The Course · Chapter 6 Beta

Chapter 6: Deeds and Real Estate Closings

Every transaction culminates in the delivery and acceptance of a properly drafted deed

In this chapter

  • What this session gives you The purpose of a deed
  • Explain what a deed does, and why it is only evidence of title, not title itself. Ten essential elements
  • List what New York requires for a deed to be valid, and what it takes to record one. Forms of deed
  • Distinguish full covenant and warranty, bargain and sale, quitclaim, and judicial deeds. Legal descriptions
  • Read metes and bounds, section-block-lot, and the government survey system. Transferring title
  • Explain voluntary and involuntary alienation, and devise or descent. Marketable title
  • Trace a chain of title and describe what an abstract and title insurance actually do. RESPA
  • Apply the kickback, title insurance, and affiliated business rules to your practice. Closing costs & prorations

Lesson 1

Deeds

The instrument that conveys a grantor's interest in real property

Deed, Title, and Equitable Title

Three words students mix up all the way to the exam

A deed is an instrument that conveys a grantor's interest, if any, in real property. A deed is also called a conveyance. The grantor is the party giving up the interest. The grantee is the party receiving it. The owner of real property uses a deed to transfer all or part of the interest in that property to somebody else. Read the definition again and notice the three words doing the heavy lifting: interest, if any. A deed moves whatever the grantor actually holds. A deed does not create ownership the grantor never had.

Title is the actual lawful ownership of real property. Title means holding the bundle of rights that were conveyed. Title is a theory pertaining to ownership rather than a piece of paper you can pull out of a drawer. The deed is written proof of the rights conveyed to the owner. Holding title is what it takes to actually own the land. That is why the textbook calls a deed mere evidence of title, and that single phrase is the most tested idea on this screen.

Keep the two apart with a picture. A receipt is evidence that you bought something. The receipt is not the thing you bought. The deed is the receipt. Title is the thing. A person can hold a deed and still not hold good title, because the grantor who signed it had a defect in the chain behind him. That is the whole reason a title search exists, and you will meet the title search later in this chapter.

Equitable title is an interest in property created on the execution of a valid sales contract, where actual title will be transferred by deed at a future date, such as at the closing. Equitable title is a lesser interest than actual title. The person holding equitable title still enjoys certain rights and privileges in the property between contract and closing. Every buyer you ever put under contract will hold equitable title during those weeks, and most of them will believe they already own the house.

Hypothetical. Your buyer signs a contract of sale on a house in Rockland County on the fourth of March, and the parties set the closing for the twelfth of June. On the fifth of March the buyer calls you and asks whether she can start pulling up the carpet. She holds equitable title. She does not hold actual title, because actual title will pass by deed at the closing in June. The answer to her question is in the contract, not in her enthusiasm, and the person who answers it is her attorney.

Much of the discussion about deeds is the practice of law. It is not an area in which a licensee may advise a client or a customer. You will read deeds, you will recognize the clauses in them, and you will hand every question about them to an attorney. Know the material anyway. A real estate transaction culminates in the delivery and acceptance of a properly drafted deed, and you are the person standing closest to the parties while that happens.

The purpose of a deed is narrow and permanent. A deed puts a transfer of land into a form that can be signed, witnessed, filed and read by strangers fifty years later. Land does not move and cannot be handed over, so the law hands over a document instead. Every entry in the public record of every county in this state is a document of that kind, and the whole system of searching title rests on the fact that conveyances of land are written down.

For a deed to be valid in New York it must be in writing. That requirement comes from the Statute of Frauds. An oral promise to convey land is not a deed and never becomes one. On top of the writing requirement, a valid New York deed must carry ten essential elements, and the next two screens take them one at a time.

NOTE: The exam separates deed, title and equitable title with one question each and always the same question. Which one is the document? The deed. Which one is the ownership? Title. Which one arises when the sales contract is signed? Equitable title. Answer in that order and the distractors fall away.

The deed is evidence; title is ownership

REMEMBER: Your buyer signed the contract last Tuesday and closes in nine weeks. What does she hold today, and what document will she hold in nine weeks?

Ten Essential Elements of a Valid Deed

Part one: the parties, the grant, and the property

A valid New York deed is in writing and carries ten essential elements. Miss one and the instrument is open to attack. Learn them in order, because the order follows an actual deed from the parties to the handover, and an exam question that describes a clause is really asking you to name the element it belongs to.

One. A competent grantor. A competent grantor is a person who wishes to grant or convey land, is of sound mind for the purposes of entering a contract, and has reached the age of majority. The age of majority in New York is 18. Competence is tested at the moment of signing. A grantor who was competent last year and is not competent today cannot sign a valid deed today.

Two. An identifiable grantee. The grantee is the person to whom the interest in real property is conveyed, identified in a way that reasonably separates that person from everyone else in the world. That means proper and complete full names, and it means designations such as Junior and Senior where a father and a son share a name. If the deed is to be recorded, New York requires both the grantor and the grantee to be identified by address.

Three. An act of conveyance. The act of conveyance is the clause stating that the grantor intends to convey title to the land, and it is also called the granting clause. These words identify the document as one that transfers an interest from one person to another. The wording must communicate a definite and clear intent by the grantor to part with the land. The classic formula is give, grant, bargain, sell, and convey, and those five words leave no doubt about what the grantor means to do.

Four. Consideration. Consideration is anything of value, such as money, goods, services or promises, given to induce another person to enter into a contract. To be valid, a deed must contain a clause acknowledging that the grantor did in fact receive some type of consideration for the land. In New York the actual price paid need not be recited in the deed. Full consideration must be stated when the deed is signed by a fiduciary, such as an executor, or by a referee in a public sale such as a foreclosure.

That fiduciary exception is worth holding on to. A private seller may convey for ten dollars and other good and valuable consideration and the deed stands. An executor selling the house of a decedent does not get that privacy, because the people the executor answers to are entitled to see the number.

Five. A legal description. The legal description of the property being conveyed should be thorough and complete. The test of a valid property description is the ability to identify and distinguish that property from any and all other parcels of land. New York uses two methods for writing one, the metes and bounds system and the section, block and lot system, and two later screens in this chapter walk through them.

The ten elements answer four questions, and grouping them that way makes the list stick. Who is giving, and is he able to give? Who is getting, and can we tell him from everybody else? What is being given, and can we find it on the ground? Did it actually change hands? The first two elements answer the first two questions. The legal description, the habendum clause, the limitations and the exceptions answer the third. The granting clause, the consideration, the signatures and delivery answer the fourth.

Hypothetical. A grantor signs a deed that describes the property as 22 Valley Lane, Yonkers. The mail arrives there and the pizza arrives there, so the address clearly locates the property. The address says nothing about where the boundaries run, so it does not describe the parcel and it cannot distinguish it from the lot behind it. A street address is useful. A street address is not a legal description.

CAUTION: Two of these five elements turn on identity, not on paperwork. A competent grantor and an identifiable grantee both fail quietly. Nobody notices at the closing. It surfaces years later when the next buyer's title company reads the file.

A street address is not a description

REMEMBER: Name the first five elements in order, then say which one an executor must state in full and a private seller need not.

Ten Essential Elements of a Valid Deed

Part two: the estate, the limits, and the handover

Six. The habendum clause. The habendum clause is often included after the granting clause, and it describes the type of estate granted. The habendum clause must always agree with the granting clause. The clause is the easiest one in the deed to spot, because it begins with the words to have and to hold. When the granting clause conveys a fee simple and the habendum clause describes a life estate, the two clauses contradict each other and the deed is in trouble.

Seven. Limitations. How the property may or may not be used must be noted in the deed. A deed restriction is the common example. A limitation that lives in the deed travels with the land to the next owner, which is exactly why it has to appear on the face of the instrument rather than in a side conversation between the parties.

Eight. Exceptions and reservations. Anything that affects the property, such as an easement, must be expressly noted on the deed. These are also known as subject to clauses, because that is how they read: the conveyance is made subject to an easement of record, subject to a right of way, subject to covenants and restrictions. A grantor who reserves something is holding a piece back out of the grant. A grantor who excepts something is telling the grantee that a third party already holds it.

Nine. Signatures. A deed must contain the signatures of all grantors. Grantees do not need to sign the document. Every grantor signs, and that includes both spouses when both are in title, and it includes every co-owner when a parcel is held by more than one person. A deed signed by one of two owners conveys one owner's interest and no more.

Acknowledgment is a separate step, and it is the step that gets skipped. Acknowledgment means the party signing the deed declares before a public official, such as a notary public or a judge, that the signature is genuine and was given voluntarily. Acknowledgment is not strictly a requirement of a valid deed. Grantees should always require it anyway, because a deed cannot be recorded without it and because it is the grantee's evidence that the signature is real.

Ten. Delivery and acceptance. Even when a deed has been properly executed, it has no legal effect until there has been delivery of the deed by the grantor with the intention of transferring title, and acceptance by the grantee receiving the land. Delivery and acceptance must take place while the grantor is alive. Delivery may be made directly to the grantee, or to a representing agent such as an attorney or a real estate broker.

Hypothetical. A father signs a deed to the family house in Suffolk County, puts it in his desk, and tells his daughter it is there for her. He dies in January. In February the daughter finds the deed and takes it to the county clerk. There was no delivery by the grantor with the intention of transferring title while the grantor was alive, so the deed has no legal effect, and the house passes through the father's estate instead. Signing is not delivering.

Once a deed is delivered and accepted, the grantee holds title to the land. Title cannot be re-conveyed by destroying the deed or by handing it back to the grantor. If the grantee wants to give the land back, the grantee executes a new deed transferring title back to the original grantor. There is no undo button on a conveyance, and a student who remembers that one sentence will pick up at least one question.

Recording is a separate question from validity. A deed does not have to be recorded to be valid. Recording protects the grantee against challenges, makes the conveyance part of the public record, and insures against lost documents. Recording an invalid document does not make it valid, and failing to record a valid deed does not make it void.

Limitations, exceptions and reservations are the elements a working agent bumps into first. They are the reason a buyer's attorney reads the deed line by line before closing, and they are the reason you never tell a buyer that a property comes free and clear of everything. You do not know that. The deed knows it, the title report knows it, and both of them are read by somebody other than you.

CAUTION: Delivery and acceptance is the element that creates the most confusion in practice, because the parties think the signature is the moment. The signature is the ninth element. The tenth element is the handover, and the tenth element is the one that has to happen while the grantor is alive.

