The Course · Chapter 8 Beta

Chapter 8: Land Use Regulations

Private covenants, public power, and the line a zoning map draws

In this chapter

  • What this session gives you Private land use controls
  • Explain how restrictive covenants and deed restrictions are created, recorded, and run with the land. Ending a covenant
  • List the ways a restrictive covenant terminates, and apply the doctrine of laches. The four government powers
  • Distinguish police power, taxation, escheat, and eminent domain. Condemnation and takings
  • Separate the power from the act, and a taking from a lawful condemnation. Planning boards
  • Describe the comprehensive plan, capital budget, official map, and site plan review. Subdivision and plats
  • Explain density, plats, demographics, topography, and surveys. Zoning
  • Read a zoning map; classify districts and types of zoning, including illegal spot zoning. Exceptions and enforcement

Lesson 1

Private Land Use Controls

Ownership can be absolute, and still be restricted by the person who sold it to you.

Restrictive Covenants and Deed Restrictions

Private controls, written by owners, binding every owner who comes after

Land ownership in New York can be absolute. The complete bundle of rights belongs to the owner, and the owner has the right to use the land, enjoy it, dispose of it and possess it. That is not the same thing as an absolute right to do whatever the owner wants with it. Restrictions get placed on land by the government, by private companies and by individuals, in the form of ordinances, deed restrictions, covenants, rules and regulations. This chapter is about all of them, and it starts with the ones a private person writes. You met the deed restriction once already, as an encumbrance that sits on a title. Here you learn where it comes from, what makes it stick, and why it sometimes beats the zoning law.

Private land use controls are restrictions that individual owners and developers impose on their own real property. They can affect a single deed or an entire neighborhood. The thing to understand about them is that they often prohibit uses that zoning laws would permit. A developer puts a restriction on land saying only single-family homes may be built on it. The zoning in that area supports any type of residential use. The developer has still cut the land down to single-family homes, and the zoning ordinance does not rescue a buyer who wanted to build a duplex.

The more restrictive use prevails

When a deed restriction and a zoning law differ, the more restrictive use prevails. That sentence is worth more to you in the field than anything else on this screen. A buyer standing on a vacant lot with the town's zoning map in his hand has only read half the file. The other half is in the recorded documents, and it can be tighter than the map.

A restrictive covenant is the instrument that does this work. To prevent objectionable land use by new owners, a grantor puts restrictions on the grantee's title, in the deed itself or in a separate document. It is common practice when land is subdivided, and it is also created by express agreement between two parties who decide to bind their land that way.

Recording is what makes the covenant reach strangers. To make a restriction enforceable against third parties, it must be recorded. Once a covenant is in the recorded chain of title, future buyers take title subject to the restriction even if it is not stated in their own deed. An unrecorded side agreement between a seller and one neighbor binds those two people. It does not bind the next buyer down the street.

A covenant must touch and concern the land

A restrictive covenant runs with the land only if it touches and concerns the land. It has to relate to the use, the maintenance or the improvement of the real property. A covenant that prohibits a landowner from smoking cannot run with the land, because it restricts a person rather than a parcel. A covenant prohibiting smoking on the land does run with it, and is a valid restrictive covenant. One word moves it from unenforceable to enforceable, and the word is the one that ties the promise to the dirt.

Deed restrictions are simply restrictive covenants written into a deed that apply to all future landowners. They run with the land, which means they move with the title in every future conveyance, and writing one is part of the bundle of rights an owner holds.

Deed restrictions may or may not be conditional, and the difference decides who owns the property after a violation. Take a deed that says the grantee covenants never to tear down the barn on the property. That covenant does not make the title conditional. Even if the restriction is violated, the property remains the grantee's. It does not revert to the original owner and it does not go to anyone else. If the barn comes down, a court may order the grantee to rebuild it or to pay damages to the grantor, but the grantee will not lose title to the land.

Now add a condition. The deed says the grantee covenants never to tear down the barn on the property, and if he violates this promise, title to the property is revoked. The grantee razes the barn, and title reverts to the grantor. That is a deed restriction with a condition attached, and the estate it creates is also known as a qualified fee estate.

Hypothetical. You are showing a vacant lot in a fourteen-lot subdivision. The recorded declaration limits every lot to single-family homes. The town's zoning permits two-family dwellings. Your buyer wants the duplex and points at the zoning map. The declaration is the more restrictive of the two, so the declaration governs and the answer is a single-family home.

CAUTION: A covenant violated is not a title lost, unless the deed said so in words. Read the instrument before you answer. A plain covenant produces a lawsuit for damages or an order to rebuild. A covenant with a condition of revocation produces a reversion to the grantor. The exam separates these two with a single clause, and so does a real deed.

Zoning is a floor, not a ceiling

REMEMBER: Your seller's covenant bars anyone from smoking anywhere in the county. Does it touch and concern the land, and would it bind the buyer after closing?

Setbacks, Enforcement, and the Doctrine of Laches

A covenant nobody enforces is a covenant that dies

Subdivision regulations can be both private and public. Private subdivision regulations are the ones the owners in a subdivision hold over each other, and they exist so that property owners can maintain the quality and the consistency of the residences around them. They are restrictive covenants doing neighborhood work.

The most common one is the setback requirement. Setback requirements mean that improvements are located a specified distance between the front property line and the building line, as well as from the front, rear and side property lines. The distances are local. Every municipality and every recorded declaration sets its own numbers, so a setback figure you learned on one deal tells you nothing about the next one.

Nobody enforces a covenant for you

Setback requirements are covenants, and that single fact decides who enforces them. If a resident does not adhere to the setback requirements, property owners within the subdivision may take legal action. The neighbors bring it, out of their own pockets, on their own initiative. Private controls come with private enforcement, and where the people who hold the benefit do nothing, nothing happens.

That is where the doctrine of laches comes in. If property owners do not take legal action to enforce covenants, or do not take legal action in a timely manner, violators are not subject to a court's orders and the covenant is terminated. The doctrine of laches is the loss of legal rights because of a failure to assert those rights in a timely manner. In New York, property owners who wish to assert their rights have two years from the date the violation of the deed restriction occurred.

Two years from the date of the violation

Run the clock from the violation, not from the day somebody noticed it. A garage built four feet inside the required side setback three years ago is a violation the neighbors can no longer take to court. Nobody excused the garage. The right to enforce the covenant died, and a dead right does not come back because a new owner finds the garage offensive.

Covenants end in other ways too, and the list is short enough to carry.

Termination date

Release

Merger

Abandonment

Changed circumstances

A covenant can state when it ends, and on that date it ends. The owner can be released from it by the party who holds the benefit. The benefited and the burdened parcels can merge into one ownership, and a covenant cannot burden a parcel for the benefit of that same parcel. The property can be abandoned. Or the circumstances of the property or the owner can change enough that the covenant no longer does the job it was written to do.

