The Course · Chapter 5 Beta

Chapter 5: Easements and Liens

Nonpossessory interests that burden a property owner's title

In this chapter

  • Types of easements Distinguish easements in gross from easements appurtenant, and say who benefits.
  • Creating easements Explain express grant, implication, necessity, prescription, condemnation, and party wall.
  • Easement vs. license Separate a permanent interest in land from revocable permission.
  • Encumbrance vs. encroachment Explain why a physical intrusion is not an encumbrance.
  • Types of liens Classify liens as voluntary or involuntary, general or specific.
  • The impact of liens Apply lien priority and describe how liens travel with a transfer.
  • Adverse possession State the requirements and New York's ten-year period.
  • Stay in your lane Recognize when to send a party to a lawyer, you may never give legal advice.

Lesson 1

Introduction

Nonpossessory Interests

A claim or a right in land, without the right to possess it

A possessory interest is the right to occupy land and use it as your own. A nonpossessory interest is a claim or a right in that same land held by somebody who has no right to possess it. The owner still owns the property. Somebody else holds a claim against it, and that claim travels with the title.

Nonpossessory interests are also called encumbrances, because they encumber the owner's title. An encumbrance is a claim, a limitation, a liability or a charge attached to real estate. A lien is an encumbrance. An easement is an encumbrance. A restrictive covenant in a deed is an encumbrance. Each of them either limits what the owner may do or hands a slice of the owner's rights to somebody else.

TWO PRIMARY TYPES IN THIS SESSION

This session covers the two you will meet most often. An easement is a right to use land. A lien is a financial claim against land. Easements fill the first half of this chapter and liens fill the second half, and the same word covers both: encumbrance.

An easement is the right to use another person's real property for a particular purpose. It creates limited rights for the holder in the land surface, in the airspace above it, or in the subsurface below it. The holder does not own the land and cannot occupy it. The holder gets a defined use and nothing more. An easement that grants access to property is commonly called a right of way.

A deed restriction is the third encumbrance to know by name. It is a limit on the use of real property imposed by an owner through language written into the deed, and it binds whoever takes title afterward. A subdivision deed that forbids commercial signage is a deed restriction. It is private, written by an owner rather than by a government, and it sits on the title the way an easement does.

Public or privateIn a deed or by agreementIn gross or appurtenant

Those are the three questions that sort any easement you are handed. Is it public, like a power line, or private, like access to a landlocked parcel? Was it written into a deed before the property transferred, or created separately by an agreement between the parties? Does it benefit a person or a company, or does it benefit another piece of land? The last question is the one the exam asks most, and the next screen is built on it.

CAUTION: A licensee must never give legal advice. Learn these concepts so you can recognize one when it appears on a title report and describe it to your client in plain words. Then tell the parties to seek legal representation. Recognizing an easement is your job. Telling a client what his rights are under it is a lawyer's job.

An encumbrance burdens the title

REMEMBER: Name the three encumbrances in this screen. Which one is a right to use land, which one is a financial claim, and which one is a limit an owner wrote into the deed?

Lesson 2

Easements

Who benefits, who is burdened, and how the right is created

In Gross vs. Appurtenant

Does the benefit run to a person, or to a piece of land?

Every easement question on the exam turns on one thing. Who gets the benefit. If the benefit runs to a person or a company, the easement is in gross. If the benefit runs to a piece of land, the easement is appurtenant. Learn the names attached to each and the rest of this screen falls into place.

EASEMENT IN GROSS BENEFITS A PERSON OR A COMPANY

An easement in gross involves a specific parcel of land and benefits a person or a company rather than another piece of land. The party who holds the benefit is the dominant tenant. The burdened land is the servient tenement. There is a dominant tenant, and there is no dominant tenement, because no second parcel is being served.

Easements in gross are most commonly held by government and by public utilities for commercial purposes. A power company holds an easement to run power lines over somebody's property. A municipality holds an easement to run sewer lines under the surface. The homeowner owns the land under the poles and over the pipes. The utility owns the right to be there, and that right does not end when the homeowner sells.

An easement in gross that belongs to a company can be assigned. If Phone Company A holds an easement in gross to place underground lines, Phone Company A can assign or sell those easement rights to Cable Company B. Your seller does not get a say in it.

An easement in gross can also be granted for a noncommercial purpose. An easement letting one named person cross a parcel to reach a public beach is a personal easement in gross. It generally may not be conveyed or assigned to anyone else, and it ends when the dominant tenant dies. Commercial easements in gross are assignable. Personal easements in gross are not.

EASEMENT APPURTENANT BENEFITS LAND

An easement appurtenant involves two separately deeded parcels owned by different parties. One parcel is burdened for the benefit of the other. The burdened parcel is the servient tenement. The benefited parcel is the dominant tenement. Both words end in tenement, because both of them are pieces of land.

An easement appurtenant can be affirmative or negative. An affirmative easement allows someone to do something, such as crossing a neighbor's property to reach a parcel with no road access. A negative easement prevents someone from doing something, such as forbidding an owner from damming a stream on his own property when the dam would deprive owners downstream of the water. Affirmative easements are the common ones. Negative easements are narrow and hard to create.

Appurtenances are rights that go with real property ownership, such as air rights, and they usually transfer with the property. An easement appurtenant is one of those rights. It goes with the land rather than with the owner, so it transfers when title transfers. When the dominant tenement sells, the new owner owns the easement. When the servient tenement sells, the new owner takes title subject to the burden of the easement.

