The Course · Chapter 13 Beta

Chapter 13: Overview of Real Estate Finance

In this chapter

  • The two instruments Distinguish the financing instrument, the promissory note, from the security instrument, the mortgage.
  • Primary vs secondary Explain the difference between the two mortgage markets and why the second one keeps the first one funded.
  • Types of primary lender Identify the primary mortgage lenders and what each one specializes in.
  • How a loan is repaid Compare fully amortizing, straight, and partially amortizing loans, and recognize negative amortization.
  • Mortgage insurance Explain what PMI covers, what it costs, and exactly when it must come off the loan.
  • Predatory lending Recognize the twelve indicators, the HOEPA protections, and the three foreclosure rescue scams.

Lesson 1

Finance Instruments

Two documents: a promise to pay, and something to take if you don't

The Note and the Mortgage

Two documents: one creates the debt, the other creates the remedy

Finance instruments are the legal documents that establish the rights and duties of every party to a transaction. A purchase made with borrowed money produces two. The financing instrument is the promissory note. The security instrument is the mortgage. Learn them as a pair, because almost every mistake a new licensee makes here comes from treating them as one document.

A promissory note is a written promise to pay. The person promising to pay is the maker of the note, usually the homebuyer, who is also the mortgagor. The person who is promised payment is the payee, usually the lender and sometimes the seller. The note is the basic evidence of the debt. It shows who owes how much to whom.

The note is a short document, often less than a page long. It carries the date, the names of the parties, the amount of the debt, how and when the debt is to be paid, what happens in the event of default, and the signature of the maker.

The note is the debt. Strip everything else away and the maker still owes the money. A debtor who signs a note and no security instrument at all is still obligated to pay it. Start there, because that one fact tells you what the second document is for.

Negotiable instruments

Most promissory notes used in real estate are negotiable instruments, freely transferable from one party to another. A bank holding a note can sell it for immediate cash, usually at a discount, meaning for less than face value, and whoever buys it collects the payments from then on.

Negotiable instruments are governed by the Uniform Commercial Code, which sets requirements for what such an instrument must contain. A note missing those elements may still be valid between the original parties and fail once it is transferred. That matters, because most real estate lenders sell their loans. A secondary market investor buys only a negotiable note, because the investor wants to be a holder in due course: one who acquires the instrument in good faith and for consideration, with rights beyond those of the original payee.

THE SECURITY INSTRUMENT

A security instrument allows a debtor to hypothecate property. Hypothecation means pledging property as security for a debt without giving up possession of it. The borrower keeps the keys and lives in the house. The lender holds a claim against it. The most common security instrument is the mortgage, in which the borrower, the mortgagor, pledges the property to the lender, the mortgagee, as collateral for the debt.

A mortgage creates a lien against the title. The owner keeps title and keeps the usual rights of ownership. What the mortgagee gets is the right to pursue the mortgagor's real estate to satisfy the debt if the debt is not paid, and in New York that right has to be exercised through a court.

Besides making the payments, a mortgagor takes on duties that run for the life of the loan. Keep the property in good repair. Insure it properly. Pay all taxes and assessments. Pay the debt the mortgage secures. Those duties protect the collateral. A house that burns uninsured, or goes to a tax sale, is a house the lender can no longer look to. Some mortgages also offer a grace period, allowing leniency in the payment schedule.

WHAT EACH SIDE GAINS AND GIVES UP

The lender's main advantage is the right to accelerate the debt in the event of default, calling the whole unpaid balance due at once. Without it, a lender chasing a borrower who missed three payments could sue for three payments. Its main disadvantage is the time and expense of judicial foreclosure, the process followed in New York on a default, which runs through a court and takes months.

Both of those facts land on the borrower, and they pull in opposite directions. Acceleration means a homeowner who misses one or two payments may face paying off the entire debt to save the home. Judicial foreclosure takes long enough that debtors usually have several months to find the money due. The first is the borrower's exposure. The second is the borrower's cushion.

Two other documents will cross your buyer's desk before closing. The Loan Estimate and the Closing Disclosure are federal forms that describe the loan: rate, payment, costs and who pays them. Those forms describe the deal. The note and the mortgage create it. Chapter 14 covers them and the law behind them.

NOTE: A question that asks which document is the evidence of the debt, or which one carries the borrower's promise, is asking for the note. A question about collateral, pledging, the lien, or what the lender forecloses on is asking for the mortgage.

The note is the debt, the mortgage the security

REMEMBER: If a borrower signed a note and the lender never took a mortgage, would the borrower still owe the money, and what would the lender have given up?

The Loan-to-Value Ratio

The lender always uses the LOWER of the appraised value or the sale price

The loan-to-value ratio compares the money borrowed to the value of the property. Divide the loan amount by the value and what comes out is the LTV. A $64,000 loan on an $80,000 property is an 80% LTV.

The lender cares about LTV because the down payment is the lender's cushion. If the loan goes bad and the property has to be sold, the sale has to cover the balance, and the borrower's equity absorbs the first loss. The lower the LTV the bigger the cushion. Every number on this screen follows from that.

The lender will always use the lower of the appraised value or the sale price, to protect its own interest. A buyer who agrees to overpay is free to overpay. The lender will not lend against a price an appraiser cannot support.

THE 80% LINE

80% conventional

LTV 80%

LOAN AMOUNT 80%

20% down

The standard conventional loan for many years. No PMI required.

90% conventional

LTV 90%

LOAN AMOUNT 90%

10% down

Qualifying standards above 80% LTV are more stringent, and PMI is required.

95% conventional

LTV 95%

LOAN AMOUNT 95%

5% down

The MAXIMUM LTV allowed by conventional standards.

Put those three tiers on one house. On a $160,000 purchase, an 80% loan is $128,000 with $32,000 down, a 90% loan is $144,000 with $16,000 down, and a 95% loan is $152,000 with $8,000 down. The first step up cuts the buyer's cash at closing by $16,000 and the second by $8,000, and each one hands the lender a thinner cushion, which is what the tighter qualifying above 80% is paying for.

Case in Point, when the appraisal comes in low

THE FACTS

Bill wants a $160,000 house on an 80% conventional loan: borrow $128,000, put $32,000 down. The appraisal comes back at $150,000.

THE RULING

The lender uses the lower of the two figures, so Bill can borrow only 80% of the appraised $150,000, that is $120,000.

WHY IT MATTERS TO YOU

He can offer the seller the appraised $150,000, find another $8,000 for the down payment, or apply for a higher-LTV loan.

80%

the standard

$80,000 × 0.8 = $64,000 loan, $16,000 down.

The property is half of what an underwriter looks at. Sale price and appraised value. Location and condition. What comparables sold for. Loan to value and the down payment behind it. And the type of property: one to four family, owner occupied or income producing.

NOTE: LTV is applied to the lower of the two figures every time, and an exam question will hand you the higher one first. Write both numbers down, circle the smaller, then multiply.

Lend on the lower of price and appraisal

REMEMBER: A low appraisal leaves your buyer $8,000 short. Name her three options, and say which one costs the seller money.

Lesson 2

The Primary and Secondary Markets

Where the money is lent, and where it comes back from

The Primary Mortgage Market

Lenders who make mortgage loans directly to borrowers

The primary mortgage market consists of the lenders who make mortgage loans directly to borrowers. It is made up of lending institutions in local communities, and the source of the money is largely the savings deposits of individuals and businesses in the local area. Money that neighbors put in the bank is money the bank lends back out on neighborhood houses.

