The Course · Chapter 16 Beta

Chapter 16: Real Estate Taxes and Assessments

In this chapter

  • The purpose of taxation Explain why local governments tax property, and what an ad valorem tax is.
  • Who may be exempt Distinguish complete from partial exemptions, and quote buyers the true tax.
  • How property is assessed Describe the tax assessor's job, assessed value, and the assessment roll.
  • Calculating the tax Work from budget to levy to rate to a single home's tax bill, in dollars per $100.
  • Equalization Show how ORPS equalization rates spread a shared levy fairly across towns.
  • Challenging an assessment Walk an owner from the assessor to the Board of Assessment Review to SCAR or certiorari.

Lesson 1

The Purpose of Taxation

Taxes and assessments go hand in hand with land ownership

A Tax Based on Value, Raised at Home

Ad valorem property tax pays for local government and public schools

Taxes and assessments go with land ownership the way water goes with rain. Anyone who owns land in New York can expect the property to be assessed and can expect to pay tax on that assessed value. Rates vary from city to town to county, so the same house moved twenty miles carries a different bill.

Real property tax is an ad valorem tax. Ad valorem means the tax is based on the assessed value of the property. Two owners of property worth the same amount should pay the same tax. The owner of the more valuable property should pay more than the owner of the less valuable one. That single idea is the whole design, and everything else in this chapter is machinery built to carry it out.

The money pays for municipal services. Schools. Road maintenance. Police and fire protection. Sewers, libraries, parks and the rest of what a resident uses without thinking about it. A property tax bill is a bill for the place, not only for the house.

$26B+

raised in local property taxes annually

The largest single revenue source for municipal and school district services. The state collects none of it.

WHO RAISES MONEY THROUGH IT

Counties, cities, and towns

Villages

School districts

Special assessment districts

Property taxes in New York are administered locally to finance local government and public schools. The state does not collect real property tax and receives no direct benefit from it. A client who asks what the state charges in property tax is asking about a tax that does not exist. Every dollar on the bill was set by a county, a city, a town, a village, a school district or a special district, and every one of those bodies sets its own rate.

WHY TAX LAND RATHER THAN RAISE SALES OR INCOME TAX

Property tax is easy to administer, because it sits on a known and stable base. It is predictable, because a municipality can count on a steady stream of income from the time a property is assessed until it is reassessed. It holds up in a slow economy better than taxes tied to what people earn and spend. It reaches everyone, because all land is taxed whether the owner lives in the town or in another country. And it is the one identifiable local revenue source for municipalities and schools, which keeps the local government that spends the money answerable to the people who paid it.

The state syllabus adds two more reasons. Land is hard to conceal. A parcel cannot be moved offshore, renamed or left off a form the way income can. And land has a long historic relationship to wealth and to what the land produces.

The tax reaches your buyer through his monthly payment. A lender that escrows taxes collects one twelfth of the annual bill with each mortgage payment and pays the bill when it comes due. When the tax on a property rises, the escrow payment rises with it, and the buyer who budgeted around a payment quoted in March opens a letter in September telling him the payment went up. Knowing why that happens, and being able to say it in one sentence, is part of the job.

You do not have to be an expert at calculating taxes to do this job well. You do have to know the arithmetic well enough to answer a buyer honestly, and you have to know where to send a client with a question you are not qualified to answer. Two offices answer almost all of them: the municipality's tax assessor, for anything about value, exemptions and the roll, and the office of the receiver of taxes, for anything about the bill itself.

NOTE: A question that offers you an answer beginning with New York State collects is testing one fact. The state collects none of it. Counties, cities, towns, villages, school districts and special districts do.

Based on value, raised and spent locally

REMEMBER: Which taxing bodies reach the house you live in right now, and which of them sets the biggest line on the bill?

Exemptions: Complete and Partial

All real property may be taxed - land and every improvement on it

All real property may be subject to property tax. That means the land itself and every improvement on it: houses, factories, barns, stores, apartments, hotels, restaurants, office buildings. A one-room cabin and a two-hundred-acre industrial park sit on the same roll under the same rule. Nearly every owner pays.

Some owners do not, and exemptions come in two sizes. A complete exemption takes the property off the tax rolls entirely. A partial exemption reduces the taxable value the bill is calculated on, and the owner pays tax on what is left.

COMPLETE EXEMPTIONS

Schools, colleges, universities

Parks

State and federal governments

Religious organizations

Hospitals

Airports

Embassies or consulates

Indian reservations

Port authority

The use controls the exemption, not the owner's name on the deed. A property must be used for the tax-exempt purpose to be granted a complete exemption. A church that owns a storefront and rents it to a laundromat is a religious organization collecting rent from commercial property, and that land is subject to tax.

The complete exemption has a consequence later in this chapter. One of the four grounds for challenging an assessment, unlawful assessment, covers a property that is wholly exempt. A parcel that qualifies for a complete exemption and still carries a taxable assessment has been assessed unlawfully, and the owner's remedy is the grievance process every other owner uses.

A partial exemption works on the taxable value. Start with the total assessed value on the roll, subtract the exemption amount, and the remainder is the value your bill is calculated on. Some partial exemptions come off every taxing line. Some come off one line only. The exemption's reach matters as much as its size.

Hypothetical. A house carries a total assessed value of $180,000 and a partial exemption of $30,000 that applies to the county and town lines. The taxable value for county and town is $150,000. The taxable value for the school district stays at $180,000, because that exemption never touched the school line. One house, two different taxable values, one roll.

Partial exemptions are applied for at the local assessor's office, and most exemption applications are due by the taxable status date. Some renew automatically and some must be renewed every year. This chapter states the categories and their limits this way.

Partial exemption

Who qualifies, and the limits

Disabled

Local governments and school districts may grant a reduction. Requires documented evidence of disability; generally a minimum income to qualify.

Veterans

Partial exemption on a primary residence (co-ops excluded); combat service adds more. Renews automatically. General municipal taxes only, never school taxes.

Elderly (65+)

Senior Citizens' Exemption: 10% to 50% off by income level. Only towns, counties, and school districts may adopt it. Must be renewed yearly.

Farmers

In specific agricultural areas, exemption from school taxes for part or all of the acreage.

Gold Star Parents

Partial exemption for parents who have lost a child in combat.

STAR homeowners

School tax relief on every NY primary residence, condos and co-ops included. School taxes only (except NYC, Buffalo, Syracuse, Yonkers, Rochester). Enhanced STAR for income-qualified elderly.

Those percentages, income limits and program rules are set by statute and by local option, and they are revised. Treat the list above as the chapter's current statement of them and confirm any number with the assessor's office for the municipality the property sits in before you repeat it to a client.

The mechanism does not move. Veterans' relief runs against general municipal taxes. School tax relief under STAR runs against the school line. An exemption that reduces one line leaves the others alone, which is why an owner with a big exemption can still open a large bill.

Quote the true tax. The true tax is the amount that would be paid before any exemptions held by the present owner are subtracted. The seller across the table may be an eighty-year-old veteran with three exemptions stacked on one parcel. Your buyer is none of those things and may qualify for none of them. Copy the seller's net bill into a listing sheet and you have handed a buyer a number that will never be his.