Recording is what makes that work. A recorded easement, whether it sits inside a deed or stands as a separate document, gives notice to third parties that somebody holds a nonpossessory interest in the land. That notice is why the easement runs with the land, and the recording screen, three screens on, is about what happens without it.

LIGHT AND AIR

An easement for light and air, also called a view easement, is a negative appurtenant easement. The owner of the dominant tenement can prevent the owner of the servient tenement from doing something on the servient land, because that something would affect the dominant land. Amy owns a house on a hillside above the ocean. Bob owns the house below her. Amy and Bob sign an agreement that stops Bob from adding height to his house that would block Amy's view of the water. Amy now holds a negative easement over Bob's land.

Solar panels have made the right to light a live question. Many states have passed solar easement laws, zoning laws or building codes aimed at solar access. Under the statutes of some states the landowner who first installs solar panels for power generation has the right to unobstructed and continued use, so a neighbor cannot plant trees or put up a structure that interferes with them.

New York law does not generally recognize a homeowner's right to a view or right to light. Your client in New York gets that protection by agreement with the neighbor, recorded, or your client does not get it at all.

NOTE: Tenant and tenement look almost alike and the exam knows it. The dominant tenant is a person or a company and holds an easement in gross. The dominant tenement is a parcel of land and holds an easement appurtenant. Read the word ending before you read the answer choices.

Person or company, or a piece of land

REMEMBER: A cable company wants to sell its line easement to a competitor. A neighbor wants to leave his beach path to his daughter. Which one can do it, and which word in this screen tells you why?

How It Works on the Ground

Two lots, one road, one lake, and two very different easements

Picture two lots side by side, both of them bordering a lake. Only Lot A touches Main Road. Lot B sits behind it with no road access of its own. A utility line runs across both lots.

Lot A is the servient tenementLot B is the dominant tenementLot B has no road accessDriveway easement appurtenantUtility easement in gross

Start with the driveway. An easement appurtenant across Lot A lets the owner of Lot B reach his property. The benefit runs to Lot B, so Lot B is the dominant tenement. The burden falls on Lot A, so Lot A is the servient tenement. Two parcels, two owners, one benefit running from one piece of land to the other.

Now the utility line. A utility easement in gross crosses both Lot A and Lot B. Here both lots are servient tenements, and the utility company is the dominant tenant. The same parcel can be the dominant tenement under one easement and a servient tenement under another at the same time. Lot B is proof of it.

Both easements are recorded, and recording gives notice to third parties. When Lot B sells, the new owner of Lot B owns the driveway easement. When Lot A sells, the new owner of Lot A takes title subject to the burden of it. Neither new owner gets to renegotiate what the deed already says. The easement runs with the land.

Sit with the utility easement for a second, because it is the one that will cost you a client. Your buyer picks this lot because the back yard is big enough for an in-ground pool. He closes. He applies for the pool permit. That is the day he learns a gas utility easement crosses the middle of the yard and nothing may be built over it. The easement was recorded. It was on the abstract. Nobody read it to him.

NOTE: A question that gives you a landlocked parcel is handing you the answer. The parcel with no road access is the one that needs the benefit, so it is the dominant tenement, and the parcel it crosses is servient.

One parcel can be both at once

REMEMBER: Redraw these two lots on paper from memory. Label the dominant tenement, the servient tenement, and the dominant tenant. If you cannot place all three, read the screen before this one again.

Six Ways an Easement Is Created

Voluntarily by agreement, or involuntarily by operation of law

An easement is created voluntarily or involuntarily. Voluntary means the parties agreed and wrote it down. Involuntary means the law imposed it, through a court or through the government's power of eminent domain, whether the landowner liked it or not. Six routes cover almost everything you will see.

Express grantImplicationNecessityPrescriptionCondemnationParty wall

Easement by express grant is the clean one. A landowner grants an easement across his land to another person in a deed or other written document. The grant can be part of the deed transfer, or a separate document conveying only the easement. Where a landowner divides land and includes deed language so the seller retains an easement across his former land, the deed transfers the servient tenement and keeps the dominant tenement for the seller, and the easement is created by express reservation. Grant and reservation are both express and both written.

Easement by implication is created by law when land is divided and there is a long-standing apparent use reasonably necessary for the enjoyment of the land. It is also called an implied easement. It usually arises where one owner held a tract, split it into two or more parcels, and kept an ingress or egress, which is a means to enter or exit property.

X owned a large tract with a long driveway running from the main road to her house. She sold the south half, the part beside the main road, kept the north half with the house on it, and reserved no easement in the deed. She went on using the driveway as she always had. The buyer sued to stop her. The court ruled that X had an easement by implication, because her use of the driveway was obvious and well established when the land was divided, and reasonably necessary for the enjoyment of her property.

Easement by necessity arises where land would be completely useless without the easement, even with no long-standing apparent use. A landlocked parcel is the standard case. The claimant does not have to prove the use was old and obvious at the time of sale. The claimant must prove the easement is strictly necessary, not merely reasonably necessary. If there is another way in, a court will not grant an easement by necessity. It is not automatic and it is usually not granted to owners of vacant land.

Easement by prescription is created by open and notorious, hostile and adverse use of another person's land for a period set by state law. Open and notorious means the use is obvious and unconcealed, so an owner keeping reasonable track of the property would know about it. Hostile and adverse means use without the owner's permission and against his interests. Permission defeats the claim. If the owner said yes, there is no prescription.

In New York, a claim of easement by prescription requires continuous use for ten years. Continuous does not mean constant. It means regular use of the kind that is normal for that type of property, so a summer path walked every summer for ten years is continuous. Prescription gives the user an easement and nothing more, and a court has to decide even that.

