Lesson 1
Real Estate as an Investment
Risk, liquidity, and leverage, the character of the asset
Why Investors Choose Real Estate
Trading a lump sum of capital today for tomorrow's returns
An investor hands money over today and gets nothing back today. That is the shape of every real estate investment. A lump sum of capital leaves the investor's hands in the present. What comes back arrives later, in pieces, spread across the years of ownership and a sale at the end of them. Every number in this chapter exists to answer one question. Are the pieces worth the lump sum?
There is a name for the problem that shape creates. Money in hand today is worth more than the same money promised for later, because money in hand can be put to work in the meantime. That is the time value of money, and it is the reason an investor cannot simply add up the dollars a property will pay and compare the total to the price. A dollar arriving in year nine is not a dollar. The measurements in this chapter are all ways of handling that mismatch, and capitalization in the third lesson handles it directly.
A buyer who wants a place to live is buying shelter. An investor is buying a stream of numbers. The roof and the boiler matter to an investor only because the numbers come out of them, and a building that produces a poor stream is a poor investment however well it photographs. Your job with an investor client is to talk about the stream. Talk about granite counters and you are selling the wrong product to the wrong buyer.
This is also the point in your career where the vocabulary changes. A residential buyer asks what the taxes are. An investor asks what the net operating income is, what the cap rate is, what the cash-on-cash return comes to. Those are not fancier words for the same thing. They are different measurements, and an agent who cannot produce them is not in the conversation.
WHAT THE INVESTOR EXPECTS IN EXCHANGE
A continuing stream of income. The property is rented, the tenants pay, and after the bills of ownership are paid something is left over each year. That leftover is why most people buy income property at all, and it arrives while the investor still owns the building.
A tax shelter. Owning investment property carries income tax advantages: deductions for property taxes, for mortgage interest, and for depreciation. A deduction reduces the income the owner is taxed on. When the deductions run larger than the cash the property throws off, they can reach past the property and shelter the owner's other income from tax. The last lesson of this chapter works through how that happens.
Equity build-up. Equity is the owner's unencumbered interest in the property, the difference between the value of the property and the liens against it. Equity grows from two directions at once. The loan balance falls as the mortgage amortizes, and the value rises if the property appreciates. Neither movement puts a dollar in the owner's pocket in the year it happens. Both of them make the owner richer.
A return on the investment when the property is sold. The sale is the day the capital comes back out, and for most investors it carries the largest single number in the whole ownership period.
Four expectations. Not four guarantees. An investor may get all four, may get two, may get none of them. The word to hold on to is expectation, and putting numbers on an expectation is what the rest of this chapter does.
TWO RETURNS TO KEEP STRAIGHT
Return OF the investment is preservation of capital. It is the assurance that the money put in comes back out. Preservation of capital is the primary goal of any investor, and it sits ahead of profit. An investment that pays beautifully for six years and then hands back sixty cents on the dollar has failed at the first thing the investor asked of it.
Return of the total investment is usually not realized until the real estate is sold. That one fact controls how the analysis is done. You cannot judge an investment property by a single good year. Analyze it across the entire ownership period, from the day the capital goes in to the day it comes back out.
Return ON the investment is an acceptable return the property earns while the capital is at risk, tied up in the property and unavailable for anything else. Real estate's ability to produce that return while the capital sits there is one of the big attractions of investing here rather than somewhere else.
Say the two out loud once. Return OF is the money back. Return ON is the money the money made. Change one preposition and you have changed the question.
Hypothetical. An investor puts $100,000 of her own cash into a two-family in Utica. For six years the property pays her $7,000 a year after every bill, including the mortgage. Then she sells, and after the loan is paid and the costs of sale are met she walks away with $118,000. The $7,000 a year was her return ON the investment, earned while her capital was tied up in the building. The $100,000 coming back was her return OF the investment. The $18,000 on top of it was profit at sale. Take the $100,000 away from that story and the $7,000 a year stops meaning anything at all.
Now run the same story with the sale going the other way. Six years of $7,000, and then a sale that returns $82,000 after costs. She collected $42,000 of income and lost $18,000 of capital. The return ON the investment was real every year it was paid. The return OF the investment was not there when it mattered. This is why an investor analyzes the whole holding period and not the first twelve months.
Real estate has to compete for that capital. There is no shortage of alternatives in the marketplace: savings accounts, stocks and bonds, certificates of deposit, money market accounts, precious metals, fine art and collectibles, commodities futures. Whatever the investment, an investor picks the opportunity she believes comes closest to her own financial goals. Real estate wins that comparison only when its expected returns are comparable to the returns from other investments carrying similar risk.
The comparable-risk clause is the whole test, and it runs in both directions. A return that looks generous beside a savings account is not generous if the risk is ten times larger. A return that looks thin is not thin if the risk is nearly nothing. Every investor you work with is running that comparison whether or not they say it out loud, and the property competes against wherever else their money could sit.
NOTE: The exam separates the two returns with one question, asked as a definition. Preservation of capital, the assurance that the initial investment comes back, is return OF the investment. The income earned while the capital is at risk is return ON the investment. Leverage and appreciation are not answers to that question. They are two of the ways the returns get produced.
Return OF first, then return ON
REMEMBER: Think of the last property you saw offered as an investment. Which of the four expectations was the listing actually selling, the income, the shelter, the equity, or the profit at sale? And could you say what the buyer's capital would be earning if it were sitting anywhere else?
Risk, and the Return It Demands
Actual events in the market may differ from what investors anticipated
An investor buys on a set of expectations. The market then does whatever it was going to do. Vacancy runs higher than anticipated. Rents at renewal come in below what was predicted. Interest rates move. A tenant who paid on time for four years stops paying. Risk is the gap between what the investor expected and what actually happens.
Say it precisely, because the exam asks for the precise version. Risk is the degree of probability that the actual rate of return earned will differ from the return expected when the investment was made. Not the probability of losing money. The probability of being wrong about the number.
The amount of expected profit is directly related to the risk inherent in the investment. Low-risk investments are expected to generate low profits. High-risk investments are expected to generate high profits. That relationship is the reason nobody gets to have both. An investor who wants the return of a distressed commercial property and the safety of a certificate of deposit is asking for something the market does not sell.
An investor's own tolerance for risk decides how much of this she will accept. An acceptable level of risk means different things to different people, and it is not your place to tell a client what their tolerance should be. It is your place to describe the risks accurately enough that they can apply their own.
That framing matters for your license as well as for your client. Naming a risk is analysis and it is part of the service an investor is paying for. Telling an investor how much risk she should tolerate is advice about her personal finances, and it belongs to her accountant and her lawyer. The line between the two is worth learning early, because investor clients will push you across it.
KNOWING THE SOURCES OF RISK IS THE FIRST STEP IN RISK ANALYSIS
Space market risk is the risk that the demand for space will affect rents, vacancy rates, and net operating income. It comes from one of two directions. Users change how much space they want, or new construction changes how much space exists. Either one moves the rent the property can charge and the share of the year it stands empty.
Space market risk is the risk a licensee is best placed to see coming, because it lives in the local market you work in every day. A large employer announcing a move affects the demand side. A hundred new apartments breaking ground four blocks away affects the supply side. Neither of them shows up on the owner's operating statement, and both of them will show up in the investor's second year.
Capital market risk is the risk that changes in the market for capital will affect the value of real estate. It is a different market from the market for space, and the exam separates them for that reason. Capital market risk is driven by the level of interest rates, by the availability of mortgage and equity capital, and by the rate of return available on alternative investment opportunities.
Watch the third driver, because it catches people. When safer investments start paying more, real estate has to pay more to compete, and a property that has to pay more is worth less. The building did not change. The alternatives did.
Financial risk results when debt is used to finance an investment. Borrowing raises the return on the investor's own equity when the borrowed money earns more than it costs. Investors expect that to be the case when they buy and finance property. Unexpected changes in market conditions can reverse it. Debt also raises the risk of default on the mortgage, and the degree of financial risk increases with the amount of debt.
Financial risk is the only one on this list the investor chooses. Space market risk and capital market risk arrive whether or not the investor wants them. Financial risk is manufactured at the closing table by the size of the loan, and it can be turned up or down by changing the down payment.
