Lesson 1
Disclosure Obligations
What you must say, and what the law protects you for not saying
Stigmatized Property
Real Property Law §443-a, the silence the statute protects
A stigmatized property is a property with nothing physically wrong with it. The roof is sound, the systems work, the inspector finds nothing. What hurts the sale is something that happened there, or something people believe happened there. A homicide nine months ago. A suicide. A felony arrest that made the local news. A settled neighborhood conviction that the house is haunted. None of that shows up in an inspection report, and all of it can move a buyer off a price.
A material fact is an important fact, one likely to influence a decision. That is the test that decides what you have to disclose, and the fight over stigmatized property is a fight about that one word. A seller says the death in the back bedroom changed nothing about the value or the usability of the house. A buyer says it changed everything. Both of them mean it. New York does not leave the argument to the two of them to settle at the closing table.
Article 12-A, §443-a, Real Property Law
Section 443-a lists the facts that are not material facts or defects for any property offered for sale or lease, residential property included, whatever the number of units. The first category is health. That an owner or occupant of the property is, or was at any time suspected to be, infected with human immunodeficiency virus, or diagnosed with acquired immune deficiency syndrome, or has any other disease that medical evidence has determined is highly unlikely to be transmitted through occupancy of a dwelling place.
The second category is death and felony. That the property is, or is suspected to have been, the site of a homicide, a suicide, or any other death by accidental or natural causes, or of any crime punishable as a felony. Read the word suspected in both categories. The statute covers what happened and it covers what the neighborhood believes happened, which is usually the part that reaches your buyer first.
Then §443-a does something most disclosure statutes never do. It closes the courthouse door. No cause of action arises against an owner or occupant of real property, against the agent of that owner or occupant, or against the agent of a seller or a buyer, for failing to disclose those facts in any real estate transaction. Failure to disclose them to a buyer is also not grounds for a disciplinary action against a licensed broker or salesperson.
That second sentence is the one protecting your license. Everywhere else in this course, staying quiet about the wrong thing costs you money and standing. Here the statute names the two categories where your silence carries no cause of action and no discipline from the Department of State. Read it as a safe harbor and read it narrowly. It reaches the facts the statute lists and it reaches nothing else.
Hypothetical. You list a house in Yonkers where the previous owner died of natural causes in the upstairs bedroom two years ago. The seller tells you at the listing appointment and asks you to keep it to yourself. You keep it to yourself. A buyer closes, hears the story from a neighbor that first weekend, and calls a lawyer. Section 443-a ends that call. The death is not a material fact, no cause of action arises against you or your seller, and the Department of State has no hook to hang discipline on.
NOTE: The exam separates a stigma from a defect with one question. Would an inspector find it? A cracked foundation is a defect, and you disclose it. A death in the bedroom above that foundation is a stigma, and §443-a covers your silence. Every version of this question turns on that single line, and the wrong answers are always physical conditions dressed up as history.
A stigma is history; a defect is condition
REMEMBER: Your seller tells you three things at the listing appointment. A suicide in the house last year, a neighborhood story that the house is haunted, and a roof that leaks in heavy rain. Which of them does §443-a let you keep to yourself, and which one would a buyer's inspector find on his own in twenty minutes?
The Written Inquiry Route
§443-a gives a buyer a way to ask, not a right to an answer
Section 443-a protects your silence. It also recognizes that a buyer may care a great deal about the history of a house the law calls immaterial. So the statute builds a route for the buyer to ask, and it spells out who hands the question to whom. The route has four steps. Step three is where new agents get the rule wrong, and step three is where the exam lives.
1 · The buyer asks in writing
While negotiating, or when making a bona fide offer, the buyer may submit a written inquiry for the information §443-a protects. The inquiry has to be written. A question asked across the kitchen island on a second showing is not an inquiry under this section, and it starts none of what follows. If your buyer wants an answer, your buyer writes it down.
2 · The request is delivered
The buyer, or the buyer's agent, provides the written request to the seller's agent. Where there is no seller's agent, the request goes to the seller directly. You are a delivery step in this sequence, and you deliver it the day you get it, because the buyer's offer is usually sitting on somebody's desk while this plays out.
3 · The seller decides
The seller may choose whether or not to respond to the inquiry. Nothing in §443-a compels an answer, sets a clock on it, or attaches a penalty to silence. A seller may read the question, decide the family's business is the family's business, and say nothing at all. That is the whole of the seller's obligation under this subdivision.
4 · The answer comes back
The seller's agent, with the consent of the seller and subject to the laws that apply to privacy, reports any response and information to the buyer's agent, or to the buyer where there is no buyer's agent. Consent comes first. You do not relay a seller's answer about a death in the house because you decided the buyer deserves to know. The seller decides that.
Where there is no seller's agent in the deal, the seller informs the buyer's agent, or the buyer directly, whether or not the seller chooses to provide a response. So where there is no seller's agent, the buyer's side always learns something. What the buyer's side learns may be only that no answer is coming, and that is a complete and lawful outcome under §443-a.