Easement by condemnation occurs through the government's power of eminent domain. The same power that lets a government take title to private property for a public use lets it impose an easement instead. These easements usually cover future rights of way, visibility, safety, and expansion of existing roadways or utilities, and they require payment of just compensation to the owner of the servient tenement.

A party wall easement is a wall shared between two connected properties. Ownership of the wall is split between the two owners, and each owner has an appurtenant easement in the other half. The agreement should be in writing and should spell out ownership. Each owner shares in the building and the maintenance costs of the wall.

CAUTION: Two limits sit on prescription and the exam reaches for both. An easement by prescription can rarely be acquired against government property. And a negative easement, such as an easement for view, cannot be created by prescription at all. Nobody gets a view easement by sitting there enjoying the view for ten years.

Ten years, open, hostile, continuous

REMEMBER: Which two of these six are voluntary, and which one of the six requires the claimant to prove that no other access exists?

Recording, and Why an Oral Promise Fails

A document granting an easement is drawn, signed and recorded like a deed

An easement created voluntarily should be put in writing by the parties who created it. The document granting the easement is drawn up and signed just like a deed, and it is recorded in the public records of the county where the property is located. Recording is what gives a later buyer notice. If the buyer does not have notice, the easement probably will not run with the land, and the conflict starts the day the buyer discovers it.

WITHOUT A WRITING

D and S are neighbors. D asks S for an access easement allowing D to cross S's property. S agrees. Nothing is ever put in writing. Six months later S changes his mind and tells D to keep off his land. D cannot enforce the easement, because it was only an oral agreement. D has no interest in S's land and never did.

WITH A RECORDED WRITING

Now change one fact. S signs a document granting D the easement, and the document is recorded in the county where the property sits. S can change his mind as often as he likes. D has an enforceable right. And when S sells, the buyer takes S's land with notice of D's easement, because the record was there to be read before the buyer ever made an offer.

Recording works by producing constructive notice. Constructive notice is the protection the recording system gives against unrecorded claims. Once a document is filed in the public record, the law treats every later buyer as knowing what is in it, whether that buyer read it or not. Actual notice is different. Actual notice is actual knowledge, what a person in fact knows. A buyer who was told about the easement over coffee has actual notice of it. A buyer who never heard of it and never opened the record still has constructive notice of it. Both of them take the land with the easement on it.

Case in Point, Montauk, Suffolk County, 1994

THE FACTS

A hotel in Montauk, in Suffolk County, filed a lawsuit in 1994 to regain access for its guests to footpaths leading to the beach, after a property owner erected fences across them. The court had to decide whether the property abutting the beach was encumbered by an easement allowing access to the water. The history of the property was traced back to an 1879 sale of the land from the Montauk Indians. In 1904 the owners filed a plan for landscaping the property in the land records.

THE RULING

The plaintiffs claimed that language in that recorded map and in their own deeds included an express grant of easement over the property to reach the beaches. The judge ruled that the map and the deeds did create an easement, and that the current property owners, the owners of the servient tenement in this case, could not eliminate it. The fences were ordered removed.

Read the dates again. A map filed in 1904 decided a fence dispute in 1994. Every party to the original grant was long dead. The easement was not. Recorded documents outlive the people who signed them, and they bind owners who were not born when the ink dried.

WHY THIS IS YOUR PROBLEM

You can imagine how much it matters to know what easements are attached to a property you are selling. Existing easements can be discovered from a number of public sources, and it should be possible to find them before a contract is signed rather than after. Even where you do not perform that research yourself, you need to be able to explain to your client any easement that shows up on a title abstract.

The abstract of title is a brief summary of the history of title to a property, listing all of the recorded documents that affect that title. A recorded easement appears there. So does a separate easement document filed at the county clerk's office, and so does a filed subdivision map. That is where the gas utility easement across the back yard would have appeared. A buyer who is planning an in-ground pool has one question about that abstract, and it is your job to make sure he asks it before closing instead of at the permit counter.

CAUTION: Explaining what an easement is and where it sits on the property is service. Telling your client whether he can build over it, or whether he can beat it in court, is legal advice and you do not give it. Hand him the abstract, point at the line, and send him to a lawyer.

Oral easements are worth nothing

REMEMBER: A seller tells you his neighbor has always let him cross the back field and there is nothing on paper. What do you tell the buyer, and who do you tell the seller to call?

Encroachment, Termination and Licenses

Three distinctions the exam asks about every time

An encroachment is a physical object intruding onto a neighbor's property. A driveway that extends two feet over a property line is an encroachment. A tree limb that extends over the line is an encroachment. Most encroachments are unintentional and come from a mistake about where the boundary runs, and the law still treats them as a form of trespassing.

If a neighbor sues, the court can order removal of the encroachment or payment of damages by the encroacher. The owner of the encroached-upon property does not have the right to destroy the encroachment himself. He cannot tear down the shed. He goes to court, or he negotiates, and the encroacher could get an easement from him to let the encroachment stay.

An encroachment is not an encumbrance, because it is not a right or an interest that is held. That is the whole distinction and it is a favorite exam question. An easement is a right somebody holds. A lien is a claim somebody holds. An encroachment is an object sitting in the wrong place.

SIX WAYS AN EASEMENT ENDS

Release. All parties sign a document releasing the easement holder's interest in the property, and the release is recorded. Ellen has an easement by necessity to reach the road across Tom's property. A new road is built abutting Ellen's land, so Ellen releases her easement. Because the release is recorded, the person Ellen sells to has no right to use Tom's property.