CAUTION: Getting the true tax is one phone call to the assessor's office where the property sits. Skipping that call and repeating the seller's bill is how a licensee ends up explaining to a new owner why the escrow payment jumped in the first year.

Quote the tax before the seller's exemptions

REMEMBER: Pull up any listing you have looked at this week. Is the tax figure on it the true tax, or is it the number the current owner happens to pay?

Special Assessment Districts

A designated area that pays the infrastructure cost of one specific project

A special assessment district is a geographic area designated to pay the infrastructure cost of a specific project. A special assessment is the tax or levy itself: a charge against real property for an improvement. The charge falls only on the owners of the properties that will benefit from the improvement, and it often varies from parcel to parcel because not every parcel benefits equally.

That is the whole difference between a special assessment and the general property tax. General property tax funds everything the municipality does and every taxable parcel pays it. A special assessment funds one project, inside one designated district, and only the benefiting parcels pay it.

LIKELY PROJECTS

Sidewalks

Ornamental street lighting

Curbs

Driveway approaches

Traffic lights

Boulevard landscaping

The projects have a family resemblance. Each one is fixed in place, serves the block it sits on, and raises the value of the parcels around it more than it raises anything else in town. A traffic light at the corner is worth more to the twelve houses on that corner than to a family four miles away, and the assessment follows the benefit.

HOW A PROJECT BECOMES A SPECIAL ASSESSMENT

Property owners or the local government identify a possible project and follow a protocol to get it approved. Hearings are held and notices go to the owners whose property is affected. An ordinance may be adopted outlining the project's nature and benefits, what it is expected to cost, and a description of the area that will be specially assessed. The assessment is then spread among the parcels of land that will benefit.

Hypothetical. A village approves a sidewalk project costing $300,000 and draws a district containing 6,000 feet of street frontage. Spread by frontage, the charge is $300,000 divided by 6,000 feet, or $50 per foot of frontage. A lot with 80 feet of frontage carries $4,000 of it. The corner lot with 140 feet of frontage carries $7,000. Same project, same district, different shares, because the parcels do not benefit equally.

A special assessment is a tax, so it behaves like one. It is levied against the property, it is collected with the property taxes, and it attaches to the title the way the general tax does. Nobody escapes it by arguing that he never wanted the sidewalk, because the charge follows the benefit to the parcel rather than the preference of whoever happens to own the parcel this year.

For a licensee this is a disclosure problem before it is anything else. A special assessment shows up as its own line on the tax bill, it may run for years until the project is paid off, and it travels with the property to the next owner. A buyer who was quoted the general tax and never told about the sidewalk assessment learns about it from the first bill.

Find it the same way you find anything else about a tax bill. Ask the assessor's office and the receiver of taxes for the municipality the property sits in whether the parcel lies inside a special assessment district, what the annual charge is, and how many years are left on it. Read the current tax bill line by line while you are at it, because the special district lines, fire, sewer, water, lighting, sit right there under the general tax lines and are easy to read past.

NOTE: Two facts separate a special assessment from every other tax in this chapter. It funds one identified improvement. It is charged only to the parcels that benefit from that improvement. An answer choice that says all residents of the community pay it has failed both tests.

Only the benefiting parcels pay

REMEMBER: If a listing sits inside a special assessment district, where on the tax bill would you find the charge, and how many years does it have left to run?

Lesson 2

Assessing the Property

Market value, the uniform percentage, and the public roll it all lands on

The Assessor and Assessed Value

Market value is the basis; the uniform percentage turns it into an assessment

Property tax does not care what an owner earns or spends. It depends on one thing: what the property is worth. Market value, the price most people would pay for the property in its current condition, is the basis for every assessment in the state.

A tax assessor is a local government official who estimates the value of real property within a city, town or village's boundaries. That territory is the assessing unit, and the assessor's job is to value every parcel in it. An assessor works like an appraiser with a different purpose. An appraiser values one property for a sale or a loan. An assessor values all of them so the tax burden can be proportioned across every owner in the jurisdiction, each paying a fair share of the total.

Once the assessor arrives at market value, that figure is converted to the assessed value, also called the assessment. An assessment is a government's valuation of property for tax purposes, and the assessed value is the value placed on land and buildings by a city, town or county assessor for use in levying annual real estate taxes. It is a percentage of market value, and the percentage has a name: the uniform percentage, or the level of assessment.

The arithmetic is one multiplication. Market value multiplied by the uniform percentage equals the total assessed value. A property with a market value of $200,000 in a municipality with a uniform percentage of 20 percent is assessed at $40,000. If the owner has no exemptions, the taxable assessed value is $40,000 as well.

Run it backward and you have a tool you will use constantly. Assessed value divided by the uniform percentage gives you the market value the assessor used. That $40,000 assessment divided by 0.20 returns $200,000. A client who calls to say the town has assessed his house at $40,000 and he paid $200,000 for it has not been cheated. He has been assessed at the same 20 percent as his neighbors.

Change the percentage and watch the assessment move without the house moving. The same $200,000 house in a municipality that assesses at 95 percent carries an assessed value of $190,000. In a municipality that assesses at 100 percent it carries an assessed value of $200,000. Three towns, three assessments, one house.

$40,000 is the base, not the bill

The assessed value is the number the tax rate is applied to. The bill depends on the municipality's tax rate, and a town with high assessments and a low rate can produce a smaller bill than a town with low assessments and a high rate. Anyone who compares two towns by assessment alone is comparing halves of two different equations.

ASSESSING AT 100 PERCENT

The state does not require a municipality to assess at 100 percent of market value. It offers an incentive. A local assessing unit that assesses at full value is eligible to be certified by the State Board of Real Property Services as an approved assessing unit and to receive state aid for each parcel of land in the assessing unit. Approved assessing unit is a term to hold onto, because the homestead option later in this chapter is open only to those units.

New York law requires that all property within an assessing unit be assessed at the same uniform percentage of market value. New York City and Nassau County are the exception, where class assessing, assessing based on property type, is allowed.

WHERE THE ASSESSOR'S INFORMATION COMES FROM

The assessor keeps a property record for every parcel in the jurisdiction holding lot size, square footage of the structures, features such as the number of bedrooms and baths and the type of heat, and the condition of the property. Building permits for new construction and renovation are copied to the assessor. Deeds and surveys are examined to update the record of any property that has sold or changed. Data collectors make actual visits to gather and confirm details.

An owner is not obligated to let an assessor inside. Sometimes the assessor has no choice but to observe the outside and make an educated estimate about the interior, which is one reason a property record can be wrong and one reason the grievance process later in this chapter exists.

NOTE: Three numbers get confused on every exam and in every kitchen conversation. Market value is what the property would sell for. Assessed value is market value multiplied by the uniform percentage. The tax bill is assessed value run through the tax rate. Say which one you are holding before you answer anybody's question.

REMEMBER: What is the uniform percentage in the town you work in most, and what does it make the assessment on a $300,000 house there?

