Lesson 1
The Structure of Local Government
Counties, cities, towns, and villages, and where their power to govern comes from
New York's Administrative Divisions
Municipal Home Rule Law - every parcel sits inside this structure
Every parcel of land in New York sits inside a stack of governments, and each layer runs offices that can tell your client yes or no. Learn the stack first. Knowing which office to walk into starts with knowing which governments reach the parcel.
The power to govern locally comes from the top. The New York State Constitution grants counties, cities, towns and villages the power to enact laws and regulate the quality of life in their jurisdictions. The Municipal Home Rule Law sets out the scope of that power and declares that a local law has the same status as an act of the State Assembly, as long as it is consistent with the State Constitution and state law.
The county is the primary administrative division and is a regional form of government. Every county has a county seat, often a populous or centrally located city or village, where the county government sits. Some counties have an executive such as a county administrator, and others have only a legislative body, which may be called a board of supervisors, a board of representatives or a county legislature. Counties run their own courts with their own judges and prosecutors, and provide police and social services to areas not delegated to a more specific division.
A city is a self-governing incorporated area with broad authority to provide services and to tax its residents. Cities are established by an act of the state legislature and are organized and governed by their own unique charters. Most New York cities have a mayor and a city council, and larger cities also have municipal courts.
A town is the major division of each county. A town contains all the unincorporated area of the county and may contain villages inside its borders. Everyone in New York who does not live in a city or on an Indian reservation lives in a town. Towns provide most services to residents of unincorporated areas and often some services to village residents as well.
A village is an incorporated area, usually inside one town, though a village can overlap several town or even county borders. A village provides local services such as garbage collection and street maintenance, and some villages have police and fire protection. Generally a village is no more than five square miles and must have at least 500 residents.
A hamlet is an unincorporated settlement served by the town it sits in. It has a name and often a post office, and it has no government of its own. The town is its government. A borough is an administrative division found only in New York City, the result of the towns, villages and cities in a county merging into one entity.
Put the stack to work on a listing. A house in a village sits inside the village, a town and a county, and all three reach it. Before you promise a client anything about taxes, permits or zoning, name the governments that reach that parcel.
NOTE: The exam likes the word unincorporated. Unincorporated area is town area. The town provides the services there and the town board makes the law there. A hamlet is a place name sitting on top of a town.
Unincorporated land is still town land
REMEMBER: Name the governments that reach the house you live in right now. How many offices could tell your neighbor no?
The Local Legislatures
Elected bodies that adopt the laws, the budget and the tax rate
Three bodies write local law for New York's cities, towns and villages. A city has a city council. A town has a town board. A village has a village board of trustees. All three are made up of elected officials whose purpose is to serve the constituents who elected them, and most of the boards and offices in the rest of this chapter answer to one of them.
A city council is the city's legislative body. City councils set policies, approve budgets, and pass ordinances and resolutions affecting everything from land use to campaign finance, and they usually partner with the mayor in governing the city. Council members are elected by the constituents of the districts they serve.
Under New York State Town Law a town board governs each town. A town board holds both executive and legislative authority. It is the legislative, appropriating, governing and policy-determining body of the town, which means it makes the law and also runs the place.
A town has officers as well as a board: a supervisor, council members, a town clerk, an assessor, a receiver of taxes and assessments, and town justices. Two of those come back later in this chapter, because the assessor and the receiver of taxes are the offices your clients ask about most. The clerk is where the municipality's papers land.
A village board of trustees governs the village. It usually includes a mayor, village administrator or town supervisor along with several trustees, and the number of trustees depends on the size of the village. Trustees are responsible for the village's budget, programming, land use regulations and services, and a board of trustees passes laws, ordinances and resolutions the same way a city council does.
Three jobs belong to the legislature. It adopts the zoning ordinance and rezones districts, which chapter 8 covers in full. It adopts the annual budget and sets the tax rate from it. And it keeps the lawmaking. The boards further down this chapter are appointed, and they hear, review and recommend, but none of them passes a law.
NOTE: Elected or appointed is a favorite exam line. The city council, the town board and the village board of trustees are elected. The planning board, the zoning board of appeals, the architectural review board and the conservation advisory council are appointed. The assessor may be either.