One more ending happens without anybody doing anything. Restrictive covenants that become illegal after they were written terminate automatically. A deed restriction saying that people of certain religious beliefs or nationalities may not purchase land was legal and enforceable in the past. When the Civil Rights Act of 1968 was enacted, religion, national origin and ancestry became protected classes, and those restrictions became illegal and terminated on their own. You will still find the language sitting in old chains of title in New York. It is dead language, and you do not read it to a buyer as though it were a term of the sale.

CAUTION: Laches is the private-controls trap on the exam because students reach for a longer period out of habit. The number here is two years, it runs from the date of the violation, and it belongs to the restrictive covenant. Do not import a limitation period from some other part of the law into this question.

Use it in time or lose it

REMEMBER: A neighbor asks what she can do about a fence that crossed the building line four years ago. What do you tell her the doctrine of laches has already done?

Lesson 2

Public Controls and Government Powers

Police power, taxation, escheat, and eminent domain, plus the review that sits behind them

The Four Powers of Government

Police power, taxation, escheat, eminent domain

Public land use restrictions are the ones imposed by government at the local, state and federal level. Government has a much broader jurisdiction over land use than the private sector does, and everything it may do to your client's land fits into one of four powers. Learn the four as a set, because the exam tests them by asking you to name which one a fact pattern describes.

Police power is the constitutional power of state and local governments to enact and enforce laws that protect the public's health, safety, morals and general welfare. When the government restricts how land is used, that is police power at work. Every county in the state and every municipality in a county has its own land use regulations, so no list of them could ever be complete. Local regulations in New York run from zoning, mobile homes, site plans and subdivisions to cell towers and shoreline development ordinances. Zoning, which takes up most of this chapter, is police power.

Taxation is the result of the government's authority to pass revenue-generating laws, levying a charge on people or on items. In New York State, property taxes are local taxes, and the income is spent locally to finance the government and the public schools. Property taxes create a lien on real estate, and in New York, as in other states, real property taxes take priority over all other liens. What a landowner actually pays is set by two things: the property's taxable assessment, calculated by a local tax assessor, and the tax rate of the locality the land sits in.

Escheat is the state's answer to a parcel with nobody left to own it. When a person dies intestate, meaning without a will, and has no heirs and no creditors, title to the property reverts back to the state through the power of escheat. Escheat assures that land is not ownerless. No sheriff sells it, no neighbor claims it, and no county auctions it off. It goes to the state.

Eminent domain is the government's constitutional power to appropriate or condemn private property for public use, as long as the owner is paid just compensation. Eminent domain is the power. Condemnation is the actual act of taking the property for public use through that power. Students lose points on this pair every year by treating the two words as synonyms, and they are not. One is the authority. The other is the exercise of it.

In New York the condemning authorities include the state and its authorized agencies, municipalities, school districts, railroads, public utilities and the federal government. A railroad and a utility can condemn. That surprises people, and it is exactly the kind of item an exam writer likes.

Two conditions must be met before the government can exercise its power of eminent domain. The condemned property must be for the use and benefit of the public. And the property owner must be paid fair market value for the property lost. Those two travel together, and without both the government cannot exercise the power.

The offer is never the last word

If the property owner disagrees with the compensation offered, he has the right to a trial in which the court decides if the compensation is just. Say that sentence to a client the day an agency puts a number in front of him. The agency's figure is an opening position, and there is a court that will decide whether it was fair. A licensee who tells an owner the number is final and that no court will hear him has given advice the law flatly contradicts.

A taking is the last idea on this screen and it is the one that does not come with a check. A taking occurs when the government acquires private property for public use by appropriation, or burdens it with excessive regulation. The difference between a taking and eminent domain is that the property is regulated by a government authority to the economic detriment of the owner, without compensation. The owner keeps the title and receives nothing.

In 1992 the United States Supreme Court ruled that a taking is unconstitutional if it prohibits the building of any habitable or productive improvement on the owner's land and eliminates all economic benefits associated with the land. Regulation that leaves an owner some economic use is regulation. Regulation that leaves an owner nothing is the case the Court was describing.

NOTE: Three words, three meanings, and the exam will hand you all three in one question. Eminent domain is the power. Condemnation is the act of taking with compensation. A taking is regulation so heavy that the owner loses the economic value and gets nothing for it. Match the word to the fact, not to the sound of it.

Power, act, and the taking with no check

REMEMBER: A client's cousin died with no will, no heirs and no creditors. Which of the four powers decides what happens to the land, and who ends up holding title?

Federal and New York State Land Use Regulation

Two layers above the town line

Most land use regulation in New York is local, and the rest of this chapter is about local. Before that, two layers sit above the town line, and each of them can stop a project a town has already blessed. Federal controls come first.

FEDERAL CONTROLS

Federal and state land use controls are increasing as a means to protect the environment. The regulations involve blocking or restricting use of land where there are environmental concerns, and sometimes this conflicts with a landowner's proposed usage of the land. The government controls land use in protecting wildlife, endangered species and wetlands, and federal and state agencies may deem land a safe haven or a protected area that cannot be developed. The rules can be revised to permit uses perceived as beneficial. These policies stay controversial, because the benefits of preservation and conservation get weighed against the benefits of use, and reasonable people weigh them differently.

The Interstate Land Sales Full Disclosure Act protects consumers from fraud and abuse in the sale or lease of land. The Act is regulated through the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development, and it exists to prevent marketing schemes that entice consumers to purchase land sight unseen. Developers of subdivisions with 25 or more nonexempt lots must register with HUD and provide each purchaser with a disclosure statement known as a property report. The property report contains relevant information about the subdivision, and it must be delivered to each purchaser at least three days before a contract is signed. If the purchaser does not receive the report, he has two years to cancel the sale.

25 or more nonexempt lots triggers HUD

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is a division of the U.S. Army made up of civilian and military members. It influences land use through its authority to permit or deny a number of water-related projects, and it provides engineering services by planning, designing, building and operating water resources and other civil works projects, by designing and managing the construction of military facilities, and by providing design and construction management support for other defense and federal agencies. On a waterfront parcel the Corps is a name that comes up early, and a permit it declines is a project that does not happen.

NEW YORK STATE

New York uses several laws, ordinances and acts to regulate land use. Four names from the state level are worth knowing: two agencies and two statutes.

The Field Services Bureau of the New York Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation oversees public recreation areas and administers federal and state preservation projects. Because New York, like most states, keeps a state register of historic places, the state receives federal grants for historic preservation. The Field Services Bureau also oversees the Certified Local Program, a nationwide program that supports local preservation and is the link between local communities and state and federal programs. When a building or a district carries a historic designation, this is the office behind it, and the designation changes what an owner may do to the property.