You cannot un-deliver a deed

REMEMBER: A grantee changes her mind two weeks after closing and mails the deed back. Who holds title the next morning, and what would actually have to happen to move it?

Recording a Deed

Filed in the county clerk's office where the property sits

Recording is usually the final step after delivery and acceptance. The document is filed in the county clerk's office in the county where the property is located. Deeds are not required to be recorded to be valid. An unrecorded deed may be perfectly valid, and it simply leaves the grantee exposed, because recording is what makes the conveyance clear to third parties as part of the public record and what insures against lost documents.

A deed needs three things beyond the ten essential elements before the clerk will record it. First, a public official such as a notary public must serve as a legal witness to the grantor's acknowledging signature. Second, a certificate of the address of the grantee, so that the tax authorities know where to send the tax bills. To record a deed, New York requires both the grantor and the grantee to be identified by address. Third, there should be evidence of real estate transfer tax, which in most states and some local governments takes the form of a stamp.

Recording an invalid document does not make it valid. The clerk is not a judge and the clerk does not review the substance of what you hand across the counter. A deed with a defective description or a missing signature is exactly as defective after it is recorded as it was before, and now it is defective in public.

New York uses three types of deed more than any other. A full covenant and warranty deed carries the strongest and broadest form of guarantee of title of any type of deed and gives the grantee the greatest protection. A bargain and sale deed implies that the grantor owns the property and has a right to convey it, and carries no warranties with it. A quitclaim deed makes no warranties at all about the title, if any, held by the grantor.

Those three sit on a ladder, and the ladder is the point. At the top the grantor promises everything and stands behind the promise. In the middle the grantor implies ownership and promises nothing. At the bottom the grantor hands over whatever he has, which may be nothing, and says so out loud. The next screen opens the top of the ladder and counts the promises.

Recording is also how a grantee wins a fight he does not yet know about. In New York a recorded deed takes precedence over any prior unrecorded deed. A grantee who records has told the world. A grantee who does not record is relying on a seller who has already been paid to behave well toward a stranger, and that is a thin thing to rely on.

Hypothetical. A seller in Ulster County deeds a parcel to a buyer in April, and the buyer puts the deed in a drawer. In September the same seller deeds the same parcel to a second buyer who searches the record, finds nothing, pays, and records that afternoon. The first buyer holds a deed that was valid the day it was delivered. The second buyer recorded. In New York the recorded deed takes precedence over the prior unrecorded deed, and the first buyer is now suing somebody instead of owning something.

NOTE: The exam likes to pair recording with validity in the same sentence and see whether you flinch. Recording is not an element of a valid deed. Acknowledgment before a notary is not an element of a valid deed either. Both are requirements for recording, and recording is what protects the grantee.

Valid and recorded are two questions

REMEMBER: Your seller's deed from 1994 was never recorded. Is it valid, and what is the risk your buyer is actually carrying?

The Six Covenants of a Full Warranty Deed

Legal promises that the grantee will enjoy full and unencumbered ownership

In a full covenant and warranty deed the grantor makes a set of covenants. A covenant is a legal promise, and these promises all say the same thing in six different directions: the grantee will enjoy full and unencumbered ownership of this land. Six covenants is the number to carry into the exam, and the covenant of warranty forever is the one to carry out of it.

The covenant of seizin assures the grantee that the grantor holds the title specified in the deed being conveyed. Seizin is an old word for possession of the estate, and the covenant is the grantor saying that what the deed describes is what he has.

The covenant of right to convey states that the grantor owns the land and has the right to convey it. It usually follows the covenant of seizin, and it covers the case that seizin does not. A trustee may hold title and still be barred by the trust from selling. Owning and being free to convey are two separate promises, so the deed makes them separately.

The covenant against encumbrances assures the grantee that the property is free of encumbrances not recited as exceptions in the deed. Read that clause slowly. The promise is not that there are no encumbrances. The promise is that there are none beyond the ones written into the deed, which is why the exceptions and reservations element matters so much.

The covenant of quiet enjoyment ensures that the grantee can possess the land without claims of title from others, and will not be disturbed in the use and quiet enjoyment of the land because of a defect in title. Quiet enjoyment is about claims of ownership. It is not a promise about a loud neighbor, and the exam has asked it that way.

The covenant of further assurances requires the grantor to remedy any defects in the title being conveyed and any errors or deficiencies in the deed itself. This is the covenant that reaches forward in time. If a scrivener dropped a call out of the description, the grantor is on the hook to sign whatever corrects it.

The covenant of warranty forever provides that the grantor will defend the grantee's interest against all lawful claims of title. It is the most important of all the covenants, because it is the best form of warranty for protecting the grantee. The other five describe the condition of the title. This one commits the grantor to stand in front of the grantee and fight.

A bargain and sale deed with covenants, sometimes called a special warranty deed, is a guarantee that the grantor has not encumbered the property in any way except as stated in the deed. Grantors are willing to warrant only the time they owned the property, and not the time of previous owners. That narrower promise is frequently used for transactions in the New York City area, so a New York student needs to know it cold.

A quitclaim deed, also known as a deed of release, makes no warranties regarding the title, if any, held by the grantor. It conveys whatever right, title or interest the grantor has at the time the deed is executed, without representing that there is any interest at all. Quitclaim deeds are often used to remedy clouds on a title, where somebody may have a claim and the cheapest fix is to buy that claim out and have him sign it away.

Hypothetical. A woman sold a house in Queens in 2011 under a bargain and sale deed with covenants. In 2024 a claim surfaces from an unrecorded easement granted in 1978. The grantor warranted her own period of ownership and nothing before it, so the covenants she gave do not reach a 1978 problem. Under a full covenant and warranty deed on the same facts, the warranty forever would.

A covenant is only as good as the grantor behind it. A full covenant and warranty deed from a seller who leaves the state with no assets is a promise nobody will collect on. That is why lenders require title insurance instead of relying on covenants, and it is worth understanding before you tell a buyer that the deed form protects him.

NOTE: Count the covenants, then rank them. Six covenants in a full covenant and warranty deed. Warranty forever is the strongest. Bargain and sale with covenants warrants only the grantor's own ownership. Quitclaim warrants nothing at all.

Six covenants; warranty forever is strongest

REMEMBER: Which covenant promises there are no encumbrances beyond the ones written into the deed, and which one puts the grantor in the courtroom with you?

Judicial Deeds

The name of the deed tells you the role of the person signing it

Judicial deeds result from some sort of court order. They generally contain no covenants or warranties, although ownership is implied. A judicial deed could contain the covenant that the grantor has done nothing to encumber the property, and that is usually as far as the promises go. The signer is a court appointee conveying somebody else's land, so the signer has nothing to warrant and no reason to warrant it.

The name of the deed reflects the role of the person executing it, and that is the whole trick to this list. An executor's deed conveys property of the deceased. An administrator's deed is signed by the person appointed by the court to convey property of the deceased. A guardian's deed conveys property by a court-appointed representative. A sheriff's deed is used in a sheriff's sale at foreclosure. A referee's deed is used in bankruptcy or foreclosure proceedings.

New York foreclosure sales are where a salesperson meets these deeds in real life. A buyer at a foreclosure auction takes a referee's deed and gets no warranties with it, which is why title insurance and a careful search matter more at an auction than at a kitchen table, not less.

Line the deeds up by how much protection the grantee walks away with. A full covenant and warranty deed carries all six covenants and is the broadest guarantee available. A bargain and sale deed with covenants warrants only the grantor's own period of ownership. A bargain and sale deed without covenants implies ownership and the right to convey, and warrants nothing. A quitclaim deed conveys whatever interest exists, and that may be none.

Every deed on that ladder validly transfers title. The ladder measures promises, not effectiveness. A quitclaim deed moves title just as completely as a full covenant and warranty deed. What it does not move is any recourse against the grantor when the title turns out to be bad, and that difference is worth money at exactly the moment the buyer has none.

The executor's deed ties back to the consideration element from earlier in this chapter. A fiduciary such as an executor, or a referee in a public sale such as a foreclosure, must state the full consideration in the deed. A private grantor need not. The estate's beneficiaries and the court are entitled to see what the property brought, and the deed is where they see it.

CAUTION: Do not read a judicial deed as a weak deed. It is a court-ordered deed. The court had the power to order the conveyance, so the conveyance works, and the absence of covenants is a statement about the signer rather than about the title.

The signer's role names the deed

REMEMBER: A buyer at a foreclosure auction asks you what protection the deed gives him. Which deed will he receive, and what does it promise?

Lesson 2

Legal Descriptions

Identifying a parcel and distinguishing it from all others

The Metes and Bounds System

Distance and compass direction, walked clockwise back to where you started

Street addresses are useful for locating property. They do not provide an accurate description of the boundaries. So real property is identified by its legal description, the description that gives the ability to identify and distinguish that property from any and all other parcels of land. Many real estate documents, deeds and mortgages among them, require a legal description to be valid.

With the metes and bounds system, a licensed surveyor describes a property's boundaries in terms of distance and compass direction. Metes are the distances. Bounds are the directions. The surveyor starts at an easily identifiable point of beginning, works clockwise to define the boundary, and ultimately returns to the point of beginning. If the walk does not close, the description is defective.

The selection of the point of beginning is perhaps the most important aspect of the whole description. The point of beginning should be easily identifiable and well established, and it is usually a point on a road. A description that starts from something a stranger cannot find fifty years from now is a description that will have to be litigated.

Once the point of beginning is identified, the surveyor sights the direction of the next marker. A marker is a fixed physical object used as a reference point. Most markers are permanent physical objects such as rods, sometimes called pins, driven into the ground and left there to be found again.

The monument system is the older relative of metes and bounds. The work is done the same way, but instead of markers or pins placed by a surveyor, the monument might be an object such as a tree, a rock, a wall, or even a specific bend in a river. Monuments are how a great deal of upstate New York was first described, and they are the reason old descriptions can be difficult to retrace. A tree dies. A river moves. A pin driven into the ground stays where it was put.

Here is a sample description, and reading one is the fastest way to understand the method. Follow it with your finger and notice that every call has a direction and a distance, that each call ends at a marker, and that the last call brings you back to where you started.

SAMPLE DESCRIPTION, “Beginning at the pin in the centre of Miller Road, go SE 300 feet at an angle until the edge of the road meets another pin; then due south 250 feet to a pin at the adjoining property's fence; then due west 350 feet to a pin at the edge of Miller's Pond; then north 200 feet to another pin; due west 100 feet to a pin near the base of an old oak tree; then due north to a pin at the edge of the road; then NE at an angle to the point of beginning.”

