Lesson 1
What Value Actually Is
Value, price, and cost are three different numbers, and they rarely match.
Value, Price, and Cost
Three words that sound interchangeable and are not
Three numbers attach to every house. What it is worth, what somebody paid for it, and what it took to build it. Three different numbers, produced three different ways. A seller who confuses them prices his house wrong, and a licensee who confuses them lets him.
VALUE
Value is the present worth of the future benefits of ownership of a commodity such as real property. A buyer is not paying for brick and drywall. A buyer is paying today for what the property will give him over the years he owns it: shelter, use, rent, resale. Value is rendered as an opinion, never as a fact.
PRICE
Price is the amount a ready, willing, and able buyer agrees to pay and a seller agrees to accept under the terms of the transaction. Price is a fact: it happened and it is recorded. Price may or may not equal value. A seller transferred to Charlotte who must be out in five weeks takes what he can get, and on that house price and value part company by whatever the hurry cost him.
COST
Cost is the total dollar expenditure for the land, materials, legal services, architectural design, financing, taxes paid during construction, interest, contractors' overhead and profit, and entrepreneurial overhead and profit. Cost is a fact about the past, and it comes in two kinds.
DIRECT COSTS
Land, materials, and labor
Building permits and equipment
Utility installation and cost
Contractor's profit
Construction site security
Direct costs are the hard costs: the money that goes into the thing itself.
INDIRECT COSTS
Property taxes during construction
Engineering and architectural fees
Appraisal, accounting, legal fees
Insurance during construction
Marketing costs and commissions
Interest on construction loans
Indirect costs are the soft costs: money spent to make the building happen rather than money spent on the building. Filing fees, administration, lease-up costs and professional fees all land here.
Cost does not equal value
A house that does not conform to the properties around it, is over-improved with features the market does not respond to, or carries excessive deterioration is worth less than the cost to build it new. That is the market saying it will not pay for what the owner chose to buy.
A new building must return more than it cost, because the developer needs a profit to justify the risk. Without the motive of profit there would be no new buildings.
NOTE: Buyers do not care what a house cost to build. They care what other houses are selling for. When a seller opens with what he put into the kitchen, he has told you which of the three numbers he is holding, and it is the one the market cares about least.
Three numbers, three processes
REMEMBER: Your seller says the house is worth $600,000 because that is what he spent on it. Which of the three numbers has he just given you, and what is the one question that moves him off it?
The Characteristics of Real Property
Seven underlying characteristics - four of value, three physical
Perhaps the greatest single factor affecting the value of real property is its location. Location is the exact position of a piece of real estate, also known as its situs. Everyone in the business knows that. Fewer can say what else has to be true before a parcel has value at all, and the exam asks about the else. Every parcel is read against seven underlying characteristics: four that create value and three that are physical.
FOUR VALUE CHARACTERISTICS - D U S T
Demand
Utility
Scarcity
Transferability
Demand is the need or desire for a specific good or service by others. Without demand, any amount of supply is meaningless. Everyone needs somewhere to live, but a need is not yet demand in the sense that creates value. Effective demand is demand backed by the ability to pay, and effective demand is what has to be present. A thousand people who love the house and cannot qualify for the mortgage do not move the price by a dollar.
Utility is the ability of a good or service to satisfy human wants, needs, or desires. It is the degree of usefulness to a prospective buyer. A majority of typical buyers must share that perception before the market prices it. One buyer delighted by the recording studio in the basement does not make the basement valuable. No perceived use, no perceived value.
Scarcity is the perceived principle of supply and demand. The more supply of a good relative to demand, the lower the value. An unlimited supply of anything is perceived to be worth little. Real estate is valued largely because the supply of it in any one place is fixed, and that perception drives the expectation that a house bought today is worth more later.
Transferability is the ability to freely buy, sell, encumber, or dispose of property in any way the owner sees fit. The fewer the restrictions, public or private, the greater the perceived value. Restrictions are not only zoning. A condition on title limiting who the owner may sell to, a deed restriction, an easement across the buildable part of the lot, an unresolved lien: each narrows the pool of buyers and each shows up in the price.
THREE PHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS
Uniqueness
Immobility
Indestructibility
No other class of property has these three as a group. That is the line the exam tests, and the word that carries it is group.
Uniqueness means every piece of land, every building, and every home is different. It is also called non-homogeneity. Two identical houses built by the same crew from the same plan are still different properties, because they stand in different places. One faces the park and one faces the parking lot. Since no more land can be created in a given location, uniqueness feeds back into scarcity.
Immobility means real estate cannot be moved from one place to another. That is the line between land and personal property, which can go anywhere. Immobility is why a local market is local, why the comparables have to come from the same area, and why a licensee's knowledge of six neighborhoods is worth something.
Indestructibility means real estate cannot be destroyed. Land is not consumed and does not wear out the way other goods do. It can be altered, flooded, graded, paved or contaminated, and it will still be there afterward. That is what makes land attractive as a long-term investment, and it is the reason land itself is never depreciated. Hold that thought; it comes back in the cost approach.
NOTE: D U S T is the memory device and it is worth the three seconds it takes. Demand, utility, scarcity, transferability. Miss any one of the four and there is no value to appraise, whatever the property looks like.
Four create value; three are physical
REMEMBER: A landlocked parcel with no legal access is beautiful, buildable and for sale cheap. Which of the four value characteristics is the buyer's real problem?
Market Value - and the Other Values
Market value is the expected price; market price is the actual price paid
Market value is the theoretical price real estate will likely bring in a typical transaction. The New York syllabus puts it more exactly: the most probable price, as of a specific date, in cash or in terms equivalent to cash, under conditions requisite to fair sale, with both parties acting prudently and knowledgeably and without undue duress. Every clause is doing work.
Most probable, not highest. Market value is the number the house will most likely bring, not the best number anybody could ever get for it.
As of a specific date. Market value carries an effective date, because the market moves. A value opinion from last spring describes last spring.
In cash or terms equivalent to cash. A price propped up by the seller taking back paper at four percent in an eight percent market is not a cash-equivalent price.
Reasonable exposure. The property has been on the market long enough for the buyers who would want it to have found it. A pocket deal signed the day the sign went up has not been exposed to the market.
A TYPICAL TRANSACTION IS AN ARM'S LENGTH TRANSACTION
An arm's length transaction is one that occurred under typical market conditions, where the parties are relative strangers to one another and each acted in their own best interests. Market value is the most probable price a property will bring if the buyer paid cash at closing or obtained a mortgage to pay the seller the agreed price at closing; the buyer and seller are not related in any way; both are acting in their own best interests; neither is acting out of undue haste or duress; both are reasonably informed about the property and its potential uses; and the property has been available on the market for a reasonable period of time.
That list is a filter you run every comparable through. A father selling to his daughter at a discount is a related-party sale and not fair market value. A bank selling a foreclosure at a Tuesday morning auction is a distress sale and not fair market value. Neither may be used as a comparable. They tell you nothing about what a stranger would have paid.
OTHER TYPES OF VALUE
Mortgage value, also called loan value, is the amount a lender is willing to let someone borrow to finance or refinance property.