Environmental risk is the risk that the value of a property will be influenced by factors that affect the owner's ability to develop or lease the space.
Legislative risk is the risk that changes in laws and regulations will affect the market value of the property.
Management risk is the risk that property management itself affects how the property performs. Two identical buildings on the same block can produce different numbers, and the difference is who is running them.
Hypothetical. An investor buys a small office building in Albany at a price that assumes ninety-five percent occupancy and rents holding steady. In year two the state agency that leases half the building consolidates into its own space, and a newer building opens two streets over. That is space market risk on both the demand side and the supply side at once. The investor's rate of return will differ from the one expected at purchase, which is the definition of risk doing exactly what it does.
LIQUIDITY AND MARKETABILITY ARE NOT THE SAME WORD
Liquidity is the ability to convert an asset into cash quickly without the loss of principal. Both halves of that definition carry weight. Quickly, and without giving up any of the money you put in.
Marketability is the ability to convert a commodity to cash quickly at any price. Marketability drops the second half. It only asks how fast you can find a buyer, not what the buyer pays.
Publicly traded stocks are highly marketable and therefore relatively liquid. A share can be sold in seconds, and the price it sells at is the price the market is quoting at that second. Speed and price are not in tension.
Real estate may require extended periods to sell and is affected by an unpredictable market. The full value of an investment property is usually not immediately convertible to cash without some loss of total value. That makes real estate one of the more non-liquid, or illiquid, of the investment alternatives.
The trade-off is easiest to see in a seller who is in a hurry. Give the property eight months on the market and it may fetch its full value. Give it three weeks and it will fetch less. Real estate can be made marketable at almost any moment by cutting the price. It cannot be made liquid, because liquidity requires the speed without the cut.
Illiquidity is not a defect to hide from an investor. It is a characteristic of the asset class, and it is priced in. Part of the return real estate pays is compensation for the fact that the money cannot be pulled back out on short notice. An investor who may need that capital in eighteen months should hear that from you before the offer, not after.
Illiquidity also explains why the risks above it compound the way they do. A stockholder who reads bad news can be out of the position before lunch. An owner whose building loses its largest tenant is still the owner of that building six months later, paying the taxes and the insurance on it while the space sits dark. Every source of risk on this screen lasts longer in real estate than it would anywhere else, because the exit takes longer.
NOTE: Liquidity and marketability are swapped on the exam in a single-word question. Liquidity is quickly and WITHOUT loss of principal. Marketability is quickly at ANY price. Read for the price clause and the answer falls out.
CAUTION: Financial risk is the answer whenever the fact pattern mentions debt, leverage, or default, and it grows with the amount of debt. Space market risk is the answer whenever the fact pattern mentions tenants, rents, vacancy, or new construction. Capital market risk is the answer whenever it mentions interest rates or the availability of financing. Match the fact to the market it belongs to before you pick.
Higher risk, higher expected profit
REMEMBER: Take a property you know and name its largest single source of risk out loud, space market, capital market, financial, environmental, legislative, or management. Then say what would have to happen for that risk to show up in the owner's numbers.
Leverage, Other People's Money
The effect borrowed funds have on investment returns
Leverage is the effect borrowed funds have on investment returns. That is the definition, and it is deliberately neutral. Leverage may increase or decrease the return an investor would have received buying the property on an all-cash basis. Which way it goes depends on one comparison, and the whole idea sits inside that comparison.
An investor borrows with an expectation. She expects the property's financial return to rise far enough that she makes a profit not only on her own invested funds, typically the down payment, but on the borrowed funds as well. Leverage is also called the use of other people's money, OPM, and it is one of the biggest draws in real estate investment.
The use of OPM lets investors compound their own buying power. The same cash buys a much larger property, or more properties, than it could if the investor had to fund the entire purchase alone. An investor with $200,000 who pays cash owns one $200,000 building. The same investor putting twenty percent down on each of four buildings controls a million dollars of real estate with the same $200,000. Four rent rolls instead of one. Four mortgages instead of none.
POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE LEVERAGE
Positive leverage is when borrowed funds are invested at a rate of return higher than the cost of those funds to the borrower. The result is a profit on the borrowed funds. The investor keeps the difference between what the money earns and what the money costs, and she keeps it on money that was never hers.
Negative leverage occurs when borrowed funds are invested at a rate of return lower than the cost of those funds to the borrower. The interest rate the lender charges is greater than the rate of return the investment is generating on those funds. The investor incurs a loss on the borrowed funds, and she pays that loss out of the return her own money earned.
One comparison decides it. What the borrowed dollars earn against what the borrowed dollars cost. Higher is positive. Lower is negative. Nothing else in the deal changes the sign.
Investors expect leverage to be positive when they purchase and finance property. Unexpected changes in market conditions can turn it negative. That is why leverage and financial risk are the same subject under two names. The degree of financial risk increases with the amount of debt, and so does the size of the mistake if the sign flips.
Work the mechanism slowly, because the exam asks it as arithmetic and not as a definition. Take the annual income the property produces. Subtract the interest the borrowed money costs for the year. What remains is what the investor's own money earned. Divide that by the investor's own money. The answer is the return on her funds, and it is the number that leverage moves.
CASE IN POINT, WILL BUYS A $150,000 RENTAL
$110,000
financed
at 6%
$40,000
down
$150,000
all cash
15%
8%
$12,000 rent − $6,000 interest = $6,000 net
$6,000 ÷ $40,000 = 15%
$12,000 rent, no loan to service
$12,000 ÷ $150,000 = 8%
Same building, same $12,000 of rent, the financed buyer nearly doubles his rate of return, because he profits on the borrowed funds too.
Read the two columns side by side. Same building. Same $12,000 of rent. The all-cash buyer put $150,000 to work and earned $12,000, which is eight percent on the money. The financed buyer put $40,000 to work, gave $6,000 of the rent to the lender, and kept $6,000, which is fifteen percent on his money. He earned a return on his own $40,000 and a return on the lender's $110,000 at the same time, and on the lender's money he kept the difference between what it earned and what it cost.
Hypothetical. Change one number and watch the return move. Will finances $100,000 at six percent instead, paying $6,000 in interest, and puts $50,000 down. The rent is still $12,000. Take $12,000 less $6,000 and $6,000 remains. Divide $6,000 by the $50,000 he put in and the return on his own funds is twelve percent. A larger down payment on the same building lowers the return on his cash, because less of the work is being done by somebody else's money.
That is leverage in one sentence. The less of your own money you use, the harder each of your dollars works, and the more of the deal depends on the borrowed dollars continuing to earn more than they cost.
Now make it negative. Leave the loan at $110,000 but put the rate where the interest comes to $13,000 a year. The rent is still $12,000. The property earns $12,000 and the borrowed money costs $13,000, so Will is $1,000 short before he has taken a dollar for himself. He now feeds the building out of his own pocket every year he owns it. The building did not get worse. The cost of the borrowed money got higher than what the borrowed money earns.
Leverage also changes what happens on the way down, and that half is usually left out of the sales pitch. An all-cash owner whose building loses value still owns the building and owes nobody. A heavily financed owner whose building loses value owes the same balance on a smaller asset, and the equity cushion is the first thing lost. Financial risk increases with the amount of debt in both directions, not just in the return.
CAUTION: Leverage is not free money and it is not a strategy that works in one direction. It multiplies whatever the property is already doing. Positive leverage on a good property is the most powerful thing in this chapter. Negative leverage on the same property turns a modest year into a loss, and the more debt is on the building the faster it turns.
NOTE: A leverage question gives you rent, interest and a down payment and asks for a return. Subtract the interest from the rent, divide by the down payment, and ignore everything else on the page. If the answer beats the all-cash return, the leverage is positive.
Borrowed dollars must earn more than they cost
REMEMBER: On the last financed purchase you looked at, what did the borrowed money cost for the year, and what did the property earn for the year? Which of the two numbers is larger, and what does that make the leverage?
Lesson 2
The Cash Flow Model
From gross potential income to the investor's bottom line
From Operating Statement to Pro Forma
Start with the owner's numbers, then make them the investor's
Investors are not emotional about buying decisions and they want an objective way to compare one property against another. They need a yardstick. The yardstick in this chapter is the cash flow model, and building it takes a great deal of financial information before a single line of it can be filled in.
