The Course · Chapter 11 Beta

Chapter 11: Human Rights and Fair Housing

Fair and equitable treatment for all people in housing is a right by law, not a choice

In this chapter

  • What this session gives you The evolution of fair housing
  • Trace the statutes and the Supreme Court decisions from the Civil Rights Act of 1866 to the 1988 amendments. Identify discrimination
  • Recognize steering, blockbusting, redlining, refusal to deal, unequal terms, and discriminatory advertising. Federal fair housing law
  • Name the seven federally protected classes, the conduct the Act forbids, and its four exemptions. The Americans with Disabilities Act
  • Explain the five titles, Title III public accommodations, and the exemptions to it. Advertising guidelines
  • Apply § 804(c), the equal housing opportunity logo, and the fair housing poster requirement. The cost of violating
  • State the filing deadlines and the penalty ceilings at HUD, the DOJ, and the Division of Human Rights. New York State law
  • Distinguish the federal, state, and New York City protected classes, and how New York narrows the exemptions. Bias, ethics, and you

Lesson 1

The Evolution of Fair Housing Law

Two hundred years of advances and reverses in the struggle for equal rights

The Civil Rights Act of 1866

The first federal law to guarantee equal housing, and the cases that tested it

Fair and equitable treatment in housing is a right by law. It is not a courtesy you extend to the clients you like. This chapter is the longest one in the course and it carries the most risk, because a licensee who learns a protected class wrong, or an exemption wrong, does not fail a test. A licensee who learns it wrong turns a real family away from a real home.

Start at the beginning. The Civil Rights Act of 1866 was the first major effort of the federal government to guarantee equal housing to all United States citizens. It prohibits any type of discrimination based on race or color. The 1866 Act carries a blanket statement: all citizens of the United States have the same right in every state to inherit, buy, sell, lease and convey real and personal property.

Two facts about the 1866 Act do the work. It provides no exemptions of any kind. And it is enforceable in federal court.

Hold onto the phrase no exemptions. Later in this chapter you will learn four federal exemptions, four state exemptions and two city exemptions, and every one of them has a hole in it shaped like the 1866 Act. Racial discrimination is prohibited in any property transaction regardless of the exemptions available under the federal Fair Housing Act. There is no version of this chapter in which race is exempt.

The road from 1866 to a working fair housing law took more than a hundred years, and it did not run straight. There have been legal advances and legal reverses in the struggle for equal rights. Three Supreme Court decisions mark the turns.

THREE RULINGS THAT FRAMED THE FAIR HOUSING ACT

Plessy v. Ferguson, 1896. In 1890 Louisiana passed a law requiring that all railway companies carrying passengers in their coaches in the state provide equal but separate accommodations for the white and colored races. Homer Plessy, a thirty-year-old shoemaker, was jailed for refusing to vacate the white car of the East Louisiana Railroad. He contested the law in court, arguing that it violated the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments. The Supreme Court ruled in favor of a separate but equal doctrine of legalized racial segregation, holding that the Louisiana statute did not deprive Black citizens of equal protection of the laws so long as they were furnished accommodations equal to those of whites.

Brown v. Board of Education, 1954. The case involved segregation in the public school system of Topeka, Kansas. The Supreme Court concluded that separate educational facilities were inherently unequal and that segregation violated the Constitution. Brown overturned Plessy after fifty-eight years.

The Civil Rights Act of 1964 brought about the end of Jim Crow laws and guaranteed access to education and public spaces to everyone regardless of race. It was a large statute and it left a large gap. Like the 1866 Act, the 1964 Act did not address discrimination based on other factors such as gender or religion, and neither Act addressed housing discrimination at all. Housing waited until 1968.

Case in Point. Jones v. Alfred H. Mayer Co., decided by the United States Supreme Court in 1968.

THE FACTS. Mr. and Mrs. Jones, an African American couple, attempted to buy a home in a subdivision being developed near St. Louis by the Mayer Company. Their offer was refused. They filed suit against the Mayer Company under the Civil Rights Act of 1866, claiming they had been turned down because of their race.

THE RULING. The court ruled in favor of the Joneses and held that the 1866 Act was constitutional. It reiterated that the Act prohibited racial discrimination by the state and by any private organization. And it stated that when it comes to race with regard to the sale or rental of housing, there are no exceptions and no exemptions.

Read the phrase by any private organization twice. A private seller is not the government. A private landlord is not the government. Neither one is outside the 1866 Act. That is the holding, and it is the reason a New York licensee can never tell a seller that a private sale puts a racial instruction beyond the reach of federal law.

The consequence for you is immediate. A seller who says he will not entertain an offer from a particular family because of their race is asking you to help him break the oldest civil rights statute on the books. You do not carry out the instruction. You do not quietly work around it. You tell your employing broker, and the Your Obligations as a Licensee screen later in this chapter tells you exactly why that phone call protects your license.

There is a second reason the 1866 Act matters to a working licensee, and it is procedural. The Act is enforceable in federal court. A person who believes he was refused a house because of his race does not have to go to an agency, wait for an investigation, and hope for a finding of probable cause. He can file a lawsuit. That route has no filing window measured in months, no conciliation stage, and no agency deciding whether the complaint is worth pursuing.

Put the 1866 Act and the modern Fair Housing Act side by side and the shape of the whole chapter appears. The Fair Housing Act is broad, it covers seven classes, and it comes with exemptions and procedures. The 1866 Act is narrow, it covers race and color only, and it comes with nothing attached at all. Wherever you find an exemption later in this chapter, the 1866 Act is standing underneath it on the one ground it covers.

DOS Subject 9 opens this material with the legacy behind it, and the legacy is worth one honest sentence. Segregation in American housing was not an accident of taste. It was built by law, by court decision, by lending policy and by the ordinary daily practice of real estate licensees, and the statutes in this chapter exist because that practice worked. The historic lack of access to opportunity in housing is the thing the law is trying to undo, and you are now one of the people who decides whether it keeps getting undone.

NOTE: The exam separates the four dates on this screen by what each one reached. 1866 reached property, race and color, with no exemptions. 1896 upheld segregation. 1954 overturned it. 1964 reached education and public spaces and left housing alone. Only the Fair Housing Act of 1968, on the next screen, reached housing directly.

No exemptions have ever covered race

REMEMBER: A seller tells you to screen out buyers of one race on a private, unlisted sale. Name the statute that stops him, the year, and the case that said private parties are bound by it.

Building the Federal Fair Housing Act

Four statutes, each one adding protected classes to the one before it

The federal Fair Housing Act is not one statute passed on one day. It is a stack. Congress passed a series of acts that extended the Civil Rights Act of 1866, and together they came to be known as the federal Fair Housing Act. Learn the stack in order, because the exam asks which act added which class, and because knowing the order tells you how recent each protection is.

The Fair Housing Act of 1968 may also be referred to as Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1968. It was the first meaningful legislation to address discrimination in the sale and rental of housing. It upheld the prohibitions against racial discrimination and added two protected classes: religion and national origin.

The Housing and Community Development Act of 1974 reinforced the federal Fair Housing Act by adding sex, also written as gender, to the list of protected classes.

The Fair Housing Amendments Act of 1988 amended Title VIII to prohibit discrimination based on disability and on familial status. The 1988 amendments did something else that matters just as much. They greatly expanded the enforcement role of the Department of Housing and Urban Development, moving HUD beyond investigation and conciliation and into mandatory enforcement. Before 1988 HUD investigated and tried to talk the parties into a settlement. After 1988 HUD could make the finding stick.

The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 sits beside the stack rather than inside it. Congress further expanded the necessary accommodations, creating consistent and enforceable standards and a clear and comprehensive national mandate for the elimination of discrimination against individuals with disabilities. The ADA gets its own screen later in this chapter.

SEVEN FEDERALLY PROTECTED CLASSES

Race. Color. Religion. National origin. Sex, or gender. Familial status. Handicap or disability. That is the federal list and it has seven items on it. Say the seven out loud now, because in a few screens you will be handed a New York list of fifteen and a New York City list of seventeen, and the only way to keep the three straight is to know which one is the shortest.

The Act does more than stop a landlord from saying no. It also prohibits discrimination in advertising, in real estate brokerage, in lending, and in other services associated with residential transactions. A brokerage that never refuses a single applicant can still violate the Act through the advertisement it writes or the service it fails to give.

The Act protects individuals associated with persons in a protected class. A landlord who refuses a white applicant because her husband is Black has discriminated on the basis of race, and the fact that the applicant is not the person the landlord objected to changes nothing.

The Act protects United States citizens and non-citizens alike. Nothing in the seven classes turns on immigration status.

The Act sets a floor and not a ceiling. The federal Fair Housing Act contains the provision that state and local governments may adopt legislation that increases the protections provided. New York State does. New York City does. Several New York counties do. That single sentence is why this chapter has three protected-class lists in it rather than one, and why a licensee who learns only the federal seven is under-equipped to practice in this state.

Notice what the stack tells you about age. Disability and familial status are the newest federal classes and they arrived in 1988. That is well within the working life of brokers still practicing today, which is part of why those two are the classes where you still find offices with habits that were legal when the office opened. Old habits in this business are not quaint. They are liabilities with a date on them.

One more consequence of the federal Act being a floor. Where New York gives more protection, New York governs, and you never have to choose between them. You give the client the benefit of whichever law protects him further. The only time the federal Act is the operative rule is where nothing stricter applies, and in New York that situation is rare.

NOTE: A favorite exam question gives you a class and asks which act added it. 1968: religion and national origin. 1974: sex. 1988: disability and familial status. Race and color were there from 1866 and were carried forward by every act since.

Seven federal classes, built in four steps

REMEMBER: Cover this screen and name the seven federal classes. Then name the two that arrived last, and the year they arrived.

The Seven Federally Protected Classes

What familial status means, and the one narrow exception to it

The federal Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination in the sale or lease of residential property on all seven classes: race, color, religion, national origin, sex or gender, familial status, and handicap or disability. Six of the seven explain themselves. Familial status does not, and it is the one students get wrong.

Familial status refers to two groups of people. Households that include individuals under the age of 18 who live with a parent or legal custodian. And pregnant women, or any person in the process of obtaining legal custody of a child under the age of 18. Read that second group again. A pregnant applicant is protected before the child exists, and a grandmother in the middle of a custody proceeding is protected before the custody order is signed.

In effect the Act makes it illegal to discriminate against a person because he or she is a parent or guardian with custody of a child under 18 years old. Familial status is not about marriage. It is a rule about children in the household, and a landlord who prefers quiet adults has just described a protected class out loud.

The practical shape of a familial status violation is almost never a refusal in plain words. It is an advertisement that says adults preferred. It is a rule that children may not use the courtyard. It is a policy putting every family with children in the rear building. Each of those changes the terms of the tenancy for one class of people, and changing the terms is discrimination just as surely as saying no.

HOUSING FOR OLDER PERSONS: THE ONE EXEMPTION FROM FAMILIAL STATUS

Families with children may be denied access to properties that qualify as housing for older persons under the 1988 Fair Housing Amendments Act. There are three ways a property qualifies, and a property needs only one of them. Learn all three conditions of the third one, because that is the route most communities actually use and it is the route with the conditions people forget.

First route. Property provided under a state or federal program designed to assist the elderly.

Second route. Property intended for and solely occupied by persons 62 or older. Solely is the operative word. One resident under 62 and the property is not on this route.

Third route. Property designed to meet the physical and social needs of older persons, where three things are all true at once. Management publishes and follows policies and procedures demonstrating an intent to provide housing for persons 55 or older. At least 80 percent of the units are occupied by at least one person 55 or older. And the facility or community provides HUD with surveys and affidavits confirming the ages of residents. All three. A community that publishes a 55-and-older policy and files nothing with HUD has not met the test.

If any one of these specific exceptions exists, senior housing facilities and communities can lawfully refuse to sell or rent dwellings to families with minor children, or may impose different terms and conditions of residency. That is the whole of the exemption and it goes no further.

Where minor children are permitted, those families may not be segregated in a particular section, building, or portion of a building. And senior housing facilities may not discriminate on race, color, religion, sex, disability, or national origin. The exemption covers familial status. It covers nothing else on the list.

Hypothetical. A Rochester landlord advertises a two-bedroom as ideal for a professional couple and tells you he will not rent it to anyone with a toddler, because the apartment below has a shift worker who sleeps days. His reason is real and his reason is irrelevant. Familial status does not ask why. It asks whether the household with a child under 18 was treated differently, and here it was refused outright and described out of the advertisement as well.

CAUTION: Qualifying senior housing is the only exemption from familial status, and it is an exemption from familial status alone. A 55-and-older community that turns away an applicant because of his national origin has violated the Fair Housing Act exactly as any other housing provider would.

Familial status means children, not marriage

REMEMBER: A community tells you it is 55-and-older and may refuse a family with a nine-year-old. Name the three conditions you would want to see satisfied before you repeat that to a buyer.

Lesson 2

Disability, Access, and the ADA

Two duties, two payers, and the building standards that came in on 13 March 1991

Disability Under the Fair Housing Act

A physical or mental impairment that substantially limits or curtails a major life activity

Disability is defined for fair housing purposes as a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits or curtails one or more major life activities. The federal Fair Housing Act then breaks that definition into three parts, and the exam tests the parts rather than the sentence.

Major life activities are functions such as caring for one's self, performing manual tasks, walking, seeing, hearing, speaking, breathing, learning, and working. Notice how ordinary that list is. Nothing on it is exotic. An impairment that substantially limits any one of them meets the definition.

Physical impairment means any physiological disorder or condition, cosmetic disfigurement, or anatomical loss. The Act gives examples: blindness, hearing impairment, mobility impairment, AIDS or HIV infection and other diseases that cannot be transmitted by casual contact, chronic fatigue, alcoholism, drug addiction.

Mental impairment means any mental or psychological disorder, such as organic brain syndrome, emotional or mental illness, and specific learning disabilities.

Two items on the physical impairment list surprise people and both of them are tested. Alcoholism is an impairment. So is drug addiction. A landlord who refuses an applicant because the applicant is in recovery has refused an applicant with a disability.

WHO IS NOT COVERED

The disability discrimination provisions of the Fair Housing Act do not extend to someone who claims to be disabled solely on the basis of being a sex offender, of using illegal drugs, or of posing a threat to others. Under the Americans with Disabilities Act the term individual with a disability likewise does not include a person who is currently engaging in the illegal use of drugs, where the covered entity acts on the basis of that use.

Hold the two ideas side by side, because they sit one line apart in the statute and they point in opposite directions. Addiction is a protected impairment. Current illegal drug use is not protected when the housing provider acts on the basis of that use. A licensee who reads the first half and stops has learned the trap rather than the rule.

HOW MANY PEOPLE THIS REACHES

According to the U.S. Census Bureau there are over forty million Americans with a disability, representing 12.8 percent of the civilian non-institutionalized population. Nearly 34.2 million people, or 17.5 percent, have a functional limitation. You will work with these clients every year of your career whether you know it or not.

Never assume. Because a person does not use a wheelchair, have hearing aids, or use a cane does not mean that they do not have a disability. Many disabilities are invisible, including autism, deafness, epilepsy, asthma and mental illness. Some people have temporary disabilities that are equally as limiting as permanent ones. And not everyone with a disability wishes to discuss it or its limitations.

The practical rule that follows from all of this is short. Do not ask. Do not guess. When a person tells you what they need, listen to what they said and act on it, and leave the diagnosis to the doctor who made it.