Investment value is the highest price a particular investor would pay based on how well he believes the property will serve his own financial goals. Two investors at the same building arrive at two investment values and one market value.
Insurable value is the amount a property can be insured for, usually only the replacement cost of the structure. The syllabus puts it bluntly: insurable value omits land and foundations. That is why a fully insured house can be insured for less than it would sell for.
Assessed value is the amount used to calculate taxes due, sometimes a percentage of market value. It is the assessor's number, not the market's. The Taxes and Assessments chapter works the conversion between market value, the uniform percentage and the assessment, and the equalization rate behind it.
Value in use is the present worth of the future benefits of ownership to a particular owner for a particular use. A working bakery is worth more to a baker than to anyone else.
VALUATION AND EVALUATION ARE NOT THE SAME WORD
Valuation is the process of estimating the value of an identified interest in specific property as of a given date. It refers to the actual approaches appraisers use, and it results in a value.
Evaluation is a study of the nature, quality, or utility of certain property interests in which a value estimate is not necessarily required. Highest and best use, feasibility, and market supply and demand studies are all evaluations. An evaluation does not result in a value of the property.
NOTE: Market value is the expected price. Market price is the actual price paid. When a question hands you a number and asks which it is, look for whether the sale has already closed.
Strangers, informed, unhurried, exposed
REMEMBER: Three sales closed on your subject's block last month. One was a divorce with a court deadline, one was an estate sale to the executor's son, one was a normal listing that sat sixty days. Which one is your comparable, and what do you tell the seller about the other two?
The Principles of Value
The ideas an appraiser - and a licensee pricing a listing - reasons with
The principles of value are the reasoning an appraiser uses between collecting data and stating a number. They are also the reasoning you use at a kitchen table. Each one answers a question a seller actually asks.
Substitution
An informed buyer will not pay more for a home than a comparable substitute. That idea is the foundation of the sales comparison approach and the reason the cost approach sets a ceiling on value. It applies to features too. If adding a fireplace costs $2,500, an appraiser cannot justify adding much more than $2,500 to the value of a home for having one.
Conformity
A home achieves its maximum value when surrounded by homes similar in style and function. Neighborhoods are more desirable where there is a general similarity in utility and value. Conformity is why a tract of ranches built in 1962 holds together as a market, and why your comparables should come from inside that tract rather than from the custom homes two streets over.
Progression and regression
The two directions conformity runs. Regression: a home that stands out as too different from the rest is worth less than that same home would be in a more homogeneous neighborhood. Progression: a lesser home is pulled up by the better ones around it, which is why buyers are told to buy the worst house on a good block.
Contribution
A particular item or feature is worth what it actually contributes in value to the property, and nothing else. Adding a fifth bedroom where five bedrooms are not desirable does not increase value. The value of an improvement equals only what a prospective buyer is willing to pay for it. Contribution answers the most common seller question there is: what did I get for the sixty thousand dollars I spent?
Anticipation
Where a future benefit or event may affect a parcel, its value may rise or fall simply on the anticipation of it. A farm sold to a developer who proposes a golf course surrounded by luxury homes can lift values across the road before a shovel goes in the ground. A rezoning hearing on a waste transfer station moves prices downward while it is still only a hearing.
Supply and demand
The broad market force. The more supply of a good relative to demand, the lower its value. Together with uniqueness and scarcity it sets the frame every other principle operates inside.
Highest and best use
The most profitable, legally permitted, economically feasible, and physically possible use of a property. All four conditions at once. This is the single most important property-specific factor an appraiser considers before determining value. For most houses in residential neighborhoods the answer is obvious, because the zoning permits nothing else. It becomes the whole question on vacant land and on improved property where the zoning has changed.
The syllabus asks for it in two forms, as vacant and as improved. As vacant asks what the site would best be used for if the buildings were not there. As improved asks whether what is standing on it is still the best use, given what it would cost to change. A house on a widened street surrounded by commercial buildings is commercial land as vacant and a house in the way as improved. The zoning must permit the intended use and the owner must be able to build it before either answer counts for anything.
Assemblage and plottage
Land utilization studies combine two or more parcels into one larger parcel, typically so one larger building can go up where only smaller ones could before. That combining is assemblage. When it produces an actual increase in land value over the combined value of the individual parcels, the increase is called plottage. Assemblage is the act. Plottage is the gain.
Change
Change is constantly occurring, so the factors that influence real estate do not remain constant. That is why an appraisal is valid only as of its effective date, and why a comparable that closed two years ago is not a comparable.
Location, or situs
The exact position of a piece of real estate. Location expresses itself only through the others. A location is valuable because of what is permitted on it, what surrounds it, what is anticipated for it, and how scarce it is.
NOTE: Contribution, substitution and highest and best use are the three to know cold. Contribution answers what a feature is worth. Substitution answers what the buyer will refuse to pay. Highest and best use answers what the land should be doing.
Each principle answers a seller's question
REMEMBER: A client spent $78,000 on a fifth bedroom and a heated pool in a neighborhood of three-bedroom ranches. Name the principle that decides what he gets back, and say out loud what you would tell him.
Lesson 2
The Three Approaches to Value
Each is independent of the others and performed separately, then reconciled into one opinion.
The Three Approaches to Value, Side by Side
The scope of work decides which are used - one, two, or all three
An appraiser values property by three methods. Sales comparison, cost, and income. Each approach is independent of the others and must be performed separately. The choice of which to run is driven by the scope of work decision, which is the type and extent of research and analyses an assignment needs. An appraiser may elect to use one, more than one, or all three.
1 SALES COMPARISON
Compares recently sold properties with the subject. Take the price a comparable actually sold for, adjust it for every significant way the comparable differs from the subject, and what you are left with is an indication of what the subject is worth. Comparable sale price plus or minus adjustments equals the indicated value of the subject.
Comp INFERIOR to the subject
ADD to the comparable
Comp SUPERIOR to the subject
SUBTRACT from the comparable
Best for non-income-producing residential property and most commercial property. It needs recent local sales, so it is not suitable for special-purpose or genuinely unique property.
2 COST
Builds the property back up from land and materials. Estimate what it would cost to put the structure up new today, subtract the depreciation the existing structure has suffered, add the value of the other site improvements, and add the value of the land. Land value plus replacement cost new, less depreciation, plus site improvements.
Best for new construction, for special-purpose property such as schools and churches where nothing comparable sells, and for insurance purposes. It also sets the theoretical ceiling of value on most property, by substitution: nobody informed pays more for a house than it would cost to buy the lot and build it.
3 INCOME CAPITALIZATION
Converts an income stream into a capital value. Net operating income divided by the capitalization rate gives value, which is the IRV relationship: I divided by R equals V.
Net operating income $60,000
Capitalization rate 7.5%
Value $800,000
Best for commercial and investment property and for residential rental real estate. Not useful for non-rental residential property, which is most of what a salesperson lists.