That is the whole engine. A depositor lends the bank money and is paid interest on it. The bank lends that money out to a borrower at a higher rate. The difference is what the bank earns. Every institution below is a variation on that idea.

Commercial banks

Financial institutions that provide a variety of financial services, including loans. Banks are the largest source of investment funds in the country today, and they tend to focus on relatively short-term commercial and consumer loans rather than thirty-year mortgages.

Savings and loan associations

Financial institutions that specialize in taking savings deposits and making mortgage loans. In the late 1970s and early 1980s, management mistakes, economic slumps and sometimes fraud drove many S&Ls toward insolvency. They were not using the uniform qualifying standards set by major secondary market investors such as Fannie Mae, so they could not sell their loans and could not raise cash against them. Today S&Ls are the leading home mortgage lenders and follow Fannie Mae qualifying standards. Read that history as a lesson about the secondary market.

Mortgage companies

Institutions that originate and service loans on behalf of large investors such as insurance companies, pension plans or Fannie Mae. Those investors operate nationally and have neither the time nor the resources to understand local risk or manage loans day to day. Mortgage companies lend some of their own money but function largely as intermediaries. They resell the loans to secondary market investors and stay on as agent to service them for a fee, and their qualification criteria have to reflect national standards so the loans can be resold.

CAUTION: A mortgage company lends money. A mortgage broker does not. A mortgage broker arranges a loan between a borrower and a lender and is paid for arranging it. Chapter 14 takes up mortgage brokerage in full, including what New York requires of one.

Credit unions

Nonprofit financial institutions owned and operated entirely by their members. Depositing money in a credit union makes the depositor a member with partial ownership. Joining usually requires belonging to a participating organization such as an employer, a school or a labor union.

Finance companies

Organizations that specialize in making higher-risk loans at higher interest rates. Finance companies are often the source of second mortgages and home equity loans made directly to borrowers.

Portfolio lenders

Financial institutions such as mortgage companies, savings and loans or commercial banks that originate loans and then service them in house instead of selling them on the secondary market. A portfolio lender keeps the loan and keeps the risk that goes with it, and that is exactly why a portfolio lender can approve a file nobody else will touch. It answers to its own standards rather than to somebody else's resale requirements.

Mutual savings banks

State-chartered institutions owned by their depositors and operated for their benefit. Conservative by nature, mutual savings banks often hold a large portion of their assets in home mortgages.

Federal law shaped all of this. The Federal Reserve Act of 1913 created the Federal Reserve System and a federal charter permitting banks to make real estate loans, an early step toward a system through which government could influence interest rates. Banking legislation in the 1930s created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation and the Federal Savings and Loan Insurance Corporation. Deposit insurance gave banks and S&Ls a continued source of funds for home mortgages, because a depositor who is not afraid of losing the money leaves the money where it is.

NOTE: Every one of the seven institutions listed on this screen lends to borrowers. Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and Ginnie Mae hand money to lenders. A question asking which of four names is not a primary market lender is testing that one line.

Primary lenders lend to borrowers

REMEMBER: Which of these seven would you expect to keep a loan rather than sell it, and what does keeping it let that lender approve?

How the Secondary Market Recycles Capital

Private investors and government agencies that buy and sell real estate mortgages

The secondary mortgage market consists of private investors and government agencies that buy and sell real estate mortgages. The federal government established it to moderate local real estate cycles. Secondary markets buy loans from all over the country as investments. Primary markets are local.

HOMEBUYER

borrows

PRIMARY LENDER

makes the loan locally

SECONDARY AGENCY

buys the mortgage

INVESTORS

buy mortgage-backed securities

cash returns to the primary lender, who makes another loan, and sells that one too

Follow the money around that circle once and the point of the system appears. A local lender has a fixed amount of money. Lend it out over thirty years and it is gone for thirty years. Sell the loan the month after closing and the money comes back at once, ready to lend again. If it keeps servicing the loan it sold, the lender collects a servicing fee on it, and it has a new loan besides. The town gets mortgage money that does not depend on how much the neighborhood deposited that year.

A mortgage is purchased by the secondary market ONLY if the primary lender conformed to secondary-market underwriting standards. Secondary markets buy loans from all over the country as investments; primary markets are local, with local lenders making local loans.

That first sentence is the price of admission, and it is why a loan application looks the same in Buffalo as in Brooklyn. Standardization is what makes a loan sellable. A lender who writes a loan its own way has written a loan it has to keep.

Why loans are bought and sold

Both markets are trying to maximize returns. As interest rates rise it is more profitable to sell older, lower-rate loans so the lender has new money to lend at higher rates. Trading mortgages also frees funds for lending again, which stabilizes local real estate markets, the reason the federal government established the secondary market in the first place.

Securitization

Securitization is the act of pooling mortgages and selling them as mortgage-backed securities. A single home loan is an awkward thing to own. One borrower, one house, one town, and it cannot be sold in a hurry. A thousand of them pooled and sold as securities is something a pension fund can trade like any other bond. It is how Fannie Mae funds its operation.

NOTE: Primary and secondary are about who the counterparty is. A primary lender deals with a borrower. A secondary agency deals with a lender.

Sell the loan, lend the money again

REMEMBER: Interest rates rise sharply this year. Say in one sentence why that makes a lender keener to sell the loans it wrote three years ago.

Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and Ginnie Mae

Three agencies account for most of today's secondary mortgage market activity

Three agencies account for most of today's secondary mortgage market activity. Two of them buy loans. One of them guarantees securities. Keep that split in mind and the three stop blurring together.

Fannie Mae

The Federal National Mortgage Association, Fannie Mae, was created to provide a place for banks and other lenders to sell FHA-insured loans. It is a government-sponsored enterprise under the conservatorship of the Federal Housing Finance Agency. Fannie Mae purchases conventional mortgages as well as FHA and VA loans, and it funds its operation by securitization. It is the nation's largest investor in residential mortgages. Its creation is also the reason home mortgage loans became standardized across the country, because a lender that wants to sell to Fannie Mae writes the loan Fannie Mae's way.

Freddie Mac

The Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation, Freddie Mac, was created in 1970 as a nonprofit, federally chartered institution controlled by the Federal Home Loan Bank System, and it is also a GSE under FHFA conservatorship. Freddie Mac does not guarantee payment of its mortgages. Its primary function is to help savings and loan associations acquire additional funds for lending by purchasing the mortgages they already hold. It may work with FHA, VA and conventional mortgages. Where Fannie Mae emphasizes purchasing, Freddie Mac also actively sells loans out of its portfolio as a conduit, and the proceeds buy more mortgages.

Ginnie Mae

The Government National Mortgage Association, Ginnie Mae, was created in 1968 as a government-owned corporation operating under the Department of Housing and Urban Development. Being government owned puts it in a different category from the other two. Its primary function is promoting investment by guaranteeing the payment of principal and interest on FHA and VA mortgages through its mortgage-backed securities program, supported by the federal government's borrowing power. That backing is what lets a Ginnie Mae security trade on the strength of the government rather than on any particular pool of borrowers.

CONFORMING AND NONCONFORMING

$806,500 (2025)

conforming limit

The FHFA resets the Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac limit every year, $806,500 for a one-family home in most of the U.S. for 2025 (it was $417,000 in 2016). Always check the current year's figure.