Reading the Assessment Roll

A public record listing the assessed value of every property in the assessing unit

An assessment roll is a public record that lists the assessed value of every property in the assessing unit. The assessor builds one every year. It is public, anyone may inspect it, and reading one is a skill that separates an agent who answers tax questions from an agent who changes the subject.

Every municipality sets dates for three milestones. The assessor completes, certifies and files a tentative assessment roll carrying the level of assessment and the proposed assessed value for each property, and any owner whose assessment or tax status changed receives a notice. The public then gets a set period to inspect the tentative roll, ending on Grievance Day, the day the local Board of Assessment Review hears complaints from owners seeking reductions. After that the assessor signs and files the final assessment roll containing the final assessments and all changes.

Those three milestones are the spine of the rest of the chapter. Every right an owner has to challenge an assessment is dated off the tentative roll, Grievance Day, or the filing of the final roll.

WHAT EACH ENTRY ON THE ROLL TELLS YOU

The SWIS code is a six-digit number the state assigns as a unique identifier for every municipality. The first two digits define the county, the second two the city or town, and the last two the village if there is one. The tax map parcel identification number, also called the Section-Block-Lot or SBL, identifies the parcel itself. That number matches the number on the tax bill and it is the number used when applying for an exemption or filing for assessment review.

The uniform percentage of market value is printed on the roll. It is the level of assessment, and a roll that says 95 percent is telling you every property in that municipality is assessed at 95 percent of market value.

Two dates are printed on the roll, and this chapter states them this way.

Valuation Date

Value is fixed as of this date, in most towns, July 1 of the prior year.

Taxable Status Date

Ownership and physical condition as of this date; most exemption applications are due by it. Most towns: March 1.

Those dates are set municipality by municipality and they change, so confirm both with the assessor for the municipality the property sits in. The mechanism behind them does not change. The valuation date fixes what the property was worth. The taxable status date fixes who owned it, what physical condition it was in, and whether an exemption application arrived in time. An owner who buys in April and files for an exemption in May has missed a taxable status date of March 1 for that roll.

Land assessment and total assessment are separate lines. Land assessment is the assessed value of the land without the improvements on it. Total assessment is land plus improvements, the whole property. By law only the total assessment may be reviewed, which is to say grieved. An owner who is convinced the land line is inflated must still challenge the total, because the total is the only line the law lets him touch.

Full market value is what a willing buyer would pay a willing seller under normal circumstances. Where the uniform percentage is 100 percent, full market value and assessed value are the same number. Everywhere else, market value multiplied by the uniform percentage gives the total assessed value.

The exemption line names the exemption and its code and shows the amount for each taxing jurisdiction. Subtract the exemption from the total assessment and the remainder is the taxable value, the number your bill is actually calculated on. A school tax relief exemption shows an amount against the school line and zero against the county and city lines, because it trims only the school taxes.

Hypothetical. A roll shows a total assessment of $190,000 and a school-only exemption of $30,000. The school taxable value is $160,000. The county taxable value and the town taxable value are both $190,000. Three taxing lines on one parcel, two different taxable values, and the tax bill applies a different rate to each line.

PROPERTY CLASS CODES

100s agricultural

200s residential

300s vacant

400s commercial

500s recreation

600s community service

700s industrial

800s public services

900s wild and forest

The code identifies the parcel's category by its range. A 210 falls within the 200 range, so a 210 is a one-family residence. The 900 range covers wild land, forested land, conservation land and public parks. The class code matters more than it looks, because misclassification is one of the four grounds for challenging an assessment later in this chapter.

The roll also carries the school district and its code, the parcel's frontal and depth dimensions, grid coordinates used for mapping, and the deed book, which is the liber and page where the deed was recorded.

On the roll's last page the assessor signs an oath that all assessments are uniform at the stated percentage of market value.

NOTE: Only the total assessment may be grieved. A complaint aimed at the land line alone is aimed at a line the law does not open for review, and the grievance goes nowhere on that ground.

REMEMBER: Pull the roll entry for your own address. What is the uniform percentage, what is the total assessment, and what market value do those two numbers imply?

Reassessment, and Its One Illegal Form

Assessments change with construction, fire, demolition and community-wide updates

Real property is assessed annually in New York. For properties to stay at a uniform percentage of current market value every year, assessments have to be reviewed and adjusted when the market moves. The assessor analyzes the market, evaluates it, and revises assessments each year to hold that percentage.

Annual reassessment does not mean your assessment changes every year. It means the assessor looks every year. In a flat market the number on the roll can sit unchanged for several rolls running.

Assessments change because of new construction, fires, additions or improvements, demolition, and periodic community-wide updates that keep the roll equitable. Those new assessments are called re-evaluations.

NEW CONSTRUCTION

A building permit is typically required to construct a new building or to renovate or alter an existing one. A copy of the submitted permit goes to the assessor, who inspects the property before the tentative assessment roll deadline to determine its status as of that date, updates the property record, evaluates the cost of the improvement, and raises the assessment accordingly.

Assessors are required to add the value of new construction that increases the value of the property. The word to hold is added. The taxable value of the rest of the property does not change; the value of the new construction is simply added to it.

New construction not fit for occupancy at the time of the annual reassessment is assessed at a value reflecting its percentage of completion as of the reassessment date. Once the construction is complete, it is assessed at full value beginning the month following completion.

Hypothetical. A spec house that will be assessed at $300,000 when it is finished is framed and roofed but unfinished on the reassessment date, and the assessor puts it at 40 percent complete. The assessment that year is $300,000 multiplied by 0.40, which is $120,000. The house is finished in September. From October it is assessed at its full $300,000.

UNDECLARED IMPROVEMENTS

Not every improvement is assessable, and a significant improvement can go undiscovered for months or years. This usually happens when the owner does no permit work and the municipality never learns the work occurred. If the improvement is discovered in the course of annual reassessment, the assessor adjusts the assessment and the new figure applies going forward. Owners are not typically responsible for the back taxes the improvement would have added.

The assessor's office may notify code enforcement that an improvement appears to have been built without a permit. In some cases fines are issued against the owner. The owner usually owes no back taxes; the code exposure is only starting.

SELECTIVE REASSESSMENT

Selective reassessment occurs when a municipality is not in the midst of a municipality-wide reassessment, yet specific parcels, portions of an assessing unit, or certain types of property are reassessed without regard to the relative uniformity of assessments within the municipality. Unless there is a planned re-evaluation, or a comprehensive plan to review the assessments of all the parcels in an assessing unit, selective reassessment is illegal. It violates the Equal Protection Clauses of the United States Constitution and the New York State Constitution.

This is where a sale comes in. The assessor is required to update the record of any property that has sold. Raising the assessment on that one parcel because it sold, outside a planned comprehensive reassessment, is reassessing a specific parcel without regard to uniformity, and that is the illegal form. A buyer who asks whether his purchase price becomes his assessment is asking a real question, and the answer turns on whether the municipality is reassessing everyone or singling out his parcel.

The benefits of annual reassessment run in the owner's favor: no surprises from equalization, stable tax rates, better communication between the local government and its taxpayers, and an equal distribution of the property tax burden.

CAUTION: The word selective carries the violation. Reassessing everybody is the job. Reassessing your parcel and leaving the block alone, with no comprehensive plan behind it, is unconstitutional.