STEP 7 - RECONCILIATION
Each approach is independent and each yields a different figure. Suppose the sales comparison approach indicates $245,900 on a single-family house, the cost approach indicates $251,000, and the income approach is not applicable because the house is owner-occupied and there is no rent to capitalize. The appraiser does not average $245,900 and $251,000. Reconciliation is a judgment about which indication is best supported, and it concludes on one opinion of value.
For a single-family residence the sales comparison approach is normally reconciled as the strongest indication, because it is deeply rooted in actual market activity. The income approach is generally not used on a single-family property at all. The cost approach sets only the theoretical ceiling.
CAUTION: Reconciliation is never an arithmetic average. Averaging treats a well-supported indication and a badly supported one as equals, which is the opposite of what reconciliation is for. If your method is to add the numbers and divide by three, you have not reconciled anything.
Three approaches, one opinion
REMEMBER: You are asked to value a fire station, a twelve-unit walk-up, and a colonial in Yonkers. Which approach leads on each one, and which approach is useless on which property?
The Sales Comparison Approach
Five steps - and the one rule students reverse every time
The sales comparison approach compares recently sold properties in the same location with the subject property to render an opinion of value. It is generally the most useful and credible of the three methods, especially for non-income-producing residential property.
The subject property is the property being appraised. The properties used to support the opinion of value are the comparables, or comps. Get those two words straight, because the rule that governs this approach is stated in terms of them.
THE FIVE STEPS, DRIVEN BY THE SCOPE OF WORK
1 Identify the market in which the subject is competitive and research it for comparable data reflecting closed sales.
2 Confirm the identified data by verifying its accuracy.
3 Choose the units of comparison most applicable to the assignment, consistent with how the market would recognize it: total price, price per square foot, price per acre.
4 Apply adjustments to each property deemed a comparable sale to address significant differences.
5 Reconcile the strengths and weaknesses of the indications to conclude on an opinion of value.
CHOOSING THE COMPARABLES
A minimum of three comparables is required by most secondary market lenders, to ensure an accurate appraisal from sufficient data. Comparables should be as recent as possible, usually sold no more than six months to a year before the appraisal date, and as similar as possible to the subject. The syllabus draws the outer line at twelve months.
YOU ADJUST THE COMPARABLE, NEVER THE SUBJECT
The subject property never changes, because its value is the thing you are solving for. Adjusting is the process of making the chosen comparables come as close as possible in features to the subject, so a meaningful price comparison can be made. Every adjustment is made to a comparable's sale price, and no adjustment is ever written on the subject's line.
The direction follows from that alone. Comparable superior to the subject, subtract from the comparable. Comparable inferior, add to the comparable. You are answering one question over and over: what would this comparable have sold for if it had been just like my subject?
Hypothetical. Your subject is a 1,600-square-foot colonial in Levittown with a one-car garage. Three weeks ago the house around the corner sold for $655,000: same model, same condition, same street, two-car garage. A garage bay contributes $12,000 in that market.
Work it. The comparable has something the subject lacks, so the comparable is superior. Subtract. $655,000 less $12,000 is $643,000, the indicated value of your subject.
Now run it backward the way students do. Add the $12,000 instead and you get $667,000. The gap between right and wrong is $24,000, twice the adjustment, because you moved the money the wrong way by the full amount. A reversed direction never produces a near miss. It produces a number wrong by double.
An appraisal is only an opinion of value. Only the marketplace can establish the true value of a property, and the opinion is valid only as of the effective date.
NOTE: On the exam the fact pattern says the comparable has a feature the subject lacks. The correct answer is subtract from the comparable's sale price. Two wrong answers will offer to adjust the subject. The subject is never adjusted.
Adjust the comp. Never the subject
REMEMBER: Your comp has central air and your subject does not. Say out loud which property gets adjusted, in which direction, and why the other three answers are wrong.
The Cost Approach and Depreciation
Land never depreciates - the structure and the site improvements do
The cost approach develops an opinion of value by calculating the cost of building the structure on the land, subtracting depreciation, and adding the value of the site and any other site improvements. A property is worth what it would cost to replace, less what age and the market have taken out of it.
THE SIX STEPS, ALWAYS PERFORMED IN ORDER
1 Define the basis for the cost: reproduction or replacement.
2 Choose a costing method: comparative unit, unit-in-place, quantity survey, or index.
3 Estimate depreciation from physical deterioration, functional obsolescence and external obsolescence, by age-life, breakdown or market extraction.
4 Add the as-is contributory value of other site improvements, stated as an aggregate.
5 Add vacant land value, developed by accepted methods and based on the land's highest and best use.
6 Conclude on an opinion of value.
REPLACEMENT
Replacement is building the functional equivalent of the original building using modern materials, design, and functional layout. It is the usual basis, because it is what a buyer would actually build today.
REPRODUCTION
Reproduction is building an exact replica of the original, duplicating the materials, design, functional layout, workmanship, and the inadequacies. It is used where the exact building matters, such as a designated landmark.
The site value used in the cost approach always represents the value of the site at its highest and best use. Where the existing improvements are not consistent with that use, the inconsistency is treated as an obsolescence and shows up as depreciation of the improvements. Driveways, landscaping, walkways and sometimes utility provisions are taken at their as-is contributory value as one aggregate figure.
DEPRECIATION IS A LOSS IN VALUE FOR ANY REASON
Most people hear depreciation and think of a building falling apart. That is one of three causes. Depreciation is a monetary loss in property value for any reason at all.
Physical deterioration
Actual wear and tear due to age, the elements, or other forces. Regular maintenance slows it, and most physical deterioration is curable, meaning repairable at reasonable cost. It is measured by taking the new price of the item and subtracting a percentage for the wear and tear.
Functional obsolescence
The building is less desirable because of something inherent in the structure itself. An outdated style, outdated fixtures, a faulty design, a bedroom you reach through another bedroom, or a super over-improvement too costly for the area. It may be curable, fixed at reasonable cost, or incurable. It is measured by the cost of curing the feature, or for incurables by comparing sale prices with the feature and without it.
External obsolescence
Something outside the control of the property makes it less desirable. Changes in land use bringing air pollution or heavier traffic, a new arterial road behind the rear fence, an industrial use approved next door. It is also called economic obsolescence. External causes are usually incurable, because the owner does not control the thing causing them, and are measured the same way.
Land itself never suffers depreciation. The value of land can fluctuate, and it can fall hard when external forces change its highest and best use, but that movement is not depreciation. Depreciation applies to the structure on the land and to the other site improvements. A report that says the land has depreciated has used the wrong word for the wrong thing.
Hypothetical. A twelve-year-old raised ranch in Dutchess County. Replacement cost new is estimated at $320,000. The effective age is twelve years against a total economic life of sixty, so by the age-life method the improvements have lost twelve sixtieths of their value, which is 20 percent. Work it: $320,000 times .20 is $64,000 of accrued depreciation, and $320,000 less $64,000 leaves depreciated improvements of $256,000. Add the driveway, walks and landscaping at an aggregate $18,000, for $274,000. Add the site value at its highest and best use, $140,000. The cost approach indicates $414,000.
