Lesson 1
The Nature of Property
People say they bought a house. The house is only one element of what they own.
Four Definitions You Cannot Confuse
Land, real estate, real property, personal property
The law sorts all property into two kinds. Real and personal. Every rule in this chapter sits on that split, and the split decides what your client is actually buying. Four words do the work, and people use all four as though they meant the same thing.
Land is the surface of the earth, the subsurface below it to the center of the earth, and the air above it within reasonable limits to permit commercial air travel. A parcel is a specific piece of land, a lot. Land is unique. No two parcels are the same.
Real estate is the physical land, also called unimproved land or raw land, plus everything permanently attached to it. Attachments count whether nature put them there or a person did.
Real property is land and its attachments, and all of the rights that come with the property. Real property is the widest of the three. A deed that conveys real property conveys the dirt, the building and the rights at the same time.
Personal property is any property that is not real property. It is moveable, so it is not fixed to the land. Personal property is also called chattel.
You are paid to know which of the four you are selling. The chandelier, the mineral rights, the air over the roof. Each one belongs in a column, and the column decides whether it walks out the door on closing day.
Rights are what make it real property
Real property also carries a set of characteristics the exam names in its own words. Immobility: land cannot be moved from one place to another. Uniqueness, also called non-homogeneity: every parcel, every building and every house is a different piece of real estate. Scarcity: the supply is limited. Situs: where a thing sits gives it a preference, and preference gives it value. Illiquidity: real estate cannot easily be converted to cash, which is why a seller who needs money by Friday has a problem a stockholder does not have.
FIVE CATEGORIES OF REAL PROPERTY
Residential property is property used as a dwelling. Single family homes, condominiums, apartment buildings, duplexes, cooperatives, mobile homes, townhouses, converted warehouse space, lofts. Most new licensees work inside this category and stay there.
Commercial property calls to mind multi-million dollar buildings with dozens of tenants. Those exist and commercial firms broker them. Most commercial investment is far smaller and open to any licensee: houses held for income, small apartment buildings, a single-user retail box, a neighborhood strip, office and industrial space.
Industrial is a very broad classification. Warehouses and general storage, often bought by investors. Distribution and manufacturing plants, which carry highly specialized features and are usually bought by the company that will use them.
New York defines agricultural property for the purpose of determining property taxes. It is land and land improvements used for agricultural production, together with the structures used to carry that production out. Croplands, pastures, greenhouses, nurseries, feed lots. Housing for employees counts, and so does land in federal supply management or soil conservation programs. Woodland counts where it produces farm wood or serves as pasture. The owner's own residence does not count, and neither does the garage or the shed beside it.
Special purpose real estate has a limited use and is most often publicly owned. Converting it to anything else takes substantial reinvestment. Golf courses, schools, churches, tennis clubs.
NOTE: The exam separates these terms with one question asked four ways. What does this term include that the term before it does not? Land is surface, subsurface and reasonable airspace. Real estate adds the permanent attachments. Real property adds the rights. Chattel is everything left over.
REMEMBER: Walk through the last house you stood in. Name one thing in it that is real property, one that is personal property, and one you are not sure about. Which column does the contract put the third one in?
The Bundle of Legal Rights
Five rights that come with ownership, and three things that interfere with them
Ownership of real property is not one right. It is a bundle of five, and each one can be handed to somebody else on its own. That is why a landlord, a tenant, a mortgage lender and a utility company can all hold real rights in the same house at the same time.
The right of possession is the right to physically occupy the land, to use it and to make it productive. An owner may use the land any way the owner wants, as long as the use is legal and does not interfere with other people's rights.
The right of quiet enjoyment is the freedom to possess and use the land without interference from other people or from society. It carries a matching duty. Your quiet enjoyment does not entitle you to hinder your neighbor's.
The right of disposition is the right to transfer all or some of the rights to other people. Sell, lease, give away, divide, keep part, or dispose of the whole thing. Selling ten acres of a hundred-acre farm is partial disposition. So is renting an apartment, because the landlord has let somebody else possess part of the property for a while.
The right of exclusion, also called restriction, is the right to stop other people from using the property or even from entering it.
The right of control is the right to physically alter or change the property. Build a garage, tear down a fence, put in a swimming pool. Zoning will often have something to say about it, and zoning is a limit on the right rather than a denial of it.
Those five rights are what a buyer is paying for, and every one of them can be cut down before the buyer arrives. An easement takes a slice of exclusion. A deed restriction takes a slice of control. A lease takes possession for a term. Know which slices are already gone before you tell a buyer what the property is.
INTERFERING WITH THOSE RIGHTS
Trespassing is a physical invasion of land by a person who has no lawful right to enter it. Trespassing interferes with the owner's possessory interest and cuts down the right of use and the right of enjoyment, because during the trespass the owner has less than full possession of the land.
Encroachment is the legal synonym for trespass, applied to objects instead of people. A neighbor's garage built over your property line encroaches. So does a tree growing across it. Legal steps can force the neighbor to tear the structure down, trim the tree, or buy the strip of land the object sits on.
A nuisance interferes with quiet enjoyment from outside causes. Loud noises, unsightliness, obnoxious odors. A nuisance does not involve possessory rights, because nobody has entered the land. To be actionable in court a nuisance must be a continuing unreasonable use of land by the offending landowner, and a court usually will not help a landowner who moved in already knowing the nuisance was there.
Hypothetical. Your buyer loves a house on a quiet street and mentions that the body shop two doors down runs a compressor at six in the morning. The compressor was running when she toured the house. If she buys, she buys knowing it is there, and a court is unlikely to give her a remedy for a nuisance she moved in on with her eyes open.
CAUTION: Trespass is people, encroachment is objects, nuisance comes from outside the property line. Exam questions swap the three words and change nothing else. Read the fact pattern for what crossed the line, not for what it was called.
Five rights, and each one sells separately
REMEMBER: Name the five rights out loud without looking. Then name which of the five a month-to-month tenant is holding while the lease runs.
Land Is an Inverted Pyramid
Tip at the center of the earth, base extending into the sky
Picture the parcel as an inverted pyramid. The tip sits at the center of the earth and the base opens out into the sky. The owner has rights to the surface inside the boundaries, to everything directly over that surface, and to everything under it inside the pyramid.
A legal description details the surface and nothing else. The law implies that subsurface rights and air rights come with the land even though they are almost never written down. Subsurface rights are the implied rights a landowner holds to the land below the surface, down to the center of the earth.