Most investors start in the same place. They ask the present owner for recent operating statements and tax returns. An operating statement is the document the present owner uses to illustrate the total revenues generated and the expenses for a given period, as a means of evaluating the property's performance. It is a record of what already happened, written by the person who owns the building.
Ask for two things and not one. The operating statements show what the owner says the building did. The tax returns show what the owner told the government the building did. Those two documents were written for audiences with opposite interests, and where they disagree you have learned something free. An owner has every reason to present a generous picture to a buyer and a modest one to the Internal Revenue Service, and the gap between the two versions is a question worth asking out loud.
Asking for it is correct. Relying on it is not. The operating statement answers a question the investor did not ask. It says what the property did for this owner, under this owner's financing, with this owner's expenses on it. The investor needs to know what the property will do for a new owner, with new financing and new expenses. Those are two different buildings on paper.
Here is a previous year's operating statement for a small apartment complex. Read down it once before reading about it.
THE OWNER'S OPERATING STATEMENT, 17-UNIT APARTMENT COMPLEX
Line item
Amount
Annual rent roll (9 @ $520, 8 @ $610)
$114,720
Gross annual revenue (actual)
$111,320
Other income (laundry)
$2,400
Total operating income
$113,720
Total expenses (incl. owner items)
$109,062
Earnings before taxes (EBT)
$4,658
Work the bottom of it. Total operating income of $113,720 against total expenses of $109,062 leaves earnings before taxes of $4,658 on a seventeen-unit building. An investor reading that number cold would walk away. The building looks like it barely breaks even.
It does not barely break even. Look at what is sitting in the expense column.
Owner-only items, salary $20,000, mortgage interest $25,806, health insurance $4,850, travel $2,025, depreciation $14,546, swell the expense column. EBT tells the owner's story, not the investor's.
Add the owner-only items together and they come to $67,227 of the $109,062 in that column. Owner's salary $20,000. Mortgage interest $25,806. Owner's health insurance $4,850. Travel and entertainment $2,025. Depreciation $14,546. Strip those five lines out and the same building produces $71,885 above its remaining expenses. Same rents. Same roof. Same tenants. A completely different property.
None of those five is a lie. Every one of them is a legitimate entry on this owner's books. Every one of them also belongs to this owner and not to the building. The buyer will not pay this owner's salary. The buyer will not carry this owner's mortgage. The buyer's depreciation will be figured on the buyer's own purchase price. Earnings before taxes tells the owner's story. It does not tell the investor's.
That is the work of this screen. The operating statement is where the numbers come from. The pro forma is where they go.
Pro forma, the APOD
A pro forma, also called annual property operating data or the APOD, is the investor's hypothetical projection of income and expenses for the first full year of ownership. Hypothetical is the operative word. Nothing on a pro forma has happened yet. Every line on it is an estimate that somebody has to be able to defend.
Investors play a what-if game when preparing one. What if I finance at six percent? What if I put $150,000 down? What if I cut expenses? What if I raise the rent rolls? A capable investor knows which questions to ask and how to make the adjustments reasonably, so that there are no unpleasant surprises when the first real operating statement arrives twelve months later.
The investor weighs historical information and trends, current supply and demand, the factors affecting those trends, and anticipated events, such as competition from other developments under construction. The owner's statement supplies the history. Everything else the investor has to go and find.
ADJUSTING THE OWNER'S DATA INTO A PRO FORMA
Add new line items that pertain solely to the financial needs of the investor or buyer. A reserve for replacements. A management fee, because a buyer who is not going to run the building himself will be paying somebody to run it.
Adjust. Make use of some of the owner's line items but revise the financial data. Property taxes will be reassessed on a sale. Insurance will be written at the new owner's rate. Rents may move. The line stays; the number changes to a market-driven one.
Omit the line items that pertain only to the present owner and are irrelevant to the investor or buyer. Owner's salary, unless the owner is doing required property management that the buyer would have to hire somebody to do. Personal insurance, including medical and retirement contributions. Travel and entertainment. Car and related expenses. Debt service. Depreciation.
The last two on that omit list are the ones that get missed, and they are omitted for two different reasons. Debt service is left out because financing belongs to the buyer, not the building, and because the cash flow model subtracts it further down, after net operating income. Depreciation is left out because it is a tax calculation figured on the new owner's basis, and because on a pro forma the reserve for replacements does the job depreciation was doing on the operating statement.
Three words for the whole procedure. Add, adjust, omit. Run every line of the owner's statement through those three and what comes out the other side is a pro forma.
The management fee deserves a sentence of its own, because new agents leave it off. The seller of a small building is very often the person who shows the apartments, takes the calls at ten at night, and meets the plumber. He does not pay himself for it, so it never appears on his statement. A buyer who lives elsewhere will pay somebody to do that work, and that cost is real whether or not it was ever written down. On the 100 Main Street pro forma the management line is figured at ten percent of effective gross income. Leave it off and the net operating income is overstated by the whole amount.
Hypothetical. A seller hands you a statement showing $3,900 in repairs for last year and $1,400 in advertising. You know the seller did his own repairs on weekends and rarely advertised because most units filled by word of mouth. Neither line is dishonest. Both are useless to a buyer who lives two hours away and will hire out every repair. Adjust both upward to what the work actually costs at market rates, and be ready to say where the new figures came from.
CAUTION: Never hand an investor a pro forma built by copying the owner's statement and changing the heading. It is the single most common error in investment analysis, and every one of the owner-only lines you left in makes the property look worse than it is, while the debt service you left in makes the net operating income wrong on top of it.
NOTE: The exam asks what gets removed when an operating statement becomes a pro forma. The answer is the owner's personal items, debt service, and depreciation. The answer is not property taxes, not utilities, and not the reserve for replacements, the reserve is something you ADD.
Add, adjust, omit
REMEMBER: You are looking at a seller's operating statement tomorrow morning. Name the lines you would expect to strike out before you show it to a buyer, and name the two lines you would expect to add that are not on it.
The Cash Flow Model, Follow the Dollars
The pro forma for 100 Main Street, Anywhere NY
The cash flow model is four numbers in a column, each one produced from the one above it. Learn the column and you can read any investment property in the state. This is the pro forma for 100 Main Street, and the figures run all the way through the rest of this chapter.
ANNUAL PROPERTY OPERATING DATA, $500,000 PURCHASE · 20% DOWN · $400,000 MORTGAGE AT 7% FOR 30 YEARS
GROSS POTENTIAL INCOME
every space leased, everyone pays
$125,460
EFFECTIVE GROSS INCOME
what's really available for expenses
$124,096
NET OPERATING INCOME
the value driver, financing excluded
$50,690
BEFORE-TAX CASH FLOW
what the investor pockets, pre-tax
$18,756
− $3,764 vacancy & credit loss @ 3%
+ $2,400 other income (laundry)
− Operating expenses $73,406
− Annual debt service $31,934
Read it as one sentence. Gross potential income less vacancy and credit loss plus other income gives effective gross income. Effective gross income less operating expenses gives net operating income. Net operating income less annual debt service gives cash flow before taxes.
The top line is the rent roll projected forward. Nine apartments at $575 a month and eight at $660 a month. Nine times $575 is $5,175 a month, which is $62,100 for the year. Eight times $660 is $5,280 a month, which is $63,360 for the year. Together they make the $125,460 of gross potential income at the head of the column, and that figure assumes every one of the seventeen units is occupied for all twelve months by a tenant who pays in full and on time.
Each of the four lines has a plain-English name underneath the accounting one. Gross potential income is the perfect year. Effective gross income is the realistic year. Net operating income is what the property earns. Cash flow before taxes is what the investor earns. Nobody ever collects the first one.
Check the arithmetic yourself, because you will be asked to do exactly this on the exam. Gross potential income of $125,460 less $3,764 of vacancy and credit loss is $121,696. Add $2,400 of laundry income and effective gross income is $124,096. Subtract $73,406 of operating expenses and net operating income is $50,690. Subtract $31,934 of annual debt service and cash flow before taxes is $18,756.
Notice where the mortgage enters. It enters once, at the bottom, and it enters after net operating income. Net operating income is the property's number. Cash flow before taxes is the buyer's number. Between them sits the loan, which belongs to the buyer and not to the building.