CAUTION: The depreciation estimate is the weakest number in the cost approach, and it is why the approach is rarely the answer on an older house. On new construction there is almost nothing to estimate and the approach is strong. On a house built in 1962 the appraiser is estimating effective age, economic life and three kinds of obsolescence, and every one is a judgment.
Land does not depreciate. Buildings do
REMEMBER: A highway opens forty feet behind a client's back fence. Which of the three forces is that, is it curable or incurable, and what has actually lost value: the house, the land, or both?
The Income Approach
Estimating value from the revenue a property generates - or could generate
The income approach estimates the value of real estate by analyzing the revenue the property currently generates or could generate, often by comparing it to similar properties. It is most widely used with commercial or investment property. On a single-family owner-occupied house there is no income to analyze, so the approach is not applied.
You need three tools from it as a residential licensee. Capitalization, the gross rent multiplier, and the gross income multiplier. The Commercial and Investment Properties chapters build the reconstructed income and expense statement, derive net operating income from a rent roll, work the pro forma, and take the analysis through debt service to cash-on-cash return. This screen stays on valuation.
CAPITALIZATION
Capitalization is interested only in net income, also called net operating income, which is income after operating expenses. That matters because an investor does not receive the money that pays the expenses. Gross rent flatters a building. Net operating income describes it.
Net operating income divided by the capitalization rate equals value. A property produces net operating income of $60,000 and the market capitalization rate is 7.5 percent. Work it: $60,000 divided by .075 is $800,000. That is the value indicated by the income approach.
Value times rate equals income, so the relationship solves for any of the three variables. Income divided by rate gives value. Income divided by value gives rate. Rate times value gives income. Value is income divided by rate, never income multiplied by rate.
GROSS RENT MULTIPLIER
The gross rent multiplier, GRM, sometimes called the gross monthly rent multiplier, is a number derived from comparable rental properties in an area and used to estimate value. Two limits define it. It is used for one- to four-unit residential property only, and it is based on total gross monthly rent. No allowance is deducted for expenses, vacancies, or collection losses.
Derive the multiplier from sales, then apply it. Hypothetical. Three two-family houses in one Bronx neighborhood sold in the last eight months. One sold for $455,000 and rented for $3,800 a month, a multiplier of 119.7. One sold for $492,000 and rented for $4,100: 120.0. One sold for $510,000 and rented for $4,200: 121.4. The three cluster tightly, and 120 is a fair multiplier for that market.
Now the subject, a two-family on the next block renting for a total of $4,050 a month. Work it: $4,050 times 120 is $486,000. That is the indication, and it took two minutes.
GROSS INCOME MULTIPLIER
The gross income multiplier, GIM, is the same idea applied to commercial and larger residential property, built on annual gross income rather than monthly rent. Hypothetical. A comparable twelve-unit walk-up produced $228,000 of annual gross income and sold for $1,596,000, which is a multiplier of 7.0. Your subject produces $240,000 of annual gross income. Work it: $240,000 times 7.0 is $1,680,000.
Both multipliers are gross measures. Neither deducts a dollar for taxes, insurance, heat, water, management, repairs or vacancy. Two buildings with identical rents and wildly different expense loads produce the same multiplier answer and are not worth the same amount. Use a multiplier to screen a property in or out in the first five minutes, and never use one derived from duplexes on a twelve-unit building.
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES
Sales comparison is the most accurate of the three when good data is available, because it relies on actual market activity, and it adjusts comparables so they more closely approximate the subject. Against it: it requires comparable properties to have sold recently in the area, and it is not suitable for special-purpose properties such as schools and churches or for other unique properties.
Cost gives a very useful and accurate estimate for special-purpose properties, uses extensive data, considers depreciation, and is excellent for new properties and for insurance. Against it: the cost of a building does not necessarily equal its value, and several market factors must still be considered for the estimate to be accurate.
Income is most useful for income-producing property such as commercial or residential rental real estate, solves for any variable, and values a future income stream. Against it: it is not useful for non-rental residential property, the income and expense figures represent past performance, and any attempt to introduce vacancy and collection losses into the equation is a guess.
NOTE: The gross rent multiplier is monthly and capped at one to four units. The gross income multiplier is annual and used above that. A question that offers you a GRM on a forty-unit building is offering you the wrong tool, and a question that gives you an annual rent and asks for a GRM wants you to divide by twelve first.
Gross screens. Net values
REMEMBER: A building nets $60,000 and the market is pricing at 7.5 percent. What is it worth, and what happens to that value if the market moves to 9 percent?
The Appraisal Process and the Appraisal Report
The same eight steps are followed whichever approach is used
Whatever approach an appraiser uses, the same step-by-step process runs underneath it. The point of the process is that the steps leading to the report are orderly and that the report is thorough, comprehensive and accurate. You are not going to do this work. You need to recognize it, because you will read appraisals, and because a client will ask you why the number came in low.
1 State the problem
Define the appraisal. What question is being answered, about what property interest, for whom, and as of what date.
2 Define the data
Define the data and the sources necessary to perform the appraisal.
3 Collect and analyze
Collect and analyze the relevant data.
4 Highest and best use
Determine the highest and best use for the subject property.
5 Value the land
Determine the value of the land separately from the structures.
6 Apply the approaches
Estimate the value of the subject property using all three approaches.
7 Reconcile
Reconcile the estimates of value produced by the three approaches.
8 Report
Report the conclusions of the valuation process, including all data used and the final value estimate.
Notice where the land is valued. Step 5, separately from the structures, and before the approaches are run. That ordering is not an accident. The cost approach cannot be built without a separate land value, and highest and best use in step 4 is what the land value in step 5 is based on.
THE APPRAISAL REPORT
The report is the final step and the primary means of communicating the appraisal results to the client. It reports a final opinion of value and it explains the appraiser's reasoning to the client and to anyone else authorized to read it. It should be clear and concise, logical and consistent, and supported and documented with market evidence in defense of its conclusions. Three elements are fundamental to every appraisal report. It must be clear, accurate, and not misleading. It must contain sufficient information to be understood properly by the intended users. And it must disclose any extraordinary assumptions or other assignment conditions that directly affect the appraisal.
URAR
The Uniform Residential Appraisal Report is the standard form lenders and appraisers use on residential property. It was developed and approved by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the secondary mortgage market buyers, so that residential properties can be compared in a consistent manner. When a buyer's lender orders an appraisal on a one-family house, the URAR is the form that comes back, and the adjustment grid on it looks very much like the one on the next screen.
NOTE: Clear, accurate, and not misleading is a standard for the whole document, not for the number at the end. A report with a defensible value and a misleading description of the property fails it.
Eight steps, then the report
REMEMBER: A lender's appraisal comes in $15,000 under the contract price. Which of the eight steps would you read first to understand why, and what would you be looking for there?
Lesson 3
The CMA and Pricing the Listing
What you may actually produce, and what you may never call it.
A Worked CMA Adjustment Grid
Subject: 2667 Oak Street, effective 1 March 2016 - every line worked through
The whole method on one property. The subject is 2667 Oak Street, a 1,268-square-foot ranch on .178 acre, three bedrooms, one and a half baths, two-car detached garage, excellent condition, effective 1 March 2016. Work each line and watch the direction.