AIR RIGHTS
Air rights are the right to undisturbed use and control of the airspace over a parcel, within reasonable limits for air travel. An owner may sell the air rights over a property separately from the land, and in New York City owners do it routinely. Because of air travel the federal government controls United States airspace. Owners keep the use of the lower reaches over their land, they may not interfere with air traffic, and they have the right not to be harmed by use of the airspace above them.
SUBSURFACE AND MINERALS
A landowner owns all the solid minerals in and under the surface of the land. Minerals are real property while they are in the ground and become personal property once they are extracted. An owner may sell or lease the mineral rights separately from the surface, and many do, especially where they have neither the skill nor the equipment to mine or drill.
Oil and gas are different, because oil and gas move. They are governed by the rule of capture. Whoever drills a well on his own land owns all the oil or gas the well produces, even where the oil or gas migrated from under a neighbor's land. Oil and gas flow toward the point of lowest pressure, and the well is the point of lowest pressure. The rule exists to stimulate production. The only way to stop your oil going to a neighbor's well is to drill your own.
Solid minerals are part of the land, and real property, until they are extracted. Oil and gas belong to whoever captures them. That is the whole distinction, and it is the one the exam asks about.
SUPPORTING RIGHTS
A piece of land is held up by the land around it and the earth beneath it, and the owner has a right to that natural support. Lateral support is support from the adjacent land. A neighbor's excavation may make your land shift and settle, and the neighbor can be held liable for the resulting damage where there was negligence. Subjacent support is support from the underlying earth. The mining party is generally liable for surface damage caused by underground mining even where the excavation was performed carefully.
Support rights are the reason a construction project next door is a real estate question and not just a noise complaint. Land does not hold itself up in isolation.
Hypothetical. A seller tells you the farm comes with everything under it. The abstract shows a prior owner sold the gas rights to a producer thirty years ago. Your seller cannot convey what a prior owner already sold, and a buyer who learns that after closing learns it from a lawyer.
NOTE: Negligence matters for lateral support and does not matter for subjacent support. The careful excavator next door may walk away. The careful miner underneath generally does not.
The surface is described; the rest is implied
REMEMBER: Say the difference between lateral support and subjacent support in one sentence, then say which one still produces liability when the work was done carefully.
Water Rights
Riparian, littoral, appropriative, and percolating
Land that touches water carries rights to the water, and which rights depend on what the water is doing. Flowing water gives riparian rights. Tidal water gives littoral rights. How far the ownership runs under the water depends on a separate question: whether the body of water is navigable.
Riparian rights are the rights of an owner whose land is contiguous to flowing water, a river or a stream. Riparian rights are principally the right of access to the water and the right to all useful purposes to which the body of water may be applied.
Littoral rights are the rights of an owner whose land is subject to the ebb and flow of the tide, an ocean, a bay or a large lake. A littoral owner may have unrestricted use of the waterway, and owns the land only up to the mean high water mark.
HOW FAR THE OWNERSHIP RUNS
Where the water is non-navigable, the riparian owner owns the land under the water to the exact middle, the center of the stream. Where the water is navigable, the owner owns the land up to the edge of the water and no farther. Navigability is the test, and it changes the answer completely.
This is a sentence you will say to a buyer. Tell a buyer of riverfront land that he owns the bed to the center of a navigable channel and you have described an interest he will not receive. The correction arrives at the closing table, from somebody else, and it is your listing that looks careless.
Appropriative rights are water rights granted by government permit, independent of land ownership. The permit allows the holder to take water from a particular body of water for a specified use, such as crop irrigation. Appropriated water does not have to be used on riparian or littoral land. Riparian and littoral owners' rights are considered when the permits are issued, and appropriative rights usually cannot interfere with them.
Percolating water rights involve the use of underground water. A landowner has the right to install a well to reach water for the owner's own use. Percolating water is the quiet one on this list, and it is the one that sells a rural listing or kills it, because a house with no municipal line is a house that depends entirely on a well.
WHEN NATURE MOVES THE PROPERTY LINE
Erosion is the gradual wearing away of land by wind, rain or other natural forces. Where eroded soil moves across a property line, the owner who lost the soil loses title to it and the owner who received it gains title.
Accretion is the gradual process of waterborne silt being deposited in a river bed, a lake bed or on the shore. The deposits are called alluvion. Riparian and littoral property is increased this way and the landowner acquires title to the silt.
Avulsion is land torn away by flowing water. Avulsion does not transfer title where the severed land is identified and reclaimed by the original owner.
Reliction is water receding and exposing more of the bed. In some states reliction adds nothing to the parcel, because the owner already held title to the bed out to the midpoint of the water.
Appurtenances are the rights that go with real property. Access rights, limited air rights, water rights, mineral rights. They are usually sold along with the land, they can be sold separately, and they may already be limited by a past transaction. An owner who sells the mineral rights to a mining company keeps the land, and when the land is later sold those mineral rights most likely stay with the mining company. The new owner is limited by a deal made before he arrived. He cannot sell those rights and he cannot transfer them in a future sale.
CAUTION: Erosion and accretion are gradual and they move title. Avulsion is sudden and it does not, provided the owner identifies and reclaims the land. The exam tests speed as much as it tests the word.
Flowing water is riparian; tidal is littoral
REMEMBER: Your listing fronts a stream nobody boats on. Which rights does the owner hold, and how far out does the ownership go?
Lesson 2
Attachments, Fixtures, and Chattel
What conveys with the land, and what walks out the door
Attachments and Fixtures
How personal property becomes real property, and how it changes back
Real estate includes attachments, which are the things attached to the land, natural or man-made. Man-made attachments artificially attached to the land are more commonly called improvements.
Buildings
Pipelines
Pavements
Sewers
Roads
Driveways
Fences
A fixture is an item of personal property that has been permanently attached to the land or to its improvements. Ceiling fans, built-in bookshelves, chandeliers, furnaces, custom-made window coverings. An item temporarily removed for servicing is still a fixture, so the built-in dishwasher sitting at the repair shop on the day of closing belongs to the buyer.
FOUR WAYS PERSONAL PROPERTY BECOMES A FIXTURE
Annexation is becoming physically attached to the real property. Association is becoming attached conceptually through close association with the real property, which is why the keys to the house go with the house. Adoption is attachment through fit, such as curtains custom made for a window of unusual size or shape, or wall-to-wall carpeting. Agreement is becoming part of the real property because the parties involved agreed it would, as a landlord and a tenant can agree.
Severance runs the other way. Detach a fixture from the land and it reverts to personal property. Take the chandelier off the ceiling and the chandelier is chattel again.