$1,209,750 (2025)

high-cost counties

The high-cost-area ceiling (150% of the baseline), which applies to New York City and the surrounding counties.

What matters about a conforming limit is the mechanism, not the figure. A loan at or under the limit can be sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. A loan over it cannot. The line is redrawn for the coming year, and high-cost areas get a higher line. Look up the current number for the year and the county you are working in, and never quote a limit to a client from memory.

A conforming loan meets Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac standards and can therefore be sold on the secondary market. Lenders make as many as they can, because a conforming loan is one they can liquidate for cash whenever they need funds. A nonconforming loan cannot be sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, though other secondary markets exist for it. Lenders who keep loans in their own portfolio, mostly banks and S&Ls, may deviate from secondary market standards within the law.

Two things usually make a loan nonconforming. The size of the loan, where a jumbo loan exceeds the maximum conforming amount. And the credit quality of the borrower. Neither makes the loan improper. Both make it a loan somebody has to be willing to hold.

NOTE: Two buy and one guarantees. Fannie Mae is the largest investor in residential mortgages. Freddie Mac acts as a conduit and does not guarantee payment. Ginnie Mae guarantees principal and interest on FHA and VA mortgages under HUD. Learn the verbs and the questions answer themselves.

Conforming means saleable to Fannie or Freddie

REMEMBER: A borrower needs $300,000 more than the conforming limit in his county. Which two doors are still open to him, and what will each one cost him?

Lesson 3

Conventional and Government Loans

What is insured, what is guaranteed, and what is neither

Private Mortgage Insurance

What makes a loan above 80% LTV possible in the first place

It insures the lender, and only the top slice of the loan

PMI is offered by private companies to insure a lender against a borrower's default. The insurer does NOT insure the entire loan amount, only the upper portion, the amount that exceeds the standard 80% LTV. Coverage varies but is typically 20–25% of the loan amount. Both Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac require third-party insurance on home loans with down payments of less than 20%.

Work out what that coverage does for the lender and you have the whole product. On a 95% loan the lender has advanced fifteen points more than it would have without insurance, and the insurance covers the top slice of it. The lender ends up holding something close to the risk of an 80% loan while the borrower puts down 5%. That is the trade, and it is why the product exists at all.

Put a number on it. A 95% loan on a $160,000 house is $152,000, and coverage at 25% of the loan amount is $38,000 of protection sitting on top of the $8,000 the buyer put down. Between the down payment and the policy, the lender has roughly $46,000 of cover on a $160,000 house. That is what makes a 5% down payment acceptable to somebody whose money is at risk.

The traditional charge is a one-time fee at closing plus a recurring RENEWAL PREMIUM added to the monthly mortgage payment.

The borrower pays the premium and the lender collects the benefit. A buyer who thinks PMI protects her from losing the house is a buyer nobody has explained it to, and explaining it is part of your job.

If the borrower defaults

The insurer and the lender negotiate how best to proceed, the insurer could pay off the loan and take title, or allow the lender to foreclose.

If the foreclosure proceeds do not fully reimburse the lender for the principal balance, the lender may claim against the insurer. If the insurer takes the loan, it may be able to file for a DEFICIENCY JUDGMENT against the borrower.

WHEN PMI MUST COME OFF, KNOW ALL THREE NUMBERS

78%

automatic cancellation

The Homeowners Protection Act of 1998 requires lenders to automatically cancel PMI on conventional loans closed after 29 July 1999 once the loan is paid down to 78% of the home's current or original value, whichever is lower.

80%

cancellation on request

The same law says lenders must drop PMI coverage at a borrower's request once the loan is paid down to 80% or less of the home's value and mortgage payments are current.

25%

New York, equity in the home

State law requires lenders to stop charging PMI once the borrower has 25% equity. Exceptions: multi-family units, non-owner-occupied homes, second homes, and second mortgages.

Convert those three numbers into one another before you sit the exam. 78% of value means 22% equity. 80% of value means 20% equity. New York's 25% equity is a 75% loan to value. It is one scale read two ways, and a question will pick whichever direction you are less used to.

The 80% number requires somebody to act. The lender drops the coverage at the borrower's request once the loan is paid down to 80% or less and payments are current, and a borrower who never asks keeps paying month after month. A call to a past client three years after closing reminding her to ask is worth more to her than most of what you will send her, and it costs you nothing.

NOTE: PMI insures the lender against the borrower's default. It is bought by the borrower, paid for by the borrower, and collected by the lender. Every wrong answer on a PMI question is some version of the idea that it protects the buyer.

PMI covers only the slice above 80%

REMEMBER: Your buyer puts 10% down. Which of the three cancellation numbers will reach her first, and what does she have to do to use it?

Points and Buydowns

A point is 1% of the LOAN amount, never of the sale price

A point is 1% of the loan amount. That is the entire definition, and the exam tests it.

Points get charged for two different reasons, and running the two together is where students lose the question. Some points pay for the work of making the loan, covering the administrative costs of processing it, and they show up on the paperwork as a loan origination fee, a loan fee, a service fee or an administrative charge. Other points buy something. A discount point is money paid to the lender up front in exchange for a lower interest rate across the life of the loan. The lender takes its money sooner and gives up rate in return. Read what each point on the sheet is actually buying before you tell a client whether it is worth paying.

The caps

For FHA and VA loans the loan fee can be no higher than one point. For conventional loans the fee varies, and it is often in the one- to four-point range.

Who pays

Points may be paid by the buyer or by the seller. Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and the FHA limit the points and other contributions paid by the seller or other interested parties, so a seller concession has a ceiling on it.

The buydown

A buydown is additional money, in the form of discount points, paid to the lender at the beginning of a loan to lower the interest rate and the monthly payments. A permanent buydown maintains the lower interest rate through the entire life of the loan. A temporary buydown lowers the rate and the payments early in the loan, with the interest rate or the payments rising later in the term. A client offered a temporary buydown is being offered a low payment now and a higher one later, and she should know which year it changes before she signs anything.

WORKED EXAMPLE, ANN'S CLOSING

Ann buys at $200,000, puts $40,000 down and borrows $160,000 from County Bank.

1 point

loan origination fee

$1,600

1 point

to service the loan

$1,600

4 points

to buy the rate down by half a percentage

$6,400

6% of the mortgage amount, paid at closing

$9,600

Work Ann's closing forward yourself rather than reading it. The loan is $160,000, so one point is $1,600. The origination point and the servicing point together are $3,200. Four points to buy the rate down are $6,400. Six points come to $9,600, which is 6% of the $160,000 she borrowed. Six percent of the $200,000 she paid for the house would have been $12,000. The $2,400 gap between those two numbers is the reason this screen exists.

Remember two things about points. They are computed as 1% of the LOAN AMOUNT, not the sale price, Ann's six points are 6% of $160,000, not of $200,000. And they can be charged for a variety of reasons, so read what each one is actually buying.

NOTE: The wrong answer is always sitting on the page. A points question hands you a sale price and a loan amount in the same sentence and then puts the percentage of the sale price among the choices. Find the loan amount first. Multiply second.

Points are on the loan, not the price

REMEMBER: A seller offers to pay two points on your buyer's $260,000 loan. What is that worth in dollars, and what would you need to know before saying it beats a $6,000 price cut?