There is a question licensees ask constantly and it deserves a clean answer. May you ask an applicant whether he has a disability? No. What you may do is respond to what a person tells you. If a client says he needs a ground-floor unit, you look for ground-floor units. You do not ask why, you do not record a diagnosis, and you do not repeat it to the landlord as background. The need is the operative fact and the condition behind it is not your business.

The same discipline applies to what you volunteer. A licensee who tells a co-op board that an applicant is in recovery, or that a buyer's child is autistic, has handed a housing provider a protected characteristic it did not ask for and cannot lawfully act on. Even where the disclosure was innocent, the board's next decision is now contaminated, and you are the reason.

Hypothetical. A Syracuse landlord tells you he will not rent to a man who mentioned he attends a recovery program, because he does not want that in the building. Addiction is an impairment on the protected list. The applicant is not currently using illegal drugs, so the exclusion does not reach him. The landlord has just described a disability refusal and asked you to carry it out.

CAUTION: A licensee who decides on his own that a client cannot manage a walk-up, and quietly stops sending her those listings, has steered on the basis of disability. He has also skipped the only step that was his to take, which was to show her the listing and let her decide.

Invisible disabilities are still disabilities

REMEMBER: Name two impairments on the protected list that students routinely think are excluded, and name the one drug-related situation that genuinely is excluded.

Accommodation, Modification, and Accessible Design

Two duties every housing provider owes, and two different people paying for them

Under the federal Fair Housing Act, if a tenant or someone associated with the tenant has a disability, the housing provider may not discriminate and owes two separate duties. The two duties have similar names and different payers, and telling them apart is worth more exam points than any other pair of terms in this chapter.

REASONABLE ACCOMMODATION: THE PROVIDER PAYS

A reasonable accommodation is a change in rules, policies, practices, or services, where the change is necessary for the disabled person to use the housing on an equal basis with non-disabled persons. Nothing physical is altered. A rule bends.

The standard example is a guide dog. A visually impaired person cannot be prohibited from having a guide dog in a building with a no-pet policy. The building keeps its no-pet policy for everyone else. The policy gives way for this tenant because the dog is what makes the apartment usable.

The housing provider is responsible for the costs associated with a reasonable accommodation, unless the accommodation is an undue financial and administrative burden. Undue burden is a real limit and it is a narrow one. It is measured against the provider's resources, not against the provider's preference.

REASONABLE MODIFICATION: THE TENANT PAYS

A reasonable modification is a physical change to the dwelling or to common use areas that would permit the tenant to fully use the housing. Grab bars in the bathroom. A widened doorway. A ramp at the entrance. The provider must allow the modification.

The tenant, or someone acting on the tenant's behalf, is responsible for the costs associated with a reasonable modification. Where reasonable, the housing provider can require the tenant to restore the property to its original condition upon moving out. New York adds one condition of its own: the modification must conform to the provisions of fire prevention and building codes.

Two words do all the work. Accommodation changes a rule and the provider pays. Modification changes the building and the tenant pays. Run every fact pattern through that one sentence and you will get it right.

ACCESSIBLE DESIGN: NEW MULTI-FAMILY BUILDINGS

Some buildings had to be built accessible in the first place. Under the federal Fair Housing Act, new multi-family buildings of four or more units that have an elevator and that were built for first occupancy on or after March 13, 1991, must provide wheelchair-width doors and hallways, accessible public and common areas, accessible routes into and through the unit, accessible light switches, electrical outlets, thermostats and other environmental controls, reinforced bathroom walls to allow later installation of grab bars, and kitchens and bathrooms that can be used by people in wheelchairs.

In a building with no elevator, those standards apply to ground units only.

Now the sentence that connects the design rule back to the money. If any of the structural changes needed by the tenant are ones that should have been included in the unit or in the public and common use areas when it was constructed, then the housing provider may be responsible for providing and paying for those requested structural changes. The tenant pays for modifications. The tenant does not pay to fix a builder's failure to follow the 1991 standard.

Hypothetical. A tenant in a Bronx building asks the landlord to assign her the parking space nearest the door because she uses a cane, in a lot where spaces are assigned by lottery. Nothing is built, moved or altered. A rule about how spaces are assigned bends for one tenant. That is an accommodation, and the landlord pays for it, which in this case costs nothing but a different name on a list.

Change one fact and the answer changes with it. The same tenant asks that a handrail be installed along the path from the lot to the door. Now something physical is being added to a common use area. That is a modification, the tenant pays, and the landlord must allow it, subject to New York's requirement that the work conform to fire prevention and building codes.

NOTE: Three facts carry this screen and all three get tested. Four or more units. An elevator. First occupancy on or after March 13, 1991. Change any one of them and you are outside the accessible design requirement, except for the ground-floor rule in a building with no elevator.

Rules and the provider pays; building and the tenant pays

REMEMBER: A wheelchair user asks to widen a bathroom door at his own expense, and a blind tenant asks for an exception to the no-pet rule. Which is which, and who pays for each?

Case in Point: The Townsend House Corp.

HUD No. 08-156, October 9, 2008 - a Manhattan co-op, a no-pet policy, and an autistic child

The last screen gave you the rule. This screen shows you a New York housing provider that agreed to the rule, said yes in writing, and got charged with housing discrimination anyway. It is the most useful case in this chapter because nobody in it ever refused anything out loud.

Case in Point. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development announced that it had charged The Townsend House Corp., a private cooperative in New York City, with housing discrimination for refusing to allow a family to obtain an animal that provides emotional support for their autistic child.

THE FACTS. Maria Mostajo and Mark Schein are the parents of an eleven-year-old boy who has been diagnosed with Autistic Spectrum Disorder and Central Auditory Processing Disorder, which significantly impair his day-to-day functioning and his ability to learn and hear. To treat their son's disorders, the child's doctor prescribed that the parents acquire a support animal to provide emotional support for their son. Before acquiring the animal the parents requested an exception to the co-op's no-pet policy, and they supplied documentation from doctors confirming the child's disabilities and the need for the animal.

THE RULING. After receiving that documentation, the co-op agreed to permit the parents to obtain a dog for their son, but only subject to the terms contained in a Pets License Agreement drafted specifically for this family. HUD's investigation confirmed that the Agreement contained unreasonable restrictions that in effect denied the reasonable accommodation to the child. The Fair Housing Act makes it unlawful to refuse to make reasonable accommodations in rules, policies, practices, or services, when such accommodation may be necessary to afford a person with disabilities equal opportunity to use and enjoy a dwelling.

WHAT THE CO-OP DEMANDED

The Agreement required the parents to obtain insurance providing liability coverage of $1,000,000.00. It imposed a ten-pound weight limit on the animal. It imposed a limit on how long the service animal could be left alone in the apartment. And it required that the dog be muzzled when in the co-op's common areas.

Look at the ten-pound limit and the muzzle together. A support animal prescribed for an autistic child has a job to do, and a ten-pound ceiling decides in advance which animals may do it. A muzzle in every common area tells the whole building which child is the one with the accommodation. Neither condition came from a rule that applied to anyone else, because the Agreement was drafted for this one family.

Quote the enforcement officer, because the sentence is the standard. It is not right or legal for landlords to dictate the unreasonable terms and conditions by which persons with disabilities should live their lives, said Kim Kendrick, HUD Assistant Secretary for Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity. HUD is deeply committed to enforcing the Fair Housing Act to make sure that this does not happen.

WHY IT MATTERS TO YOU

Saying yes is not enough. A housing provider that grants an accommodation and then loads it with conditions no other resident faces has refused the accommodation. The paperwork says approved. The conduct says no. HUD looked at the conduct.

Co-op and condominium boards are housing providers for this purpose. So are their managing agents. In New York City an enormous share of the housing stock is co-op and condominium, which means an enormous share of the reasonable accommodation requests in this state land on a volunteer board that has never read the Fair Housing Act. You are frequently the only person in the room who has.

That puts a working question in front of you every time a board asks your advice. A board may set conditions on an accommodation. A board may not set conditions that swallow it. The test is whether the condition is something the board would impose on any resident, or whether it exists only because this resident is disabled.

Hypothetical. A Queens co-op board approves an emotional support animal and then tells the shareholder the dog may only ride the service elevator. No other resident is restricted to the service elevator. The condition applies to one household, it exists only because of the accommodation, and it marks the family every time they leave the building. That is the Townsend House pattern with a different set of facts.

The defensive move for a licensee is the same in every version of this. Put the request in writing. Put the doctor's documentation in the file. Put the board's answer in writing, conditions and all. A file that shows what was asked and what was granted is the only record anyone will have a year later when an investigator asks.

One more thing to take from this case. The family did everything a housing provider could reasonably ask. They requested the exception before acquiring the animal rather than after. They supplied documentation from doctors confirming the disabilities and the need. They went through the front door. A provider who then answers a well-made request with a specially drafted agreement has not raised a legitimate concern. It has raised a wall.

CAUTION: Do not treat the disclosure of a disability as information to pass along. A tenant's diagnosis belongs in the accommodation request and nowhere else. Repeating it to a board member, a neighbor or another agent is its own problem, and it has nothing to do with whether the accommodation was granted.

An approval with impossible conditions is a refusal

REMEMBER: A board says yes to a service animal and attaches four conditions. Which question do you ask about each condition before you tell the shareholder the board complied?

The Americans with Disabilities Act

Signed into law in 1990 - five titles, and the one that changed every public building

The federal Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination against persons with disabilities in housing. Congress went further in 1990 and expanded the necessary accommodations through the Americans with Disabilities Act.

At the time the ADA was signed into law in 1990 there were more than 43 million Americans with one or more physical or mental disabilities. Congress found that, unlike other protected classes, individuals with disabilities repeatedly encountered a variety of forms of discrimination and often had no legal recourse. The purpose of the Act was to provide a clear and comprehensive national mandate for the elimination of discrimination against individuals with disabilities, and to create consistent and enforceable standards.

The ADA addresses five general areas, called titles. Learn them as a list of five and learn Title III properly, because Title III is the one that reaches your office and your open houses.

Title I, Employment. Employers engaged in interstate commerce having 15 or more employees, including employment agencies, labor organizations, or joint labor-management committees.

Title II, Public Services. State and local services and public transportation.

Title III, Public Accommodations. Private entities which own, lease, lease to, or operate a place of public accommodation.

Title IV, Telecommunications. Common carriers engaged in interstate communication.

Title V, Miscellaneous Provisions. Minimum guidelines, a technical assistance plan, and a number of other provisions.

TITLE III HAS HAD THE GREATEST EFFECT ON THE LIVES OF DISABLED PERSONS

A public accommodation is a facility that is owned, leased, leased to, or operated by a private entity. Title III requires public accommodations to make reasonable modifications in policies, practices, or procedures when the modifications are necessary to afford goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations to individuals with disabilities. The public accommodation escapes the requirement only where it can demonstrate that making the modification is not readily achievable, or that the modification would fundamentally alter the nature of what is offered.

Title III primarily deals with accessibility of public facilities such as restaurants, hotels and parks. It also requires that public and common use areas at housing developments comply with its accessibility provisions. That is the sentence that puts the ADA into a residential file, and it is the one students skip.

Notice the vocabulary problem before it costs you a question. Under the Fair Housing Act, a modification is physical and the tenant pays for it. Under ADA Title III, a modification is a change in policies, practices or procedures made by the business. Same word, two statutes, two meanings. Read which Act a question is asking about before you answer it.

EXEMPTIONS TO TITLE III

Title III exempts private clubs and places of worship. Historic buildings, meaning properties listed or eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places, must still comply with Title III to the maximum extent feasible. Where adapting the building would destroy its historic significance, an alternative can be used. An alternative for a real estate sales office in a historic building might be holding a meeting with a client at another location.

That alternative is a real answer to a real problem, and it is also a trap. Meeting the client somewhere else is an alternative to an inaccessible entrance. It is not an alternative to serving the client. A licensee who uses the historic building as a reason to hand the client to somebody else has not found an alternative. He has declined the business of a person with a disability.

PENALTIES

$55,000

maximum civil penalty, first violation

Enforced by the U.S. Department of Justice and the Attorney General, who may also grant equitable relief and award monetary damages. Civil penalties may NOT be assessed against state or local governments.

The goal of the ADA enforcement program is to work with wrongdoers toward compliance, and alternative means of dispute resolution are encouraged through settlement negotiations, conciliation, facilitation, mediation, fact-finding and arbitration. Where offenders refuse to comply and violations are substantial, private individuals or the Department of Justice may initiate actions, including court orders to stop discrimination.

Keep the two statutes in their own lanes and most ADA questions answer themselves. The Fair Housing Act is about dwellings: where people live, and who may live there. The ADA is about access to goods, services and facilities: where people go, and whether they can get in. A client's apartment is a fair housing question. Your office, the lobby you meet them in, and the community room of the development you are selling are ADA questions.

That division is why the ADA sits in a fair housing chapter at all. A licensee's own place of business is a public accommodation operated by a private entity, which is the Title III definition. The sign on your door invites the public in. Having invited them, you are responsible for whether they can actually come in.

The requirement is not that everything be rebuilt. Title III asks for reasonable modifications in policies, practices or procedures, and lets the public accommodation off where the modification is not readily achievable or would fundamentally alter the nature of what is offered. Readily achievable is a real standard and it is measured against what the business can do. A brokerage that has never once asked the question will find that standard harder to meet than one that has.

NOTE: The ADA and the Fair Housing Act are enforced by different agencies. Fair housing complaints go to HUD. ADA enforcement runs through the Department of Justice and the U.S. Attorney General. A question naming the wrong agency for the wrong statute is testing exactly that.

Five titles; Title III reaches your office

REMEMBER: Your brokerage rents a storefront with two steps at the door and no ramp. Which title applies, who enforces it, and what is the first question you ask your broker?

Lesson 3

Prohibited Conduct

Steering moves the people. Blockbusting moves the owners. Redlining moves the money.

Three Practices Students Confuse

The same prejudice, three different mechanisms - tell them apart by who acts and on whom

Steering, blockbusting and redlining come from the same prejudice and run through three different machines. Students mix them up on the exam and licensees mix them up in the field. There is a reliable way to separate them. Ask who is doing it, and ask who it is being done to.

STEERING: THE LICENSEE DECIDES WHAT YOU SEE

Steering relates to buyers or renters. It is channeling prospective buyers or renters to or away from specific neighborhoods based on their race, religion, national origin, or another protected class, in order to maintain or change the character of a neighborhood. Caucasian customers might be shown homes only in traditionally Caucasian neighborhoods, and Hispanic customers shown homes only in traditionally Hispanic neighborhoods.

The licensee is the actor. The buyer or renter is the person acted upon. And steering is prohibited even where the prospective buyer or tenant asks for it. That last clause is the one that catches honest agents, and the next screen takes it apart.

BLOCKBUSTING: THE OWNERS ARE THE TARGET

Blockbusting relates to owners. It is inducing or attempting to induce, for profit, any person to sell or rent property based on representations made regarding entry into the neighborhood of persons of a particular race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. It is prohibited under federal and state law. You may also hear it called panic selling or panic peddling.

The licensee is again the actor, and this time the owner is the target. The owner is told the neighborhood is changing, that values will fall, that crime will rise, that the schools will suffer. Enough owners believe it and the block sells cheap. The licensee buys low, resells high, and the profit is the point.

REDLINING: THE MONEY STOPS AT THE LINE

Redlining is discriminating against anyone by a commercial lender in making a loan for buying, building, repairing, improving or maintaining a dwelling, or in the terms of such financing. It is a refusal to make loans or provide insurance on property located in particular neighborhoods for discriminatory reasons, which is where the name comes from: a red line drawn around an area on a map.