THE ADJUSTMENT SCHEDULE
Sale date +$500 a month in a rising market · lot size $500 per .01 acre · gross living area $40 a square foot · half bath $1,500, full bath $3,000 · garage $4,000 a bay, attached +$1,000 over detached · condition $5,000 a grade. Every line is rounded to the nearest $100: 63 sq ft × $40 = $2,520, taken as $2,500.
SALE DATE, AT $500 A MONTH IN A RISING MARKET
Comp A sold two months ago for $241,600. In a rising market the older price is low, so the comparable is inferior on time: two months at $500 is plus $1,000. Comp B sold one month ago for $241,200: plus $500. Comp C sold four months ago for $244,500: plus $2,000.
LOT SIZE, AT $500 PER .01 ACRE
The subject sits on .178 acre. Comp A has .164, .014 less and inferior: add 1.4 times $500, plus $700. Comp B has .184, .006 more and superior: subtract .6 times $500, minus $300. Comp C has .210, .032 more: minus $1,600.
GROSS LIVING AREA, AT $40 A SQUARE FOOT
The subject has 1,268 square feet. Comp A has 1,205, 63 fewer and inferior: 63 times $40 is $2,520, plus $2,500 rounded. Comp B has 1,296, 28 more: $1,120, minus $1,100. Comp C has 1,305, 37 more: $1,480, minus $1,500.
BATHS, AT $1,500 A HALF BATH
The subject has one and a half baths. Comp A has two full, a half bath more and superior: minus $1,500. Comp B matches the subject, so no adjustment at all. Comp C has two full: minus $1,500.
GARAGE, AT $4,000 A BAY AND $1,000 FOR ATTACHED
The subject has a two-car detached garage. Comp A matches, so nothing moves. Comp B has one-car detached, a bay short and inferior: add $4,000. Comp C has two-car attached, superior: subtract $1,000.
CONDITION, AT $5,000 A GRADE
The subject is excellent, and so are Comps A and B. Comp C is graded good, one grade below and inferior: add $5,000.
NOW TOTAL EACH COMPARABLE
Comp A: plus $1,000, plus $700, plus $2,500, minus $1,500. The gross adjustment, every adjustment added as a positive number regardless of sign, is $5,700. The net is plus $2,700. $241,600 plus $2,700 is $244,300.
Comp B: plus $500, minus $300, minus $1,100, plus $4,000. Gross $5,900, net plus $3,100. $241,200 plus $3,100 is $244,300.
Comp C: plus $2,000, minus $1,600, minus $1,500, minus $1,500, minus $1,000, plus $5,000. Gross $12,600, net plus $1,400. $244,500 plus $1,400 is $245,900.
ADJUSTED SALE PRICE
$245,900
Read the gross adjustments before the answers. Comp C needed $12,600 of correcting, more than twice either of the others, so it was the least like the subject and every figure in its column rests on more judgment. A and B land in the same place from two different starting prices, and that agreement is the strongest evidence here.
THE RULE THAT GOVERNS ALL OF IT
You adjust the COMPARABLE, never the subject. The subject property never changes, adjusting is the process of making the chosen comparables come as close as possible in features to the subject so meaningful price comparisons can be made.
Comparable SUPERIOR to the subject → SUBTRACT. Comparable INFERIOR → ADD.
Reconcile. Never average. Averaging $244,300, $244,300 and $245,900 gives $244,833 and hides the fact that the outlier is also the weakest comparable.
NOTE: Gross adjustment is a quality measure and net adjustment is the answer. A comparable with a small net and a huge gross has had large adjustments cancel out, and it is worse than one with a larger net and a small gross.
REMEMBER: Cover the numbers and work Comp B from the raw facts alone. Did you get plus $3,100, and did the garage and the lot size move in opposite directions?
CMA, BPO, and Appraisal - Who May Do What
A CMA may be similar to an appraisal. It is never equal to one.
This is the screen your license depends on. Everything else in this chapter is method. A salesperson prepares a comparative market analysis. A salesperson does not appraise.
COMPARATIVE MARKET ANALYSIS
A comparative market analysis is a method of determining the approximate market value of a subject property by comparing it to similar properties in the area that have sold, are presently for sale, or did not sell. It is prepared by a real estate licensee, for a seller who wants to know what to ask or a buyer who wants to know what to offer. It is also called a competitive market analysis or a residential market analysis. The syllabus states its nature in five words: CMAs are opinions of value.
APPRAISAL
An appraisal is an unbiased estimate of the nature, quality, value or utility of an interest in or aspect of identified real estate. It is an opinion of value as of a specified date, supported in writing by objective data and reasoning, prepared by a licensed or certified appraiser. It looks only at homes that have sold, applies the three approaches within a defined scope of work, and reconciles them. It is the only one of the two that may support a federally regulated loan.
WHAT A LICENSEE MAY SAY ABOUT VALUE
You may tell a seller what comparable homes sold for, what the competing homes are asking, and what the expired and withdrawn homes failed to get. You may give a range of probable selling prices and recommend a list price inside it. You may explain every adjustment and defend it with data.
WHAT A LICENSEE MAY NOT SAY
You may not call it an appraisal. New York State law specifically indicates that a CMA may never be referred to as an appraisal, and the Department of State syllabus states the rule the same way: by law, CMAs may never be referred to as appraisals. You may not describe your work as a certified or licensed appraisal either. Executive Law §160-b provides that only a person certified or licensed under Article 6-E may describe or refer to any appraisal or other evaluation of real estate located in this state by the term certified or licensed. And a CMA cannot be used to determine property value for a federally regulated loan.
WHAT HAPPENS WHEN A CMA IS DRESSED UP AS AN APPRAISAL
Putting the word appraisal on a cover sheet is not a description of the pages inside. It is a statement about who prepared them and under what standard, and that statement is false when a salesperson prepared them. The work has not changed. The claim about the worker has.
Three things go wrong at once. The seller prices his house off a number never produced under appraisal standards. The lender cannot use it, so the loan file is defective. And the Department of State has a licensee who held himself out as qualified to do work he is not credentialed to do. Real Property Law §441-c lets the Department revoke or suspend a license, or impose a fine, for demonstrated untrustworthiness or incompetency.
The fix costs nothing. Call it a CMA. Put the words comparative market analysis on the cover. State that it is an opinion of value prepared by a licensed real estate salesperson and is not an appraisal. When the seller asks for an appraisal, refer the work out.
BROKER PRICE OPINION
Sometimes a lender asks a licensee for an analysis like a CMA, called a broker price opinion, or BPO. The classic occasion is a bank-owned foreclosure that will be sold at auction. A BPO is lawful work and you may be paid for it, under the same two limits as a CMA. It can never be called an appraisal, and neither a CMA nor a BPO may be used to determine property value for a federally regulated loan.
WHO MAY APPRAISE IN NEW YORK
Real estate appraisers in New York are licensed and certified under Article 6-E of the Executive Law, titled State Certified and Licensed Real Estate Appraisers, and regulated by the Department of State, Division of Licensing Services. There are four credentials: State Licensed Real Estate Appraiser Assistant, State Licensed Real Estate Appraiser, State Certified Residential, and State Certified General. Each carries its own education, experience and examination requirements and its own limits on the assignments it may accept.