FHA-Insured and VA-Guaranteed Loans

Neither agency makes loans: one insures, the other guarantees

Two federal programs stand behind residential loans, and neither one of them lends a dollar. The FHA insures the lender against loss. The VA guarantees the lender against loss up to a set amount. In both cases the money comes from an approved private lender, and what the government supplies is a promise that lowers the lender's risk. Lower a lender's risk and the lender will accept a smaller down payment and a thinner file. That is the mechanism behind both programs on this screen, and it is worth saying to yourself once before you learn the details.

FHA · FEDERAL HOUSING ADMINISTRATION

Part of HUD. Its primary function is to INSURE loans, the FHA does not make loans or build homes

No income limits. Insures only FIRST mortgage loans on one- to four-family units, based on a sound appraisal

Lower down payment, the FHA minimum is 3.5%, less stringent qualifying, and no prepayment penalties

HUD limits the maximum insurable loan in a given community, based on the median price of homes there. Boundaries may follow a county, zip code, or MSA; amounts are reviewed every three years

The FHA ceiling is a local number by design. HUD sets the maximum insurable loan community by community based on the median price of homes there, so two towns twenty minutes apart can carry different limits. Look up the current figure for the county you are working in rather than carrying one in your head, and tell your buyer where you looked.

VA · DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS

Guarantees repayment of certain residential loans to eligible veterans. The VA does not make loans, it guarantees lenders against losses for the guaranty amount

Eligibility: generally more than 180 days' active duty in peacetime or at least 90 days in wartime, no dishonorable discharge, validated by discharge papers (DD-214) plus a VA Certificate of Eligibility

No down payment required, no maximum loan amount, secondary financing permitted, no prepayment penalties, origination fee capped at one point, and assumable in some circumstances

Must be OWNER-OCCUPIED. Single-family: the veteran must intend to occupy it. Multi-family up to four units: the veteran must occupy one of them. The VA charges a funding fee; disabled veterans may be exempt

The occupancy rule is where a salesperson gets a veteran into trouble. A VA loan buys a home to live in. A veteran may buy a building of up to four units with one, and he has to occupy one of those units himself. A veteran who wants to buy a building purely as an investment and rent out every unit is asking the program for something it does not do, and telling him otherwise puts his file and your license in the same sentence.

MIP IS NOT PMI. A mortgage insurance premium is required on ALL FHA loans regardless of the size of the down payment. There is an upfront premium (UFMIP) payable at closing, which may be financed into the loan, and if it is, the UFMIP does NOT count toward the loan-to-value. FHA loans also carry a monthly MIP on the balance, based on the LTV and the loan term: a 30-year loan at 95% LTV carries a higher MIP than a 15-year at 90%. Critically, MIP does NOT go away automatically when the loan-to-value reaches a certain point, on some FHA-insured loans the borrower pays it for as long as the loan is active.

Put the two insurance products side by side once and the difference sticks. PMI comes off a conventional loan automatically at 78% and on request at 80%. MIP is required on every FHA loan whatever the down payment, and on some FHA-insured loans it runs for as long as the loan is active. A borrower choosing between a conventional loan at 95% and an FHA loan at 3.5% down is choosing between an insurance premium that ends and one that may not. That is a conversation for her loan officer, with you in the room listening closely enough to catch it if the answer is wrong.

NOTE: Insures, guarantees, lends. Three verbs, and the question is nearly always which verb belongs to which agency. The FHA insures. The VA guarantees. SONYMA, on the next screen, is the one that lends.

FHA insures, VA guarantees, neither lends

REMEMBER: A veteran client asks whether he can use his benefit on a four-unit building. What is your answer, and what is the one condition you have to say out loud?

USDA Rural Development and SONYMA

The rural program, and the one government program that lends

Two more programs sit behind residential loans in New York. One is federal and reaches rural areas. One is the state's own, and it is the exception to everything on the last screen.

USDA Rural Development housing programs

The USDA Rural Development direct and guaranteed loan programs provide low-interest, no-down-payment loans to help eligible families living in rural areas purchase homes. The direct loan program is geared toward low-income individuals. The Department of State syllabus lists the same programs under the name Rural Housing Service.

Eligible applicants are qualified for a loan amount up to a county-by-county limit based on debt-to-income ratios. Applicants must have an acceptable credit history and adequate, dependable income. Borrowers must personally occupy the dwelling following the purchase, and the dwelling must be structurally sound, functionally adequate and in good condition. That condition requirement catches deals. A rural property that would sell fine for cash can fail the program on a roof.

The standard term for a loan in this program is 33 years. Three extra years against a thirty-year loan is a smaller payment on the same balance, which is the point of it. Depending on the applicant's income, loans may be subsidized and interest rates may be reduced to as low as 1%. Closing costs may be included in the loan, which matters to a buyer whose problem is cash at closing rather than income.

SONYMA, State of New York Mortgage Agency

Created in 1970 to reduce funds shortages from private banks for mortgage lending within New York. It is THE ONLY GOVERNMENT PROGRAM THAT IS A DIRECT LENDER. Its programs make housing affordable to low- and moderate-income households and are funded by the sale of tax-exempt bonds.

Below-market interest rates

Low or no down payment requirements

No prepayment penalties

Closing cost assistance

The tax-exempt bond is where the below-market rate comes from. An investor will accept a lower return on a bond whose interest is not taxed, so the agency raises money more cheaply than a bank does and passes the difference on as a lower mortgage rate. The saving is real and it comes out of the tax treatment of the bond.

Four programs, four doors into the same building.

SONYMA program

Target audience

Additional information

Remodel New York

First-time homebuyers and owners in target areas

Helps finance the cost of renovations

Achieving the Dream

Low-income, first-time homebuyers

Offers the lowest interest rate of any SONYMA program

Construction Incentive Program

First-time homebuyers purchasing new builds

Offers 100% financing with a stepped interest rate that is lower for the first four years

Homes for Veterans Program

Qualified veterans

Loans require only 3% down

You do not need to know the fine print of any of them. You need to know the names exist, so that a client who does not fit the one program you have heard of gets asked about the others instead of being told no. The agency and its participating lenders handle the qualifying.

NOTE: The FHA insures. The VA guarantees. SONYMA lends. If a question asks which government program is itself the direct lender, the answer is the New York one.

SONYMA lends its own money

REMEMBER: A first-time buyer wants a house that needs $40,000 of work. Which SONYMA program would you ask her lender about by name?

Lesson 4

How a Loan Is Repaid

Principal, interest, and the shape of thirty years

The Amortization Curve

Every payment is the same size, and what it buys changes completely

A mortgage has two components. The principal is the amount originally borrowed. The interest is the charge a borrower pays a lender for the use of the lender's money. Amortization is the reduction of the loan balance by paying back some of the principal on a regular basis.

Here is why the curve bends. Interest is charged on the balance still outstanding. The payment is level, the same figure every month for the whole term. Each month the lender takes the interest owed on the current balance first, and whatever is left goes to principal. Pay down principal and next month's balance is smaller, so next month's interest is smaller, so more of the same payment reaches principal. The process feeds itself.

$200,000 borrowed at 6% over 30 years, level payment of $1,199 a month

$231,676

total interest over the term

More than the amount borrowed, which is why the schedule is worth showing a client.

Run the first payment on that loan yourself. Six percent of $200,000 is $12,000 a year, which is $1,000 in the first month. The payment is $1,199, so $1,000 goes to interest and about $199 goes to principal. Twelve months of that pays the balance down by roughly $2,456. Your client has handed the bank about $14,389 over her first year and owns $2,456 more of her house.