Legislatures are elected; boards are appointed
REMEMBER: Your client wants the zoning on his block changed. Which kind of body on this screen can do it, and which kind cannot?
How a Bill Becomes a Local Law
The New York City Council - the model every local legislature follows in some form
A client who wants the law itself changed is asking for this process. A rezoning, a new sign ordinance, a change to a permit requirement: none of it happens at a counter. Knowing the steps tells you how long a client waits and where he can be heard.
A council member files a bill, which is simply proposed legislation, with the council speaker's office. The bill is introduced into the council during a stated meeting and referred to the appropriate committee. One or more public committee hearings may be held on it. The bill may be amended after public testimony and committee debate, and the committee then votes on the final version.
If the committee passes the bill it goes to the full council for more debate and a final vote. If at least 26 of the 51 members vote yes, the bill is sent to the mayor, who also holds a public hearing on it. The mayor then signs the bill or vetoes it.
If the mayor signs, the bill immediately becomes a local law and is entered into New York City's Charter of Administrative Code. If the mayor does not sign and does not veto within 30 days of receiving the bill from the council, it is automatically approved.
If the mayor vetoes, he must return the bill to the city clerk along with his objections by the next scheduled stated meeting. The council then has 30 days to override the veto. If the council re-passes the bill by a two-thirds vote, at least 34 of the 51 members voting yes, the bill is adopted and becomes a local law.
Notice where the public gets in. There is a committee hearing before the bill is ever voted on, and a second hearing at the mayor's office after the council has passed it. A client who cares about a proposed local law has two places to say so, and both are on a calendar anyone can read.
There may be slight differences to this process in other municipalities, but every local legislature in New York adopts its laws through some version of these same steps: introduction, committee, hearing, vote, executive signature.
NOTE: Three numbers carry this screen and the exam uses all three. 26 of 51 to pass. 34 of 51 to override. 30 days twice, once for the mayor to act and once for the council to override. A veto is a step in the process rather than the end of it.
26 to pass, 34 to override
REMEMBER: The mayor vetoes a bill your investor was counting on. What do you tell her happens next, and how long does she wait?
Lesson 2
Taxes and Assessments
Two different numbers, determined by two different entities
The Real Property Tax
Administered locally, never by the state
In New York the real property tax is a tax based on the assessed value of real property. Cities, counties, villages, towns, school districts and special districts all raise money through it, and for most of them it is one of the largest sources of income they have. Because municipalities and school districts are the ones collecting it, property taxes and assessments are administered locally rather than by the state.
The money funds schools, pays for police and fire protection, maintains roads, and pays for the other services residents enjoy without thinking about them. A property tax bill is a bill for the place as much as for the house, which is why two identical houses twenty miles apart carry different numbers.
FROM BUDGET TO TAX RATE
Property tax rates are determined by tax levies, and settling on a levy starts with a budget. The local entity creates and adopts its budget for the year. It then establishes where every source of revenue other than property taxes comes from. Those revenues are subtracted from the budget, and the remainder becomes the tax levy, the amount that has to be raised through real property taxes.
The rate comes out of one division. Each board divides the total taxes it needs to raise by the total taxable assessed value of its jurisdiction. That gives the tax rate. An individual owner's share of the tax is the tax rate multiplied by the property's assessed value, minus exemptions.
Whether a city, town or village is governed by a city council or a board of trustees, and whether it has a mayor or an administrator, that local governing body is the one responsible for determining property tax rates from its annual budget. School boards and county legislatures do the same for their own levies. That is why a single parcel carries several lines on one bill, and why a client who asks why his taxes went up may have to be told that it was the school district rather than the town.
Chapter 16 takes the arithmetic apart in detail: how rates are expressed, how exemptions reduce a bill, how the state equalizes between municipalities, and what happens when taxes go unpaid. This screen is about which body does it. The board sets the levy and the rate, and no state agency sets either one.
NOTE: An answer choice that starts with New York State collects or the state sets the rate is wrong on its face. Counties, cities, towns, villages, school districts and special districts raise and spend this tax. The state is not in the chain.
The board sets the rate from its budget
REMEMBER: Say the four steps from budget to tax rate out loud. Which step is the levy, and what gets divided into what?
Two Offices at Town Hall
The assessor sets the value. The receiver of taxes collects the bill.