Added value is added, not recalculated

REMEMBER: A client finished a basement without a permit four years ago and the assessor just found it. What happens to this year's assessment, what happens to the four years of back taxes, and who else may come knocking?

Lesson 3

Tax Rates, Levies & Equalization

From a town budget to one home's bill, and how the state keeps it fair between towns

From Budget to Tax Bill

The tax rate is the direct result of the tax levy

A municipality's tax rate falls out of arithmetic, and the arithmetic starts with a budget. The taxing jurisdiction develops and adopts a budget, evaluates the revenue from all sources other than property taxes such as state aid, sales tax and user fees, and subtracts those revenues from the budget. What remains is the tax levy, the formal action that imposes the tax, and the levy is the amount that has to be raised through the property tax. Before the levy goes to the community, appropriation occurs, which authorizes the expenditure of the funds and provides for the sources of the money.

The rate comes next. Take the total amount of money to be raised by the tax levy and divide it by the taxable assessed value of all taxable real property in the municipality. In New York, tax rates are expressed in dollars per hundred dollars of assessed value.

Village ABC adopts a levy of $2,000,000 and its roll carries $40,000,000 of taxable assessed value. Two million divided by forty million is 0.050. That decimal is dollars per dollar, so multiply by 100 to put it in New York form: $5 per $100 of assessed value.

Now one home's bill. Divide the home's assessed value by 100 and multiply by the rate. A home assessed at $40,000 gives $40,000 divided by 100, which is 400, multiplied by $5, which is $2,000 of tax for the year.

MILLS, HUNDREDS AND PERCENTS ARE THE SAME NUMBER

A mill is one tenth of one cent, or $0.001. One mill is one dollar of tax for every thousand dollars of assessed value, ten cents per hundred, and one tenth of one percent. Village ABC's $5 per $100 is $50 per $1,000, which is fifty mills, which is five percent. Five percent of $40,000 is $2,000, the same bill by a different road.

CAUTION: Read a $5 per $100 rate as five dollars per thousand and the arithmetic gives $200 instead of $2,000. The error is a factor of ten and it is a common mistake made with New York tax rates. New York quotes per hundred.

Change the base and watch the rate move. Hold the levy at $2,000,000 and put it against a roll of $80,000,000 instead of $40,000,000. Two million divided by eighty million is 0.025, which is $2.50 per $100, or 25 mills. The same $40,000 home now owes 400 multiplied by $2.50, which is $1,000. Double the taxable assessed value behind a fixed levy and the rate is cut in half.

Levy divided by assessed value sets the rate

REMEMBER: Work it once on paper. A levy of $3,000,000 against $60,000,000 of taxable assessed value gives what rate per $100, and what bill on a house assessed at $50,000?

The Homestead Tax Option

Approved assessing units may apply separate rates to different categories of property

The Homestead Tax Option allows approved assessing units to apply separate tax rates to two categories of property. One assessing unit, two rates, sorted by what the property is.

HOMESTEAD

Dwellings of four or fewer units

Owner-occupied mobile homes

Residential condominiums

Farms

Vacant land suitable for building

NON-HOMESTEAD

Industrial parcels

Commercial parcels

Most vacant land

The option is locally established and locally administered, and only approved assessing units may adopt it. It exists to prevent a large shift of the property tax burden onto residential property owners after reassessments occur, which is exactly what can happen when commercial values fall and residential values climb in the same year.

Here is the shift the option is built to stop. Hypothetical. A town raises a levy of $2,000,000 against a roll of $40,000,000, and residential property makes up $24,000,000 of that roll, which is 60 percent, so residential owners carry $1,200,000 of the levy. A revaluation follows in which house values have climbed and commercial values have not, and residential property now makes up $30,000,000 of the same $40,000,000 roll, which is 75 percent. Without a separate rate, residential owners now carry $1,500,000 of the same levy. The same houses, the same town budget, and $300,000 shifted onto homeowners by a reassessment.

Hypothetical. A town adopts the option and sets a homestead rate of $5 per $100 and a non-homestead rate of $8 per $100. A house assessed at $40,000 owes 400 multiplied by $5, which is $2,000. A storefront assessed at the same $40,000 owes 400 multiplied by $8, which is $3,200. Identical assessments, different categories, different bills.

Two rates, one assessing unit

REMEMBER: Which of the two categories does a three-family house fall into, and what decides which category the vacant lot beside it falls into?

Equalization: Same Assessment, Different Burden

Two towns, one school district, one levy - why an even split would be unfair

School districts, counties and fire districts cross municipal lines. When one levy has to be split between two towns, and each town assesses at its own percentage of market value, raw assessed values cannot do the splitting. Equalization is how the state makes the split fair.

The New York State Office of Real Property Services, ORPS, is obligated by law to administer an equalization program to ensure equitable property tax allocation among all the taxing jurisdictions in New York. Equalization attempts to measure the relationship of locally assessed values to a fluid real estate market. The only instance where equalization does not apply is where full-value assessments are conducted, because at 100 percent the assessed value already is the market value.

An equalization rate is the state's measure of a municipality's level of assessment. ORPS first analyzes the level of assessment published by each assessor. If that level of assessment meets appropriate standards, the assessor's figure becomes the jurisdiction's equalization rate. If ORPS cannot confirm or accept it, ORPS calculates an equalization rate from property sales instead. Once the rate for every assessing unit is set, the state can estimate the total market value of the entire taxing jurisdiction.

Town A and Town B share School District XYZ, and the district needs to raise $1,000,000 through property taxes. Both towns carry a total assessed value of $10,000,000. Splitting the levy in half looks fair and is not, because the two assessors are working at different levels of assessment.

Town A has an equalization rate of 33.33, which is one third rounded. Divide its assessed value by that rate: $10,000,000 divided by 0.3333 gives $30,000,000 of market value. Town B has an equalization rate of 50.0. Divide: $10,000,000 divided by 0.50 gives $20,000,000 of market value. Together the two towns hold $50,000,000 of market value.

Now split by market value. Town A holds $30,000,000 of the $50,000,000, which is 60 percent, so Town A carries 60 percent of the levy, or $600,000. Town B holds $20,000,000, which is 40 percent, so Town B carries $400,000. The same $10,000,000 of assessed value in each town, and a $200,000 difference in what each town owes, because one town's dollar of assessment stands behind three dollars of real property and the other's stands behind two.

The equalization rate is also a tool you can use on a single house. Assessed value divided by the equalization rate estimates market value. A house assessed at $40,000 in a town with an equalization rate of 20 implies a market value of $200,000. That is a rough figure, not an appraisal, and it is a fast sanity check on whether a client's assessment is in the neighborhood of what the property would sell for.

The rate also tells you something about the municipality at a glance. A rate near 100 means assessments are close to market value. A rate of 20 means assessments are running at about a fifth of market value, and every assessment on that roll has to be divided by 0.20 before it means anything to a buyer. When a market runs hard and assessments lag behind it, the equalization rate falls, because the same assessed dollars now stand behind more market value than they did the year before.