Article 9-A of the New York State Real Property Law requires subdividers to file with the Department of State before offering to sell or lease subdivided vacant lands to New York State residents on an installment plan. The filing consists of a filing statement, an offering statement and a filing fee.

Article 9-A has two limits and both of them matter in practice. It applies only to vacant land sold on an installment plan. If the offering consists of lots on which homes exist, no filing is necessary. And deed and mortgage transactions that require a down payment are not included in the Article. Because of those two caveats, most real estate offerings in New York are not required to be filed with the Department of State. Knowing when the filing is required is the point. A developer selling forty vacant lots to New York residents on an installment plan is squarely inside Article 9-A, and a licensee who waves that off has walked his client into a filing violation.

The State Environmental Quality Review Act requires a state environmental quality review to assess the environmental impact of any activity or action approved by a state agency or a unit of local government. The review requires the government entity that sponsored or approved the activity not only to identify its significant environmental impact, but to mitigate it. Identifying the problem is half the obligation. Fixing it is the other half.

If a proposed action may significantly impact the environment, an environmental impact statement is necessary. The environmental impact statement is the process that describes and analyzes the proposed action, and it is the document a development stands or falls on.

The lead agency runs the review

If multiple agencies are involved, a lead agency oversees the entire evaluation process. The lead agency makes the final decision about whether an environmental impact statement is required and files the statement. One agency leads. The others participate. Which agency filed first has nothing to do with it, and neither does which agency a developer would prefer.

New York names the factors it counts as adverse to the environment. A substantial change in air quality, in ground or surface water quality or quantity, in traffic, or in noise levels. A significant increase in solid waste production, or the potential for erosion, flooding, leaching or drainage problems. Removal or destruction of vegetation or fauna. And impairment of the character or quality of historical, archeological, architectural or aesthetic resources, or of existing communities or neighborhoods. Environmental concerns reach land use policy at all three levels of government, because agencies at all three levels approve projects with potential environmental risk.

NOTE: This chapter covers environmental review, meaning the process by which a project gets approved or stopped. The environmental hazards themselves, and what you must disclose about them, are the subject of the construction and environmental chapter. Keep the two apart in your head. Review is about permission. Disclosure is about what you tell a buyer.

The New York State Department of Transportation is responsible for building and maintaining state-owned roadways, bridges and overpasses. Streets and roads provide access to residential, commercial and public places, so the state regulates land use in these cases to benefit the community as a whole. State-owned roads in New York City are the exception, because New York City has its own department of transportation.

Federal, then state, then the town

REMEMBER: A town's environmental review pulls in three separate agencies. Which one decides whether an environmental impact statement is required, and which one files it?

Municipal Planning Boards

What a planning board is responsible for

City planning is essential for city growth, and thoughtful, deliberate planning is what allows expansion to be consistent and balanced. Nearly every municipality in New York has a planning board that holds public hearings, investigates solutions for the planning issues at hand, and makes recommendations to the appropriate legislative authority. The board recommends. The legislature enacts.

A planning board's responsibilities reach almost everything that affects how a community grows. There are six of them.

Creating a capital budget. Like any household or business, a city has to determine what money is coming in and what money is going out. Planning boards include in the master plan what money they expect to take in over the long term and how, whether through taxes or other means, so that projects short and long term can be planned and financed.

Developing and controlling the comprehensive plan. A comprehensive plan, also called a master plan, is a written document that identifies the goals, objectives, principles, guidelines, policies, standards and strategies for the growth and development of a community. The planning board creates the plan in association with other government agencies and community leaders, and maintains it. Maintaining it means revising it for budgetary concerns, new land use regulations, new environmental concerns and whatever else is unique to that community.

Regulating plat, density, street and traffic patterns. The board regulates how the land is laid out and how people and cars will move through it once it is built.

Controlling subdivision development. Deciding how land may be divided, and what may be built on the pieces.

Reviewing site plans. Local planning boards review site plans to evaluate the effects a development may have on the community.

Taking specific zoning actions. Requests run from minor variances for single-family homes to site plans for major development projects, and the board assesses each one against the county's comprehensive plan and against how the request will affect streets, roads, traffic, parks, services and the overall well-being of the community and its residents.

The official map is final and conclusive

The planning board is also responsible for the community's official map, and the official map goes hand in hand with the comprehensive plan. The official map is final and conclusive with respect to the location and width of the community's streets, highways, drainage systems and parks. Final and conclusive is strong language and it is meant to be. An owner who believes a street runs somewhere other than where the official map puts it is arguing with the record.

One more rule governs how all of this happens in public. City councils, town boards, village boards of trustees, school boards, commissions, legislative bodies and subcommittees all fall within the framework of the Open Meetings Law, known as the Sunshine Law, which went into effect in New York in 1977. The law gives the public the right to attend meetings of public bodies, and it requires that prior notice be given of the time and place of those meetings.

NOTE: The Sunshine Law is a working tool, not trivia. A client worried about what is going up behind his lot can sit in the room where it is decided, and you can tell him when and where. That is a real answer to a question agents usually answer with a shrug.

The board recommends; the legislature enacts

REMEMBER: Name the document that is final and conclusive on where a street runs, and name the board responsible for it.

Subdivision Regulations, Plats, and Site Plans

From families per acre to a recorded map at the county clerk

When a subdivision is planned for a community, one of the first things determined is its density. Density is the number of families that can inhabit a plot of land. Planning boards regulate density to avoid overcrowding in residential areas, and they do it by placing minimums on the lot size, the setback and the boundary requirements, and on the size of the dwellings on the land. Every one of those minimums is a local number set by a local board.

Subdivision regulations are state and local laws regulating how land may be subdivided. They may govern the size of the lots in a subdivision, the location of streets and sidewalks, and sewer and water lines. Open spaces and recreational areas may also be required through subdivision regulations.

A local government enforces subdivision regulations by requiring developers to submit a plat for approval. A plat depicts the arrangement of buildings, roads and other services for a development. Plats get used in determining traffic patterns, because they illustrate the primary roads, the through streets and the cul-de-sacs, which are dead-end streets that do not connect to main roads.

Approval comes first, recording second

After a plat has been approved, it may be recorded in the county in which the land is located. The order there is the whole rule. Approval first, recording second. A plat that has not been approved is a drawing.

Before the board grants or denies the proposal it researches the impact the development will have, and the first step is a demographics study. Demography is the study of the social and economic status of a given area or population, and it tells planners whether the community can support new development. To study it, planners rely on census tracts, which are relatively small areas used by the U.S. Census Bureau to track the population of the United States.

