The Course · Chapter 12 Beta

Chapter 12: Contracts and Contract Preparation

In this chapter

  • Classify any contract Express or implied, unilateral or bilateral, executory or executed, valid, void, voidable, or unenforceable.
  • The six essential elements Name every element a contract must have to be valid, and what happens when one is missing.
  • Statute of frauds Apply GOL § 5-703 and the Sullivan Law, and explain part performance and parol evidence.
  • Breach and remedies Distinguish substantial performance from material breach and name the six remedies.
  • Assignment vs novation Explain who stays liable after each, and which contracts cannot be assigned at all.
  • Offer and acceptance Meet the requirements for a binding acceptance and recognize a counteroffer when you see one.
  • Prepare a sales contract Identify the data a contract needs and the line New York draws around a licensee's role.
  • Leasehold estates Distinguish the leasehold estates, the lease types, eviction, and rent regulation.

Lesson 1

Contract Law Fundamentals

Agreement is another word for contract, and the rules are the same for all of them

The Five Contracts You Will Actually Handle

One body of contract law governs all five

Five contracts carry almost all of the work you will do, and the same body of contract law governs every one of them. Learn how a contract is formed once and you can read all five.

A listing agreement is an agency contract between a seller and a broker, setting out their agreement including the broker's commission with regard to the seller's property. A buyer agency agreement is the same document from the other side. It gives the details of the agreement between a buyer and a broker, and how the broker is paid for representing that buyer.

A sales or purchase contract is the contract between a buyer and a seller detailing the sale of real property. Everything else in the transaction hangs off it. The lender reads it. The title company reads it. Both attorneys read it.

A lease is a contract between a landlord and a tenant stipulating the terms of tenancy, the rent, and the tenant's rights and obligations. An option to buy or lease is a contract giving one party the right to buy or lease another's property at a specified price within a specified time. Lesson 3 comes back to the option and Lesson 4 takes the lease apart.

Agreement is another word for contract. A contract does not have to be a long document and it does not have to be printed on a form. What it has to do is satisfy the rules of formation. Miss one and a court will not enforce the agreement.

Hypothetical. A seller signs a listing with your broker. A buyer signs a buyer agency agreement with you. The two of them sign a purchase contract, and the seller rents the house back for thirty days after closing. Four of the five contracts, one file, one body of law.

CAUTION: Chapter 1 set out this rule and it reaches every document named here. In New York it is unlawful to practice law without a license, and the Department of State asserts that a real estate broker's license does not grant the right to draft legal documents or give legal advice. When a client asks a legal question about a contract, the answer is that the client needs an attorney.

Agreement is another word for contract

REMEMBER: Name the five contracts without looking back. Which of the five have you already signed in your own life, and did you read it before you signed it?

Classifying a Contract

How it was created, who promised, how far along it is, and whether a court will enforce it

A contract is an agreement between two or more parties to do, or not do, something. Contracts are legally enforceable promises, and the law provides remedies when one is broken. Every contract gets sorted by three questions, and then by a fourth that matters more than the other three.

The first question is how the contract was created. An express contract is an agreement expressed in words, spoken or written. Signing a work order at the garage to have your car repaired in exchange for payment is express. An implied contract has not been put into words. It is implied by the actions of the parties. Eating in a restaurant is the standard example, because it is understood you will pay the bill.

The second question is who made a binding promise. In a unilateral contract only one party makes a binding promise to the other. An option is the example to hold on to, because one party has the right to do something within a set time without any obligation to do it. In a bilateral contract each party makes a binding promise. A listing agreement is bilateral.

The third question is how far along the contract is. A contract is executory while one or both parties have not yet completed performance. The parties sign a listing agreement and the broker is out looking for a buyer. That contract is executory. A contract is executed when both parties have fully performed. A buyer is found and the seller pays the commission at closing. That contract is executed.

NOTE: Do not confuse an executed contract with executing a contract. Executed means both sides have finished performing. Executing means signing. The exam asks this by describing a contract that has just been signed and offering executed as an answer. A contract that has just been signed is executory.

AND THE FOURTH QUESTION, IS IT ENFORCEABLE?

A valid contract is binding and legally enforceable. It meets every essential element of formation and binds both parties to its terms. A void contract lacks one or more of the essential elements or is otherwise defective. A listing agreement missing the signature of one of two owners is void, because a required signature is a missing element.

A voidable contract is one a single party may end without liability, because of a lack of legal capacity or some other factor such as fraud or duress. A sales contract signed by a minor is voidable by the minor and not by the other party. An unenforceable contract may have been valid between the parties, and a court will still refuse to enforce it. An oral contract for the sale of real estate is unenforceable.

Four words, four different outcomes

REMEMBER: Run your own listing agreement through all four questions. Express or implied. Unilateral or bilateral. Executory or executed. Valid, void, voidable or unenforceable. If you hesitate on any of the four, read this screen twice.

The Six Essential Elements of a Valid Contract

Remove one and what is left is not a contract

Six elements make a contract valid. Competent parties. A lawful and possible objective. Consideration. A description. Mutual agreement. Written format and signatures where the law requires them. Every one of the six has to be there.

Competent parties means each party is legally competent, which is also called contractual capacity. It requires the legal age of majority, which is 18. It requires mental competence, meaning sober and of sound mind. It requires proper authorization where somebody signs on behalf of a corporation or another entity.

A lawful and possible objective means the purpose of the contract must be lawful at the time it is made. A promise to pay somebody for an illegal act is void. A court may also refuse to enforce a contract whose objective violates public policy. Many contracts are severable, so one unenforceable provision can be cut out and the rest enforced.

Consideration, also called valuable consideration, is anything of value given to induce another to enter a contract. Money, services, goods or promises. The parties are sometimes called the promisor, the one making a promise, and the promisee, the one who gets the benefit of it. Consideration can also be a promise to refrain from doing something, and that is forbearance. Exchanging consideration separates a contract from the promise of a gift.

A description is a description of what is being contracted, and for real property that can be a legal description or simply the address. Mutual agreement is offer and acceptance, also called the meeting of the minds. Written format and signatures are required wherever the statute of frauds says so, and the next two screens are about those last two elements.

TWO ELEMENTS THAT TRIP PEOPLE UP

Consideration does not have to be equal. The value one party gives need not match what the other gives, and a party who struck a bad bargain still has an enforceable contract, unless fraud, undue influence, duress or mistake is proven. A contract may even rest on good consideration, which is nothing more than a promise of love and affection.

Capacity runs one way with a minor. Where an adult contracts with a minor, the contract is voidable by the minor only, even where the minor pretended to be over 18. The minor may disaffirm before turning 18 or within a reasonable time after. The minor may instead enforce it and require the adult to perform, and the adult has no power to disaffirm. Once a court has declared a person incompetent, any contract that person enters is void.

Missing an element makes it void

REMEMBER: Say the six elements out loud. Then answer this: a contract signed by somebody a court declared incompetent last year is void or voidable, and why?

Genuine Assent

Four things that mean consent was not freely given

Mutual agreement is not enough on its own. The consent behind it has to be genuine, which means freely given. Four circumstances mean it was not, and each one can give the injured party a way out of the contract.