Legally immaterial and personally immaterial are two different things. A buyer who will not sleep in a house where someone died will still not sleep in it after you have read her the statute. Stay sensitive to how a client reacts to a house's history. The statute settles what you owe. Your client's reaction settles whether the deal closes, and you are paid on the second one.
Hypothetical. Your buyer submits a written inquiry about a suicide she heard about from a neighbor. The seller's agent comes back two days later and says the seller has chosen not to respond. Your buyer is furious and wants to know whether she can force an answer or walk with her deposit. She cannot force an answer. What she can do is decide, right now, what the silence is worth to her, and you help her make that decision instead of arguing with the statute.
CAUTION: Section 443-a protects silence. It does not authorize a false answer to a direct written inquiry, and it never reaches active concealment of a physical defect. An agent who invents an answer to make a buyer comfortable has stepped out of the safe harbor and into fraud.
The buyer may ask; the seller may pass
REMEMBER: A buyer hands you a written question about a death in a house you are listing, and your seller says nothing back. What do you tell the buyer's agent, and what do you never tell them without the seller's consent?
Four Notices Before a Binding Contract
RPL §242 and §333-c, all four early
Four New York disclosures run on a clock that ends before the deal really starts. Three of them sit in §242 of the Real Property Law, inside Article 8, which covers conveyances and mortgages. The fourth sits in §333-c, inside Article 9, which covers the recording of instruments affecting real property. Two go to the buyer in writing before a purchase offer is accepted. One goes to the buyer before the contract is entered into. The fourth goes into the contract itself.
No utility electric service · §242(1)
Any person, firm, company, partnership or corporation offering to sell real property to which no utility electric service is provided gives written notice to the prospective purchaser, or to the purchaser's agent, clearly indicating that fact. The notice goes out before a purchase offer is accepted. A parcel with no utility electric service is not a hidden defect. It is a condition the buyer has to price, because bringing service to a remote parcel is the new owner's bill and it is rarely small.
Electric or gas utility surcharge · §242(2)
A seller offering real property against which an electric or gas utility surcharge is assessed, to defray the costs of a line extension or of related facilities, gives written notice to the purchaser or the purchaser's agent stating: “This property is subject to an electric and/or gas utility surcharge.” The notice also states the type of the surcharge, its purpose, the amount of it, and whether it is payable monthly, yearly or on some other basis. The seller provides it before accepting a purchase offer.
Uncapped natural gas wells · §242(3)
Any person, firm, company, partnership or corporation offering to sell real property on which uncapped natural gas wells are situated, and of which the seller has actual knowledge, informs any purchaser that those wells exist before entering into a contract for the sale of the property. Actual knowledge is the trigger. A seller who knows, tells. Capping a natural gas well can cost a new owner thousands of dollars that appeared nowhere in the asking price, and that cost is the reason the notice exists.
This is the one disclosure in the chapter that the State places on your license law syllabus by name. Learn the three parts of it. Uncapped wells, actual knowledge, and notice before the contract is entered into, not before the closing.
Agricultural district · §333-c
When any purchase and sale contract is presented for the sale, purchase or exchange of real property located partly or wholly within an established agricultural district, the contract must include the agricultural district disclosure notice. The notice tells the purchaser that farming activities occur in the district and that those activities may involve noise, dust and odors. This one lives inside the contract rather than in a separate letter, so the moment to catch it is the day you write the deal.
New York amended its Constitution in 1970 to recognize the value of the state's agricultural legacy and to encourage development and improvement of its farm land. Inside an established agricultural district, local government agencies are prohibited from unreasonably restricting or regulating farm operations. A buyer moving from Brooklyn to an agricultural district upstate cannot call the town about the manure spreader running at six in the morning and expect the town to act. The disclosure notice is the warning that comes attached to that protection.
NOTE: The timing is what gets mixed up on every exam. The §242(1) and §242(2) notices are delivered before the seller accepts the purchase offer. The §242(3) well notice comes before the contract is entered into. The §333-c agricultural notice is part of the contract of sale. And §242(3) attaches to a seller's actual knowledge of the wells, which is the phrase the question will quote back at you.
Electric, surcharge, wells, farmland
REMEMBER: You are writing an offer this afternoon on ten acres upstate. Which of the four notices do you check for before your seller signs anything, and which one has to be inside the contract you are typing?
Lesson 2
Megan's Law and Sex Offender Registration
A registry the public can search, and a duty you do not have
Megan's Law and SORA
A federal mandate, a New York registry, and a duty you do not have
In 1996 the United States Congress modified the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act to require released sex offenders to register with their local law enforcement agencies and to register their addresses with those agencies. Those agencies, in turn, can make the addresses available to the public. The federal law is known commonly as Megan's Law, and it required all states to enact their own version by September 1997.
New York's answer: SORA
New York's version of Megan's Law falls under the Sex Offender Registration Act of 1996, which everyone in practice calls SORA. Any person convicted of a sexual crime and released on probation, or released from jail, from state prison or from another institution, must register with the Division of Criminal Justice Services at least ten days prior to release. The registry is a state registry, held by a state agency, and that is the first thing a question about it tests.