The last year looks nothing like the first, and the payment never changed. Around year 19 the principal portion finally overtakes the interest portion. By the final year that same $1,199 is almost all principal, with a few hundred dollars of interest left in the whole year.

That level payment has a name worth carrying into the investment chapters. Debt service is the periodic payment of principal and interest on a loan.

The amortization schedule

Shows exactly how much of each payment goes to principal and how much to interest over the life of the loan, year-to-year or month-to-month, and the total the loan costs over its entire term.

AMORTIZATION is the reduction of the loan balance by paying back some of the principal on a regular basis. With a fully amortizing loan, each payment is applied FIRST to interest owed and then to principal, so early on most of it is interest, and if every payment is made on time the loan is paid off in full with the last scheduled payment.

NEGATIVE AMORTIZATION is the opposite: the loan balance GROWS because the payments do not cover the interest on the loan. It is one of the practices HOEPA prohibits on high-cost loans, any interest rate change or payment cap must be coordinated so the schedule at minimum pays off the interest.

NOTE: A question asking what happens to the interest portion of a level payment over the term is asking one thing: does the balance go down? It does, so interest goes down and principal goes up. The payment itself never moves on a fixed-rate loan.

Interest follows the balance down

REMEMBER: After a full year of payments on that $200,000 loan, how much more of the house does your client actually own?

Three Ways a Loan Is Structured

Fully amortizing, straight, and partially amortizing

Three repayment structures, and what separates them is what is left owing at the end of the term.

Fully amortizing

Regular payments are applied first to the interest owed and then to the principal, over a number of years called the term. Early on more goes to interest. If all payments are made on time the loan is paid off in full with the last scheduled payment.

Straight, or interest-only

Regular payments cover only the interest over the term. The balance never moves, because nothing is ever applied to principal. At the end of the term a lump sum payment of the principal is required.

Partially amortizing

Periodic payments pay down some principal but do not fully amortize the loan by the end of the term. The final payment is larger than the others and is called a balloon payment.

Line the three up and the pattern is plain. Fully amortizing ends at zero. Straight ends owing everything. Partially amortizing ends owing something in between. A client signing a balloon is signing up to refinance, sell or produce a lump sum on a date certain, and she should have that date circled.

TWO MORE THINGS THAT CHANGE WHO OWES WHAT

Assumption

One party agrees to take over payments of another's debt, with the terms of the note unchanged. The property remains security, and the BUYER becomes PRIMARILY liable, but in the event of foreclosure the SELLER remains SECONDARILY liable. Rarely possible with loans written today, though some conventional mortgages allow it if they have no enforceable alienation clause. Advise clients to consult the original lender or a lawyer.

Read that liability rule slowly. The buyer becomes primarily liable. The seller remains secondarily liable. A seller who walks out of that closing believing he is finished with the loan is wrong unless the lender released him.

Subprime loans

Also called B-C loans or B-C credit, more risk than the conforming market allows. Prime loans go to customers with good credit at rates posted publicly; for less-than-perfect credit, rates are quoted on the risk the lender associates with the loan, and larger down payments or secondary owner financing may be required. The UNDERWRITER makes the final decision.

The underwriter is the person the whole file is built for, and the underwriter answers two questions. Is the property worth lending against: price, appraised value, condition, location, comparables, loan to value and the down payment behind it, and whether it is one to four family, owner occupied or income producing. And can the borrower repay: income and how long it has been steady, employment history, qualifying ratios measuring the housing payment against gross monthly income, liquid assets, monthly obligations and a credit report. Chapter 14 works those ratios with numbers.

NOTE: Straight loan, interest only, one lump sum at the end. Partially amortizing, some principal paid, balloon at the end. Those two get swapped in the answer choices more than any other pair here.

Zero, everything, or something in between

REMEMBER: Which structure leaves a client owing the most five years in?

Lesson 5

Predatory Lending and Foreclosure Scams

The motive is profit, take the property, strip the equity, or live off the fees

What Predatory Lending Looks Like

Loans that take advantage of ill-informed consumers, and the fees that do the damage

Predatory lending involves loans that take advantage of ill-informed consumers through excessively high fees, misrepresented loan terms, frequent refinancing that does not benefit the borrower, and other prohibited acts. It targets borrowers with little knowledge of these practices and little defense against them.

The motive is profit, and it arrives in three shapes. Take the property. Strip the equity out of it. Or live off the fees. Every scheme on this screen and the next three is one of those three wearing a different suit, and you can sort any story a client brings you by asking which of the three the other side is after.

Predatory loans are approved without regard for the borrower's ability to repay. Interest rates are higher than the level of risk justifies. Lenders may bundle unrelated products into the mortgage loan, a life insurance policy for instance, to push the profit further. All of it happens while the lender claims to be helping the borrower reach the American dream of homeownership, which is what makes it hard for the borrower to see.

Specifically prohibited

Packing a loan with credit insurance and other extra fees

Extending credit to people with little or no income and little chance of repaying, the lender forecloses and keeps the excess equity

Refinancing the lender's own high-cost loan with another fee-rich loan in less than a year, unless the new loan demonstrably benefits the borrower

WHAT IT COSTS THE BORROWER

Exorbitant fees

Loan origination and settlement fees, unreasonable servicing fees, and unknown charges in poorly disclosed fine print. A dozen or more may appear under a variety of names alleging services done on the borrower's behalf. Fees greater than 4–5% of the loan amount are usually too much; some scams have involved 10–20% or more.

Put that guideline into dollars once and it stops being abstract. On a $160,000 loan, 4 to 5% is $6,400 to $8,000, and that is already the outer edge of reasonable. The 10 to 20% that some scams have involved is $16,000 to $32,000 taken out of a borrower's equity at a single closing. A borrower who cannot read a settlement statement never sees it leave.

Prepayment penalties

Exorbitant penalties lock borrowers into abusive loans that cannot be refinanced when credit scores improve. They may run to thousands of dollars and persist five years into the loan, the point is to discourage payoff of a highly profitable loan.

A prepayment penalty is a lock, and its purpose is what tells you whether it is abusive. A modest penalty in the first year or two compensates a lender who priced the loan expecting to hold it for a while. A penalty running to thousands of dollars that persists five years into the loan exists to stop the borrower from refinancing out of a loan that is very profitable to somebody else. Same instrument, two intentions, and the size and the duration are what separate them.

Equity skimming

Making loans knowing the borrower cannot make the payments, setting up a foreclosure in which the borrower loses the home and the equity in it. Home improvement scams and loan flipping are both forms of it.

Extreme lending

Borrowers with very high debt relative to income are the target. More than 8% of homeowners put 50% or more of income toward the mortgage, against a conventional guideline of no more than 28%, one lay-off away from foreclosure.

That 28% guideline is worth understanding rather than memorizing. A qualifying ratio measures the housing payment against gross monthly income. A borrower earning $5,000 a month gross, held to 28%, is being kept to about $1,400 of housing payment. Push the same borrower to 50% and she is paying $2,500, with $2,500 of gross income left, before taxes, for food, transport, medicine and everything else in her life. That is the household one lay-off away from foreclosure, and a lender who wrote the loan knowing it is a lender who was aiming at the house.

NOTE: A high rate charged to a genuinely risky borrower is legitimate. A rate higher than the risk justifies, on a loan approved without regard to whether the borrower can pay it, is predatory. The distinction comes up again on the next screen and it comes up on your exam.