Fraud is intentional or negligent misrepresentation of material facts. The fraud produces a contract that would not have been completed had the truth been known. That is the test. Not whether the statement was careless, but whether the other party would still have signed knowing the truth.

Undue influence is excessive pressure on someone that prevents that person from making a rational or prudent decision. A contract is voidable where a person is persuaded to sign by taking advantage of trust or of a weakness of mind such as exhaustion or senility. Watch for it where the person signing depends on the person doing the persuading.

Duress is threatening violence against a person, or against a member of that person's family, or unlawfully confining them, to force a signature. Duress can also be a threat of injury to reputation. Economic duress, also called business compulsion, is a threat to take action that will be financially disastrous to the victim.

Mistake occurs where one or more parties are mistaken about a fact or a law, and bad faith is usually absent. Where both parties are mistaken about something important to the contract, that is mutual mistake and either party may disaffirm. Where only one party is mistaken, that is unilateral mistake, and it does not make the contract voidable unless the other party knew about the mistake and said nothing.

Case in Point. Stewart was 17 when he signed a contract to buy a house from Pete, who did not realize Stewart was a minor. A few weeks later, with the sale ready to close, Stewart changed his mind and told Pete the deal was off. Pete cannot sue to enforce the contract. Had the tables been turned and Pete wanted to back out, Stewart could have sued Pete to enforce it. Voidability runs one way. The minor may disaffirm before turning 18 or within a reasonable time after, and the adult never can.

Offer and acceptance is the mechanism. An offer is one party, the offeror, proposing a contract to another party, the offeree. Acceptance of those terms is the meeting of the minds. Once an offer is accepted a contract is formed and both parties are legally bound, and neither can back out without a legal excuse.

CAUTION: Fraud, undue influence, duress and mutual mistake make a contract voidable rather than void. Voidable means somebody has to act. The party who was defrauded or pressured has to disaffirm, and the right does not sit open forever.

Consent has to be genuine, not just given

REMEMBER: A seller signs at ten at night after a nine-hour hospital shift because the buyer's agent will not leave the kitchen. Which of the four is that, and who gets to disaffirm?

The Statute of Frauds

General Obligations Law §5-703, in writing, signed, or unenforceable

The statute of frauds is a law requiring certain contracts to be in writing and signed to be enforceable. Its purpose is to prevent fraudulent claims and false testimony about agreements nobody wrote down. New York's statute of frauds is codified in the General Obligations Law at §5-703, and it requires real estate contracts to be written and to contain all the essential elements of a valid contract.

It applies to contracts conveying an interest in real estate. Purchase contracts. Options. Mortgages. Deeds. A power of attorney authorizing someone to sell another's real estate. Leases for more than one year. An oral agreement on any of those is unenforceable, which is the word from the screen on classifying contracts: valid between the parties, and useless in court.

Two doctrines sit on either side of the writing requirement. The doctrine of part performance allows a New York court to enforce an oral agreement that should have been in writing, where the promisee has taken irrevocable steps to perform her side and failing to enforce would give the promisor an unjust benefit. The rule of parol evidence runs the other way. The written agreement overrides any oral agreements, so what the parties said before signing does not survive the document they signed.

The plain-language requirement, known as New York's Sullivan Law, states that written agreements for the sale or lease of residential property must contain words common in everyday usage if the transaction is for $50,000 or less.

A power of attorney is an instrument authorizing one person, the attorney-in-fact, to act as another's agent to the extent stated in it. Unlike an attorney at law, an attorney-in-fact can be anyone, and the authority is restricted to what the document specifically states. A power of attorney conferring the right to sell another's real property must be in writing, signed, witnessed by two competent witnesses, acknowledged before a notary, and recorded with the county recorder where the land sits before it becomes effective.

NOTE: The statute of frauds does not make an oral real estate agreement illegal. It makes it unenforceable. Both parties may perform it happily and nothing is wrong. The moment one of them refuses, the other walks into court with nothing to hand the judge.

In writing, signed, or unenforceable

REMEMBER: A client says she and her neighbor agreed on a price for his back lot over coffee and shook on it. What do you tell her the handshake is worth, and who does she need to call?

Lesson 2

Performance, Breach and Discharge

What happens after the ink dries, and what a court will do about it

Time Is of the Essence

Five words that decide whether a missed deadline is a material breach

A breach of contract occurs when one party fails to perform with no legal cause. The breach does not end the breaching party's obligations, and the non-defaulting party may take legal action.

Deciding whether a breach has happened is harder than it sounds. Curtis does everything he promised and Amy thinks none of it was done well. Whether Amy still has to pay depends on which side of one line the facts fall: substantial performance or material breach.

Substantial performance means the promisor has not performed every contractual obligation but has done enough that the promisee is still required to fulfill hers. Curtis has carried out the main objectives of the contract. Amy may be able to sue for damages over the unfinished details, and she still has to perform as agreed.

Material breach is a breach important enough to excuse the non-breaching party from performing at all. Curtis fails to perform some important part of the contract, or performs very badly. Amy may sue for damages and is excused from fulfilling her own promises.

Many contracts state that time is of the essence. The phrase makes timely performance an essential part of the contract, so that failure to perform on time is a material breach.

Run the two side by side. Without the clause, the buyer is late, the seller may give him a reasonable time to perform, and the contract is voidable by the seller from that point, so the seller could terminate at any time. With the clause, the contract is void the moment the deadline passes and there is a material breach. Depending on local market custom it could be the buyer in breach or the seller.

CAUTION: The only way to save a contract with a time is of the essence clause is for buyer and seller to agree to extend it before the deadline passes. After the deadline there is nothing left to extend. An agent who tells a buyer to relax and take another three weeks has just given away a client's contract.

Conditions, also called contingency clauses, make the parties' rights or obligations depend on the occurrence or non-occurrence of certain events. A purchase agreement may be contingent on the sale of the buyer's current home, or on the buyer qualifying for financing. If the event does not occur, the promisor can withdraw without liability for breach. The promisor must make a good faith effort to fulfill the condition and cannot deliberately prevent it to escape the contract, and a condition can be waived by the party it was meant to protect.

Extend before the deadline or not at all

REMEMBER: Your buyer will close four days late. Look at the contract in your hand. Are those five words in it, and what does your answer change about the call you are about to make?

Remedies for Breach of Contract

What the non-defaulting party can ask a court to do

When one party breaches, the non-defaulting party may file suit in a court of law. Seven remedies come up often enough to name, and the exam separates them by what each one does to the contract.

Cancellation is the termination of a contract without undoing acts already performed under it. It can be done without going to court where both parties agree they would rather cancel. When a contract is cancelled, all further obligations are terminated.

Compensatory damages are intended to compensate the plaintiff for harm caused by the defendant's act or failure to act. This is the most common remedy for breach of contract. The award is usually the amount that will put the non-breaching party in the same position he would have been in had the other party performed.

An injunction is a court order requiring a party to do, or to refrain from doing, a certain act. An injunction is not a money award, and that is the point of it.

Liquidated damages are an amount of money specified in the contract to be awarded if the agreement is breached. The clause is written in to lessen the chance of expensive litigation. Because the parties agreed in advance on a figure or on a formula, the non-breaching party must accept liquidated damages instead of suing for actual damages.

Reformation is a court or a judge changing or modifying a contract to reflect the true intent of the parties. It usually happens where the parties entered the contract without realizing it contained a clerical error.