Offenders from outside New York
Offenders who live outside New York but who work in the state or go to school here must also register, and their registration must include the address of the employer or the educational institution. The registry follows where a person spends the day, not only where a person sleeps. An offender who lives in New Jersey and works in Rockland County is inside New York's scheme.
How the public gets the information
There are two routes and a buyer can use either one. The first is the Division of Criminal Justice Services itself, by telephone or through its public website. The second is the local police agency, which will help an interested party look. Both routes are open to any member of the public, and neither one requires a real estate license, a lawyer or a reason for asking.
That last sentence is the whole of your position. The information is public. Any buyer who wants it can get it in an afternoon without your help. New York courts have held that the burden of researching the registry sits with the buyer, and the next screen is the case that says so.
So handle it the same way every time. At the buyer consultation, tell your buyers the registry exists, tell them who keeps it, and tell them how to reach it. Put that in writing in your file. Then let the buyers do the search themselves. You are pointing at a public source, and pointing at a public source is a service you can give every buyer identically.
Identically is the word doing the work there. A script you use with every buyer, in the same words, at the same point in the relationship, is a script you can defend later. A favor you do for one buyer and not for another is a pattern somebody else gets to characterize, and characterizing patterns is what plaintiffs' lawyers do for a living.
Hypothetical. Your buyers are under contract on a house in Suffolk County and the wife calls on a Saturday. A neighbor mentioned that someone on the block is on the registry and she wants you to look it up and tell her. You tell her the registry is public, you give her the Division of Criminal Justice Services website and the number for the local police, and you email her the same two lines that afternoon so there is a record. She searches it herself in ten minutes. You answered the question, you did not become the source of the answer, and the file shows exactly what you said.
NOTE: Three numbers and one agency carry this screen. Congress acted in 1996, the states had until September 1997, and New York's SORA arrived in 1996. Registration happens at least ten days before release, and it happens with the Division of Criminal Justice Services. A choice that names a local police department as the agency of registration is the distractor.
Public registry, buyer's search
REMEMBER: A buyer asks you at the second showing whether any registered offenders live on that block. Say out loud, in one sentence, exactly what you will answer and where you will send her.
Glazer v. LoPreste
The case that settled what a licensee owes about the neighbors
Glazer v. LoPreste, Supreme Court, Nassau County (2000)
Several lawsuits against real estate licensees and brokers followed the implementation of Megan's Law, and the most notable one in this state is Glazer v. LoPreste. It is the case that answers the question every new agent asks about the registry. If I know, do I have to say? Read the facts and then read the ruling, because the ruling turns on what the buyers did not do and on what the sellers and agents did not do.
THE FACTS
Neil and Kerry Glazer bought a home in Nassau County. After the closing they learned that a convicted sex offender lived across the street. They sued the sellers and both real estate agents, claiming the sellers and the agents had fraudulently concealed the information from them, and they sought punitive damages for the intentional infliction of emotional distress.
THE RULING
The court dismissed the case. Requiring full disclosure would create an unfair duty to impose on sellers and agents, absent a confidential relationship between the buyers and one of the defendants, and there was no such relationship here. Because the information is public and available to everyone, the court upheld caveat emptor. The Glazers had apparently made no effort to discover whether offenders lived in the neighborhood, even though the matter had been publicized in the local media. There was no evidence that the sellers or the agents had actively concealed the offender's presence.
Caveat emptor is the old rule that a buyer is expected to examine a property carefully rather than rely on the seller to point out its problems. New York has cut that rule back hard over the last fifty years, which is why this course spends so much time on required disclosures. Glazer marks one of the places where caveat emptor still stands, and it stands there because the information sits in a public database anyone can search.
What the case means for you
Real estate licensees are not obligated to disclose the presence of registered sex offenders near a property being sold. Point your buyers at the Division of Criminal Justice Services registry and let them do their own research. Then read the court's last finding again. There was no evidence the sellers or agents actively concealed anything. Concealing what you know is a separate wrong with a separate ending, and no case in this chapter protects it.
Hypothetical. A buyer asks you directly whether there is anything about the neighborhood she should look into. You know, because the seller told you, that an offender lives two doors down. You say the registry is public, you tell her where it is, and you write the referral in your file. That is Glazer. Now change one fact. You tell her the block is quiet and there is nothing to look into. That is active concealment, and Glazer will not be there for you.
Active concealment has a concrete meaning. It is doing something to keep a fact from being found. Answering a direct question falsely. Steering a buyer away from the neighbor who would have told her. Taking a document out of a file before the buyer's side sees it. The court in Glazer looked for evidence of that conduct and found none, and the absence of it is part of why the case was dismissed. Another part was that the buyers made no effort to look at a public record that had already been in the local paper.
License restrictions
A companion rule in New York law decides who is allowed to carry a license in this business, and that rule belongs on this screen rather than somewhere in the licensing chapter. It is the other side of the same policy. The public gets a registry it can search, and the licensing system keeps the people on that registry out of the profession that opens front doors for a living.