Merger. Two or more separate properties are united by transferring ownership of all of them to one person. When one person owns both the dominant tenement and the servient tenement, the easement is terminated by merger. Divide the land again later and the easement does not come back. It has to be recreated.

Abandonment. Abandonment is the failure to occupy and use property, which may result in a loss of rights. Non-use alone is not enough for abandonment. There must be an act or a statement that clearly expresses the owner's intention to abandon the easement. Walking away from an easement for a few years does not end it.

Prescription

Ten years of non-use and the easement can be lost by prescription.

Failure or expiration of purpose. An easement ends when the purpose it was created for no longer exists. An electric company's easement for power lines across a farmer's land ends by failure of purpose when the company removes the lines. An easement can also end when the property is involuntarily destroyed. If a dock is wrecked by a hurricane and rebuilt, the previous easement to use it is not automatic and has to be recreated.

Court action. An easement may be terminated through a quiet title action, a lawsuit to determine who holds what interest in a property. Ellen keeps using Tom's driveway after the new road is built, because it is more convenient. Tom can go to court to have the easement terminated. Once it is in a judge's hands, termination is not guaranteed.

CAUTION: Watch the clock in any fact pattern about an easement that nobody has used. Two years of non-use ends nothing. Abandonment needs an act or a statement showing intent, and the prescription period in New York is ten years. Short periods of non-use are the trap.

A LICENSE IS BARE PERMISSION

A license is temporary, revocable, non-assignable permission to enter another's land for a particular purpose. A license resembles an easement, because it grants permission to use another's property. A license creates no interest in property and is not considered an encumbrance, and that is the line between the two.

Run the two side by side. An easement usually runs for an indefinite period, while a license is often temporary. An easement is created by written agreement or by action of law, while a license may be created by an oral contract. An easement runs with the land, while a license does not have to. An easement cannot be revoked, while a license may be revoked at any time, except where the licensee has made a substantial financial commitment in reliance on it. A license cannot be assigned, and it becomes invalid when the licensee dies.

NOTE: A ticket to a ballgame is the plain example of a license. It lets you enter somebody's land for a particular purpose, it is temporary, it is revocable, and it hands you no interest in the stadium. Ask of any fact pattern whether the holder got an interest in land or only got permission.

Permission ends; an interest survives

REMEMBER: A neighbor has let your seller park on his lot for years, with nothing in writing and clear permission given. Easement, license, or encroachment, and what does the buyer inherit?

Lesson 3

Liens

A financial interest, and a financial encumbrance

What a Lien Is, and the Two Axes That Classify It

Every lien on the exam is one of each

A lien is a financial interest in property and a financial encumbrance on the owner's title. A lien is security for a debt, and it gives the creditor, called the lien holder, the right to foreclose on the debtor's property if the debt is not paid. In foreclosure the property is sold, and the lien holder collects the amount of the debt out of the proceeds of the sale.

That is the engine under everything in the second half of this chapter. The lien does not give the creditor the right to move in or to use the property. It gives the creditor the right to force a sale and take money out of it. A lien is a nonpossessory interest, the same family as an easement, and the thing it claims is money.

General or specificVoluntary or involuntary

Two axes classify every lien, and every lien on the exam carries one label from each. A general lien attaches to all property, personal and real, owned in the county by the debtor. A specific lien attaches only to specific property, usually the property that incurred the debt. That is the first axis, and it answers how much of the debtor's world the creditor can reach.

The second axis is consent. A voluntary lien is placed against property with the consent of the owner. An involuntary lien arises by operation of law without the consent of the property owner. Involuntary liens exist to protect a landowner's creditors, who would otherwise have nothing but a promise.

Put the two together and you get four combinations. Voluntary and specific. Involuntary and specific. Voluntary and general. Involuntary and general. Every lien in this chapter lands in one of those four boxes, and an exam question that gives you only one label is asking you to supply the other.

THE VOLUNTARY LIEN YOU WILL SEE EVERY DAY

Mortgages are written instruments that use real property to secure payment of a debt. Without a debt there can be no mortgage. The mortgage is a powerful incentive for an owner to pay, because it represents a potential transfer of title to the mortgagee in case of default. A home equity line of credit works the same way and carries the same classification.

A mortgage is a voluntary, specific lien. Voluntary, because the owner signed for it and asked for the money. Specific, because it attaches to the mortgaged property and to nothing else the borrower owns. Learn that pair first. It is the one lien your clients will hold, and it is the reference point for every other lien in this chapter.

NOTE: Consent is the test on the voluntary axis. A mortgage is voluntary because the owner agreed to it. A mechanic's lien is involuntary even though the owner hired the contractor, because the owner agreed to pay a contractor and never agreed to a lien on his house.

Consent, and how much it reaches

REMEMBER: Say the two labels on a mortgage out loud. Now say what would have to change about the facts for either label to flip.

Involuntary Liens

Created by law to protect a landowner's creditors

An involuntary lien arises by operation of law without the consent of the property owner. Nobody signs anything. The law attaches the claim because a debt exists and somebody has to be protected. These are the liens that surprise a seller two weeks before closing.

Mechanic's liens and materialman's liens are claimed by someone who performed work on real property, or supplied material for it, and was not paid. The property serves as security for payment when the owner does not pay contractors, subcontractors, laborers or materialmen for improvements. If the bills go unpaid, the holder of the lien can force the sale of the property and collect from the proceeds. A party can file a mechanic's or materialman's lien without going to court.