The demographic study matters because it reveals whether the city's infrastructure can sustain the added burden of a new development and all the people it will bring. Infrastructure is the support facilities and services of a community: roads, parks, sewers, water, schools, and police and fire protection. A development the roads and the schools cannot carry is a development the board will take a hard look at.

Site plans are an integral part of any new development. Developers create site plans for commercial and residential projects, and the site plan includes everything that must be considered before work can begin. In New York, local planning boards review site plans in order to evaluate the effects the development may have on the community.

When developers create a site plan they consider the topography of the parcel, which is its physical characteristics. Topography takes in water sources, native vegetation, the location of trees and rocks, soil type and floodplains. All of it affects how and where buildings and utilities will be situated. The site plan also accounts for environmental issues, the types of structures to be built, the configuration of streets and sidewalks, the zoning in surrounding areas, and what utilities are available.

Finally, a survey is included in the site plan. A survey locates and measures the boundaries of a property and identifies the improvements, encroachments and easements associated with the land.

One federal standard rides along with all of this. Federal Housing Administration approval is an important component of subdivision regulation, though it is not the planning board's responsibility. The FHA has minimum building standards for properties with FHA-approved mortgages, and for homes built in a subdivision with FHA financing, developers must follow the FHA's regulations and guidelines as well as the municipality's.

NOTE: Density, lot size, setback and dwelling size are all local numbers. No figure you memorize will be right in the next town. What travels from town to town is the sequence: density, regulations, plat, impact study, approval, recording.

Density, plat, study, approval, record

REMEMBER: A developer hands you an unapproved plat and asks whether he can record it at the county clerk. What is your answer, and what has to happen first?

Lesson 3

Zoning

A map that divides the community, and a text that says what may happen on each piece

Zoning Ordinances and the Zoning Map

A map that draws the districts and a text that says what may happen in each

Cities, counties, subdivisions and even streets are typically divided into distinct zoning classifications. The kinds of activities permitted in different zones are regulated to protect the public. Zoning ordinances are local laws that divide a city or county into different areas, or zones. They set forth the type of use permitted under each zoning classification and specify the requirements for compliance.

Once the planning board creates a plan, members begin establishing zoning ordinances accordingly, and every zoning ordinance has two parts. The first part is a zoning map that divides the community into designated districts. The second part is the text of the zoning ordinance, which sets forth the type of use permitted in each zone, including the specific requirements for compliance. The map draws the line. The text says what may happen on each side of it.

Residential

Commercial

Industrial

Open space or park

Those labels are what a zoning map shows you, and they are only the headline. The text is where the work is. Each zone generally sets a minimum lot size, a building height limit, setback and side yard rules governing the position of a building, and it may even limit how much of a lot a building can cover. Zoning laws are also likely to set rules for off-street parking, landscaping, outdoor lighting and other items.

Every one of those numbers is local. A minimum lot size in one town is not the minimum lot size in the next town, and a height limit that applies on one side of a district boundary may not apply on the other. When a client asks you how high he can build, the honest answer names the district and sends him to the ordinance, and it is a better answer than a number you half remember.

Hypothetical. A buyer asks you whether she can put a two-chair hair salon in the front room of a house she is considering. You look at the zoning map and the parcel is inside an R-2 district. The map has told you which district the property is in and nothing more. Whether a salon may operate there is a question for the text of the ordinance, and the text may permit it outright, permit it with a special use permit, or forbid it. The map is an index. The text is the law.

Who writes zoning

New York State has some responsibility for determining zoning, mainly for public lands and open spaces. In other areas zoning is the responsibility of local governments, and that responsibility encompasses everything from subdivision development and building codes to budgeting and site plan review. Zoning is a local subject with a state edge on it.

County review is not optional. According to New York State law, municipalities are required to refer certain planning and zoning actions to their respective county planning boards for review. When a municipality wishes to add or change zoning in a particular area, planning boards, along with planning department staff, review the request and prepare a recommendation letter in response. The referral is a second set of eyes on a local decision, and it is one reason a zoning change takes longer than a client expects.

A zoning law is constitutional only if it applies in the same manner to all similarly situated property owners. That principle has a name, as of right zoning, and it is the rule that keeps a zoning ordinance from becoming a favor. If one landowner is permitted by the ordinance to build a fence on his land, all landowners in that zone are permitted to do the same. Equal application is what makes the law a law.

Which brings up the abuse of it. Spot zoning is the rezoning of a single parcel or a small area to benefit one or more property owners rather than carry out the objectives of the master plan. It is illegal, and it is illegal for the reason you would expect: the law is not being applied the same way to all landowners. A single lot in the middle of an established residential district, rezoned to commercial so one owner can put up a drive-through, is the textbook picture of it. The Types of Zoning screen, two screens on, puts spot zoning next to the legitimate types of zoning it imitates.

CAUTION: A zoning question that begins with one owner and one parcel is asking you about spot zoning or about a variance, and the two have different answers. Rezoning changes the law. A variance excuses one parcel from a law that stays in force. Read the fact pattern for which one actually happened.

Map draws the line; text sets the rule

REMEMBER: Name the two parts of a zoning ordinance, then say which part tells you whether a restaurant may open on a given lot.

Zoning Classifications

Typical New York districts, each with subcategories of its own

Typical New York zoning classifications include residential, commercial, industrial, institutional, agricultural, public open space, parkland, recreational and vacant land. Each classification also has numerous subcategories, which is why a map says R-1 and R-2 rather than just residential. Learn the nine headline classifications, because the exam asks you to sort a use into one, and because a listing description that names the wrong one is a statement a buyer may rely on.

Residential zones are for residences and not commercial buildings, and they consist of single-family as well as multi-family dwellings. Even so, accessory uses are common in residential areas. An accessory use is a use or occupancy incidental or subordinate to the principal use or occupancy of a property. A home occupation, in which a small business or other occupation is carried out in the residence, is an accessory use. So is an accessory apartment, which is an apartment within a primary residence.

Commercial zoning covers hotels, retail shops, restaurants, malls, salons and a host of other business entities. Industrial zoning covers manufacturing facilities, and it covers them whether the facility actually manufactures the goods or merely stores them. Institutional zoning includes schools, college campuses, hospitals, correctional facilities and courthouses, and institutions may appear in residential or commercial zones depending on the local ordinance. Agricultural zoning is for areas where animals may graze and crops may be grown.

Public open space is land intentionally left undeveloped. Forests, public parks, lakes, bays and shorelines are examples, and public open space can be owned either privately or publicly. Parklands differ slightly, in that they are used specifically for recreational activities and maintained for their ecological, aesthetic and educational value, and local, state and federal authorities can all exercise power over parkland. Recreational areas in New York are owned primarily by municipalities and private citizens, and the Department of Environmental Conservation and the Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation classify them as greenways, parks, public fishing areas, shorelines, trailways and waterway access.