The actor here is not the licensee. Redlining relates to mortgage lending and insurance brokers, not to showing property. A licensee does not redline. A licensee watches it happen to his buyers and has to be able to name it.

Lenders may still deny loans in neighborhoods where property values are declining. That decision must be based on objective criteria regarding the condition and value of the property or the area. A lender may not simply equate integrated or minority neighborhoods with declining property values.

Filtering down is what follows redlining. With purchase and renovation loans almost impossible to get, it becomes extremely difficult to market, maintain, or improve homes in those neighborhoods, so values decline, and the assumption that started the cycle appears to have been correct all along. The prophecy pays for itself.

Hold the three side by side. Steering moves the people. Blockbusting moves the owners. Redlining moves the money. Two of the three are your own offense as a licensee. The third is one you will see done to your clients.

One more distinction separates the first two from each other, and it is about what the offender wants. A licensee who steers wants to keep a neighborhood the way it is, or to change it, and the steering is the instrument. A licensee who blockbusts wants the commissions and the resale margin, and the fear is the instrument. The federal definition of blockbusting says for profit in so many words, and the definition of steering does not mention profit at all.

Hypothetical, with three characters and one afternoon. A licensee shows an Albany buyer only the listings east of the highway and tells her the other side would not suit her. That is steering. The same licensee then telephones owners on the west side to say the neighborhood is turning and they should list now. That is blockbusting. Her buyer's mortgage application on a west-side house is declined by a lender that has written off the area on a map. That is redlining, and it is the one act on the afternoon that was not hers.

NOTE: An exam question describing a lender is never steering, and a question describing a buyer being shown a short list is never redlining. Identify the actor first. The answer usually falls out before you have finished reading the options.

Steering moves people; blockbusting moves owners

REMEMBER: Say the three definitions in one sentence each, naming who acts and who is acted upon, without looking back at this screen.

Steering and Blockbusting Up Close

Both are the licensee's own offense, and both were once ordinary practice

These two are worth a screen of their own because they are the two violations a licensee commits personally, with his own mouth, in the ordinary course of a working day. Nobody needs a bank or a board to steer. You can do it in one sentence on a Tuesday.

STEERING

Steering relates to buyers or renters. It is channeling prospective buyers or renters to or away from specific neighborhoods based on their race, religion, national origin, or other protected class, in order to maintain or change the character of a neighborhood. It is prohibited even where the prospective buyer or tenant asks for it.

Case in Point. When real estate licensees make assumptions about the types of neighborhood clients would like to live in, instead of showing them all available options, they are practicing steering. Never assume you know what is best for your client. Spend time talking about their preferences, and then show them a variety of options that meet their requirements.

Most steering in New York does not sound like steering. It sounds like helpfulness. You would be more comfortable over here. That school district is a better fit for your family. I do not think that block is really for you. Each of those sentences narrows a buyer's search on the basis of a protected class, and each of them was said by someone who thought he was doing the client a favor.

Now the hard version, because the client will ask. A buyer tells you she wants to see homes only in a Jewish neighborhood. Because of the fair housing laws, a real estate agent cannot narrow down homes on the market to a particular neighborhood if the request touches on a protected class. What the licensee in the textbook did was tell the buyers she could not do that, and then offer what she could do: if the buyers told her the exact blocks they wanted, she could show them any houses listed there.

Read the difference carefully, because it is the whole job. The buyer may choose an address. The buyer may choose a street, a school district, a commute, a budget, a synagogue she wants to walk to. What the licensee may not do is take a protected class as a search filter and build the list around it. Geography chosen by the client is a client decision. A list built on a class is your violation.

The same answer works for the seller who asks you to screen buyers, for the landlord who tells you the type of tenant he wants, and for the buyer who asks what kind of people live on the block. You do not argue and you do not lecture. You say what you can do, you say what you cannot do, and you document the conversation.

BLOCKBUSTING

Blockbusting relates to owners. It is inducing or attempting to induce, for profit, any person to sell or rent property based on representations regarding entry into the neighborhood of persons of a particular race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. It is prohibited under both federal and state law.

Before the federal Fair Housing Act, unscrupulous real estate licensees intimidated homeowners into selling their homes by suggesting the ethnic or racial composition of their neighborhood was changing. Homeowners were led to believe that their property values would decline, that the area would experience higher crime rates, and that the quality of the schools would suffer. The apparent motive was profit. Property owners listed or sold at a reduced price, and the licensee turned around and resold the properties at a higher price.

THREE CLASSIC BLOCKBUSTING TECHNIQUES

The pamphlet. Passing out pamphlets stating that a member of a minority group has purchased a home nearby.

The wrong number call. Telephone calls in which the caller says they thought they were calling the new Asian family who just moved in.

The buy-and-tell. Purchasing a home in the area, selling it on contract to a minority buyer, and then suggesting to existing homeowners that it is time to move.

Those three are historical and they are also templates. The modern version is a mailing that names a recent buyer and asks whether you have thought about selling before the block changes. The delivery method moved to email and social media. The offense did not move at all.

Both offenses are on the list of grounds for which the Department of State may suspend or revoke a license, because violating a discrimination law in the sale, rental or advertisement of housing or commercial space is a disciplinary ground under the license law. So a single steering incident can produce three proceedings out of one afternoon: a human rights complaint, a Department of State disciplinary case, and a civil action.

CAUTION: Blockbusting does not require a completed sale. The statute reaches inducing or attempting to induce. The leaflet is the violation whether or not one owner lists.

A client's request is not a defense to steering

REMEMBER: A buyer asks to be shown homes only where people of her own faith live. Say your answer to her out loud, in two sentences, without refusing her the service.

Redlining, Filtering Down, and the Acts the Act Forbids

Redlining relates to lenders and insurers, and the consequences land on the block

Redlining runs in four steps and the four steps are a loop. Follow the loop once and you will understand why a neighborhood that was denied credit in one generation is still being appraised low in the next.

Step one, the assumption. In the past, many lenders assumed an integrated or predominantly African American neighborhood was a place where property values were declining.

Step two, the refusal. Based on that assumption they refused to make loans there, and refused to write homeowners insurance on property in those neighborhoods.

Step three, the consequence. In most cases homeowners insurance and financing must both be obtained in order to buy a house. With purchase and renovation loans almost impossible to get, it became extremely difficult to market, maintain, or improve homes in those neighborhoods.

Step four, filtering down. Values decline. And the assumption that started the loop now looks like it was correct all along, which is what makes the practice so durable. Filtering down is the name for one practice having negative residual effects on everything around it.

Lenders may still deny loans in neighborhoods where property values are declining. That denial must be based on objective criteria regarding the condition and value of the property or area. A lender may not simply equate integrated or minority neighborhoods with declining property values. That is the line, and it is a line about evidence rather than about outcome.

You are not the lender. You are the person whose buyer just got declined, and you are frequently the first person who hears about it. Knowing the name of the practice and the agency that hears the complaint is part of the service you owe that buyer.

SIX ACTS THAT ARE ILLEGAL UNDER THE FEDERAL FAIR HOUSING ACT

Refusal to deal. Refusing to sell, rent, or otherwise make unavailable a dwelling after receipt of a bona fide offer, based on a protected class.

False unavailability. Representing that a dwelling is not available when in fact it is, based on prohibited criteria. Telling a family with children that the apartment is taken when it is not is the standard example, and it is the single most common way the refusal actually happens.

Refusing an offer. Refusing to accept an offer to purchase or rent because the applicant is a member of a protected class.

MLS access. Denial of access to or participation in a multiple listing service based on prohibited criteria.

Financial assistance. Discrimination in granting requested financial assistance based on prohibited criteria.

Unequal terms. Changing any conditions, services, or terms for different individuals as a means of discrimination.

The last one is the widest and the quietest. A larger security deposit for one applicant. A credit score floor applied to some and waived for others. An application fee charged to one family and not another. A showing on Saturday for one couple and a callback that never comes for the next. None of those is a refusal in words, and every one of them is a violation.

GROUP HOMES AND LOCAL ZONING

The Fair Housing Act does not pre-empt local zoning laws, as long as there is no discrimination based on a protected class. The Act does apply to municipalities and other local government entities, prohibiting them from making zoning or land use decisions or implementing land use policies that exclude or otherwise discriminate against protected persons, including individuals with disabilities.

A group home is a property occupied by a number of individuals with disabilities, or offered by an organization that provides services for such individuals. Since a group home falls under the Fair Housing Act's definition of a dwelling, municipalities cannot place undue burdens on operators of such properties as they seek permits from local zoning boards to allow reasonable accommodations on behalf of those individuals. A town cannot write a spacing rule or a special permit requirement that applies to group homes and to nothing else.

Hypothetical. Two applicants apply for the same Staten Island apartment in the same week with nearly identical income and credit. One is asked for two months' security, a guarantor and a letter from her employer. The other is asked for one month and nothing else. Both are offered the apartment. Nobody was refused, nobody was lied to, and the terms were not the same, which is the whole of the violation.

The same analysis reaches service rather than paperwork. Answering one caller in an hour and another in four days. Opening the building on a Saturday for one family and telling the next that weekend showings are not possible. Offering to run comparables for one buyer and not the other. Changing any conditions, services, or terms for different individuals as a means of discrimination is the statutory language, and services is in it.

NOTE: Unequal terms is the answer to more exam questions than refusal to deal, because it is the only one of the six that does not require the housing provider to say no. Watch for the fact pattern where everybody gets the apartment and only one applicant got the extra condition.

Objective criteria, or it is redlining

REMEMBER: Name the four steps of the redlining loop in order, then name the point in the loop where the lender's conduct becomes defensible if the evidence supports it.

Fair Housing Advertising, the Logo, and the Poster

Section 804(c) of the Fair Housing Act restricts what an advertisement may say

In addition to outlawing discrimination in housing, the federal Fair Housing Act of 1968 restricts the publication of any real estate advertising that indicates a limitation, preference, or intent to discriminate based on a protected class. This is the part of the Act a licensee is most likely to violate by accident, because an advertisement is written quickly, by one person, under deadline, and nobody reads it back.

Section 804(c) of the Fair Housing Act states that it is unlawful to make, print, or publish, or cause to be made, printed, or published, any notice, statement, or advertisement, with respect to the sale or rental of a dwelling, that indicates any preference, limitation, or discrimination because of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, or national origin, or an intention to make any such preference, limitation, or discrimination. However, the prohibitions of the Act regarding familial status do not apply with respect to housing for older persons.

Read what the statute actually forbids. It forbids an advertisement that indicates a preference. There is no requirement that anybody be turned away, no requirement that the advertiser intended harm, and no requirement that a single person read it. Publishing it is the offense.

That is why the safe habit is to describe the property and stop. Square footage, rooms, condition, price, location, terms. The moment an advertisement starts describing the ideal occupant rather than the dwelling, it is in trouble. Perfect for a young professional. Ideal for a mature Christian couple. No children. Walking distance to St. Anne's. Each of those describes a person, and each of them points at a protected class.

Hypothetical. A Brooklyn listing runs as a quiet building, adults only, no kids. The landlord meant that the walls are thin. The advertisement says familial status. The landlord's intention is not the test, and the copy is the evidence.

THE LOGO, STATEMENT, OR SLOGAN

All advertising of residential real estate for sale or rent, and for real estate financing, should contain an equal housing opportunity logo, statement, or slogan. Its purpose is to educate the public that the property is available to everyone regardless of race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status, or national origin.

THE POSTER

The Fair Housing Act requires fair housing posters to be displayed and maintained at any place of business where housing is offered for sale or rent. They should be prominently displayed so as to be readily apparent to all persons seeking housing accommodations or seeking to engage in residential real estate-related transactions or brokerage services.

The poster is form HUD-928.1, and it says this. We Do Business in Accordance With the Federal Fair Housing Law, the Fair Housing Amendments Act of 1988. It is illegal to Discriminate Against Any Person Because of Race, Color, Religion, Sex, Handicap, Familial Status, or National Origin. In the sale or rental of housing or residential lots. In advertising the sale or rental of housing. In the financing of housing. In the provision of real estate brokerage services. In the appraisal of housing. Blockbusting is also illegal.

The poster also carries the complaint line, so that a member of the public standing in your office can act without asking you how. Anyone who feels he or she has been discriminated against may file a complaint of housing discrimination at 1-800-669-9777 toll free, or 1-800-927-9275 TTY.

Using the fair housing logo, statement, slogan and poster declares to the public that the brokerage and its licensees subscribe to the principles of fair housing practices. That is the stated purpose, and there is a second and sharper reason to comply.

If a broker or lender is investigated for alleged discriminatory acts, failure to display the poster and use the logo may be considered evidence of discrimination. Read that again with an investigation in mind. The missing poster does not prove anything on its own. It becomes one more fact on the wrong side of the ledger at the exact moment your conduct is being weighed.

That cuts the other way too, which is why this is worth doing properly rather than grudgingly. A brokerage with the poster on the wall, the logo on every advertisement, and a signed disclosure in every file has three pieces of evidence that it takes the law seriously before anyone asks it a single question.

Advertising has moved and the rule has not. A listing site, a social media post, a text blast, a team page and a video walkthrough are all advertisements of the sale or rental of a dwelling. So is the caption. So is the hashtag. Everything on this screen applies to a post you write on your phone in a parking lot, and the post is easier to prove than anything you ever said out loud.

CAUTION: The familial status carve-out in 804(c) is narrow. An advertisement may indicate a familial status preference only with respect to housing that actually qualifies as housing for older persons. A building that is simply full of older tenants does not qualify, and an advertisement that says adults preferred is a violation.

Describe the dwelling, never the occupant

REMEMBER: Look at the last three listing advertisements you saw this week. Does any word in them describe a person rather than a property?

Lesson 4

New York's Human Rights Law

Article 15 of the Executive Law, and the longest protected-class list in the country

The New York State Human Rights Law

Article 15 of the Executive Law - an exercise of the state's police power

The federal Fair Housing Act contains the provision that state and local governments may adopt legislation that increases the protections provided. New York State has the distinction of being the first state in the nation to pass human rights laws prohibiting broad areas of discrimination.

New York's Human Rights Law is technically an exercise of the state's police power to protect the public welfare, health and peace. It is contained within Article 15 of the New York Executive Law.

SEVEN AREAS THE LAW COVERS

The Human Rights Law prohibits discrimination in employment, in educational institutions, in public services, in credit transactions, and in places of public accommodation, resort or amusement. Then it reaches the two that belong to you. Housing accommodations, purchasing or renting. And commercial space, purchasing or renting.

The federal Fair Housing Act is a residential statute. New York's Human Rights Law reaches commercial space as well, so a licensee leasing a storefront in Yonkers is inside it.

The New York State Division of Human Rights was created to enforce this law. Its mission is to ensure that every individual has an equal opportunity to participate fully in the economic, cultural and intellectual life of the State.

In terms of housing and commercial property, the provisions of the Human Rights Law must be observed by all property owners, real estate brokers and salespersons, real estate boards, lessees and sublessees, managing agents, and any employees or agents of these parties. You are on that list twice: once as a salesperson and once as an agent of your broker.

WHAT NEW YORK STATE ADDS TO THE FEDERAL LIST

New York's Human Rights Law prohibits discrimination against any of the seven federal protected classes: race, color, religion, national origin, disability, sex and familial status. New York then extends the protected classes related to housing. Eight more.

Age, defined as 18 or older.

Marital status, defined as people who are either married or divorced.

Military status, defined as a person's participation in any military service of the United States or the military service of the state.