NOTE: Equalization changes nobody's assessment and does not touch the assessor's roll. It changes how a shared levy is divided between municipalities. A question that says the equalization rate raises or lowers an owner's assessment has the mechanism backward.

Shared levies split by market value

REMEMBER: Two towns, identical total assessed values, one school levy. Which town pays the larger share, the one assessing at 33 percent of market value or the one assessing at 50 percent?

Lesson 4

Challenges, Liens & Foreclosure

The owner's right to fight an assessment, and the government's power to collect

Four Grounds to Challenge an Assessment

Owners who believe the assessment is wrong have the right to challenge it

An owner who believes a property has been assessed incorrectly has the right to challenge the assessment. New York gives taxpayers four grounds, and a complaint has to rest on one of them.

Excessive assessment. The property's assessment exceeds its full market value, or the assessment is excessive because all or a portion of a partial exemption was denied. An owner assessed at $250,000 in a municipality that assesses at 100 percent, on a house that would sell for $200,000, has an excessive assessment worth $50,000 of assessed value.

Unequal assessment. The property is assessed at a higher percentage of its full market value than all other properties of the same class on the assessment roll. The claim here is about the ratio, not the dollar amount. Take a house worth $200,000 in a town assessing at 20 percent. The uniform percentage puts it at $40,000. If the roll carries it at $60,000, the assessor has it at 30 percent of market value while the rest of the class sits at 20 percent, and the excess is $20,000 of assessed value.

Unlawful assessment. The property is wholly exempt. Or it lies entirely outside the boundaries of the taxing unit it is listed in. Or it was assessed and entered on the roll by a person or entity without authority to make the entry. Several other technical grounds fall here too.

Misclassified assessment. The real property is misclassified. In an approved assessing unit, a residence accidentally classified as industrial property carries the industrial level of assessment, which is higher, and the owner pays for somebody's typing error until the classification is fixed.

The amount of the tax bill is not grounds for filing a grievance. The total bill depends on several factors the assessor has no control over: the budget, the levy, the rate, the school district, the special districts. The assessor merely establishes a value for the property. Challenge the value, not the bill.

Each ground asks the owner to prove a different thing. Excessive assessment asks him to prove what the property is worth, so the evidence is sale prices, an appraisal, an offering price. Unequal assessment asks him to prove what everyone else on the roll is carried at, so the evidence is other assessments and the ratios behind them. Unlawful assessment asks him to prove a fact about status or authority, not about value at all. Misclassified assessment asks him to prove what the property is. Pick the ground first and the evidence you need follows from it.

CAUTION: A bill that doubled is the most common complaint a licensee will hear and it is not a ground. Take the client back to the value. Is the assessment above full market value? Is it at a higher percentage than the rest of the class? Is it unlawful? Is it misclassified? If none of the four fits, the grievance has nothing to stand on.

Only the total assessment may be grieved, so a complaint aimed at the land line alone is aimed at the wrong line.

Challenge the value, not the bill

REMEMBER: Name the four grounds without looking. Then say which one a client uses when his neighbors are all assessed at 20 percent and he is at 30.

From Grievance Day to the Courthouse

Administrative review first, always - then 30 days to choose a judicial door

The challenge process runs in a fixed order and the order is the exam question. Administrative review comes first and it is a prerequisite to judicial review. An owner who skips it has no judicial door to walk through.

STEP ONE: MEET THE ASSESSOR

The owner meets with the assessor to voice concerns and request adjustments, and to understand the factors that went into the assessment. Most of what looks like an unfair assessment is a factual error in the property record: square footage that counts a garage as living space, a bathroom that does not exist, a condition rating set from the street. An assessor who agrees the record is wrong can fix it without a hearing.

STEP TWO: GRIEVE TO THE BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW

An owner who still disagrees files a complaint, also called a grievance, with the local Board of Assessment Review. The board hears complaints and can lower or raise assessments based on the evidence provided. The complaint must be filed on or before the Grievance Day set by the board. Only the assessment on the current tentative assessment roll may be reviewed. Separate complaints must be filed for each assessed parcel in question, in the city or town where the property is located.

Grievance Day is set locally and the date is not the same everywhere, so confirm it with the assessor's office for the municipality the property sits in. The complaint is made on the state complaint form, Form RP-524, which is attached to this screen.

An administrative review has three possible outcomes. Full denial of the claim. Full reassessment of the property. Partial reassessment of the property. Those same three outcomes apply at every stop in the process, including the judicial stops.

CAUTION: The board can raise an assessment on the evidence in front of it. An owner who walks in with a weak case and a recent appraisal showing a higher value than the roll implies has handed the board a reason to move the wrong way.

STEP THREE: THE FINAL ROLL, AND 30 DAYS

The assessor signs and files the final assessment roll. An owner still dissatisfied after administrative review may seek judicial review. Either judicial procedure, a tax certiorari proceeding in New York State Supreme Court or a Small Claims Assessment Review, must be initiated within 30 days of the filing of the final assessment roll or notice of such filing, whichever is later.

The clock starts on the roll, not on the bill. The tax bill arrives months after the final roll is filed, and an owner who waits for it has watched the 30 days run out while he waited.

TWO JUDICIAL DOORS

Small Claims Assessment Review, called SCAR, is a municipal hearing. It is an option only for owner-occupants of one-, two- or three-family residences, and for owners of vacant land not large enough to accommodate a one-, two- or three-family dwelling. The owner completes a petition for a hearing obtained from the county clerk's office. The hearing officer may determine the final assessment to be the same as or less than the original assessment, and cannot reduce it to an amount lower than what the owner claimed on the petition.

Tax certiorari is a legal action challenging an assessment, brought in New York State Supreme Court. It is the route for larger and commercial properties, and it is the only judicial route open to a commercial property owner.

Commercial property owners take assessment disagreements to the same Board of Assessment Review, using the same procedure and the same four grounds as residential owners. The difference comes after. A commercial owner may not request a SCAR and must commence a tax certiorari proceeding instead.

A taxpayer who has exhausted his options and is still dissatisfied may continue to appeal by commencing an Article 78 proceeding in New York State Supreme Court.

Failure to file complaints on time terminates the owner's right to administrative and judicial review of the current year's assessment. The whole year is gone, and the next chance is the next tentative roll. In both arenas the burden of proof rests on the taxpayer, not on the assessor. The assessment is presumed correct until the owner proves otherwise.

Lay the year out as a calendar and the process stops feeling complicated. The valuation date fixes what the property was worth. The taxable status date fixes ownership, condition and exemption applications. The assessor files the tentative roll. The public inspects it. Grievance Day closes the administrative window. The assessor files the final roll, and 30 days later the judicial window closes too. Every deadline in that list belongs to the roll, and none of them waits for the tax bill.

Your part in this has a hard edge on it. A licensee can explain how an assessment becomes a tax bill, pull comparable sales, and point a client at the assessor's office, the Board of Assessment Review and the county clerk. Choosing a proceeding for a client, filing it for him, or coaching him on how to argue it is practicing law. Explain the mechanism, hand over the data, and tell the client to seek legal representation.