Natural attachments are the plants growing on the land. Trees, perennial flowers and other vegetation are part of the land and therefore real property. Plant an apple tree next to the house and the tree becomes real property, called fructus naturales. Pick an apple and the apple is personal property. Flowers, crops and vegetation planted or cultivated annually or seasonally are fructus industriales, fruits of industry, also called emblements.
Every one of these words turns into money at a closing. Annexation and adoption are how a seller loses an item he thought was his. Severance is how a buyer loses an item she thought she bought. You are the person in the room who knows the difference before anyone has to argue about it.
Fixtures and improvements are part of the real estate, so it is tempting to assume they are included by implication in the description of the property. Do not assume it on a client's behalf. The safe practice is to state everything that is included in the sale, in the listing agreement, in words, before a buyer has ever walked through the door.
Hypothetical. A seller unbolts the built-in microwave the week before closing and puts a countertop model in its place. The microwave was annexed, it was real property, and taking it out was a severance the buyer never agreed to. The seller is convinced he took his own appliance. He took part of the house.
NOTE: Adoption is the category people miss. Wall-to-wall carpeting cut to fit a room, and curtains made for one odd window, are fixtures even though neither one is bolted down. The fit is the attachment.
Attach it and it stays; sever it and it goes
REMEMBER: Name the four ways personal property becomes a fixture. Then name which of the four need no screws, no nails and no glue.
Trade Fixtures and Personal Property
The tenant's pizza ovens, and everything else that is not real property
Trade fixtures are any equipment or personal property a commercial tenant installs for business purposes. They may be attached to the real property and they remain the personal property of the tenant. Unless the lease says otherwise the tenant should remove them before the lease ends.
A tenant who opens a pizza shop can take the ovens he installed, even though the ovens are bolted to the floor. What he cannot do is leave a hole. The tenant must repair any damage the removal causes.
The word commercial is doing the work in that rule. Trade fixtures belong to a business tenant who installed equipment to run a trade. A residential tenant who bolts a shelf to a bedroom wall is not installing a trade fixture, and the ordinary fixture rules decide who keeps it.
Personal property, also called chattel, is any property that is moveable and not fixed to land. Personal property is tangible where it can be held or touched, such as appliances, cars and furniture. It is intangible where it cannot, such as savings accounts, stock rights and intellectual property.
Ownership of personal property is conveyed two ways. A sale transfers it by bill of sale. A will transfers it by bequest, sometimes called a legacy. A deed transfers real property. A bill of sale transfers chattel. They are different instruments and you will see both in the same transaction.
Unless the parties agree otherwise, all real property is included in a transfer, and personal property that happens to be on the land is not necessarily included. That one sentence is the source of most fixture disputes.
HOW TO NEVER HAVE THIS FIGHT
Write it into the listing. Always note what personal property is included in the sale, and note what is not. If the seller is taking the chandelier or the kitchen appliances, say so in the listing agreement so buyers know from the start what they are getting. A listing that is silent on the point is not neutral. It is an argument waiting for a closing date.
Better still, replace it first. The most reasonable strategy you can give a seller is to remove or replace the item before showing the house. A buyer cannot expect an item she never saw. If the seller intends to take the dining room chandelier to the new house, he should swap it for an appropriate light fixture before the first showing and end the question there.
Use a separate bill of sale. Where a buyer wants items the seller never intended to sell, the living room curtains for instance, have the parties draw up a separate bill of sale. A bill of sale transfers title to personal property the way a deed transfers title to real property. Tell the agents and the attorneys on both sides, because a private side deal that nobody else knows about is the one that blows up a closing.
Hypothetical. Your seller mentions on the drive back that the washer and dryer are going with him. It is a sentence in a car. It is not in the listing, it is not in the contract, and the buyer has walked past those machines twice. Put it in writing this afternoon or plan to buy somebody a washer.
The reason to fix this early is that a fixture argument arrives at the worst possible time. It arrives at the walk-through, hours before a closing, with movers in the driveway and a lender waiting. Nobody is reasonable at that hour. A single line in the listing agreement, written months earlier, is what keeps that conversation from happening at all.
CAUTION: Trade fixtures and ordinary fixtures look identical when they are bolted down. The question is never how firmly it is attached. The question is who installed it and why.
Real property conveys; chattel does not
REMEMBER: A commercial tenant's walk-in cooler, a homeowner's built-in oven, a tenant's window air conditioner. Who keeps each one, and what is your reason for each answer?
Settling a Fixture Dispute
What a court actually looks at
Where a seller does not clearly label items as personal property in the listing agreement, the argument can end up in court. Courts answer the question with a set of tests, and the tests are worth knowing because you can run them yourself before anybody files anything.
The first question is practical. Can the object be removed without damaging the property? The second follows it. Was the item custom made or designed specifically to fit or be used in this property?
Physical attachment is taken into account and it is not decisive. A court weighs it and then keeps looking at the other factors. Bolted down does not settle it, and sitting loose does not settle it either.
One of the most important issues a court considers is the intent of the annexer and the purpose of the annexation. The annexer is the owner of the personal property who brought it onto the real property. Did the annexer intend the item to become part of the real property, or to stay personal? Was the item bought to improve the real property, or simply for personal use?
A court looks for objective evidence of that intent. It is not enough to claim you always meant to take the item with you. The nature of the item and the manner of annexation are read as objective evidence of what you intended. Setting a statue in concrete shows intent to make it a permanent feature. Setting the same statue out on the lawn does not.
THE RELATIONSHIP OF THE PARTIES
Between a seller and a buyer of real property, the rules are usually interpreted in favor of the buyer. The law presumes a homeowner intends to improve the real property, so what the homeowner attached is presumed to have been attached for good.
Between a landlord and a tenant, the rules tend to be interpreted in favor of the tenant. The law presumes a tenant installs things only for personal use. A tenant who installs a chandelier, or another ornamental item, usually has the right to remove it at the end of the lease.
That presumption is not a guarantee, and it weakens fast where the tenant did the work without written permission. A tenant who built a deck onto the back of a rented house has almost certainly created a fixture that belongs to the landlord's real property. A wrought iron railing installed without permission may go the same way. The court looks at the nature of the item, the manner of annexation, and how hard it would be to remove.
A written agreement beats all of it. Whatever the tests would have produced, where there is a written agreement between the parties stating how an item is to be treated, a court will enforce the agreement.
That is the sentence to carry into practice. You cannot control how a judge weighs a statue in concrete. You can control whether the listing agreement names the chandelier. Recommend that everything be put in writing and you are of genuine use to your client the day a dispute starts.
