The Course · Chapter 14 Beta

Chapter 14: Mortgage Basics

Loan types, clauses, foreclosure, lending regulations, and the people who move the money

In this chapter

  • Mortgage types Match repayment, refinance, and special-purpose loans to the buyers who need them.
  • Mortgage clauses Read acceleration, alienation, defeasance, prepayment, and subordination clauses.
  • Judicial foreclosure Walk the process, and place the equitable right of redemption window on it.
  • Lending regulations Apply TILA / Reg Z, RESPA, and the TRID disclosure deadlines.
  • The loan application Know what the 1003 asks for, and how lenders evaluate the borrower.
  • Qualifying standards Run the ratios for conventional, FHA-insured, and VA-guaranteed loans.
  • Banker, broker, MLO Tell the three apart, and state each one's New York licensing rules.
  • Dual agency disclosure Handle the agent-who-is-also-a-mortgage-broker situation the Article 12-D way.

Lesson 1

Types of Mortgage Loans

Defined by how they repay, what they fund, and the situations they solve

Mortgages Sorted by How They Are Repaid

And the loans that turn equity back into cash

Every mortgage loan does the same thing. A lender advances money, the borrower promises to repay it, and the property stands as security until the debt is gone. What separates one loan from another is the schedule. Learn the loans by their repayment pattern and the names stop being vocabulary.

DEFINED BY REPAYMENT METHOD

A graduated payment mortgage, a GPM, starts the borrower with payments that are deliberately too small. They do not cover the interest accruing on the loan, so the shortfall is added to what is owed and the balance grows while the borrower is paying on it. That growth has a name. Negative amortization is a loan balance increasing because of deferred interest, and for a time the borrower owes more than he borrowed.

At a point fixed in the loan documents the payments escalate on a schedule, and they keep escalating until they fully amortize the loan over whatever is left of the term. A GPM is built for a borrower whose income is expected to rise. If the income does not rise, the borrower is holding a bigger debt than he started with and a payment he cannot reach.

A straight mortgage, also called a term or interest-only mortgage, pays interest and nothing else for a stated term. The principal never moves. At the end the whole principal comes due in one balloon payment, and the borrower either has the money, sells, or refinances the balloon into a new loan.

FOR ADDITIONAL FUNDS AND REFINANCE

An open-end mortgage lets the borrower go back to the same lender and request more money after the loan is made, up to a limit set at the start. Lenders in most cases will not advance beyond the original principal balance, or past a predetermined loan-to-value.

A home equity loan and a home equity line of credit both reach the same pot of money, which is the equity the owner already has in the house. A home equity loan is usually a one-time loan for a specific amount and often for a specific purpose. A home equity line of credit is money kept available for the owner to use as expenses arise. Both attach a junior mortgage to the property, unless the property is free and clear of liens, in which case the new mortgage stands alone.

Junior means second in line. A junior mortgage is paid out of a foreclosure sale only after the first mortgage is paid in full, and if nothing is left it is paid nothing. That position is why the junior lender carries more risk than the first mortgage lender on the same house.

A reverse equity mortgage runs the other direction. A qualified homeowner with few or no outstanding liens mortgages the home and receives a monthly check from the lender instead of writing one. These loans are designed to help elderly homeowners convert home equity into cash. The qualifying rule and the repayment trigger work this way.

62 minimum age for a reverse equity mortgage

The homeowner must also have little or no outstanding mortgage balance.

When is it repaid?

The lender sends a monthly check; the loan is repaid when the home is sold, the borrower dies, or the borrower is out of the home for 12 consecutive months. The amount depends on home value, the owner's age, and the interest rate.

With any loan the rate may be fixed or adjustable, and most states have usury laws limiting the maximum interest rate that can be charged.

NOTE: A question that gives you an age and asks about a reverse mortgage is testing two facts and not one. The age is half of it. The mortgage balance is the other half, and it is the half students drop.

Learn the loan by its payment schedule

REMEMBER: Say what negative amortization does to a loan balance, then name the loan on this screen that ends in a balloon payment.

Loans Built for One Situation

Construction, bridge, blanket, package, purchase money, and the seller who finances the deal

The loans on the last screen were sorted by how they are repaid. These are sorted by the problem they solve. A developer with twenty lots. A buyer who has not sold his old house yet. A seller who cannot find a qualified buyer at any price. The name of the loan describes the situation rather than the payment.

A construction mortgage is a temporary loan used to finance the construction of buildings on land. When construction is complete it is replaced by permanent financing, and the permanent loan that takes it out is called the end loan.

A bridge mortgage, also called a swing loan, covers the gap between selling one property and buying another. Bridge mortgages are usually short term, and the course materials add that they are used most commonly for construction financing.

A blanket mortgage covers more than one parcel or lot under a single mortgage, and it is usually used to finance subdivision developments. Whole, it would trap the developer, because he cannot deliver clear title to a lot that still carries a lien for the entire subdivision. The answer is written into the loan. A partial release clause lets the borrower pay a certain amount of money to release one or more lots, with the mortgage continuing to cover the rest, and the released lots are then sold to generate income.

A package mortgage finances personal property together with the real property in one contract. An appliance included in a property sale is financed with the house rather than separately. Package mortgages are typically used for condominiums and vacation homes, where the furnishings come with the unit.

A no doc or stated doc mortgage relies on stated income rather than documentation. It may be available to a borrower who cannot pass a credit review but has a large down payment, or who cannot prove income stability because he is self-employed. These are also called no ratio or nonconforming loans.

Sale-and-leaseback financing is used mostly where long-term leases are involved, as with commercial or retail property. The purchaser, usually an investor, buys the property and leases it back to the seller. The new owner gains income tax benefits and a guaranteed rental stream, and the seller frees up capital and still controls the property under the lease.

A purchase money mortgage may generically mean any mortgage loan used to buy real estate. The term more often describes one particular arrangement: the seller finances all or part of the sale price for the buyer. When you hear purchase money on an exam, look first for the seller lending the money.

A land contract is a real estate installment agreement. The buyer, the vendee, makes payments to the seller, the vendor, in exchange for the right to occupy and use the property. No deed or title transfers until all of the payments, or a specified portion of them, have been made. The seller holds title to the land as security rather than holding a mortgage lien on it, which is a stronger position than a lender has. The buyer's present interest is equitable title, because actual title will be transferred by deed at a future date.

Why a seller finances at all is the practical question behind both. The buyer cannot afford the cash a conventional down payment requires. The buyer wants the benefit of the low rate on the seller's existing mortgage. The buyer cannot qualify with an institutional lender. And in a tight money market, financing part of the price may be the only way the seller makes a deal at all. Sellers often enhance the salability of a property by offering complete or partial financing.

NOTE: Blanket and package are the pair most often confused. Blanket covers more than one parcel of land. Package covers land plus personal property. Read the answer for what is being covered, not for which word sounds bigger.

The name describes the situation

REMEMBER: A developer calls and says he cannot close on the third lot he sold. Which clause is missing from his mortgage, and what does that clause let him do?

Selling a House That Still Has a Mortgage on It

Free and clear, subject to, assumed, or wrapped

Most houses sold in New York have a mortgage on them the day they are sold. There are three ordinary ways to handle that mortgage at closing, and one arrangement built on top of the second that a licensee has to recognize.

Sale free and clear is the ordinary path. The seller's loan is paid off out of the sale proceeds at closing and the buyer takes title with no lien from the seller's lender on it. The buyer's own lender typically brings a check for the payoff made out to the seller's mortgagee, and once that lender is paid it issues a satisfaction of mortgage.