Rescission is the destruction, annulment or termination of a contract, and all parties must give back anything acquired under it. Rescission comes up where one party does not want to enforce the other's promise, where one party did not provide the promised consideration, or where a voidable contract is disaffirmed. When a contract is rescinded, all contractual obligations are terminated.

Specific performance is a court ordering someone who has breached to perform as agreed rather than simply pay damages. It is used most often where the non-breaching party cannot be compensated for the harm the breach caused. That is common in real estate, because no two parcels are alike and money does not replace the one the buyer contracted for. Specific performance is also called a forced sale.

NOTE: A liquidated damages clause does not keep anyone out of court. If the breaching party refuses to pay the agreed amount, the case goes to court anyway. The clause narrows the argument to whether there was a breach. It does not settle whether there is a right to sue.

Cancellation keeps what was done; rescission undoes it

REMEMBER: A seller refuses to close on a one-of-a-kind waterfront lot. Which remedy does the buyer's attorney ask for first, and why is money the wrong answer here?

Discharge of Contracts

Five ways a contract comes to an end

Discharging a contract means terminating it. Most contracts end without anybody breaching anything, and five headings cover almost all of it.

Agreement of the parties. When all parties to a contract agree, any executory contract can be discharged. This is also known as release of contract. Partial performance. Both parties agree to accept something different from the terms of the original contract, and the original obligation is extinguished.

Full performance. All parties have fulfilled their contractual obligations, so the contract is executed and released. This is the ordinary way a contract ends and the only one that leaves nobody with a claim. Impossibility of performance. Performing the contractual obligation becomes illegal because of a change in the law after the contract was created, and the contract is terminated.

OPERATION OF LAW, THREE ROUTES

Operation of law means the rights and liabilities of the contracting parties are changed by the application of law rather than by anything the parties do. A contract can be terminated through alteration, through bankruptcy, or through the statute of limitations.

Alteration of contract. Intentionally cancelling or altering a contract discharges the agreement. Bankruptcy. Contracts in existence as of the date of the bankruptcy filing are terminated. Statute of limitations. Under New York State law, the time limit to bring legal action regarding a real estate contract is six years.

6 years to bring legal action in New York

The six-year clock is the one to carry into practice. It is long enough that a file you have forgotten can come back. That is one of several reasons a broker keeps records, and Chapter 1 set out the three-year records rule that sits under the same habit.

NOTE: Impossibility of performance is narrower than it sounds. The textbook rule is a change in the law that makes performance illegal. A seller who finds the job inconvenient, expensive or unpleasant has not been handed impossibility.

REMEMBER: Which of the five discharges a contract with both parties satisfied, and which two of them can happen without either party agreeing to anything?

Assignment and Novation

Both hand the contract to somebody else; only one lets you walk away

In an assignment one of the parties, the assignor, transfers rights or interests under a contract to another person, the assignee. The other party to the contract stays where it was. The original contract stays alive. Only the rights move.

Generally either party can assign a contract without the other's consent, unless the contract states that consent is required. In New York all contracts are assignable unless the contract says otherwise.

The consequence is the part people get wrong. When a contract is assigned, the assignor is not relieved of liability under it. The assignor remains secondarily liable to the other party and can be sued if the assignee does not perform. That rule applies even where the other party consented to the assignment. Consent is permission to hand over the rights. It is not a release.

One exception concerns contracts for personal services. A party to a personal service contract can assign the contract only with the consent of the other party. Listing agreements are considered personal service contracts and thus cannot be assigned.

Novation is the substitution of a new contract for an earlier contract. The new contract cancels the original. A novation may also involve the substitution of a new party for an original party. That is the difference that matters to a client: a novation releases the party who leaves, and an assignment does not.

CAUTION: A buyer who wants out of a contract and hands it to a relative is still on the hook if the relative fails to close. An agent who tells that buyer he is completely off the hook has given legal advice, and has given it wrong.

Assignment moves the rights, not the liability

REMEMBER: Say the difference between assignment and novation in one sentence. Then say why your own listing agreement cannot be handed to the agent down the hall.

Lesson 3

The Sales Contract

Offer, counteroffer, acceptance, and the document that carries the whole transaction

How a Sales Contract Is Formed

A listing is not an offer to sell; it is a solicitation of offers

A real estate listing is not a property owner's offer to sell. By listing the property the seller is soliciting offers. A buyer does not create a contract by accepting the seller's listing. The buyer makes an offer and the seller accepts or rejects it. The listing is an independent contract between a seller and a broker, and it is not part of the contract between seller and buyer.

An offer to purchase has to meet three basic requirements. Intent to contract, meaning the words and actions of the offeror reasonably indicate an intention to form a contract. Definite terms, because a vague offer or one missing the essential elements is not binding. Communication, meaning the offer is clearly communicated to the offeree.

HOW AN OFFER DIES BEFORE IT IS ACCEPTED

Lapse of time. An offer may state that it expires at a certain time, and where it does not, it expires after a reasonable amount of time. Death or incapacity. The death or incapacity of either party kills the offer even before a stated expiration date. Revocation. The offeror withdraws the offer before the offeree accepts it, and the offeree has lost the chance.

The buyer is the offeror and the seller is the offeree. The seller can do three things. Accept, and a binding contract is formed, both parties are legally bound, and the broker has earned a commission even if the sale never closes. Reject, and the offer is dead, and the offeree cannot revive it later by changing his mind. Counteroffer, and the roles swap.

A counteroffer is a change to any term. It is a rejection plus a new offer. The offeror becomes the counterofferee and the original offeree becomes the counterofferor. No binding contract exists until the counterofferee accepts the counteroffer.

THREE REQUIREMENTS FOR A BINDING ACCEPTANCE

Acceptance must be communicated to the offeror. Until the accepting party tells the other, the offer can still be revoked. Even where the seller cashed the earnest money check, it is not enough that the buyer knows. The seller must communicate acceptance directly to the buyer.

Acceptance must be made in the manner specified, such as in writing, by fax, or by delivering a cashier's check, and it is not effective unless those instructions are followed. Where an offer does not specify, any reasonable method binds the offeror. Acceptance must not vary the terms of the offer. The offeree must accept exactly the terms offered, with no modifications and no new terms.

Any change to any term is a counteroffer

REMEMBER: Your seller wants to accept but move the closing by two weeks. What has your seller just done to the buyer's offer, and who is now free to walk?

Earnest Money and What a Sales Contract Does

The deposit is an inducement, not consideration, and not required

An earnest money deposit made with an offer to purchase is not consideration. Earnest money is not required for an offer at all. Those two sentences carry more weight than anything else on this screen, because both of them get told backwards to sellers every day.

Earnest money is an inducement to have the buyer's offer accepted. It is a means of showing the seller that the buyer is serious and able to follow through with the financing necessary to buy the property. The amount can be a factor in whether an offer is accepted, and that matters most where the seller has more than one offer in front of her. A buyer putting 20 percent down looks more secure than a buyer putting 10 percent down, and the seller reads the deposit the same way.

Earnest money deposits are generally held by the listing broker, the selling broker, or the attorney representing the seller. The deposit must be maintained in a separate escrow account to prevent commingling of funds. Chapter 1 put commingling on the list of grounds for suspension or revocation, and this is where a new licensee meets it first.