Notice what the two presumptions have in common. Both of them are reading the annexer's likely purpose. An owner improves the place she lives in and expects to sell. A tenant fits out a place she expects to leave. Neither presumption is a rule about who is more deserving. Each one is a guess about why the item went up, and evidence of a different purpose will beat the guess.
Hypothetical. The seller's above-ground pool sits on the lawn, unattached, filled with water. The buyer assumed it was staying because it was there at every showing. Nothing in the file says a word about it. Now two people who were about to close are arguing about a pool, and neither of them is wrong on the facts.
NOTE: Once a dispute reaches a court, anything can happen. The tests point in a direction. They do not promise an outcome, and no licensee should ever tell a client that they do.
Put it in writing and the tests never run
REMEMBER: Name the presumption that favors a buyer and the presumption that favors a tenant. Then name the one thing that overrides both.
Lesson 3
Estates in Land
Freehold, leasehold, and the future interests that follow them
Freehold Estates
A possessory interest of uncertain duration
Two words come first, because the rest of this lesson uses them constantly. A person with a property right or a claim against property has an interest in the property. An interest may be an ownership right such as a life estate, a right to use the land such as an easement, or a financial claim against the title such as a mortgage.
An estate is a possessory interest in real property. An estate entitles the holder to possess the property now, which is a present interest, or at some later time, which is a future interest. Every estate is also either a freehold or a leasehold.
A freehold estate is a possessory interest of uncertain duration. It may end, but nobody knows when. The holder of a freehold estate holds title. Events that end a freehold estate include transfer of the property to someone else, the death of the owner, foreclosure, confiscation for back taxes, and condemnation under eminent domain.
Escheat belongs on that list too. Escheat is what happens when property reverts to the state after a person dies without leaving a valid will and without heirs, or when property is abandoned. The state is the owner of last resort, and the estate ends there.
FEE SIMPLE ESTATE
A fee simple estate is the fullest freehold interest that exists in real property. It is also called fee title or fee simple absolute. A person described simply as the owner of land usually holds fee simple absolute, and that owner has all of the bundle of legal rights. Absolute means there are no conditions on the title. The estate is perpetual, inheritable and transferable.
When a fee simple absolute owner deeds an interest to someone else, it is presumed the entire estate transfers unless the deed language says otherwise. The new owner holds fee simple absolute too. Fee simple is the default, and a grantor who wants something narrower has to write it down.
QUALIFIED FEE: FEE SIMPLE DETERMINABLE
A qualified fee estate, also called a fee simple defeasible estate, is created when a grantor puts a condition or a requirement into the deed. Where the estate terminates automatically on the condition failing, and title reverts to the grantor or the grantor's heirs, it is a fee simple determinable.
Deed language transfers Juanita's land to Darlene, as long as the land is used as a park. Darlene uses it for something else and title reverts to Juanita or her heirs. No lawsuit, no notice, no step anyone has to take. The word determinable means it determines itself.
A qualified fee creates a kind of encumbrance on the title, because it runs with the land. The restriction is not against the owner. The restriction is against the land, and it is still there for the next owner and the one after that.
QUALIFIED FEE: FEE ON CONDITION
Where the condition in the deed gives the grantor a right of reentry if the condition is not met, the estate is a fee on condition. The grantor or the grantor's heirs have the right to terminate the estate, and termination does not happen automatically. Deed language transfers David's land to Frank, but if Frank builds a bar the grantor may take possession or go to court to regain possession. The grantor would generally have to prove in court that the stated event occurred before regaining title.
A grantor can also hold title back until a condition occurs. Bill will transfer title to his grandson Will if Will marries before his twenty-fifth birthday.
Qualified fees reach you through the title report, never through the seller. A seller rarely thinks of a fifty-year-old deed restriction as part of what he is selling, because it has never inconvenienced him. It will inconvenience a buyer who wanted to do something different with the land, and it is far better found during the listing appointment than during attorney review.
CAUTION: Determinable terminates by itself. Fee on condition gives the grantor a right to act. An exam question that describes a deed condition is asking which of those two happens next, and nothing else.
Fee simple absolute is the default
REMEMBER: A deed says the land goes to the church as long as it is used for worship. If the church opens a parking lot, who owns the land the next morning, and did anyone have to do anything?
Life Estates and Future Interests
The measuring life is not always the life tenant
A life estate is a freehold estate that lasts only as long as a specified person lives. That person is the measuring life. The holder of the life estate is the life tenant. Everything difficult about life estates comes from one fact: the measuring life and the life tenant are not always the same person.
CONVENTIONAL LIFE ESTATE
In a conventional life estate the measuring life and the life tenant are the same person. Grantor Jane owns property in fee simple and deeds it to grantee David for life. Jane still owns the property. David has the right to occupy and use it for as long as he lives. When David dies the life estate ends.
LIFE ESTATE PUR AUTRE VIE
A life estate may instead be measured by the life of somebody other than the life tenant. That is a life estate pur autre vie, for another's life. Paul owns property in fee simple and deeds it to Sue for as long as Mike lives. Sue is the life tenant. Mike is the measuring life. When Mike dies the life estate ends and Sue's right to occupy the property ends with it, whatever Sue's own health may be.
WHAT A LIFE TENANT CAN AND CANNOT DO
A life tenant's interest can be sold, mortgaged or leased. A person can transfer only the interest he owns, so anyone who buys a life tenant's interest buys a life estate and nothing more. That interest ends when the measuring life dies.
Larry has a life estate, takes a job out of state, and sells to Barb. Barb can live on the property. Barb does not own the property. Barb's interest ends when Larry dies, because Larry is still the measuring life. Barb bought a clock she cannot see.
A life tenant may not commit an act of waste. An act of waste is what happens when a possessor who holds less than fee ownership, a tenant or a life tenant, misuses or abuses the property. Using the property in a way that damages it or reduces its market value is waste. A life tenant therefore holds restricted rights of use, and those restricted rights are what transfers with the life estate.
This is the screen that protects you from a bad listing. A life tenant who wants to sell is selling an estate that ends on a date nobody can predict, and it is not fee simple. Market it as fee simple and you have misrepresented the interest to every buyer who reads the advertisement.
EVERY LIFE ESTATE CREATES A FUTURE INTEREST
Both kinds of life estate are present interests that create a future interest for whoever will possess the land when the measuring life ends. The future interest is either reversionary or a remainder.
A reversionary interest means the property reverts to the grantor, or to the grantor's heirs, on the death of the measuring life. Joe grants a life estate to his daughter Sue. Joe is the reversioner. When life tenant Sue dies the estate reverts to Joe.