Sale subject to the mortgage leaves the existing loan in place. The buyer takes title with the lien still attached and makes the payments, and the seller stays on the note he signed. The lender never agreed to any of it, which is the whole risk of the arrangement.

Sale subject to the mortgage with the buyer assuming the debt is the third path. Assumption means one party agrees to take over payments of another party's debt, with the terms of the note staying unchanged. The property is still security for the loan and the buyer becomes primarily liable, but in a foreclosure the seller remains secondarily liable. Assumption is rarely possible with loans written today, though some conventional mortgages allow it where there is no enforceable alienation clause. Send the client to the original lender or to a lawyer before anyone relies on it.

One obligation, two loans

A financing arrangement in which an existing loan on the property is combined with a new loan, for example, the seller keeps the existing loan while giving the buyer another mortgage.

Follow the money through a wraparound. The buyer makes one combined payment to the seller. The seller pays the original lender out of it. Every dollar the buyer pays passes through the seller's hands before it reaches the lender holding the senior lien.

Why it is dangerous

If the seller stops paying the original loan, the property goes into foreclosure even though the buyer has paid the seller faithfully every month. The buyer's payments were never the lender's problem, because the buyer never had a contract with that lender.

The lender's answer is a clause. Lenders often include a due-on-sale clause in the mortgage that would prohibit a property owner from offering a wraparound at all. A wraparound written over a loan with that clause hands the lender the right to call the whole balance due the moment it learns of the transfer, and the person who loses the house is the buyer.

CAUTION: A wraparound arranged around a lender with a due-on-sale clause in its mortgage is not clever structuring. It is a transfer the lender has the stated right to accelerate, and the licensee who helped arrange it and said nothing is standing in the middle of it.

One obligation, two loans, one weak link

REMEMBER: In a wraparound, name the party who is paid last and the party who loses the property first. They are not the same person.

Fixed Rates and the 15-Year Question

Same rate on both terms below, to isolate what the shorter term saves

A fixed rate loan carries an interest rate that stays constant for the whole term. The borrower knows the payment on the day he signs and knows it will be the same payment in year nineteen. If rates rise he is protected, and if rates fall he can refinance. The lender takes the other side of that trade and gets a guaranteed rate of return.

For many years the traditional conventional home loan has been the 30-year fixed rate mortgage. The length is negotiable, and lenders typically offer 20-, 25-, and 35-year payouts as well. The 15-year fixed is the one borrowers ask about, because over the life of the loan the total interest paid on a 15-year mortgage is about one-third less than on a 30-year mortgage at the same interest rate.

The figures below are held at one rate for both terms so the only thing changing is the number of years.

Loan amount

Term

Rate

Monthly payment

Total interest paid

$50,000

15 yr

$449.41

$30,894.54

$50,000

30 yr

$332.65

$69,754.45

$100,000

15 yr

$898.83

$61,789.09

$100,000

30 yr

$665.30

$139,508.90

$150,000

15 yr

$1,348.24

$92,683.63

$150,000

30 yr

$997.95

$209,263.35

Read the middle pair. The same hundred thousand dollars costs about seventy-eight thousand dollars more in interest across thirty years than it does across fifteen, and the monthly payment is about two hundred thirty dollars higher on the shorter loan. That is the whole decision in two numbers.

~1/3

less total interest on a 15-year loan

The shorter term has real costs. Payments are higher. Larger down payments are sometimes required on 15-year mortgages to keep payments manageable and to qualify the buyer. Both of those consume money that could have been invested elsewhere at a better return than the mortgage rate. And the borrower loses the mortgage interest tax deduction sooner, because the house is paid for sooner.

NOTE: The exam does not ask which loan is better. It asks what the shorter term does to total interest and what it does to the monthly payment, and those two move in opposite directions.

Shorter term, less interest, bigger payment

REMEMBER: A buyer asks you whether to take the 15 or the 30. Name the two questions you would ask her before you say anything at all.

Adjustable Rate Mortgages

The lender moves the rate risk to the borrower and charges less up front for it

An adjustable rate mortgage, an ARM, permits the lender to adjust the interest rate periodically so it reflects the changing cost of money. The rate is not set by the lender's mood. It is built from two pieces, and once you know the two pieces every ARM question becomes arithmetic.

CURRENT INDEX VALUE

MARGIN

INTEREST RATE

The index is a statistical report reliably indicating the cost of money; the margin is the lender's profit. Future adjustments follow the index.

The index is outside the lender's control, which is what makes the arrangement defensible. The margin is the lender's profit and it stays fixed for the life of the loan. Future rate adjustments follow the index, so a borrower who wants to know where his payment is heading watches the index rather than the lender.

THE ELEMENTS OF AN ARM LOAN

Rate adjustment period

The interval at which the rate changes, most commonly every 6 months or 1 year. Lenders must notify borrowers of a change in writing.

Payment adjustment period

The interval at which the actual P&I payment changes. It may not coincide with the rate adjustments.

Interest rate cap

Limits how far the rate can move. A common cap is 2/5: 2 = the most it can change per adjustment, up or down; 5 = the lifetime cap.

Ceiling

The highest interest rate that may be charged over the term of the loan, the lifetime cap by another name.

Conversion option

Lets the borrower convert to a fixed rate, typically with conditions, such as a higher interest rate.

Take the cap apart, because it is the most tested element on the screen. A 2/5 cap means the rate may move at most two percentage points in any one adjustment, up or down, and may move at most five percentage points over the life of the loan. Start at four percent with a 2/5 cap and the worst the borrower can ever face is nine percent, and he cannot be taken there in one jump.

Because ARMs shift the rate risk to the borrower, lenders normally charge a lower initial rate on an ARM than on a fixed rate loan. That lower starting rate is also what helps borrowers qualify more easily, since the payment the lender tests against the qualifying ratios is the smaller one. If rates climb the payments go up. If rates decline the payments go down.

The two adjustment periods are separate for a reason, and the separation is where negative amortization can appear. The rate adjustment period is when the interest rate changes. The payment adjustment period is when the principal and interest payment changes. Where the rate moves up and the payment has not caught up to it yet, the shortfall goes onto the loan balance.

CAUTION: A borrower who qualified on the initial ARM rate qualified on a payment the loan is allowed to raise. Ask what the payment becomes at the first adjustment and at the ceiling before you tell anybody they can afford the house.

Index plus margin equals the rate

REMEMBER: An ARM at 4 percent has a 2/5 cap. What is the highest rate the borrower can be charged, and how many adjustments does it take to get there?

What the Mortgage Instrument Actually Does

The lien, the record, and the five clauses that move rights between the parties

A mortgage is an instrument that creates a voluntary lien on real property to secure repayment of a debt. Voluntary means the owner consented to it. The parties are the mortgagor, the borrower who gives the mortgage, and the mortgagee, the lender who receives it. Without a debt there can be no mortgage.

Some states use a different instrument for the same job. A deed of trust, or trust deed, creates a voluntary lien on real property held by a third party as security for the payment of a note. The borrower is called the trustor, and a trustee holds the security.

That difference decides how a lender takes the property back. In a lien theory state the mortgagee holds only a lien and the mortgagor holds actual title until the loan is repaid. In a title theory state the mortgagee holds actual title. Where a deed of trust is used, a trustee can conduct a trustee's sale under a power of sale clause, a non-judicial foreclosure with no court in it. New York does it the long way. With a mortgage as the security instrument, the procedure on default is judicial foreclosure.