New York State law prohibits anyone convicted of a felony or misdemeanor sex offense, or of a sexually violent offense, from obtaining or keeping a real estate license. The intent of the law is plain from what a licensee actually does all day. The license is a key to other people's homes, and the State does not hand that key to a person convicted of these crimes.
Under the law, misdemeanor-level sex offenses include these.
Sexual misconduct
Sexual abuse, second degree
Forcible touching
Unlawful imprisonment, 2nd degree
Hate crimes
There is also a reporting duty that runs the other way. Whenever a person licensed as a real estate broker or salesperson is convicted, in New York or anywhere else, of a felony, of a sex offense, of any offense committed elsewhere that would constitute a sex offense, or of a sexually violent offense, the licensee must transmit a certified copy of the judgment of conviction to the Department of State within five days of the imposition of sentence. Five days from sentencing. The licensee does the transmitting, and a certified copy is what the Department wants.
CAUTION: The five-day rule catches people because nothing prompts it. No form arrives, no notice goes out, and the licensee is usually thinking about anything except the Department of State that week. The clock runs from the imposition of sentence whether anything prompts it or not.
Public information; no duty to disclose
REMEMBER: Name the one thing Glazer does not protect. Then say how many days a convicted licensee has, and what document has to reach the Department of State inside them.
Lesson 3
New York City Bedbug Disclosure
Administrative Code § 27-2018.1 and Form DBB-N
NYC Bedbug Disclosure
NYC Administrative Code §27-2018.1 and form DBB-N
Article 4 of the Administrative Code of the City of New York covers extermination and rodent eradication, and in 2010 the City amended it to deal with bedbugs. The amendment requires owners and landlords of property within the City of New York to disclose the bedbug infestation history of a property before it is leased. This is a City rule. It binds property inside the five boroughs and it does not reach a rental in Albany.
What the notice must say
For housing accommodations subject to the code, an owner shall furnish to each tenant signing a vacancy lease a notice, in a form promulgated or approved by the State Division of Housing and Community Renewal, that sets forth the property's bedbug infestation history for the previous year. The history covers the premises rented by the tenant and the building in which those premises are located. One year back, the apartment and the building, in writing, at signing.
The trigger is the vacancy lease. The notice belongs with the lease package, next to the other documents a new tenant signs, and the owner furnishes it rather than waiting for anyone to ask.
Upon written complaint by the tenant, in a form promulgated or approved by the Division of Housing and Community Renewal, that he or she was not furnished with a copy of the required notice, the Division shall order the owner to furnish the notice. A tenant who was skipped has a route that costs nothing and takes one form, so a landlord who skips the notice gains nothing by it.
Form DBB-N
The form is titled Owner's Notice to Tenant, Disclosure of Bedbug Infestation History, and it comes from the New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal. It asks for the names of the tenants, the subject premises, the apartment number and the date of the vacancy lease. Then it offers a short set of boxes, and only the boxes checked apply. The building had an infestation in the past year and eradication measures were taken, with the floors named. The building had one, with the floors named, and eradication measures were not taken. The apartment had one and measures were employed. The apartment had one and measures were not employed. There is no history of any bedbug infestation within the past year, in the building or in any apartment. Or a box marked Other, with a line to fill in. The tenant signs and dates it, and the owner or managing agent signs and dates it.
Your job as a licensee
You are not an expert in pest control and nobody expects you to be one. On a first walk-through of a property you should still be on the lookout for the tell-tale signs of insect infestation or damage. Dark spotting along a mattress seam. Shed skins in a bed frame joint. Peeling paneling that nobody wants you to look behind. You are responsible for what you know and for what you should know, and a walk-through is where the second half of that sentence is decided.
Ask the sellers whether they know of any problem, the same way you ask about water damage or a roof leak. Ask it out loud, ask it early, and write down the answer. The question costs you nothing at the listing appointment and it is worth a great deal eighteen months later when somebody wants to know what you were told.
Then disclose. You are obligated to disclose material facts and defects about the condition of the property to a buyer even where a seller claims that the disclosure violates your agency relationship and your fiduciary obligations of loyalty, obedience or confidentiality. When that argument starts, remind the seller of what you told him at the first listing appointment. You must treat everyone fairly and honestly, and you said so before he signed.
CAUTION: Are bedbugs a material fact? That is an argument that could end up in court, and a court is an expensive place to find out. Disclosure of the facts that are important to the transaction is what keeps you out of the room where the question gets answered.
Vacancy lease in, DBB-N out
REMEMBER: You are renting a Brooklyn walk-up to a new tenant on Thursday. What has to be in the signing package besides the lease, how far back does it look, and what does it cover besides the apartment itself?
What Happens After a 311 Call
New York City's enforcement protocol for bed bug complaints
The disclosure is the paperwork. This is what happens when an infestation is real and a tenant picks up the phone. Learn the sequence, because you will be the person a tenant calls first, and because the owner you manage property for will want to know what is coming and in what order.