Property taxes and property assessments are two different numbers determined by two different entities, and they sit in two different offices. Property taxes are set by boards: school boards, town boards, village boards and county legislatures. Each board determines the total amount of taxes it needs to raise and divides that total by the total taxable assessed value of the jurisdiction to arrive at the tax rate. Assessors, not municipal legislators, figure a property's assessed value.
A property's assessment is a percentage of its market value. Market value is how much a property would sell for under normal market conditions, and assessments should be based on it. Assessors estimate value in several ways, from the sale prices of similar properties or from the depreciated cost of the materials and labor required to replace the building.
Tax assessors are elected or appointed local officials who independently estimate the value of real property. Assessing units follow county, city, town or village boundaries, so the assessor who values your listing is the assessor for the municipality the parcel sits in, and a neighboring town's assessor has nothing to do with it.
The tax assessor's office is where a client goes with any question about value. The office determines assessed value, processes exemption applications, keeps a close watch on the local real estate market, and monitors improvements to properties for reassessment. It keeps records of the location of parcels, property ownership, tax information, sales information, tax maps and exemptions. Those records are a working tool for a licensee.
Every parcel of real property in an assessing unit is assessed, no matter how big or how small. Assessed and taxed are different things. Property owned by a church or a temple, or by the government, may be totally exempt from property taxes, and veterans may receive partial exemptions. The parcel still appears on the roll with a value on it; the exemption operates on the tax, and the application for a partial exemption is filed at the assessor's office.
The tax departments of New York municipalities are called the office of receiver of taxes, and the elected official who runs that office is the receiver of taxes. The office collects taxes, disburses funds, keeps tax records and handles other accounting functions. It is strictly an administrative office rather than a policymaking one. It does not set tax rates. It collects them.
Two offices, two kinds of question. Anything about what a property is worth, what it is assessed at, what exemption might apply, or what the record says goes to the assessor. Anything about the bill itself belongs to the receiver of taxes. Chapter 16 goes deeper into how the assessor arrives at the number and what the assessment roll looks like.
CAUTION: Nobody negotiates a tax rate at either counter. The receiver of taxes has no power to change a rate, and the assessor has no power to set one. A client who walks in asking for a lower rate is in the wrong building, and the licensee who took him there looks like he has never done this before.
Assessor for the value; receiver for the bill
REMEMBER: A buyer calls about a veterans' exemption and a neighbor calls about a missing payment. Which office gets which call?
Challenging an Assessment
Four grounds, three steps, three outcomes
Sometimes an assessment has to be challenged, and there are four grounds for it. Excessive, meaning the assessment exceeds the property's market value. Unequal, meaning it is out of line relative to other similar properties. Unlawful, meaning the assessment is contrary to law. Misclassified, meaning the property has been placed in the wrong class.
The steps run in order and the order matters. First, meet with the assessor to voice concerns and request adjustments. Second, file a complaint with the local Board of Assessment Review on or before the day the board meets to hear complaints. Third, seek judicial review, either by commencing a tax certiorari proceeding in New York State Supreme Court or by filing a Small Claims Assessment Review, known as SCAR.
Three outcomes are possible at the end of it. Full denial, full reassessment, or partial reassessment. Chapter 16 works through the grievance in detail, including the complaint form attached to this screen, the dates the clock runs from, and which owners may use SCAR.
NOTE: The order is what gets tested. An owner who files in Supreme Court without ever meeting the assessor or filing with the Board of Assessment Review has skipped the administrative review the law expects first. Advising a client to go straight to court is the wrong answer on the exam and expensive advice in practice.
Assessor, then the board, then the court
REMEMBER: Name the four grounds without looking. Then name the three steps in the order the law expects them.
Lesson 3
Planning, Zoning & Preservation
The boards that decide how a community grows, and what it keeps
Planning Board and Planning Department
Same mission, different work - and only one of them approves anything
Nearly every municipality in New York has a planning board. It consists of community members appointed by the mayor, the town supervisor, the village administrator or the equivalent, for terms ranging from one to several years. They are residents serving on a board rather than employees, and that is the first thing separating them from the planning department.
The planning board holds public hearings, investigates solutions for the planning issues in front of it, and makes recommendations to the appropriate legislative authority. It approves or rejects proposals for subdivisions based on the municipality's comprehensive plan. It advises all other boards on land use matters. And it ensures that the requirements of the State Environmental Quality Review Act are followed.