The mortgage is recorded in the county where the property is located. Recording gives constructive notice to the public and establishes lien priority, and normally the first instrument recorded has priority.

THE FIVE CLAUSES

Acceleration

Lender may declare the entire loan balance due immediately on borrower default or violation of other contract provisions. Found in most notes, mortgages, trust deeds, and land contracts.

Alienation / due on sale

Stated rights when ownership transfers: accelerate the debt, change the interest rate, or charge a hefty assumption fee. FHA and VA loans cannot include one.

Defeasance

When a stated condition is fulfilled, the debt repaid, the mortgage becomes null and void. The mortgagee then prepares a satisfaction of mortgage for the public record.

Prepayment penalty

Lets the lender charge for early payoff or big principal reductions. Standard Fannie Mae / Freddie Mac notes don't have them; prohibited in FHA and VA loans; usual in subprime.

Subordination agreement

Gives a later-recorded mortgage priority over an earlier one. Made between lienholders, the parties opting out of first-to-record priority.

Read those five as rights rather than as definitions. Acceleration is triggered by default. Alienation is triggered by transfer, so a borrower who is current can still trigger it by selling.

Defeasance is why a satisfaction of mortgage exists. Once the debt is repaid the mortgage is cancelled, the mortgagee has no further claim on the property, and the mortgagee prepares a satisfaction of mortgage for the public record. A recorded lien stays on the record until something recorded takes it off.

Assignment moves the other way. It is one party, the assignor, transferring rights or interests under a contract to another, the assignee. A lender that sells a loan assigns the mortgage along with the note, and the borrower keeps paying the same debt to a different holder.

NOTE: Acceleration and alienation both let the lender call the balance, and the exam separates them by the trigger. Acceleration is triggered by default. Alienation is triggered by transfer. FHA and VA loans cannot include an alienation clause, and prepayment penalties are prohibited in them as well.

Recording sets priority; the clauses set rights

REMEMBER: Your seller paid off his mortgage four years ago and the lien is still showing on the title search. Name the document that was supposed to be recorded and the party who prepares it.

Lesson 2

Default, Foreclosure, and Redemption

The court-ordered path from missed payment to sheriff's sale, and the way back

Judicial Foreclosure and the Redemption Window

New York requires a court-ordered sheriff's sale, and leaves the door open until confirmation

Default is a failure to fulfill an obligation, and on a mortgage it usually means the borrower stopped paying. The lender's first move is acceleration: it advances the due date of the debt to the present and gives the debtor notice of default demanding the entire outstanding balance at once. Everything after that is a court proceeding, because in New York the security is a mortgage, the collateral is real estate, and the procedure is judicial foreclosure.

Judicial foreclosure requires a court-ordered sheriff's sale of the property to repay the debt. The lender starts the action in the county where the property is located. If the court determines the lender is rightfully owed the money, the judge issues an order of execution directing an officer of the court to seize and sell the property. Five steps, in order, and the exam tests the order.

1 DEFAULT

Borrower fails to pay; lender accelerates the debt and demands the entire balance at once.

2 ACTION FILED, LIS PENDENS

Lender sues in the county where the property sits; the lis pendens gives notice of the pending foreclosure.

3 ORDER OF EXECUTION

If the lender is rightfully owed, the judge directs an officer of the court to seize and sell the property.

4 SHERIFF'S SALE

The sheriff advertises place and date; public auction to the highest bidder at or above the minimum bid.

5 CONFIRMATION OF SALE

Filed to finalize. The transfer is final, the right to redeem ends here.

The officer of the court in New York is usually the county sheriff, and it is the sheriff who notifies the public of the place and date of the sale. The auction is public and the property goes to the highest bidder at or in excess of the minimum bid. After the sale a confirmation of sale is filed to finalize the transaction, and once it is filed the transfer of the property is final.

That word final is doing real work. It is the moment the debtor's rights end, and everything the debtor could have done had to be done before it.

EQUITABLE RIGHT OF REDEMPTION

A debtor can redeem the property, which means save it, from the time the lis pendens is filed until the confirmation of the foreclosure sale. A lis pendens is a recorded notice that a lawsuit is pending which may affect title to the defendant's real estate, and in a foreclosure it is the public notice that the action has begun. The debtor redeems by paying the court what is due, which may include court costs and attorneys' fees. Once the redemption is made the court sets aside the sale, pays the parties, and the debtor gains title to the property again.

STATUTORY RIGHT OF REDEMPTION, SOME OTHER STATES

Allows debtors to redeem themselves AFTER the final sale

Not used in New York, here, after confirmation of sale the debtor no longer has the right to redeem

The difference between the two is timing and nothing else. The equitable right runs before confirmation. The statutory right, where a state has one, runs after the final sale. New York gives the debtor the first and not the second.

CAUTION: A client who tells you a lis pendens has been filed still has a window, and telling her it is over is bad advice that costs her a house. The window closes at confirmation of sale, and how much of it is left is a question for her lawyer today rather than next month.

Lis pendens opens it; confirmation closes it

REMEMBER: Put the five steps in order out loud, then say which two of them the redemption window sits between.

After the Sheriff's Sale

Where the money goes, and what happens when there is not enough of it

The sale produces a pile of money and the order it is paid out in is fixed, because a foreclosure sale is the moment every lien on the property is tested against every other lien.

HOW SALE PROCEEDS ARE DISTRIBUTED

1 Back taxes

Any back property taxes are paid first, always.

2 Sale costs

The cost of the foreclosure: sheriff, appraisers, transfer tax, auctioneer.

3 Lienholders

Paid in priority order, first lien in its entirety, then second, then third, until the money is gone.

4 Surplus

Anything left over goes to the debtor.

Work the list from the bottom. The debtor gets the surplus, which means the debtor gets whatever is left after everyone ahead of him is paid in full. When the money runs out before his turn, he gets nothing.

Lien priority is the reason. A first mortgage, also called a senior mortgage, holds first lien position and is paid first out of foreclosure proceeds. A second mortgage, a junior mortgage, sits behind it. The property is still security for the junior loan, but if nothing is left after the first mortgage is paid, the junior lender gets nothing at all.

Liens are paid in the order they were applied to the property, with one exception. A tax lien is always paid first: it is the only lien that pre-empts a first mortgage.

A tax lien outranks everything, including a first mortgage recorded years before the tax was ever assessed. Apart from a subordination agreement the lienholders sign themselves, that is the one exception to first-to-record, and it is the exception the exam asks about.

DEFICIENCY JUDGMENT

Deficiency judgment

If the sale doesn't cover the loan, accrued interest, and costs, the creditor may obtain a court order that the debtor owes the difference, a personal judgment creating a general, involuntary lien against ALL the debtor's real and personal property.

Read what that judgment is. It is a personal judgment against the debtor, and it creates a general and involuntary lien against all of the debtor's real and personal property. General means it reaches past the house that was sold, so a debtor who thinks the matter closed at the auction can find the judgment attached to a second property.

Deed in lieu of foreclosure

A voluntary conveyance: the debtor still loses the property, but by returning it before final court action avoids a foreclosure on the credit record. After confirmation of sale it is too late.

A deed in lieu is a voluntary conveyance and the debtor generally receives nothing for surrendering title. What he receives is the absence of a foreclosure on his credit record, and for a client who intends to buy again that is worth more than it sounds. The timing rule is absolute. Before final court action it is available, and after confirmation of sale it is too late.