A SALES CONTRACT SERVES THREE PURPOSES

It is the buyer's initial offer, and every subsequent counteroffer as the parties negotiate. It is the receipt for any earnest money deposit taken with the offer. And it is the contract between the buyer and the seller once it is accepted.

That third purpose reaches further than the two parties. A sales contract establishes the terms and conditions of the sale, and it is the document that communicates the details of the transaction to the mortgage lender, the title company and every other party. Everyone downstream works from it. An error in the contract becomes an error on the closing statement.

Hypothetical. A buyer submits a clean full-price offer with no deposit. Your seller says an offer without a check is not a real offer. She is entitled to prefer a deposit and she is entitled to take a different offer. She is not entitled to be told the offer in front of her is invalid, because it is a valid offer and accepting it would form a binding contract.

CAUTION: The escrow account is not a formality you attend to when the paperwork catches up. A deposit parked in the brokerage's operating account for a week is commingling, whatever the reason and whatever the intention. Separate account, immediately.

Not consideration, not required, not yours

REMEMBER: A buyer hands you a $12,000 check at the kitchen table on a Saturday. Where is that check by Monday morning, and whose name is on the account it sits in?

Preparing the Contract

New York dictates no form, and local custom splits the state in two

New York State does not dictate the use of a specific form for sales contracts. When a buyer is ready to make an offer, the procedure used to prepare the sales contract is determined by local custom and practice. The state splits roughly in two, and which half you work in decides what lands on your desk.

STANDARDIZED SALES CONTRACT · UPSTATE

New York's Attorney General has concluded that a broker may use a standardized sales contract form approved by a recognized Bar Association in conjunction with a local Board of REALTORS, as long as it meets certain criteria. The form requires the broker to fill in only nonlegal provisions: the names of the parties, the property location and description, the terms of the sale, and the date and location of the closing. The form states clearly and prominently on its face that it is legally binding and that all parties are recommended to seek an attorney's advice before signing. And brokers cannot add provisions to the preprinted form unless they make the entire contract subject to the review and approval of the attorneys representing all parties.

Standardized sales contracts are used most often by Upstate brokers, typically understood to include anything north of Westchester County. Chapter 1 gave you the case law and the Judiciary Law sections behind that rule. This is the same rule at the moment you hold the pen.

THE BINDER · NEW YORK CITY AND LONG ISLAND

A binder is also called a Sales Agreement, a Purchase Agreement or a Deal Sheet. It is generally one page, and it carries most of the information that will go into the sales contract prepared by the seller's attorney. The agent fills it out on receiving an offer and presents it to the listing agent and the seller. On acceptance it goes to both attorneys, and the seller's attorney draws the sales contract and sends it to the buyer's attorney.

The buyer always signs the contract first, and then the seller signs. The order is not ceremony. Whoever signs second is accepting, and a contract signed by the buyer alone is still an offer the seller can decline.

Data you will need to assemble

Survey of the property's boundaries. Evidence of encumbrances such as easements or liens. The prior deed, used to draft the new deed. The most recent property tax bills, plus special assessments and water and fuel bills needed to adjust expenses at closing. The certificate of occupancy, which indicates the property is habitable. The Department of State syllabus adds the prior title insurance policy and the parties' personal data, meaning names, addresses, telephone numbers, marital status and Social Security numbers.

That information comes from the buyer, the seller and the public records, and a licensee may facilitate assembling it. Assembling is the word to hold. You collect the documents and hand them to the attorneys.

The property can be described four ways. A metes and bounds description. A lot on a filed map. A tax map designation. A street address. A sales contract can usually run on the street address, and a deed cannot. Where the prior deed and the tax map disagree, that is a question for the attorney.

Who holds the down payment follows the same geography. Upstate, brokers typically hold deposit money in an escrow account, and buyers often put it toward fees at closing. Downstate, attorneys usually hold it in their Interest on Lawyer Account of the State of New York, the IOLA account. The syllabus lists the Lawyers' Fund for Client Protection as a reason an attorney holding the down payment is safer for the parties.

NOTE: The syllabus also requires the section 443 agency disclosure statement to be included when brokers prepare contracts. Agency disclosure has its own chapter. Carry one thing into this one: preparing the contract does not suspend the disclosure obligations you already have.

Fill the blanks; attorneys write the terms

REMEMBER: You work in one half of this state. Name the form your office uses, name who drafts the contract, and name who will be holding the deposit on your next file.

Clauses, Contingencies and Disclosures

The provisions that decide who carries which risk

Each sales contract is different and most of them carry the same sections. Learn the sections and you can read an unfamiliar contract quickly, because you will notice what is missing.

The contract identifies the parties and the property, lists the personal property included and the items excluded, states the purchase price, records the earnest money deposit, and indicates the type of deed to be conveyed. Upstate New York generally uses a warranty deed, and south of Poughkeepsie the norm is a bargain and sale deed.

It then handles money and timing. Mortgage expenses and recording fees are paid by the purchaser unless otherwise negotiated. Tax liability sets out who pays the New York State transfer tax. Tax and other adjustments, called apportionments, divide the bills that straddle the closing date. The real estate agents section names the broker and salesperson and carries the commission information.

The right of access lets the buyer enter for inspections required by the contract, and inspect the property before closing, generally within 48 hours. The attorney approval clause makes the agreement contingent on the parties obtaining their attorneys' approval, on a date that gives each attorney time to review. The contract closes with the attached addenda, the delivery details for notices, and the disclaimers and signatures. The entire agreement disclaimer there is the merger clause, which says the signed document is the whole agreement.

An as is clause states that the buyer accepts the property in its present condition, having inspected it and agreed to take it without requiring the seller to fix problems. An as is clause does not protect the seller from liability for non-disclosure of latent defects. It cannot protect a seller or an agent who deliberately conceals a defect. It is not a defense to fraud.

Case in Point. Broker Sue has a foreclosed house listed. It has been vacant two months with the utilities disconnected, and the basement flooded because the sump pump was not connected. The furnace and the electrical service sit in that basement. Sue cannot protect herself and the seller by telling buyers the property is sold as is, without apprising them of the water in the basement. She must make purchasers aware of the condition, because she is aware of it. An as is clause allocates the risk of what a buyer can find, never of what the seller and the agent know and do not say.

An escape clause, also called a kick-out clause, a 72-hour clause or a 48-hour clause, is for the buyer who has to sell his own home first. The seller may keep pursuing other buyers, while giving the first buyer the right to perform or cancel if another contract is considered.

Contingencies are conditions that must occur for the contract to be performed. Satisfactory inspections, such as termite, septic system, home systems and radon. A mortgage contingency, in which the buyer must secure a mortgage for a specified amount on specified terms. A contingency that the buyer must sell his own house first. The mortgage contingency reads differently for traditional financing, for VA or FHA financing, for a purchase money mortgage the seller takes back, and for a mortgage the buyer assumes.

Riders are amendments to contracts. A buyer using an FHA or VA loan may attach a rider voiding the contract if the appraisal comes in below the purchase price. Riders and addenda should be written by an attorney.