In New York a mechanic's lien refers broadly to any work performed or material used to improve a property. The filing deadlines are the part you have to know cold.

4 months8 months1 year

On a single-family residence the lien must be filed within four months of the date the labor was completed or the material supplied. The deadline is eight months for other properties. Once it is filed, a mechanic's lien is good for one year, although it can be renewed. A mechanic's lien is an involuntary, specific lien.

That law reaches brokers too. Under New York Lien Law Section 10, a broker who is owed a commission for negotiating a long-term commercial lease can file a lien for the unpaid commission up to eight months after the commission is due. Your own commission on a commercial lease is a debt the law is willing to secure against the property.

Tax liens are liens on property to secure the payment of taxes. Property taxes create an involuntary, specific lien against real estate. The lien can come from ad valorem taxes, meaning taxes based on the assessed value of the property, assessed by local entities such as municipalities and school districts to raise revenue. It can also come from a special assessment, a tax levied to pay for a specific improvement that benefits only certain property owners. To be enforceable, the taxes creating the lien must be legitimate, which requires them to be properly levied, used for legal purposes, and equitably applied to all landowners.

Judgment liens are liens against a person's property through court action. At the end of a lawsuit, if one party is found to owe the other money, a judgment is entered. The winner, the judgment creditor, may claim a lien against the real property or other assets of the loser, the judgment debtor.

To claim the lien, the judgment creditor obtains a certificate of judgment from the court that issued it and files it in the county where the judgment debtor owns real property. The lien attaches to all of the debtor's real property in each county where the certificate is recorded. It is valid for ten years from the date of the judgment and renewable for ten more. Judgment liens are generally involuntary, general liens.

One judgment lien runs the other way. A confession of judgment is a written statement in which someone who owes money permits judgment to be entered against him without legal proceedings. A judgment lien created by a confession of judgment is a voluntary, general lien, because the debtor agreed to it.

Attachment liens are intended to prevent the transfer of property pending the outcome of litigation. When a plaintiff files a lawsuit there is a danger the defendant will sell everything before judgment is entered and leave the winner with a worthless piece of paper. To stop that, at the outset of the suit the plaintiff can ask the court to issue an order of attachment. The order directs the sheriff to seize personal property, or to create an involuntary lien against real property, personal property, or both.

A notice of a pending suit, called a lis pendens, may also be recorded. A lis pendens is recorded notice to potential buyers that a lawsuit is pending and that the outcome may affect the title to the property. It is notice and not a lien, and a buyer who reads it cannot later claim he did not know.

CAUTION: Four months on a single-family residence, eight months on everything else, and the lien is good for one year once filed. Those three numbers are exam answers and they are also the numbers a seller's lawyer will be counting the week before your closing.

Filed by law, without a signature

REMEMBER: A contractor finished work on a house five months ago and was never paid. Which deadline applies, has it run, and what would your answer be if the building were a four-unit rental?

The Four Tax Liens

Watch the general and specific labels; this is where exam questions live

Four tax liens carry their own names on the exam, and each one carries the two labels you learned two screens ago. Read each one for what it attaches to, because that is the label students lose points on.

A property tax lien comes from ad valorem taxes assessed by municipalities and school districts, or from a special assessment for an improvement that benefits only certain owners. It attaches to the taxed parcel. Property taxes create an involuntary, specific lien against real estate.

An income tax lien comes from unpaid federal income taxes. Income tax liens are involuntary, general liens, so unlike other tax liens they can attach to personal property as well as to real property. The Internal Revenue Service is reaching the taxpayer, and not one particular house.

An estate tax lien is administered to the estate of a person who has died. The taxable estate is the gross estate less allowable deductions. The estate can include life insurance, annuities and property. The deductions can include funeral costs, debts, charity and a state death tax where one applies. An estate tax lien is an involuntary, general lien.

A corporation franchise tax lien follows from an annual state tax that corporations operating in New York pay based on net profit. If the corporation fails to pay, the outstanding amount becomes a lien on corporate assets. The state can attach the assets, foreclose, and dissolve the corporation, and a dissolved corporation can no longer operate legally in New York. A corporation franchise tax lien is an involuntary, general lien.

Sort the four by what they reach. The property tax lien is specific, because it attaches to the parcel that was taxed. The income tax lien, the estate tax lien and the corporation franchise tax lien are general, because each reaches the debtor rather than one piece of land. The state licensing outline groups them the same way. Under general liens it lists judgments, with lis pendens named in parentheses beside them, then estate and inheritance taxes, the debts of a deceased person, the corporation franchise tax and IRS tax. Under specific liens it lists tax, mortgage and mechanic's liens. The outline files lis pendens beside judgments because the notice is recorded with a lawsuit. The lis pendens itself is notice and not a lien, as the screen before this one explained.

Type of lienVoluntaryInvoluntary

General (all property, personal or real)

Specific (against specific real property)

Property tax lienIRS tax lienEstate tax lienCorporation franchise tax lienMortgage lienMechanic's lienJudgment lienAttachment lien

NOTE: Every lien in that list carries two labels, one from each axis. Only one of the eight is always voluntary, the mortgage. The judgment lien is generally involuntary, and it is voluntary only when it is entered on a confession of judgment. Only three of them are specific: the property tax lien, the mortgage lien and the mechanic's lien.

Specific reaches a parcel, general a person

REMEMBER: Cover the list and label all four tax liens yourself, voluntary or involuntary, general or specific. Which one of the four is the odd one out, and why?