NOTE: A deficiency judgment is not automatic and it is not the lender helping itself. It is a court order the creditor may be able to obtain when the sale does not cover the loan amount, the accrued interest and the other costs. Read the question for whether a court was asked.

Taxes, costs, liens in order, then the debtor

REMEMBER: A house sells at auction for less than the first mortgage balance. Say what the second mortgage holder receives and say what the borrower may still owe.

Lesson 3

Lending Regulations That Protect Borrowers

TILA, RESPA, and the TRID rule that fused their disclosures

Two Federal Laws, One Goal

TILA disclosed the cost of the credit; RESPA disclosed the cost of the closing

Federal regulation of mortgage lending rests on two statutes written years apart to fix two different problems. A borrower who does not know what the credit costs him, and a borrower who does not know what the closing costs him. Know which statute does which and most of this material stops being a memory exercise.

TRUTH-IN-LENDING ACT, REGULATION Z

The federal Consumer Credit Protection Act, prevents abuses in consumer credit cost disclosure

Requires uniform disclosure of credit costs so consumers can compare and shop for terms

Applies to credit for personal residential or agricultural purposes, not commercial or business use

Covers credit with finance charges, or payable by written agreement in more than four installments

Also regulates how consumer credit terms are advertised

The Truth-in-Lending Act is implemented by Regulation Z, which controls the disclosure of interest rates and other finance charges. Disclosures are required in two places: when lenders offer credit to borrowers, and when credit terms are advertised. That second one is the half that reaches you, because a real estate advertisement quoting financing terms is an advertisement of credit.

RESPA, REGULATION X

Requires lenders to disclose actual closing costs in a timely manner

Helps consumers shop for settlement services and cuts unnecessary cost increases

Loan Estimate settlement terms must hold at least 10 business days, rate-dependent charges excepted, hence rate locks

Your Home Loan Toolkit handbook due within 3 business days of a completed application

RESPA is the federal Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act, passed by Congress in 1974 and implemented as Regulation X. TILA is about the loan. RESPA is about the closing table.

The ten-business-day rule is what makes shopping possible. The estimate of the charges and terms for all settlement services stays available for at least ten business days from when the Loan Estimate is provided. It does not reach the interest rate or the charges that depend on it, such as adjusted origination charges and per diem interest, which is why borrowers and lenders agree to a rate lock for a set period.

APR

the most important disclosure

The actual rate charged, including loan fees and points, an 11% note rate may be an 11.5% APR.

The APR is the number to teach a buyer. The note rate is what the loan says. The annual percentage rate is what the loan costs, with the loan fees and points folded in and spread over its life. A buyer comparing two quotes on note rate alone is comparing the wrong number.

TRID, the TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure (2013)

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau merged the two laws' paperwork. The TRID Loan Estimate replaces the initial Truth in Lending Statement (TILA) and the Good Faith Estimate (RESPA), to improve understanding of the mortgage process, aid comparison shopping, and prevent surprises at the closing table.

NOTE: TILA and RESPA are easy to separate by what the borrower is being protected from. Reg Z protects him from the cost of the money. Reg X protects him from the cost of the closing. TRID is the rule that put both disclosures on the same two forms.

Reg Z is the loan; Reg X is the closing

REMEMBER: A buyer is quoted an 11 percent rate and the disclosure says 11.5 percent. Which number is which, and what is in the gap?

The TRID Disclosure Clock

Four deadlines worth memorizing, all counted in business days

TRID replaced four old forms with two. The Loan Estimate goes out near the beginning, the Closing Disclosure goes out near the end, and four deadlines govern the distance between them. Every one is counted in business days, and every one is on the exam.

Here are the four.

3 days to the Loan Estimate

Delivered no later than 3 business days after the lender receives the completed application.

7 days before closing can happen

A mandatory waiting period runs from when the Loan Estimate is given to when the loan can close.

3 days with the Closing Disclosure

The 5-page final-charges form must reach the borrower at least 3 business days before closing.

10 days the estimate must hold

Settlement charges and terms stay available at least 10 business days, rate-dependent items excepted.

The seven-day rule is the one students misread. It is a mandatory waiting period running from the time the Loan Estimate is given to the borrower to the time the loan is allowed to close. Seven days after the disclosure, rather than seven days before the closing date.

The point of the three days on the Closing Disclosure is comparison. The borrower is meant to set the final charges beside the estimate he was given at the start and see what moved.

Tolerances and the corrected CD

Final Closing Disclosure charges are compared with the Loan Estimate against TRID tolerance limits. Exceed them and a corrected Closing Disclosure must go out, triggering an additional waiting period.

That has teeth at the table. The final annual percentage rate is disclosed on the Closing Disclosure too, and a closing can move because a fee moved.

What the Loan Estimate shows

Lender's name, APR, Total Interest Percentage, closing costs and cash to close, payment schedule, prepayment provisions, the collateral, assumption, servicing, and that receiving it obligates the borrower to nothing.

The Loan Estimate is a shopping document rather than a commitment. It shows the date through which the rate is available, whether the rate can rise, whether the lender requires an escrow account for taxes or hazard insurance, and the total estimated settlement charges. Signing it confirms the borrower received it and nothing more.

Where TRID does NOT apply

Home equity lines of credit (HELOCs), mortgages on mobile homes, and reverse mortgages.

A borrower may waive the waiting periods and expedite closing only for a bona fide personal financial emergency, such as avoiding foreclosure.

CAUTION: The waiver is narrow and it belongs to the borrower rather than to the lender or the agent. A bona fide personal financial emergency, such as a closing that has to happen to avoid a foreclosure, is the standard. Wanting the keys sooner is not an emergency.

Three, seven, three, and ten

REMEMBER: Say the four deadlines in order and say which form each one attaches to, without looking back at the screen.

Reg Z in the Wild: Advertising and Rescission

Trigger a term, disclose everything, and know which borrowers get three days to walk

Before the Truth-in-Lending Act an advertiser could publish the most attractive term in a loan and nothing else. Seventy-five dollars a month, with no mention of the large down payment a buyer needed to reach it. Reg Z fixed that with a rule about which words start an obligation. Triggering terms are words or phrases that describe a loan, including the down payment, the terms and the monthly payment. If an advertisement uses a trigger phrase, disclosures are required and they must tell everything about the loan. If it uses none, no disclosures are needed.

TRIGGERING TERMS, FULL DISCLOSURE REQUIRED

“20% down”

“Pay only $700 per month”

“Only 360 monthly payments”

“30-year financing available”

“1% finance charge”

NON-TRIGGERING TERMS, NO DISCLOSURE NEEDED

“No down payment”

“We'll work with you”

“Easy monthly payments”

“FHA financing available”

“100% VA financing available”

Read the two lists against each other and the rule names itself. A specific term triggers. A mood does not. Easy monthly payments promises nothing measurable, and FHA financing available and 100% VA financing available name a program rather than a term. Twenty percent down and seven hundred dollars a month are specific enough to act on, which is why the rest of the loan has to come with them.

If an ad triggers, it must disclose all of:

Amount or percentage of down payment

Terms of repayment

“Annual percentage rate”, spelled out in full, with any indication the APR may increase (e.g., ARMs)

This one reaches you directly. Your open house flyer and your listing advertisement are advertisements, and a payment or down payment figure in one advertises credit terms. The listing agent who writes a monthly payment on a flyer has triggered Reg Z as surely as the lender would have.