1 · HPD inspects
When a complaint is made to 311 about bed bugs in a residential building, a housing inspector from the Department of Housing Preservation and Development may conduct an inspection. The inspector examines the places bed bugs are commonly found, on and around mattresses, beds and headboards, and any other potentially infested areas the tenant directs him to. If the inspector finds bed bugs, the property owner is issued an HPD Notice of Violation ordering that the condition be addressed.
2 · The Commissioner's order
When HPD issues that Notice of Violation, the property owner also receives an Order of the Commissioner from the Health Department. The order tells the owner what has to be done. Hire a licensed pest management professional to treat the infestation. Inspect, and where necessary treat, the apartments next to the infested unit and the ones above and below it. Keep a record of every treatment conducted. When those actions have been taken, the owner notifies HPD that the problem has been corrected, through HPD's violation certification process.
3 · Persistent problems
Beginning in 2011 the City took a stronger approach to owners who persistently fail to comply with the Housing and Health Codes. Where bed bugs persist, or occur in multiple apartments in the same building, the Health Department issues an Order of the Commissioner requiring several additional steps. The owner develops a building-wide Pest Management Plan and distributes it to tenants. The owner notifies tenants that bed bugs have been found in the building and provides guidance on preventing and controlling infestations. And the owner has the licensed exterminator complete an Affidavit of Correction of Pest Infestation to prove the treatment happened.
Failing to file
Owners who fail to provide these documents to the Health Department in a timely way are issued a Notice of Violation and have to appear at a hearing before the City's Environmental Control Board, where fines may be levied. The fine is rarely the worst of it. The hearing, the exterminator, the adjacent units and the vacancy while the work is done all land on the same owner in the same month.
Notice what the City asks of the owner at each stage. An inspection the owner does not control. An order the owner did not ask for. A licensed professional the owner has to hire. Records the owner has to keep. A certification the owner has to file to close the violation out. Every one of those steps is a place where an owner who is slow, or badly advised, turns a treatable problem into a hearing.
Here is where this touches your week. A tenant calls you about bites, not about a statute. Write down what the tenant tells you and the date. Route it to the owner in writing the same day. Follow up in writing when the treatment is scheduled. If the matter ever reaches HPD or the Environmental Control Board, the file you built in the first week is the only version of events anybody can check.
NOTE: Keep the three agencies straight. A tenant calls 311. HPD inspects and issues the Notice of Violation. The Health Department issues the Order of the Commissioner and escalates where the problem persists. The Environmental Control Board is where the fines get levied.
311, HPD, Health, ECB
REMEMBER: A tenant in a building you manage reports bed bugs this morning. Name the first agency through the door, the document the owner receives from each of the two agencies, and the one thing you do before the end of the day.
Lesson 4
The Commission Escrow Act
RPL § 294-b, protecting a commission you already earned
The Commission Escrow Act
Real Property Law §294-b, effective 2009
Picture the deal where everything went right and the money still did not arrive. The broker took the listing, marketed the house, produced a buyer who was ready, willing and able, and carried the deal to the closing table. At the table the seller refuses to pay the commission. Before 2009, the broker's options were to accept less money than the agreement called for or to file a lawsuit and wait. Neither one is a business plan.
In 2009 the New York Commission Escrow Act, §294-b of the Real Property Law, went into effect. The Act gives real estate brokers a way to protect a commission they earned by performing the terms of their brokerage agreement, where the seller or the buyer refused to pay it at closing. It does that by securing the disputed money instead of leaving the broker to chase it.
What it covers
The Act applies to the sale of residential real property, and residential includes a condominium unit and an interest in a cooperative apartment. Those are the three things to remember, and a question about this Act almost always asks you to pick them out of a list.
What it does not do
The Act does not apply to vacant property, to commercial property or to leased property. It does not create a lien on the property, even though the county clerk files it in the lien docket, which is exactly the fact the exam uses to bait you. And it does not invalidate the transfer of the real property. The deed still passes and the buyer still owns the house. What changes is where the disputed commission sits while the fight is settled.
The bold-face statement
The provisions of the Commission Escrow Act are applicable only where a binding brokerage agreement between the broker and the client contains the following statement, in clear and conspicuous bold face type.
“At the time of closing, you may be required to deposit the broker's commission with the county clerk in the event that you do not pay the broker his or her commission as set forth herein. Your obligation to deposit the broker's commission with the county clerk may be waived by the broker.”
No statement, no protection. A brokerage agreement without that paragraph in bold face leaves the broker exactly where brokers stood in 2008, which is holding an unpaid invoice and a decision about whether to sue. Drafting the agreement is the broker's job. Reading it is yours, because you are the one who will hand it to a seller and answer questions about it.
Affidavit of entitlement
A broker who disputes a commission files an affidavit of entitlement to commission for completion of brokerage services with the Department of State, and attaches the brokerage agreement to it. The statute is specific about who may file. Only the duly licensed real estate broker can file the affidavit of entitlement. The broker is also responsible for any applicable filing fees. A salesperson never files this document, and a salesperson who files one under a salesperson license number has created a second problem on top of the unpaid commission.