Vacant land is unimproved land, or land with no buildings on it. Land that does have a building on it is not necessarily occupied, and it may still be considered vacant if that building or improvement does not serve a purpose. A falling-down shed on five acres does not take the parcel out of the vacant land classification, and that matters for a marketing description as much as for a filing.

Accessory uses are where most residential clients actually live inside this material. A home occupation and an accessory apartment are both incidental to the principal use of the house, which is why neither one turns a residence into a commercial building or a two-family. Where a local ordinance limits the size of a home occupation, the number of employees, or the signage it may display, those limits are local and written into the ordinance. Read them before you tell a buyer she can run her business out of the front room.

Group homes in a residential zone

A group home is a residential facility in a residential zone for three or more unrelated people. Group homes serve the special needs of a group, usually the physically or mentally disabled, or those recovering from an affliction or dependency. Foster homes, rehabilitation centers and halfway houses are all examples.

Because of the nature of group homes there is controversy over whether they should be allowed in residential zones. The Fair Housing Act settles the part of the argument that matters, because it makes it illegal to deny a permit for a home because of the disability of individuals who live or would live there. A neighbor's objection to a group home is not a zoning objection when the objection is to the residents. That distinction will reach you in the field before it reaches you on an exam.

Residents in residential areas often declare that only families can reside in residential dwellings, which raises the question of what a family legally is. Under New York State law, a family can be an individual, or two or more people related by blood, marriage or adoption living together in one dwelling. It can be a group of up to three people who are not married, not blood relatives and not adopted, who live together as a single unit. Or it can be one or more people living in a single unit, as distinguished from a group occupying a hotel, a club, or a fraternity or sorority house.

CAUTION: The two numbers on this screen look alike and mean opposite things. Three or more unrelated people is the definition of a group home. Up to three unrelated people living as a single unit is one of the definitions of a family. Read which way the question is counting before you answer it.

Nine classifications, each with subcategories

REMEMBER: A client runs a bookkeeping practice out of the spare bedroom of her house in an R-1 district. What is that called, and why does it not need a different zone?

Types of Zoning

Classifications say what a zone is for; types say how the rule is applied

Just as there are several classifications of zoning, there are several types of zoning. Some types are specific to a classification and others apply across the board. A classification tells you what a district is for. A type tells you how the ordinance is being applied to the land inside it.

As of right zoning is implied in the bundle of rights that comes with ownership, and it prohibits discrimination among landowners in a particular zone. If one landowner is permitted, through zoning ordinances, to build a fence on his land, all landowners in that zone are permitted to do the same. This is the baseline. Every other type on this screen is a departure from it, and each departure has to justify itself.

Cluster zoning allows developers to provide a varied selection of lot sizes and housing choices within a single area. A common element in areas with cluster zoning is the incorporation of green spaces, or open spaces, to add to the development's beauty and for the entire community's enjoyment. The zone may consist of abutting properties, which are directly contiguous parcels sharing at least one common boundary.

Cluster zoning may also take the form of a planned unit development. A planned unit development is a special type of subdivision in which developers do not have to comply with all standard zoning and subdivision regulations. Nonresidential and residential buildings may be combined in the overall plan. And because the developer does not have to follow setback and lot size rules, buildings may be closer together, which is what creates the large open spaces for public use and enjoyment. The buildings move in so that the land can open up. That trade is the whole idea of a planned unit development.

Incentive zoning is a system by which developers receive zoning incentives on the condition that specific physical, social or cultural benefits are provided to the community. Common incentives are increases in the permissible number of residential units or in the gross square footage of the development, and waivers of the height, setback and use provisions of current zoning ordinances. What the community gets in exchange is affordable housing, recreational facilities, open space, day-care facilities and infrastructure. Incentive zoning is a bargain struck in the open, and it is legal precisely because the community is paid for what it gives up.

Spot zoning is illegal

Spot zoning is the illegal rezoning of a single parcel or a small area to benefit one or more property owners rather than carry out the objectives of the master plan. Rezoning itself is a revision in zoning law, usually changing a zone from one type to another. When rezoning occurs the zoning law is actually changed. Rezoning is not a variance and it is not an exception. Spot zoning is a perfect example of how the rezoning process can be abused, and isolated zoning changes can be illegal because the law is not applied the same way to all landowners.

Set incentive zoning next to spot zoning and the line is clear. Incentive zoning relaxes a rule for a developer and the community is compensated in housing, open space or infrastructure. Spot zoning relaxes a rule for an owner and nobody is compensated for anything. One carries out the master plan. The other quietly abandons it for one parcel.

A transfer of development rights is the last type and it works differently from the rest. Development rights go hand in hand with zoning, because a landowner buys land to develop it and the ability to develop is tied directly to the zoning ordinance. Owners of historic buildings and properties often cannot exercise their development rights, because the properties must be preserved. That does not mean the right to develop is lost. A transfer of development rights occurs when a developer buys the development rights from a property owner who cannot use them. The owner of a home listed on the National Register of Historic Places has development rights even if she never intends to use them, and she can sell those rights to a developer or another individual.

NOTE: Sort these by who is asking and what changes. As of right, nothing changes and nobody asks. Cluster and planned unit development change the layout with the board's blessing. Incentive trades relief for a community benefit. Spot zoning changes the law for one owner and is illegal. A transfer of development rights moves a right from one parcel to another without changing any law at all.

Rezoning changes the law itself

REMEMBER: A town board changes one lot in the middle of an R-1 district to commercial for a single owner. Name what that is, and say in one sentence why it is illegal.

The Zoning Board of Appeals

Who grants relief, who changes the law, and who reviews them both

New York State statutes require that a zoning board of appeals be formed when a local legislature adopts its zoning law. The board must consist of three to five members. The zoning board of appeals does not make policy and does not write the zoning law. It applies the law the legislature wrote, to parcels, one at a time.

The essential functions of the zoning board of appeals are twofold. It grants variances, and it interprets ordinances. In both capacities it protects landowners from the unfair application of the laws in particular circumstances. The board also hears appeals from the decisions of the zoning enforcement officer or the building inspector when interpretations of the zoning ordinance are involved. An owner denied a permit by a building inspector who read the ordinance one way has somewhere to take that reading, and this board is it.

Conditional or special uses are allowed in certain zoning districts, but only upon issuance of a special use permit, subject to conditions designed to protect surrounding properties and the community from a possible negative impact resulting from the permit. A special use permit works differently from a variance. The use is already allowed in that district, and the permit attaches conditions to it so the neighbors are protected. A hospital in a residential neighborhood is the standard picture of a conditional use.