Sexual orientation, defined as heterosexuality, homosexuality, bisexuality or asexuality, whether actual or perceived. This class was added with the passage of the Sexual Orientation Non-Discrimination Act, SONDA, in 2002.

Gender identity or expression. The Gender Expression Non-Discrimination Act, GENDA, signed on January 25, 2019 as Chapter 8 of the Laws of 2019, wrote this class into the statute. Executive Law §292 defines it as a person's actual or perceived gender-related identity, appearance, behavior, expression, or other gender-related characteristic regardless of the sex assigned to that person at birth, including the status of being transgender.

Before GENDA, a 2015 state regulation, Section 466.13, protected gender identity by reading it into the classes of sex and disability. The statute now names gender identity or expression as a class of its own.

Victims of domestic violence. In October of 2015 the Governor signed a bill amending the Human Rights Law to prohibit landlords from discriminating against victims of domestic violence when they attempt to rent or lease housing. The amendment also makes it illegal to ask about a prospective tenant's or buyer's status as a victim of domestic violence, unless that inquiry is solely for the purpose of assistance rather than hindrance in obtaining housing. It provides victims with an affirmative defense in eviction proceedings.

That protection bars the question, not only the refusal. An application form that asks every applicant whether they have ever been a victim of domestic violence violates the law on its face, and it violates it against every applicant who fills it in.

Lawful source of income, protected in housing statewide since April 12, 2019. Executive Law §292(36) defines it to include child support, alimony, foster care subsidies, Social Security, public assistance or housing assistance including Section 8 vouchers, and any other forms of lawful income. New York City protected it first, in 2008.

Citizenship or immigration status, added by Chapter 748 of the Laws of 2022, signed on December 23, 2022. Executive Law §292 defines it as the citizenship of any person, or the immigration status of any person who is not a citizen of the United States.

CAUTION: Age under New York law means 18 or older. It is not a rule about the elderly. A landlord who refuses a qualified twenty-two-year-old because he wants a more settled tenant has discriminated on age under the Human Rights Law, and there is no federal age class to hide behind.

Fifteen classes, and commercial space too

REMEMBER: Name the eight classes New York adds to the federal seven. Then name the one of those eight that is enforced by barring a question as well as a refusal.

Protected Classes: Federal, State, and City

Three lists, not one - and neither New York list is a copy of the federal one

There are three lists. Do not merge them. A licensee who carries one blended list in his head will be confident and wrong, because he will not know which protection he can promise a client in which county.

Seven classes are federal, under the Fair Housing Act. Race. Color. Religion or creed. National origin. Familial status. Disability. Sex or gender. Those seven are protected everywhere in the United States, including every inch of New York.

Fifteen classes are protected in housing under the New York State Human Rights Law. The seven federal classes, plus age, marital status, military status, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, victim of domestic violence, lawful source of income, and citizenship or immigration status.

Seventeen classes are protected in housing under the New York City Human Rights Law, Title 8 of the Administrative Code. The city covers every state class in its own words. Gender takes in sex, gender identity and gender expression. Uniformed service stands in for military status. Familial status is written as children who are, may be or would be residing with the person. Then the city adds three classes the state lacks: height, weight, and partnership status.

Two more points about the city list are worth memorizing. The city protects a victim of domestic violence in housing, and it extends the same protection to a victim of sex offenses or stalking. And lawful source of income is on both lists. The city protected it in 2008, eleven years before the state did.

HOW TO USE THREE LISTS

A stricter law always takes precedence. That sentence resolves every conflict you will meet. Where the federal Act and New York law differ, New York governs, because New York is stricter. Where New York State and New York City differ, the stricter of the two governs in the five boroughs.

The practical consequence is that you learn the list for every jurisdiction in which you practice. A licensee working Nassau and Queens is working under two different protected-class lists on the same Saturday, and height, weight and partnership status are on one of them and not the other.

Two rules sit above all three lists and never move. A real estate licensee is never exempt from any of them. And there are no exemptions for racial discrimination anywhere, because the Civil Rights Act of 1866 prohibits it in any property transaction and has no exemptions at all.

The safe working habit is to practice to the strictest list that could apply to you, everywhere, all the time. It costs you nothing to treat weight as protected in Suffolk County. It costs you a great deal to treat it as unprotected in Brooklyn. Where the layers differ, the stricter answer is always the safe one to act on, and it is never the wrong one.

NOTE: The exam's favorite version of this screen names a class and asks which layer protects it. Marital status: state and city, not federal. Lawful source of income: state and city, not federal, and statewide since April 12, 2019. Height and weight: city only. Familial status: all three, worded differently in the city. Learn the four answers as four answers.

Seven federal, fifteen state, seventeen city

REMEMBER: You are showing an apartment in Mount Vernon and one in Manhattan on the same day. Which list governs each, and name one class that differs between them.

The New York City Human Rights Law

Title 8 of the Administrative Code - one of the most comprehensive civil rights laws in the nation

The New York City Human Rights Law is Title 8 of the Administrative Code of the City of New York, and it is one of the most comprehensive civil rights laws in the nation. It is enforced in the five boroughs by the New York City Commission on Human Rights, created with the power to eliminate and prevent discrimination from playing any role in actions relating to employment, public accommodations and housing and other real estate, and to take other actions against prejudice, intolerance, bigotry, discrimination and bias-related violence or harassment.

SIX AREAS THE LAW ADDRESSES

Housing, which includes those who reside in apartments or other multiple family buildings, condominiums, cooperatives, government-assisted housing, and residential hotels. Public accommodations, meaning anyone who provides goods or services to the general public, such as medical offices, restaurants, schools, banks, stores, theaters, stadiums, hair salons, hotels and taxi cabs. Employment practices, including hiring, firing, salary, benefits, promotions and discipline, where interns, whether paid or not, are considered employees. Retaliation against someone who has filed a complaint, opposed a discriminatory practice, or was involved in an investigation or hearing. Discriminatory harassment, including a pattern of verbal harassment, cyberbullying, or damaging real or personal property. And bias-based profiling by law enforcement.

Note who is named in the housing paragraph. Condominiums and cooperatives are inside this law, which means boards are inside it, which means the managing agent is inside it. In this city that is most of the housing stock.

PROHIBITED IN REAL ESTATE

It is illegal for landlords, superintendents, building managers, condominium owners, and cooperative owners and their boards to discriminate in the sale, rental or lease of a housing accommodation. These practices are specifically prohibited when based upon someone's actual or perceived membership in a protected class.

Refusing to sell or rent housing, or refusing to negotiate the sale or rental of housing. Misrepresenting the availability of housing. Setting different terms, conditions or privileges for the sale or rental of housing. Providing different housing services or facilities. Using different forms of application or inquiry for the purchase, rental, or lease of housing. Posting discriminatory advertising or marketing that indicates a preference, limitation, or discrimination based on a protected class. Refusing to provide a reasonable accommodation for a person with a disability. Steering a potential homebuyer or renter to or away from an area. And blockbusting, written into the city law as representing that a neighborhood is changing or in some way deteriorating because of the presence of persons of a particular protected class, whether implicitly or explicitly, for the purpose of either inducing or discouraging the sale or listing of property in order to make a profit.

The words actual or perceived are doing work in that list. A landlord who refuses an applicant because he believes the applicant belongs to a protected class has violated the law whether or not he guessed right.

Those activities are also generally prohibited in the sale, rent, or lease of land and commercial space. New York City, like New York State, reaches past residential.

DISCRIMINATORY LENDING

The city law also prohibits discriminatory lending practices by any person, bank, trust company, private banker, savings bank, savings and loan association, credit union, investment company, mortgage company, insurance company, or any other financial institution or lender, when a prospective borrower applies for a loan, mortgage or other financial assistance for construction, repairs or maintenance of real property. Violations include discrimination in the granting, withholding, extending or renewing of loans, in the required use of different forms, applications or inquiries, in the fixing of rates, terms or conditions, and in the appraisal of property. It is also against the law for financial institutions to redline, which is the practice of denying mortgages to prospective purchasers in certain communities.

LAWFUL SOURCE OF INCOME

The New York City Human Rights Law was amended in 2008 making lawful source of income a protected class. Lawful source of income includes income derived from Social Security or any other form of federal, state or local public or housing assistance, including Section 8 vouchers.

As enacted, Local Law 10/2008 made it illegal for an owner of a building with six or more units to do three things. Refuse to rent an apartment to someone because they receive federal, state or local public housing assistance, including Section 8. Refuse to accept federal, state or local public housing assistance, including Section 8 vouchers, toward the payment of rent, whether the tenant is new or existing. And print advertisements of any kind that indicate a refusal to accept tenants based on their source of income. Below six units, it still reached a rent-controlled tenant who lived there when the law took effect in March 2008, and an owner with another city building of six or more units.

The state law came eleven years later and it has no unit count. Since April 12, 2019, the New York State Human Rights Law has protected lawful source of income in housing everywhere in the state, in private housing under Executive Law §296(5) and in publicly-assisted housing under §296(2-a). The Division of Human Rights states that it applies to all landlords and rental property, regardless of the number of units. The six-unit threshold is city history.

Two of the Human Rights Law's housing exemptions can reach a voucher. The bans on refusal and on unequal terms do not apply to the rental of a unit in a building for not more than two families living independently of each other, if the owner resides in one of them, or to the rental of a room or rooms by the occupant or by an owner who resides there. The two-family owner is still bound by the advertising ban, and a discriminatory advertisement costs him the exemption. Source of income does not reach land or commercial space. A broker or salesperson has no source-of-income exemption at all.

Hypothetical. A tenant hands you a voucher for an apartment you are renting in a twelve-unit walk-up in the Bronx, and the owner tells you he only takes real money. The refusal violates the state law and the city law both. The refusal to accept the voucher toward rent is a second act on the same list. And if you write the advertisement the way he told you to, that is a third.

GENDER IDENTITY AND EXPRESSION IN THE CITY

In 2002 the New York City Council passed the Transgender Rights Bill to expand the scope of the gender-based protection of the city law. The intent is to prohibit any gender-based discrimination, including discrimination based on an individual's actual or perceived sex, and discrimination based on an individual's gender identity, self-image, appearance, behavior, or expression. The Commission publishes Gender Identity and Gender Expression: Legal Enforcement Guidance, which summarizes Local Law No. 3/2002 and gives examples of violations and detailed definitions. If you will practice in New York City, read it. It does not constitute legal advice, and for specific questions you contact the Commission or seek legal counsel.

Three of the city's classes are easy to overlook. Height and weight, protected since Local Law 61 of 2023, mean a landlord may not refuse an applicant because of her size. Partnership status protects a person in a domestic partnership. Lawful occupation, which older course materials list, is not named in the city's current housing provision, so do not describe it to a client as a housing class.

CAUTION: Executive Law §296(5)(c) makes it unlawful for a real estate broker or salesperson to refuse to rent or to negotiate because of lawful source of income. Carrying out the owner's unlawful instruction is your own violation, not the owner's alone. Tell your employing broker the day it happens.

The city list is the longest list you will work under

REMEMBER: The owner of a three-unit building in Yonkers, who lives elsewhere, tells you to refuse vouchers because the city's six-unit rule does not reach him. What do you tell him, and which law are you relying on?

Exemptions, and How New York Narrows Them

A stricter law always takes precedence

This is the most dangerous screen in the chapter. Every exemption on it is narrow, every one of them has conditions, and every year licensees get into serious trouble by remembering the name of an exemption and forgetting what it requires. Read the conditions, not the headline.

Start with the two rules that survive every exemption. A real estate licensee is never exempt. And there are no exemptions for racial discrimination, because under the 1866 Civil Rights Act discrimination based on race or ancestry is prohibited in any property transaction regardless of the exemptions available under the federal Fair Housing Act. No transaction involving a real estate licensee is exempt.

Read that as a working rule rather than a footnote. These exemptions describe an owner acting alone. The moment you are involved, you are not looking at an exempt transaction. You are looking at a transaction that has a licensee in it.

FEDERAL FAIR HOUSING ACT: FOUR EXEMPTIONS

Owner-occupied buildings. The exemption requires that the owner occupies one unit as a residence, and that no discriminatory advertising is used. It does not apply where the owner is a real estate licensee. Federal law applies this to buildings of up to four units, which is why you will hear it called the four-family exemption or, informally, the Mrs. Murphy exemption.

Single-family housing. The law does not apply to a single-family home sold or rented by a private owner, provided that the owner owns no more than three such homes at one time and that no discriminatory advertising is used. To qualify for this exemption the owner must meet all requirements. If the owner is not the occupant or the most recent occupant, the exemption may be used only once every 24 months.

Housing operated by organizations. In dealing with their own property in noncommercial transactions, religious organizations or affiliated non-profit organizations may limit occupancy, or give preference, to their own members, provided that membership is not restricted based on race, color, or national origin.

Housing operated by private clubs. Private clubs with lodging not open to the public and not operated for commercial purposes may limit occupancy or give preference to members. Membership may not be restricted based on race, color or national origin.

Count the conditions on the second one. Single family. Private owner. No more than three such homes at one time. No discriminatory advertising. All requirements met. And the 24-month limit where the owner is not the occupant or most recent occupant. Six conditions on an exemption most people describe in four words.

NEW YORK STATE HUMAN RIGHTS LAW: FOUR EXEMPTIONS

The rental of one unit of an owner-occupied two-family residence, a duplex for example. The rental of a room in a housing accommodation where all rooms are rented to people of the same sex, such as a dormitory. The rental of a room or rooms in an owner-occupied single-family home. And restriction based entirely on age and familial status for housing accommodations or public housing exclusively intended for people age 62 or older and a spouse, or housing intended and operated for occupancy by at least one person age 55 or older in each unit.

WHERE FEDERAL AND NEW YORK DIVERGE

A stricter law always takes precedence, and here New York is much stricter in two specific places.

Four units becomes two. Federal law exempts owner-occupants of four-family residences. New York exempts only two-family residences. An owner living in one unit of a four-family house in Buffalo is outside the federal Act and squarely inside the New York Human Rights Law.

There is no single-family sale exemption in New York. New York has no exemptions for the sale of single family housing, unlike the federal law. This is the single most dangerous gap in the chapter, because the federal single-family exemption is the one everybody has heard of. A private owner selling his own single-family house in New York is bound by the New York Human Rights Law. A licensee who tells that owner otherwise has given him advice that will cost them both.

NEW YORK CITY: TWO EXEMPTIONS

The housing provisions of the New York City Human Rights Law do not apply to the rental of a housing accommodation in a property where two families live independently of each other, if the owner or a member of the owner's family resides in one unit. Nor to the rental of a room or rooms in an owner-occupied house, if the owner or a member of the owner's family also resides in the house.

Both city exemptions carry a condition that erases them in most of the situations a licensee actually sees. Neither exemption applies for publicly-assisted housing, or if the housing has been publicly advertised, listed, or otherwise offered to the general public. An owner who puts the unit on a listing site has advertised it to the general public and has spent the exemption.

Put the three layers together and the picture is plain. These exemptions were written for an owner renting a room in her own house without advertising and without an agent. They were not written for the business you are about to enter. In practice, a New York licensee will go an entire career without working inside one.

Work an exemption the way you would work a title problem. Do not ask what it is called. Ask what it requires, item by item, and check each item against the facts in front of you. Who owns it. Who lives in it. How many units. How many other properties. Was it advertised. Is there an agent in the transaction. Which class is the owner acting on. Most claimed exemptions fail on one of those questions, and the one they fail on is usually the advertising or the agent.