Take the property, the equity, or the fees

REMEMBER: Which of the three motives explains a lender who refinances the same borrower every eleven months, and what is that practice called?

The Twelve Indicators of Predatory Lending

As identified by the Mortgage Bankers Association

The Mortgage Bankers Association identifies twelve indicators of predatory lending. Twelve is a list to recognize on sight rather than recite, and it sorts into four families. Learn the families and the twelve come back to you.

Price and payment

Steering borrowers to high-rate programs. Structuring high-cost loans with unaffordable payments. Increasing interest rates for late payments. Charging excessive prepayment penalties. Four of the twelve are about what the loan costs and how the cost is arranged so the borrower cannot get out from under it.

The documents

Falsely identifying loans as lines of credit or open mortgages. Falsifying loan documents. Forging signatures on loan documents. Changing loan terms at closing. Four more are about the paper. The loan the borrower agreed to and the loan the borrower signed are two different loans.

Who is targeted

Making loans to mentally incapacitated homeowners. Requiring credit insurance. Two are about choosing a borrower who cannot resist, and then selling a product on top of the loan that the borrower neither asked for nor needs.

After the closing

Failing to report good payment history on a borrower's credit report. Failing to provide the accurate loan balance and payoff information. The last two happen after everyone has gone home and they are the quietest of the twelve. A borrower whose good payments are never reported never improves her credit score. A borrower who cannot get a payoff figure cannot refinance away. Both keep her where she is, which is the point.

For many borrowers, loan documents are simply hard to understand, legal jargon, small print, page after page presented for immediate signature, with pressure to finish the closing and no time to read. The solution is not a sharper eye: have an attorney review all documents before signing, or get a credit counselor or other expert to review them.

Legitimate subprime lending is not predatory lending. Subprime lenders must charge higher rates and fees to accommodate genuine risk, without them, riskier borrowers could not tap home equity or own a home at all. They have been accused of predatory lending where the allegations were unfounded, which makes it harder for borrowers to tell who is legitimate.

Hold that distinction, because your clients will not hold it for you. A legitimate subprime lender charges more because the risk is real. A predatory lender charges more because the borrower will not notice. From the rate sheet alone they can look alike, which is why the advice you give is procedural: have a lawyer read it before you sign it.

NOTE: You are not the person who decides whether a loan is predatory. You are the person who notices something and says so out loud. Telling a client to have an attorney review the documents is inside your license. Telling her the loan is illegal is not.

Recognize the pattern, name the fix

REMEMBER: Which two of the twelve could happen to a client who never misses a payment, and how would she find out?

Anti-Predatory Lending Law

HOEPA amended the Truth in Lending Act in 1994, and New York added its own in 2003

Laws have been enacted at the federal, state and city level to stop predatory lending. The federal one is the Home Ownership and Equity Protection Act, HOEPA, which amended the Truth in Lending Act in 1994. It prohibits equity stripping, where a homeowner loses the equity in a home through excessive fees, along with other abusive lending practices. It is enforced by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, for all federally regulated depositories, and by the Federal Trade Commission.

HOEPA does not reach every loan. It reaches loans that meet its definition of a high-cost loan, and what it does to those loans is take options away from the lender. Read the protections below as a list of things a lender may no longer do to a borrower who is already paying more than most.

Understand what that structure buys the consumer, because most consumer lending law follows the same model. The law identifies loans expensive enough to be dangerous, then strips out the features that turn an expensive loan into an inescapable one. A high rate you can see is survivable. A high rate plus a balloon plus a prepayment penalty plus no verification of whether you can pay is a trap, and the trap is what the statute dismantles.

Balloon payments

Prohibited on HOEPA loans with terms of less than five years. Covered loans must also have regular payments that pay down principal, or at minimum pay the interest.

Negative amortization

Loans with any interest or payment adjustment that could result in negative amortization are not permitted. Rate changes and payment caps must be coordinated to avoid it.

Pressure tactics

Lenders must include text in the disclosure stating the consumer is not required to complete the credit transaction, to counter implications of being locked in, or that cancelling is complex or expensive.

Loan pricing

Loans subject to HOEPA must not include more than two advance payments from the loan proceeds. The borrower should get maximum use of the funds.

Acceleration clauses

Part of the predatory practices HOEPA controls. The regulation prohibits increasing interest rates if the customer is in default.

Prepayment penalties

Generally prohibited unless limited to the first five years, and prohibited outright if the consumer's total monthly debts including the HOEPA loan exceed 50% of verified gross monthly income.

Loan flipping

Refinancing a HOEPA loan within a one-year period is strictly prohibited unless it is clearly in the borrower's best interest.

Demand clauses

Any provision enabling the creditor to call the loan before maturity is strictly prohibited, except for fraud, material misrepresentation, default, or damage to the property.

Income verification

HOEPA makes it illegal to lend without verifying the consumer can repay. Lenders must compile written income verification and a written record of ratios such as debt-to-income or cash flow analysis.

Four of those rules come back to a single idea, and seeing it turns four items into one. The balloon rule, the negative amortization rule, the income verification rule and the prepayment penalty rule all point the same direction. The payment schedule has to actually retire the debt, and the borrower has to actually be able to make the payments. A lender who verified nothing and wrote a schedule that never pays the loan down was not making a loan. He was scheduling a foreclosure and collecting fees until it arrived.

New York's 2003 anti-predatory lending law

Applies restrictions to HIGH-COST LOANS that are first or junior lien mortgages. To qualify, the loan must be for a principal amount less than the Fannie Mae conforming limit for a comparable dwelling, up to $300,000; for personal or family purposes, not business; and on real property of one to four units used as the borrower's primary residence. It sets further fee and interest thresholds, bans lending without regard to ability to pay, and urges borrowers to seek financial counseling.

Look at how that definition is built, because the shape of it is the lesson. It reaches first and junior lien mortgages. It reaches one- to four-unit property the borrower actually lives in. It reaches loans taken for personal or family purposes rather than for business. And it caps the loan size by reference to the Fannie Mae conforming limit for a comparable dwelling, with its own ceiling sitting on top of that. A definition pinned to a limit that is reset every year is a definition that moves every year, which is one more reason to check a current figure rather than quote the one you learned in this course.

NYC PACE program

Preserve Assets and Community Equity, begun in 2005 by Mayor Bloomberg and HPD to fight predatory lending. It educates homeowners in targeted segments, works with community and nonprofit organizations to help those already victimised, and offers legal and financial assistance, loans, training and counseling.

Notice what a program like PACE does, because it is the pattern every anti-predatory effort follows once the statutes are written. Education before the loan. Help for those already caught. And somebody to call who is not the lender. A licensee who knows one local counseling program by name is more use to a frightened homeowner than one who can recite all nine HOEPA protections.

NOTE: HOEPA's prepayment rule has two halves and questions test the second half. Generally prohibited unless limited to the first five years of the loan. And prohibited outright if the consumer's total monthly debts, including the HOEPA loan, exceed 50% of the gross monthly income verified by the creditor.

High-cost loans lose options

REMEMBER: A client shows you a high-cost refinance with a three-year term and a balloon at the end. Which HOEPA protection does that break, and what is the number inside it?

Foreclosure Rescue Scams

When foreclosure rates rise, so do the scams that follow them

Scam artists, known as “rescuers”, find victims through public foreclosure notices in newspapers and at government offices, or from private companies that sell the lists. The National Consumer Law Center identified three common varieties.

