it failed. A figure that is too small usually means somebody multiplied where he should have divided. A figure that is too large usually means somebody applied a rate to the wrong base. Naming the direction of the error is how you name the rule that was broken, and a graded answer wants the rule.
Third, the lease-structure pass. Who pays what under the lease that was signed? Count the N's. What happens at the end of the term? Who stays liable after a transfer? When may a right actually be exercised? Each of those is a one-sentence rule from this chapter, and each of them can be stated backwards in a way that sounds reassuring. A statement that makes a tenant feel better is the statement to check first.
Fourth, the money and duty pass. How is the broker being paid, by whom, and under what agreement? Did anyone agree with competitors about price? Did anyone tell a buyer he was getting more than the seller actually owns? Compensation and the bundle of rights are where the last issues usually hide, because they sit at the edges of the story rather than in the middle of it.
Mark first, judge second
HOW A GOOD ANSWER IS WRITTEN
An issue-spotting answer has four parts and it is worth practicing the shape before you need it. The fact. The rule. Why the fact breaks the rule. And what the licensee should have done instead. Miss the first part and you have recited law. Miss the last part and you have criticized without teaching yourself anything.
Here is the shape, worked on a hypothetical that is not in the case below, so nothing is given away. A salesperson tells an office tenant that a suite quoted at 30 dollars per square foot with 4,000 usable square feet and a 25 percent loss factor will cost her 120,000 dollars a year.
The fact: the salesperson multiplied the quoted rate by the usable area. The rule: rent is calculated on rentable square footage, and the load is added to usable space to find it. Why it breaks: 4,000 usable times .25 is 1,000 square feet of common area, so the rentable area is 5,000 square feet, and 5,000 times 30 dollars is 150,000 dollars a year. The quote understated the rent by 30,000 dollars a year, and by 150,000 dollars over a five-year term. What should have happened: the salesperson should have obtained the rentable figure from the landlord in writing, checked it with the load calculation, and quoted the rentable number while explaining the usable number separately.
Four sentences. A fact, a rule, a calculation, a correction. Write every issue you find in that shape and you will find you cannot bluff, because the calculation either comes out or it does not.
A DRILL BEFORE YOU START
Run these five calculations cold, before you read the case. They cover the same ground the case will ask you to check, on different numbers. Do them on paper. A calculation you can follow when you read it is not a calculation you can do.
One. A tenant takes 3,000 usable square feet in a building with a 25 percent loss factor. Her share of common area is 3,000 times .25, which is 750 square feet, so the rentable area is 3,750 square feet. At 40 dollars per square foot her annual rent is 150,000 dollars, and her monthly rent is 12,500 dollars. Divide the annual rent by her usable area and she is paying 50 dollars per usable square foot for a space quoted at 40.
Two. A retail tenant pays 120,000 dollars annual base rent with a 6 percent overage. The breakpoint is 120,000 divided by .06, which is 2,000,000 dollars. On gross sales of 2.3 million dollars the overage is 300,000 times .06, which is 18,000 dollars, and the tenant's total rent that year is 138,000 dollars. Check the breakpoint by running it backwards: 6 percent of 2,000,000 dollars is 120,000 dollars, which equals the base rent. The division was right.
Three. A tenant occupies 6,000 square feet of a 24,000 square foot building, so the pro-rata share is 6,000 divided by 24,000, which is 25 percent. Property taxes run 5 dollars per square foot against a 4 dollar stop, so this tenant pays 1 dollar per rentable square foot, which is 6,000 dollars for the year, or 500 dollars a month on top of rent.
Four. A building has 15,000 rentable square feet and 11,250 usable square feet. Subtract: the difference is 3,750 square feet of common area. Divide by rentable: 3,750 over 15,000 is .25, a 25 percent loss factor. Check it from the other side: 11,250 over 15,000 is .75, so the building is 75 percent efficient, and 25 plus 75 is 100. Whenever the two numbers do not add to 100, one of them is wrong.
Five. A seller lists a building at 1.8 million dollars under a graduated commission schedule of 7 percent on the first 500,000 dollars, 6 percent on the next 500,000, and 5 percent above 1 million. Layer it: 35,000 dollars, plus 30,000 dollars, plus 5 percent of the remaining 800,000 dollars, which is 40,000 dollars. The total is 105,000 dollars. Applying a flat 7 percent to the whole price would have produced 126,000 dollars, which is why the schedule has to be worked in layers and why the rate is negotiated before the listing is taken, not after the offer arrives.
If any of those five gave you trouble, go back to the screens on measuring space, on percentage leases, on escalation clauses, and on commissions before you read the case. The case is written to punish exactly the calculation you just skipped.
THE CASE
Read carefully. Some of these facts decide the case. Some are ordinary commercial practice put there to see whether you will accuse someone of something lawful. They are not labeled.
Leo, a salesperson at Meridian Commercial, decides to break into commercial work. He wins a diner owner's listing by boasting that he can charge a premium because he “holds the special commercial endorsement most agents never bother to get.” When two business partners ask to tour a vacant Garment District storefront, Leo quietly drops them after meeting the Black partner, telling his broker the building's owner “prefers a different kind of buyer.” Advising a landlord client on a lobby renovation, he says to skip the wheelchair-accessible entrance, “since disability law only covers housing, not commercial buildings.”
Space math comes next. Leo shows a tenant a 2,000-usable-square-foot suite in a 10,000-square-foot building with a 20% loss factor and quotes the rent “on your carpetable space, that's the only space you pay for.” Pressed for the rentable figure, he works it out on a napkin: “two thousand plus the load, call it 2,200 rentable square feet.” Signing the deal, he reassures her that the “net-net-net” lease is the good kind: “the landlord picks up the taxes, the insurance, and the common area maintenance.”