TWO DISCLOSURES THE CONTRACT MUST CARRY

Buyers who write a contract on almost any residential property built prior to 1978 must be given a booklet discussing lead-based paint hazards, and have ten days to investigate potential hazards before the contract becomes binding. New York law also requires sellers to provide buyers with a Property Condition Disclosure statement. The former $500 credit in lieu of disclosure was repealed effective March 20, 2024, and the completed statement must be delivered before the buyer signs a binding contract under Article 14 of the Real Property Law.

CAUTION: Caveat emptor, let the buyer beware, is the old rule that a buyer must examine property carefully rather than rely on the seller to point out its faults. New York has cut it back with the disclosure statutes and the law on latent defects.

As is covers the visible, never the concealed

REMEMBER: Pick one contract you have seen. Which section tells the buyer what is not included in the sale, and which section tells the buyer what to do if the bank says no?

Other Sales-Related Contracts

Four ways property changes hands that are not an ordinary purchase agreement

The single-family purchase contract is the most common agreement you will handle. Four others turn up often enough that you have to know what changes when they do.

Cooperatives are buildings owned by corporations, with the residents as shareholders who each receive a proprietary lease on an individual unit and the right to use the common areas. Proprietary leases run longer and offer more rights than an ordinary tenant lease. Title to the building is held by the corporation formed for that purpose.

A buyer making an offer on a cooperative apartment wishes to purchase shares of stock in the corporation, and that changes both the contract and the financing. A board of directors usually interviews potential shareholders and either agrees or disagrees to the purchase. The financing is governed by the Uniform Commercial Code, under which the lender retains a security interest in the personal property, or chattel, until paid in full. The loan is secured not by a mortgage but by the shares of stock.

Options are contracts giving one party the right to do something without obligating him to do it, which makes an option a unilateral contract. The most common real estate option is a lease with an option to purchase. An option to purchase gives the optionee the right to buy the property of the optionor at a specified price within a limited time, with no obligation to exercise it.

An option is supported by consideration. The optionee pays the optionor for the option right. An owner willing to sell for $100,000 might take $1,000 to keep that offer open for a month. The payment of consideration makes the option irrevocable until it expires, and where the optionor dies first it is still binding on his heirs.

The right of first refusal is the right to have the first chance to buy or lease property if the owner decides to sell or lease it. Where a third party makes an offer the owner is willing to accept, the right holder must match the terms of that offer in order to acquire the property. An option sets a price now. A right of first refusal sets no price and waits for somebody else to set one.

Installment sales contracts, also called land contracts, are agreements in which the buyer, called the vendee, makes payments to the seller, called the vendor, in exchange for the right to occupy and use the property. No deed or title transfers until all of the payments, or a specified portion of them, have been made. The seller holds title to the land as security. An installment sales contract is an express, bilateral, executory contract.

Each side takes on obligations. The seller promises to give possession, to accept payments toward the purchase, and to convey title once the agreed payments are made. The buyer promises to make the payments, pay the taxes, obtain insurance and maintain the property. A land contract can work for a buyer who cannot qualify for a conventional mortgage loan. It can work for a seller, who can still claim depreciation as owner and pays capital gains tax a percentage each year as payments come in rather than in a lump sum.

CAUTION: In a land contract the buyer has possession and the seller has title. That gap is the whole risk of the arrangement and it can run for years. Every land contract question on the exam turns on the same fact: the deed has not been delivered yet.

Shares in a co-op, not real property

REMEMBER: Your client holds a right of first refusal on the unit next door and the owner has a signed offer at $600,000. What must your client do, and by when does the contract say she must do it?

Lesson 4

Leases

The contract that creates a leasehold estate, a temporary right to possess

The Leasehold Estates

When the lease ends, possession returns to the landlord

A leasehold estate gives the holder, the tenant or lessee, a temporary right to possession without title. The owner is the landlord, or lessor. A leasehold is reversionary, so when the lease ends, possession reverts to the landlord.

An estate for years is a leasehold set to last for a specific period, after which it terminates automatically and neither party has to give notice. It is also called a term tenancy, and the duration can be any length, even a single day. Neither party can end it early unless both agree or someone breaches. Death of a party does not end it, and neither does a sale.

NOTE: That is the estate rule. In New York City, and in any locality that adopts it, the Good Cause Eviction Law sits on top of it, and a covered landlord needs good cause to refuse a renewal or remove the tenant. Two later screens teach it.

A periodic estate continues for successive equal periods until proper notice from either party ends it. The term may be any length agreed to, such as week to week, month to month or year to year, and it renews itself at the end of each period. Death of a party and sale do not end it either.

NY notice to terminate: at least ONE MONTH PLUS ONE DAY, by either party.

Rent is due the first of June and the tenant is to be out by the first of July, so notice is given by the 31st of May.

An estate at will is a leasehold with no lease specifying a termination date or a rental period. Sometimes no rent is paid at all, as with a resident superintendent. Renting to a family member who pays now and then, with no lease, is the common example.

NY notice: not less than 30 DAYS. Unlike the others, it ends automatically on the death of either party.

Tenancy at sufferance is possession by a tenant who came in under a valid lease and stays on after it expires without the landlord's permission. A tenancy at sufferance is not a leasehold estate. The landlord owes a holdover tenant no notice of termination. New York real property law lets landlords remove holdover tenants through the legal eviction process, and only a sheriff can physically remove one.

In New York municipalities without rent regulations, a landlord who accepts rent from a holdover tenant automatically creates a month-to-month periodic tenancy, Real Property Law § 232-c.

NEW YORK CITY, an estate for years whose lease does not state the duration continues until the first day of October after possession. An automatic-renewal clause is unenforceable unless the landlord gives written notice at least 15 days before renewal. A month-to-month tenancy may be terminated by the landlord on at least 30 days' notice from the expiration of the term.

CAUTION: A landlord who takes the holdover's rent check has made a decision. He now has a month-to-month tenant and owes notice he did not owe before.

REMEMBER: Four estates, and the question is always how each one ends. Which two need no notice at all, which dies with a party, and which is not a leasehold estate?

Inside the Lease

No statutory form, and a lease is a contract, so every essential element applies

Leases are contracts in which one party, the lessee, pays the owner, the lessor, rent in exchange for possession of real estate. A lease conveys a leasehold estate from the fee owner to a tenant. Owners receive rent plus the reversionary interest.

There is no statutory form of a lease. A lease is a contract, so the six essential elements from Lesson 1 apply one for one.

STANDARD LEASE PROVISIONS

Legal capacity to contract, so both parties are competent and over 18. A demising clause, which grants possession of the property to the lessee. The terms of the lease, clearly stated, including the duration of the tenancy and its expiration date. An adequate description of the property, and for most leases the street address is sufficient. Consideration, usually rent, indicating the amount and how and when it is paid. Signatures of both parties.

Four more provisions matter. Lease renewal, because New York provides no statutory right of renewal, though many leases include an option to renew. Rent stabilization and the Good Cause Eviction Law limit when an owner may refuse a renewal. A use provision, because residential leases allow only a place to live, while commercial leases usually allow any lawful purpose that does not violate private deed restrictions. Plain language. And the terms in writing if the lease will last more than one year. An oral lease for less than one year is generally enforceable in New York.

The Department of State syllabus adds three details. Rent is due in arrears unless the lease provides otherwise. Signatures are not notarized unless the lease is to be recorded. Commercial rent is usually expressed in annual terms.