Bought with all cash there is no debt service at all, and cash flow simply equals net operating income. That is worth holding on to, because it shows what the debt service line is really doing. Debt service is the price of having used somebody else's money, and it belongs below the property's own earnings for exactly that reason.
Run the column once more with the loan turned off and watch what moves. A cash buyer at the same $500,000 price collects the same $125,460 of gross potential income, suffers the same $3,764 of vacancy loss, pays the same $73,406 of operating expenses and arrives at the same $50,690 of net operating income. Then the column stops. His cash flow is $50,690, nearly three times the financed buyer's $18,756. He also tied up $500,000 to get it instead of about $110,000. Neither buyer changed the building. They changed how much of it they paid for themselves.
Build one habit now and it will serve you for the rest of your career. Whenever somebody quotes you an income figure on an investment property, ask which line of this column it came from. Gross, effective, net and cash flow differ by tens of thousands of dollars on a building this size. An asking price justified by the wrong one is wrong by an amount you can see from across the room.
Positive cash flow means more money is coming in from the investment than is leaving it. Negative cash flow is the opposite, and a negative number on that bottom line is a warning on any pro forma. It does not always kill a deal. An investor buying for appreciation may accept it knowingly. It has to be knowingly.
NOTE: Every line of this column is tested by giving you three of the four numbers and asking for the fourth. Learn the order of operations rather than the figures. Vacancy comes out before other income goes in. Operating expenses come out before debt service. Debt service comes out last.
Four lines, in that order, every time
REMEMBER: Cover the numbers with your hand and say the four lines of the model from the top down, naming what comes out and what goes in between each pair. Which line is the property's, and which line is the buyer's?
Inside the Model: The Judgment Calls
Each line of the pro forma is an estimate you must defend
The cash flow model looks like arithmetic all the way down. Every line above net operating income is a judgment somebody made, and the arithmetic only carries out what the judgments told it to. Push the rent line up by five percent and the value of the building moves by tens of thousands of dollars. This screen is about the judgments.
Gross potential income is the total income, both cash and non-cash, received from an investment or business before any expenses are paid or losses accounted for. It is also called gross revenue. On a pro forma, gross potential income is the rent roll projected for the coming year, and the first judgment is which rent roll to project.
CONTRACT RENT AND ECONOMIC RENT
The gross income line on an owner's operating statement reflects the current rent roll. That is contract rent, what the leases actually say, what the tenants actually pay.
A potential buyer is more interested in economic rent, also called market rent. Economic rent is the rent it would be possible to charge if the rents were adjusted to appropriate market levels. Where market rent differs from contract rent, an adjustment may be made on the pro forma.
One condition controls that adjustment, and it is where careless pro formas go wrong. If the tenants have long-term leases, the pro forma should project the current rent roll. Market rent should not be used to project gross potential income if the landlord is not in a position to raise the rent. A landlord who cannot reopen a lease cannot collect market rent, and a pro forma that shows him collecting it is showing income that will not arrive.
The reverse mistake is quieter and costs the seller money. A property owner is always challenged to charge market-appropriate rents while keeping occupancy at an acceptable level. If occupancy runs consistently at ninety-five percent, the rent might be too low. A building that never has a vacancy is not necessarily a well-run building. It may be a cheap one.
Hypothetical. Seventeen units, all on leases with fourteen months to run at an average of $565. Market says $620. The difference across seventeen units is $11,220 a year of income the buyer cannot touch until the leases roll. Project the $565. Then tell the investor what the roll to $620 would be worth in year two, and say plainly that it is year two money. That is the honest version, and it is also the version that survives the first appraisal.
VACANCY AND COLLECTION LOSSES
Gross potential income assumes every space in the building is leased all year with no vacancies. It also assumes everyone is not only paying rent but paying on time. Those conditions are not attainable. Every landlord experiences some period of vacancy during the year, and occasionally some tenants fail to pay.
The cash flow model makes provision for that with an allowance for vacancy and collection losses. It is a generally accepted accounting practice that some vacancy loss is shown here, even if minor, because no property is expected to be one hundred percent occupied all the time. The allowance may be adjusted up or down based on circumstances and on perceived risk.
Three sources feed the number. Historical data from the existing operating statements. Projections based on current market conditions in the area, such as unemployment. And a market analysis of the vacancy losses at comparable properties.
The vacancy loss figures so importantly into net operating income that a conservative investor errs on the side of caution when creating a pro forma. Run the sensitivity once and you will see why. On the 100 Main Street pro forma the allowance is three percent, which is $3,764. Move it to six percent and it becomes $7,528, another $3,764 straight out of net operating income. At an eight percent cap rate that single change moves the supportable value of the building by $47,050.
A zero on the vacancy line is the loudest thing on a pro forma. It tells a lender, an appraiser, and any experienced investor that whoever prepared the sheet either does not know the practice or is selling something.
MISCELLANEOUS INCOME
Some properties generate income for their owners other than rent. The change collected from an apartment complex's coin-operated laundry. The vending machines in an office building's break room. Parking income, storage space fees, rooftop antennas. Any money earned other than rent and rent-related items should be itemized and added in as miscellaneous income.
Read the exclusion carefully. Tenant reimbursements for taxes or utilities are rent-related items. They are not miscellaneous income. A tenant who pays a share of the tax bill is paying rent under another name, and putting that money on the miscellaneous line inflates the top of the pro forma with income that is already accounted for.
RESERVE FOR REPLACEMENTS
A reserve for replacements is money a property owner sets aside regularly in anticipation of needing to fund capital improvement projects or to pay for extraordinary repairs. Roofs, boilers, parking lots, elevators. Things that do not fail every year and are ruinous in the year they do.
An investor evaluating a property for purchase should not neglect the reserve as an expense category on a pro forma. The reserve for replacements is to the pro forma what depreciation is to the operating statement. An owner does not actually pay depreciation to anybody, so there is no absolute correlation between the depreciation figure and what an investor should set aside. The depreciation figure does provide a reasonable number to use in a pro forma when evaluating an investment property.
The argument against including it is always the same and it is always wrong. Nobody writes that check this year. True. The roof still has a finite number of winters left in it, and the buyer who left the reserve off the sheet is the buyer who has to find the money in the year it goes.
FIXED EXPENSES AND VARIABLE EXPENSES
Owning and managing income-earning property costs money, and expenses divide broadly into two classes.
Fixed expenses occur on a regular basis and have regular payment amounts. Property taxes and insurance. Landscaping and other service contracts. They generally do not vary in response to changing levels of occupancy, and they occur whether the property is vacant or fully leased. An empty building still gets a tax bill.
Variable expenses are necessary to maintain the income stream of the property and to provide services to the tenants. Maintenance, repairs, advertising, utilities, pool inspections, city business licenses. Variable expenses tend to be tenant driven. They occur regularly but may vary based on occupancy levels and on amount, and they generally depend on the type, size, age and condition of the property.
The test for which class an expense falls into is a single question. Does the bill shrink when the units empty out? Heating oil for vacant units, yes. Advertising when there is nothing to advertise, yes. The property tax bill, no. The insurance premium, no. Taxes and insurance are the classic fixed expenses and they are the ones swapped on exam questions.
EFFECTIVE GROSS INCOME
Effective gross income is the estimated rental income the owner anticipates collecting, and it is what will be available to pay the expenses of owning the property. Calculate it by subtracting the allowance for vacancy and collection losses from gross potential income and adding the miscellaneous income.
EGI = GPI − Vacancy + Misc. Income
Subtract the operating expenses from effective gross income and what remains is net operating income: the annual income from a property that is left after the annual operating costs are paid. Because property has value independent of any financing an investor might obtain to acquire it, net operating income does not take into consideration any expense associated with the financing of the property. No mortgage payment. No loan interest. Not on that line.
One more reason to keep financing off that line. If net operating income included the mortgage, two buyers looking at the same building on the same day would compute two different net operating incomes, because they would be offered different loans. The number would then describe the buyer rather than the property, and it would be useless for comparing one building against another. Keeping financing out is what makes net operating income a yardstick.
Net operating income is one of the first indicators of the real worth of an investment and the most important component in valuing income-producing properties. It measures the ability of an investment property to produce an income stream from its operations. Once an investor determines net operating income, he can use it to decide how much he would be willing to pay. The next lesson does exactly that.