Hypothetical. Your seller's survey begins at a pin in the center of a town road, runs southeast, then south to a fence, then west to the edge of a pond, then north, then west to an old oak, then north to the road, then northeast back to the pin. That is one parcel, fully described, and no other parcel in New York fits those calls. That is the test a legal description has to pass.

A survey is the process of determining the physical size and boundaries of a property, and it is the work that produces a metes and bounds description in the first place. A licensed surveyor does it. A licensee does not, and a licensee does not opine on where a boundary runs. When a buyer asks whether the fence is on the line, the answer is a survey, and the cost of that survey shows up again in the closing costs screen later in this chapter.

Metes and bounds is the older of the two New York systems and it is the one that describes most rural and upstate parcels. It is also the one that generates most boundary disputes, because a description written in 1911 depends on markers that somebody has to find in 2026. When a survey and a deed disagree, the disagreement is expensive, and it is the reason a lender wants a current survey rather than the one in the seller's file.

NOTE: Two things get asked about metes and bounds and almost nothing else. Which direction does the surveyor travel? Clockwise. Where does the description end? At the point of beginning.

Start at the POB, walk clockwise, come back

REMEMBER: If a metes and bounds description does not return to the point of beginning, what do you actually have in your hand?

Block and Lot, and the System New York Does Not Use

Platted land, and the arithmetic of the government survey

The block and lot system is a legal description used for platted property, which is land that has been subdivided into blocks and lots. To find the exact location of a parcel, you consult a plat of subdivision, a detailed survey map of a subdivision recorded in the county where the land is located. The plat map may also be called a plot plan or a recorded plat, and it gives a unique number to each lot in each block of that subdivision.

A legal description using this system might read: Lot No. 105 as shown on said plan, as found in Plan Book, or liber, Volume 88, page 23. Read what that sentence is doing. It gives the location of the lot, and it gives the location of the plot plan in the public records. Anyone can now go to the clerk's office and see the same map the drafter was looking at.

In New York the system is more typically referenced as section, block and lot, written in a legal description as SEC, BLK, LOT. The legal description of each lot may be further defined using the metes and bounds system, so the two methods sit side by side rather than competing. Section, block and lot tells you which parcel. Metes and bounds tells you exactly where its lines run.

The government survey system, sometimes called the rectangular survey system, is the third method, and New York does not use it. It is based on intersecting principal meridians running north and south and base lines running east and west, designated through much of the country. Using the meridians and base lines, land is divided into six-mile by six-mile squares called townships.

Learn four numbers from that system anyway, because they are on the exam and because the arithmetic behind them is clean. One township contains 36 sections. One section is 640 acres and one square mile. One square mile is 640 acres. One acre is 43,560 square feet. A township is six miles by six miles, which is 36 square miles, which is why a township holds 36 sections.

A reference to a plat is what makes the block and lot system work, and it is worth understanding why it is cheap. A subdivision is surveyed once. The map is recorded once. After that, every deed, every mortgage and every tax bill for every lot in that subdivision can point at the recorded map instead of repeating a page of calls. That is why most subdivided residential land is described this way.

Hypothetical. A question hands you a quarter of a section and asks for the acreage. One section is 640 acres, so a quarter section is 160 acres. Halve it again and you have 80 acres. The exam builds these questions out of halves and quarters, so the only number you truly have to memorize is 640, and the only other one is 43,560 square feet in an acre.

Here is where a salesperson actually meets a section, block and lot number. It is on the tax bill, on the assessment roll, on the title report and in the listing. When a client hands you a tax bill and asks what all the numbers mean, the SEC, BLK and LOT string is the parcel's identity in the county's records, and it is what a searcher uses to pull the file.

NOTE: New York uses metes and bounds and section, block and lot. New York does not use the government survey system. The exam asks the arithmetic of a system this state does not use, and students who skip it because it does not apply here lose the points anyway.

36 sections, 640 acres, 43,560 square feet

REMEMBER: Say the four government survey numbers out loud. Then say which two systems actually describe land in New York.

Lesson 3

Transferring Ownership

Alienation: voluntary, involuntary, and by devise or descent

Voluntary and Involuntary Alienation

Alienation is the process of transferring ownership interests in property

Alienation is the process of transferring ownership interests in property. In New York, title to real property may be transferred three ways: voluntary alienation, involuntary alienation, or devise or descent. This screen takes the first two. The third has a screen of its own.

Voluntary alienation is an action the property owner undertakes of his free will, and it is the most common way to transfer ownership of land. It takes four forms. A sale, in which the owner agrees to hand over title in exchange for consideration, usually completed with a deed. A gift of a deed, in which the owner transfers title without receiving anything of value from the recipient. A dedication of private property for public use. And a grant, when the government transfers title to land to an individual.

Dedication shows up in your working life more than students expect. A developer who dedicates land for the streets inside a new subdivision is dedicating private property for public use. So is an owner who dedicates a strip to a municipality for a park. The land leaves private hands, the municipality takes on the maintenance, and the lots that front those streets become saleable.

A grant runs the other direction, from the government to a person. Historically, government land grants were issued to public companies to build railroads and to colleges and universities. Grants are still available in Alaska to individuals who want to create homesteads on the land. The evidence of title from a grant of this kind may be referred to as a land patent.

Involuntary alienation is the transfer of title in an interest in real property against the will of the owner, or without any action by the owner. Nobody signs a contract. Something happens, and the title moves anyway. There are four routes, and each one is tested.

Eminent domain is the government's constitutional power to take private property for public use, as long as the owner is paid just compensation. The actual act of taking is known as appropriation or condemnation. Most frequently it is the federal, state and local governments, utility companies and school districts that exercise the right. Before the property transfers, the courts must rule that the recommended use will benefit the public's greater good. In New York, when private property is condemned through the right of eminent domain, the landowner has the right to challenge the compensation offered.

Read that last sentence twice, because it is the New York wrinkle. The owner cannot usually stop a taking that a court has found to serve the public good. The owner can fight over the number. Just compensation is a question of value, and questions of value are argued by appraisers.

Foreclosure is the second route. If a landowner defaults on debts secured by real property, the property can be transferred without consent through foreclosure. The property is sold and the proceeds from the sale are applied to the owner's debt. Default on a mortgage loan is the most common reason for foreclosure. Unpaid taxes, liens and judgments can also result in foreclosure, which is why a small unpaid judgment is never a small problem.

Adverse possession is the third. Possession and use of property can mature into title. Acquiring title to land by adverse possession requires use of another's land that is open and notorious, hostile and adverse, exclusive, and continuous, for a designated period of time. In New York that period is ten years. All four qualities have to be present for the whole ten years, and a use that the true owner permitted is not hostile, so it never starts the clock.

Accession is the fourth. Accession is the acquisition of title to land by its addition to real estate already owned, through human actions or natural processes. Accession gives property owners the right to everything produced by their land. Sometimes the addition to one person's land results in the involuntary alienation of another person's land, and the next screen is about exactly that.

Hypothetical. A neighbor in Dutchess County has mowed, fenced and parked on a twelve-foot strip of your seller's back lot since 2009, openly, without permission, and without anybody else using it. Your seller wants to list the property this spring. That strip is a question for a surveyor and an attorney before it is a question for a listing agreement, because ten years of open, notorious, hostile, exclusive and continuous use is the New York standard.

Adverse possession is the one students argue about, so be clear about what it is not. It is not squatting for a weekend and it is not a handshake with a neighbor. It is ten years of use that the true owner could have stopped and did not, carried out in the open, against the owner's interest, by one person to the exclusion of others, without a break. Courts do not hand out land casually, and the ten-year requirement is the reason.

CAUTION: Voluntary means the owner acted. Involuntary means the owner did not. A sale under pressure from a lender is still a sale and still voluntary. A foreclosure is not, because the owner signs nothing. Sort the fact pattern by who signed, not by who was unhappy.

Ten years, and all four qualities throughout

REMEMBER: Name the four voluntary routes and the four involuntary ones. Then say which single fact decides which column a transfer belongs in.

Nature, Wills, and What Happens With No Heirs

Accretion, avulsion, reliction, devise, descent, and escheat

Land bordering bodies of water can grow and shrink without anybody doing anything. Four words cover it, and all four come up on the exam as vocabulary rather than as analysis.

Accretion is the gradual addition to dry land by the forces of nature. The land added through accretion is known as alluvion. Accretion is slow and the owner keeps what arrives. Avulsion is when land is lost due to sudden acts of nature such as floods or earthquakes. Reliction is when a body of water gradually recedes, exposing land that was previously underwater.

The pattern is easy once you hear it. Accretion and reliction are gradual and they add. Avulsion is sudden and it takes. Alluvion is the material, not the process, and that is the distinction the exam is usually testing when all four words appear in the same set of answers.

The other way title moves is on the death of the owner, and it happens two ways. When someone dies with a will, he is said to die testate. In the will, the testator, or testatrix for a woman, may have named an executor, or executrix, to carry out the provisions of the will, including disbursement of land. If no executor was named, the court appoints an administrator with the responsibility of carrying out the decedent's wishes.

To transfer land through a will is to devise it, so the heirs who are left the land are devisees. The process by which the deceased's property is distributed is called probate. Probate occurs under the supervision of the surrogate court in the county where the decedent lived. That is where the executor gets the authority to sign an executor's deed, and it is why an estate sale moves on the court's calendar rather than on your buyer's.

When someone dies without a will, he is said to die intestate. Property descends by intestate succession to the natural heirs of the deceased, and title acquired this way is title by descent. Natural heirs include spouses, children and relatives. The Statute of Descent and Distribution lists those persons in a close enough degree of kinship to be considered natural heirs, and the list is fixed. Nobody negotiates it and nobody is added to it by affection.

If a property owner dies intestate and there are no heirs and no creditors, the property reverts to the state through the process of escheat. Escheat is rare, and it is the reason the state is the backstop owner of last resort. Land never goes ownerless in New York.

Devise and descent are their own category. They are not voluntary alienation, because the owner is not acting. They are not involuntary alienation either, because nothing is taken. Title moves because the owner died and the law says where it goes next.

Hypothetical. An owner in Nassau County dies in March leaving a will that names her brother as executor. The house is listed in June. Your buyer asks who signs the deed. The executor signs, and he signs an executor's deed, and he signs it with authority that comes from the surrogate court in Nassau County. Change one fact and there is no will. Now the court appoints an administrator, the property descends by intestate succession, and the deed at the closing is an administrator's deed.