RIGHT OF RESCISSION

Right of rescission, until midnight of day 3

Consumers may rescind credit secured by their EXISTING primary residence, home equity loans, refinancing, a new mortgage on an existing home, until midnight of the third business day after closing. It does NOT apply to loans to purchase or construct a principal residence. Lenders must disclose the right in a separate document; a borrower who rescinds gets every fee back.

The line runs on what the money is doing. Credit secured by a residence the borrower already lives in may be rescinded. A mortgage used to finance the purchase or construction of a principal residence may not, which protects builders who performed work relying on the buyer's commitment and sellers who bought another house on the strength of this sale.

NOTE: The rescission question is always the same question in different clothes. Is this borrower already living in the house that secures the loan? Answer that and the three days answers itself.

A specific term triggers; a mood does not

REMEMBER: Look at the last listing flyer you saw with a payment on it. Name the three things Reg Z required next to that number.

Lesson 4

Applying and Qualifying for the Loan

From the 1003 application to the underwriter's final answer

Pre-Qualification, Pre-Approval, and the 1003

One of them binds nobody

Buyers used to complete a mortgage application when they were ready to buy a particular house. The trend now runs toward getting the buyer approved first, and the reason is leverage. A seller choosing between two offers takes the one more likely to close.

The two words sound alike and mean different things, and telling a buyer the wrong one is a promise you cannot keep.

PRE-QUALIFICATION

Estimates the size of loan a potential buyer might be eligible for

An agent OR a lender can do it

Does not guarantee approval, and is NOT binding on the lender

The lender is only indicating it looks likely the buyer will be approved

PRE-APPROVAL

A lender determines if, and for how much, the borrower can be financed

The buyer goes through many of the actual loan-process steps; the situation is verified

Providing all circumstances stay the same, the lender will loan a certain amount

Pre-qualification estimates the size of loan a buyer might be eligible for. An agent or a lender can do it, it does not guarantee approval, and it is not binding on the lender. You are allowed to pre-qualify a buyer yourself at a kitchen table. You are not allowed to tell her it means the bank has committed.

Pre-approval is the process by which a lender determines if, and for what amount, a potential borrower can be financed. The buyer goes through many of the steps of the actual loan process and the lender verifies the situation. The lender then states that, provided all circumstances stay the same, it will lend a certain amount, and puts it in writing in a certificate or letter of pre-approval.

THE 1003

The 1003, Uniform Residential Loan Application

The form most lenders require. It captures the type of mortgage and its terms, the property and the purpose of the loan, and the borrower's personal, employment, and financial information.

The application is where the borrower's income gets its first test. Stable monthly income is the monthly income that can reasonably be expected to continue in the future: gross base income from a primary job, plus earnings from acceptable secondary sources such as bonuses, commissions, a second job or investment income.

Stable monthly income

Gross base income plus acceptable secondary sources, bonuses, commissions, a second job, investments, screened for quality (dependability) and durability (probability of continuance). The Equal Credit Opportunity Act bars discrimination against income from public assistance.

The underwriter decides what portion of the verified earnings counts by studying two things. Quality, which is the dependability of the source. Durability, which is the probability that it continues. A commission income of three years' standing and a bonus paid once are both earnings, and only one is stable monthly income.

CAUTION: The federal Equal Credit Opportunity Act prohibits discrimination against borrowers whose source of income is public assistance. A lender may test whether income is dependable and likely to continue. A lender may not discount it because of where it comes from.

Pre-qualified is an estimate; pre-approved is verified

REMEMBER: A buyer tells you she is pre-qualified for $600,000. Name the one sentence you would say to her before she writes an offer on a $590,000 house.

Evaluating the Borrower: the Five C's

What every lender is really asking, and what the underwriter does with the answers

A lender deciding whether to make a loan is answering one question in five parts. Can this person pay, and if he stops paying, is the property worth enough to get the money back? The five C's are how the industry breaks that question up, and every verification form in the file is evidence for one of them.

Capacity

Can the borrower pay the mortgage along with other debts and obligations?

Collateral

Are the down payment and property value enough for the lender to recoup its money in foreclosure?

Credit

Does past payment history show willingness and ability to repay?

Character

Job and personal stability, will obligations be honored even through setbacks?

Conditions

Do the borrower's job field and general economic conditions look favorable?

Two of the five are about willingness rather than arithmetic. Credit asks whether past payment history shows a willingness and an ability to repay obligations. Character asks whether the borrower has stability in a job and in his responsibilities, such that even with setbacks the obligations will be honored. A borrower can clear every ratio in this chapter and still fail on those two.

Collateral is the C about the house rather than the person. The lender asks whether the down payment and the property value are sufficient to recoup its money if foreclosure becomes necessary. That is why the appraisal is ordered, and why a lender looks at whether the property is a one- to four-family, whether it is owner occupied, and whether it produces income.

FROM APPLICATION TO ANSWER

1 Processing

The lender reviews and verifies what was submitted; the credit report, verification forms, and appraisal are assembled into a loan package.

2 Underwriting

The underwriter weighs the risk: can the borrower reasonably make the payment, and is there enough value in the collateral? Meet both and Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac call it an “investment quality loan.”

3 The decision

Approve, reject, or approve with conditions. The underwriter, human or automated with human referral, is usually the final decision maker.

Automated underwriting changed the job without removing it. Software applies the qualifying standards and either recommends acceptance or refers the file to a human underwriter. In many cases the underwriter cannot override the system either way, and the role becomes verifying the data that went into it.

Credit scoring assigns numerical values to open accounts, limits, outstanding debt, late payments, and liens. The higher the score, the better the risk, low scores can mean a declined application or a higher rate.

Credit history is a record of debt repayment. Borrowers must tell the lender about all debts, including obligations that may never show up on a credit report, and a borrower who hides one is building the underwriter's decision on a false file.

NOTE: Different lenders set their own cutoff scores. A score that is fine at one lender can produce a decline or a higher rate at another, so a client who was turned down has not been turned down by every lender in New York.

Two questions: can he pay, is it worth it

REMEMBER: Name the C that fails when a buyer with perfect credit wants to borrow more than the appraisal supports.

Qualifying Ratios, and How to Run Them

A buyer must qualify under both ratios; the smaller answer governs

Lenders evaluate a borrower's income against his debt load to decide how much mortgage debt he can comfortably carry, and they do it with two ratios. The first tests the housing payment against income. The second tests all recurring debt, housing included, against the same income. A borrower has to clear both.

The payment being tested is PITI. Principal, interest, taxes and insurance, added together as one monthly figure.

PITI, the payment being tested

Principal + Interest + Taxes + Insurance; add association fees (as with a condo) for the complete housing expense. Lenders often collect taxes and insurance monthly into an escrow, impound or reserve, account, then pay them on the owner's behalf when due.

Recurring debt is the second ratio's material, and the ten-payment rule is what decides what counts. Anything with ten or more payments remaining is recurring debt. A car loan with twenty payments left counts in full. Telling a buyer to ignore a debt because it is almost paid off is how a file comes back short.

Qualifying standards vary from lender to lender, but with lenders selling loans to the national secondary markets, most have incorporated Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac standards into their own conventional underwriting. FHA and VA guidelines are more liberal. A borrower considered marginal by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac may qualify more easily for an FHA or a VA loan.

Here are the ratios.

Loan type

Payment-to-income (PITI)

Debt-to-income (PITI + debt)

Conventional (Fannie/Freddie)

28% of income

36% of income

FHA-insured

31% of income

43% of income

VA-guaranteed

Not used, residual income instead

41%, ALL debt incl. utilities

The VA line is the odd one and the exam knows it. A VA-guaranteed loan does not apply a payment-to-income ratio at all. It looks at residual income, which is the income a borrower has left after subtracting taxes, housing and recurring debt obligations, and the VA has regional guidelines estimating the cost of utilities by house size that are counted as part of the debt obligations.