Creating a capital budget
Controlling the comprehensive plan
Plat, density, street, traffic
Regulating subdivision development
Reviewing site plans
Specific zoning actions
Those are the major responsibilities of a city planning board. Chapter 8 covers the devices themselves. This screen is about who sits at the table.
A planning department is an office of the jurisdiction with employees who carry out administrative functions. It provides professional advisement to the agencies and boards of the community, and its work runs to comprehensive municipal planning, grant implementation, transportation planning, zoning referrals review, long-range economic development, water resource management and capital improvements development. A planning department does not approve subdivision plans. It helps carry them out once the board has approved them.
A public hearing is the part your client will actually attend. The board meets on a published date, the application is called, the applicant or his engineer presents, and the public is heard on the record before the board votes. Notice goes out ahead of the meeting, and the notice period and its form are set by local law. Get both from the municipality rather than from memory.
New York City runs this differently. There the planning board and the zoning board are one entity known as the Board of Standards and Appeals, which consists of 12 members and one chairperson. A licensee working on both sides of the city line is working in front of two different structures.
NOTE: The subdivision question separates the two bodies. A subdivision proposal is approved or rejected by the planning board, measured against the comprehensive plan. Hand it to the planning department and it gets read by professionals with no power to approve it.
The board decides; the department advises
REMEMBER: Your developer client wants six lots out of one parcel. Which body votes on it, and what document does the vote get measured against?
Three More Boards That Shape What Gets Built
Zoning relief, community appearance, and the natural environment
Three more appointed boards stand between an owner's plan and a permit. Members are appointed by the city mayor, the town administrator or the village board of trustees, for terms of various lengths. They meet in public, and what they decide or recommend goes on the record.
A local zoning board of appeals hears and decides requests for variances and special permits brought before it. Interpreting zoning laws is its other function, and New York State statutes specifically give the zoning board of appeals the power to hear appeals seeking interpretation of the provisions of local zoning ordinances. It also hears appeals from the decisions of zoning enforcement officers and building inspectors. State statutes require the board when a local legislature adopts a zoning law, and it must consist of three to five members.
This board applies the zoning law to one parcel at a time. Changing the law itself is the legislature's work, so a client who wants his block rezoned is asking the town board or the city council. Chapter 8 teaches the use variance, the area variance and the special use permit, and it teaches the Article 78 proceeding an aggrieved party brings in state court when the board rules against him. Here the question is only which board hears the application.
A local architectural review board determines the effects a proposed building or other structure, or an alteration to an existing structure, will have on the desirability, property values and development of surrounding areas. Its purpose is to conserve the value of property and encourage the most appropriate land use by upholding municipal ordinances, and it approves new construction and remodeling under them.
Watch what gets referred to that board. Applications for building, sign and fence permits are often referred to the architectural review board, and the construction of any structure visible from any street, or an alteration affecting the exterior appearance of a building, falls within its realm.
A conservation advisory council studies matters affecting the environment, preservation, development and use of a community's natural and physical features, with regard to ecologic integrity, aesthetic appeal and quality. Local legislatures create these councils to advise on the protection of natural resources, to prepare an inventory map of open spaces, and to see that environmental issues are handled according to municipal ordinances. Some municipalities call the body a wetlands commission.
CAUTION: The sign is the trap. A storefront tenant who wants a large projecting sign over a sidewalk is proposing something visible from the street, and a sign permit application is exactly what gets referred to the architectural review board. Tell the client to ask before the sign is ordered.
Three boards, all appointed, all public
REMEMBER: A corner lot needs relief from a side-yard setback. Which of these three boards hears it, and which body could not hear it at all?
Historic Preservation and Landmarks
The local preservation office and the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission
A historic preservation office identifies, evaluates, preserves and revitalizes a municipality's historic, archaeological and cultural resources. Its purpose is to provide advice and guidance to property owners and government agencies about historic preservation in the community, and to recommend properties for preservation.
The office typically consists of a board composed of members familiar with historic preservation. Members are usually appointed and may include architects, historians, archaeologists and archivists. In many municipalities other departments sit on the board as well, such as planning, tourism and the historical society.