CAUTION: Two conditions carry this whole Act, and an exam question will usually break one of them. The bold-face statement has to be in the brokerage agreement before any of this works, and the person who files the affidavit has to be a licensed broker.
Bold face in the agreement, broker files
REMEMBER: Pull up your office's listing agreement tonight. Is the escrow paragraph in it, is it in bold face, and who in your office is the person allowed to file on it?
How the Escrow Works, and the Two Clocks
Miss either deadline and the protection is gone
Once the affidavit is filed and served, the law moves the money. Any disputed commission is taken out of the proceeds of the sale and placed into escrow with the county clerk, in the county where the property is located, and it stays there until the dispute is resolved. Escrow here means what it means everywhere else in this course. A thing of value is held by a disinterested third party until the conditions are met.
The law in no way takes sides. It is a method to secure the funds until an impartial review of the case takes place, or until both parties come to some agreement of their own. At that point the funds are distributed to whoever is entitled to them. The Act leaves the question of who is right to that review or to the parties themselves. What the Act settles is that the money will still exist on the day somebody answers it.
That is the protection, and it is a real one. Money already in the county clerk's hands is money the seller cannot spend on the next house. A seller who knows the deposit is coming has a reason to settle the argument that a seller holding all the cash never has.
60 days
A broker must initiate action within sixty days of the deposit. Miss it and the seller can ask the county clerk for the return of the funds, and the money you secured goes back to the person who refused to pay you. Sixty days from the deposit, not from the closing and not from the day the argument started.
Six months
A broker must initiate legal action within six months of the deposit or lose any claim for the commission entirely. This is the clock that ends the matter. The first clock decides whether the money stays put. The second clock decides whether you still have a claim at all.
What goes in the affidavit
Who you are. Your name and your license number, and a sworn statement that you are a duly licensed real estate broker in the State of New York who produced a person ready, willing and able to purchase the property or an interest in a cooperative apartment, under a written contract of brokerage employment with the owner.
Who owes you. The name of the seller or of the person responsible for the commission. Where somebody other than the seller authorized the sale on the seller's behalf, that person's name and the date of the authorization go in as well.
What property. The county in New York where the real property or the cooperative interest is situated, a description of it, and the amount of the commission that is due and unpaid.
What you did. A schedule of the brokerage services performed with the applicable dates against them, and the written brokerage employment agreement attached as an exhibit. That attached agreement is the one carrying the bold-face statement, which is why the two screens belong together.
Hypothetical. A broker in Utica closes a house on the first of March and the seller announces at the table that he is paying half the commission because he found the buyer at a barbecue. The brokerage agreement carries the bold-face statement. The broker files the affidavit of entitlement with the Department of State, attaches the agreement, and the disputed half goes to the Oneida County clerk instead of into the seller's account. Nothing about who is right has been decided. What has been decided is that the money is still there in June.
The affidavit does one more thing. By filing it and serving it on the seller, the broker puts the seller on notice that if the broker is not paid at or before the delivery of the deed, or the delivery of the stock certificate and proprietary lease, the lesser of the net proceeds of the sale or the unpaid portion of the compensation must be deposited by the seller with the county clerk at that moment. Where the seller fails to make the deposit, the seller may be responsible for the broker's costs and reasonable attorney fees under §294-b(5).
CAUTION: Both clocks start on the same day, the day of the deposit. Sixty days to initiate action keeps the money where it is. Six months to initiate legal action keeps the claim alive. A broker who lets the first one pass still has a claim. A broker who lets the second one pass has nothing.
60 days for the money, 6 months for the claim
REMEMBER: The deposit went in with the county clerk on the first of March. What is the last useful day in April, and what is the last useful day of the whole matter?
Lesson 5
Antitrust Laws and the Real Estate Industry
Where competing and cooperating collide
Why Real Estate Is Exposed to Antitrust
You compete with the same people you cooperate with
Antitrust is a business activity that attempts to monopolize, to contract or to conspire, or any of those things together, in a way that negatively affects another party's ability to do business. The antitrust laws regulate business activity generally, on the conclusion that restraint of trade practices are so injurious to competition that they could never be justified as anything but unreasonable, and are therefore illegal. It is a complicated subject and it reaches many industries. It reaches this one hard.
The nature of real estate practice makes licensees particularly open to an antitrust challenge. You compete vigorously against the firm across the street to secure the listings you offer for sale. Then you cooperate with that same firm, constantly, as subagents, as buyer's agents and as broker's agents, to find ready, willing and able buyers for those same listings. That dual tradition of competing and cooperating exists in few other professions, and it is exactly what creates the opening for antitrust misconduct, whether intentional or inadvertent.
Carry one rule into every conversation with a competitor. When engaging in real estate, never behave in such a way as to limit the consumer's choices. That sentence answers most of the questions this chapter will ask you, and it answers most of the situations your career will hand you.
The federal framework
The Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 was the earliest federal law to address antitrust issues. It outlawed practices harmful to consumers, monopolies among them. It was a first step, and it was considered vague and therefore difficult to enforce.