CAUTION: Every judgment on this screen moves net operating income, and net operating income moves the value of the building. Optimistic rent, a thin vacancy allowance, a missing reserve and a management fee left off will each make a property look better than it is. Put four of them on the same sheet and the pro forma is fiction with a letterhead.
NOTE: Two exam traps live here and both are one word wide. Tenant reimbursements for taxes and utilities are rent-related, so they are not miscellaneous income. Property taxes and insurance are fixed, not variable, because they arrive whether or not the building is occupied.
Every line is an estimate you must defend
REMEMBER: Take the last rent roll you saw. Was the rent contract rent or economic rent, and could the landlord actually raise it this year? If not, which of the two numbers belongs on the pro forma?
Lesson 3
Valuing the Investment
Cap rates, cash-on-cash, and what the numbers say to pay
The IRV Formula and Capitalization Rates
Estimating the present value of future income
An investor knows what the property earns. An investor knows what return she needs. From those two she can work out what the property is worth to her. That calculation is capitalization, and investors use the capitalization rate method to estimate the present value of future income.
The capitalization rate is essentially the rate of return an investor would expect to earn on a real estate investment. It is not guaranteed by anybody. Because it is not guaranteed, an investor expects a larger rate of return than she could get from safer investments, and the gap between the two is the price of the risk she is taking.
The calculation is called the IRV formula and it relies on three variables. Income, Rate, Value.
Cover the variable you need, what remains is the formula.
I
R
V
I is Income: the property's annual net operating income. It may be based on the income the property produced before, or on the projected income demonstrated in a pro forma. It is impossible to predict every variable, but if the property's income is fair in the marketplace it is reasonable to expect the income stream to continue into the future.
R is Rate: the capitalization rate, the amount of return the investor expects to earn from the investment. Investors decide for themselves what rate of return is acceptable. One investor may be looking for ten percent. Another would be content with eight.
V is Value: the amount an investor would be willing to pay for the property.
Read that last definition closely, because it is narrower than it looks. It is what THIS investor would pay, given the return THIS investor requires. Market value is a different idea, the theoretical price a property is most likely to bring in a typical transaction. The two land in the same neighborhood when the rate you use is the rate the market is actually using, and they part company as soon as one investor's required return is out of step with everybody else's. An investor who demands fourteen percent in a market pricing at eight will produce a value on his own worksheet that no seller in that market will accept.
Know any two of the three and you can calculate the third. Income divided by Rate gives Value. Income divided by Value gives Rate. Rate multiplied by Value gives Income. Those are the only three arrangements, and every capitalization question on the exam is one of them.
The triangle is the memory device. Income sits on top. Rate and Value sit side by side underneath. Cover the variable you are looking for and what is left shows you the operation. Cover V and you are left with I over R, so divide. Cover R and you are left with I over V, so divide. Cover I and R and V sit beside each other, so multiply.
Get the direction right before you touch the calculator. Value is income DIVIDED by rate. It is never income multiplied by rate. Multiplying a $50,690 net operating income by eight percent gives $4,055, which is not a price anybody would pay for a seventeen-unit apartment building. If your answer looks absurd, you ran the triangle backward.
SAME NOI, $50,690, THREE INVESTORS, THREE PRICES
$724,143
at a 7% cap rate
$633,625
at an 8% cap rate
$506,900
at a 10% cap rate
Work all three. Net operating income of $50,690 divided by .07 is $724,143. Divided by .08 it is $633,625. Divided by .10 it is $506,900. One building, one income stream, three prices, and the only thing that changed was what each investor demanded in return.
Look at what happened as the rate went up. The value went down, and it went down hard. Between the seven percent investor and the ten percent investor there is $217,243 of difference in what the same building is worth. The rents did not change. The expenses did not change. The required return changed.
Given the same level of net operating income, as the desired rate of return increases, the value decreases. Put the other way round, as the price of the property rises, the cap rate falls. Value and cap rate move in opposite directions, and that is called an inverse relationship. It is the single most tested idea about cap rates.
The reason is easier to feel than to memorize. A cap rate is a return demanded per dollar paid. Demand more return from the same income and you must pay fewer dollars to get it. Pay more dollars for the same income and the return you are getting per dollar has to be smaller.
Agents run the formula backward too, and this is the version you will use most. When you are working with a seller to determine an asking price, you do not start from one investor's personal goals. You look at comparable properties that have sold in the area. Where the selling price is known and the net operating income can be found, divide the income by the price and the result is a reasonable cap rate for that kind of property in that market.
Hypothetical. Three similar mixed-use buildings in the same Hudson Valley village sold in the last year. One produced $42,000 of net operating income and sold for $525,000, which is eight percent. One produced $61,000 and sold for $780,000, which is 7.8 percent. One produced $38,000 and sold for $487,000, which is 7.8 percent. The market is telling you it prices this kind of building at roughly eight percent. Apply that to your seller's $55,000 of net operating income and the indicated value is about $687,500.
Derived cap rates are only as good as the net operating incomes behind them, and that is the trap in the backward calculation. A sale price is a hard fact; it is recorded. The net operating income of a building somebody else owns is a figure you assembled from what you could find out. Assemble it loosely and the cap rate you derive is loose, and you will then apply that loose rate to your own seller's income and produce a value with two errors compounded into it.
Temper the number with three things before you say it out loud. The location of the property. The economic situation of the area. And the current prime interest rate, because the cost of money moves what investors demand from every alternative including this one.
CAUTION: Two properties with identical net operating income are not worth the same amount. The cap rate carries all the risk the income statement does not show, the neighborhood, the condition of the building, the quality of the tenants, the length of the leases. When somebody quotes you a cap rate with no property attached to it, they have told you almost nothing.
NOTE: The exam gives you a net operating income and a rate and asks for a value. Divide. It gives you a price and a net operating income and asks for a rate. Divide. The only question that multiplies is the one that hands you a value and a rate and asks for income, and it is the rarest of the three.
Value = Income ÷ Rate. Never times
REMEMBER: Take a net operating income of $60,000. What is the property worth to an investor who needs eight percent, and what is it worth to one who needs six? Which of those two investors will win the bidding, and why does that follow from the arithmetic rather than from how much either of them wants it?
Debt Service, Cash Flow, and Cash-on-Cash
What the lender takes, and what your cash actually earns
Net operating income tells you what the property earns. It does not tell you what the investor gets to keep, because the investor almost never buys with cash. Between net operating income and the investor's pocket stands the lender. This screen walks the last three steps of the cash flow model and then turns them into a percentage.
1 Start at NOI
$50,690 from the 100 Main Street pro forma. Operations only. There is no financing cost anywhere in that number, by design, because property has value independent of how a particular buyer chose to pay for it.
2 Subtract debt service
Debt service is the amount of money required for the payment of current interest and principal on a long-term debt. It has two components. The interest due on the outstanding balance, and the amortization of the balance, the regular repayment of some of the principal owed. On this purchase the annual debt service is $31,934.
That figure comes out of the terms of the loan and nothing else. A $400,000 mortgage at seven percent for thirty years carries a payment of $2,661.21 a month. Twelve of those is $31,934.52, and $31,934 is the figure the pro forma carries. Change any of the three terms and the whole bottom of the sheet moves. Same building, same rents, different loan, different investor return.
3 Before-tax cash flow
$50,690 less $31,934 leaves $18,756. That is cash flow before taxes: the gross amount of income available before considering income taxes. Cash flow is a measurement of both the income and the expense items associated with operating the property, and this is where this chapter's model stops.
Bought with cash, cash flow would equal net operating income, the whole $50,690, with nothing going to a lender. This investor gave $31,934 of it away to buy the use of $400,000 he did not have. Whether that was a good trade is the leverage question from the first lesson, asked one more time.
4 Divide by cash in
Cash-on-cash return, also called cash in on cash out, is the ratio of the income generated by the property to the cash investment in the property. Once the before-tax cash flow is determined, find it by dividing that number by the out-of-pocket cost to purchase the property.
Before-Tax Cash Flow ÷ Purchase Costs = Cash-on-Cash Return
The New York State salesperson syllabus names this the equity dividend rate and gives cash-on-cash return as the same measurement. Both names describe one thing: what the money the investor actually took out of his own pocket earned in the first year.