Reviewing and commenting on any project that could affect historic properties falls to this office. Many boards, working with the municipality's building inspector, review applications requesting permission to demolish all or any substantial part of a building and decide whether the building appears to be one with significant historical value. Where a municipality has designated properties, the state syllabus gives the historic preservation or landmark commission approval over construction and remodeling of those properties.
New York City's Landmarks Law sets a threshold before anything can be designated. A potential landmark must be at least 30 years old and must possess "a special character or special historical or aesthetic interest or value as part of the development, heritage, or cultural characteristics of the city, state, or nation."
The Landmarks Preservation Commission, the LPC, is the New York City agency responsible for identifying and designating the city's landmarks. The commission also regulates changes to landmarks that have already been designated, which is the part that reaches a working licensee. An owner of a designated property who wants to change it deals with the LPC before he deals with anyone else.
A landmark does not have to be a building. Buildings, bridges, parks, cemeteries, fences, sidewalk clocks, building lobbies and even trees have been designated. As long as it meets the Landmarks Law criteria it may be considered for designation.
This matters on a listing before it matters anywhere else. A designated property, or a property inside a historic district, carries a review layer over exterior work that an ordinary listing does not. An agent who markets such a house as ready to renovate to taste, without checking, is setting a buyer up for a permit application that goes somewhere the agent never mentioned.
CAUTION: Thirty years is a minimum age, and age alone does not qualify a property. The property must also possess the special character or historical or aesthetic value the Landmarks Law describes, and designation is a decision the commission makes. Telling a seller that designation is automatic once a building is old enough is wrong twice over.
Age is the threshold; character is the test
REMEMBER: Your seller owns a designated brownstone and wants to replace the front windows. Who does he go to, and what is that body regulating?
Lesson 4
Permits, Public Works & Public Health
The offices watching over construction, infrastructure, and community safety
The Building Department
Gatekeeper of every construction project
Landowners must obtain building permits before constructing or renovating residential or commercial property. Local building departments issue those permits, see that code restrictions are followed, and see that construction and renovation are done by licensed professionals. Building departments are essentially the gatekeepers of any construction project.
The sequence is short and every step of it protects somebody. An owner who wants to build or remodel submits plans to the local building department for approval. Building permits are issued only if the plans comply with the codes. Copies of building permits are also sent to the municipality in which the property is located, which gives the local assessor notice of the improvements for reassessment. Local inspectors then examine the project several times throughout construction to make sure the work is up to code, and they can stop work if necessary.
Building codes are established locally and permits are issued through local government authorities. New York also uses a statewide building code that applies to all construction when no local code exists, or when the local code is less restrictive. A town with no code of its own is not a town without a code.
The permit copy is a loop worth memorizing, because the exam asks about it from the assessor's side. An owner pulls a permit, the copy reaches the municipality, and the assessor's office monitors the improvement for reassessment. That is how the town finds out about the new addition. The title company does not tell them and the listing broker does not tell them. The permit does.
In New York City the building department is the Department of Buildings, and the certificate of occupancy it issues at the end of a job is covered in the construction chapter. Here the point is the office: plans in, review, permit, inspections, and a stop-work order if the job goes off the plans.
CAUTION: Interior work on your own property is still work on a building. A kitchen taken down to the studs is a renovation, and renovation is what the permit requirement is written for. Being the owner changes nothing and being indoors changes nothing. What exactly triggers a permit is set by the local code, so the client asks the building department before the demolition.
No permit, no lawful construction
REMEMBER: How does your town's assessor find out you finished the attic, and what happens to the assessment when it does?
The Engineer's Office and the County Health Department
Public works on one side of the hall, public health on the other
The planning, design and construction of New York's public works facilities and projects all fall within the scope of a municipality's engineer's office. The office is headed by a city, county, village or town engineer who oversees engineering services and the support staff, and municipal engineers are usually civil engineers by trade. The office designs capital improvement projects such as roadways, sewer systems and water connections.
Subdivision and land development
Construction standards ordinances
Drainage, grading, water retention
Site plan review
Engineering research
Public works communication
Those are the office's other functions. It evaluates applications for subdivisions and land development. It prepares and updates the ordinances that set construction standards. It makes recommendations on drainage, grading and water retention. It reviews site plans for commercial, industrial and multi-family properties. It conducts engineering research. And it communicates with the municipality's legislators, administrators and constituents about public works projects. A buyer asking whether a vacant lot can be connected to public water and sewer is asking an engineering question, and this is the office that answers it.