Notice how the victim is found, because it is the part clients never expect. Foreclosure is public. A notice runs in a newspaper or sits in a government office where anyone may read it, and private companies gather those names and sell them. A homeowner in default does not go looking for a rescuer. The rescuer already has her address before she has told a single friend.

Phantom help

Ridiculously high fees are charged for minimal help, or the rescuer promises to represent the borrower further, and simply does not.

Bailout

Homeowners surrender title to their home believing they will be able to rent it back from the rescuer, and eventually buy it back.

Bait and switch

Homeowners do not realize they are surrendering homeownership in exchange for being rescued.

All three are heavily promoted and all three claim to save the borrower from foreclosure. All three end in the homeowner losing the equity in the home or losing ownership altogether. Sort them by what the homeowner hands over. Phantom help takes money. Bailout and bait and switch take the deed, one with a story about renting it back and one without the homeowner understanding what she signed.

WHY THE TACTICS WORK

Trusting the wrong people

A borrower facing the loss of a home is emotionally vulnerable; criminals exploit the belief that the perpetrator is genuine, fuelled by the desire to be saved.

Few or no details

Most consumers have never been through foreclosure and do not know how or when things happen, or what recourse exists. The rescuer implies his help is the only way.

Fraud and deception

Forgery, lies, fake documents and blank documents, signed to give the impression that action is being taken, while signing away the property or its equity.

Lack of financial knowledge

Borrowers do not realize they are falling prey to high-interest loans or exorbitant, unnecessary fees.

Desperation

Once foreclosure starts, time is short. Rescuers are experts at manufacturing pressure and lying about when the owner will lose the home.

Affinity and saturation marketing

Rescuers present themselves as “one of us” to religious groups, seniors and others, even choosing a business name to suggest it, then make repeated contact until the promises land.

Read those tactics together and a pattern appears. Every one works on a person who is frightened, short of time and short of information. Supply any one of those three and the scheme gets much harder to run. That is what a licensee is good for here. You cannot fix her finances. You can give her time by telling her the process is slower than the rescuer says, and information by telling her exactly who to call.

ADVISE CLIENTS: avoid anyone calling himself a foreclosure consultant, and if he seems credible, check references and licensing and ask people in the lending business about him. Never work with anyone who solicits door to door or advertises to those on pending foreclosure lists. Never pay an upfront fee, and never give anyone mortgage payments to pass along, always pay the lender or servicer directly. Be wary of anyone claiming to pay closing costs on a new loan or wanting to buy the home as is. And never sign the title over to anyone to avoid foreclosure.

Two lines on that list carry more weight than the rest. Never pay an upfront fee. And never give anyone mortgage payments to pass along. Payments go to the lender or to the loan servicer, directly, every time. A homeowner who sends two payments to a middleman has not made two payments, and by the time the servicer's letter arrives she is two months further into the foreclosure than she believed she was.

Know where your license ends here. You may tell a client what these scams look like. You may tell her to call her lender or her servicer, to check references and licensing on anyone calling himself a foreclosure consultant, and to see a lawyer. What you may not do is take her file on, quote her a payoff figure, or turn the conversation into an offer to buy the house yourself. A licensee who warns her about a rescuer and then makes her an offer looks to her exactly like the next rescuer.

NOTE: One fact separates a bailout from an ordinary sale, and it is the promise. A homeowner who sells her house and moves out has sold her house. A homeowner who signs over the deed believing she can rent it back and buy it back later has been handed a promise, and the promise is almost never kept.

The deed goes one way only

REMEMBER: A past client calls to say a man found her name in the legal notices and wants a fee to save her house. Name the three things you would tell her in the first two minutes.

Session Summary

The eight things to carry out of Chapter 13

Eight ideas carry this chapter. Every one is a mechanism rather than a fact to memorize, and a mechanism survives the year the numbers change.

Two instruments

The promissory note is the financing instrument. The maker promises to pay, the payee is promised payment, and the note is the basic evidence of the debt. It is a negotiable instrument governed by the Uniform Commercial Code, which lets a lender sell it and lets the buyer become a holder in due course. The mortgage is the security instrument. The mortgagor hypothecates the property to the mortgagee as collateral, keeping possession and the usual rights of ownership while the mortgagee holds a lien. The note is the debt. The mortgage is the remedy.

Primary market

Lenders making loans directly to borrowers, funded largely by local savings deposits. Commercial banks, S&Ls, mortgage companies, credit unions, finance companies, portfolio lenders and mutual savings banks. A portfolio lender keeps what it writes. A mortgage broker does not lend money at all.

Secondary market

Private investors and government agencies buying and selling mortgages, established by the federal government to moderate local real estate cycles. Sell the loan and the money comes back to be lent again, which is why a local market is not limited to local deposits. A loan is saleable only if the originating lender met secondary market underwriting standards, and that is what standardized home lending nationwide. Fannie Mae is the largest investor in residential mortgages. Freddie Mac acts as a conduit. Ginnie Mae, under HUD, guarantees principal and interest on FHA and VA mortgage-backed securities.

Conventional loans and LTV

A conventional loan is not insured or guaranteed by a government agency. The lender applies the loan-to-value ratio to the lower of the appraised value or the sale price, always. 80% is the standard, above 80% the qualifying tightens and insurance is required, and 95% is the conventional ceiling. A point is 1% of the loan amount and never 1% of the sale price.

PMI and MIP

Private mortgage insurance insures the lender and covers only the portion of the loan above 80% LTV. It cancels automatically at 78%, on request at 80% with payments current, and New York requires it to stop at 25% equity. The mortgage insurance premium on an FHA loan is a different animal. It is required whatever the down payment, and it does not fall away automatically.

Government programs

The FHA insures. The VA guarantees. Neither makes a loan. FHA sets a 3.5% minimum down payment and insures first mortgages on one- to four-family homes. VA requires no down payment but requires owner occupancy and caps the origination fee at one point. USDA Rural Development runs direct and guaranteed loan programs in rural areas on a 33-year term. SONYMA is New York's own agency, funded by tax-exempt bonds, and the only government program that is a direct lender.

Repayment

A fully amortizing loan applies each payment to interest first and then to principal, reaching zero with the last scheduled payment. A straight loan pays interest only and leaves the whole principal due in a lump sum. A partially amortizing loan ends in a balloon payment. Negative amortization is the balance growing because the payments do not cover the interest. On an assumption the buyer becomes primarily liable and the seller stays secondarily liable.

Predatory lending

Excessively high fees, misrepresented terms, and refinancing that does not benefit the borrower. Twelve indicators from the Mortgage Bankers Association. HOEPA amended the Truth in Lending Act in 1994 and bans balloon payments on high-cost loans of less than five years, bans negative amortization, bans flipping within a year unless the new loan is clearly in the borrower's best interest, limits prepayment penalties and requires verification of the ability to repay. New York added its own high-cost loan law in 2003. Foreclosure scams: phantom help, bailout, bait and switch.

One warning to carry out with the eight. Almost everything in mortgage finance that carries a number moves. Conforming limits, FHA ceilings, PMI thresholds, qualifying ratios, rates and the points charged on them get reset, some every year. The figures here teach the mechanism. They are not a reference table, and a client who needs a number needs today's number from the lender.