NOTE: Four facts carry most of the questions on this screen. Administrative review first. Only the current tentative roll. Thirty days from the final roll's filing or notice, whichever is later. Burden of proof on the taxpayer.

Assessor, then board, then court

REMEMBER: A client calls the week his tax bill arrives, furious, having done nothing all spring. What can you tell him is still available to him this year?

Administrative Review and Judicial Review

Same three outcomes at every stop: full denial, full reassessment, partial reassessment

The two halves of the challenge process do different work, and a licensee who keeps them straight can walk a client through a spring without giving legal advice.

ADMINISTRATIVE: THE BOARD OF ASSESSMENT REVIEW

The board hears complaints and can lower or raise assessments on the evidence provided. The complaint is due on or before Grievance Day, and only the current tentative roll may be reviewed. Separate complaints go in for each assessed parcel in question. Administrative review is a prerequisite, so there is no judicial review without it.

JUDICIAL: SCAR OR TAX CERTIORARI

SCAR is a municipal hearing for owner-occupants of one-, two- and three-family residences and for owners of vacant lots too small for such a dwelling. Tax certiorari is a legal action in New York State Supreme Court and is the commercial owner's only route. Either one must be initiated within 30 days of the final roll's filing or notice of it, whichever is later. The burden of proof rests on the taxpayer in both arenas.

The possible outcomes of a SCAR are the same as those of the Board of Assessment Review: full denial, full reassessment, or partial reassessment. Nothing about going to a hearing officer expands what an owner can win.

WHAT A SCAR PETITION MAY OFFER AS EVIDENCE OF MARKET VALUE

Purchase price, if recent

Recent offering price

Professional appraisal

Recent construction cost

Insured amount

Comparable recent sales

Those six establish what the property is worth, which is the evidence an excessive assessment claim needs. An unequal assessment claim needs a second kind of evidence: assessment information and assessment ratios for comparable properties on the same roll, showing that the rest of the class is carried at a lower percentage of market value.

Hypothetical. An owner petitions claiming a market value of $200,000 in a town with a level of assessment of 20 percent. Twenty percent of $200,000 is $40,000, so the lowest assessment the hearing officer can set is $40,000. The roll carries the property at $55,000. The officer can leave it at $55,000, cut it to $40,000, or land anywhere between, and cannot go below the $40,000 the owner's own claim implies.

A taxpayer who has exhausted these options and is still dissatisfied may continue to appeal by commencing an Article 78 proceeding in New York State Supreme Court. That is the end of the road drawn in this chapter, and it is well past the point where a licensee should be doing anything but handing a client to a lawyer.

You will be asked for comparable sales by clients preparing a grievance, and providing market data is ordinary work you already do for listings. Pull the comparables, print them, give them to the client, and let him or his attorney decide what to do with them. Preparing a valuation and calling it an appraisal is a different activity under a different license, and the petition form lists a professional appraisal as its own kind of evidence.

CAUTION: The number an owner writes on the petition is a floor under his own case. Claim a market value higher than the property is worth and the owner has capped his own relief before the hearing starts.

The petition sets the floor, not the ceiling

REMEMBER: Which of the six kinds of evidence would you be able to produce for your own home this afternoon, and which would take a week?

Tax Liens and Tax Foreclosure

Real estate is fixed and ownership is hard to hide, so taxes attach to the title

Local governments impose taxes on real estate to fund their services and programs, and they expect to collect on those taxes. Real estate is permanently fixed. Ownership is nearly impossible to hide. A government that taxes land knows where the land is and knows it will still be there next year.

Taxes are liens on property titles. A lien is a nonpossessory interest in property giving the lienholder the right to foreclose if the owner does not pay a debt owed to the lienholder. The owner keeps possession and keeps title. The lienholder holds a claim against that title and a right to force a sale.

To be enforceable, the taxes creating the lien must be legitimate, which requires three things. Properly levied. Used for legal purposes. Equitably applied to all landowners. The uniform percentage, the equalization program and the grievance process earlier in this chapter all exist to satisfy that third requirement.

FIRST IN THE PRIORITY OF LIENS, ALWAYS

Property tax liens always have higher priority than other previously recorded liens. First in time, first in line is the general rule for liens, and the property tax lien is the exception that jumps the whole queue no matter when it arose. A mortgage recorded ten years ago sits behind a tax lien that arose last year.

That single rule explains escrow accounts. A lender that lets property taxes go unpaid watches a lien it did not create climb in front of its mortgage. Collecting taxes monthly and paying them for the borrower keeps the lender in first position, which is the position it lent money on.

IN REM TAX FORECLOSURE

When an owner defaults on property tax payments, the taxing authority may foreclose. Tax foreclosures resemble mortgage foreclosures, and many of them are in rem. An in rem action is a lawsuit or legal action directed toward the property rather than toward a particular person. These are considered specific liens, and an in rem foreclosure is binding on all persons who claim title to the property.

Read that last sentence twice, because it is the one clients get wrong. An owner who was never named personally in the papers is still bound by the judgment, because the case was brought against the parcel and everyone who claims title to that parcel comes along with it.

In a property tax foreclosure the municipality is the lienholder that goes to court and subsequently takes title to the property for which taxes are delinquent. The municipality may keep the property or dispose of it by sale.

WHERE THE TAX SALE MONEY GOES, IN ORDER

A tax sale is comparable to a sheriff's sale, which is what happens when a mortgagor defaults on a mortgage loan. After notice has been published, a tax collector conducts the sale and the property goes to the highest bidder at or in excess of the minimum bid. The proceeds are then applied in a fixed order. Back property taxes first. Then the costs of the foreclosure, such as appraisers, transfer tax and the auctioneer. Then the lienholders in priority order. Any surplus funds go to the debtor.

Hypothetical. A parcel sells at a tax sale for $85,000. Back property taxes of $12,000 come off first, leaving $73,000. Foreclosure costs of $8,000 come off next, leaving $65,000. A recorded mortgage of $50,000 is paid in its priority position, leaving $15,000. That $15,000 surplus goes to the debtor, the former owner.

Once the property has been sold, the delinquent taxpayer is usually free of any personal liability for the unpaid taxes. The debt was collected out of the land.

Unpaid taxes turn up in your work long before any of this happens. They surface in the title search on the way to a closing, and they have to be satisfied before a seller can deliver clear title, which usually means they come off the seller's proceeds at the closing table. A listing with years of delinquency behind it is a listing with a deadline attached, because the municipality's remedy does not sit still while a property takes six months to sell.

Buying at a tax sale is a different business from buying a listing, and it is worth knowing enough to answer a client who asks. The bidder is buying whatever the foreclosure produced, at a sale set by the municipality, with a minimum bid the municipality sets, after notice that was published rather than mailed to him. The next screen adds the fact that matters most to that bidder: the former owner may still have a right to pull the property back.

NOTE: Two facts on this screen decide most questions. Tax liens outrank previously recorded liens, always. In rem foreclosure binds everyone who claims title, named or not.

The tax lien goes to the front of the line

REMEMBER: A buyer asks why his lender insists on escrowing taxes when he would rather pay them himself in December. What is the one-sentence answer?