An estate sale is different work from an ordinary sale and the difference is authority. Before anything can be signed, somebody has to be appointed, and the appointment comes from the surrogate court in the county where the decedent lived. Until that happens there is nobody who can convey the property, no matter how much the family agrees about what should happen to it. Ask who has been appointed, and ask early.

NOTE: Testate and intestate are the two words to keep straight, and the trick is in the prefix. Intestate is the one with no will. Devise is what a will does with land. Escheat happens only when there is no will, no heir and no creditor.

No will, no heirs, no creditors: escheat

REMEMBER: Your seller inherited the property from a parent who died without a will. Which deed will she sign at closing, and which court gave her the authority?

Real Estate Closings

Session 6-A begins here

A ready, willing and able buyer is found. The sales contract is drawn. Both parties fulfill their obligations under the agreement. Then the closing happens, and at the closing the buyer receives the deed and the seller receives payment for the property.

The rest of this chapter is the closing. What makes a title marketable, what the public record does, what RESPA requires, which documents show up on the table, who pays which cost, and how to prorate a shared expense down to the day.

Marketable Title and the Public Record

What the seller must deliver, and how anyone can find out

When conveying real property, the seller is generally expected to deliver a marketable title. A marketable title is a title free and clear from undisclosed encumbrances or other defects that would expose a purchaser to litigation, impede the purchaser's ability to enjoy the property, or make the property hard to sell later. Notice the word undisclosed. A disclosed easement does not make a title unmarketable. A surprise does.

A title search of the public records, also known as a title examination, is necessary to determine ownership and the quality of the title prior to conveyance. If a marketable title cannot be produced, a closing may have to be postponed. That sentence is your professional life in miniature. Most closings that fall apart in the last week fall apart here, and they fall apart in the week when everybody has already given notice on an apartment.

The recording acts are the statutes behind all of this, and the public records system is what they build. That system is the way the public gets notice of who holds an interest in any piece of property. Recording documents in the public records of the county clerk's office where the property is located allows property owners to defend their estate, right or interest against third parties claiming a subsequent interest. The clerk's office is open to anybody. That openness is the engine of the whole system.

There is no legal requirement to record a real estate document, such as a deed, an easement, a lien, a restrictive covenant or a long-term lease. An unrecorded document is likely to be unenforceable against a third party claiming a subsequent right or interest in the property. In New York a recorded deed takes precedence over any prior unrecorded deed, so it is in all parties' best interests to record.

Constructive notice provides that protection. A person is considered to have constructive notice of something when it should be known, even if it is not. Since the public records are available for anyone's inspection, everyone is considered to have constructive notice of the contents of recorded documents. The burden of discovery rests with the general public. Nobody has to send you a letter. The record is there and you are charged with it.

Actual notice exists when individuals have actual knowledge of a fact. Actual notice includes what someone personally saw, heard, read or observed. The law expects a buyer or a lender to search the public record for his own protection, and searching is how constructive notice turns into actual notice. The record gives you constructive notice whether you read it or not. Reading it gives you actual notice.

Hypothetical. A restrictive covenant recorded in 1987 bars any structure within twenty feet of the rear line of the lots in a Saratoga County subdivision. Your buyer never opens the file and buys the lot planning a garage across the back. He had constructive notice from the day the covenant was recorded, because the document sits in a public office anyone may walk into. His plans are not a defense and neither is his surprise.

What makes a title unmarketable in practice is rarely dramatic. An open mortgage that was paid off in 2003 and never satisfied of record. A judgment against a person with your seller's name. An estate that was never fully probated. A boundary line that the survey and the deed describe differently. None of those are accusations against anybody. All of them are defects that would expose a purchaser to litigation, and that is the test.

This is also why the title search is ordered early. The search is not a formality performed the week of the closing. It is the step that finds the problem while there is still time to clear it, and clearing a problem usually means finding a person, getting a signature, and recording a document. Every one of those takes days that nobody has in the last week.

CAUTION: Recording protects the party who records. It is not a favor to the county and it is not a formality. The recorded deed takes precedence over the prior unrecorded deed, and that is a rule with a winner and a loser in it.

The record charges you, read or not

REMEMBER: Say the difference between constructive notice and actual notice in one sentence, then say which one your buyer has before the title search and which one he has after.

Chain of Title, Clouds, and the Abstract

Tracing successive conveyances back through the public record

The chain of title is a clear and unbroken chronological record of the ownership of a specific piece of property. Tracing the chain of title means tracing the successive conveyances of title, starting with the current deed and going back a suitable number of years. Each owner is linked to the previous owner and to the next owner through deeds, and the links, taken together, are the chain as disclosed in the public records.

In New York, chains of title, if unbroken, date all the way back to a grant from the King of England. That is a piece of trivia with a practical edge. This state has been conveying land for four hundred years, in several languages, through several legal systems, and every one of those conveyances is somebody's link. Nobody searches back to the King in practice. A searcher goes back a suitable number of years, and the standard for what counts as suitable is set by the title company and the lender rather than by you.

A gap in the chain of title creates uncertainty, and that uncertainty is called a cloud on the title. A cloud is also called color of title. The cause can be something perfectly ordinary. Sue Jones buys a house. She gets married and becomes Sue Smith. When she sells, the grantor name on the deed is Sue Smith, and the searcher reading the record sees a stranger conveying property that belongs to Sue Jones. That is a break in the chain.

Clouds come from small human events. A name change. A misspelling. A missing middle initial. A deed signed by one of two owners. An heir nobody listed. A satisfaction of mortgage that was paid but never recorded. None of these are frauds and all of them stop a closing, because a lender will not fund against a chain with a hole in it.

A suit to quiet title may be required to close any missing links and remove the cloud. A suit to quiet title is a lawsuit filed to determine and resolve problems of the instruments conveying a particular piece of land. Its purpose is to clear a particular known claim, title defect or perceived defect. In New York this is accomplished through an Article 15 proceeding under the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law. To close the gap and clear the cloud, the court may issue a quitclaim deed or a judicial deed.

Hypothetical. Your listing in Orange County was bought in 1996 by a couple who divorced in 2004. The husband's interest was supposed to pass to the wife in the settlement, and no deed was ever recorded. She is your seller and she cannot deliver marketable title today, because half the record title still sits with a man who has not lived there in twenty years. Either he signs a deed, or the seller brings an Article 15 proceeding. Both take time, and the time is why the title search happens early and not the week of the closing.

How far back is a suitable number of years? The searcher goes back far enough to satisfy the lender and the title insurer that the chain holds, and the practice varies by county and by the age of the record. That vagueness is not sloppiness. It is the system admitting that a chain reaching to the seventeenth century has to stop somewhere, and that the stopping point is a question of risk rather than of law.

A title search, usually performed by an abstractor or a title company, starts with the chain of title and results in the creation of an abstract of title. An abstract of title is a summarized chronological history of title to a property, listing all recorded documents that affect the title. A title abstractor examines public records of deeds, taxes, special assessments, liens, judgments, mortgages and other encumbrances that have ever affected the property, even if the encumbrance has since been removed or satisfied.

An abstract of title does not ensure the validity of the title. There is no guarantee associated with this type of title evidence, so the homeowner or the lender has no recourse if title defects are discovered later. On rare occasions an abstract could be accepted in place of title insurance, if a satisfactory letter of opinion from an attorney is issued regarding the quality of the title. Know that exception and know how rare it is.

An affidavit of title, also referred to as a continuation, is a statement sworn in front of a notary public or other authorized official by the seller or grantor. It identifies the grantor, identifies the grantor's marital status, and certifies that the grantor has no new judgments, liens, divorces, unrecorded deeds or other potential title defects since the title examination was completed.

The affidavit of title also certifies that the grantor is in possession of the property and that there are no tenants on the property. It is used to bring down the title report from its preliminary issuance to the current date, as may be required at settlement. The title report was true on the day it was pulled. The affidavit is the seller swearing that nothing has happened since.

Title insurance protects lenders, and sometimes property owners, against loss due to disputes over ownership of a property and defects in the title not found in the search of the public record. It protects against claimants not listed in the policy, including defects in the public record such as forged documents, improper deeds, undisclosed heirs, errors in a property's legal description and other mistakes. A title insurance policy is generally paid for with a one-time premium.

Title insurance does not generally cure defects. A title company could potentially purchase the property and fix the problem, and more commonly it simply insures against losses up to the coverage amount specified in the policy, for title defects other than those specifically excluded. The policy may require the title company to go to court if necessary to defend its policyholder against a claim against ownership of the land, and that duty to defend is a large part of what the premium buys.

There are four policies and each one names a different insured. A mortgagee's policy protects the lender's interests, for the loan amount outstanding at the time a claim is paid. An owner's policy is issued in the name of the property owner and runs from the time of purchase for as long as the policyholder owns the property. A leasehold policy is less common, taken by lessees who invest a substantial amount of money in a property, such as a building owned on leased land. An easement policy is also less common, and it protects an easement owner's interests across another's property.

The owner's policy carries the fact students forget. When the property is sold, the new buyer must purchase a new policy and be named beneficiary in order to collect on a claim from a title defect. Coverage does not ride along with the land to the next owner. Owner's and mortgagee's policies typically coincide, so the title insurance issuer is not paying twice on the same claim.

Put the four documents of this screen in the order a transaction meets them. The chain of title is what the searcher traces. The abstract is what the search produces. The affidavit of title is what the seller swears to at the end, to cover the gap between the search and the table. The title insurance policy is what the buyer and the lender actually rely on afterward. Four documents, one sequence, and each one answers a question the one before it left open.

NOTE: Separate the three pieces of title evidence in your head. The abstract is a history and guarantees nothing. The affidavit of title is a sworn statement bringing the report up to the minute. Title insurance is the only one of the three that pays a claim.

An abstract reports; only insurance pays

REMEMBER: Your buyer asks why he needs an owner's policy when the lender already required one. What does the lender's policy cover, and who is left uninsured without his own?

The Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act

Federal, 1974, implemented as Regulation X and enforced by the CFPB

The federal Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act of 1974, known as RESPA, requires mortgage lenders, mortgage brokers and servicers of home loans to provide borrowers with pertinent and timely disclosures of the nature and costs of the real estate settlement process. Its purpose is to regulate settlement and closing procedures and to protect borrowers. RESPA is implemented as Regulation X and is administered and enforced by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

RESPA applies when the purchase of a one- to four-family house is financed by a federally related mortgage loan. That covers loans from banks and credit unions, loans insured by the FHA, and loans guaranteed by the VA, which in practice is nearly every residential mortgage a salesperson will ever see. RESPA does not apply to vacant land, and it does not apply to loans involving 25 acres or more.