USPAP
The Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, issued by the Appraisal Standards Board of The Appraisal Foundation, are the minimum standards every credentialed appraiser must follow. Compliance is required in federally related transactions, and credentialed appraisers must complete the 7-hour National USPAP Update Course every two years. A CMA is not held to USPAP, and that is the honest reason a CMA is not an appraisal.
YOUR LANE
Most licensees are not equipped to offer an official opinion of value in the form of an appraisal. You are nonetheless responsible for assigning value when you list a home and when you negotiate a price for a buyer. You need the vocabulary because customers will ask.
CAUTION: A licensee who appraises a property he also hopes to list is standing on both sides of the number the client is relying on. The License Law chapter flags that conflict where it lists the other licenses that touch real estate. If you ever hold both credentials, you do not use both on the same transaction.
Produce a CMA. Call it a CMA
REMEMBER: A seller asks you for an appraisal so his bank will accept it. Say the answer out loud in three sentences: what you can give him, what you cannot, and who he needs to call.
The Whole Market - and Arriving at a List Price
An appraiser looks only at what sold. A CMA looks at everything that entered the market.
An appraiser looks only at homes that have sold. A CMA should consider every similar home that entered the market. The appraiser answers what the property is worth. You answer what it will sell for, in this market, against this competition, in the time your seller has. Four categories go into the analysis.
Active
Homes currently listed for sale, from the MLS and from for-sale-by-owner. These are your seller's direct competition. Watch four things: how many competing properties are on the market, how long each has been listed, whether the list price has been reduced, and how many times.
Sold
Homes that sold recently, typically within the past six months, in the market and area where the subject sits. The New York syllabus sets the outer boundary at sales closed within the last twelve months. Necessary, and never sufficient by itself.
Expired
Homes where the listing agreement ran out because the property did not sell during the listing period.
Withdrawn
Homes taken off the market. Properties under contract are useful too. There is no sold price yet, but you can see the original price, the price changes, the days on market and the price it went to contract at.
WHY THE SOLD HOMES ARE NOT ENOUGH
It is tempting to look only at what sold, on the theory that a house that sold must have been priced right. The logic is incomplete. There may have been a unique buyer who needed that house or had to buy quickly, so one sale cannot justify a price. It is impossible to know all the factors in one buying decision. And the competition that existed at the time cannot be seen in the sold column.
WHY THE HOMES THAT DID NOT SELL TELL YOU MORE
The market's reaction to those homes is already known. A home did not sell because it was overpriced, because it lacked the features the market wanted, or because there was an oversupply. Any way you read it, a comparable non-sale means the subject should be priced lower than that home if you want buyers and activity. A seller may still insist on more, but the market has spoken and the house will take longer.
DAYS ON MARKET AND ABSORPTION
Days on market for every home that entered the market gives a rough idea of how long the subject will take. Then count the standing inventory. Six sales in 125 to 180 days is about one a month, so 18 active listings is roughly 18 months of absorption. If the seller needs to be out sooner, a lower price is the only lever that moves reliably.
WHAT ELSE A CMA COMPARES
Size: lot, square feet, rooms
Location: water, golf, traffic
Buyer appeal: style, materials
Condition: age and upkeep
Neighborhood: transport, schools
A CMA is primarily concerned with the observable differences that would draw a buyer to one house over another. Buyer appeal is subjective and it is critical. Curb appeal decides whether the buyer gets out of the car.
ARRIVING AT A LIST PRICE
Do not lead with a number
Use the first visit to evaluate the property, note the selling points and the obvious problem areas, and get a feel for how the house fits the community. Is it the best site on the block, the worst, or average? Find out what the sellers actually need, and document everything from the first visit forward.
Give a range, not a point
After you gather the facts and research the comparables, present a comprehensive CMA containing a range of probable selling prices, so the sellers can decide what to ask. There is no single right answer, and some analyses are far better than others.
Justify it with data
You must be able to defend the value range and the recommended list price with the solid data you collected from the marketplace. The syllabus names four duties for the salesperson in this subject: competence, diligence, documentation, and effective communication. Documentation is the one that saves you.
Know when to walk away
Some sellers are certain the house will beat what you presented. It may be more prudent to decline the listing than to take it above what the market supports. Set the price too low and both seller and broker lose money; set it too high and it may not sell. The seller decides the asking price. Your job is to make that decision an informed one.
CAUTION: Reasonable care does not stop when the listing is signed. Update the MLS and every advertisement when the price changes, and update the photographs when the season changes. A listing still showing snow on the lawn in August tells every buyer how long the house has been sitting.
Everything that entered the market
REMEMBER: Your seller wants $40,000 more than your range. What three pieces of market data do you put in front of him, and what do you do if he still says no?
Lesson 4
Real Estate Math
The calculations that come up every week, measurement, commission, net to seller, interest, and return.
Real Estate Math - Measurement
Square footage, acreage, frontage, perimeter, and volume
Measurement math shows up every week and it shows up on the exam. None of it is hard. All of it is easy to get wrong in a hurry, and a lot of it depends on knowing a handful of conversions cold rather than working them out.
THE CONVERSIONS WORTH MEMORIZING
12 inches
1 foot
3 feet
1 yard
16½ feet
1 rod, perch, or pole
5,280 feet
1 mile, or 80 chains
9 square feet
1 square yard
43,560 square feet
1 acre, or 10 square chains
2.47 acres
1 hectare (10,000 sq metres)
640 acres
1 square mile, or 1 section
36 sections
1 township
27 cubic feet
1 cubic yard
Learn the four that carry the most questions: 43,560 square feet in an acre, 5,280 feet in a mile, 640 acres in a square mile, and 27 cubic feet in a cubic yard. A square mile is also one section, and 36 sections make one township. A rod, a perch and a pole are the same 16 and a half feet.
AREA
Area equals width times length. Turn it around and area divided by width gives length, and area divided by length gives width. Any missing dimension of a rectangle is one division away. A lot of 33,750 square feet that runs 225 feet deep is 33,750 divided by 225, which is 150 feet wide.
FRONT FEET
Frontage is the portion of the lot facing the street, and in a stated measurement it is always the first number. A 125 by 200 lot has 125 front feet. That convention matters as soon as land is priced per front foot, because reversing the two numbers changes the price of the parcel.
TRIANGLES AND IRREGULAR LOTS
A triangle is base divided by two, times height, which is the same as base times height divided by two. A triangular parcel with a 200-foot base and a 350-foot height is 200 divided by 2, which is 100, times 350, which is 35,000 square feet.
An irregular lot is not one shape, so stop treating it as one. Break it into squares, rectangles and triangles, work each piece separately, and add the pieces: 1,250 plus 150 plus 375 is 1,775 square feet. Draw the lines on the survey before you touch the calculator.
ACREAGE
Square footage divided by 43,560 equals acres. A 120 by 200 lot is 24,000 square feet, and 24,000 divided by 43,560 is .55 acre. Run it the other way to go from acres to square feet: multiply by 43,560.