Two Rights of Redemption

A delinquent taxpayer can pull the property back, before the sale or after it

A delinquent taxpayer gets two chances to save the property, and the two are told apart by one thing: whether the tax sale has happened yet.

The equitable right of redemption is exercised before the tax sale. The taxpayer pays the delinquent taxes plus interest, along with any penalties associated with the delinquency, and the property never reaches the auction block.

The statutory right of redemption is granted by New York State law after a tax sale. The taxpayer pays the amount owed at the tax sale along with interest and penalties, and the property comes back.

Each county establishes its own allowable period of redemption

That redemption period is set county by county and the lengths change, so confirm the period with the county where the property sits rather than carrying a number from one county to another.

Hypothetical. An owner owes $9,000 in delinquent taxes, $1,200 of accrued interest and $600 in penalties. Redeeming before the sale costs him $9,000 plus $1,200 plus $600, which is $10,800. Redemption is never a partial payment or a payment plan. It is everything owed, in full, inside the window.

No matter how the property is redeemed, once it has been sold the delinquent taxpayer is usually free of any personal liability for the unpaid taxes.

The statutory right is the one that reaches a buyer. Property bought at a tax sale can still be redeemed by the former owner while the county's redemption period runs, which means the purchaser holds something less settled than the title he would get from an ordinary closing. A client who asks you about the bargain he saw at a county auction needs to hear that the redemption period exists, needs to be told to ask the county how long it runs, and needs a lawyer before he bids.

NOTE: Equitable comes before the sale. Statutory is the one the statute grants afterward. A fact pattern that gives you a date will always tell you which side of the sale you are standing on, so find the sale date first and the answer follows.

Before the sale, or after it

REMEMBER: A client says he can pay half now and half in sixty days to save the house. What do you tell him redemption actually requires?

What to Carry Out of This Chapter

Six ideas, and the arithmetic under each one

AD VALOREM, RAISED LOCALLY

Real property tax is based on assessed value, so the owner of more valuable property pays more. Counties, cities, towns, villages, school districts and special assessment districts raise it. The state does not. It funds schools, road maintenance, police and fire protection and the rest of municipal service. Your job is not to be an expert. Your job is to answer honestly and to send a client to the assessor's office and the receiver of taxes when the question passes what you know.

EXEMPTIONS

Complete exemptions go to schools and colleges, parks, state and federal governments, religious organizations, hospitals, airports, embassies and consulates, Indian reservations and the port authority, and only while the property is used for the exempt purpose. Partial exemptions reach persons with disabilities, veterans, the elderly, farmers, Gold Star parents and homeowners under STAR. A partial exemption reduces taxable value on the lines it reaches and leaves the rest alone. Quote the true tax, the amount before the present owner's exemptions, because your buyer may qualify for none of them.

ASSESSMENT

The assessor values every parcel in the assessing unit and converts market value to assessed value with the uniform percentage. Market value multiplied by the uniform percentage equals the total assessed value: $200,000 at 20 percent is $40,000. Divide back the other way to recover market value. It all lands on an annual public assessment roll with a tentative version, a Grievance Day and a final version. Only the total assessment may be grieved. Reassessment is annual, new construction is added rather than recalculated, and selective reassessment violates the Equal Protection Clauses of the federal and state constitutions.

RATES AND LEVIES

Budget minus all other revenue equals the tax levy. Levy divided by total taxable assessed value equals the tax rate, expressed in New York as dollars per hundred dollars. A $2,000,000 levy against $40,000,000 of assessed value gives $5 per $100, and a home assessed at $40,000 owes 400 multiplied by $5, which is $2,000. Fifty mills, five percent and five dollars per hundred are the same rate said three ways, and misreading per hundred as per thousand is an error of a factor of ten. Approved assessing units may adopt the Homestead Tax Option and run separate homestead and non-homestead rates.

EQUALIZATION

ORPS measures each municipality's level of assessment and publishes it as an equalization rate, so a levy shared across municipal lines splits by true market value rather than by raw assessed value. Assessed value divided by the equalization rate estimates market value: $10,000,000 at a rate of 33.33 implies $30,000,000. Equalization does not apply where full-value assessment is already in place.

CHALLENGES, LIENS AND REDEMPTION

Four grounds: excessive, unequal, unlawful, misclassified. The amount of the bill is not one of them. Meet the assessor, then grieve to the Board of Assessment Review on or before Grievance Day on the current tentative roll, then file a SCAR or a tax certiorari within 30 days of the final roll's filing or notice, whichever is later. SCAR is for owner-occupants of one- to three-family homes; certiorari is the commercial owner's only judicial route; Article 78 is the appeal. The burden of proof is on the taxpayer throughout. Tax liens outrank every previously recorded lien, in rem foreclosure binds everyone who claims title, and redemption is equitable before the sale and statutory after it.

THE FIVE CALCULATIONS

Five lines of arithmetic carry this entire chapter, and you should be able to write them from memory. Market value multiplied by the uniform percentage equals assessed value. Assessed value divided by the uniform percentage, or by the equalization rate, returns market value. Budget minus other revenue equals the levy. Levy divided by total taxable assessed value equals the tax rate. Assessed value divided by 100, multiplied by the rate, equals the tax owed for the year. Everything else in this chapter is a rule about who does what and when.

WHAT A CLIENT WILL ACTUALLY ASK YOU

The questions come in three shapes. What are the taxes on this house, which is answered with the true tax and a phone number for the assessor. Why did my bill go up, which is answered by separating the assessment from the rate and finding out which of the two moved. And can I fight this, which is answered by the four grounds, the calendar, and a referral to a lawyer. Learn the arithmetic well enough that none of those three conversations makes you change the subject.

REMEMBER: Six ideas, and each one has a number attached to it. Which of the six numbers could you not reproduce right now without looking back?

YOU BE THE JUDGE

The Maple Hollow Miscalculation

Vera, a salesperson at Maple Hollow Realty, preps a CMA for buyers eyeing a colonial owned by an 82-year-old widow. She copies the owner's current tax bill, net of the Senior Citizens' and Enhanced STAR exemptions, straight into the flyer as “what you'll pay.” Showing a condo two streets over, she assures that buyer that Basic STAR will shave his county and town bills along with the school levy.

Working numbers on a $200,000 listing in a town that assesses at 20% of market value, Vera warns the buyers to “budget about $40,000 a year in property taxes.” When they gasp, she “corrects” herself with the town's $5 tax rate, “five dollars per thousand, so call it $200 a year.” Two clients in the same school district ask why their towns' bills differ when each town carries an identical $10 million total assessment; Vera says the district's levy “has to split fifty-fifty, assessed value is assessed value.” Only her aside about the half-framed spec house down the road, that this year it will be assessed at just its percentage of completion, and at full value beginning the month after it's finished, goes unchallenged.

A past client opens his assessment notice and finds his tax bill has doubled. “A doubled bill is automatic grounds for a grievance,” Vera tells him. She coaches him to attack the land-assessment line, “since that's where they padded it,” to skip the Board of Assessment Review, “a rubber stamp”, and file directly for a Small Claims Assessment Review, and to have his cousin do exactly the same for the cousin's strip mall.