CAUTION: Never tell a client that a federal exemption lets him do something New York law forbids. The federal Act is the floor. Where a federal exemption exists and New York's does not, New York law still binds the owner, and your advice to the contrary is the part that will be quoted back to you.

A licensee is never exempt, and race never is

REMEMBER: A private owner selling his own single-family home in New York asks you whether the exemption he read about online covers him. Answer him in two sentences.

Lesson 5

Enforcement, Penalties, and Your Duties

One year to file, and a license on the line if you get it wrong

From Complaint to Enforcement

Who files, with whom, within what period, and what happens after that

Three agencies hear fair housing complaints in New York, and a complainant may also go to court. Learn the mechanism rather than memorizing a list of agency names, because the mechanism is the same in all three and the differences between them are few and specific.

The clock is the first thing. A complaint is filed within one year of the date on which the alleged discrimination occurred. That is the period at HUD, at the New York State Division of Human Rights, and at the New York City Commission on Human Rights. One year, three forums.

STEP ONE: FILE THE COMPLAINT

Any person or entity may file. That includes an individual who believes he was discriminated against, and it includes a community group that was not itself refused anything. The complaint goes to HUD's Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity, or to a regional office of the New York State Division of Human Rights, or to the Law Enforcement Bureau of the New York City Commission on Human Rights.

STEP TWO: JURISDICTION AND INVESTIGATION

If the agency determines it has jurisdiction over the complaint, it investigates. In New York the Division of Human Rights investigates the complaint to determine whether there is probable cause. A complaint that the Division does not sustain is dismissed at this stage, and that is the end of it in that forum.

STEP THREE: CONCILIATION OR MEDIATION

Where an investigation reveals evidence of a violation, the agency attempts negotiation and conciliation in an effort to obtain voluntary compliance with the Act. New York works the same way and names it differently: if the complaint is not dismissed, the Division attempts first to resolve the matter through a mediation conference.

This step is where most complaints end, and it is worth understanding why. Conciliation is voluntary compliance. The respondent agrees to do something and the matter closes without a finding. A licensee who reaches this stage with a complete file, a signed disclosure and a record of equal service is in a very different negotiation from one who reaches it with nothing.

STEP FOUR: A HEARING, OR A COURT

If conciliation is unsuccessful, HUD generally refers the matter to an administrative law judge. In New York, where mediation does not resolve it, the case is heard by an administrative law judge in a public hearing. Public is not a detail. A hearing that anybody may attend is a hearing that anybody may read about afterwards.

A complainant may instead bring a civil action. Under the New York City Human Rights Law a civil action must be commenced within three years of the alleged unlawful act. One year to an agency. Three years to a court, in the city.

STEP FIVE: REMEDIES AND PENALTIES

Where discrimination is found, the orders available run further than money. Cease and desist from the unlawful discriminatory practice. Affirmative action, such as requiring the respondent to extend a lease to the complainant under equal terms. Actual, compensatory or punitive damages. Injunctive or other equitable relief. Attorneys' fees. Civil fines. And the surrender to the state of any profits obtained through unlawful discriminatory acts associated with blockbusting.

That last one is aimed squarely at the economics of blockbusting. The practice only ever made sense because the profit was larger than the risk. Taking the profit removes the reason to do it.

THREE FORUMS, THREE SETS OF RULES

HUD, Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity. When Congress passed the Civil Rights Act in 1968 it gave HUD the responsibility for administering the federal Fair Housing Act. The 1988 amendments greatly increased HUD's enforcement role beyond investigation and conciliation and into mandatory enforcement. The Act also requires HUD to develop voluntary programs to achieve fair housing goals, and one of HUD's main responsibilities is fair housing education as well as enforcement. Any person or entity may file within one year after the alleged discrimination.

New York State Division of Human Rights. Any person or organization claiming to be aggrieved by an alleged unlawful discriminatory practice may file a complaint with one of the regional offices. Complaints must be filed within one year of the date on which the alleged discrimination occurred. The Division investigates for probable cause, attempts a mediation conference, and otherwise sends the case to an administrative law judge for a public hearing.

New York City Commission on Human Rights. Anyone who believes they have been a victim of illegal discrimination within the five boroughs may file with the Law Enforcement Bureau within one year of the last alleged act of discrimination. Note the wording: the last act, which matters where the conduct was repeated over months.

The city forum carries one rule the other two do not. Someone cannot file a complaint with the NYC Commission on Human Rights if he or she has already filed a complaint about the same incident with another agency, such as the New York State Division of Human Rights, HUD, or a state or federal court. A complainant chooses a door. The choice is not free.

COUNTY COMMISSIONS

Most counties, and many municipalities, in New York have passed anti-discrimination laws that are in line with those passed by the State. Such laws allow complaints to be filed and handled locally, which generally results in more efficient processing. Nassau, Rockland, Suffolk and Westchester Counties have passed laws making it illegal to deny a person the opportunity to sell, purchase, lease, rent, or obtain financing for the purchase or lease of housing accommodations because of membership in a protected class. Each of these counties has its own Commission on Human Rights with the authority to receive complaints, investigate, hold hearings, and impose civil penalties.

So a licensee practicing on Long Island can be answering to a county commission, the State Division, and HUD for the same conduct, under three sets of rules, from three different buildings. That is not a reason to panic. It is a reason to keep one standard of service and apply it to everybody.

Two features of this machinery are worth holding onto because they change how you behave now rather than later. The first is that any person or entity may file, which means a fair housing organization that was never refused anything can put a complaint in front of an agency based on what its testers found. You do not have to have wronged a client for a complaint to reach you.

The second is that the investigation looks backwards at records that already exist. Nobody creates evidence after a complaint lands. The file is whatever you wrote at the time, and the comparison is between how you treated this person and how you treated everybody else that month. Which is why the documentation section of the Your Obligations as a Licensee screen is not administration. It is the case.

NOTE: The number to keep is one year, and it is the same at all three agencies. The three-year figure belongs to a civil action under the New York City Human Rights Law and to nothing else on this screen.

One year to an agency; three to a city court

REMEMBER: A tenant tells you in October that she was refused an apartment the previous March. Which forums are still open to her, and which one closes a door she may want later?

Penalties and Deadlines

The figures worth memorizing, and the ones that move

Four figures and four deadlines. Two of the figures are set by New York and are stable. Two of them are federal, and they are the kind of number that gets adjusted, so learn the figures this course gives rather than trusting a number you half-remember.

$16,000

per violation, first offense

Statutory maximum civil penalty a HUD administrative law judge may award (the figure used on the exam; HUD adjusts it for inflation each year, so the current amount is higher), in addition to actual damages, injunctive or other equitable relief, and attorneys' fees.

$55,000

first ADA violation

The original statutory figure (used on the exam); the Department of Justice raised it to $75,000 for a first violation and $150,000 for subsequent ones in 2014. Assessed by the U.S. Attorney General. Civil penalties may NOT be assessed in cases against state or local governments.

NEW YORK STATE FIGURES

Where it is determined that discrimination did occur, the Commissioner of the Division of Human Rights may assess civil fines and penalties not to exceed $50,000. Where the act of discrimination is determined to have been willful, wanton, or malicious, the ceiling is not to exceed $100,000.

Read the gap between those two numbers as a description of conduct rather than a price list. The difference between fifty and a hundred thousand dollars is whether the finder of fact concludes you knew what you were doing. A licensee who followed an owner's unlawful instruction and documented nothing has a hard time arguing about which side of that line he is on.

WHAT THE COMMISSIONER CAN ORDER

Require the respondent to cease and desist from the unlawful discriminatory practice. Require the respondent to take affirmative action, for example to extend a lease to the complainant under equal terms. Award compensatory or punitive damages to the complainant. Require the respondent to pay the state any profits obtained through the commission of unlawful discriminatory acts associated with blockbusting. And assess the civil fines and penalties above.

County commissions have their own teeth. Civil penalties for unlawful discriminatory practices may result in significant fines, especially where it is determined that the practice was the result of the respondent's wanton or malicious act. Nassau, Rockland, Suffolk and Westchester each have a Commission that can receive complaints, investigate, hold hearings and impose those penalties without anybody traveling to Albany or to Washington.

WHERE TO FILE, AND HOW LONG YOU HAVE

HUD's Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity: one year. Jurisdiction, investigation, conciliation, and then an administrative law judge.

The New York State Division of Human Rights, at a regional office: one year. A probable-cause investigation, a mediation conference, and then an administrative law judge in a public hearing.

The New York City Commission, Law Enforcement Bureau: one year from the last alleged act, and barred if the same incident has already been filed with another agency or a court.

A civil action under the New York City Human Rights Law: three years from the alleged unlawful act.

The figure that ends careers is not on this screen. It is on your license. Violating a discrimination law in the sale, rental or advertisement of housing or commercial space is a ground for suspension or revocation under the license law, and the Department of State proceeding runs alongside the human rights complaint rather than instead of it. One act, two cases.

Notice what is missing from every schedule on this screen. None of these figures is a cap on the complainant's actual damages. Actual damages, compensatory damages, punitive damages, injunctive relief and attorneys' fees all sit outside the civil penalty, and the civil penalty is money paid to the government rather than to the person who was harmed. A licensee who reads the ceilings as the worst case has read only the part that goes to the state.

CAUTION: Dollar ceilings in this area are adjusted over time and the figure in a question may be the statutory one rather than the current one. Answer the exam with the figures as this chapter states them, and check the agency's current schedule before you ever quote a number to a client.

One year to file; the license case runs beside it

REMEMBER: Name the New York ceiling, then name what has to be found for it to double. Then say which of your own habits would be the evidence against you.

Testers, Cease-and-Desist Zones, and Solicitation

How violations are discovered, and the one solicitation rule that is New York's alone

Almost nobody is caught discriminating by a confession. Violations surface two ways. A person who was treated badly files a complaint. Or a tester walks into the office and finds out what happens.

FAIR HOUSING TESTING

In 1991 the Civil Rights Division of the Department of Justice established a fair housing testing program to objectively compare access and treatment of prospective homebuyers or renters.

The method typically involves two teams of testers, also known as checkers, posing as customers or clients with similar housing needs and economic qualifications, but with obvious differences due to inclusion in or exclusion from a protected class. After both teams attempt to secure the same real estate services, they compare notes on the specific treatment they received: which properties were shown, the list price or rent quoted, the manner of the real estate licensee.

Understand what that design measures. The two testers are matched on everything that is supposed to matter. Same budget, same needs, same qualifications. Anything that differs in how they were treated is left over after the legitimate explanations are used up, and that remainder is the evidence.

Testing may be initiated because HUD or some other fair housing agency receives a specific complaint from an individual who believes he has been unlawfully treated. It may also occur as part of an ongoing program of enforcement, when a fair housing agency randomly selects a geographic area to test. Randomly selects. No complaint, no accusation, no warning.

The federal Fair Housing Act also contains provisions that encourage businesses and organizations to self-test for compliance. A brokerage that tests itself finds out what its own agents do before somebody else does, and it finds out at a stage where the answer is a training problem rather than a charge.

Testing also answers a question students ask about this whole chapter, which is how anybody ever proves what was in a licensee's head. The answer is that nobody tries to. The comparison between two matched testers, or between two matched clients in your own files, is evidence about conduct. Intent never has to be established, which is why a licensee who meant no harm and delivered unequal service is in exactly as much trouble as one who meant it.

The lesson a working licensee should take from testing is not to be suspicious of unfamiliar clients. It is the opposite. Treat every caller as though the file will be read line by line next year, because the only defensible practice is one identical service delivered to everyone. A licensee who is consistent has nothing to fear from a tester, and a licensee who is not will not be able to tell which caller was which.

NON-SOLICITATION ORDERS: STRUCK DOWN

At one time, in an effort to combat blockbusting, the New York Secretary of State was given the authority under Article 12-A of the Real Property Law to establish a non-solicitation order for a designated geographical area. A non-solicitation order prohibited the solicitation of residential property listings and applied to all real estate brokers and agents. It could also prohibit any real estate broker from establishing a new principal office or branch office within the designated area without prior approval from the Secretary of State.

The New York State Association of REALTORS challenged non-solicitation orders on First Amendment grounds. In 2002 the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled the non-solicitation regulation unconstitutional. Non-solicitation orders are in this chapter because the syllabus names them and because the exam may, and not because they are a rule you will work under.

CEASE-AND-DESIST ZONES: STILL GOOD LAW

The Secretary of State does have the authority under Article 12-A of the Real Property Law to designate certain geographic areas as cease-and-desist zones for up to five years. A zone may be designated where residents in a particular area report that they have been subject to intense and repeated solicitations by real estate licensees to list or sell their property.

After a zone has been designated, individual property owners may file an owner's statement with the Department of State to indicate that they do not want to sell, lease, or list their property. The zone by itself does not protect an owner. The owner has to register.

Once property owners register on the cease-and-desist list, brokers and salespersons are prohibited from engaging in any form of solicitation, directly or indirectly, of that property owner to obtain a listing to sell the residential property. The prohibition applies to direct forms of solicitation such as the telephone, the mail, and personal contact. Generally speaking, advertisements in newspapers would not be prohibited.

Two words in that rule are the ones that get licensees in trouble. Any form. And indirectly. A postcard is solicitation. A door knock is solicitation. A letter from your team rather than from you is solicitation. Asking a neighbor to mention your name is solicitation indirectly.

Violation of a cease-and-desist order is considered an act of untrustworthiness or incompetence on the part of the licensee and could result in stiff penalties. That is license-law language, and it puts this violation in front of the Department of State rather than in front of a human rights agency.

The practical duty is simple and it is yours. Before you prospect an area, find out whether it is a cease-and-desist zone and check the list. The list is published by the Department of State, it changes, and a check you did in the spring does not cover a call you make in the autumn.

Understand why New York has this rule at all, because the reason explains its shape. Cease-and-desist zones grew out of blockbusting. The practice worked by volume: call every owner on the block, again and again, until enough of them believed the neighborhood was turning. The remedy attacks the volume rather than the message, which is why the surviving rule protects owners who have said in writing that they want to be left alone.

Hypothetical. You farm a Brooklyn neighborhood you grew up in and you have mailed the same quarterly postcard for two years. The area is designated a cease-and-desist zone in March and eleven owners register in April. Your July mailing goes to the whole farm list. Eleven of those postcards are violations, the zone's designation was public, and the fact that you have always done it this way is not a defense to any of them.

NOTE: Keep the two apart. Non-solicitation orders covered whole areas and were struck down in 2002. Cease-and-desist zones last up to five years, are still good law, and protect only the owners who have registered.

Check the list before you prospect the block

REMEMBER: Name the three things that must be true before a phone call to a homeowner is a cease-and-desist violation.

Your Obligations as a Licensee

Disclose, document, and know the law in every jurisdiction in which you practice

Everything in this chapter arrives at one place: what you do on Monday. Licensed real estate professionals have the duty to disclose fair housing laws to clients, while being cautious not to practice law. Disclose the law. Do not interpret it for them.

TWO REQUIRED DISCLOSURES

New York State Human Rights Law requires that agents provide, to a prospective purchaser, tenant, seller, or landlord upon first substantive contact, the Housing and Anti-Discrimination Disclosure form. And to a prospective tenant upon first substantive contact, the Reasonable Accommodation and Reasonable Modification Disclosure form.

The disclosures must be signed by the prospective purchaser, tenant, seller, or landlord, and retained for a minimum of three years.

Three details decide whether you have actually complied. The timing is first substantive contact, not the day of the offer. The signature is required, so an emailed form nobody signed is not a disclosure. And the retention period is three years, which means a file you cleared out after closing will not help you.