Lien Priority

First in time, first in line, except when it is not

It is not unusual for real estate to carry several liens at the same time. A mortgage, a mechanic's lien and a property tax lien can all sit on one parcel. Sometimes the total owed is more than the land will bring at a sale, so there has to be an order for paying them off after a foreclosure.

Generally, liens are paid in the order they were attached to the land. First in time, first in line. The creditor with the first recorded lien is paid first and gets every cent owed to him. If money is left over, the second recorded lien holder is paid, and so on down the line. If there is a third lien holder and the proceeds only covered the first two, the third lien holder gets nothing at all.

THE BIG EXCEPTION

Property tax liens are superior to all other liens. No matter when a property tax lien is placed on a property, it is paid before any other lien when the property is sold. That is why many mortgage lenders prefer to maintain an escrow account for property taxes. Paying the taxes themselves keeps the lender assured the taxes are paid, and keeps the lender in first position behind nothing.

One more lien can move. Under certain circumstances a lien recorded by the Internal Revenue Service for unpaid federal income taxes may jump ahead of a recorded mortgage lien or another lien. It never jumps ahead of a property tax lien. The property tax lien is the top of the ladder and stays there.

CASE IN POINT: May buys a house with a mortgage from TOP Bank. A few years later she hires ABC Construction to build a pool. ABC hires subcontractor Tom to dig the hole and pour the concrete and never pays him, so Tom files a mechanic's lien against May. A month later May takes out a home equity loan with ACE Bank. Two months after that she is sued for an unpaid credit card debt and a judgment lien is recorded against her. Three months after that the city assesses a special assessment to replace the curbs on her street, she ignores the bill, and the city files a lien. May now has five liens on one house.

The bank forecloses and the property sells for $132,000. The city is paid its $3,000 special assessment lien first, even though it was filed last, because a tax lien outranks everything. TOP Bank is paid its $100,000 mortgage balance next, as the first recorded of the remaining liens. Tom the poolman is paid his $2,000 mechanic's lien third. ACE Bank is owed $30,000 on the home equity loan and there is only $27,000 left, so ACE takes a $3,000 loss. The credit card company is owed $14,000 on its judgment lien and receives nothing. The money ran out one lien above it.

Read May's list again with the order of recording in front of you. The city filed last and was paid first. The credit card company filed before the city and was paid nothing. Recording order decided four of the five positions, and the tax exception decided the one that mattered most.

A creditor can also agree to move down the order. A subordination agreement is a contract in which a lender voluntarily puts its lien in a lower order of priority, which can give a mortgage recorded at a later date priority over one recorded earlier. A lender usually agrees to it where the lender is confident the property is worth enough to pay off the additional liens and the mortgage both.

NOTE: The exam sentence to watch is a mortgage described as the first recorded lien. First recorded is not the same as first paid. Read the whole list for a property tax lien or a special assessment before you answer, because either one goes to the front of the line.

Taxes first, then the recording order

REMEMBER: If May's house had sold for $110,000 instead, who would have been paid and who would have walked away with nothing? Work the numbers before you move on.

Transferring Property That Has Liens

A lien does not stop a sale, and a sale does not kill the lien

Liens against property do not prevent the property's transfer, and a transfer does not nullify the lien. Both halves of that sentence are exam answers. The seller can sell a property with liens on it. The buyer who takes it does not get a clean title because the deed changed hands.

The buyer takes the property subject to the liens. Taking subject to a lien means the buyer takes the property with the lien obligation but without being personally liable for the debt. The buyer must keep paying the liens to keep the property, and loses his equity in the event of default. The creditor cannot hold the new owner personally responsible for these debts, because the new owner never assumed them.

THREE WAYS A SELLER CLEARS TITLE BEFORE CLOSING

Withhold the funds at settlement. The necessary funds are held back out of the sale proceeds to pay off the debt, and a record of satisfaction of the lien is recorded in the public records to protect the new owner. Recording the satisfaction is the step people forget, and it is the step that proves the lien is gone.

Bring a check to the table. If the seller owes more on the property than the sale of it will generate, the seller may have to come to the settlement table with a check to discharge the additional debt. A seller who does not know that in advance learns it on the day, and the closing does not happen.

Release or switch the collateral. Where the claim is a general lien against the property owner rather than a specific lien on this parcel, the creditor could agree to release the property being sold, if the debtor has other collateral, or agree to switch the lien to a property the debtor will acquire. The lien follows the debtor to other collateral.

In most real estate transactions sellers clear their titles of all liens before closing. Nothing in the law requires it. A buyer paying cash has the right to buy a property subject to outstanding liens with his eyes open, and that transaction is lawful even though almost nobody does it. A buyer using a mortgage will find his lender has an opinion, because the lender wants first position.

ADVERSE POSSESSION, WHEN USE MATURES INTO TITLE

The last idea in this chapter runs the other way from a lien. A lien is somebody's claim for money against your client's land. Adverse possession is somebody's claim to your client's land itself, built out of nothing but using it. Four elements have to be satisfied, and New York adds a fifth.

Open and notorious, the first two elements, proved together. The use must be obvious and unconcealed, so an owner keeping reasonable track of the property would know about it. Hostile and adverse, the third. The use must be without the owner's permission and against the owner's interests. Continuous for ten years, the fourth. That is New York's period, the same period as easement by prescription. Cultivated or enclosed, New York's fifth. A claim in New York generally requires that the property be cultivated or improved, or protected by a substantial enclosure.