THE SECURITY DEPOSIT

A security deposit is money the tenant pays the landlord as monetary security against damage to the residence or failure by the lessee to comply with the lease. Lessees usually receive it back at the end of the term, less deductions for necessary repairs beyond normal wear and tear.

Security deposits must be held in an escrow account, separate from the owner's personal or operating accounts. In New York it is illegal to commingle security deposit funds with other funds.

Owners of six or more units must hold deposits in INTEREST-BEARING accounts. The interest belongs to the tenant; the owner may claim 1% annually for administration.

NOTE: The deposit is the tenant's money the whole time the landlord holds it. That is why the interest is the tenant's and the 1 percent is only a fee for the work.

THE BROKER’S FEE · NEW YORK CITY

In New York City the FARE Act, Local Law 119 of 2024, took effect on June 11, 2025. Landlords pay their own brokers. A landlord's agent, including an agent who lists the apartment, may not charge the tenant any fee related to the rental. A tenant may still hire her own broker and pay that broker. Every fee the tenant must pay goes clearly in the listing, and the tenant signs an itemized written disclosure of those fees before signing the lease. This is New York City law only.

A lease is a contract before it is anything else

REMEMBER: Open any lease you can find. Point to the demising clause, point to the use provision, and say whether the building it covers has six or more units.

The Landlord's Duties and the Tenant's Rights

What New York requires of an owner once the tenant has the keys

Signing the lease is where the landlord's obligations start. New York loads duties onto the owner that the lease cannot sign away, and a licensee who handles rentals is asked about them constantly.

Under the New York State Warranty of Habitability Law, property owners are required to lease property that is habitable and livable at the beginning of the lease term, and to maintain the premises in habitable and livable conditions throughout the term. Owners are obligated not to subject tenants to conditions that are dangerous or detrimental to their life, health and safety. To comply, landlords must provide heat, hot water and pest control.

New York's Multiple Dwelling Law and Multiple Residence Law require an owner renting a multiple-family dwelling to keep the property in good repair. Where the landlord's negligence leads to injury or results in unsafe living conditions, the landlord can be held legally responsible.

The tenant carries obligations too, and they are narrower than owners often believe. The lessee's basic obligation under any lease is to maintain the premises in the same condition they were in at the beginning of the term. Normal wear and tear is expected and accepted. The lessee is responsible for damage caused by his own negligence.

APARTMENT SHARING

Under New York State Real Property Law a lease cannot restrict occupants in an apartment to just the tenant named on the lease. Where there is more than one named tenant, the landlord must allow the immediate family to share the apartment. Where there is only one named tenant, the tenant can share the apartment with immediate family, one additional occupant, and that occupant's dependent children, as long as the apartment is the primary residence of the tenant or the tenant's spouse.

Two limits sit on that rule. If the named tenant moves out, those sharing have no right to stay without the landlord's consent. And landlords may limit occupancy where the number of people in the apartment violates local occupancy and health laws.

The Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Act of 1992 applies to residential leases as well as to homes that are sold. For rental property it requires landlords and agents to disclose known lead paint hazards for units built prior to 1978, with exceptions such as dormitories and leases for less than 100 days, which covers vacation rentals. Landlords must disclose any known hazard and give tenants any reports from prior lead tests. They must give renters a pamphlet about protecting families from lead in homes. And they must include certain language in the leasing agreement, in the lease or as an attachment, signed by landlords, agents and tenants.

COVENANT OF QUIET ENJOYMENT

Leases often contain covenants, which are promises or guarantees. A common guarantee in a lease is the covenant of quiet enjoyment, which means the property cannot be interrupted or invaded by anyone, including the property owner, without the lessee's consent. Property owners do not have the automatic right to enter the premises unannounced, and neither do contractors the owner employs to make repairs or installations.

Owners must provide reasonable notice to tenants before they, or contractors they have employed, enter the premises. Usually 24 to 48 hours is sufficient. The owner does have the right to enter the premises in an emergency in order to protect the property.

Typical residential leases also address a longer list: the landlord's or property manager's right of entry and inspection, pet policies including deposits and damage fees, smoking policies, conduct and house rules, the responsibilities of landlord and tenant for property condition and maintenance, the landlord's rights of termination in the event of breach, liability and indemnity insurance, late fees, parking, noise, alteration of the premises, and prohibited furnishings such as a large aquarium or a water bed.

CAUTION: Chapter 18 covers what a property manager does with all of this day to day. Your concern here is narrower. Every duty on this screen is a term of the lease contract, so a landlord client who asks you to draft around one of them is asking you to write an unenforceable clause and to give legal advice while you do it.

Habitability is owed for the whole term

REMEMBER: A landlord client tells you the plumber is going in Thursday and the tenant does not need to know. Name the covenant he is about to breach and the notice he actually owes.

Transferring and Ending a Tenancy

Who stays on the hook, and the one thing a landlord may never do

A tenant who wants out of a lease has two routes, and the difference decides who the landlord can sue when the rent stops.

Assignment occurs when the lease contract is transferred from the present lessee to an assignee. Assignment transfers a tenant's entire interest, and it does not transfer a tenant's entire liability. The assignee and the assignor share legal responsibility for paying rent. If the assignee does not pay, the landlord may sue both.

A sublease is when a tenant transfers only part of his right of possession, or another interest in the leased property, for part of the remaining lease term. The sublessee pays rent to the lessee, who then pays the lessor. In a sublease the original tenant is responsible to the owner for all provisions in the lease.

Owners typically prohibit assignment and subleasing without written approval. In New York, where owners unreasonably withhold consent to assign or to sublet, tenants may legally be released from the lease, or may go ahead and sublet.

HOW A LEASE ENDS

Expiration is the usual route. With no renewal agreement in place, lessees must vacate voluntarily and fully, and possession reverts to the owner. Surrender is when the owner and the tenant mutually agree to cancel the lease before expiration. Surrender cancels all duties and possession reverts to the owner.

CAUTION: Expiration now has an overlay. Under Real Property Law §215, no landlord of a unit covered by the Good Cause Eviction Law may remove a tenant, or refuse to renew a lease, except for good cause. The next screen shows which units are covered.

Section 216 lists the good causes, and a court must find one. Unpaid rent, unless it came from an unreasonable increase. A substantial lease violation not cured within ten days of written notice. Nuisance or damage. Illegal occupancy or use. Refusing access unreasonably. The landlord's good-faith need of the unit as a principal residence for the landlord or a listed relative, never against a tenant who is 65 or older or disabled. Demolition. Withdrawal from the rental market. Refusal of reasonable lease changes.

Eviction is the forced removal, by legal means, of a tenant and the tenant's belongings from a leased premise. This process is known as actual eviction, and an owner may turn to it where a tenant breaches the lease.

Constructive eviction is when a tenant is prevented from the quiet enjoyment of the property. Inoperable plumbing and a lack of heat through the owner's negligence are the standard examples. To claim constructive eviction a tenant must vacate the premises while the conditions that make the property uninhabitable still exist.

Abandonment ends a lease where the tenant abandons the premises and the owner re-enters to repossess. An owner does not have to accept return of the premises and can pursue the lessee for rent either way.