18.76%
cash-on-cash return
$18,756 cash flow ÷ $100,000 down payment
17.1%
the more realistic figure
$18,756 ÷ $109,800, down payment plus $9,800 of closing costs
Work both figures. The investor anticipates before-tax cash flow of $18,756. He expects to make a $100,000 down payment and take a $400,000 mortgage. Divide $18,756 by $100,000 and the cash-on-cash return is 18.76 percent.
Then count the rest of the money. When calculating the first-year cash-on-cash return, many investors include not only the down payment but all of the costs associated with purchasing the property, the nonrecurring closing costs such as appraisal fees, attorney fees, title insurance, recording fees and financing fees. This investor estimates $9,800 of them, which makes the total out-of-pocket cost to purchase the property $109,800. Divide $18,756 by $109,800 and the return is 17.1 percent.
Both numbers are correct arithmetic. Only one of them is a true picture of the first year. The second one counts every dollar that left the investor's hands, which is what cash-on-cash was invented to measure. Quote the first figure to a client without saying what it excludes and you have flattered the deal by more than a point and a half.
Keep cash-on-cash and the cap rate apart in your head. The cap rate divides net operating income by the whole value of the property and ignores financing entirely. Cash-on-cash divides after-debt cash flow by the investor's own money and is therefore about the financing as much as the building. Same property, two percentages, two different questions. On 100 Main Street the cap rate at the $500,000 purchase price is 10.1 percent and the cash-on-cash is 17.1 percent, and neither number is wrong.
That gap between the two is leverage showing up in a percentage. The property earns about ten percent on its full price. The borrowed $400,000 costs less than it earns. The surplus lands on the investor's $109,800 and lifts the return on his own money to seventeen. Turn the loan off and both numbers collapse into the same ten.
Hypothetical. Two investors buy identical buildings on the same street for $500,000, each producing $50,690 of net operating income. One puts twenty percent down and finances the rest. One pays cash. The financed buyer's cash-on-cash is about seventeen percent. The cash buyer's is $50,690 divided by $500,000 plus costs, just under ten percent. The cash buyer has no debt service, no default risk, and no lender. The financed buyer has a higher return and $400,000 of financial risk. Neither of them is doing it wrong.
Positive cash flow means more money is coming in from the investment than is leaving it. Negative cash flow is the opposite. A negative bottom line on a pro forma means the investor pays to own the building every month, and it belongs in a conversation before an offer rather than after one.
Cash-on-cash also has a blind spot you should name for a client rather than let them find. It measures one year, and it measures cash only. It says nothing about the $4,063 of principal the tenants paid down for the investor that year, nothing about appreciation, and nothing about the tax shelter. Those are three of the four things the investor came for, and none of them appear in the percentage. Cash-on-cash is a good first-year yardstick. It is not the whole return.
Before-tax cash flow is not the last line in the world. Subtract the income tax owed on the property's taxable income and what is left is after-tax cash flow. This chapter stops at the before-tax line and works out taxable income separately on the next screen, because the tax depends on the owner's own situation and not on the building.
CAUTION: Cash-on-cash return divides by the cash the investor put in, never by the purchase price. Dividing $18,756 by the full $500,000 gives 3.75 percent and makes a healthy deal look like a failure. It is the most common way this calculation is botched, and it is botched in the direction that loses your client a good property.
NOTE: Read the question for which pile of money is the denominator. Down payment alone gives one answer. Down payment plus closing costs gives a slightly lower and more realistic one. Purchase price gives an answer that is simply wrong.
Divide by the cash you put in
REMEMBER: On the last financed deal you can picture, how much money actually left the buyer's hands at closing, every dollar of it? That total is the denominator, and any return quoted on a smaller one is quoting a better deal than the buyer got.
Taxable Income, Depreciation, and Loan Interest
The tax shelter working behind the cash flow
There are two sets of books on every investment property and both of them are legitimate. One tracks cash: what came in, what went out, what is left. The other tracks taxable income: what the government counts as profit. They are not the same number, and the distance between them is where the tax advantages of owning real estate live.
Taxable income is simply the amount of income on which an investor must pay taxes. A property owner deducts any legitimate expense item from the bottom line to find it, and for investment property that includes mortgage interest as well as depreciation.
Depreciation = cost recovery
Depreciation can be thought of as the loss of value to a property over the time during which it is expected to be useful. For investment property, depreciation may be determined for tax purposes only. It is not a true reflection of the property's actual value and it is not an out-of-pocket expense. The Internal Revenue Service allows an accounting deduction that reflects the economic fact that buildings do wear out. This kind of depreciation is also called cost recovery.
Hold on to the phrase not an out-of-pocket expense. Nobody writes a depreciation check. No money moves. The deduction is still treated as a line item expense on an operating statement, and because it is subtracted from gross revenues like any other line item, earnings before taxes are reduced by the depreciated amount. A deduction that costs nothing and lowers the tax bill is the most valuable line on the statement.
IRS RECOVERY PERIODS SET BY FEDERAL TAX LAW
27½ years, residential
39 years, commercial
Federal income tax laws set the recovery periods on investment property. Residential investment property is recovered over 27½ years. Commercial property is recovered over 39 years. Those two numbers are worth committing to memory in that pairing, because every depreciation question on the exam turns on picking the right one.
A residential investment property depreciates faster in the eyes of the Internal Revenue Service than a nonresidential investment does, and a faster recovery period therefore produces a larger annual deduction. The same $400,000 of building recovered over 27½ years yields a bigger write-off each year than it would over 39.
THE ANNUAL DEDUCTION
Improvement Value ÷ Recovery Period = Annual Depreciation
Read the first term again. Improvement value. The annual depreciation is calculated by dividing the value of the improvement, not the value of the land on which the improvement sits, by the designated recovery period. Land does not wear out and land is never depreciated.
$400,000 building ÷ 27.5 years = $14,546 a year. Only the improvement is depreciated, never the $100,000 of land under it. Many investors allocate as much value to buildings as legally possible.
Work the wrong versions once so you recognize them. Depreciating the whole $500,000 over 27.5 years gives $18,182 and depreciates land, which is not allowed. Running the $400,000 building over 39 years gives $10,256 and uses the commercial period on a residential property. Running the whole $500,000 over 39 gives $12,821 and makes both mistakes at once. The correct figure on this property is the $400,000 improvement over 27½ years.
The allocation between land and building is a real decision with real money attached, and it is why many investors allocate as much value to the building as the law permits. Push value to the land and the annual deduction shrinks. Take the same $500,000 property and suppose the land is worth more than $100,000, say $150,000. The depreciable improvement drops to $350,000, and $350,000 over 27.5 years is $12,727 a year instead of $14,546. Nothing about the building changed. The deduction fell by $1,819 a year for as long as the investor owns it.
ONLY THE INTEREST DEDUCTS
When a property owner prepares an operating statement he normally includes the mortgage interest payment as a line item expense. Interest is deductible. The principal portion of the payment is not, because paying down principal is not a cost. It is the investor buying a piece of his own building back from the lender.
First year on the $400,000 mortgage at seven percent: the owner paid $31,934 in total debt service. Of that amount, $27,871 is interest and $4,063 is principal. Include only the interest portion on the operating statement, which is the more proper strategy, and no further calculation is needed to determine taxable income.
If the owner did include the entire mortgage payment as a line item expense, it becomes necessary to add the principal portion of the payments back to the bottom line in order to determine taxable income, because that part of the debt service is taxable. Expense the whole $31,934 and you must add $4,063 back. Expense only the $27,871 and there is nothing to add back.
Like depreciation, subtracting the interest paid on the mortgage reduces the earnings on which the owner's taxes are calculated, and so lowers the tax burden.
There is a second reason to know the split between interest and principal, and it has nothing to do with taxes. The $4,063 of principal paid in year one is equity build-up, one of the four things the investor came for. The tenants paid the mortgage, and $4,063 of what they paid turned into the investor's ownership of the building. It never shows up as cash and it never shows up as income. It shows up when the property is sold.
Watch how that split moves over the life of the loan. Early payments are almost all interest, so the deduction is large and the equity build-up is small. Later payments are mostly principal, so the deduction shrinks and the equity grows. The payment stays $2,661.21 a month the whole time. What changes is which column it lands in, and both columns matter to the investor for different reasons.