Two exclusions and one inclusion is the whole coverage test, and exam questions are built out of it. One to four family, financed by a federally related mortgage loan: RESPA applies. Vacant land: RESPA does not apply. Twenty-five acres or more: RESPA does not apply. A cash purchase of a house has no federally related mortgage loan in it, so there is nothing for RESPA to attach to.

RESPA prohibits a required use of specific settlement service providers, with some exceptions for lenders. Required use is the practice of telling a consumer that he must use this title company, this attorney, this insurer, in order to get the deal or the price. A recommendation is lawful. A requirement is not.

RESPA defines settlement services broadly, as any service provided in connection with a prospective or actual settlement. The definition matters because everything inside it is inside RESPA's rules about referrals and fees, and the list reaches a great deal further than most new agents assume.

Services by a real estate broker are on the list, and they are on it by name. That means the work of making sure the transaction details are handled so the closing proceeds smoothly: appraisals, repairs made or credits agreed to, utility services transferred or set up, condominium move-in and move-out fees paid and paperwork completed, and the final walk-through. Your ordinary week is a settlement service under federal law.

The list continues. Services related to the origination, processing, underwriting or funding of a mortgage loan, including service by a mortgage broker. Title services, including title searches, examinations, abstract preparation and the issuance of title insurance policies. Services by an attorney, including review and modification of the transaction documents. Preparation of documents, including notarization, delivery and recordation.

And it finishes with five more. Rendering of credit reports and appraisals. Inspections. The conducting of settlement by a settlement agent, and any related services. Services involving mortgage, hazard, flood or other casualty insurance, or homeowner's warranties. Services involving real property taxes or any other assessments or charges on the real property.

RESPA exists because settlement used to be a black box. A borrower arrived at a closing, was handed a stack of numbers he had never seen, and signed. The statute's answer was disclosure on a schedule, so that the borrower sees the costs while he can still do something about them, and a set of flat prohibitions on the referral economy that had grown up around those costs.

That shapes how RESPA touches your work. The disclosure duties sit with the lender, the mortgage broker and the servicer. The referral and fee rules sit on everybody in the transaction, including you. A salesperson never prepares a Closing Disclosure and a salesperson can absolutely violate RESPA before lunch.

Hypothetical. Your buyer is purchasing forty acres upstate with a bank loan and asks whether he gets the federal protections he read about online. The loan involves 25 acres or more, so RESPA does not apply to it. Change the parcel to a half-acre lot with a house on it and the same loan from the same bank is a federally related mortgage loan on a one- to four-family house, and RESPA applies in full.

CAUTION: Do not learn that list as trivia. Learn it as the boundary of your own exposure. Every provider on it is a provider somebody may be tempted to pay you to recommend, and the next screen is about what happens when they do.

One to four family, federally related loan

REMEMBER: A buyer is paying cash for a two-family house in Utica. Does RESPA apply to that transaction, and why?

RESPA: The Provisions You Will Be Tested On

Sections 8 and 9, affiliated business, escrow, and penalties

Section 8 of RESPA prohibits giving or accepting a fee, a kickback, or anything of value in exchange for referrals of settlement service business. A referral is any oral or written action directed to a person that has the effect of affirmatively influencing the selection of a provider of a settlement service or business. RESPA defines a thing of value very broadly, and it can include money, services, discounts and unusual banking terms.

Both halves of that sentence bite. Giving is prohibited and accepting is prohibited. The agent who takes the check and the company that writes it are both on the wrong side of Section 8, and the breadth of thing of value is what catches people who would never take cash. A free printer. A paid seat at a conference. A loan on terms nobody else in the office could get. All of it counts.

Section 9 of RESPA prohibits a seller from requiring the homebuyer to use a particular title insurance company, either directly or indirectly, as a condition of sale. A buyer may sue a seller who violates this required use provision for an amount equal to three times all charges made for the title insurance. The remedy is written into the statute and it is written as a multiple, so it is a number worth memorizing exactly.

RESPA does recognize the legitimacy of affiliated business arrangements. An affiliated business arrangement, or AfBA, is a situation where a person in a position to refer settlement services has either an affiliate relationship with, or a direct or beneficial ownership interest of more than 1 percent in, a provider of settlement services. Under RESPA it is acceptable for that person to refer business to that provider or to influence the selection of that provider.

The condition is disclosure. Whenever a settlement service provider in a RESPA covered transaction refers the consumer to a provider in which the referring party has an ownership or other beneficial interest, that relationship must be disclosed. The referring party must give the AfBA disclosure to the consumer at or prior to the time of referral. Not at the closing. Not when it comes up. At or before the referral.

RESPA also limits the escrow reserves a lender may require at closing for hazard insurance and property taxes, to no more than the amount required for two months. Those reserves show up as escrow collection in the buyer's closing costs later in this chapter, and a borrower who is being asked for more than two months of reserves has a question for his lender.

Four kinds of payment are allowed. Payment of fees to attorneys, title companies or agents for services actually performed. Payment of a bona fide salary or compensation to a person for goods or products actually furnished, or services actually performed, in the making of a loan. Payments pursuant to cooperative brokerage and referral arrangements or agreements between real estate agents and brokers. And legitimate package discounts on a combination of settlement services, as long as use of the combination is optional to the purchaser and the lower combined price is not made up by higher costs elsewhere in the settlement.

Three things are prohibited. Fee-splitting. Receiving unearned fees. And receiving a percentage of any charge made or received for services not actually performed. The phrase that ties all three together is actually performed, and it is the phrase to test any offer against. If work was done, a fee for it is lawful. If no work was done, the payment is for the referral, whatever the invoice calls it.

The penalties are criminal and civil, and they run together. Fines up to $10,000. Imprisonment up to one year. And liability up to three times the amount of the charge paid for the service, in a civil lawsuit brought by the consumer.

Section 8 and Section 9 answer two different questions and the exam counts on you confusing them. Section 8 is about payments for referrals, and it binds everybody in the transaction. Section 9 is about a seller forcing a buyer's choice of title insurer, and its remedy is three times all charges made for the title insurance. One is about money moving toward a referrer. The other is about a condition placed on a sale.

Hypothetical. A title company offers to pay your office $300 for each closing you send it, and calls the payment a marketing fee. Nobody at your office performs any service for that money. That is a thing of value in exchange for a referral of settlement service business, so Section 8 is broken by the company paying it and by the licensee taking it. The cooperative brokerage exception does not help, because that exception covers arrangements between real estate agents and brokers, not between a broker and a title company.

CAUTION: The most dangerous version of this on the job does not look like a bribe. It looks like a friend, a sponsorship and a favor. Ask one question of every arrangement. What service was actually performed for this money?

Paid for work, lawful; paid for referrals, not

REMEMBER: Name the three penalties under RESPA, then say what an affiliated business arrangement needs in order to be lawful and when that has to happen.

The Closing

Two closings happen at once, and everyone in the room has a job

A closing, also called a title closing or a settlement, is the final step in a real estate transaction, when the transfer of real property ownership from seller to buyer occurs according to the terms and conditions in the sales contract. In most real estate transactions two closings take place simultaneously, and a student who can name both has understood the day.

The first is the closing of the buyer's mortgage loan and the disbursement of funds. Sellers are paid the balance of the purchase price. Existing liens, such as a mortgage, are satisfied out of those funds. Buyers typically pay the balance of the purchase price with a combination of a mortgage loan and personal funds, which is why the lender is in the room.

The second is the closing of the sale and the transfer of title. Before a real estate transaction closes, all conditions and contingencies of the sales contract must be met. Once all parties are satisfied that the conditions and contingencies have been met, the deed can be executed and delivered, transferring title to the new owner. The deed is the last thing to move and it moves only when everything else has cleared.

A closing is usually a face-to-face meeting of all interested parties, and the sales contract typically identifies when and where it takes place. Closings are generally held at the title company's office, the broker's office, the lending institution, or one of the participating attorneys' offices. The closing may be conducted by an attorney, a broker, or a title company representative, sometimes called a closing agent or a settlement officer.

Each participant has a distinct role. Buyers attend to pay for and receive title to the property. Sellers attend to grant their property to the buyers and to receive payment. The buyer's and seller's attorneys are present to review all closing documents to ensure they are in their clients' best interests.

Real estate agents are there to fulfill their fiduciary obligation to their clients to account for all monies transacted. That is the whole of the agent's formal role and it is not a small one. Deposits, credits, adjustments and commission all pass through the statement, and accounting for money held for a client is a duty you will meet again in the agency material.

A mortgage company representative examines all loan documents, makes sure the property for which the mortgage is being issued has a clear title, prepares the settlement statement, and disburses funds to the seller. Title company representatives review the documents and, once satisfied, deliver evidence that the title is insured.

The broker's role varies by region. In some areas it is customary for brokers to step out of the picture once they have brought about a meeting of the minds, turning things over to the attorneys for the seller and the buyer. In other areas brokers remain involved all the way through the closing, advising the client and staying in contact with all parties to make sure everything needed to close is in place.

One piece of the broker's role does not vary. Brokers attend a final walk-through with buyers on the day of closing or immediately prior to it. The walk-through is where an agent earns a reputation, because it is the last moment before the money moves when a missing appliance, a broken window or a tenant still in the basement can be dealt with at somebody else's expense.

Even though brokers are not typically responsible for conducting the closing, a broker fulfills the fiduciary obligations of care and accountability by making sure the closing follows the terms of the written sales contract. Regardless of the extent of the broker's participation, the broker's commission is paid at the closing.

The mechanics of getting paid are worth knowing before your first check. Prior to the closing, the broker submits a commission statement to the participating attorneys or to the closing agent, and a check is cut to the broker for the commission earned. The broker is then responsible for distributing the commission to his agents and to any cooperating agents according to their agreement. The check goes to the broker. It does not come to you directly, and no closing agent is going to hand you one.

The walk-through has a short list and it is the same list every time. Is the property in the condition the contract requires? Are the fixtures and appliances the contract included still there? Were the agreed repairs made? Is the property empty of people and of everything the seller was supposed to remove? You are not inspecting the house. You are comparing the house to the contract.