Death of a party and sale of the property do not end a lease. The heirs or the new owner must honor the existing lease contracts. A tenancy at will is the exception, and generally ends on the death of either party.

A self-help eviction is a landlord using physical force, threats, or other means to get rid of a tenant instead of going through the legal process. This is illegal in New York. Changing the locks is a self-help eviction. Putting belongings on the sidewalk is a self-help eviction. Shutting off the heat to drive a tenant out is one too, and it breaches the warranty of habitability on the way past.

CAUTION: An owner client will ask you about this. Tell him the removal goes through the courts and only a sheriff carries it out. Then send him to his attorney, because you do not prepare the notices that start it.

Assignment shares the liability; sublease keeps it

REMEMBER: Your tenant client wants to hand her apartment to a friend for the last eight months of a two-year lease. Is that an assignment or a sublease, and who does the landlord sue if the friend stops paying?

Rent Control and Rent Stabilization

Two programs, both overseen by the Division of Housing and Community Renewal

Many communities throughout New York have rent regulation programs known as rent control and rent stabilization. Rent regulations protect tenants in privately owned buildings from illegal rent increases, while allowing property owners to earn enough from rent to properly maintain their buildings and recognize a profit. The New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal, the DHCR, has oversight of state and local rent control and rent stabilization programs.

RENT CONTROL

Rent control is the older of the two systems. It dates back to the housing shortage immediately following World War II and generally applies to buildings constructed before 1947. In New York City rent control operates under the maximum base rent system. A maximum base rent is established for each apartment and is adjusted every two years to reflect changes in operating costs.

RENT STABILIZATION

Rent stabilization generally covers buildings built between 1947 and 1974, as well as apartments that have been removed from rent control. Outside New York City rent stabilization goes by the name ETPA, the Emergency Tenant Protection Act of 1974, and the DHCR determines the maximum allowable rates of rent increase.

Both types of regulation do the same two things. They restrict the amount of rent a property owner may charge, and they restrict the right of an owner to evict tenants. Rent stabilization then layers further protections on top, and the one tenants notice most is the right to have their leases renewed. Under the ETPA a tenant is in most cases entitled to a one-year or two-year renewal.

1947 and 1974 are the two lines

Hold those two dates the way you hold 1978 for lead paint. They are a starting point for a regulated building. The status of any given unit is a DHCR question with a paper record behind it.

GOOD CAUSE EVICTION · RPL ARTICLE 6-A

The Good Cause Eviction Law took effect on April 20, 2024, and it reaches many apartments neither program covers. It applies in New York City. A village, town or city outside the city is covered only if it adopts the law by local law. The main exemptions are a small landlord, meaning ten units or fewer in the state unless a local law sets another number, and an owner-occupied building of ten units or fewer. Also exempt are a unit already regulated, a condominium or cooperative unit, a building with a certificate of occupancy issued on or after January 1, 2009, for thirty years, and a unit renting above 245 percent of fair market rent.

A rent increase in a calendar year above the local rent standard is presumed unreasonable, and unpaid rent that came from an unreasonable increase is not good cause. The local rent standard is 5 percent plus the annual change in the Consumer Price Index, capped at 10 percent. The presumption is rebuttable, and a court weighs the landlord's costs, such as fuel, utilities, insurance, maintenance and property taxes. Every initial lease, renewal lease and eviction notice or petition must carry the state's notice telling the tenant whether the law applies and, if not, why.

CAUTION: Do not tell a client an apartment is regulated, or covered by Good Cause, or neither. You do not have the records. A buyer asking whether he can raise the rents in a 1952 building gets one answer: the status is checked before anybody prices the deal.

REMEMBER: Name the agency, the two year lines, and the one protection stabilization gives that control does not. Then say the formula that makes a Good Cause increase presumptively unreasonable.

Types of Leases

Leases are categorized by the method of rent payment

Leases are categorized by the method of rent payment, and the dividing line is who pays the bills that come with owning a building.

A gross lease is one in which the tenant pays a fixed rent while the owner pays all ownership expenses, such as property taxes, repairs, insurance and sometimes utilities. Almost every residential lease you handle is a gross lease.

A net lease is one in which the tenant pays some or all of the ownership expenses in addition to a monthly rent payment. Net leases are typically used for commercial properties. The owner has shifted much of the risk of increased costs to the tenant, and the tenant gets the additional tax benefit of the business expense.

The three expenses in question are taxes, insurance and maintenance. A lease requiring the tenant to pay one of them is a single net lease. A lease requiring the tenant to pay any two is a net-net lease, also called a double net lease. A triple net lease, also called a net-net-net lease, requires the tenant to pay all three.

COMMERCIAL LEASE TYPES

A percentage lease has the tenant pay a percentage of gross sales on the premises, often in addition to a fixed monthly rent. It is most common for retail tenants, and may include a clause allowing the owner to reclaim the premises if gross sales fall below a specified point. The landlord is buying a share of the tenant's business.

A land lease, also called a ground lease, is one in which a tenant leases unimproved land on a long-term basis. The lease typically provides that the tenant will construct a building on the property, which the tenant will own upon completion. That is why ground leases run for decades.

An index lease ties the amount of the rent to a common index indicator that neither the landlord nor the tenant controls, such as the Consumer Price Index or the Wholesale Price Index. As the agreed index increases, the rent goes up by the same percentage of change.

A graduated lease spells out step-by-step rent increases, or decreases, generally paid in installments. A long-term lease setting out annual rent increases is the ordinary example.

Lessees are entitled to quiet enjoyment, which is the right to the use and possession of real property without interference from the previous owner, the lessor, or anyone else claiming title. Lessors hold a reversionary interest, so the property reverts to them at the end of the term. Both are true of every lease type here.

NOTE: The exam separates these by one question. Who pays the taxes, the insurance and the maintenance? Gross means the owner. Net means the tenant, and the number of Ns tells you how many of the three. Index and graduated describe how the rent changes over time.

Gross, net, and how many Ns

REMEMBER: A retail tenant pays $4,000 a month plus 6 percent of everything over a set sales figure, and pays the property taxes as well. Name both lease types in that sentence.

Chapter 12 Summary

The eight things to carry out of contracts and leases

Classification. Express or implied, by how the contract was created. Unilateral or bilateral, by who promised. Executory or executed, by how far along performance is. Then valid, void, voidable or unenforceable. Executed is not executing.

Six essential elements. Competent parties, mutual agreement, consideration, a description, a lawful and possible objective, and written format with signatures where required. Miss an element and it is void. Lose genuine assent to fraud, undue influence, duress or mutual mistake and it is voidable by the injured party. Valid but unprovable is unenforceable.

Statute of frauds. General Obligations Law §5-703 requires contracts conveying an interest in real estate to be in writing and signed, covering purchase contracts, options, mortgages, deeds, powers of attorney to sell, and leases for more than one year. Part performance can rescue an oral agreement. Parol evidence says the writing overrides what was said before it. The Sullivan Law adds plain language at $50,000 or less.

Breach and remedies. Substantial performance still obliges the promisee, and material breach excuses her. A time is of the essence clause turns a missed deadline into a material breach, and the only cure is an extension agreed beforehand. The remedies are cancellation, compensatory damages, injunction, liquidated damages, reformation, rescission and specific performance.