WHEN A CLIENT WILL NOT COMPLY

After you properly disclose the laws governing fair housing to your clients, you have fulfilled your obligation of disclosure. If you later discover that you are working with a client or customer who is not willing to abide by fair housing laws, you must inform your employing broker.

You should also inform the person you are working with that your employing broker may want to discuss the relationship, since both you and your employing broker could be held liable for violating fair housing laws.

Read the word must. Telling your broker is not a judgment call and it is not disloyalty to the client. It is the step that moves the decision to the person whose license carries the office, and it is the step that is missing from every one of these cases when it goes wrong.

Hypothetical. A Westchester landlord tells you, three weeks into a good working relationship, that he will not rent to anyone with a voucher and would rather you did not send him families with small children. You have disclosed. He has told you he will not comply. The next call you make is to your employing broker, and the file note you write is dated today.

DOCUMENTATION IS YOUR DEFENSE

Some brokers require their licensees to use a preprinted contact form, such as a needs and wants checklist or a prospect data sheet, to document whom they spoke with and what they discussed. Where they are required as part of fair housing compliance procedures, data sheets show that licensees are providing equal service to all.

Gather the same data from every prospective buyer. Name and contact information. Preferred method and time for communication. Current housing situation. Timeframe for moving. Type of property desired and preferred style. Preferred neighborhood or area. Price range, both purchase amount and monthly payment. Whether they are prequalified with a lender. Occupation and income. Preferred lot size. Property amenities. Square footage. Number of bedrooms and bathrooms. Interior features. Preferred heating and appliances. And special requirements, such as accessibility or proximity to schools or public transportation.

The point of gathering the same data every time is not the data. It is the sameness. A file in which every buyer was asked the same questions is a file that shows equal service without anybody having to argue about it.

Keep good records of all meetings, phone calls, appointments, showings and missed appointments. You may not be legally obligated to keep notes of every substantive conversation, and it can still be your strongest defense to establish that you gave equal professional service. If you find yourself being questioned, or end up in court, at least you can demonstrate a conscious effort to be fair, open and honest with everyone.

WHAT YOUR BROKER OWES, AND WHAT YOU OWE

Your employing broker should have office policies and procedures in place to ensure compliance with fair housing laws. That is where the fair housing policy lives, along with the posted signs, the advertising review, the training of staff and agents, and the record-keeping materials the office makes available to you. Ask to see the policy on the day you join the office rather than on the day you need it.

Your own side of it is shorter and it is entirely within your control. Know the fair housing laws in every jurisdiction in which you practice. Give the two disclosures at first substantive contact and keep the signed copies. Write advertisements that describe property. Keep the same record on every prospect. Report a violation to your broker. And attend fair housing training when it is offered, which in New York is not only good practice: your renewal cycle requires fair housing and discrimination instruction, cultural competency and implicit bias hours, as Chapter 1 sets out.

COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL LAWS

Most counties, and many municipalities, in New York have passed anti-discrimination laws in line with the State's. Nassau, Rockland, Suffolk and Westchester Counties each have their own Commission on Human Rights with authority to receive complaints, investigate, hold hearings and impose civil penalties. It is critical that you understand the laws in the jurisdictions in which you practice, and that sentence is doing real work in a state where a licensee may list in two counties in one week.

YOUR E AND O POLICY WILL NOT SAVE YOU

It is not only your duty as a licensee to provide unbiased service to all customers and clients, it is your legal responsibility. If you do not comply with fair housing laws, you and your employing broker may be subject to fines, loss of license, and other legal action.

Fair housing violations are serious, so much so that they are almost always excluded from errors and omissions insurance policies. Every other mistake you make in this business has an insurer behind it. This one does not. To protect yourself against fair housing violations, treat everyone equally and fairly.

PRESSURE FROM THE PEOPLE YOU WORK FOR

Most of the pressure to discriminate in this business does not come from your own prejudice. It comes from somebody else's, expressed to you as an instruction. A seller asks that certain buyers not be shown the house, or worries what the neighbors will think. A landlord describes the type of tenant he wants. A buyer asks pointed questions about who lives on a block, makes a remark about a part of the community, or says she will not view a house if certain people live nearby.

Have the answer ready before you need it, because these conversations arrive without warning and in the middle of something else. The answer has three parts and it takes about fifteen seconds. Say what the law requires. Say what you can do for them instead, which is almost always a real and useful offer. And say nothing that sounds like a negotiation, because there is nothing here to negotiate.

Then do the two things the conversation obliges you to do. Write the file note the same day, in the client's own words where you can. And if the person has told you plainly that they will not comply, tell your employing broker. Those two steps take five minutes and they are the difference between a licensee who met a discriminatory request and a licensee who carried one out.

CAUTION: The emotional cost of housing discrimination does not appear on any penalty schedule and it is the part that lasts. A family that was turned away remembers the afternoon for years. Keep that in view alongside the fines, because it is the reason the fines exist.

Same questions, same service, signed and filed

REMEMBER: Which two forms do you owe a prospective tenant at first substantive contact, who signs them, and where will they be in thirty months?

Lesson 6

Human Rights & Ethics

Everyone has biases. What matters is whether you know it, and what you do about it.

Explicit and Implicit Bias

We start with biases, turn them into stereotypes, develop prejudices, and let them grow into discrimination

The first part of this chapter was law. This part is about the machinery that produces the conduct the law punishes, because almost nobody who commits a fair housing violation set out to commit one. They followed a habit of mind and the habit made the decision for them.

Bias is a prejudice in favor of or against one thing, person or group compared with another, usually in a way considered to be unfair. Today the word is typically used to indicate a tendency, known or unknown, to prefer one thing over another in a way that prevents objectivity and inhibits impartial judgment. Biases are often based on mistaken, inaccurate or incomplete information.

Then follow the sequence, because it is the whole argument of this session. We start with biases, turn them into stereotypes, develop prejudices, and allow them to grow into discrimination. Four stages. The first three happen in your head and are not illegal. The fourth is an act, and it is.

EXPLICIT BIAS

Explicit means clear and exact. Explicit bias is a bias or prejudice that a person expresses openly. Overlooking transgender people for leadership positions because they cannot make up their minds is an explicit gender bias, stated out loud and stated as a reason.

Overt discrimination has long been part of United States history. In the late nineteenth century it was common for business owners to hang signs reading Help Wanted: No Irish Need Apply, or Whites Only. That explicit, overt form is not tolerated today, which is the good news and also the reason the rest of this screen exists. The conduct did not disappear when the signs came down.

IMPLICIT BIAS, ALSO CALLED UNCONSCIOUS BIAS

Implicit means suggested but not communicated directly. Implicit bias refers to attitudes or stereotypes that affect an individual's understanding, actions and decisions in an unconscious manner, which is what makes them difficult to control. The person holding the bias is not aware of it.

Implicit bias is a universal phenomenon, not limited by race, gender or even country of origin. Implicit bias is normal. Every person has biases of one kind or another and it is fine to have different likes and dislikes. What is not fine is letting the bias make a business decision without your noticing, and that is exactly what an unconscious association is built to do.

Because people with an implicit bias are not aware of it, the bias can influence them to make biased decisions in business, education and social settings. Unfortunately, some real estate agents let their biases get in the way and discriminate against people from diverse backgrounds and cultures. Nobody in that sentence woke up planning to.

FIVE WORDS THAT ARE NOT SYNONYMS

Preference. Preference is when we knowingly like one thing or person more than another, such as liking green more than orange. Bias and preference are not the same. Preferences and desires are also different: desires are directed at one object, whereas preferences concern a comparison between two alternatives of which one is preferred to the other.

Attitude. An attitude is an evaluative judgment of an object, a person, or a social group. An attitude is held by, or characterizes, a person. Implicit attitudes are evaluations that occur without conscious awareness.

Stereotype. A stereotype is the association of a person or a social group with a consistent set of traits. Stereotypes may include positive and negative traits, and either way the stereotype is an oversimplified generalization that does not take individual differences into account. Stereotypes can be based on race, ethnicity, age, gender or sexual orientation, and on almost any other characteristic.

Prejudice. Prejudice is a favorable or unfavorable preconceived feeling or opinion formed without knowledge, reason or thought, which prevents objective consideration of an idea, individual, group or thing. Prejudice is not based on experience. It is a prejudgment that originates from outside experience.

Discrimination. Prejudice refers to biased thinking. Illegal discrimination consists of actions against a group of people. That is the line the law draws, and it is the line this whole chapter has been describing from the other side.

Biases, preferences, attitudes, stereotypes and prejudices are all examples of psychological constructs. Psychological constructs are mental associations that can influence a person's behavior and feelings toward an individual or group. Where the person is unaware of these mental associations, they are said to be implicit.

WHERE IMPLICIT BIAS COMES FROM

Socialization. Socialization is the process of training people to behave in a way that others in the group think is suitable. It introduces people to social norms and customs, which helps individuals function in society. Family members, teachers, religious leaders and peers all play roles in it. Primary socialization takes place from birth through adolescence. Secondary socialization continues throughout one's life, and adult socialization may occur whenever people find themselves in new circumstances, especially those in which they interact with individuals whose norms or customs differ from theirs.

Ingroup and outgroup. An ingroup is a social group with which one identifies and an outgroup is one with which one does not. Ingroup favoritism is a pattern of favoring members of one's ingroup over outgroup members, and we generally tend to hold implicit biases that favor our ingroup. It can be expressed in evaluating others and in allocating resources. Ingroup preferences emerge very early in life, even among preschoolers, and the categorization is usually automatic and unconscious.

Ethnocentrism. Ethnocentrism is the tendency to view your own society or culture as superior, and as the standard by which other societies and cultures are judged. It can be positive or negative. Civic pride is a positive example. Belittling non-conforming minority groups is a negative one.

NOTE: The exam separates prejudice from discrimination by one word. Prejudice is thinking. Discrimination is acting. Every definition on this screen sits on one side of that line, and knowing which side is most of the question.

Thinking is prejudice; acting is discrimination

REMEMBER: Name the four stages from bias to discrimination in order. Then name the stage at which the law first has anything to say about you.

Bias in the Mind: Six You Will Recognize

None of these requires ill will, which is what makes them dangerous in a brokerage

Six named biases do most of the damage in an office, and not one of them requires a person to dislike anybody. They are errors of processing. You can hold every one of them while believing, sincerely, that you treat everyone the same.

Affinity bias. Affinity bias is the tendency to unconsciously gravitate toward people who share qualities with you, or with someone you like. It occurs because your brain sees them as familiar and relatable. That might mean favoring someone who shares your race, gender, age or educational background, or who went to the same school or shares similar hobbies.

In a brokerage, affinity bias decides who gets called back first. A licensee with twelve messages returns the three from people who sound like him, and the rest wait. Nobody was refused anything. The service was still unequal, and a tester would find it.

Attribution bias. Attribution bias is the tendency to project negative traits onto someone when they make a mistake, rather than blaming the mistake on circumstances. It explains a person's behavior by referring to their character rather than to any situational factor. We generally attribute our own accomplishments to skill and our own failures to external factors, and reverse the pattern when judging other people.

Three versions have names. The ultimate attribution error is the same bias at a group level: positive acts by our own group are treated as good character, positive acts by another group as luck or circumstance. Hostile attribution bias interprets unclear behavior as outwardly hostile, such as reading two people whispering as criticism with no evidence at all. Self-serving bias is the belief that one's successes come from character and ability rather than luck, and that one's failures come from outside.

The main characteristic of attribution bias is perceptual error. When people do not have the full picture they use whatever information they have to draw conclusions, and the conclusions are usually about the person's character and are usually unfounded. Somebody cuts you off on the highway and you decide what kind of person they are. What you do not know is that a bee came through the window.

Confirmation bias. Confirmation bias is the tendency to look for or favor information that confirms beliefs we already hold. People primarily search for bits of evidence that back up their opinions rather than looking at the whole picture. It leads to selective observation, which means overlooking other information and focusing on what fits your view, and it can lead you to reject new information that contradicts the first evidence.

Confirmation bias is the reason first impressions are so expensive in this business. You decide in the first two minutes that a buyer is not serious, and everything after that gets read as proof. The buyer who closes with somebody else in March was serious the whole time.

Conformity bias. Conformity bias is very common in group settings. It happens when your views are swayed by those of others, because we all seek acceptance and want to hold opinions our community recognizes. It is similar to groupthink. In an office where one agent's assumptions about a neighborhood go unchallenged, conformity bias is how those assumptions become the office's assumptions.

The contrast effect. The contrast effect occurs when you compare two or more similar things against each other rather than judging each on its own merits. It is common in recruitment, and it is just as common in reviewing offers: the second offer gets judged against the first rather than against the seller's actual position.

The halo and horn effect. The halo effect occurs when our impression of someone unconsciously influences our opinion of a different aspect of their character. We focus on one great feature and then view everything else about the person in a positive light. The horn effect is the opposite: you focus on one negative feature, which clouds your view of the person's other qualities. If a person does not use proper table manners you may assume they are uneducated and discount everything they say. One mistake or flaw does not represent the person as a whole.

SPEAKING WITHOUT GENDER BIAS

Language is where an unconscious bias becomes audible to somebody else. These pairs come from the GLAAD Media Reference Guide, and the pattern in them is consistent: state what the person is, rather than narrating a change from what you assume they were.

Instead of Pat was born a man but identifies as a woman, which implies gender identity is a choice, say Pat is a transgender woman.

Instead of John's coworkers did not know that he used to be a woman, say John's coworkers did not know that he is a trans man.

Instead of Li grew up male and became a woman at age 25, say that when Li was younger she was perceived to be male by others, and that at age 25 she disclosed that she is a trans woman and began her transition.

Use gender-inclusive language with clients, customers and other agents. At one point it was appropriate to ask a person for their preferred pronouns. Now, just say pronouns.

NOTE: None of the six biases on this screen is itself illegal. Each of them becomes illegal the moment it changes what service a client receives, and the exam tests that transition rather than the definitions alone.

A bias becomes a violation when service changes

REMEMBER: Pick the one of these six you recognize in yourself. Name the moment last month when it decided who you called back first.

Race, Ethnicity, and the Biases About People

Three words used interchangeably that do not mean the same thing

Race, ethnicity and minority group are used as though they were synonyms. They are not, and a licensee who cannot separate them will not be able to follow a fair housing complaint, because the law uses race, color and national origin as three different classes.

RACE

For most sociologists, race refers to superficial physical differences that a particular society considers significant. Race is a concept without a generally agreed-upon definition. Some people think race is a biological reality; others say it is a social construct. Historically it has been documented as a concept since the eighteenth century, dividing humans into groups based on physical appearance and on social and cultural background, and over time it became more concerned with superficial physical characteristics.

The National Human Genome Research Institute describes race as a fluid concept used to group people according to various factors, including ancestral background and social identity, and to group people who share a set of visible characteristics such as skin color and facial features. Though those visible traits are influenced by genes, humans are less genetically diverse than many animals. Our DNA is 99.9 percent the same, and of the variance that remains, almost all of it, 95.7 percent, is found among individuals of the same race. There is more genetic diversity within a race than between races.

ETHNICITY

Ethnicity is a broader term than race. It is used to categorize groups of people according to their cultural expression and identification. Ethnicity describes shared culture: the practices, values and beliefs of a group, including shared language, religion and traditions.