NOTE: Subject to is the phrase to underline. A buyer who takes subject to a lien is not personally liable for the debt, and he still loses the property if the debt goes unpaid. The exam will test whichever half of that you skipped.

The lien survives the closing

REMEMBER: Your seller has a judgment lien he refuses to pay off. Your buyer is paying cash and does not care. Is the closing lawful, and what do you put in writing before anybody signs?

Adverse Possession in Practice

Title by prescription, and the court awards the land, not the calendar

Adverse possession is acquiring title to someone else's real property through open, notorious, hostile and continuous use of it for a period of time set by state law. In New York that period is ten years, the same period as easement by prescription, and a claim generally requires that the property be cultivated or improved or protected by a substantial enclosure.

Adverse possession is also called title by prescription, and it works like easement by prescription with one enormous difference. Easement by prescription gives the user a right to use the land while title stays with the owner. Adverse possession gives the user the title itself. The owner loses the land, not just the argument about the path across it.

Two limits sit on the doctrine. Adverse possession does not apply to government-owned land, so a strip of town parkland is not available no matter how long anyone has mowed it. And adverse possession does not automatically convey title when the ten years run. A court has to make the decision to award the land. The calendar creates the claim. The judge creates the title.

New York's extra requirement does real work. A claim here generally requires that the property be cultivated or improved, or protected by a substantial enclosure. Walking across the corner of a neighbor's field for ten years does not satisfy it. Fencing that corner, farming it, paving it or building on it is the kind of act the requirement is looking for, and it is also the kind of act an owner can hardly miss.

WHERE IT ACTUALLY SHOWS UP

Title to large parcels of property through adverse possession is not common. A boundary line is where you will meet it. A fence in the wrong place, a driveway that was paved eighteen inches too far, a hedge somebody planted in 1990 on the wrong side of the line, and two owners who each have a reason to believe the land is theirs.

THE FACTS

Homeowner Joe put up a fence that enclosed a small portion of his neighbor's property. Over the years Joe planted trees and bushes inside the fence and enjoyed the use of that ground as if it were his own. Twenty years later the neighbor's property was sold. The new owners had the land surveyed, discovered the fence was on their property, and removed it. Joe sued to claim title to that portion of the property through adverse possession.

Run Joe's facts against the elements before you guess at the outcome. The fence and the plantings are open and notorious, and they are cultivation and enclosure both. Twenty years is well past ten. The question a court would ask is whether Joe's use was hostile and adverse, meaning without permission, and whether he can prove each element for the whole period. Permission from the old neighbor at any point would end the claim.

WHY IT MATTERS TO YOU

You are not going to litigate this. You are going to be standing in a back yard with a buyer who says the fence looks like it is in the wrong place, and a seller who says it has always been there. A survey answers the first question. A lawyer answers the second. Your job is to make sure somebody orders the survey before the contract goes hard, and to keep your own opinion about who owns that strip to yourself.

CAUTION: Neither doctrine works well against the government. Adverse possession does not apply to government-owned land, and an easement by prescription can rarely be acquired against government property. A fact pattern that names a town, a village, a school district or a park is telling you the answer before it asks the question.

Use gets an easement; possession gets title

REMEMBER: Say the four elements out loud, add New York's fifth, and say the number of years. Then say which one of the two doctrines leaves the original owner still holding title.

Session Summary

Eight things to carry out of this chapter

Encumbrances are nonpossessory interests in property. A person can hold a claim or a right to a property without possessing it, and that claim burdens the property. The two common encumbrances are easements and liens, and a deed restriction written by an owner burdens the title the same way.

Easements are the right to use another's property for a particular purpose. An easement appurtenant burdens one parcel, the servient tenement, for the benefit of another parcel, the dominant tenement. An easement in gross burdens one parcel for the benefit of an individual or a company, the dominant tenant, such as a utility.

Easements are created by express grant or express reservation, by implication, necessity or prescription, and by condemnation and party wall agreement. A voluntary easement is written into a deed or created separately by an agreement between the parties. Easements are terminated by release, merger, abandonment, prescription, failure or expiration of purpose, and court action. In New York the prescription period is ten years.

An encroachment is a physical object intruding onto a neighbor's property. Most encroachments are unintentional and the law still treats them as a form of trespassing. An encroachment is not an encumbrance, because it is not a right or an interest that is held, and the owner encroached upon may not destroy it himself.

A license is temporary, revocable, non-assignable permission to enter another's land for a particular purpose. A license grants permission to use another's property the way an easement does. A license creates no interest in property and is not an encumbrance, and it becomes invalid when the licensee dies.

Liens are nonpossessory interests and financial encumbrances. Every lien is voluntary or involuntary, and general or specific. The common ones are mortgages, tax liens, mechanic's liens, judgment liens and attachment liens. A mechanic's lien is filed within four months on a single-family residence and eight months on other property, and is good for one year. A lis pendens is recorded notice of a pending suit and is not a lien.

Lien holders can foreclose when the debt goes unpaid, which forces a sale and uses the proceeds to repay the debt. Priority generally follows the order in which liens were recorded. The exception is a tax lien, which takes priority over all other liens, and a creditor can agree to move down the order with a subordination agreement.

Adverse possession is acquiring title to someone else's real property through open, notorious, hostile and continuous use for a period set by state law. In New York the period is ten years, the same as easement by prescription, and the property generally must be cultivated, improved or enclosed. Adverse possession does not apply to government-owned land, and a court must award the title.

REMEMBER: Eight ideas, and one of them is the one you would get wrong today. Which one is it, and which screen do you need to read again before the chapter quiz?