The Clayton Antitrust Act of 1914 was passed to enhance the Sherman Act by prohibiting specific anticompetitive practices. It bans mergers and acquisitions, and price discrimination, that lessen competition and create a monopoly in any line of commerce. It also provides more stringent penalties for businesses that do not abide by these laws.
The Federal Trade Commission Act, also passed in 1914, created the Federal Trade Commission as the nation's consumer protection agency. The stated mission of the FTC is to prevent business practices that are anticompetitive, deceptive or unfair to consumers, to enhance informed consumer choice and public understanding of the competitive process, and to accomplish both without unduly burdening legitimate business activity. Congress has added to the agency's authority over the years.
Hypothetical. Four brokers sit on a local board committee that meets every month to talk about the MLS. They are competitors in the morning and partners in the afternoon, and by the third meeting nobody in the room thinks of the others as competitors at all. That room is where antitrust cases in this industry come from. The people in it are not criminals and they are usually trying to make the market work better. The law does not ask what they were trying to do.
NOTE: Federal antitrust laws identify certain activities that are presumed to be an unreasonable restraint on trade regardless of intent. Regardless of intent is the phrase to underline. Meaning well is not a defense, and neither is a friendly lunch where nobody thought of it as a conspiracy.
Compete hard; never limit the choice
REMEMBER: Name the three federal acts and the years. Then say which one created an agency, and which one a felony conviction comes out of.
The Four Per Se Violations
Presumed an unreasonable restraint on trade, whatever you meant
Four activities are presumed to be an unreasonable restraint on trade. Presumed means the court does not weigh whether the arrangement was reasonable, whether it helped anyone, or whether you meant any harm by it. The agreement itself is the violation. Learn these four as four, because the exam asks you to name them and the field asks you to notice them while somebody is still talking.
Price fixing
Antitrust problems most frequently arise out of agreements, conspiracies really, among competitors that have the effect of eliminating or restricting competition between the parties to the agreement. A common subject of such agreements is the price or fee each competitor charges its customers. In this profession that usually means commission rates. The prohibition is simple to state. Two or more competing real estate firms may not agree on the commission rate that each will charge. Brokers must not agree with others on commission rates, and must take care to avoid even implying that they have discussed or reached agreement on fees. Agents must take the same care to avoid the implication that their firm is part of a price-fixing conspiracy.
A seller will ask you what the standard commission rate is, probably this year. There is a correct answer and it takes one breath. Your broker sets your firm's rate, every other broker sets their own, and the seller is free to shop all of them. Anything you add to that answer about what other firms charge, what the MLS expects, or what everybody in the area is at, moves you toward the violation this paragraph describes.
Market allocation
Two or more brokers who conspire to divide their customers in any way are guilty of market allocation, also called market division or territory allocation. It might be an agreement to split a city into specific territories. It might be an agreement that each firm handles properties within a certain price range or a certain neighborhood. Even where the arrangement sounds logical, and saving gas money sounds very logical at lunch, it restrains trade because it limits the choices of the consumer. Any restraint on trade is illegal.
Group boycotting
A boycott is a concerted refusal to deal with a particular party, as when two or more businesses agree to refuse to deal with another competitor to force a change in that competitor's behavior or to drive it out of business. The typical group boycott allegation in this business is a claim that two or more real estate firms have agreed to refuse to cooperate with a third firm, or to cooperate only on less favorable terms. The target is often a broker using a discount, an alternative or some other nontraditional commission arrangement with clients. The purpose, said out loud or left unsaid, is to eliminate that firm as a competitor or to make it abandon the discount. The antitrust laws make boycotts like these illegal.
Tie-in arrangements
A tie-in arrangement is a requirement that a consumer, as a condition of a transaction, use or not use a particular service or product. The classic example in real estate is a broker who requires a buyer to use a certain inspection company, lender or other service provider as a condition of an exclusive buyer agreement. Handing a buyer three inspectors and letting the buyer choose is service. Making one of them a condition of your representation is a tie-in.
A fifth risk: disparagement
Putting a competitor down to build yourself up has no place in a professional business. False, misleading or negative comments about a competitor to a client, about a client to a competitor, about a customer, about a fellow licensee, or about a group or organization, are at best gossip. Making an untruthful spoken statement about a person that harms that person's reputation or standing in the community is slander. The slandered person could bring a civil lawsuit under the Clayton Antitrust Act where the statements negatively affected that person's business.
Hypothetical. Two brokers in Queens agree over coffee that neither office will show listings from a flat-fee firm that opened last spring, because there is no money in it for either of them. Nobody signs anything. Nobody raises a rate. That is a group boycott, complete the moment they agree, and the fact that they were only protecting their own agents' paychecks is not a defense to any part of it.
NOTE: Count them carefully. Price fixing, market allocation, group boycotting and tie-in arrangements are the four presumed violations. Disparagement is a fifth risk that reaches you through slander and a Clayton Act suit rather than as a per se violation, and a question that lists five per se violations is testing that difference.
Price, territory, boycott, tie-in
REMEMBER: Say the four in order, then give the sentence a working agent would actually say out loud for each one.