Hypothetical. You represent the buyer on a house in Albany County. The lender is ready, the title report is clean, and at the walk-through on the morning of the closing the seller's washer and dryer, which were listed in the contract, are gone. That is a contract term, the closing has not happened yet, and the moment to raise it is now. After the deed is delivered your buyer owns a house and a grievance.

Conditions and contingencies are the reason a closing date in a contract is a target rather than a promise. A mortgage contingency, an inspection contingency, a contingency on the sale of the buyer's current home, a repair the seller agreed to make: each one is a condition that must be met before the transaction closes. Your job through those weeks is to know which conditions are still open and who is holding each one.

NOTE: Two closings, one meeting. The loan closes and funds are disbursed. The sale closes and title transfers. Any question that asks what happens at a closing is asking you to keep those two tracks separate.

The commission is paid at the closing

REMEMBER: Name the six participants and the job each one is there to do. Then say who actually hands you your commission.

Typical Closing Documents

The sales contract dictates what the closing requires

One of the most important documents needed to prepare for a closing is the sales contract itself. The terms of the sales contract dictate the requirements of the closing, including which documents have to be there. If the transaction involves the transfer of personal property from the seller to the buyer, a bill of sale may be required. Not every document below is applicable to every closing, and several of them are presented and reviewed at almost all of them.

The deed. At closing the seller, as grantor, provides a new signed deed to the buyer, as grantee. To take effect, the deed must be delivered by the grantor with the intention of transferring title. Once the grantee accepts the deed, she holds title to the land. Everything in the first half of this chapter lands on this one document at this one moment.

The survey. A survey is the process of determining the physical size and boundaries of a property, and in some transactions the buyer or the buyer's lender will require one to make sure the property description is accurate. If the mortgage company requires a survey, the buyer usually bears the cost of it. In certain counties in New York the seller pays for it instead, so this is a local-custom item to ask your broker about before you promise a client anything.

Mortgage documentation comes in two parts and students mix them up every year. The financing instrument is typically a promissory note, a written promise to repay the money owed, signed by the borrower. The security instrument is usually the mortgage, which provides security for the debt by creating a voluntary lien against the property. The buyer signs the mortgage and gives it to the lender as security for repayment of the note.

The mortgage must be recorded at the county clerk's office in the county where the property is located, to ensure constructive notice to the public and to establish lien priority. Recording is doing two separate jobs there. It tells the world the lien exists, and it fixes the lien's place in line against every other claim on the property.

If the seller still has a mortgage on the property, the buyer's lender typically brings a check in the payoff amount made out to the seller's mortgagee. Once the seller's lender is paid, that lender issues a satisfaction of mortgage, which should be recorded as evidence that the lien has been released. Under New York law, lenders have 45 days after the request from the mortgagor to record the satisfaction of mortgage.

Homeowners insurance. Lenders require homeowners insurance policies sufficient to replace the home or reimburse the mortgage amount in the event of a fire or other disaster. Depending on the location of the property, flood insurance may also be required. A binder that is not in place on the morning of the closing stops the closing, and it is the kind of small item an attentive agent tracks in the week before.

Property inspection reports and certificates of occupancy. Lenders require a pest inspection. Buyers may also want a home inspection. Other inspections a buyer or lender may require include structural integrity, septic systems, soil and waterflow, which are called percolation or perc tests, and radon gas, among others. Some municipalities require a certificate of occupancy as evidence that the property is inhabitable.

IRS Form 1099-S. For sales or exchanges of certain real estate, the settlement officer must report the seller's proceeds to the Internal Revenue Service using IRS Form 1099-S. Generally this is a requirement only for title transfers involving the sale of principal residences with gross sales prices above $500,000 for sellers who are married couples, or above $250,000 for sellers who are single taxpayers. Many settlement officers choose to submit the report for every transaction anyway.

New York requires two forms of its own, and both of them are exam material. Form TP-584 is the Combined Real Estate Transfer Tax Return, Credit Line Mortgage Certificate, and Certification of Exemption from the Payment of Estimated Personal Income Tax. All transfers of real property in the state of New York require it. Among other things, it transmits the New York State transfer tax and exempts New York State residents from owing state capital gains tax on the sale of the property. Form TP-584 must be signed by both buyer and seller at closing before the deed can be recorded.

Form RP-5217 is the Real Property Transfer Report. The New York State Office of Real Property Services requires it to accompany the deed when the deed is recorded. The form documents the details of the property transfer so that property tax records can be updated. New York City has its own version, Form RP-5217NYC, which must accompany the deed along with the filing fee when it is recorded there.

Hypothetical. Your closing in Westchester is set for Friday. The lender's package is ready, the title report is clean, and the seller's attorney has not produced a signed TP-584. The deed cannot be recorded without it, so the buyer would leave the table holding an instrument that nobody can put on the public record. Forms are not paperwork at a closing. Forms are the closing.

Evidence of title belongs on this list too, and in most New York transactions that evidence is a title insurance policy rather than an abstract with an attorney's opinion attached. The lender will not fund without its own policy, so the policy is produced at or before the closing as a matter of course.

NOTE: Two form numbers, two jobs. TP-584 carries the transfer tax and is signed by both parties at closing before the deed can be recorded. RP-5217 travels with the deed so the assessor can update the tax roll. Learn the numbers with the jobs attached and the exam question answers itself.

TP-584 pays the tax; RP-5217 updates the roll

REMEMBER: Name the two instruments in the mortgage package and say which one creates the lien. Then name the two New York forms and say which one has to be signed by both parties.

The Closing Disclosure

The standardized settlement statement under the TRID rule

A settlement statement is the balance sheet that itemizes all expenses and costs paid by the buyer and the seller to close the real estate transaction, including loan origination costs, all sales commissions, and any other charges that either the borrower or the seller will pay at settlement, as well as charges paid outside of settlement. For each separately identified settlement service, the name of the person ultimately receiving the payment must be shown together with the total amount paid to that person.

The standardized settlement statement is the Closing Disclosure. It is a five-page document that must be used in all RESPA-related transactions, meaning any one- to four-family residential property financed by a federally related mortgage loan. The Closing Disclosure is defined under the TILA-RESPA Integrated Disclosure rule, known as TRID, promulgated by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

The Closing Disclosure replaced two older documents at once. It replaces the HUD-1 Settlement Statement, which was standard in real estate transactions for decades, and it replaces the final Truth in Lending Statement that was required under the Truth in Lending Act. One form now does the work of both, and an exam question that names either of the old forms is asking about this one.

The settlement officer and the lender generally collaborate to gather the data and the calculations needed to prepare the Closing Disclosure. Either one of them may prepare the final version. The lender is ultimately responsible for making sure the Closing Disclosure is available for the borrower's inspection at least three business days prior to loan consummation, and the lender must also obtain proof that the borrower received it.

A Closing Disclosure must be prepared for the buyer and for the seller, although it is permissible for the buyer's copy to show only his information and the seller's to show only hers. Where the purchase does not involve any federally related financing, the Closing Disclosure is not required, and it may still be used for the sake of convenience. A cash closing has no lender in it, so it has nothing to trigger the rule.

Pages one through five each carry their own job. Page one gives details about the transaction and the loan terms, including total payments. Page two itemizes the specific closing costs paid by the buyer and by the seller in separate columns, and page two is where you can see the commission paid to real estate brokers. Page three presents a summary of the transaction details and compares the actual costs with those the buyer received in the Loan Estimate. Pages four and five are of interest mainly to the buyer, with details about the loan characteristics and terms.

An updated Closing Disclosure is required in three situations. The annual percentage rate increases by more than one-eighth of a percent for fixed-rate loans or one-quarter of a percent for adjustable loans. A prepayment penalty is added, which could make it expensive to refinance or sell the property in the early years of the loan. Or the basic loan product changes, such as a switch from a fixed rate to an adjustable rate, or to a loan with interest-only payments.

An updated Closing Disclosure triggers another three business day waiting period before closing can take place. Hold on to that consequence, because it is where the rule reaches your calendar. Last-minute negotiations can push a closing by most of a week. Scheduling back-to-back closings, where the sale of one property is contingent on the closing of another, is risky for exactly this reason.

Most costs appear on the Closing Disclosure and some do not. When an item is paid outside of closing, the party pays the provider directly, and the charge may not appear on the statement at all. A charge paid in advance that does appear on a closing statement is marked P.O.C., for paid outside of closing. Fees for a professional home inspection are a common example, and so are the attorney's fees one of the parties pays personally.

Hypothetical. Your buyer's closing is set for Thursday morning. On Tuesday the lender switches him from a fixed rate to an adjustable product to keep the payment where he wanted it. The basic loan product has changed, so an updated Closing Disclosure is required, and the update triggers another three business day waiting period. Thursday is gone, and so is the moving truck he booked for Friday.

CAUTION: Three business days is a minimum for inspection, and the lender must obtain proof the borrower received it. A disclosure emailed on the morning of the closing satisfies nothing at all, whatever the parties agree to among themselves.

Three business days, and the clock restarts

REMEMBER: Name the two documents the Closing Disclosure replaced. Then name the three changes that force a new one and say what each new one costs you in time.

Who Pays What

Every item is negotiable; these are the defaults

Any cost to a buyer or a seller can be listed on a settlement statement, and the payment of any item is always negotiable between buyer and seller. What follows are the defaults, meaning who customarily pays in a New York residential transaction when nobody negotiates anything. Learn the defaults. Then read the contract in front of you, because the contract beats the custom every time.

Sellers can expect to pay attorney fees, which vary with the type of representation provided and the amount of work involved. Sellers pay the broker's commission, which is typically a percentage of the property's sale price. When a buyer's broker is involved, the buyer's broker may be paid a percentage of the selling broker's commission through a cooperative arrangement as detailed in the sales contract.

Condominium and cooperative sellers have two more items. Condo or co-op fees are assessments for maintenance of common areas and other items, and before closing the seller must bring the account current. Co-op owners may also be required to pay a flip tax upon the sale or transfer of a cooperative. The flip tax may equal 1 percent to 5 percent of the purchase price, and it is not paid to the city or the state. It is paid to the cooperative corporation.

Existing liens on the property are generally satisfied prior to closing, although it is not a legal requirement. In a cash transaction, for example, a buyer has the right to purchase the property subject to outstanding liens. Sellers also pay recording fees when they have to file a discharge of mortgage or satisfactions of judgments through their attorneys.