WORKED EXAMPLE, RALPH

Stable monthly income $2,900 · car payment $320/mo

TEST 1 · PAYMENT-TO-INCOME

$2,900

income

28%

$812

max PITI

TEST 2 · DEBT-TO-INCOME

$2,900

income

36%

$1,044

total debt

$1,044

−

$320

car loan

$724

max PITI

Qualify under BOTH, the smaller number wins. Ralph's ceiling: $724 PITI.

Work Ralph's numbers yourself and the method transfers to any loan type. Test one multiplies income by the housing ratio and stops. Test two multiplies income by the debt ratio and then subtracts the known debts, because the debt ratio covers the mortgage and everything else together. The lower of the two answers is what the borrower may spend on housing.

FHA and VA ratios work the same way, just with their own percentages.

NOTE: Students fail this question by stopping after test one. Running only the payment-to-income ratio gives Ralph $812 and a loan he does not qualify for. Run both, every time, and take the smaller.

Both ratios, then the smaller number

REMEMBER: Give yourself $4,000 of income and a $500 car payment and run both conventional tests in your head. What is your ceiling?

Lesson 5

Bankers, Brokers, and Mortgage Loan Originators

Who lends, who places, who originates, and how New York licenses each

Mortgage Banker, Mortgage Broker, and Who Regulates Them

The Department of Financial Services, not the Department of State

Chapter 1 listed the other licenses that touch real estate in New York and said the mortgage ones would be handled here. The first thing to fix is the regulator. Your real estate license comes from the Department of State. A mortgage banker's license and a mortgage broker's registration come from the New York State Department of Financial Services, and the applications go through the Nationwide Mortgage Licensing System and Registry, the NMLS, which provides a centralized and standardized system for mortgage licensing across the country.

Two regulators means two sets of consequences. Being in good standing with the Department of State is no answer to the Department of Financial Services.

MORTGAGE BANKER: THE LENDER

The actual lender of the mortgage money, in the primary market; also called a mortgage company

Originates, underwrites, and services loans, comprehensive companies do all three

Charges an origination fee plus interest; sells loans to secondary-market investors and keeps servicing them for fees

License required from NY DFS for anyone originating 5+ mortgage loans in any one year

Origination, underwriting and servicing are three separate functions, and a comprehensive mortgage company does all three on the same loan. Origination is making or initiating the new loan: taking the application, pulling the credit report, ordering the appraisal, assembling the file. Underwriting is deciding whether to make the loan, done by the funding source and almost never by a mortgage broker. Servicing is the continued maintenance of the loan afterward: statements, collection, pursuing late payments.

MORTGAGE BROKER: THE PLACER

MORTGAGE BROKER, REGISTERED

Article 12-D: solicits, processes, places, or negotiates mortgage loans FOR OTHERS, it does not lend

Scope: 1- to 4-family owner-occupied residential property in New York State

Must register with the Superintendent before engaging in the business

Needs 2 years of credit analysis or underwriting experience (or must employ someone who has it), plus a $10,000–$100,000 surety bond by volume

Article 12-D of the New York Banking Law defines a mortgage broker as a sole proprietor or company engaged in the business of soliciting, processing, placing or negotiating mortgage loans for others, on one- to four-family owner-occupied residential property located in New York State. The words for others are the whole distinction. A mortgage broker does not lend. It places the loan with someone who does, and it must first be registered with the Superintendent.

NEW YORK MORTGAGE BANKER LICENSE

NEW YORK MORTGAGE BANKER LICENSE, WHAT IT TAKES

$250K

adjusted net worth

Maintained at all times.

$1M+

line of credit

From a bank or insurer outside the corporate structure.

$50–500K

corporate surety bond

Principal amount scaled to volume of business.

5 yrs

verifiable experience

Making mortgage loans, retail or wholesale, plus fingerprints and a background check.

CAUTION: Banker and broker are separated on the exam by one question. Whose money reaches the closing table? The banker's money is the banker's. The broker is placing somebody else's.

Bankers lend; brokers place; DFS regulates both

REMEMBER: Which agency would you call about a mortgage broker's registration, and which one would you call about the same person's real estate license?

The Mortgage Loan Originator

An individual licensed under Article 12-E of the Banking Law

A mortgage loan originator does not lend money. An MLO earns a fee to act as an intermediary bringing together borrowers and the lenders who originate the actual loans, and the fee is the point. As defined by New York Banking Law, a mortgage loan originator is an individual, a natural person rather than an organization or entity, who takes a mortgage loan application or offers or negotiates terms of a mortgage loan for, or in the expectation of, compensation or gain.

Three things make somebody an MLO. A natural person. Taking an application or negotiating terms. Compensation, or the expectation of it. A person doing all three without a license is originating loans without one, whatever else he is licensed to do.

THE EXCLUSION EVERY REAL ESTATE LICENSEE NEEDS

The definition excludes an individual who performs only real estate brokerage activities and is licensed under applicable New York law, unless that individual is compensated by a lender, a mortgage broker, or another mortgage loan originator. Your real estate license covers you while you are doing real estate work. The moment a lender or a mortgage broker pays you, the exclusion drops away and you are inside the MLO definition.

That sentence is the hinge of the chapter for a working agent, and it lines up with Regulation 175.7 from Chapter 3, which limits compensation from more than one party in a transaction except with full disclosure and the consent of all parties. One payment, two regulators.

What an MLO does

Solicit, process, place, and negotiate residential loans: pre-qualify buyers, gather documentation for pre-approval, submit applications, explain rates, points, and fees, negotiate a rate lock, secure the lender's written mortgage commitment, and schedule the closing.

Two terms come out of that work and both are on the exam. A rate lock is the agreed interest rate and points frozen until the loan closes. A mortgage commitment is the lender's written letter confirming its willingness to lend the money, and securing it is what the file has been building toward.

An MLO is especially useful to a borrower who needs a nonconforming loan, one that does not follow the standards set by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, whether because it exceeds the maximum loan amount or misses the minimum qualifying standards.

The SAFE Act (2008)

Part of the Housing and Economic Recovery Act: national minimum training standards to cut fraud. Every residential MLO must be state-licensed (NY Banking Law Article 12-E) or federally registered, registration is only for employees of federally supervised depository institutions.

Who is exempt from licensing

Registered MLOs at depository institutions; anyone negotiating a loan for an immediate family member; loans on the individual's own residence; certain attorneys and manufactured home sellers. Loan processors and underwriters are excluded, unless working as independent contractors.

An applicant must demonstrate the financial responsibility, character and fitness necessary to command the confidence of the community, and to warrant a determination that he or she will operate honestly, fairly and efficiently.

PRELICENSING EDUCATION, RENEWAL AND BONDING

20 hrs NMLS prelicensing education

The twenty hours break down as three hours of federal law and regulations, three hours of ethics covering fraud, consumer protection and fair lending, two hours on lending standards for the nontraditional mortgage marketplace, three hours of applicable New York law and regulations, and nine hours of electives related to the mortgage industry. Nontraditional is defined by the SAFE Act and Article 12-E as anything other than a fixed rate 30-year mortgage.

December 31

every license expires

Renewed annually through the NMLS.

11 hrs

annual continuing ed

Evidence due by the expiration date.