Now follow it one step further. In his will Joe leaves everything to his son Bill, so Bill now holds the reversionary interest as well. If Joe dies before Sue, the estate reverts to Bill on Sue's death. Bill cannot remove his sister in the meantime. Sue's life is the measuring life and she may stay until she dies, at which point Bill takes the property in fee simple. If Bill dies before Sue, Sue stays and the estate goes to Bill's heirs when she dies.
A remainder interest is created where the grantor grants the life estate to one person and then to another person, the remainderman, on the death of the measuring life. Joe deeds property to his daughter Sue for life, and then to his nephew Tim. Tim has a remainder interest and Tim is the remainderman. When Sue dies, Tim or his heirs take title in fee simple, because the death of the measuring life ends the life estate.
Change the order of the deaths and nothing changes. If Joe dies before Sue, Sue still holds the present life estate and Tim still holds only the future remainderman estate. A future interest is a real interest. It is simply not a possessory one yet.
Life estates turn up in ordinary New York families more often than students expect. A parent deeds the house to the children and keeps a life estate, so the parent can stay in it and the house is already where it needs to be when the parent dies. The children own a remainder interest the whole time. They cannot sell the house out from under their mother, they cannot rent it, and they cannot decide the kitchen needs updating. What they own is the day after.
NOTE: Reversion goes back to the grantor. Remainder goes forward to a third person the grantor named. Read the deed for one question. When the measuring life ends, does the property go back where it came from, or on to somebody new?
The estate ends when the measuring life ends
REMEMBER: Larry sold his life estate to Barb and then moved to Florida and lived another thirty years. Whose death ends Barb's interest, and what does Barb own the day after it?
Freehold vs. Leasehold
Two families of estate, three leasehold estates, and the tenant at sufferance
Every estate is one of two families, and the line between them is title. A freehold estate is a possessory interest of uncertain duration. It may end, but no one knows when. The holder owns an estate in the land itself and holds title. Fee simple, qualified fee, fee on condition and life estates are all freeholds. A freehold ends by transfer, by the death of the owner, by foreclosure, by confiscation for back taxes, or by condemnation under eminent domain.
A leasehold estate gives the holder a temporary but exclusive right to possession of the estate without title. It is more limited than a freehold. The holder of a leasehold is the lessee, or tenant. The owner who leases the property out is the lessor, or landlord. A tenant has the right to exclusive possession, and only for a limited time.
The landlord's side has a name too. The leased fee interest is reversionary, because possession reverts to the landlord when the lease ends.
THREE LEASEHOLD ESTATES, AND ONE THAT IS NOT
An estate for years is a leasehold set to last for a definite period, a week or three years, after which it terminates automatically. It is also called a term tenancy, and the name is misleading because the period does not have to be measured in years.
A periodic estate continues for successive equal periods of time, week to week or month to month, until either the lessor or the lessee ends it by proper notice. Most residential tenancies in New York end up here once the written term runs out.
An estate at will is a leasehold with no specified termination date and no regular rental period. It is also called a tenancy at will.
A tenancy at sufferance is possession by a tenant who came into the property under a valid lease and stays on after the lease expires without the landlord's permission. It is not a leasehold estate, because the landlord has granted nothing for the holdover period. Chapter 12, on contracts and leases, takes all of these further.
AND THREE WAYS TITLE IS CREATED AND CONVEYED
By deed, which is a document that transfers ownership of real property, as when one person sells a house to another. By devise, which is real property transferred because of a will. By descent, which is real property transferred to an heir where there is no will.
NOTE: Freehold holders have title. Leasehold holders have possession. A question that hands you exclusive possession and no title is handing you a leasehold, however long the term runs.
Title is the line between the two families
REMEMBER: A tenant stays past the end of a one-year lease and the landlord neither agrees nor objects. What is that tenant's position called, why is it not a leasehold estate, and which words in its definition decide it?
Lesson 4
Forms of Ownership
Severalty, co-ownership, and the five unities
Severalty, Co-Ownership, and the Five Unities
Severalty sounds like several. It means one.
Ownership divides into two primary forms, and the division is simply how many people hold the title. One holder is severalty. More than one is co-ownership.
Ownership in severalty, also called tenancy in severalty, is the simplest form. It is a sole form of ownership, meaning only one person or one legal entity holds title to the property. Do not let the word mislead you. Severalty does not imply several people. It means that one owner's interest has been severed from the interests of everyone else.
Co-ownership, also called concurrent ownership, is any form of ownership where two or more persons or legal entities share title, each holding an undivided interest in the property. An undivided interest gives each co-owner the right to possession of the whole property, not just part of it. Under the law any number of persons may join in the ownership of real property.
That word undivided is the one students skip. Four co-owners of a house do not own a bedroom each. Each of the four has the right to use the entire house, and the percentages on paper describe shares of value, not rooms.
THE FIVE UNITIES
Unity of possession: all co-owners hold the same undivided right to possess the whole property, as opposed to a designated portion of it. Unity of interest: all co-owners hold equal ownership interests. Unity of time: all co-owners acquired their interests at the same time. Unity of title: all co-owners acquired their interests through the same deed or will. Unity of person: all co-owners are a single, indivisible legal unit, and this fifth unity applies only to legal spouses.
Read the five again and notice that four of them are about matching. Equal shares, the same moment, the same document, the same right to the whole. A form of ownership that demands all four breaks, for that share, the moment somebody sells a share to a stranger, and that is exactly what happens to a joint tenancy when one owner deeds his interest away.
The right of survivorship means the property passes automatically to the other co-owners when one co-owner dies. Which unities are present, and whether the right of survivorship is present, is what tells the three forms of co-ownership apart. Learn the five unities now and the next three screens are bookkeeping.
NOTE: Count the unities, then ask about survivorship. One unity is a tenancy in common. Four is a joint tenancy. Five is a tenancy by the entirety. That is the whole comparison chart in one line.
One, four, or five unities
REMEMBER: Say the five unities in order without looking. Then say which one can only ever apply to a married couple.
Tenancy in Common
The most common form, and the only one that allows unequal shares
A tenancy in common is co-ownership by two or more persons with an undivided interest in the entire land and no right of survivorship. It requires only the unity of possession, and that single requirement is what makes it the only co-ownership that can be held in unequal portions.
Because only possession is required, the co-owners can hold any shares they like, they can buy in at different times, and they can take title through different deeds. Nothing about their shares has to match.