Sellers are required to pay the New York State real estate transfer tax, which is a tax on the sale of real property. The amount of any mortgage being assumed is subtracted from the tax owed, so only new funds brought to the transaction are taxed. Assumptions are rare, so in most transactions the full price is the base.

TRANSFER TAX MATH

$4 per $1,000 of the purchase price, or fractional part thereof, rounded up to the next $2 up to $500, and to the next $4 above $500.

Purchase price $120,300 → $120,300 ÷ $1,000 = $120.30 × $4 = $481.20 → rounded up to the next $2 = $483.

Mansion tax: an additional 1% of the sale price on residences where consideration is $1 million or more. Prior to 1983 the transfer tax was $1.10 per $1,000. A gift transfer owes no transfer tax; with new construction the developer may require the buyer to pay it.

Buyers pay a longer list, and most of it comes from the lender. Appraisal, credit report and survey fees are typically charged to buyers by lenders as part of the mortgage application process. Buyers pay their own attorney's fees, and if the lender has an attorney, the buyers are responsible for those fees as well.

Bank fees are a set of charges payable to the lender at closing. An origination fee compensates the lender for making the loan. Points are charged for a variety of reasons, such as to lower the interest rate or to accommodate a higher risk borrower or a higher risk property, and one point is equal to 1 percent of the loan amount. Escrow collection covers hazard insurance and property taxes. A tax service fee offsets the cost of monitoring the escrow account for property taxes. And private mortgage insurance may be charged as well.

Mortgage insurance protects the lender in the event the buyer defaults on the home loan. If the buyer puts down more than 20 percent of the purchase price, mortgage insurance is usually not required. FHA loans always require mortgage insurance, whatever the buyer puts down.

Buyers also pay condo or co-op fee adjustments for assessments the seller already paid covering services the buyer will use. Buyers pay for a home inspection if they want one, and home inspections, though strongly encouraged, are not a lender requirement. Lenders do require a termite inspection, and the buyer pays for that one.

MORTGAGE RECORDING TAX

Mortgage recording tax: 0.75% of the mortgage; 1.25% in counties with public transportation, where the buyer pays 1% and the lender 0.25%

Buyers round the list out with recording fees paid to the county clerk for filing the deed, the mortgage and Form RP-5217, with the title search and title insurance the lender requires to ensure a good marketable title, and with a flood certification fee, which pays for the analysis of whether the property sits in a flood zone and therefore requires flood insurance.

CLOSINGS IN NEW YORK CITY

Documents are filed and recorded in the Register's Office. The City imposes an additional transfer tax of 1% of the purchase price of residential property up to $500,000, and 1.425% above $500,000.

Two habits will keep you out of trouble on this screen for an entire career. The first is to read the contract before you answer any question about who pays what, because the defaults are custom and the contract is law between the parties. The second is to ask your broker what the custom is in your county, because New York is not one market and survey costs, title company selection and even which attorney orders the search vary from one end of this state to the other.

There is one more reason the buyer's list runs longer than the seller's. Most of the buyer's costs are not costs of the property. They are costs of the loan. Origination, points, escrow collection, tax service, mortgage insurance, the appraisal, the credit report, the flood certification and the mortgage recording tax all exist because somebody is lending money. A cash buyer's closing costs are a fraction of the list above, and that is worth explaining to a seller comparing two offers.

Hypothetical. Your seller in Brooklyn is selling a co-op and asks you what the sale will cost her. Attorney fees. Your commission. Maintenance brought current. A flip tax paid to the cooperative corporation. The New York State transfer tax. And a New York City transfer tax on top of it. She will ask you for numbers, and the only honest answer is that her attorney will give her a figure. You can name the items. You do not quote the tax.

CAUTION: Every rate on this screen is a rate the Legislature can change, and several have changed since your instructor first taught them. Name the item and hand the arithmetic to the attorney or the title company. A licensee who quotes a tax figure that turns out to be wrong has cost a client money.

Name the item; the attorney quotes the number

REMEMBER: List the six things a New York seller typically pays. Then say which of them a co-op seller owes that a house seller never will.

Debits, Credits, and Prorations

Dividing a shared expense in proportion to actual usage

To understand the final distribution of money in a transaction, a licensee has to be comfortable with two words. Debits are like debts. A debit is a sum of money owed, charged to a particular party on the balance sheet to represent money that must be paid out. Credits are sums of money received. A credit is given to a particular party to represent money that is paid by another party, or that has already been paid.

Debits and credits work together when reconciling the settlement statement, and reconciliation is simply making the two sides agree. All debits owed by the buyer are totaled and added to the purchase price. Then the credits are totaled and subtracted, and what is left is the money the buyer must bring to closing.

The mortgage amount shows up as a credit to the buyer. That surprises students every single time, and the reason is plain once you say it out loud. The lender brings that money to the closing on the buyer's behalf, so it is money already provided toward the price, and money already provided is a credit.

A similar process runs on the seller's side. All credits due to the seller are totaled and added to the purchase price. All debits owed are totaled and subtracted from the total money due, and the difference is what the seller actually walks away with. Every item on the statement lands in one of those four boxes, and prorations are simply the items that have to be split before they can be placed.

Proration is the division of expenses between buyer and seller in proportion to the actual usage of the item represented by that expense. A proration is also known as an adjustment. To adjust a cost shared by both parties, first determine whether the expense is accrued or prepaid, because that single question decides who gets the credit and who takes the debit.

Accrued expenses are items for which the cost has been incurred but the expense has not yet been paid. Unpaid recurring assessments and mortgage interest are the standard examples. Accrued items start from the position that nothing has been paid, so the seller's portion is calculated, the seller is debited for it, and the buyer is credited.

Prepaid expenses are items the seller has already paid. Homeowners insurance, association fees, utility bills, and some property or special assessment taxes may be prepaid. Since the seller has already paid, the seller is entitled to a credit for the portion paid that he will not use, and the buyer takes the matching debit.

Hypothetical. A transaction closes on May 31. The neighborhood has a special assessment for sidewalks and the next payment is due June 30. The seller lived in the house for five of the six months the unpaid assessment covers, so that portion is prorated on the settlement statement as a debit to the seller and a credit to the buyer. Nothing has been paid yet, so the seller pays his share by handing it to the buyer, who will pay the whole bill at the end of June.

The items that get adjusted at a New York closing are the recurring ones. Real estate taxes and special assessments. Insurance. Fuel left in the tank. Water and sewer charges. Rent, when the property is tenanted. And tenants' security deposits, which transfer to the new owner rather than being split. Buyers and sellers also sometimes share the cost of surveys, inspections and lender fees, and those are easy, because they are negotiated or calculated as a percentage rather than by days of usage.

Five steps produce every proration on the exam. Determine whether the expense is accrued or prepaid. Divide the expense by the appropriate period to find a monthly or daily rate. Determine how many months or days are affected. Multiply the rate by the number of affected months or days. Then determine which party is credited and which is debited.

Security deposits deserve a separate line in your head, because they are not an expense and they are not prorated. A deposit is the tenant's money that the landlord is holding. When the property sells, the deposit moves to the new owner in full, and the tenants must be notified of the transfer.

NOTE: Step one and step five are the same question asked twice. Accrued means nothing has been paid, so the seller is debited and the buyer is credited. Prepaid means the seller already paid, so the seller is credited and the buyer is debited. Get step one right and step five writes itself.

Accrued debits the seller; prepaid credits him

REMEMBER: The mortgage amount sits in the buyer's column as a credit. Say why, out loud, before you go on.

Working a Proration

The factor matters: a 360-day year of twelve 30-day months, or a 365-day year of actual days

Before any proration arithmetic, know the factor you are working with. Expenses may be prorated using a 360-day year, made of twelve months of 30 days each. Or they may be prorated using a 365-day year, counting the exact number of days in each month and taking leap years into account. The same facts give two different answers under the two factors, so the factor is the first thing to establish and the first thing an exam question will tell you.

Example one uses a 360-day year. Property taxes of $2,140 are due at the beginning of the year. The transaction closes on September 15. Step one: property taxes are a prepaid item that the seller paid. Step two: $2,140 divided by 12 is $178.33 per month, and $178.33 divided by 30 is $5.94 per day.

Step three: September 15 to September 30 is 16 days, and October through December is 3 months. Step four: 16 days at $5.94 is $95.04, and 3 months at $178.33 is $534.99, which add to $630.03. Step five: that is tax the seller paid for time he will not own the house, so the seller takes a credit of $630.03 and the buyer takes a debit of $630.03. Work it on paper and you will get the same $630.03.

Example two uses a 365-day year. Condominium fees of $275.50 were paid on the first of the month. The transaction closes on July 17. Step one: condo fees are a prepaid item that the seller paid. Step two: July has 31 days, so $275.50 divided by 31 is $8.89 per day.

Step three: July 17 to July 31 is 15 days. Step four: 15 days at $8.89 is $133.35. Step five: seller credit of $133.35, buyer debit of $133.35. Notice that the daily rate came from the actual length of the month rather than from 30, and that is the only difference between the two methods once you are inside the arithmetic.

Both examples are prepaid, and both end the same way. The seller paid ahead. The seller leaves. The unused part comes back to the seller as a credit and is charged to the buyer as a debit, because the buyer is the one who will use it. An accrued item runs the other way and the five steps do not change.

A proration question on the exam will hand you the factor, the annual or monthly amount, the closing date and nothing else. Everything you need is in those three items. Write the five steps down the side of your scratch paper and fill them in. Students lose these questions by doing the arithmetic in their heads and skipping step one, which is the step that decides the direction of the whole answer.

Four notes finish the topic, and the first is about dates. Generally in New York, buyers become the owners of the property they purchase on the closing date. In practice, either the buyer or the seller may be charged with that day's fees and expenses, so the contract decides who owns the closing day for accounting purposes.

Actual possession of the property may take place several days, weeks or even months after the closing. Where that happens, the sales contract should note who is responsible for which expenses until the new owner takes possession. Ownership and possession are two different dates and a contract that treats them as one date creates an argument.

The second note is the factor again, because it is the most common source of a wrong answer. In some areas, unless specifically noted otherwise, interest, taxes, utility bills and similar expenses are calculated using 360 days in a year and 30 days in a month. In other areas, prorations are calculated using the actual number of days in the calendar month of closing and 365 days in a year. Find out which factor applies before you compute anything.

The third note is special assessments. In some cases sellers are expected to pay off special assessments before the transaction can close. Special assessments are usually levied for municipal improvements such as street repairs and the installation of sidewalks and sewers, and they are usually payable over several years, which is why they show up mid-stream in a sale.