THE TAX SHELTER
A tax shelter is any method used to reduce taxable income, and so to reduce the amount of tax paid to a government. Property investment gives owners certain income tax advantages when the deductions, expenses, property taxes, mortgage interest, and depreciation, exceed the cash flow. That excess can in effect shelter the owner's other income from taxes.
Follow it on 100 Main Street. The property throws off $18,756 of cash the investor can spend. Now take net operating income of $50,690, subtract $27,871 of mortgage interest and $14,546 of depreciation, and the taxable income from the property is $8,273. The investor has $18,756 in hand and is taxed as though he made $8,273. The $10,483 gap is the shelter: the $14,546 depreciation deduction, which cost him nothing at all, less the $4,063 of principal he paid but cannot deduct.
That $8,273 is the number the tax is figured on. Apply the owner's own tax rate to the taxable income and the result is the income tax the property generates for the year. Subtract that tax from the before-tax cash flow of $18,756 and what remains is after-tax cash flow, the last line of the whole model and the only one that is genuinely the investor's to spend. This course does not compute it, because the rate depends entirely on the individual owner's return and not on the building, and a licensee who supplies that rate is practicing accountancy.
Keep the two ladders straight in your head, because they run side by side and they use different numbers. The cash ladder goes gross potential income, effective gross income, net operating income, before-tax cash flow, after-tax cash flow. The tax ladder starts from net operating income, takes out mortgage interest and depreciation, and arrives at taxable income. The cash ladder subtracts the whole mortgage payment. The tax ladder subtracts only the interest portion of it and adds a depreciation deduction that never cost anybody a dollar. That is precisely why the two bottom lines do not match.
Push the numbers a little further and the shelter reaches outside the building. A larger loan means more interest. A larger building means more depreciation. When the deductions climb past the property's income, the loss they create can reduce the tax on income the owner earned somewhere else entirely. That is what the phrase sheltering other income means, and it is one of the four things an investor came for.
CAUTION: Federal tax law is the one area of this chapter that changes without warning, and the rules on how much sheltered loss an owner may actually use against other income are detailed, personal, and outside a licensee's scope. Teach the mechanism. Name the recovery periods. Then send the investor to an accountant before he relies on any of it, and put that in writing.
NOTE: Three facts carry almost every depreciation question. Only the improvement depreciates, never the land. Residential investment property runs 27½ years and commercial runs 39. And depreciation is a paper deduction that reduces taxable income without reducing cash flow by a dollar.
Building only. 27½ residential, 39 commercial
REMEMBER: On a $600,000 investment property where the land is worth $150,000, what is the annual depreciation if the building is residential, and what is it if the building is commercial? Say both numbers before you move on.
Session Summary
What Chapters 19 and 20 put in your hands
This session took a building apart into numbers and put the numbers back together into a price. Run the summary as a checklist. Anything you cannot say in your own words is the screen to go back to.
Why real estate
Preservation of capital comes first. Return OF the investment is the assurance that the money put in comes back out, usually realized when the property is sold, which is why an investment is analyzed over the entire ownership period. Return ON the investment is what the capital earns while it is tied up in the property. In exchange for a lump sum today an investor expects a continuing stream of income, a tax shelter, equity built through leverage and appreciation, and a return when the property sells. Real estate competes for that capital against every other investment of similar risk.
Risk
Risk is the degree of probability that the actual rate of return will differ from the return expected when the investment was made. Expected profit is directly related to risk: low-risk investments are expected to generate low profits and high-risk investments high profits. The three named sources are space market risk, from the demand for and supply of space; capital market risk, from interest rates, the availability of capital, and the returns on alternatives; and financial risk, created by using debt. Environmental, legislative and management risk round out the list.
Liquidity and leverage
Liquidity is converting an asset to cash quickly without loss of principal. Marketability is converting it quickly at any price. Real estate may take extended periods to sell and its full value is usually not convertible to cash without some loss, which makes it one of the least liquid investments. Leverage is the effect borrowed funds have on investment returns. It is positive when the borrowed funds earn more than they cost and negative when they earn less, and the degree of financial risk rises with the amount of debt.
The cash flow model
Gross potential income less vacancy and credit loss plus miscellaneous income gives effective gross income. Effective gross income less operating expenses gives net operating income. Net operating income less annual debt service gives cash flow before taxes. The model is what turns the present owner's operating statement into the investor's pro forma, also called annual property operating data. Add the investor's own line items, adjust the owner's figures to market, omit what belongs only to the owner, salary, personal insurance, travel, car expenses, debt service and depreciation.
The judgment calls
Contract rent is what the leases say; economic or market rent is what the space could command. Project the current roll where long-term leases stop the landlord raising rent. Show some allowance for vacancy and collection loss even when the building is full, because it is generally accepted practice and it drives net operating income. Book only true non-rent income as miscellaneous, not tenant reimbursements for taxes or utilities. Never drop the reserve for replacements. Fixed expenses like taxes and insurance arrive whether or not the building is occupied; variable expenses move with the tenants.
Valuing from NOI
Net operating income is the most important component in valuing income-producing property, and it excludes every cost of financing. The IRV formula does the valuing: Income divided by Rate gives Value, Income divided by Value gives Rate, Rate times Value gives Income. Value and cap rate move inversely, with net operating income held level, a higher required return means a lower price. Cash-on-cash return, which the state syllabus also calls the equity dividend rate, is before-tax cash flow divided by the out-of-pocket cost to purchase, and the honest version of that denominator includes the closing costs and not just the down payment.
Depreciation and the shelter
Improvement value divided by the recovery period gives the annual depreciation, 27½ years for residential investment property, 39 for commercial, and land is never depreciated. Depreciation is a line item expense for tax purposes only, never out of pocket, and together with mortgage interest it reduces taxable income and can shelter the owner's other income. Only the interest portion of debt service deducts; expense the whole payment and the principal has to be added back.
The leverage arithmetic
One calculation carries every leverage question you will be asked. Take what the property earns for the year, subtract what the borrowed money costs for the year, and divide what remains by the investor's own money. Will's $150,000 rental produced $12,000. All cash, $12,000 divided by $150,000 is eight percent. Financed, with $6,000 of the rent going to the lender and $40,000 of his own money in the deal, $6,000 divided by $40,000 is fifteen percent. Same building, same rent, nearly double the return on his own funds, because he profited on the borrowed money as well as his own.
What this chapter asks of you on the job
An investor client is buying an income stream and will judge you on whether you can describe it accurately. That means asking the seller for operating statements and tax returns, and then not trusting them. It means projecting the rent the landlord can actually collect rather than the rent the market would bear. It means showing a vacancy allowance on a full building, keeping the reserve for replacements on the sheet, and keeping debt service off the net operating income line. And it means sending every tax question to an accountant, because the shelter is real and the rules around it are not yours to interpret.
The numbers that ran through the whole session
One property carried the arithmetic from the first lesson to the last. A $500,000 purchase, $100,000 down, a $400,000 mortgage at seven percent for thirty years. Gross potential income $125,460. Effective gross income $124,096. Net operating income $50,690. Annual debt service $31,934. Before-tax cash flow $18,756. Cash-on-cash 18.76 percent on the down payment, 17.1 percent counting $9,800 of closing costs. Annual depreciation $14,546 on the $400,000 improvement. If you can rebuild that column from the top, you can read any pro forma put in front of you.
NOTE: The arithmetic on the exam is the arithmetic on this screen. Order of operations in the cash flow model, Value equals Income divided by Rate, cash-on-cash over the money actually invested, and improvement value over the recovery period. Four calculations. Practice them until the order is automatic and the reading of the question is the only work left.
Follow the dollars, in order, every time
REMEMBER: Say the cash flow model from gross potential income to cash flow before taxes without looking. Then say what net operating income leaves out, and why leaving it out is the point.
YOU BE THE JUDGE · ISSUE-SPOTTING CHALLENGE
The Schenectady Shortfall
Priya, a salesperson with Electric City Realty, is helping investor Marcus evaluate a 17-unit apartment complex on Craig Street in Schenectady. She starts sensibly enough, asking the owner for his two most recent operating statements and his tax returns. Then she builds the pro forma: although every tenant is locked into a long-term lease the landlord cannot reopen, she projects the rent roll at full market rents. She types a zero on the vacancy and collection line, “the building is full and everyone pays on time”, and pads miscellaneous income with the tenants' utility reimbursements on top of the laundry money.