Plus: pass the NMLS written test (with a NY-specific portion), and carry a surety bond, the originating entity's bond can cover it, sized by prior-year volume.

An MLO must be employed by, or an independent contractor to, ONE licensed or registered originating entity, never affiliated with more than one at a time.

NOTE: The exemptions are narrow and they are tested by changing one fact. Registered MLOs at depository institutions. A loan negotiated for an immediate family member, which includes stepfamily and adoptive relationships. A loan on the individual's own residence. Certain attorneys and manufactured home sellers. Change family member to friend, or own residence to rental property, and the exemption is gone.

Take the fee, meet the definition

REMEMBER: You refer a buyer to a lender and the lender offers you $500 for the referral. Name the definition you just walked into and the regulation from Chapter 3 that reaches the same payment.

When the Agent Is Also the Mortgage Broker

Dual agency on the financing side, under Article 12-D of the Banking Law

Dual agency exists when a real estate licensee represents both the buyer and the seller as clients, and Chapter 3 taught what that costs and how it is disclosed. The same problem appears on the financing side, and it appears in a form that looks harmless enough to walk into.

The Lisa problem

A buyer asks Lisa, the listing agent, to recommend a mortgage broker, and Lisa is one. As real estate licensee her primary responsibility runs to the seller; as mortgage broker it would run to the buyer/borrower. That is dual agency: she must explain the concept to BOTH buyer and seller and obtain consent from BOTH parties before taking on the role.

Take the conflict apart before the paperwork. As the real estate licensee she represents the seller in the sale, and her primary responsibility is to the seller. As the mortgage broker she represents the buyer in the acquisition of the mortgage loan, and her primary responsibility is to the buyer. Those two responsibilities point in opposite directions on the one number both parties care about.

THE DISCLOSURE

3 years

minimum retention

A hard or electronic copy of the disclosure form and signed acknowledgment must be kept by the MLO.

The disclosure form

Required by Article 12-D and signed by BOTH parties. It may be in writing or sent electronically; signatures may be handwritten or digital where New York law recognizes them as binding.

What consent costs

The form warns each party they are giving up the right to undivided loyalty, urges them to weigh the consequences, suggests consulting an attorney, and reminds each side they may hire their own separate broker instead.

Three or fewer, or more

The form states whether the broker ordinarily places mortgage applications with three or fewer lenders, or with more than three, and each party acknowledges which.

The content of the form is worth knowing, because the exam asks what it says. The licensee may represent them only with the knowledge and informed consent of each of them. By consenting they give up the right to undivided loyalty. The licensee is not a legal expert or an attorney and they may wish to consult one before signing. And the buyer may retain a real estate broker or mortgage broker who represents only the buyer, while the seller, subject to any contract or agreement already signed, may retain a real estate broker who represents only the seller.

The lender-relationship rule

Any regular business relationship the mortgage broker maintains with a lender must be disclosed at the FIRST substantive contact with the buyer/borrower. Sole exception: a broker submitting applications to more than three lenders.

Any regular business relationship the mortgage broker maintains with a lender she presents applications to must be disclosed at the first substantive contact with the buyer or borrower, and the exception is a broker who submits applications to more than three lenders. A broker sending every file to one lender has a relationship the borrower needs to know about before it starts steering the file.

Now stack the rules, because they come from three places and all reach the same transaction. Article 12-D of the Banking Law requires the dual agency disclosure and both signatures. Regulation 175.7 limits compensation from more than one party except with full disclosure and consent of all parties. And your license law from Chapter 1 says a salesperson takes compensation only from the sponsoring broker. A salesperson collecting a fee directly from a lender has a problem under all three at once.

CAUTION: Consent here means both parties, in writing, before the role is taken on. A buyer who is told and a seller who is not told is not dual agency consent. It is the disclosure half done, and the half that was skipped belongs to the client the licensee owes the most.

Explain it, get both signatures, keep it three years

REMEMBER: You list a house and the buyer asks you to place his mortgage. Name the three documents or duties that attach the moment you say yes.

Chapter 14

Key takeaways

The mortgage instrument. A mortgage creates a voluntary lien on real property to secure a debt, between the mortgagor who borrows and the mortgagee who lends. It is recorded in the county where the property sits, and recording gives constructive notice and sets lien priority. Other states use a deed of trust, with a third party holding the security and a power of sale that allows foreclosure without a court. New York uses the mortgage and requires judicial foreclosure.

Types of loan. By repayment: graduated payment, with its scheduled negative amortization, and straight or term, which pays interest and ends in a balloon. For equity: open-end, home equity loan, home equity line of credit, and the reverse equity mortgage. By situation: construction with its end loan, bridge, blanket with a partial release clause, package, no doc, sale-and-leaseback, purchase money, land contract and wraparound.

Clauses. Acceleration calls the whole balance on default. Alienation, the due-on-sale clause, calls it on transfer, and FHA and VA loans may not contain one. Defeasance ends the mortgage when the debt is paid, and the mortgagee prepares the satisfaction of mortgage for the record. Prepayment penalties are prohibited in FHA and VA loans. Subordination lets a later-recorded mortgage take priority over an earlier one.

Foreclosure. Default, lis pendens, order of execution, sheriff's sale, confirmation of sale. The equitable right of redemption runs from the lis pendens to confirmation, and New York has no statutory right of redemption after it. Proceeds pay back taxes, then foreclosure costs, then lienholders in priority order, then the debtor. A tax lien is the only lien that pre-empts a first mortgage. A shortfall can become a deficiency judgment, which is a general involuntary lien against all of the debtor's property.

TILA and RESPA. Reg Z requires uniform disclosure of credit cost, makes the APR the central number, controls advertising through triggering terms, and gives a right of rescission until midnight of the third business day on credit secured by an existing primary residence. RESPA and Reg X reach the closing. TRID merged their forms: Loan Estimate within three business days, no closing for seven days after it, Closing Disclosure three business days before closing, terms held ten business days.

Applying and qualifying. Pre-qualification estimates and binds nobody; pre-approval is verified and put in writing. The 1003 captures the mortgage terms, the property and the borrower. Lenders weigh capacity, collateral, credit, character and conditions, and test stable monthly income for quality and durability. Run both ratios and take the smaller answer.

Bankers, brokers and originators. The Department of Financial Services licenses and registers all three through the NMLS. Mortgage bankers lend, and originate, underwrite and service. Mortgage brokers place loans for others under Article 12-D and register with the Superintendent. MLOs are individuals licensed under Article 12-E, and a real estate licensee who is compensated by a lender or a mortgage broker falls inside the MLO definition.

Dual agency on the financing side. A licensee acting as both listing agent and mortgage broker must explain dual agency to the buyer and the seller, obtain the signed consent of both, keep the disclosure and acknowledgment for at least three years, state whether she places applications with three or fewer lenders or more, and disclose any regular lender relationship at the first substantive contact.

One chapter, one habit: follow the money to its source

REMEMBER: Which of these eight could you not explain to a buyer at a kitchen table right now? Go back to that screen before the quiz.

YOU BE THE JUDGE

The Sheepshead Bay Shortfall

Denise, a salesperson at Emerald Shore Realty, decides her Sheepshead Bay listing will “close faster if I run the financing myself.” She takes the buyers' loan application and negotiates the rate and points with Metro Funding, which pays her a $1,500 fee for the file, she holds no MLO license, “because I'm already licensed in real estate.” Arranging the loan on her own listing, she mentions to the buyers, but never to the sellers, that she is “wearing two hats,” collects only the buyers' signature on a form she drafts herself, and shreds her signed disclosure forms every January to keep the files thin. Though she has placed every application this year with Metro Funding, she says nothing about that relationship when she first sits down with the buyers.