Hold that difference, because it decides which application your client files. A variance asks the board to excuse a parcel from a rule that forbids what the owner wants. A special use permit asks the board to approve something the ordinance already contemplates in that district, on terms. One is relief from the ordinance. The other is compliance with it. Filing for the wrong one costs a client months.

Occasionally planning boards impose a moratorium, which temporarily suspends the right of property owners to obtain development approvals while the local legislature takes time to consider, draft and adopt land use regulations or rules to respond to new or changing circumstances its current laws do not deal with adequately. Moratoriums get imposed when a comprehensive plan or zoning law is being established, and when the municipality cannot provide the services necessary to support a proposed action. When a moratorium is imposed the municipality is exercising its police power, and moratoriums can be used only to protect the public's welfare.

FOUR DEVICES AND WHO DECIDES

Four devices change what may happen on a parcel, and the exam tests them by asking who decides. Rezoning revises the zoning law itself, usually changing a zone from one type to another, and the local legislature does it. A variance is administrative relief allowing property to be used in a way that does not comply with the literal requirements of the ordinance, and the zoning board of appeals grants it. A special use permit allows a conditional use in a district where it is already allowed, subject to protective conditions, and the zoning board of appeals issues it. And an Article 78 proceeding lets an aggrieved person challenge the board's determination, and the state courts hear it.

The legislature changes the law; the board excuses a parcel

A zoning board's determinations can be challenged in state courts through Article 78 proceedings. An Article 78 proceeding refers to an article of the New York Civil Practice Law and Rules that allows aggrieved persons to bring an action against a government body or officer, or in the case of zoning disputes, against a municipality's zoning board of appeals. The device allows review of state and local administrative proceedings in court. It is the same Article 78 route used to appeal a determination of the Department of State, and it is worth noticing that the two live in the same place.

New York City is the exception to the structure on this screen. In New York City the planning board and the zoning board are one entity, known as the Board of Standards and Appeals. It consists of 12 members and one chairperson, and there is no separate board of appeals. A licensee who works across the city line works in front of two different structures, and the exam asks about the difference.

NOTE: Who decides is the whole question. If a fact pattern has a town board voting, you are looking at rezoning and at a change in the law. If it has a board hearing one owner's application, you are looking at a variance or a special use permit, and the law has not changed at all. If it has somebody unhappy with the board's decision, you are looking at Article 78.

Three to five members, two functions

REMEMBER: Your client lost at the zoning board of appeals. Name his next step, name the court that hears it, and name the law it comes from.

Nonconforming Uses and Variances

One is lawful because it came first; the other is permission to depart from a rule already in force

To prevent undue hardships, zoning laws usually provide for limited exceptions. Two of them sit on this screen, and students mix them up every year.

A nonconforming use occurs when a land use does not conform to current zoning laws, but is legally allowed because the land use was established before the new zoning laws were enacted. The use was lawful the day it started, and it stayed lawful when the ordinance changed around it. A nonconforming use is not a variance, because nobody gave permission. It is not a violation, because the use broke no law when it began.

It came first, so it stays

Most nonconforming uses are allowed to continue but may not be expanded or enlarged. A corner grocery that has stood since 1968 in what is now a residential district may keep selling groceries. It may not double its footprint next spring.

Permission to continue a nonconforming use is not tied to the landowner. If the property is sold, the new owner may continue the nonconforming use. Some localities have zoning laws that automatically terminate the right if the use is discontinued for a certain amount of time, usually one year, so check the local ordinance before you promise a buyer that a long-empty store may reopen.

A variance is the other exception. A variance is a form of administrative relief that allows property to be used in a way that does not comply with the literal requirements of the zoning ordinance. The zoning board of appeals grants it on an application. There are two types, and state law gives each its own test: Town Law §267-b, Village Law §7-712-b and General City Law §81-b.

THE USE VARIANCE: UNNECESSARY HARDSHIP

A use variance allows a use the zoning does not permit, such as a commercial use in a residential zone, and it is granted only when the current zoning ordinance causes the landowner an unnecessary hardship. To prove unnecessary hardship, owners must establish that the requested variance meets four statutorily prescribed conditions. The landowner is deprived of all economic use or benefit of the property, and can provide financial evidence to that effect. The landowner did not create the hardship. The hardship is not common to the area or neighborhood. And the variance will not change the nature and quality of the neighborhood.

The owner must prove all four, and that is why a use variance is hard to get.

THE AREA VARIANCE: PRACTICAL DIFFICULTY

Area variances entitle landowners to use land in a way that is not allowed by the dimensional or physical requirements of the zoning law, such as the setback, height, lot or area requirements. The statute writes this test as a balance. The board weighs the benefit to the applicant against the detriment to the health, safety and welfare of the neighborhood or community. Then it considers five things. Whether the variance will produce an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties. Whether the applicant can achieve the benefit by some other feasible method. Whether the variance is substantial. Whether it will have an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or district. And whether the alleged difficulty was self-created, which is relevant to the board's decision but does not necessarily preclude granting the area variance.

A use variance is four conditions the owner must prove. An area variance is a balance of five considerations, and no single one decides it.

CAUTION: Self-created hardship is the trap on this screen. On a use variance it is a bar, and an owner who created his own hardship does not get the variance. On an area variance it is one factor the board weighs, and it does not necessarily preclude the grant. An owner who built a deck two feet into the side setback created his own difficulty, and the board may still grant him the area variance.

Nonconforming came first; a variance after

REMEMBER: Two owners each created their own problem. One wants a shop in a residential zone. The other built a porch into the front setback. Which one does self-creation stop, and which one does it only count against?

Lesson 4

Enforcement

Codes, permits, inspectors, and the certificate that says a building may be lived in

Building Codes and the Certificate of Occupancy

Codes are set locally and permits are issued by local government

Zoning says what may be built on a parcel. Building codes say how it has to be built, and the permit is the instrument that enforces both. Several codes, departments and individuals enforce land use regulations within a community, a municipality, a city and a state, and this screen is about all of them.

Building codes protect the public by setting minimum standards and requiring builders to adhere to certain construction standards, including particular methods and materials, sanitary equipment, electrical wiring and fire prevention standards. Landowners must obtain building permits before constructing or renovating residential or commercial property. The permit application is the checkpoint, where a project meets the zoning ordinance, the code and the inspector at once.

The sequence runs the same way in every municipality. An owner who wants to build or remodel a building submits plans to the local building department for approval. A building permit is issued only if the plans comply with the codes. Local inspectors, who can stop work if necessary, inspect the project several times throughout the construction process. Once construction is complete a final inspection is conducted, and if deficiencies are found, no certificate of occupancy will be issued until the landowner and the contractor correct the problems and another inspection takes place.

A certificate of occupancy is a permit issued to the builder after all inspections have been made and the property is deemed fit for occupancy. A certificate of compliance is issued for an altered building. Your client cannot move into a new building without the first one, and a closing can hang on it for weeks.