The fourth note is rental property, and it matters in a state where so much property is tenanted. When rental property is sold, the rent is commonly prorated on the basis of the actual number of days in the month of closing. Buyers often agree to collect any unpaid rent for the current month and remit a share of it to the seller, since the property was still the seller's when the rent was due.

Tenants' security deposits are transferred by the seller to the new property owner. They are not prorated and they are not the seller's to keep. Even though the transfer may be invisible to the tenants, the law requires that tenants be notified of the transfer of the deposit.

One habit catches most of the errors before they reach a client. After you compute a proration, look at the answer and ask whether it is roughly the right size. In example one the seller prepaid $2,140 for a full year and owned the property for about eight and a half months of it, so a credit of a little over a quarter of the bill is what you would expect. A credit of $630.03 against a $2,140 bill is 29 percent of it, and that is the right neighborhood. An answer that comes out at half the bill or at twice it is telling you that a step went wrong.

CAUTION: Check the day count before you check the multiplication. Most proration errors are off by exactly one day, and an off-by-one day error survives every recount of the arithmetic because the arithmetic is fine.

Establish the factor before you compute

REMEMBER: Take example one and rerun it on a 365-day year. Which number changes first, and which of the five steps are untouched?

Session Summary

Nine things to carry out of this chapter

Deed and title. The deed is the document the owner of real property uses to transfer all or part of an interest to another, and it is mere evidence of title. Title is the actual lawful ownership, which means holding the bundle of rights conveyed, and title is a theory pertaining to ownership rather than a document. Equitable title arises on the execution of a valid sales contract, and actual title passes by deed at closing.

The ten elements. A competent grantor. An identifiable grantee. The act of conveyance, which is the granting clause. Consideration. A legal description. The habendum clause, which begins to have and to hold. Limitations, such as deed restrictions. Exceptions and reservations, which are the subject to clauses. The grantor's signature. And delivery of the deed with acceptance by the grantee, which has to happen while the grantor is alive.

Forms of deed. A full covenant and warranty deed carries all six covenants and gives the grantee the greatest protection: seizin, right to convey, against encumbrances, quiet enjoyment, further assurances, and warranty forever. A bargain and sale deed with covenants warrants only the grantor's own period of ownership. A quitclaim deed warrants nothing. Judicial deeds are named for the role of the court appointee who signs them. All of them validly transfer title.

Legal descriptions. Metes and bounds runs from a point of beginning, clockwise, back to the point of beginning, using distances and compass directions. Section, block and lot describes platted land by reference to a recorded plat. The government survey system is not used in New York, and its numbers are on the exam anyway: 36 sections in a township, 640 acres in a section, one square mile in a section, and 43,560 square feet in an acre.

Transferring ownership. Voluntary alienation covers sales, gifts, dedications and grants. Involuntary alienation covers eminent domain, foreclosure, adverse possession, and natural processes such as accretion, avulsion and reliction. Death is its own category. Testate means a will, probate in surrogate court, and land devised to devisees. Intestate means descent to natural heirs, and escheat to the state when there are no heirs and no creditors.

Marketable title and the record. A title search of the public records determines ownership and the quality of title before conveyance. It starts with the chain of title and produces an abstract of title, which guarantees nothing. A gap in the chain is a cloud, cured in New York by a suit to quiet title under Article 15 of the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law. Everyone has constructive notice of what is recorded. Title insurance is the only piece of title evidence that pays a claim.

RESPA. No kickbacks, no fee-splitting, no unearned fees, and nothing of value in exchange for a referral. Affiliated business arrangements are lawful when the relationship is disclosed at or prior to the time of referral. A seller may not require the buyer to use a particular title insurance company. Penalties run to fines, imprisonment and civil liability of three times the charge paid.

Costs and prorations. Sellers typically pay attorney and broker fees, existing liens, recording fees and the New York State transfer tax. Buyers typically pay lender fees, their own attorney, recording fees, the mortgage recording tax, title insurance and homeowners insurance. Accrued expenses debit the seller and credit the buyer. Prepaid expenses credit the seller and debit the buyer. Prorate on a 360-day year or a 365-day year, and establish which one before you touch the arithmetic.

The closing itself. Two closings happen at once, the loan and the sale. The sales contract dictates what documents the closing requires, and the deed, the note, the mortgage, the insurance binder, the inspections, Form TP-584 and Form RP-5217 are the usual set. The Closing Disclosure must be available for the borrower's inspection at least three business days before consummation, and three changes force a new one and restart that clock. The broker's commission is paid at the closing, to the broker.

A word on how this material is tested. The deed questions are definitional, so learn the vocabulary exactly. The alienation questions are classification questions, so sort the fact pattern by who acted. The RESPA questions are about whether a service was actually performed. The cost questions are about which column an item belongs in. And the proration questions are about the factor and the day count, in that order.

One last thing to carry out of this chapter. Almost everything on these screens is somebody else's job to perform and your job to recognize. The attorney drafts the deed. The surveyor sets the line. The abstractor reads the record. The title company insures it. The lender funds it. You are the person who knows what all of them are doing and who notices when one of them has not done it.

Recognize the document; hand off the advice

REMEMBER: If you could keep only three facts from this chapter, which three would you keep, and could you defend the choice to a client on the phone tomorrow?

You Be The Judge

The Closing at 12 Sycamore

This is an issue-spotting exercise. Read the story through once for the shape of it, then read it again with this chapter open in your head. Everything you need is in the screens you have just finished: the ten essential elements, delivery and acceptance, recording, the deed forms, RESPA sections 8 and 9, the Closing Disclosure timing, and the transfer taxes.

Owen is the broker on 12 Sycamore. To save the parties a fee he drafts the deed himself and reassures the buyer that “title looks clean to me.” The deed he produces describes the property only as “12 Sycamore Street, and improvements,” contains no clause acknowledging any consideration, and follows its granting clause with a habendum clause conveying a life estate. The grantor never signs it; the grantee does, believing that is what makes it binding.

The seller dies on a Tuesday. On Thursday his executor hands the deed to the buyer and everyone calls it delivered. A week later the buyer gets cold feet, drives the deed back to the estate's attorney and says, “Here, undo it.” Owen tells him that settles it, and adds that the earlier deed from the prior owner “was never recorded, so it was void anyway.” When the new deed finally goes to the county clerk, no notary has taken the grantor's acknowledgement.

Epsilon Title sends Owen $500 “for the referral,” which he deposits without mentioning it to anyone. The seller, meanwhile, tells the buyer the deal is contingent on using Epsilon for title insurance. The lender emails the Closing Disclosure to the borrower at 8:00 a.m. on the morning of the closing.

The purchase price is $1,120,300. Owen tells the seller the New York transfer tax is “about $4,480, call it round numbers,” and that because the buyer is putting 25% down there is no mansion tax to worry about. The property is in a county with public transportation; the buyer pays 1% of the mortgage recording tax and the lender pays 0.25%.

Twelve violations are buried in that story, and one lawful act is planted in it to catch you out. Work it in that order. Find the acts first, then name the duty, the statute or the rule each one breaks.

A method that works on a fact pattern this dense. Take one paragraph at a time. In each paragraph, ask who acted, what they did, and which rule from this chapter speaks to it. Write the issue down in four or five words before you move to the next sentence, because an issue you notice and do not write down is an issue you will lose.

Issue-spotting is the skill this whole chapter has been building toward, and it is a working skill before it is an exam skill. A transaction rarely fails because of one enormous mistake. It fails because six small things were each allowed to pass, and the person best placed to notice any of them was the agent standing closest to the parties. That person had to know what a correct version looked like.

Two of the traps are arithmetic rather than conduct, and they are in the last paragraph. Read the numbers as claims that somebody is making, not as facts you are given, and check each claim against the rules on the closing costs screen.

NOTE: One act in this story is perfectly lawful and looks wrong. Finding it is part of the exercise, because the working version of this skill is telling a client which of his worries is real.

Twelve violations, one lawful act

When you have your list, test each item by naming the rule rather than the feeling. Saying that something looks improper is not an answer. Saying that a licensee drafted an instrument, or that a party took a thing of value for a referral, or that a required disclosure arrived too late, is an answer, and it is the form the graded version of this question wants.

REMEMBER: Before you check your answers, count what you found. If you have fewer than twelve, go back to the paragraph you read fastest.

Check yourself

11 questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see whether it is right and why.

Key terms

Deed
The written instrument by which a grantor conveys an interest in real property; evidence of title, not title itself.
Equitable title
The buyer's interest arising on execution of a valid sales contract, before legal title passes by deed at closing.
Habendum clause
The 'to have and to hold' clause defining the estate conveyed; it must agree with the granting clause.
Acknowledgment
The grantor's declaration before a notary or judge that the signature is genuine and voluntary; required to record a deed.
Covenant of seizin
The grantor's warranty that he holds the title being conveyed.
Bargain and sale deed
A deed implying the grantor owns and may convey the property but carrying no warranties; with covenants, the grantor warrants only his own period of ownership.
Quitclaim deed
A deed of release conveying whatever interest the grantor may have, with no warranties; often used to cure clouds on title.
Metes and bounds
A legal description using distances and compass directions from a point of beginning, walked clockwise back to the start.
Alienation
The transfer of ownership; voluntary (sale, gift, dedication, grant) or involuntary (eminent domain, foreclosure, adverse possession, accession).
Escheat
Reversion of property to the state when an owner dies intestate with no heirs.
Chain of title
The unbroken chronological record of successive conveyances of a parcel.
Abstract of title
A summarized history of all recorded documents affecting title; it carries no guarantee, unlike title insurance.
RESPA
The federal Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (Regulation X, CFPB): settlement-cost disclosures, no kickbacks or unearned fees, no required title insurer, escrow reserve limits.
Closing Disclosure
The five-page TRID settlement statement that replaced the HUD-1; must be available to the borrower three business days before consummation.
Proration
Dividing a shared expense between buyer and seller in proportion to their periods of ownership; prepaid items credit the seller, accrued items credit the buyer.

Practise this chapter

Flashcards (free) Practice exam

Read Chapter 6 in the Book

The Book comes with the Salesperson pass ($39 for 3 months).

A study course, in beta. This is not a New York State Department of State approved qualifying course, and the time you spend here does not count toward the 77 hours you need for a salesperson license. Take the 77-hour course at a DOS-approved school; use this to learn the material and to review it. · Powered by License to Earn LLC