NOTE: If you can state what the lender is protecting itself against, you can usually derive the rule. LTV protects against a foreclosure sale that does not cover the balance. PMI protects the slice above 80%. Acceleration protects against a slow default. Underwriting protects against a borrower who cannot pay.

Mechanisms last, numbers do not

REMEMBER: Of the eight, which one would you have to explain to a buyer at a first meeting, and could you do it in ninety seconds without notes?

YOU BE THE JUDGE

The Riverhead Rate Trap

Tomas has a buyer, Della, under contract at $240,000 in Riverhead. Della asks him which loan she should take. Tomas sits her down and walks her through his recommendation in detail, the 30-year over the 15-year, the adjustable over the fixed, and why she should pay four discount points to buy the rate down. He tells her the points will run “four percent of the two-forty, so about $9,600.” The appraisal comes back at $228,000. Tomas tells her not to worry: on an 80% conventional loan the bank will still lend her 80% of the $240,000 purchase price.

Della is short on cash, so the file moves to a 90% loan. Tomas explains that private mortgage insurance will cover the whole loan amount if she ever defaults, so the bank is fully protected, and that the lender will drop the PMI automatically as soon as she is halfway through the term. When she asks about an FHA loan instead, he tells her the mortgage insurance premium works the same way and falls off by itself once she has enough equity. He adds that if she qualifies, “the FHA will write you the loan directly.”

Della's brother-in-law Ray is a veteran who wants to buy a two-family house in Southold and rent out both units as an investment. Tomas tells him a VA-guaranteed loan is perfect for that, and that the lender he works with charges a two-point origination fee on VA files, which is standard. Ray's own lender, meanwhile, is a legitimate subprime shop: because Ray's credit is thin, it quotes him a rate well above the posted prime rate and higher-than-typical closing and processing fees. Tomas tells Ray that is simply what the risk costs.

A third client, Mrs. Aldana, is behind on a high-cost first mortgage. The lender that wrote it eleven months ago offers to refinance her into another one of its own fee-rich loans, this time a three-year term with a balloon payment at the end. Tomas tells her it sounds like a fresh start. He also passes along the card of a foreclosure consultant who found her name in the legal notices, the man wants a fee up front, asks her to make her next two mortgage payments to him instead of the servicer, and says the fastest fix is to sign the title over to his company and rent the house back until she is on her feet.

12 violations are buried in this story

, plus one lawful act planted to catch you out.

How many can you spot?

Work it the way you would work a file rather than the way you would take a test. Read it through once without marking anything. Read it again with a pen and mark every sentence that made you pause. Then name the rule each marked sentence touches.

MUCH OF THIS STORY IS ARITHMETIC

Half of what Tomas gets wrong turns on a number, and a number can be checked. Every figure in the first two paragraphs runs in one line on the back of an envelope, and the envelope will tell you he is wrong before any rule does.

Run the points calculation yourself. Write down the definition of a point from this chapter in the exact words. Then write the two dollar figures from the first paragraph and label which is the sale price and which would be the loan. Multiply the way the definition tells you to and compare your answer to the figure Tomas quotes. Then ask what number he actually calculated, and what it is a percentage of.

Run the loan amount yourself. There are two values in the first paragraph and the chapter gives you a rule for choosing between them. Apply the rule, multiply by the ratio, and put your answer beside what Tomas tells Della the bank will lend. The gap is money her deal does not have.

The second paragraph is about insurance and holds four statements to test. What PMI actually covers. When PMI comes off, and which of the three numbers governs. Whether MIP behaves the way he says. And who writes an FHA loan. Take each one to the screen it belongs to. Three are on the PMI and FHA screens. The fourth is a single verb.

The third paragraph has a property problem, a fee problem and a distractor. The property problem is what the veteran intends to do with the building, answered by one sentence on the VA screen about occupancy. The fee problem is a cap that applies to two kinds of loan and no others, so find the cap and see whether the lender is inside it. The distractor is the hard part, because it looks like the worst thing there and it is lawful. Go back to the screen on legitimate subprime lending and say precisely why.

The fourth paragraph splits in two. The first half is a lender refinancing its own high-cost loan, and you should be able to name the practice, the statute, the time limit, and the second thing wrong with the new loan's structure. The second half is not lending at all. It is a rescue scam, and several distinct wrongs sit inside one short passage: how he found her, what he wants paid up front, where he wants her payments sent, and what he wants her to sign. Name each separately.

Write each answer in three parts and it will hold up in front of anyone. The fact, quoted from the story. The rule, named from this chapter. And the correct advice, in the words you would have used with that client in front of you.

Watch for the moment Tomas stops answering a real estate question and starts answering a financial one. This chapter exists because a licensee should not be giving financial advice, and should understand financing well enough to know when a client has been told something untrue. One of those two things is happening in the first paragraph, before any number goes wrong.

NOTE: If your answer to an issue is a rule with no facts attached, you have not spotted an issue. You have recited a rule and hoped it fit. Name the fact first, then the rule it breaks, then what a licensee who knew the arithmetic would have said.

Name the fact, then name the rule

REMEMBER: Which of Tomas's errors would cost a client the most money on closing day, and which one would cost her the most over thirty years?

Check yourself

11 questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see whether it is right and why.

Key terms

Hypothecate
To pledge property as security for a debt without giving up possession of it, what a mortgagor does.
Acceleration clause
The lender's right to declare the entire loan balance due upon default.
Loan-to-value ratio
The loan amount as a percentage of the lower of sale price or appraised value; 80% is the conventional standard without PMI.
Primary mortgage market
Lenders that make loans directly to borrowers: banks, S&Ls, mortgage companies, credit unions, finance companies, portfolio lenders, mutual savings banks.
Secondary mortgage market
Investors and agencies (Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, Ginnie Mae) that buy and sell existing mortgages, recycling capital to primary lenders.
Securitization
Pooling mortgages and selling them as mortgage-backed securities.
Conforming loan
A loan meeting Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac size and underwriting standards; a jumbo loan exceeds the conforming limit.
Private mortgage insurance (PMI)
Insurance protecting the lender on the portion of a conventional loan above 80% LTV; cancelled at 78% automatically, 80% on request, 25% equity under NY law.
Point
One percent of the loan amount, charged as an origination fee or as discount points to buy down the rate.
Mortgage insurance premium (MIP)
The upfront and annual insurance required on all FHA loans regardless of down payment.
SONYMA
The State of New York Mortgage Agency, created in 1970; the only government program that is a direct lender, with below-market rates for first-time buyers.
Amortization
Reduction of a loan balance through regular payments applied first to interest, then principal.
Balloon payment
The large final payment on a partially amortized loan.
Subprime loan
A B-C credit loan at higher rates for borrowers with less-than-perfect credit; legitimate when priced for genuine risk, predatory when abusive.
HOEPA
The 1994 Home Ownership and Equity Protection Act amending TILA to restrict high-cost loans: no short balloons, negative amortization, default-rate hikes, or lending without verifying ability to repay.
Loan flipping
Repeatedly refinancing a borrower's loan to generate fees without benefit to the borrower; a predatory practice.

Practise this chapter

Flashcards (free) Practice exam

Read Chapter 13 in the Book

The Book comes with the Salesperson pass ($39 for 3 months).

A study course, in beta. This is not a New York State Department of State approved qualifying course, and the time you spend here does not count toward the 77 hours you need for a salesperson license. Take the 77-hour course at a DOS-approved school; use this to learn the material and to review it. · Powered by License to Earn LLC