Permit, inspections, certificate

Building codes are established locally and permits are issued through local government authorities. New York State adopted the International Building Code in July 2003, and it applies to all construction when no local code exists, or when local codes are less restrictive.

International Building Code, adopted by New York in 2003; the current NYS Uniform Code (2020 edition) is based on the 2018 International Codes

That edition line is worth reading twice, because code editions move. What does not move is the relationship between the state code and the local one.

The New York State Uniform Fire Prevention and Building Code sets forth the construction, materials, safety and sanitary standards for buildings in New York, as well as standards for the condition, occupancy, maintenance, rehabilitation and renewal of existing buildings. The code provides minimum standards for all types of buildings, residential and commercial, new and existing. If a local code is more stringent than the state code, the local code applies. If there is no local code, the State of New York code applies.

The state code is a floor, not a ceiling. Stricter local rules win, and a licensee who quotes the state standard in a town with a tougher one has given an answer that is wrong in the only place it matters.

A city or municipality's building department protects residents by seeing that code restrictions are followed and that construction and renovations are performed by licensed professionals. Building departments also oversee code enforcement, and investigators, code enforcement officers and inspectors all work to protect the public's safety and welfare. Other agencies do the same work from a different direction. The New York State Department of Health is not associated with the building department, but it can also inspect and investigate building code violations that ultimately affect the health and safety of the community.

Land use regulations, zoning ordinances and building codes could not be applied or enforced without hundreds of individuals representing both public and private interests. Architects, urban designers, project managers, surveyors, engineers and planners are all directly involved.

The courts are the last piece. In New York State the courts have the responsibility of controlling local land use decisions, and when those decisions are challenged, the courts typically uphold what was decided at the local level. That is the practical answer to a client who wants to fight the town. It can be done, and Article 78 is how, but the odds sit with the municipality.

NOTE: This chapter covers codes as enforcement of land use. The construction chapter covers what the codes actually require: framing, systems, materials, and the inspections that check them. If a question is about who enforces and in what order, it belongs here.

Stricter local code always wins

REMEMBER: Your buyer's new construction has failed its final inspection. What document is he not getting, what has to happen before he does, and who issues it?

Chapter 8 Key Takeaways

Nine things to carry out of land use regulations

Private controls. Owners and developers restrict their own land, and those restrictions often prohibit what zoning would allow. A restrictive covenant must be recorded to bind third parties, and it must touch and concern the land to run with it. Where a deed restriction and a zoning law differ, the more restrictive use prevails. Break a deed restriction without a condition and the result is damages or an order to rebuild. A deed restriction with a condition creates a qualified fee estate, and breaking it sends title back to the grantor.

Ending a covenant. Termination date, release, merger, abandonment, changed circumstances. A covenant that becomes illegal after it was written terminates automatically, which is what happened to the religious and national-origin restrictions still sitting in old chains of title. And a covenant nobody enforces dies of the doctrine of laches, which in New York gives an owner two years from the date the violation occurred.

Four government powers. Police power protects health, safety, morals and general welfare, and zoning is police power. Taxation creates a lien that outranks all other liens in New York. Escheat returns intestate, heirless, creditor-free land to the state. Eminent domain takes property for public use with just compensation.

Condemnation and takings. Eminent domain is the power; condemnation is the act. Two conditions have to be met: the property is for the use and benefit of the public, and the owner is paid fair market value. An owner who disagrees with the offer has the right to a trial in which the court decides whether the compensation is just. A taking is different, because there the government regulates to the owner's economic detriment and pays nothing.

Above the town line. The Interstate Land Sales Full Disclosure Act reaches developers of subdivisions with 25 or more nonexempt lots, who register with HUD and deliver a property report at least three days before contract. Real Property Law Article 9-A requires subdividers to file with the Department of State before selling vacant land to New York residents on an installment plan. And the State Environmental Quality Review Act requires the sponsoring entity to identify and mitigate significant impact, with an environmental impact statement where the action may significantly affect the environment, and a lead agency in charge when multiple agencies are involved.

Planning and subdivision. Planning boards create a capital budget, control the comprehensive plan and the official map, regulate plat, density, street and traffic patterns, control subdivision development, review site plans and take specific zoning actions. A plat is recorded only after it has been approved. The official map is final and conclusive on streets, highways, drainage systems and parks.

Zoning. Two parts: a map dividing the community into districts, and a text of permitted uses and compliance requirements. Nine classifications, from residential through vacant land. As of right gives every owner in a zone the same rights. Cluster varies lot sizes around open space and can take the form of a planned unit development. Incentive trades relief for a community benefit. Spot zoning is illegal. A transfer of development rights sells a right the owner cannot use.

Exceptions and enforcement. A nonconforming use pre-dates the ordinance, may continue but may not be expanded, and runs with the property rather than the owner, though a locality may end it after a period of discontinuance, usually a year. A variance is relief granted afterward by the zoning board of appeals, on the unnecessary hardship test for a use variance and the practical difficulty test for an area variance. Self-creation bars a use variance. On an area variance it is weighed, and it does not necessarily preclude the grant. A special use permit is neither one, because the use is already allowed and the permit only attaches conditions. Building codes end in a certificate of occupancy, and the stricter local code always wins.

Who decides. Sort every land use question in this chapter by that one word and most of it falls into place. A private covenant is enforced by the private parties who hold the benefit, the neighbors or the grantor, and by no public office. Rezoning is done by the local legislature, and it changes the law. A variance and a special use permit come from the zoning board of appeals, and they leave the law standing. A subdivision plat and a site plan go to the planning board. An environmental review belongs to the lead agency. And a person unhappy with any zoning board determination goes to state court under Article 78.

Ask who wrote the rule and who may excuse it

REMEMBER: Which of these nine could you not explain to a buyer standing on a vacant lot right now? Go back to that screen before you take the quiz.

YOU BE THE JUDGE

The Cedar Ridge Overreach

This is the graded issue-spotting activity for the chapter, and it is harder than the quiz, because nothing in the story is labeled. Read it once straight through for the shape of it. Then read it again slowly, marking every sentence where Victor says something, does something, or fails to do something. Marking is all you do on the second pass. Judgment comes after.

Victor Aldana has the listing on fourteen vacant lots at Cedar Ridge. The recorded declaration restricts every lot to single-family homes, but the town's zoning permits two-family dwellings, so Victor tells his buyer, “Zoning is the law, build the duplex, the covenant is just paperwork.” To a second buyer he explains that the seller's covenant barring the owner from smoking anywhere in the county “touches and concerns the land, so of course it runs with it.” He then has a seller sign a side agreement creating a brand-new restriction on lot 9, never records it, and assures the neighbours it binds every owner up and down the street.