Each county in New York State has its own health department, a human service and regulatory agency that administers public health programs and activities within the county. Health departments assess the health status of the community and then develop policies and plans to meet the needs the assessment identifies.
The essential services run wide: monitoring the health status of the community to solve chronic problems, educating the community about healthy living and preventive care, enforcing laws and regulations that protect health and safety, connecting residents to needed services, training public health care providers, and researching solutions to local health problems.
THE PART LICENSEES FORGET
Some of what the county health department does is not obvious from the name, and it lands directly on your transactions. The department is responsible for approving septic and other sanitation systems. It also regulates food service establishments, tanning salons, swimming pools and environmental health concerns. A rural listing with a new septic system was signed off by the health department, and a buyer who asks who approved it deserves the right answer.
Land use regulation, public health, public works, historical integrity, taxes and zoning all run through a municipal agency. Get to know the local officials and keep up with local legislation. Knowing whom to turn to is superior customer service, and superior service is what referrals are made of.
NOTE: Septic is the classic mix-up. The building department issues the building permit and inspects the construction. The county health department approves the septic system. Both were involved in that new house, and only one of them signed off on the sanitary system.
Engineers build it; the county approves it
REMEMBER: A rural buyer asks three questions: who approved the septic, who runs the sewer line, and who inspected the framing. Name the office for each.
What to Carry Out of This Chapter
Six things about who does what at town hall
The divisions. The county is the primary administrative division, and cities, towns and villages are the municipalities below it. A town contains all the unincorporated area of a county, so everyone who does not live in a city or on an Indian reservation lives in a town. A hamlet is an unincorporated place served by its town, and boroughs exist only in New York City. Under the Municipal Home Rule Law a local law has the same status as an act of the State Assembly.
The legislatures. City councils, town boards and village boards of trustees are elected. They set policy, approve budgets, pass ordinances and adopt the zoning ordinance, and appointed boards do the rest of the work. In New York City a bill needs 26 of 51 votes to pass, the mayor has 30 days to sign or veto, silence approves it, and an override takes 34 of 51 within 30 days.
Taxes and assessments. Boards set taxes. The rate is the levy, which is the budget minus all other revenue, divided by the total taxable assessed value of the jurisdiction. Assessors figure assessed value as a percentage of market value. The receiver of taxes collects and sets nothing. Every parcel is assessed and not every parcel is taxed. A challenge runs assessor, then Board of Assessment Review, then certiorari or SCAR, on grounds of excessive, unequal, unlawful or misclassified.
Planning and zoning. The planning board is appointed, holds public hearings, approves or rejects subdivisions against the comprehensive plan, advises all other boards, and sees that the State Environmental Quality Review Act is followed. The planning department is staff that advises and carries approved plans out. The zoning board of appeals, three to five members, decides variances and special permits and interprets the zoning law, and an aggrieved party goes to court under Article 78. In New York City both boards are one body, the Board of Standards and Appeals, 12 members and a chairperson.
Character and history. The architectural review board weighs a structure's effect on surrounding property values, and building, sign and fence permit applications are often referred to it. The conservation advisory council advises on natural resources. Historic preservation offices recommend properties and review demolition applications. New York City's Landmarks Preservation Commission designates landmarks at least 30 years old that possess special character, and regulates changes to those already designated.
Permits, works and health. Building departments issue permits only when plans comply with the code, inspect throughout construction, and send the permit copy that tells the assessor an improvement is coming. Municipal engineers design roads, sewers and water connections and review site plans. County health departments approve septic and other sanitation systems and regulate food service, pools and tanning salons.
One habit carries all six. When a client asks whether he can do something to a property, answer with the name of the office that decides, and offer to find out when it meets.
Name the office before you name the answer
REMEMBER: Which of these six could you not explain to a client at a kitchen table right now? Go back to that screen before the quiz.
YOU BE THE JUDGE
The Cedar Hollow Runaround
Sal, a salesperson at Gateway Realty, farms the hamlet of Birchwood, out in the unincorporated part of the county. “The beauty of Birchwood,” he tells a relocating buyer, “is that it isn't part of any town, unincorporated means no local government at all.” The same week his New York City investor calls in a panic: the mayor has vetoed the council bill that would have rezoned the block behind her building. “Then the bill is dead,” Sal tells her. “A veto is the end of the road.”