PERIMETER
Perimeter is every side added together. Fencing, trim, baseboard and gutter are all perimeter problems. A 75 by 50 yard needs 75 plus 50 plus 75 plus 50, which is 250 linear feet of fence.
VOLUME
Volume is length times width times height. A 12 by 8 pool six feet deep is 12 times 8 times 6, which is 576 cubic feet, and 576 divided by 27 is 21.33 cubic yards. Concrete, fill and excavation are all sold by the cubic yard, so the division by 27 is usually the last step.
Volume is Length × Width × Height. A 60' × 4' sidewalk 4 inches deep is 79.2 cu ft, three bags.
Watch the units when a depth is given in inches. Four inches is a third of a foot, and a depth entered as 4 instead of .33 makes the answer twelve times too large. The unit error is the one that produces an absurd number, and an absurd number is the signal to go back rather than to write it down.
NOTE: Read what the question is asking for before you calculate. Square feet, acres, front feet, linear feet and cubic yards are five different answers to the same lot, and the wrong unit is a wrong answer even when the arithmetic is perfect.
Convert first, then calculate
REMEMBER: A 160 by 180 lot. How many square feet, how many acres, and how many front feet? Three answers from one line of figures.
Real Estate Math - Percentages and Money
Commission, net to seller, interest, and return on investment
Almost every money problem in real estate is one percentage relationship wearing different clothes. Learn it once as a shape and you will recognize it in a commission, net-to-seller, interest or return question.
T-MATH
Draw a T. The part goes on top. The percent and the whole go on the bottom, side by side. Know any two and you can find the third. The horizontal line means divide and the vertical line means multiply. Percent times whole equals part. Part divided by percent equals whole.
COMMISSION
The commission is the part, the rate is the percent, the sale price is the whole. Sale price times rate equals commission; commission divided by rate equals sale price.
.06 × $211,000 = $12,660
Six percent of $211,000 is $12,660. Check it backward: $12,660 divided by .06 returns $211,000.
NET TO SELLER
Net to seller is an estimate, never a guarantee, of what the seller keeps after everything is paid. The commission comes out of a sale price you do not know yet, so you cannot multiply your way in. You have to divide.
A seller must clear a $35,000 mortgage, $3,200 of closing costs, and $40,000 for her next purchase, at a 6.5 percent rate.
100% − 6.5% = 93.5%
$35,000 + $3,200 + $40,000 = $78,200
$78,200 ÷ .935 = $83,636.36, so she must sell for $83,637
Work it in order. 100 percent minus 6.5 percent is 93.5 percent, the share the seller keeps. Add what she needs: $35,000 plus $3,200 plus $40,000 is $78,200. Divide: $78,200 divided by .935 is $83,636.36, so she must sell for $83,637. Multiplying by 1.065 gives $83,283, short by enough to break the closing.
PRINCIPAL AND INTEREST
Interest is the cost of borrowing and principal is the loan balance. On a level-payment loan the interest is computed on the balance, and whatever the payment does not use goes to principal.
.075 × $135,000 = $10,125 a year
$10,125 ÷ 12 = $843.75 a month
$985 − $843.75 = $141.25 to principal
Work it. A $135,000 loan at 7.5 percent: .075 times $135,000 is $10,125 of interest a year. Divide by 12 and the first month's interest is $843.75. If the payment is $985, then $985 minus $843.75 leaves $141.25 going to principal. Next month the balance is smaller, so more of the same payment reaches principal. That is amortization.
RETURN ON INVESTMENT
Profit divided by the original purchase price gives the percentage of profit. The denominator is what you paid, not what you sold for.
$115,000 − $100,000 = $15,000
$15,000 ÷ $100,000 = .15, or 15% profit
$115,000 minus $100,000 is $15,000 of profit, and $15,000 divided by $100,000 is .15, or 15 percent.
WORKED PRACTICE PROBLEMS
Land sells for $22,800 an acre. What does a 160 by 180 lot cost?
(160 × 180) ÷ 43,560 = .66 acre; .66 × $22,800 = $15,048
160 times 180 is 28,800 square feet, and 28,800 divided by 43,560 is .66 acre. Then .66 times $22,800 is $15,048.
A 150 by 600 commercial lot at $2,000 a front foot, and the same lot at $3.25 a square foot.
150 × $2,000 = $300,000; 90,000 sq ft × $3.25 = $292,500
Frontage is the first number, so 150 times $2,000 is $300,000. By area, 150 times 600 is 90,000 square feet, and 90,000 times $3.25 is $292,500.
A house sells for $90,000 at 7 percent commission, split evenly between two firms.
$90,000 × .07 = $6,300; $6,300 ÷ 2 = $3,150 to each company
$90,000 times .07 is $6,300 of total commission, and $6,300 divided by 2 is $3,150 to each company.
Bill sold for $234,900, making a 28 percent profit. What had he paid?
$234,900 ÷ 1.28 = $183,516; check: $51,384 ÷ $183,516 = 28%
The sale price is 128 percent of what he paid, so divide: $234,900 divided by 1.28 is $183,516. Check it. $234,900 minus $183,516 is $51,384 of profit, and $51,384 divided by $183,516 is 28 percent.
CAUTION: Never take 28 percent of the sale price and subtract it. That gives $169,128, a wrong answer offered on purpose. The percentage was earned on what he paid, so what he paid is the whole and goes on the bottom of the T.
The price you paid is the whole
REMEMBER: Which calculations on this screen require you to divide rather than multiply, and what goes wrong if you multiply instead?
Session Summary
Nine things to carry out of this chapter
VALUE, PRICE, AND COST
Value is the present worth of the future benefits of ownership, rendered as an opinion. Price is what a ready, willing and able buyer agrees to pay and a seller agrees to accept, and it is a fact. Cost is the total expenditure to build, direct and indirect, and it is a fact about the past. Market value is the expected price; market price is the actual price paid. Cost does not equal value, and a buyer does not care what the house cost to build.
CHARACTERISTICS OF VALUE
Demand, utility, scarcity and transferability create value, and demand has to be effective demand, backed by the ability to pay. Uniqueness, immobility and indestructibility are the physical characteristics no other class of property has as a group. Location, or situs, is perhaps the greatest single factor, and it works through the others.
MARKET VALUE
The most probable price, as of a specific date, in cash or terms equivalent to cash, under conditions requisite to fair sale, with both parties acting prudently and knowledgeably and without undue duress. Most probable, not highest. Market value implies an arm's-length transaction between unrelated parties who are informed, unhurried and acting in their own interests, on a property exposed to the market for a reasonable time. Related-party sales and distress sales are not fair market value and may not be used as comparables.
THE PRINCIPLES OF VALUE
Substitution caps what a buyer will pay. Conformity, with progression and regression, explains what the neighborhood does to a house. Contribution says a feature is worth only what it adds. Anticipation moves value on a future event. Supply and demand sets the frame. Assemblage is the act of combining parcels and plottage is the gain in value it produces. Change is why an appraisal is valid only as of its effective date. And highest and best use is the most profitable, legally permitted, economically feasible and physically possible use, analyzed both as vacant and as improved.