When the final assessment roll is filed on July 1, Vera tells the client to relax about court papers: “the clock doesn't start until your first tax bill arrives.” That fall she reassures a buyer inside a new sidewalk special-assessment district that the levy “gets spread over every taxpayer in town, so your share is pennies.” And when the widow from the first showing confides that her own taxes have gone unpaid and the county has begun an in rem proceeding, Vera waves it off: “They never named you in the lawsuit, a case against the property can't bind you.”

Twelve violations are buried in that story, and one lawful act has been planted among them to catch you out. Work it the way you would work a file for a client rather than the way you would take a test.

Read it once straight through without marking anything. Read it a second time with a pen and mark every sentence that made you pause, without deciding yet whether it is wrong. Then go back through this chapter and name the rule each marked sentence touches. A sentence you cannot tie to a rule is a sentence you have not finished with.

THIS CHAPTER'S ISSUES ARE MOSTLY ARITHMETIC

Most of what Vera gets wrong here is a number, and numbers can be checked. Do the checking. Every figure she gives a client can be run in one line on the back of an envelope, and the envelope will tell you whether she is right before any rule does.

Run the assessment conversion yourself. Market value multiplied by the uniform percentage equals assessed value. Put the listing price and the town's percentage into that sentence and see what comes out, then compare it to the number Vera tells the buyers to budget. Ask what the number she quoted actually is, and which of the three values in this chapter it belongs to.

Run the rate conversion yourself. New York expresses tax rates in dollars per hundred dollars of assessed value. Take the assessed value you just calculated, divide it by 100, multiply by the rate she names, and write down the answer. Then take the same assessed value and divide it by 1,000 instead, multiply by the same rate, and write that answer down too. The gap between your two answers is the size of Vera's per-thousand mistake, and it is the same gap that separates dollars per hundred from mills.

Run the equalization split yourself. Two towns, identical total assessed values, one school levy. Give each town a different level of assessment, convert each town's assessed value to market value by dividing by its equalization rate, add the two market values, and take each town's share of that total. If your two shares are not equal, Vera's fifty-fifty is not equal either, and you can say precisely why in numbers rather than in adjectives.

The first paragraph is not arithmetic at all. It is about what a licensee tells a buyer a property will cost him, and about which lines of a tax bill a given exemption reaches. Take those two sentences to the exemption screen and ask, for each one, whose exemption it is and which taxing line it touches. Then ask what number should have gone on that flyer.

THE PROCESS ISSUES

The second half of the story is about sequence and standing. Sequence: what has to happen before what, which roll is open for review, which line on the roll may be challenged, and what date the clock starts running from. Standing: who is allowed to use which door. For each of Vera's procedural statements, ask two questions. Is this step available at all? Is it available to this particular owner with this particular property?

Pay attention to what kind of property each client owns. One of the people she advises does not own a house. That fact alone closes a door she sends him through, and it opens a different one she never mentions.

Pay attention to dates. There is a sentence in the last paragraph about when a clock starts. Find the event the 30 days actually runs from, then decide what happens to the client who follows her advice and waits.

The sidewalk district in the last paragraph is a two-word problem. Find the sentence in the special assessment screen that says who pays a special assessment, hold it beside what Vera tells that buyer, and the error names itself. Then say what the buyer's actual exposure depends on, since the charge is not the same for every parcel in the district either.

The widow's situation at the end is the one with real money on it. An owner behind on taxes, a county proceeding already started, and a licensee telling her it cannot touch her. Go to the tax lien screen, find the sentence about who an in rem judgment binds, and work out what she should have been told to do and how much time she may still have. Two screens in this chapter answer that, and the second one has two answers in it depending on whether a sale has already happened.

Work your marked sentences into three piles. Clearly wrong. Clearly lawful. Cannot tell from these facts. The third pile is the one that teaches, because for every item in it you have to name the missing fact that would move it into one of the other two piles. Naming the missing fact is most of what a working licensee does with a tax question.

Write each answer in three parts and your work will hold up in front of anyone. The fact, quoted from the story. The rule, named from this chapter. The correct advice, in the words you would have used with that client standing in front of you. An issue you can only half answer will show you which of the three parts you are missing, and that is the part to go study.

One sentence in the story describes something Vera got right, and it sits directly beside sentences that are wrong. Finding it matters as much as finding the errors, because a licensee who calls everything a violation is as unreliable as one who calls nothing a violation. Check it against the reassessment screen and be able to say which rule makes it correct.

Then argue the other side of the item you were least sure about. Say it in full sentences, out loud, as though Vera is across the table with a reason for everything. If you cannot build that argument at all, go back to the screen the rule came from, because you have memorized a phrase rather than learned a rule.

Watch for the moment Vera stops answering a real estate question and starts giving advice she is not qualified to give. Explaining how an assessment becomes a tax bill is your job. Telling a client which proceeding to file, and coaching him on how to argue it, is a lawyer's job, and the line between the two is crossed somewhere in the third paragraph.

NOTE: If your answer to an issue is a rule with no facts attached, you have not spotted an issue. You have recited a rule and hoped it fit. Name the fact first, then name the rule it breaks, then say what the client would have been told by a licensee who knew the arithmetic.

Name the fact, then name the rule

REMEMBER: Which of Vera's twelve errors would have cost a client the most money, and which one would have cost him an entire year of review rights?

Check yourself

11 questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see whether it is right and why.

Key terms

Ad valorem tax
A tax based on the assessed value of property; the basis of New York's locally administered real property tax.
STAR
School Tax Relief exemption on every New York primary residence; Enhanced STAR for income-qualified seniors.
Special assessment
A levy for a specific local improvement charged only to the parcels that benefit from it.
Uniform percentage (level of assessment)
The single percentage of market value at which all property in an assessing unit is assessed.
Assessment roll
The public record listing every parcel's assessed value, exemptions and taxable value; the tentative roll is grievable, the final roll starts the judicial clock.
Taxable status date
The date (March 1 in most towns) as of which ownership, condition and exemption eligibility are fixed for the roll.
Tax levy
The amount a taxing jurisdiction must raise from property taxes: adopted budget minus all other revenue.
Homestead tax option
A program letting approved assessing units apply separate tax rates to residential (homestead) and non-homestead property.
Equalization rate
The state's measure of a municipality's level of assessment, used so shared levies are split by true market value.
Grievance Day
The deadline for filing an assessment complaint with the Board of Assessment Review.
Small Claims Assessment Review (SCAR)
A municipal hearing available to owner-occupants of one-to-three family homes to challenge an assessment after administrative review.
In rem foreclosure
A tax foreclosure directed at the property rather than a person, binding on all who claim title.
Statutory right of redemption
The right under New York law to recover property after a tax sale by paying the amount owed plus interest and penalties within the county's period.

Practise this chapter

Flashcards (free) Practice exam

Read Chapter 16 in the Book

The Book comes with the Salesperson pass ($39 for 3 months).

A study course, in beta. This is not a New York State Department of State approved qualifying course, and the time you spend here does not count toward the 77 hours you need for a salesperson license. Take the 77-hour course at a DOS-approved school; use this to learn the material and to review it. · Powered by License to Earn LLC