When a tenant in common dies, his interest in the property passes to his heirs. It does not pass to the surviving co-owners. That is the central difference between a tenancy in common and a joint tenancy, and it is the difference the exam asks about most.
Tenancy in common is also the default. Where the language in a deed does not specify a different type of co-ownership, or where the co-owners are not married to each other, tenancy in common is assumed. Where the deed is silent as to the interests of the parties, the shares are equal.
SHARES MOVE; THE FORM DOES NOT
Four people own a property as tenants in common. A holds thirty-five percent, B holds twenty, C holds thirty and D holds fifteen. D sells his fifteen percent to E. Now A, B, C and E are the tenants in common and the form has not changed. B then sells his twenty percent to C, and C holds fifty. Still a tenancy in common. Shares move freely and the form of ownership stays where it was.
Now A dies. That thirty-five percent share goes to A's heirs, not to co-owners C and E. There is no right of survivorship in a tenancy in common, and the surviving owners simply acquire a new partner they did not choose.
Where an owner dies without a valid will and without heirs, the interest escheats to the state. That is the end of the line for a share of a tenancy in common, and it is rare, but it is the reason escheat sits on the list of ways an estate ends.
This form is why co-ownership questions land on your desk. Two friends buying together, a parent and an adult child, three siblings who inherited a house. Each of them is deciding who receives a share on death, and each of them should hear that question from an attorney rather than from you.
CAUTION: Tenancy in common is the form New York falls back to when a deed to co-owners who are not married to each other is careless. That makes it the answer to more exam questions than any other form, and the outcome of more real deeds than the buyers intended.
No survivorship; the heirs take the share
REMEMBER: Three cousins own a house as tenants in common in unequal shares. One dies leaving two children. Who owns the house the next day, and in what shares?
Joint Tenancy
Four unities, equal shares, and the right of survivorship
A joint tenancy exists where each co-owner has an equal undivided interest in the land together with the right of survivorship. A joint tenancy requires all four unities: possession, interest, time and title. Equal interests are part of the definition, so a joint tenancy can never be held in unequal shares.
The main feature is survivorship. As each joint tenant dies, the surviving joint tenants absorb the deceased owner's share automatically. Five joint tenants each hold twenty percent. E dies and the remaining four hold twenty-five percent each. D dies and the three hold a third each. C dies and the two hold half each. B dies and A owns the whole property in severalty.
Survivors take ownership equally and simultaneously, and that has a consequence people find surprising. A person can neither will nor inherit a survivorship estate. A joint tenancy ownership interest may only be conveyed through a deed.
Conveying an interest breaks the joint tenancy for that share. When a joint tenant deeds his interest away, the new co-owner is a tenant in common in relation to the other co-owners, and the right of survivorship in that specific interest ends. The remaining joint tenants keep survivorship between themselves.
Three joint tenants each hold a third. C sells his interest to D, so D is now a tenant in common holding a third while A and B remain joint tenants. B dies and A absorbs B's third, holding two thirds. D dies and D's third goes to D's heirs, because D never had survivorship to begin with.
Notice what that breaks and what it leaves alone. The unity of time and the unity of title are gone for the new owner, because he acquired his share later and through a different deed. The original owners still hold all four unities between themselves, so survivorship survives among them.
NEW YORK CAUTION: Joint tenancy generally assumes the right of survivorship. In New York the creation of a joint tenancy with right of survivorship must be explicitly stated in the deed, for example: Jane and Jack, as joint tenants with right of survivorship and not as tenants in common. Simply writing joint tenants in a New York deed creates a tenancy in common, with no right of survivorship at all.
That is the most expensive sentence in this chapter. Two buyers who believe they have survivorship, and a deed that does not say so, will discover the problem at the worst possible moment. You do not draft the deed. You do know enough to tell both buyers to have an attorney read the language before they sign it.
Survivorship in New York must be written down
REMEMBER: A New York deed reads to Jane and Jack, as joint tenants. Jane dies. Who owns her half, and what single phrase would have changed the answer?
Tenancy by the Entirety
Legal spouses only, all five unities, and what New York does not recognize
A tenancy by the entirety is a form of co-ownership involving only owners who are legal spouses, each holding an equal and undivided share of the property. It includes the right of survivorship, so the property automatically goes to the surviving spouse, who then owns it in severalty.
It requires all five unities, possession, interest, time, title and person, because spouses are considered a single, indivisible legal person. The fifth unity is the whole reason this form exists and the whole reason nobody else can use it.
In New York, ownership by legal spouses is assumed to be tenancy by the entirety unless the deed specifies otherwise. Compare that with joint tenancy, where New York assumes the opposite and makes you write survivorship in. Spouses get survivorship by default. Everybody else has to ask for it.
THREE WAYS IT TERMINATES
Either spouse dies, and the surviving spouse becomes the owner in severalty. Both parties agree to end this type of ownership and both sign a new deed. Or the couple divorces. In New York, distribution of property on divorce falls under the Domestic Relations Law, which mandates equitable distribution, and equitable may or may not be equal. After a divorce the couple owns the property as tenants in common.
WHAT NEW YORK DOES NOT RECOGNIZE
Three terms show up in national study material and in questions written elsewhere. Dower is the interest held by a married person in the real property owned by a spouse. Curtesy is likewise one spouse's interest in the other spouse's property. New York recognizes neither one. Community property is co-ownership limited to legal spouses under the law of certain other states, and New York does not acknowledge it either.
Homestead is a word with two meanings in New York and both are worth knowing. As a tax term, homestead property means dwellings of four or fewer units, owner-occupied mobile homes, residential condominiums, farms, and vacant land suitable for qualified buildings, which may be eligible for a separate tax rate. Homestead protection is a limited protection for a debtor against the claims of judgment creditors, exempting some of the owner's equity in the residence from lien foreclosure.
PARTITION
Parties to a joint tenancy or a tenancy in common have the right of partition, which allows any co-owner to end the co-ownership. A voluntary partition divides the property so that each owner holds a piece in severalty, where that can be done equitably. Where the owners cannot agree, one owner can sue the others to dissolve the co-ownership and either divide the property or sell it and divide the proceeds.
CAUTION: You may be familiar with every form of ownership on these screens. Your role is not to be a lawyer, an estate planner or a tax advisor to your clients. Explaining how the forms differ is teaching. Telling a buyer which one to choose is advice you are not licensed to give.
Spouses only, five unities, survivorship
REMEMBER: A married couple takes a New York deed that says nothing about the form of ownership. What do they hold? Now say what the same silence would produce for two business partners.