Someone may say their race is Black and their ethnicity British. Someone may say their race is White and their ethnicity Irish. Ethnic groups can be broadly or narrowly construed, as broad as indigenous peoples in America or as narrow as individual nations such as the Sioux, the Cheyenne or the Apache. Indians may be treated as one ethnic group and there are dozens of bona fide ethnic groups within that, such as Gujarati, Punjabi, Bengali and Tamil.

The working consequence is that a region is not a culture. A manager once dismissed an employee's discrimination complaint on the ground that she and her supervisor were both from South Asia. Bengali is the official language of Bangladesh and Hindi is the primary language of India. South Asia is a region of a continent, not a country or a nation, and the complaint should not have been dismissed.

MINORITY GROUP

A minority group is any group of people who, because of their physical or cultural characteristics, are singled out from others in the society in which they live for differential and unequal treatment, and who therefore regard themselves as objects of collective discrimination. The dominant group is the group that holds the most power in a given society.

Charles Wagley and Marvin Harris list five characteristics of a minority group. Unequal treatment and less power over their lives. Distinguishing physical or cultural traits such as skin color or language. Involuntary membership in the group. Awareness of subordination. And a high rate of in-group marriage.

Being a numerical minority is not one of the five. Sometimes larger groups are minority groups because of their lack of power. Apartheid in South Africa is the clearest example: a numerical majority exploited and oppressed by a minority. Protestants in a predominantly Catholic town would also be a minority group.

FIVE MORE BIASES A LICENSEE MEETS

Colorism. Colorism is the practice of favoring people with lighter skin over those with darker skin. It is a global, cultural and social construct that exists within many groups, including White, Black, Asian and Latino communities, and it occurs both intraracially, within groups, and interracially, across ethno-racial groups. The preference for lighter-skinned Blacks, held by both Whites and Blacks, can cause darker-skinned Blacks to have poorer outcomes in areas such as education and income than their fairer counterparts.

Religious bias. Religious bias involves viewing people favorably or unfavorably because of their religious, ethical or moral beliefs. It pertains to people who belong to traditional organized religions such as Buddhism, Christianity, Hinduism, Islam and Judaism, and to other sincerely held religious, ethical or moral beliefs. Respect religious observances, dress and grooming practices: head coverings, a Jewish yarmulke or a Muslim headscarf, Rastafarian dreadlocks, Sikh uncut hair and beard. An employer cannot allow items of one particular faith and not others, and cannot let one employee display a Bible on her desk while telling another to put the Quran out of view.

Ableism. Ableism is the bias of, and social prejudice against, people with disabilities, based on the belief that typical abilities are superior. At its core it assumes that people who are disabled require fixing. It classifies entire groups of people as less than, and includes harmful stereotypes, misconceptions and generalizations. The practical rules are short. Believe people when they disclose a disability. Do not assume you know what someone needs. Do not speak on behalf of someone with a disability unless they ask you to. Keep invasive questions to yourself. Listen when someone requests an accommodation. And never touch a person with a disability or their mobility equipment without consent.

Ageism. Ageism is discrimination or prejudice against an individual or group based on their age. Dr. Robert Butler coined the term in 1968, noting that ageism exists in all cultures. Age discrimination is the act; age prejudice is the attitude. It tends to affect women more than men and starts at younger ages. Not hiring an older person on the preconceived notion that their abilities will be lacking is ageism, and so is speaking over an older person on the notion that their opinion has no value.

Personal appearance. Beauty bias refers to the favorable treatment and positive stereotyping of individuals considered more attractive, and lookism describes the prejudice people have toward others because of their appearances, devaluing those society considers physically undesirable. Sizeism, or weight stigma, is prejudice or discrimination based on a person's size or weight. Heightism is unfair treatment based on height: for men, a 1.8 percent increase in wages accompanies every additional inch of height, and 90 percent of CEOs are of above-average height.

Put these five beside the law you learned earlier and the connection is direct. Colorism is race. Religious bias is religion. Ableism is disability. Ageism, in New York, is a protected class from the age of 18. Sizeism and heightism, in New York City, are weight and height. What the bias section adds is the mechanism, and the mechanism is where you can actually intervene.

One practical habit follows from this whole screen. Do not group people by region and treat the group as a culture. Ask the person. A client will tell you what matters to her about a neighborhood in thirty seconds if you ask an open question and then stop talking, and what she says will be more specific and more useful than anything you would have assumed about her.

CAUTION: A licensee who has never refused anyone can still deliver unequal service through these biases, because every one of them operates on how much effort a client receives rather than on whether the client is served at all.

Race, ethnicity and minority group are three things

REMEMBER: Name the five Wagley and Harris characteristics of a minority group, and then name the one thing that is not on the list.

Class, Meritocracy, and What Actually Works

Two systems of stratification, and the uncomfortable evidence on bias training

Class is the bias people are least willing to name and the one a real estate licensee touches every single day, because the entire job runs on what a client can afford. That makes it worth understanding precisely rather than avoiding.

CLASSISM AND SOCIAL STRATIFICATION

Classism is prejudice against, or in favor of, people belonging to a particular social class or perceived social class. It is based on social hierarchy, which is a system of social stratification in which an individual or group resides within a culture, organization or society.

Social stratification refers to the way people are ranked and ordered in society. In Western countries this stratification primarily occurs as a result of socioeconomic status, in which a hierarchy determines the groups most likely to gain access to financial resources and forms of privilege. Typically the upper classes have the most access to those resources, while the lower classes may get few or none, which puts them at a distinct disadvantage. Sociologists recognize that social class, race, gender, sexuality, nationality and sometimes religion all influence social stratification.

Stratification has a strong effect on the access a person has to education and on the quality of that education. It also affects who a person knows socially, the extent to which those people can provide advantageous economic and employment opportunities, and political participation.

INCOME, WEALTH AND EDUCATION

According to a 2019 study released by the Federal Reserve, the top 10 percent of households control 70 percent of the nation's riches. In 1989 that portion of the population held just 60 percent, an indication that class divides are growing rather than closing. The Federal Reserve attributes the trend to the richest Americans acquiring more assets, and the financial crisis that devastated the housing market also contributed to the wealth gap.

Education correlates positively with income and wealth. A survey of young United States adults found that those with at least a college degree are nearly four times as wealthy as the average young person, and hold 8.3 times as much wealth as those who completed high school only.

Completion of college is itself stratified. The Pew Research Center has reported that an estimated 63 percent of Asian Americans and 41 percent of Whites graduate from college, compared with 22 percent of Blacks and 15 percent of Latinos. Social stratification shapes access to higher education, which in turn affects a person's income and wealth, which in turn decides who can buy a house.

Two more terms keep the vocabulary straight. Economic class refers specifically to how one ranks relative to others in terms of income and wealth. Socioeconomic class, or socioeconomic status, is a more complex formulation, because it combines occupation, education and culture with wealth and income, and it considers the social status attached to professions considered prestigious and the stigma attached to others.

Class traits are the typical behaviors, customs and norms that define each class, and they are a trap for a licensee, because people do not obey them. A wealthy person may prefer a rock concert to an opera. A middle-class person may adore opera and ballet. An auto mechanic could be a skilled pastry chef. A billionaire might dress in ripped jeans and a low-income person might own a designer purse. Every time you decide what a client can afford by looking at them, you are betting on a stereotype that fails constantly.

TWO SYSTEMS OF STRATIFICATION

A class system is based on social factors and individual achievement. A class consists of a set of people who share similar statuses on factors like wealth, income, education and occupation. Class systems are open: occupation is not fixed at birth, people are free to gain a different level of education or employment than their parents, and they can socialize with and marry members of other classes, which allows people to move from one class to another.

Meritocracy is a social system, society, or organization in which people acquire success or power because of their abilities, not because of their money or social position. It is a social system in which people advance based on their merits. The term was coined by Michael Young in 1958, as the idea of replacing aristocracy with talent, skill and effort-based systems of economic and political reward.

Meritocracy is an ideal system. In reality social standing is influenced by multiple factors, not merit alone. Opponents of a merit-based system note that the resources to promote merit are largely based on a person's current and historic socioeconomic status, so those born into a higher standing have access to more resources than those born into a lower one. Unequal access to resources has a direct effect on the quality of a person's education, which affects how meritorious that person will appear when they apply for anything.

MEASURING BIAS, AND TRYING TO TRAIN IT AWAY

The Implicit Association Test was introduced into scientific literature in 1998 by Anthony Greenwald, Debbie McGhee and Jordan Schwartz. It is intended to detect subconscious associations between mental concepts in memory. Participants classify a series of words and images into categories and attributes and are required to rapidly pair the groups with positive or negative attributes. An implicit association is said to exist when a respondent takes longer to respond to a category-inconsistent pairing than to a category-consistent one.

The advantage is access. The test is online, so a participant needs only an internet connection, a device, and about ten minutes of concentration. The disadvantage is that it is easy to fake responses.

Now the part that is rarely taught honestly. Researchers from the University of Wisconsin at Madison, Harvard and the University of Virginia examined 426 studies over 20 years involving 72,063 participants that used the IAT and similar tests. They concluded that the correlation between implicit bias and discriminatory behavior appears weaker than previously thought, and that there is little evidence that changes in implicit bias correlate with changes in a person's behavior. Based on the evidence presented by their peer researchers, Greenwald and Banaji conceded that the IAT does not predict biased behavior and that it is problematic to use it to classify persons as likely to engage in discrimination.

Implicit bias training carries the same caution. A significant body of research suggests it has limited effects on changing beliefs in the long term. A 2020 analysis of 260 studies concluded that the positive effects of diversity training rarely last beyond a day or two, and that a number of studies suggest training can activate bias or spark a backlash. A 30-minute or 60-minute session cannot begin to compete with a lifetime of cultural socialization.

Where training does earn its place is at the start. If implicit bias training is designed to kick-start raising awareness, it can do some good, and raising awareness is in fact its most common achievement. That is why this session exists, and it is why the session is not the end of the work.

WHAT YOU CAN ACTUALLY DO

Be honest with yourself. It is fine to have biases, because everyone does, and having them does not make you any less of a person. What matters is that you control them and actively look for ways to expand and revise your views. Attend diversity-related training when it is offered. Think about each person as an individual, and judge each person on their merit rather than on a group. And change your outlook: aim to assess others more positively, give credit where it is due, and do not magnify shortcomings.

NOTE: A question asking whether the Implicit Association Test predicts discriminatory behavior has one defensible answer in this chapter. Greenwald, one of its authors, conceded with Banaji that it does not.

Awareness is the start of the work, not the end

REMEMBER: Name the two systems of stratification and the one difference between them. Then say honestly what a single training session can and cannot change.

More Biases, and the Words That Matter

Sexism, gender bias, classism, name and political bias, and four terms that are not synonyms

Four more biases and one vocabulary list. The vocabulary is the part that will come up in front of a client, in a week where you are busy and you say the first word that arrives. Getting it right costs nothing and getting it wrong costs the relationship.

SEXISM AND GENDER BIAS

Sexism is any act, gesture, visual representation, spoken or written words, practice or behavior based on the idea that a person or a group of persons is inferior because of their sex, occurring in the public or private sphere, whether online or offline. It occurs in education, advertising and media, business, culture and sport.

The signature of sexism is the double standard: different expectations about how men and women are supposed to behave, and different treatment for identical behavior. An assertive woman is called pushy where an assertive man is promoted. An aging woman is a hag where an aging man is a silver fox. Men who work long hours are workaholics where career-focused women are selfish.

Gender bias is a preference for one gender over the other. It often stems from deep-seated beliefs about gender roles and stereotypes, which are how we judge people based on a society's assigned feminine and masculine traits. Particular professions are implicitly associated with genders: elementary school teachers are implicitly stereotyped as female and engineers as male.

Gender bias occurs because we favor people we can relate to, especially those of the same gender. It becomes a problem when someone acts on negative stereotypical attitudes or prejudices, as when a hiring manager unconsciously leans toward a man for a physically demanding job regardless of the applicant's experience. Gender bias can be implicit or explicit. Assigning a gay man to plan the holiday party without thinking about why is implicit. Overlooking transgender people for leadership because they cannot make up their minds is explicit.

CLASSISM

Classism is prejudice against, or in favor of, people belonging to a particular social class or perceived social class. The words perceived social class do the damage in real estate. A licensee decides from a car, an accent, a zip code or a pair of shoes what a prospect can afford, and then serves the prospect at that level. The decision was made before anybody was prequalified.

FOUR TERMS THAT ARE NOT THE SAME

Sex is the biological and physiological characteristics that define humans as female or male.

Gender is a social, psychological and cultural construct developed in the process of socialization. Different societies and cultures may have different understandings of what is masculine or feminine. Gender is deeply personal: some people recognize their gender identity early in childhood and some later. For transgender people, gender identity does not align with sex. You cannot look at someone and see their gender identity, because a person's sex does not determine it.

Gender expression is the external manifestation of gender, expressed through a person's name, pronouns, clothing, haircut, voice and behavior. Most transgender people seek to align their gender expression with their gender identity.

Sexual orientation describes a person's physical, romantic or emotional attraction to another person. It is not the same as gender identity, and the two are constantly confused. Like everyone else, transgender people have sexual orientations: they may be straight, lesbian, gay, bisexual, pansexual, queer or asexual.

LGBTQ is the acronym for lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer. When LGBTQ organizations, leaders and media use the acronym, the Q generally stands for queer; in settings offering support for youth it can also stand for questioning. LGBTQ-plus is used with the plus added in recognition of all non-straight, transgender identities.

Some words in common use a few years ago are now outdated or offensive. Transvestite. Transsexual, which has been rejected by the transgender community. Homosexual, which because of its clinical history is frequently used by anti-LGBTQ extremists to denigrate people and relationships. Sexual preference, which inaccurately suggests that attraction is a choice that can be cured or changed. And lifestyle, which implies the same thing. Use gay, lesbian, bisexual, pansexual or queer as appropriate, and use sexual orientation.

NAME BIAS

Name bias is the tendency to prefer or dislike people based on their name and perceived background. People often prefer certain names over others, usually based on their own culture, and may dislike names that are difficult to pronounce or that are associated with negative events.

Name bias follows the news. After World War II there was a strong anti-German bias and many private companies refused to hire non-citizens or American citizens of German or Italian ancestry. After September 11 the bias against people with Arab names increased. During COVID-19 the United Nations Secretary-General said the pandemic continued to unleash a tsunami of hate and xenophobia, scapegoating and scare-mongering against Chinese and other Asians. A study found that applicants with Chinese and Middle Eastern-sounding names were far less likely to be called for an interview.

Name bias is most prevalent in recruitment, for jobs and colleges, and in membership of clubs and associations. Put it in a real estate office and it decides which internet lead gets a call back within the hour. Nobody records that decision anywhere, which is precisely why the office needs a rule about response times rather than a feeling about them.

POLITICAL AFFILIATION BIAS

Political affiliation bias means having a positive or negative feeling about people who are members of a political party. Political affiliation is not a protected class, except in some cities such as Washington, D.C. A hotel could lawfully refuse a reservation because the guest is, or is perceived to be, a member of a particular party. That is lawful, it is explicit bias and discrimination, and it is not good business practice.

Keep that example in your head as the control case for the whole chapter. Lawful and right are two different tests. Almost everything else in this chapter fails both. This one fails only the second, which is a useful reminder that the law is the floor of your conduct rather than the ceiling.

Biases, preferences, attitudes, stereotypes and prejudices are all psychological constructs: mental associations that can influence a person's behavior and feelings toward an individual or group. Where the person is unaware of them, they are implicit.