On the expense side, Priya copies the owner's operating statement wholesale into the pro forma, owner's salary, owner's health insurance, travel and entertainment and all. She adds Marcus's new mortgage payment as an operating expense “like any other bill,” subtracting it before the line she labels NOI. Reserve for replacements she deletes entirely: “the roof is only eight years old, and nobody actually writes that check.” When Marcus asks why property taxes and insurance appear under variable expenses, she explains that “if units sit vacant, those bills shrink with them.”
For value, Priya multiplies the NOI by Marcus's 8 percent target, “income times rate gives value.” When Marcus says he might hold out for a 10 percent return instead, she congratulates him: “a higher cap rate means the property is worth more, so offer more.” Computing his first-year return, she divides the $18,756 before-tax cash flow by the full $500,000 purchase price, frowns at the 3.75 percent, and pronounces the deal “weak on a cash-on-cash basis.”
Finally, the taxes. Priya sets up depreciation on the entire $500,000, “land, building, the whole basis”, and spreads it over 39 years, “the recovery period for investment property.” Marcus signs the offer sheet that evening, comforted by a pro forma in which nearly every number leans the wrong way.
Twelve violations are buried in that story, and one lawful act has been planted to catch you out. This one is different from the issue-spotting cases earlier in the course. Almost nothing here turns on a statute. It turns on whether Priya understands what each line of a pro forma is for, and on whether she can be trusted with an investor's money.
That is the reason to take it seriously. A licensee who mishandles a disclosure form gets caught by a broker or a Department of State investigator. A licensee who mishandles a pro forma hands a client a number that is wrong, and nobody catches it until the first real operating statement arrives a year later.
HOW TO WORK IT
Read the story once straight through without marking anything. Then read it again with a pen and mark every sentence where a number, a category or a formula is being handled, whether or not you think it is wrong yet. Almost every sentence in this case does something to the pro forma. That is the point of the exercise.
Then rebuild the pro forma yourself, from the top of the cash flow model to the bottom, and check Priya's treatment of each line as you pass it.
Start at the income lines. What rent belongs at the top of a pro forma when every tenant is locked into a lease the landlord cannot reopen? Priya made a choice there. Say out loud what the correct choice would have been and why the difference matters in dollars.
Go to the vacancy and collection line. What does generally accepted practice require on that line, even in a building that is full today and has never had a late payment? Priya put a number on it. Say what is wrong with that number as a matter of practice, not just as a matter of caution.
Go to the miscellaneous income line. Two kinds of money are being booked there. One of them belongs. One of them is rent-related income wearing a different hat. Name which is which and say the rule that separates them.
Now the expense side, which is where this pro forma really comes apart. Ask the add, adjust, omit question about every line Priya carried over from the owner's statement. Which of those lines pertain only to the present owner? She copied the statement wholesale, so the answer is a list rather than a single item.
Then find the line she put in the wrong place entirely. Something is being subtracted above the net operating income line that has no business being anywhere near it. Name it, say which line of the cash flow model it actually belongs on, and say what its misplacement does to every number below it. This one error poisons the valuation, the cash flow and the return all at once.
Then find the line she took out. An expense category that an investor evaluating a property should never neglect has been deleted, and the reason she gives for deleting it is the reason people always give. Name the category and answer her reason.
Then check her classification of expenses. She has put two items in a class they do not belong to and given a justification for it. The test is one question: does that bill shrink when the units empty out? Run her two items through that question.
Now the valuation. She states the IRV relationship out loud and states it backward. Write the correct formula down before you go on, then read her sentence again and say exactly which two operations she swapped.
Then she explains what a higher required return does to price. Say what the correct relationship is called and which direction each variable moves. If you can state the inverse relationship in one sentence, you have this one.
Then the first-year return. She uses the right numerator and the wrong denominator. Name the denominator cash-on-cash return actually calls for, name the two components of it on a real deal, and then say whether the deal she called weak is in fact weak.
Finally the depreciation. There are two separate errors in that one sentence, and they are independent of each other, fixing either one still leaves the other. Name both. Then compute what the correct annual depreciation would be on this property, given that this is a residential apartment building with $100,000 of land under it.
WORK THE DOLLARS, NOT JUST THE LABELS
Naming an error is half the exercise. Sizing it is the other half, and sizing it is what an investor would actually ask you for. Take three of Priya's lines and put numbers on them, using the figures this chapter has been carrying.
Take the rent. Seventeen units under leases the landlord cannot reopen, projected instead at full market. In this chapter's worked example the owner's actual annual rent roll was $114,720 and the market projection was $125,460. That is $10,740 a year of income the leases will not deliver, and every dollar of it flows down the column into net operating income and then into the price Marcus is being told to pay.
Take the vacancy line. A zero where practice calls for an allowance adds the whole allowance back into net operating income. On this property a three percent allowance is $3,764. At an eight percent cap rate, $3,764 of phantom net operating income supports $47,050 of phantom value. One number, typed once, moves the justified price by the cost of a car.
Take the mortgage payment placed above the net operating income line. Annual debt service on this deal is $31,934. Subtract it before the net operating income line and the figure Priya labels net operating income is $31,934 too low. Capitalize that understated figure at eight percent and the building appears to be worth $399,175 less than the same building capitalized correctly.
Then notice the directions do not all run the same way. Some of what she did makes the property look better than it is. Some of it makes the property look worse. An investor who is handed both at once, and who trusts the person who handed them over, has no way to tell which figures to believe, and a number that happens to land near the truth because two errors pulled against each other is not analysis. It is luck.
ONE ACT IN THE STORY IS CORRECT
One thing Priya does is exactly what a competent agent would do, and it sits in the first three lines of the case beside things that are wrong. Finding it is the harder half of this exercise. An accusation made too quickly is its own kind of problem for a licensee, and an agent who flags a correct act as a violation has shown a client that she cannot tell the difference either.
WHEN YOU HAVE YOUR LIST
Sort what you marked into three piles. Clearly wrong. Clearly correct. Cannot tell from these facts. The third pile teaches the most, because for every item in it you have to name the missing fact that would move it into one of the other two. A licensee who can name the missing fact is a licensee who knows what to ask the seller for.
Then argue the other side of the item you were least sure about. Build Priya's best case for it in full sentences, as though she is across the table and has a reason for everything she did. If you cannot build that argument at all, go back to the screen the rule came from, because you have memorized a phrase rather than learned a rule.
Keep one more question running underneath all of it. Where in this story does Priya stop analyzing and start selling? There is a point where she is no longer working out what the property is worth and is instead assembling a number that will make Marcus sign. Naming that moment is worth as much as naming any single arithmetic error, because it is the thing a hearing would care about.
Count the dollars at the end. Add up how far each of her errors pushed the numbers, and in which direction, and notice that they do not cancel out. A pro forma with twelve independent mistakes is not saved by the ones that happen to offset each other. It is a document nobody can rely on.
WHAT THE HONEST VERSION SOUNDS LIKE
Finish the exercise by writing the sentence Priya should have said at each of the places she went wrong. Not the rule. The sentence, in words Marcus would understand, delivered before he signs anything.
The rent one is the model for the rest of them. It is not hard to say and it does not lose the deal. The leases run to a date the landlord cannot move, so the pro forma has to project what the leases pay, and here is what the roll to market would be worth in the year after they expire. Two sentences, a truthful number, and a second number clearly labeled as future. An investor hears that and knows exactly what he is buying. An investor handed a single optimistic figure hears a promise, and a promise is what he will remember when the promise does not arrive.
The point of this case is not that Priya is dishonest. Nothing in the story says she meant to deceive anybody. Every one of her errors is the kind an agent makes by working quickly from somebody else's paperwork and never checking what each line is for. The consequence is the same either way. Marcus signed on numbers that were not true, and the person who handed them to him holds a license.
NOTE: If your answer to an issue is a rule with no facts attached, you have not spotted an issue. You have recited a rule and hoped it fit. Name the sentence first. Then name the line of the cash flow model it damages. Then name the rule.
Rebuild the pro forma line by line