Assignment and novation. An assignor stays secondarily liable even where the other party consented. Only a novation releases the one who leaves. Listing agreements are personal service contracts and cannot be assigned.

Offer and acceptance. A listing solicits offers rather than making one. Acceptance must be communicated to the offeror, made in the manner specified, and must not vary the terms. Any change is a counteroffer. Earnest money is neither consideration nor required, and it belongs in a separate escrow account from the moment it reaches you.

Preparing the contract. New York dictates no form. Upstate brokers use Bar-approved standardized contracts, fill in only the nonlegal provisions, and may add nothing unless the whole contract goes to the attorneys for all parties. New York City and Long Island use a one-page binder, the seller's attorney draws the contract, and the buyer signs first.

Leases. Estate for years, periodic estate and estate at will are leasehold estates. Tenancy at sufferance is not. A lease is a contract, so every essential element applies. Security deposits go in a separate escrow account, interest-bearing at six units or more. Assignment shares the liability and a sublease keeps it with the original tenant. Only a sheriff removes a tenant. In New York City, and in any locality that adopts it, the Good Cause Eviction Law requires good cause to remove a covered tenant or refuse a renewal. In New York City the FARE Act bars a landlord's agent from charging the tenant a fee.

Eight ideas, one body of law

REMEMBER: Which of the eight could you not explain to a client over the phone right now? Go back to that lesson before you take the quiz.

YOU BE THE JUDGE · ISSUE-SPOTTING CHALLENGE

The Ossining Overreach

Rosa takes a listing on a house in Ossining. The sellers ask for a rider covering the pool equipment, so Rosa opens the Bar Association form her office keeps on file, fills in the names, the property description, the terms of sale and the closing date, and then types three paragraphs of her own about the pool into the body of the preprinted contract. Nobody's attorney sees it. When the sellers ask whether they are locked in, she tells them they shook hands with the neighbour last spring about selling him the back lot, so “that one's already a done deal, handshakes hold up fine on land.”

A buyer submits an offer with a $12,000 check. Rosa tells the sellers the check is the consideration that makes the contract binding, and that no offer is worth looking at without one. She deposits the check into the brokerage's operating account because the escrow account statement had not come back yet. The sellers cash nothing but want the deal; Rosa phones the buyer's agent and says, “They've got the check, so you're accepted.” The sellers then send back the same offer with the closing date moved out four weeks, and Rosa writes in her file that the contract is fully accepted as of that date.

The buyer turns out to be seventeen. When the sellers get a better offer, Rosa tells them not to worry, a minor's contract is no contract, so they are free to walk away and take the new one. Meanwhile a second file is falling apart: that contract says time is of the essence and the closing deadline came and went on the 15th, but Rosa tells the buyer to relax, she will just give him another three weeks to get his financing together.

On a third file the buyer wants out and asks to hand the contract to his brother-in-law. Rosa papers an assignment and tells the buyer he is now completely off the hook. She also assigns her own listing agreement on the property to a friend at another brokerage who has more time to work it. Finally, one of her landlord clients calls about a tenant who stopped paying in the spring; Rosa tells him to change the locks over the weekend and put the tenant's things on the porch.

Twelve violations are buried in that story, and one lawful act has been planted in it to catch you out. Work it the way you would work a file rather than the way you would take a test.

Read it once for the story and mark nothing. Read it again with a pen and mark every sentence that made you pause, without deciding yet whether it is a violation. Then go back through this chapter and name the rule each marked sentence touches.

Four threads run through the facts. What a licensee may write on a contract form, and what has to be in writing at all. How an offer becomes a contract, and what money has to do with it. Which contracts a minor can escape, and which deadlines nobody can. Who stays liable after a contract is handed to somebody else, and how a landlord may lawfully get a tenant out.

Rosa is confident in every paragraph, and the confidence is what makes this fact pattern useful. She says each wrong thing out loud to a client who trusts her, which is how these violations happen in a real office. Read her dialogue as evidence rather than as narration.

One sentence describes something Rosa did correctly, and it sits right next to sentences that are wrong. Finding it is the harder half of the exercise. An accusation made too quickly is its own kind of problem, and a licensee who cannot tell a permitted act from a violation is no safer than one who commits them.

Sort the marked sentences into three piles. Clearly a violation. Clearly lawful. Cannot tell from these facts. The third pile is the one that teaches you something, because for every item in it you have to name the missing fact that would move it into one of the other two. Naming the missing fact is the skill, and it is also how a good file gets built.

Then argue the other side of the item you were least sure about. Say it out loud in full sentences, as though Rosa is across the table and has a reason for everything she did. If you cannot build that argument at all, go back and read the screen the rule came from, because you have memorized a phrase rather than learned a rule.

Watch for the moment Rosa stops describing and starts advising. There are several. Each time she answers a legal question with her own opinion instead of sending the client to an attorney, she has crossed the line Chapter 1 drew, whether or not her answer happened to be correct.

NOTE: If your answer to an issue is a rule with no facts attached, you have not spotted an issue. You have recited a rule and hoped it fit. Name the fact first, then name the rule it breaks.

Name the fact, then name the rule

Check yourself

12 questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see whether it is right and why.

Key terms

Executory contract
A contract in which one or both parties have not yet fully performed; an executed contract is fully performed.
Voidable contract
A contract one party may cancel because of incapacity, fraud, undue influence, duress or mistake; valid until disaffirmed.
Consideration
Anything of value given to induce agreement, including a promise to refrain; need not be equal in value.
Statute of Frauds
GOL §5-703: contracts conveying an interest in real estate, and leases over one year, must be in writing and signed to be enforceable.
Time is of the essence
A clause making timely performance essential, so that missing a deadline is a material breach.
Liquidated damages
A sum fixed in the contract in advance as the damages payable on breach.
Specific performance
A court order requiring the breaching party to perform the contract rather than pay damages.
Novation
Substitution of a new contract or new party for an old one, releasing the original party from liability.
Counteroffer
A response that changes any term of an offer; it rejects the original offer and creates a new one.
Earnest money
A deposit made with an offer to show the buyer's seriousness; not consideration, not required, and held in a separate escrow account.
Binder
The one-page sales agreement or deal sheet used in NYC and Long Island that goes to the attorneys, who then draw the formal contract.
Escape (kick-out) clause
A provision letting a seller keep marketing while a buyer's home-sale contingency is pending, giving the buyer a short period to perform or release.
Right of first refusal
The right to match a third party's offer before an owner sells or leases to that third party.
Installment sales (land) contract
A contract in which the vendee pays the vendor over time and title does not pass until all or a specified part is paid.
Tenancy at sufferance
A holdover tenant who remains after a lease expires without permission; not a leasehold estate.
Warranty of habitability
The landlord's duty to deliver and maintain premises fit for living and free of dangerous conditions.
Constructive eviction
A landlord's failure that deprives the tenant of quiet enjoyment (no heat, no plumbing); the tenant must vacate to claim it.

Practise this chapter

Flashcards (free) Practice exam

Read Chapter 12 in the Book

The Book comes with the Salesperson pass ($39 for 3 months).

A study course, in beta. This is not a New York State Department of State approved qualifying course, and the time you spend here does not count toward the 77 hours you need for a salesperson license. Take the 77-hour course at a DOS-approved school; use this to learn the material and to review it. · Powered by License to Earn LLC