His retail clients fare no better. For a jeweler paying $80,000 annual base rent with an 8% overage, Leo computes the breakpoint by multiplying: “$80,000 times .08, you'll owe overage on everything past $6,400 in sales.” He tells a coffee-bar tenant on a 10-year ground lease to build out lavishly because “when the lease ends, the building is yours to keep.” When another tenant needs out in year two of a five-year term, Leo arranges a sublease and congratulates her: “Your name's off the lease, no further obligations.” And he urges a tenant holding a right of first refusal to “exercise it today, before the owner even puts the place on the market.”
At a trade-group breakfast, Leo passes around a printed “Meridian recommended commercial commission schedule” and asks the room to adopt it “so we all stop undercutting each other.” Selling a development parcel, he assures the buyer that fee simple title “always includes the minerals,” even though the abstract shows the seller conveyed the mineral rights to a drilling company years ago. Meanwhile, Meridian's broker signs a site-search consulting agreement with a warehouse user, charging a monthly retainer that is payable even if no purchase ever closes.
12 violations are buried in this story
, plus one lawful act planted to catch you out.
How many can you spot?
Name the duty, statute, or rule each act breaks. Write the rule next to the fact, in your own words, before you look at anything else. An answer that names a rule without naming the fact it attaches to is not an answer.
Then do the harder half. Sort what you found into three piles. Clearly a violation. Clearly lawful. Cannot tell from these facts. The third pile is the one that teaches you something, because for each item in it you have to name the missing fact that would move it into one of the other two.
Then find the plant. One act in this story is lawful and is written to look suspicious. Ask yourself which fact you accused fastest, and whether you accused it because of a rule or because of a feeling. An accusation made too quickly is its own kind of untrustworthiness, and in practice it costs licensees more than a missed issue does.
Last, argue the other side of the single issue you were least sure about. Say it out loud. If you cannot construct the argument, you did not spot an issue. You recited a rule and hoped it fit.
THINGS THAT LOOK WRONG AND ARE NOT
Commercial practice is full of arrangements that startle someone who has only done residential work. Each of the following is ordinary, lawful, and negotiated every day, and a student who flags them as violations has learned the wrong lesson from this chapter.
A rent that rises with the tenant's sales. A lease that makes the tenant pay the taxes, the insurance, and the maintenance on a building he does not own. A lease that ends with the landlord keeping a building the tenant paid to construct. A demand that a tenant sign a certificate confirming what his own lease says. A clause making an existing lease junior to a mortgage signed years later. A commission rate that falls as the price rises. A fee paid in advance under a written agreement for work the broker actually performs, whether or not anything closes. A business owner who personally guarantees his company's rent.
Every one of those has a name in this chapter and a legitimate reason for existing. None of them becomes a violation because it seems hard on one side. Commercial parties are presumed to negotiate at arm's length, and the licensee's duty is to explain the deal accurately, not to decide it is unfair.
What turns any of them into an issue is a licensee describing it wrongly. The percentage lease is lawful; a breakpoint calculated by multiplying is not. The absolute net lease is lawful; telling the tenant the landlord carries the three expenses is not. The ground lease reversion is lawful; telling the tenant he keeps the building is not. The pattern holds through the whole story. Look at what the licensee said about the arrangement, not at the arrangement.
WHY THIS IS THE WHOLE JOB
Every act in this story is the kind of thing a licensee does in an ordinary week. Quoting a rent. Explaining a lease type. Reassuring a tenant who wants out. Answering a question about what a buyer is getting. Talking to other brokers at a breakfast. None of it looks like misconduct while it is happening, and that is exactly the problem. Commercial mistakes are made in a confident voice, in front of a client who has no way to check them.
Notice also how many of the issues in a commercial file are statements rather than acts. Somebody says a lease works a certain way. Somebody says a law does not apply. Somebody says a number is a number. A false statement of a material fact made to induce a client to act is a misrepresentation whether or not the licensee knew it was false, because a licensee is held to what he should have known. That standard is why the four passes matter. You are not being asked to be honest. You are being asked to be right.
And notice the last thing, which is the reason the case includes an act that is perfectly lawful. Part of competence is declining to call something a violation. A licensee who reports a colleague for an ordinary commercial arrangement has damaged someone over his own gap in knowledge. Read the whole chapter before you read the whole case, and let the rules decide rather than the instinct.
WHEN YOU HAVE FINISHED
Compare your list against the rule, screen by screen, not against a memory of the story. Take each issue you found and name the screen in this chapter that contains the rule it breaks. Any issue you cannot trace back to a screen is either a rule from another chapter, which is fine, or a feeling, which is not. Then take the screens that never came up in your list and ask whether that is because the case does not test them or because you did not look.
Then open the graded activity for this chapter. Same skill, same case, and a score attached to it.
NOTE: Most of what goes wrong in this story is lease mechanics and arithmetic rather than license law, and that is what makes it a commercial case. If your list is all statutes and no numbers, you have read it as a license law case and you have missed the larger half. Go back with a calculator.
CAUTION: Do not grade yourself on the count alone. A student who finds nine issues and can state the rule and the fact for each of the nine has learned more than a student who finds twelve and can explain four. The count is a scoreboard. The reasoning is the skill.
Name the fact, then name the rule
REMEMBER: Before you open the graded activity, say out loud the three formulas from this chapter and the one sentence about what happens to a building when a ground lease expires. Those four facts carry more of this case than anything else you know.