THE THREE APPROACHES
Sales comparison adjusts recent comparable sales to the subject and is strongest for residential. Cost adds land value to replacement cost new less depreciation, plus site improvements, and suits new or special-purpose property and insurance. Income capitalizes net operating income, for commercial and investment property: $60,000 divided by 7.5 percent is $800,000. The gross rent multiplier is monthly and limited to one- to four-unit residential; the gross income multiplier is annual and used above that; neither deducts expenses. The appraiser reconciles, and reconciliation is never an average.
DEPRECIATION
A loss in value for any reason. Physical deterioration is wear and tear and is usually curable. Functional obsolescence is inherent in the structure and may be curable or incurable. External, or economic, obsolescence comes from outside the property's control and is usually incurable. Land itself never depreciates, though land value can fluctuate. Depreciation attaches to the structure and the other site improvements.
THE CMA AND THE ADJUSTMENT RULE
A CMA compares the subject to homes that have sold, are for sale, expired, or were withdrawn, and the ones that did not sell often tell you more. Sale date, lot size, condition, square footage and terms of sale are all significant. You adjust the comparable and never the subject: comparable superior, subtract; comparable inferior, add. Reverse the direction and the error is twice the adjustment. Weigh the comparables with the smallest gross adjustments most heavily, and reconcile rather than average.
WHAT YOU MAY CALL IT
A CMA is never equal to an appraisal, and New York law says it may never be called one. A BPO for a lender is lawful licensee work under the same two limits. Neither a CMA nor a BPO may be used to determine value for a federally regulated loan. Appraisers are licensed and certified under Article 6-E of the Executive Law in four credentials and work to USPAP. Produce a CMA, call it a CMA, and refer the appraisal work out.
PRICING THE LISTING
Present a range, justify it with market data, and document everything. Competence, diligence, documentation and effective communication are the four duties the syllabus names for a salesperson in this subject. Too low and seller and broker lose money; too high and it may not sell. Keeping the MLS price and photographs current is part of reasonable care. The seller sets the asking price, and your job is to make that decision an informed one.
REMEMBER: Nine ideas. Which one could you not explain to a seller right now without looking back at the screen it came from?
YOU BE THE JUDGE
The Larkspur Lane Overprice
Dev Marchetti, a salesperson at Ridgeline Realty, sits down at 14 Larkspur Lane in New Rochelle with the Okafors, who want to sell. He hands them a bound document with a gold cover sheet reading “APPRAISAL OF VALUE, 14 Larkspur Lane.” Inside are three comparables, all of them closed sales; Dev never pulled the eleven homes currently listed on the same block, the two listings that expired in November, or the one the owners withdrew in January. One of his three comps closed twenty-six months ago. Another was the foreclosure that Mrs. Okafor's brother-in-law bought from the bank at a Tuesday-morning auction, which Dev says is “the truest number on the street.”
The subject has three bedrooms and one and a half baths, a 1,268-square-foot main floor, and a two-car detached garage. Comp A has two full baths, so Dev writes “+$1,500” on the subject line to bring the subject up to the comparable. Comp B has a three-car attached garage against the subject's two-car detached, and Dev adds $6,000 to Comp B “because the garage is better.” He then takes his three adjusted figures, $244,300, $251,900 and $268,000, averages them to $254,733, rounds to $255,000, and writes that number on the signature page as the appraised value.
The Okafors mention that they spent $78,000 in 2019 adding a fifth bedroom over the garage and putting in a heated pool. Dev tells them the house is therefore worth what it cost to build plus the $78,000, dollar for dollar. He also notes that the Cross County connector opened four hundred feet behind the rear fence in 2021, and writes in his report that the LAND has depreciated twenty percent since then, and that the traffic noise is “curable, put up an eight-foot fence and it goes away.”
On his way out, Dev promises to email the same document to the Okafors' buyer's lender, Harbor Savings, so the bank can rely on it to set the value for the buyer's conventional mortgage. He mentions that he also has a twelve-unit walk-up on Union Avenue under contract, which he valued by multiplying the building's total gross monthly rents by a multiplier he pulled from two nearby duplexes, with no deduction for expenses or vacancy. And he says he is finishing a broker price opinion this week for Harbor Savings on a foreclosed cottage the bank will put up at auction next month.
Twelve violations are buried in that story, and one lawful act has been planted among them. Read it again with a pen and mark every sentence that made you pause. A sentence you cannot tie to a rule is one you have not finished with.
THE COVER SHEET
Before you look at a single comparable, ask what that label claims about who prepared the document and under what standard. The rule is on the CMA screen, in one sentence, without exceptions. Then say what the cover sheet should have read.
HIS DATA SET
Which categories of property did he look at, and which does a CMA require that an appraisal does not? How old is his oldest sale, against the outer limit this chapter gives? And what kind of transaction is the one he calls the truest number on the street? Two separate rules condemn it.
HIS ARITHMETIC
Paragraph two catches him with a calculator rather than an adjective. Three errors sit in it.
The first is which property he wrote on. He handled a bath difference by writing a figure on a line that may never carry one. Name the rule, and say where the adjustment belonged.
The second is direction. Comp B has more garage than the subject and he moved the money up. Decide whether that comparable is superior or inferior, then size his mistake. It is not $6,000.
The third is what he did with three figures at the end. Add them, divide by three, confirm you get his $254,733. The arithmetic is fine. The method is the violation. Name the step he skipped.
THREE PRINCIPLES IN A ROW
The Okafors spent $78,000 and Dev hands it back dollar for dollar. Two ideas from this chapter say he cannot. One is about cost and value. The other is about what a feature is worth in a neighborhood that does not want it.
Then the sentence about the land. One word in this chapter attaches to structures and site improvements and never to land, and he has attached it to land. Say what is true instead, because land value can move; it does not move by the mechanism he named.
Then the highway. Name which of the three forces of depreciation a new arterial road four hundred feet behind the fence is, say whether it is usually curable or incurable, and decide what an eight-foot fence does not fix. Curability is about removing the cause, not softening the symptom.
WHO MAY USE WHAT
The email to Harbor Savings raises two questions. May this document be called what he called it, and may a document of this kind be used by a lender to set value for that buyer's mortgage? The second has its own rule and its own phrase in this chapter.
The twelve-unit walk-up. Ask what kind of property his multiplier may be used on and what unit of income it is built from, then what he should have capitalized instead. The tool does not fit the building, and the comparables do not fit either.
The broker price opinion. Look hard before you call it. Find the rule that makes it lawful, then state the two limits that still apply to it.
Write each answer in three parts. The fact, quoted from the story. The rule, named from this chapter. The advice you would have given the Okafors.
NOTE: If your answer is a rule with no facts attached, you have not spotted an issue. You have recited a rule and hoped it fit. Name the fact first, then the rule it breaks, then what the client should have been told.
Name the fact, then name the rule
REMEMBER: Which of Dev's twelve errors puts his license at the greatest risk, and which costs the Okafors the most money? They are not the same error.