Ownership by Businesses
Some business forms are a legal person; some are just the people in them
Severalty and co-ownership both extend to businesses, including nonprofit groups and other organizations. Depending on its form, a business association may be a legal entity separate from its members or owners, or it may be nothing more than the people who make it up. That single question decides who signs, who is liable, and who is taxed.
A sole proprietorship is a business owned by a single individual, or by legal spouses for tax purposes, in severalty. The owner is personally responsible for any business debts, and personal assets can be attached in the event of default. There is one exception worth remembering: property owned with a spouse as tenants by the entirety. A sole proprietorship can operate under the proprietor's own name or under an assumed or fictitious name registered with the state, as in Joe Smith doing business as Smith Realty.
PARTNERSHIPS
A partnership is an association of two or more individuals as co-owners of a business, as specified in the partnership agreement. The Uniform Partnership Act, first established in 1914 by the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws and adopted by New York State, allows a partnership to take title to property in the name of the partnership as tenants in partnership. That is a form of co-ownership giving each partner an equal undivided interest in the property, and the property is purchased and owned by the partnership itself.
Partners may instead take title in the names of the individual partners, as tenants in common or as joint tenants. Any of the partners may convey partnership property. All members of the partnership must agree before any one party can sell or assign his own interest in partnership property.
In a general partnership all partners share in the financial liability, both individually and as members of the partnership. A limited partnership has one or more general partners and one or more limited partners. The general partners have the same rights and duties as partners in a general partnership. The limited partners have no say in partnership matters, and their liability is limited to their original investment.
CORPORATIONS
A corporation is a legal entity created and operated according to the laws of each state. A corporation may be public, as cities, counties and school districts are, or private for profit, or private nonprofit. The law regards a corporation as a legal person separate from its individual stockholders, so shareholders are not personally liable for the corporation's debts. Within a corporation, property is owned in severalty, because the corporation is the one legal person holding it.
A C corporation must pay corporate income tax. When profits are distributed the shareholders pay income tax on the dividends as well, which is the classic double taxation situation. A subchapter S corporation functions as a corporation but, like a partnership, pays no corporate income tax. Income or losses are divided among the shareholders and passed through to them, and each shareholder reports the income or loss on an individual return. S corporations are not recognized in New York City, so an S corporation there must pay New York City corporate taxes.
You will meet these forms as signatures on a contract. A corporate seller signs through an officer. A partnership may need every partner's agreement before a partner's own interest moves. A sole proprietor is personally on the hook for the deal. Knowing which form you are dealing with tells you who has authority to bind the seller, and a contract signed by somebody without that authority is a closing that does not happen.
Hypothetical. A corporate seller's contract comes back signed by a man whose card says sales manager. He is not an officer and the corporation never authorized him to sell real property. The signature binds nobody. Everything built on top of that contract, the inspection, the mortgage application, the moving truck, was built on a page that is not an agreement.
NOTE: The exam pairs each form with one phrase. Sole proprietorship goes with severalty. Partnership goes with tenants in partnership. Corporation goes with severalty as a legal person. Limited partnership goes with liability limited to the original investment.
Ask whether the business is a legal person
REMEMBER: Your seller is a two-person partnership and only one partner will come to the closing. What do you need to know before you tell the buyer the date is safe?
Condos, Co-ops, Townhomes, and Investment Vehicles
What is owned, and what is actually transferred
Condominiums, cooperatives and townhomes physically and legally combine individual ownership with co-ownership. This screen answers two questions about each of them. What interest does the buyer own, and what changes hands at the closing? The full treatment of condominiums and cooperatives, including offering plans, board packages and financing, is its own session later in the course.
A condominium is property developed for co-ownership where each co-owner has a separate fee simple interest in an individual unit and an undivided interest in the common areas. The common areas are the parts of the development all residents use and own as tenants in common: the parking lot, the hallways, the recreational facilities. A condo is real property and the unit owner holds a fee simple deed to the unit.
A cooperative is a building owned by a corporation with the residents as shareholders. Title to the cooperative building is held by a corporation formed for that purpose. A person who wants to live in the building buys shares in the corporation instead of renting or buying a unit, and receives a proprietary lease on a unit plus the right to use the common areas. A proprietary lease is an exclusive, longer-term lease given to a person who lives in the building and owns stock in the cooperative.
Here is the sentence that matters at a closing. A co-op owner's shares are personal property. The co-op buyer receives stock and a lease, not a deed, and no fee simple interest in the apartment exists for anybody except the corporation that owns the building. A condominium purchase is a fee simple transaction and the unit owner receives a deed. Describe a co-op as fee simple title to an apartment and you have described a transaction that does not exist.
A townhome is property developed for co-ownership where each co-owner has a separate fee simple interest in an individual unit, including its roof and basement and the land directly beneath the unit, plus an undivided interest in the common areas. The fee simple ownership may extend to a small patio or lawn outside the unit.
TRUSTS
A trust allows the owner of property, the trustor, to transfer ownership to someone else, the trustee, so that the trustee can manage the property for a third party, the beneficiary. A trustee may be an individual or a company. Trusts are often established to reduce inheritance taxes or to direct an estate, and the trustee's powers are limited by the terms written into the trust. A trust established during the trustor's lifetime is a living trust. A trust established by will, or after the death of the trustor, is a testamentary trust.
VEHICLES FOR OWNING REAL ESTATE
A syndicate, or syndication, is a joint participation of individuals, partnerships and corporations in a real estate investment. A syndicate is not a recognized legal entity. It allows most property ownership forms, joint tenancy, tenancy in common, partnership or corporation, and it is generally used for large-scale ongoing projects or for multiple projects.
A joint venture is an arrangement in which two or more individuals or companies pool resources in order to engage in one project or a series of projects, but not as an ongoing business concern. The project ends and so does the venture. That is what separates a joint venture from a partnership.
A real estate investment trust, a REIT, is a real estate investment business with at least one hundred investors, organized as a trust where one or more trustees manage property for the benefit of the beneficiaries. A trust document vests title to the property in the trustees, who hold only those powers expressly granted to them in the document. The beneficiaries have no legal interest in the property itself, and they do have the power to enforce performance of the trust.
The distinction between a syndicate, a joint venture and a REIT is a distinction of permanence. A joint venture ends with the project. A syndicate is a way of organizing a larger or longer effort, and it borrows whatever legal form suits it. A REIT is a standing business with at least a hundred investors behind it.
NOTE: Sort these by what the buyer receives. A deed to a unit is a condominium. A deed to a unit plus the ground under it is a townhome. Shares and a proprietary lease is a cooperative. A beneficial interest with no legal interest in the property is a trust or a REIT.