You Be the Judge

The Hollow Creek Tangle, an issue-spotting challenge

Everything in this chapter arrives in the same form on the job. It arrives as something an agent says to a client in a car or over the phone, confidently, in a sentence that sounds helpful. Dana is that agent. Read what she does at Hollow Creek and find the places where she is wrong.

Work it in four passes rather than reading it once. First pass, read the whole story straight through without stopping, so you have the shape of the deal in your head. Second pass, take one paragraph at a time and write down every separate statement Dana makes. Third pass, put the rule beside each statement. Fourth pass, decide whether the statement breaks the rule.

Two kinds of error are hiding in here and they score the same. One kind is a statement of law that is simply wrong, a number that is not New York's number or a doctrine applied to facts it does not reach. The other kind is a statement that might even be correct and that a licensee is not permitted to make at all. Catch both. The second kind is the one that costs a license.

Keep the chapter's vocabulary at hand while you read. Easement appurtenant and easement in gross. Dominant tenement and servient tenement. Encumbrance and encroachment. Easement by prescription and adverse possession, and the ten-year period they share. The filing deadlines on a mechanic's lien. Lien priority and the one lien that jumps the line. What a buyer takes when he takes subject to a lien.

THE HOLLOW CREEK TANGLE

Dana lists a rural parcel at Hollow Creek. Years ago the seller shook hands with his neighbour over a driveway crossing the neighbour's land, nothing was ever written down or recorded. Dana assures the buyer the arrangement “runs with the land, don't worry about it,” and adds that in her opinion the buyer “has a solid legal claim either way.”

The title abstract shows a gas utility easement crossing the middle of the back yard. Dana skips it in her summary, because the buyer is planning an in-ground pool and “it'll only spook him.” When the buyer asks about the neighbour's shed sitting two feet over the line, Dana calls it “just another encumbrance on the title” and tells him he's welcome to knock it down once he owns the place.

Dana tells the buyer he can lock in a right of way over the adjoining farm because people have cut across it for six years, and that he can stop the farmer from planting a tree line by claiming a view easement by prescription. She adds that the strip of town parkland at the rear “has been mowed by this family forever, that's adverse possession, easy.”

At closing prep Dana reviews the liens. A contractor filed a mechanic's lien on this single-family residence three months after finishing; Dana says it's void because “you only get sixty days.” She tells the seller the first mortgage will be paid before the county's property tax lien because it was recorded first, and reassures the buyer that “once it sells, the liens are wiped out.” On a second file she tells a client an easement died because nobody used it for two years. The seller on that file declines to satisfy a small judgment lien before closing; the cash buyer shrugs and takes the property anyway.

12 violations are buried in this story

Plus one lawful act planted to catch you out. One thing Dana does or allows in these four paragraphs is permitted, even though it looks careless. Finding it is worth as much as finding an error, because in practice you will be asked to sign off on things that look wrong and are not.

Name the duty or the rule each act breaks, in your own words, before you check anything. Write the list first. Then walk back through this chapter screen by screen and mark the ones you missed. The screens you had to reread are the screens to review before the chapter quiz.

CAUTION: Resist the urge to count only the dramatic errors. Several of Dana's mistakes are quiet, ordinary sentences that an agent says a dozen times a week without thinking about them. Those are the ones that show up in a complaint to the Department of State.

Twelve errors, and one lawful act

REMEMBER: Before you look at a single answer, ask yourself the one question that settles half of this case. Which of Dana's statements were hers to make at all, and which ones belonged to a lawyer?

Check yourself

10 questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see whether it is right and why.

Key terms

Encumbrance
A nonpossessory claim, limitation, liability or charge attached to real estate that burdens the owner's title, such as an easement or lien.
Easement appurtenant
A right to use another parcel that benefits a neighboring parcel (dominant tenement) and burdens the servient tenement; runs with the land.
Easement in gross
An easement that benefits a person or company rather than a parcel; commercial ones (utilities) are assignable, personal ones are not.
Easement by necessity
An easement arising when land would be useless without it, strict, not merely reasonable, necessity must be proven.
Easement by prescription
An easement created by open, notorious, hostile and continuous use for ten years in New York.
Party wall
A wall shared by two connected buildings; each owner holds half and an appurtenant easement in the other half.
Encroachment
A physical intrusion of a structure or object onto a neighbor's land; a trespass, not an encumbrance.
License
Temporary, revocable, non-assignable permission to enter another's land; creates no interest in property.
Lien
Security for a debt giving the creditor the right to foreclose on the debtor's property; classified voluntary/involuntary and general/specific.
Mechanic's lien
An involuntary specific lien for unpaid labor or materials; filed within 4 months (single-family) or 8 months (other property) and good for one year.
Judgment lien
A general involuntary lien created by filing a certificate of judgment in each county where the debtor owns property; valid ten years, renewable.
Lis pendens
A recorded notice of a pending lawsuit that may affect title; a warning to buyers, not a lien.
Subordination agreement
A creditor's agreement to move its lien down in priority behind a later lien.
Adverse possession
Acquiring title to another's land through open, notorious, hostile and continuous use for ten years, awarded by a court; not available against government land.

Practise this chapter

Flashcards (free) Practice exam

Read Chapter 5 in the Book

The Book comes with the Salesperson pass ($39 for 3 months).

A study course, in beta. This is not a New York State Department of State approved qualifying course, and the time you spend here does not count toward the 77 hours you need for a salesperson license. Take the 77-hour course at a DOS-approved school; use this to learn the material and to review it. · Powered by License to Earn LLC