When a Birchwood buyer's first tax bill looks high, Sal walks her into the office of the receiver of taxes to “negotiate a lower rate with the man who sets it.” Sent away, he explains that the real culprit is the tax assessor, “since the assessor fixes your tax rate.” To fight the number itself, he tells her to skip the local bureaucrats and file straight away in New York State Supreme Court. Touring a colonial beside St. Anselm's, he mentions that the church parcel “isn't even assessed, religious property never is.” He does add that her husband, a veteran, may qualify for a partial exemption, and that the application belongs at the assessor's office.
Sal's developer client wants to split a parcel into six lots, so Sal hand-delivers the subdivision proposal to the planning department, “they're the ones who approve these.” The corner lot needs relief from a side-yard setback, and Sal tells the developer to request the variance from the town board at its next meeting. Downstate, he assures the seller of a handsome 25-year-old apartment house that landmark designation is “basically automatic at this point.” And when his storefront tenant asks about mounting a big new projecting sign over the sidewalk, Sal waves it off: “Signs don't need anyone's review, just hang it.”
Back home, a flip client plans to take a kitchen down to the studs. “Interior work on your own property doesn't need a building permit,” Sal advises, “so don't invite the town in.” A month later a rural listing goes under contract, and the buyer asks who signed off on the brand-new septic system. “The building department,” Sal answers confidently. “They approved it with the rest of the construction.” He closes out the week updating his farm mailer, which now promises insider answers on “every agency in town.”
Twelve violations are buried in that story, and one lawful act has been planted among them to catch you out. Work it the way you would work a client file rather than the way you would take a test.
Read it once straight through without marking anything. Read it again with a pen and mark every sentence that made you pause. Then go back through this chapter and name the office each marked sentence is really about.
THE ERRORS HERE ARE ERRORS OF ADDRESS
Almost everything Sal gets wrong is a wrong door. So for each marked sentence ask one question first. Which body actually decides this, and is that the body Sal named? Most of the twelve answer themselves the moment you ask it that way.
Start with the word unincorporated in the first paragraph. Find the sentence about who lives in a town, then decide what Sal has told that buyer about who makes the law on her street. The second half of that paragraph is a counting problem, and the two numbers are on the legislative process screen.
The second paragraph is two offices, one board and one sequence. Name the body that sets a rate, the office that sets an assessed value, and the office that collects the bill. Sal attributes the rate to two different offices and neither is right. Then take his Supreme Court advice to the screen on challenging an assessment and count the steps he skipped.
The church parcel is a distinction this chapter draws on purpose. Assessed and taxed are not the same thing. One statement in that paragraph is correct and is sitting right beside the wrong ones, so find it and say which office receives that application.
The third paragraph has three wrong doors in it. A subdivision proposal, a request for relief from a setback, and a sign over a sidewalk each go to a specific body, and Sal names the wrong one every time. The third sentence there is about a building's age, and the answer is a minimum plus a test rather than a calendar.
The last paragraph is the building department and the county health department, and both errors would cost a real client money. One is whether a permit is needed when the work is inside and the owner is doing it himself. The other is which agency signs off on a septic system.
Sort your marked sentences into three piles. Clearly wrong. Clearly lawful. Cannot tell from these facts. The third pile teaches the most, because for each item you have to name the fact you are missing that would move it to one of the others.
Write each answer in three parts and it will hold up in front of anyone. The fact, quoted from the story. The office or rule, named from this chapter. And the advice you would actually have given that client. An answer you can only half write shows you which screen to go back to.
Finding the lawful act matters as much as finding the errors. A licensee who calls everything a violation is as unreliable as one who calls nothing a violation. Then argue the other side of whichever item you were least sure about, out loud, as though Sal were across the table with a reason for everything.
NOTE: If your answer is the name of an agency with no facts attached, you have not spotted an issue. You have recited a list. Name the fact first, then the office that decides it, then what the client should have been told.
Name the fact, then name the office
REMEMBER: Which of Sal's twelve errors would have cost a client the most money, and which one would have cost the client the most time?