Shares and a lease, or a deed
REMEMBER: A buyer asks whether she will own her apartment. Answer it once for a condominium and once for a cooperative, and use the word deed in only one of the two answers.
Session Summary
Eight things to carry out of this chapter
Real property is land and its attachments plus all the rights associated with the property, and it is wider than land or real estate. The bundle of legal rights is possession, quiet enjoyment, disposition, exclusion and control. Trespassing by people, encroachment by objects and nuisance from outside causes all interfere with those rights. Land itself is unique, immobile, scarce, tied to its situs, and illiquid.
Personal property, also called chattel, is any property that is not real property. A bill of sale transfers title to it, and a bequest passes it under a will. Unless the parties agree otherwise, all real property is included in a transfer and personal property on the land is not necessarily included.
An owner holds the surface, everything over it and everything under it. The law implies subsurface, air, mineral and water rights even though a legal description details only the surface. Flowing water gives riparian rights, tidal water gives littoral rights, and navigability decides how far the ownership runs under the water. Appropriative rights come by government permit. Solid minerals are real property until extracted; oil and gas go to whoever captures them.
Personal property attached to real property becomes a fixture by annexation, association, adoption or agreement, and severance turns a fixture back into chattel. Major fixtures are improvements. Natural attachments are real property in the ground and personal property, or emblements, once picked. Trade fixtures installed by a commercial tenant stay the tenant's personal property, and the tenant must repair any damage the removal causes.
A freehold estate is a possessory interest of uncertain duration and the holder has title. Fee simple absolute is the fullest: perpetual, inheritable and transferable, and it is what the law presumes a deed conveys. A fee simple determinable reverts automatically when its condition fails. A fee on condition gives the grantor a right of reentry that must be exercised. A leasehold gives exclusive possession for a limited time without title, and the three leasehold estates are the estate for years, the periodic estate and the estate at will. A tenant who holds over without permission is a tenant at sufferance, which is not a leasehold estate.
A life estate lasts as long as the measuring life. In a conventional life estate the measuring life and the life tenant are the same person. In a life estate pur autre vie they are not. A life tenant may sell, mortgage or lease the interest and may not commit an act of waste. Every life estate creates a future interest, reversionary back to the grantor or a remainder forward to a remainderman.
Ownership is in severalty, held by one person or one legal entity, or in co-ownership. Tenancy in common requires only the unity of possession, allows unequal shares, has no survivorship, and passes a deceased owner's share to his heirs. Joint tenancy requires all four unities, holds equal shares, carries survivorship, and in New York must state that survivorship expressly in the deed. Tenancy by the entirety is for legal spouses only, requires all five unities, carries survivorship, and in New York is assumed for spouses unless the deed says otherwise. Joint tenants and tenants in common both have the right of partition.
Sole proprietorship is ownership in severalty and the owner is personally liable. Partnerships may hold title as tenants in partnership, and a limited partner's liability stops at the original investment. A corporation is a legal person that owns property in severalty. A condominium unit is fee simple with an undivided share of the common areas. A townhome adds the land beneath the unit. A cooperative resident owns shares of stock, which are personal property, plus a proprietary lease.
REMEMBER: Which of these eight could you not explain to a friend over coffee right now? Go back to that screen before you take the quiz.
YOU BE THE JUDGE
The Willow Lane Muddle
Nina lists Willow Lane. The sellers intend to take the dining room chandelier with them, but Nina writes the listing agreement silent on the point, “buyers never notice.” She does tell them to unhook it and hang a plain fixture before the first showing, which they do. Walking a buyer through, Nina says the wall-to-wall carpet cut for the odd-shaped landing is “personal property, it goes with them,” and promises that the pizza ovens bolted into the floor of the ground-floor commercial tenant's space “convey with the building.”
The buyers are two friends, unmarried. Nina drafts nothing but tells them the deed will read “to Jane and Jack, as joint tenants,” assures them that gives each a right of survivorship, and says that as co-buyers they will hold tenancy by the entirety. She adds that if one of them later takes title as a tenant in common instead, “his share automatically goes to the other owners when he dies.” Asked which structure is best for their taxes and their kids, Nina walks them through her recommendation in detail.
Down the road, Nina has a second file. Larry holds a life estate in a farmhouse measured by his own life. Nina markets it as “fee simple, free and clear,” and when Larry pulls down the failing barn to open up the view, she tells him it is his property to do with as he likes.
The farm fronts a navigable river. Nina tells the buyer he will own the riverbed out to the exact centre of the channel. She also has a co-op unit under contract in the city, which she describes to that buyer as giving him fee simple title to his apartment plus an undivided share of the hallways.
Twelve violations are buried in that story, and one lawful act has been planted to catch you out. Work it the way you would work a file rather than the way you would take a test.
Read it once for the story and do not mark anything. Read it again with a pen and mark every sentence that made you pause, without deciding yet whether it is a violation. Then go back through this chapter and name the rule each marked sentence touches.
Five threads run through the facts and each one is a section of this chapter. What conveys with the property and what does not. How co-buyers take title in New York. What a life tenant owns and what a life tenant may do to the property. How far a riverfront owner's land runs under the water. What a buyer actually receives in a cooperative.
One sentence in the story describes something Nina did correctly, and it sits right beside the sentences that are wrong. Finding it is the harder half of the exercise, because an accusation made too quickly is its own kind of problem for a licensee.
Watch for the moment Nina stops explaining and starts advising. There is a point in the second paragraph where the question she is answering stopped being a real estate question. Naming that moment is worth as much as naming any of the property rules.
Work the marked sentences in three piles. Clearly a violation. Clearly lawful. Cannot tell from these facts. The third pile is the one that teaches you something, because for every item in it you have to say which missing fact would move it into one of the other two. A licensee who can name the missing fact is a licensee who knows what to ask for.
Then argue the other side of the item you were least sure about. Say it out loud, in full sentences, as though Nina is across the table and has a reason for everything she said. If you cannot build that argument at all, go back and read the screen the rule came from, because you have memorized a phrase rather than learned a rule.
Not every issue in this story is about property law. Some of them are about what a licensee is allowed to say. Everything in this chapter describes how the forms of ownership differ, and describing the difference is your job. Choosing among them for a client is somebody else's, and that line is drawn in the last caution of the ownership lesson.
NOTE: If your answer to an issue is a rule with no facts attached, you have not spotted an issue. You have recited a rule and hoped it fit. Name the fact first, then name the rule it breaks.
Name the fact, then name the rule