Her open-house flyer reads “Pay only $1,450 a month, just 10% down!” and nothing more. At the kitchen table she pre-qualifies the Okafors herself, working through their income and debts. Then she assures them the pre-qualification “locks the bank in, approval is guaranteed now.” The Okafors bring home $3,000 a month in stable income and pay $400 a month on a car loan with twenty payments left; Denise tells them a conventional lender will allow a full $1,080 PITI payment, “thirty-six percent, and forget the car, it's almost paid off.”

Across town she advises a 58-year-old widow with a small remaining mortgage balance to “take a reverse mortgage, any homeowner qualifies, and the checks start next month.” For a buyer who cannot qualify at the bank, she engineers a wraparound: the seller keeps his existing low-rate loan, which contains a due-on-sale clause, and takes one combined payment from the buyer, “and the bank never has to know.” To an FHA buyer she explains the fine print: “expect a prepayment penalty if you ever pay early, every mortgage has one.”

Then her former client Marisol calls in tears: a lis pendens has been filed on her house. “Once that's filed it's over,” Denise tells her. “You can't save it, wait for the auction.” Back on the Okafor file, the loan sails through underwriting and Denise books the closing. At the table, the settlement agent hands the Okafors their first-ever look at the five-page Closing Disclosure; Denise waves them on: “standard paperwork, sign and let's get your keys.”

Twelve violations are buried in that story, and one lawful act has been planted among them to catch you out. Work it the way you would work a file rather than the way you would take a test.

Read it once straight through and mark nothing. Read it again with a pen and mark every sentence that made you pause, without deciding yet whether it is wrong. Then name the rule each marked sentence touches. A sentence you cannot tie to a rule is one you have not finished with.

THE LICENSING ISSUES COME FIRST

Start with what Denise did rather than what she said. Hold the sentence about the loan file beside the definition of a mortgage loan originator. A natural person. Taking an application or negotiating terms. Compensation. Count how many of the three she meets, then read the exclusion a real estate licensee normally enjoys and find the words that take it away from her. Who paid her is the fact that decides it.

That payment reaches her from two more directions. Chapter 3 gave you a regulation about compensation from more than one party in a transaction. Chapter 1 gave you a rule about who a salesperson may accept compensation from. An issue she breaches three ways is worth three sentences in your answer.

Then work the dual agency paperwork as a checklist. A disclosure required by name, a set of people who must sign it, a retention period for the signed copy, and a moment at which a regular lender relationship must be disclosed. Mark which she met, which she half met, and which she never attempted.

THE ADVERTISING AND THE ARITHMETIC

The flyer is a Reg Z problem and the rule is mechanical. Decide whether anything on it is a triggering term, and if it is, list what the advertisement was then required to include, in the words the regulation uses, including the one that must be spelled out in full.

The kitchen table has two things happening at it and only one is wrong. One act is something a licensee is permitted to do, and it is the planted lawful act if you can say why. The other is a statement about what that act guarantees, and it turns a non-binding estimate into a promise the lender never made.

Then run the Okafors' numbers rather than arguing about them. Three thousand dollars of stable monthly income. A four hundred dollar car payment with twenty payments left. Conventional ratios. Run test one, run test two, subtract what the ten-payment rule says must be subtracted, and compare your answer to her figure. Two errors sit in that one sentence: the test she skipped and the debt she told them to forget.

THE PRODUCT ADVICE

Three statements about three loan products, and each fails on a specific fact. For the widow, check both qualifying facts for a reverse equity mortgage and say which one she fails. For the wraparound, find the clause in the seller's existing loan, say what it entitles the lender to do on a transfer, and name who loses the house when the lender does it. For the FHA buyer, find the sentence on the clause screen about what FHA and VA loans may not contain, and notice that she has it backwards.

Marisol's call has a clock on it. Go to the foreclosure screen, find the two events the redemption window runs between, and work out how much of it is still open on the day of that call. Then say what a licensee who knew the rule would have told her to do that afternoon.

The closing table is a deadline. Name the form the Okafors are seeing for the first time, name the number of business days it was supposed to arrive ahead of closing, and say what that waiting period was for, because the purpose explains why seeing it at the table defeats it.

Sort everything you marked into three piles. Clearly a violation. Clearly lawful. Cannot tell from these facts. The third pile teaches the most, because each item in it needs the missing fact named.

Write each answer in three parts. The fact, quoted from the story. The rule, named from this chapter or the chapter that carries it. The advice a licensee who knew the rule would have given, in the words you would have used with that client in front of you.

Then argue the other side of the item you were least sure about, out loud, as though Denise has a reason for everything she did. If you cannot build that argument, go back to the screen the rule came from.

NOTE: If your answer to an issue is a rule with no facts attached, you have not spotted an issue. You have recited a rule and hoped it fit. Name the fact first, then the rule, then what should have been said instead.

Name the fact, then name the rule

Check yourself

11 questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see whether it is right and why.

Key terms

Graduated payment mortgage
A loan with small early payments that create scheduled negative amortization, then rise to fully amortize the balance.
Reverse mortgage
A loan for homeowners 62+ with little or no mortgage balance in which the lender pays the borrower; repaid on sale, death, or 12 months' absence.
Blanket mortgage
One mortgage covering several parcels, usually with a partial release clause.
Wraparound mortgage
Seller financing in which a new loan is combined with the seller's existing loan; the buyer pays the seller, who keeps paying the original lender.
Purchase money mortgage
Any loan used to buy real estate, specifically, a mortgage the seller takes back for part of the price.
Adjustable rate mortgage
A loan whose rate equals an index plus the lender's margin, adjusting at set periods within rate caps.
Alienation (due-on-sale) clause
A clause letting the lender accelerate the debt or change terms when the property is transferred; not permitted in FHA or VA loans.
Defeasance clause
The provision that voids the mortgage once the debt is repaid; the lender records a satisfaction of mortgage.
Equitable right of redemption
The debtor's right in New York to save the property by paying what is due any time from the lis pendens until confirmation of the foreclosure sale.
Deficiency judgment
A personal judgment against the debtor for the shortfall when foreclosure proceeds do not cover the debt.
Deed in lieu of foreclosure
The debtor's voluntary conveyance of the property to the lender to avoid a foreclosure on the credit record.
Regulation Z
The Truth in Lending Act rule requiring uniform disclosure of credit costs (APR), regulating triggering terms in ads, and giving a three-day rescission right on loans secured by an existing residence.
TRID
The TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure rule: Loan Estimate within 3 business days, Closing Disclosure 3 business days before closing.
PITI
Principal, interest, taxes and insurance, the housing payment tested in qualifying ratios (conventional 28/36, FHA 31/43).
Pre-approval
A lender's verified commitment to lend a stated amount if circumstances stay the same; pre-qualification is only a non-binding estimate.
Mortgage loan originator
An individual who takes loan applications or negotiates terms for compensation; licensed under NY Banking Law Article 12-E through the NMLS (20 hours education, exam, annual renewal).

Practise this chapter

Flashcards (free) Practice exam

Read Chapter 14 in the Book

The Book comes with the Salesperson pass ($39 for 3 months).

A study course, in beta. This is not a New York State Department of State approved qualifying course, and the time you spend here does not count toward the 77 hours you need for a salesperson license. Take the 77-hour course at a DOS-approved school; use this to learn the material and to review it. · Powered by License to Earn LLC