The reason this vocabulary belongs in a licensing course rather than in a style guide is that in New York these words name protected classes. Sex is a class. Sexual orientation is a class. Gender identity or expression has been a class of its own in the state statute since GENDA in 2019, and the city law covers it under gender. A licensee who cannot tell these apart cannot tell which protection he is about to violate, and the client on the other side of the desk will notice the confusion long before any agency does.

NOTE: Sexual orientation and gender identity are two different classes and both are protected in New York. Sexual orientation came in with SONDA in 2002. Gender identity or expression came into the Human Rights Law with GENDA in 2019.

Lawful and right are two separate tests

REMEMBER: Say the difference between gender identity and sexual orientation in one sentence, the way you would to a colleague who used them interchangeably.

Chapter Summary

Nine things to carry out of Human Rights and Fair Housing

This is the longest chapter in the course and it reduces to nine things. Read them once now and once the night before the exam.

ONE: THE STATUTES IN ORDER

The Civil Rights Act of 1866 was the first federal anti-discrimination statute to affect real estate. Race and color. No exemptions of any kind. Enforceable in federal court. Jones v. Alfred H. Mayer Co. upheld it in 1968 and held that it binds private parties as well as the state. Plessy v. Ferguson upheld separate but equal in 1896; Brown v. Board of Education overturned it in 1954; the Civil Rights Act of 1964 ended Jim Crow laws and did not touch housing. Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1968 added religion and national origin. 1974 added sex. 1988 added disability and familial status and moved HUD into mandatory enforcement.

TWO: THE SEVEN FEDERAL CLASSES

Race, color, religion, national origin, sex or gender, familial status, and handicap or disability. The Act also reaches advertising, real estate brokerage, lending and other services associated with residential transactions. It protects people associated with a member of a protected class, and it protects citizens and non-citizens alike. Familial status means children under 18 in the household, pregnancy, or a pending custody proceeding, and its only exemption is qualifying housing for older persons.

THREE: THE PROHIBITED PRACTICES

Steering channels buyers and renters and is prohibited even when the client asks for it. Blockbusting panics owners into selling cheap and is an attempt offense, so the leaflet is enough. Redlining is lenders and insurers refusing an area, and filtering down is the decline that follows and appears to justify it. Add refusal to deal, false unavailability, refusing an offer, denial of MLS access, discrimination in financial assistance, and unequal terms. Unequal terms is the quietest and the most common.

FOUR: TWO DUTIES, TWO PAYERS

The housing provider makes reasonable accommodations in rules, policies, practices or services, and pays for them absent an undue financial and administrative burden. The tenant pays for reasonable modifications, which are physical changes to the dwelling or common use areas, and may be required to restore the property where reasonable. New multi-family buildings of four or more units with an elevator, first occupied on or after March 13, 1991, had to be built accessible, and where a needed change should have been built in, the provider may have to pay for it. Granting an accommodation and burying it in conditions is a refusal, which is what HUD charged in the Townsend House case in 2008.

FIVE: THE ADA

Five titles: employment, public services, public accommodations, telecommunications, miscellaneous. Title III has had the greatest effect, and it reaches public and common use areas at housing developments as well as your own office. It exempts private clubs and places of worship, and historic buildings comply to the maximum extent feasible. It is enforced by the Department of Justice and the Attorney General, not by HUD.

SIX: NEW YORK GOES FURTHER

The New York State Human Rights Law, Article 15 of the Executive Law, covers housing accommodations and commercial space, and New York was the first state in the nation to pass laws of this kind. It adds age at 18 or older, marital status, military status, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, victims of domestic violence, lawful source of income in housing since April 12, 2019, and citizenship or immigration status since December 2022, for fifteen classes. New York City's Human Rights Law, Title 8 of the Administrative Code, covers all of those in its own words and adds height, weight and partnership status, for seventeen in housing. The city protected lawful source of income first, in 2008. Three lists. Never one.

SEVEN: EXEMPTIONS ARE NARROW AND NEW YORK NARROWS THEM

A stricter law always takes precedence. Federal law exempts owner-occupants of up to four units; New York exempts only a two-family. New York has no exemption for the sale of single-family housing. New York City's two exemptions vanish if the housing is publicly assisted, or advertised, listed or offered to the general public. Two rules hold everywhere: a real estate licensee is never exempt, and there are no exemptions for racial discrimination.

EIGHT: ENFORCEMENT

File within one year with HUD's Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity, with a regional office of the New York State Division of Human Rights, or with the Law Enforcement Bureau of the New York City Commission on Human Rights, which counts from the last act and is barred if the same incident is already filed elsewhere. A civil action under the New York City law runs three years. The mechanism is jurisdiction, investigation, conciliation or mediation, then an administrative law judge. Remedies run to cease and desist orders, affirmative action, damages, attorneys' fees, civil fines, and surrender of blockbusting profits. New York fines reach $50,000, or $100,000 for a willful, wanton or malicious act. Testers find what complaints do not. Cease-and-desist zones last up to five years and bind you as to registered owners; broader non-solicitation orders were struck down in 2002.

NINE: YOUR OWN OBLIGATIONS

Give the Housing and Anti-Discrimination Disclosure form to a prospective purchaser, tenant, seller or landlord at first substantive contact, and the Reasonable Accommodation and Reasonable Modification Disclosure form to a prospective tenant. Get them signed and keep them three years. Document every prospect the same way. Advertise the property and never the occupant. Tell your employing broker when a client will not comply. Know the law in every jurisdiction in which you practice. And remember that everyone carries implicit biases, that a single session does not remove them, and that fair housing violations are almost always excluded from errors and omissions insurance.

One sentence holds the whole chapter together. Treat everyone equally and fairly, keep the record that proves you did, and you will never need most of what you just learned.

THE THREE QUESTIONS THAT SETTLE ALMOST ANY FACT PATTERN

Who acted, and on whom. That separates steering from blockbusting from redlining, and it separates a licensee's offense from a lender's.

Which class, and under which layer. Federal, state or city. The answer decides whether there is a violation at all in the county you are standing in.

Refusal, or unequal terms. Half the conduct in this chapter is not a refusal. It is the same housing offered on different terms, or the same service delivered with different effort, and that is a violation on its own.

NOTE: If you remember only three things from this chapter, make them these. A licensee is never exempt. Race is never exempt. And the stricter law always governs.

Same service to everyone, and the file to prove it

REMEMBER: Name the seven federal classes, the eight New York adds, and the three New York City adds. If you can only do the first seven, you are ready for a state you do not practice in.

YOU BE THE JUDGE

The Marlowe Gardens Affair

Rhea Colvin of Colvin & Marsh takes the Marlowe Gardens file in Queens. Her first buyers, the Okonkwos, tell her they want four bedrooms and a garden anywhere within thirty minutes of the hospital. Rhea shows them six houses, every one of them on the same four blocks off Guy Brewer Boulevard, and says the two listings up in Whitestone “wouldn't really be your kind of street.” Her next appointment is a couple who ask to be shown houses only in an Orthodox Jewish neighborhood. Rhea says of course, prints a list confined to that neighborhood, and shows them nothing else.

That afternoon she works the blocks around Marlowe Gardens itself. She drops eight hundred leaflets reading “A minority family has just closed at 41 Marlowe, call Rhea before the whole block goes.” Two of the owners she then telephones are registered on the Department of State's cease-and-desist list for the zone, which she knows because she checked the list in the spring. For the one listing she does win she writes the advertisement herself: “Quiet, well-kept building, ideal for a mature Christian couple. No children.”

On the rental side Rhea manages a twelve-unit walk-up in the Bronx. She tells a mother with two young children that 3C is already taken; it is not, and she rents it eight days later to a single tenant. She turns away an applicant who offers a Section 8 voucher, explaining that the owner “only takes real money.” The tenant in 2A, who is visually impaired, asks for an exception to the building's no-pet rule for her guide dog, and Rhea refuses. The tenant in 1B, who uses a wheelchair, offers to hire and pay a contractor himself to widen the bathroom doorway and fit grab bars, and Rhea refuses that too. The application form she hands every applicant asks them to state whether they have ever been the victim of domestic violence.

Her seller at 12 Marlowe Terrace, a private owner selling the single-family house he lives in, tells Rhea he will not entertain an offer from “anyone from that family.” Rhea tells him not to worry, that a private single-family sale in New York is exempt from fair housing law anyway, and carries on marketing the house without mentioning a word of it to her employing broker. On none of these files does she give the purchaser, tenant, seller, or landlord the Housing and Anti-Discrimination Disclosure form, and she keeps no signed copies of anything. Across the parkway the Bayview 55 community turns down a family with a nine-year-old: Bayview publishes and follows policies providing housing for persons 55 and older, at least 80% of its units are occupied by at least one person 55 or older, and it files its age surveys and affidavits with HUD.

Twelve violations are buried in that story, and one lawful act has been planted among them to catch you out. Work it the way you would work a file, not the way you would take a test.

Read it once straight through without marking anything. Read it a second time with a pen and mark every sentence that made you pause, without deciding yet whether it is wrong. Then go back through this chapter and name the rule each marked sentence touches. A sentence you cannot tie to a rule is a sentence you have not finished with.

FOR EACH ACT, ASK THE SAME FOUR QUESTIONS

Who acted, and on whom. That single question separates steering from blockbusting from redlining, and the first paragraph and the second paragraph of this story are built to be told apart by it.

Which protected class is in play, and under which law. Some of Rhea's acts violate the federal Fair Housing Act. Some violate only New York, because New York protects classes the federal Act does not. At least one of them turns on a class that both the New York State and the New York City Human Rights Laws protect, and the building it happens in is in the city. Name every layer you are relying on, not just the offense.

Was the conduct a refusal, or unequal terms. Several acts in this story are not refusals at all. Something was done differently for one person than for another, and unequal terms is a violation in its own right.

What should the licensee have done instead. An issue you can spot but cannot cure is half an answer. Write the sentence Rhea should have said to that client, in the words you would have used.

THE BUYER PARAGRAPH

Two buyer appointments open the story and both of them are the same offense wearing different clothes. In the first, the licensee decided where the clients belonged. In the second, the clients asked and the licensee obliged. Go back to the steering screen and find the clause about a request from the prospective buyer or tenant, then decide whether obliging is a defense. Then write what the licensee could lawfully have offered the second couple, because there is an answer that serves them without breaking the rule.

THE SOLICITATION PARAGRAPH

The leaflets are one issue and the phone calls are a second, separate one, under a different body of law with a different enforcer. Ask whether any house had to sell for the leaflet to be a violation. Then go to the cease-and-desist screen and work out exactly which fact makes the calls unlawful: the existence of the zone, or something the owners did. Note when she last checked the list, and ask whether that is good enough.

The advertisement in that paragraph is a third issue and it names more than one protected class in a single line. Count them. Then ask which statute section restricts what an advertisement may say, and whether it matters that the seller, rather than the licensee, may have wanted that wording.

THE RENTAL PARAGRAPH

Five things happen in the Bronx building and they are five different rules. One is a statement about availability. One is about the source of the rent money. Check it against the state law and against the city law that came first, and notice which of the two ever asked how many units the building has. Two of them are the accommodation-and-modification pair, and the whole point is that they are not the same duty and do not have the same payer. And one of them is not a refusal at all: it is a question printed on a form, which is unlawful on its own terms under a New York protection added in 2015.

THE SELLER PARAGRAPH

The seller's instruction and the licensee's answer are two separate failures. Take the answer first. She tells him a private single-family sale in New York is exempt from fair housing law. Go to the exemptions screen and check that sentence against what New York actually exempts, then check it a second time against the 1866 Act and the class the seller named. Then ask what the licensee owed her employing broker once the seller said it, and when she owed it.

The disclosure failure later in that paragraph is the easiest issue in the story and the one most students leave out, because nothing dramatic happens. Name both forms, name the moment they were due, name who signs, and name how long they are kept.

THE ONE LAWFUL ACT

Something in this story is lawful and it sits next to conduct that is not. Find it. A licensee who calls everything a violation is as unreliable as one who calls nothing a violation, and in front of a client it is worse, because it costs a seller a deal that was never unlawful. Check the facts given about that community against all three conditions on the relevant screen, and be able to say which condition each stated fact satisfies.

HOW TO WRITE YOUR ANSWERS

Write each one in three parts and your work will hold up in front of anybody. The fact, quoted from the story. The rule, named from this chapter, with the layer it comes from. And the correct conduct, in the words you would have used with that client in the room. An issue you can only half answer will show you which of the three parts you are missing, and that is the part to go study.

Then argue the other side of the item you were least sure about. Say it out loud, in full sentences, as though Rhea is across the table with a reason for everything she did. If you cannot build that argument at all, go back to the screen the rule came from, because you have memorized a phrase rather than learned a rule.

One last pass, and it is the one that turns this from an exercise into practice. Go through your twelve answers and ask, for each, at what moment it could still have been prevented. Almost every one of them has a moment: a sentence not said, a form not given, a call to the broker not made, a list not checked. Write that moment down. Those are the habits this chapter is actually asking you to build.

NOTE: If your answer to an issue is a rule with no facts attached, you have not spotted an issue. Name the fact first, then the rule it breaks, then what the client should have been told by a licensee who knew the law.

Name the fact, then name the rule

REMEMBER: Which of Rhea's acts would have cost a family a home, and which one would have cost her the license she needs to fix it?

Check yourself

12 questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see whether it is right and why.

Key terms

Civil Rights Act of 1866
Federal law guaranteeing all citizens the same right to buy, sell, lease and convey property; prohibits racial discrimination with no exemptions (Jones v. Mayer, 1968).
Fair Housing Act
Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1968, as amended in 1974 and 1988, protecting race, color, religion, national origin, sex, familial status and disability in housing.
Familial status
Households with children under 18, pregnant women, or persons obtaining custody; exempt only in qualifying housing for older persons (62+, or 55+ with 80% occupancy).
Reasonable accommodation
A change in rules, policies or services needed for a disabled person to use housing equally, paid for by the housing provider.
Reasonable modification
A physical change to a dwelling or common area needed by a disabled tenant, paid for by the tenant, who may be required to restore the premises.
Steering
Channeling buyers or renters toward or away from neighborhoods because of a protected class.
Blockbusting
Inducing owners to sell, for profit, by representations that members of a protected class are entering the neighborhood; also called panic selling.
Redlining
A lender's or insurer's refusal to make loans or write insurance in a neighborhood for discriminatory reasons.
Tester
A person posing as a housing customer to compare the treatment given to members of different protected classes.
Cease-and-desist zone
An area designated by the Secretary of State for up to five years in which owners who file a statement may not be solicited by licensees.
New York State Human Rights Law
Executive Law Article 15, enforced by the Division of Human Rights; adds age, marital status, military status, sexual orientation, gender identity, domestic-violence victim status and lawful source of income to the federal classes.
Lawful source of income
A protected class covering public assistance, Section 8 vouchers, Social Security and similar income; landlords may not refuse tenants or rent payments on that basis.
Housing and Anti-Discrimination Disclosure
The DOS-2156 notice licensees must give at first substantive contact, signed and retained three years.
Implicit bias
Unconscious attitudes or stereotypes that affect actions and decisions; the starting point of the bias → stereotype → prejudice → discrimination chain.

Practise this chapter

Flashcards (free) Practice exam

Read Chapter 11 in the Book

The Book comes with the Salesperson pass ($39 for 3 months).

A study course, in beta. This is not a New York State Department of State approved qualifying course, and the time you spend here does not count toward the 77 hours you need for a salesperson license. Take the 77-hour course at a DOS-approved school; use this to learn the material and to review it. · Powered by License to Earn LLC