Reviewing a fourth deed, Victor tells the grantee that a plain covenant never to tear down the barn, no condition attached, means title snaps back to the grantor the day the bulldozer arrives. Down the road a Cedar Ridge homeowner complains that his neighbour's garage was built four feet inside the required side setback three years ago. “Relax,” Victor says, “you've got ten years in New York to bring that one.”

The state's transportation agency has offered another client $48,000 for a strip taken for a highway ramp. Victor tells the client the number is final and that there is no court anywhere he can argue it. When a third client asks what became of a cousin who died with no will, no heirs, and no creditors, Victor answers that the county sheriff auctions the land off to the highest bidder. Meanwhile his developer client, Halstead Homes, plans to sell forty of the Cedar Ridge lots, all still vacant, to New York residents on an installment plan. Asked whether anything must be filed, Victor says the Department of State “only cares about co-ops,” and adds that HUD registration does not kick in until a hundred lots.

The town's environmental review turns out to involve three separate agencies. Victor tells Halstead that whichever agency files its paperwork first is the one that controls. He then arranges for the town board to rezone one client's single lot in the middle of an established R-1 district to general commercial so a drive-through can go up on it, “one parcel, one favor, nobody else is affected.” Two blocks away sits a corner grocery that has stood since 1968, years before the district was rezoned residential. Victor tells the grocery's buyer two things: that he may double the store's footprint next spring, and that because permission to continue the use is not tied to the landowner, the store may keep operating after he takes title.

Twelve violations are buried in that story, and one lawful act is planted in it to catch you out. Find the acts first, then name the rule each one breaks. In that order, because a rule recited with no fact attached to it is not an issue you spotted. It is a rule you remembered.

Twelve violations, one lawful act

A method that works on a fact pattern this dense. Take one paragraph at a time and ask three questions of it. Who acted. What exactly did they say or do or fail to do. Which rule from this chapter is that. If you cannot name the rule, you have found something that bothers you rather than something you can prove.

The first paragraph is entirely about private land use controls, and it holds three items. One turns on what happens when a recorded declaration and a zoning ordinance say different things. One turns on whether a promise touches and concerns the land, and the fix is a single word in the sentence Victor uses. One turns on what an unrecorded instrument can and cannot do to people who never signed it. Work all three against the first screen of this chapter.

The second paragraph holds two items and both are about consequences. The first is the difference between a covenant with a condition attached and a covenant without one, and the question to ask is what actually happens to title when a plain covenant is broken. The second is a number. Victor gives a period for bringing an action on a setback violation, and New York's doctrine of laches gives a different one. Say New York's number out loud before you check.

The third paragraph moves to public power and filings, and it carries four items. One is about whether a condemnation offer is ever final, and the answer is a right the owner has that Victor denies him. One is about what happens to land when a person dies with no will, no heirs and no creditors, and Victor names the wrong authority entirely. Two are filing questions: one about a New York statute that reaches vacant land sold on an installment plan, and one about a federal act with a lot count in it. Victor gets the New York statute's subject wrong and the federal act's number wrong, and each error is its own item.

The fourth paragraph carries three items. One is about which agency controls an environmental review when three agencies are involved, and the answer has nothing to do with who filed first. One is a town board rezoning a single parcel in the middle of an established district for one owner's benefit, and the name for it is a word from this chapter. And one is about a store that opened lawfully in 1968 before the district was rezoned. Victor tells the buyer two separate things about that store. One of the two is correct, and it is the planted lawful act. The other is the violation. Separating them is the whole exercise.

NOTE: When you finish, sort what you found into three piles. Clearly a violation. Clearly lawful. Cannot tell from these facts. The third pile teaches you the most, because for each item in it you have to name the missing fact that would move it into one of the other two. A licensee who can name the missing fact is a licensee who knows what to look up.

Then do the harder half. Take the item you were least sure about and argue the other side of it out loud, as though Victor were across the table with a reason for what he said. If you cannot build that argument, go back to the screen the rule came from.

Notice how Victor is wrong. Every one of his errors is delivered as reassurance, in the voice of a man who has done this a long time. Zoning is the law. Of course it runs with it. Relax. The number is final. Nobody else is affected. Not one of the twelve came from anything he looked up, and not one would have survived the only sentence that protects a licensee in this subject: let me check the recorded documents and the local ordinance.

Almost every item here is a moment where Victor answered a land use question from memory instead of from a document. The recorded declaration was available. The deed was in front of him. The local ordinance and the filing requirements are public. Land use is the subject where the answer is almost always written down within reach, and where a confident guess is the most expensive thing an agent can offer.

Name the fact, then name the rule

REMEMBER: Count what you found before you check anything. Fewer than twelve means going back to the paragraph you read fastest, and it is usually the one with the filings in it.

Check yourself

10 questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see whether it is right and why.

Key terms

Restrictive covenant
A private limitation on the use of land placed in a deed or declaration; must be recorded and 'touch and concern' the land to run with it.
Doctrine of laches
Loss of the right to enforce a covenant through unreasonable delay; two years in New York.
Police power
The government's constitutional authority to regulate land use for public health, safety, morals and general welfare, the basis of zoning and building codes.
Eminent domain
The government's power to take private property for public use upon payment of just compensation; condemnation is the act.
Taking
Government regulation that deprives an owner of the economic use of land without compensation; unconstitutional when all economic benefit is eliminated.
SEQR
New York's State Environmental Quality Review Act requiring agencies to identify and mitigate significant environmental impacts, with an environmental impact statement where needed.
Comprehensive (master) plan
The planning board's written statement of goals, policies and strategies for a community's growth.
Plat
A recorded subdivision map showing lots, blocks, streets and services; recorded only after board approval.
Spot zoning
The illegal rezoning of a single parcel to benefit its owner rather than carry out the master plan.
Nonconforming use
A lawful use that predates a zoning ordinance and may continue ('grandfathered') but not expand.
Variance
Administrative relief from a zoning requirement granted by the zoning board of appeals: use variance (unnecessary hardship) or area variance (practical difficulty).
Special use permit
Permission for a conditional use allowed in a district subject to conditions protecting neighboring property.
Transfer of development rights
The sale of unusable development rights (e.g., from a landmarked building) to a developer who can use them elsewhere.
Certificate of occupancy
The building department's certification after final inspection that a building complies with codes and may be occupied.

Practise this chapter

Flashcards (free) Practice exam

Read Chapter 8 in the Book

The Book comes with the Salesperson pass ($39 for 3 months).

A study course, in beta. This is not a New York State Department of State approved qualifying course, and the time you spend here does not count toward the 77 hours you need for a salesperson license. Take the 77-hour course at a DOS-approved school; use this to learn the material and to review it. · Powered by License to Earn LLC