What a Violation Sounds Like
If you hear yourself saying one of these, stop talking
Nobody in real estate signs a document called a conspiracy. It happens in sentences, at a closing table, in a board meeting, over lunch, in the car on the way back from a broker open house. The sentences are ordinary and they sound like shop talk. So learn the sentences themselves, because recognizing one while it is still in your mouth is the entire skill.
Price fixing sounds like this
“This is the rate every firm charges.” “I'd like to lower the commission, but no one else in the MLS will show your house unless the commission is X percent.” “Commission rates are pretty standard.” Each one tells a consumer that the price is set by the market as a whole rather than by your broker alone. The third one is the dangerous one, because it sounds like a harmless answer to a question a seller asks in every listing appointment.
Market allocation sounds like this
“It could save us both a lot of gas if your firm would concentrate on the north side and ours concentrated on the south side.” It is a friendly sentence about fuel and drive time. It is also a proposal to divide the customers of an entire city between two firms, and a consumer on the north side has just lost half her choices without ever hearing about it.
Group boycotting sounds like this
“Let's not show those listings from UP Realty since they charge a flat fee and you won't make much commission.” “If they truly wanted to cooperate, they would not allow part-timers to work for them.” “I bet they'd drop their discount program if we told them they couldn't market or sell our listings.” All three are the language of a concerted refusal to deal, and the third one says the purpose out loud.
Tie-in arrangements sound like this
“If I'm going to submit an offer for you, I need you to use XYZ Home Inspectors.” “I only work with ABC Mortgage Company, so you need to call them before we proceed.” Both make a service provider a condition of your representation. Turn the condition into a recommendation the buyer is free to decline, and the same advice becomes lawful.
Disparagement sounds like this
“You don't want to list with ABC Realty; they don't know how to close a deal.” “Before you list with XYZ Realty, you should know that nobody works on their listings.” Neither sentence describes your own service. Both describe a competitor's, in terms you could not prove in a courtroom, to a consumer who is deciding where to take her business.
Read the five groups again and notice where each one happens. Price fixing happens at a listing appointment and at a board meeting. Market allocation happens in a car or over lunch, between two people who like each other. Group boycotting happens in an office when a discount firm opens nearby and everybody is annoyed about it. Tie-in arrangements happen while you are writing an agreement, because it is genuinely easier to work with the vendor you trust. Disparagement happens when you are losing a listing and reaching for something to say.
Hypothetical. You are at a broker open house in Bay Ridge and an agent from another firm says, within earshot of two more agents, that her office has stopped showing a flat-fee brokerage's listings and asks whether yours has done the same. Say that you cannot have that conversation, and mean it. Then leave the group. That evening, write down the date, the address, who spoke and what was said, and send it to your broker. You have not agreed to anything, and now there is a record made the same day saying so.
When you hear one of these from another licensee, say plainly that you cannot discuss it, and change the subject or leave the conversation. Then write down the date, who was there and what was said, and tell your broker. Antitrust liability attaches to the agreement, and the clearest evidence that you did not agree is a record you made the same day.
Commission rates are set independently by each broker. There can be no standardized rate among competitors, and none among the members of any organization, a local board of REALTORS included. A seller who asks you what the standard rate is deserves a straight answer, and the straight answer is that your broker sets your rate and every other broker sets their own.
CAUTION: The trap on this screen is the honest-sounding sentence. Commission rates are pretty standard reads like a neutral observation about the market. Said to a seller, it tells that seller there is no point shopping, and that is the harm the price-fixing rule exists to prevent.
Rates are set one broker at a time
REMEMBER: Which of the sentences above is closest to something you have already heard somebody say in an office? What will you say back the next time you hear it?
The Cases That Built the Rules
Antitrust reaches real estate, one decision at a time
Four cases built the rules you just learned, and three of them were brought against boards of real estate brokers rather than against individual agents. Read them for the pattern. In every one of them, the people involved thought they were doing ordinary business, and in every one of them the federal government treated it as a restraint on trade.
1950 · U.S. v. NAREB
It was not until 1950 that the concepts of antitrust were formally applied to the real estate industry. In United States v. National Association of Real Estate Boards, at 339 U.S. 485, the charge was that members of the Washington Real Estate Board, a member board of the National Association, had combined and conspired to fix the commission rates for their services as brokers in the sale, exchange, lease and management of real property in the District of Columbia, in violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act.
The Board's code of ethics provided that brokers should maintain the standard rates of commission adopted by the Board, and that no business should be solicited at lower rates. Members agreed to abide by the code. The prescribed rates were used in the great majority of transactions, with a lower charge made in exceptional situations. Departure from the prescribed rates brought no sanction from the Board at all.
The federal District Court decided in favor of the Board, holding that the agreement to fix the rates of brokerage commissions was no violation of the Sherman Act, because the prescribed rates were not mandatory. On appeal the Court ruled that price fixing is per se an unreasonable restraint of trade and therefore illegal under the Sherman Act. The absence of a penalty for deviating from the schedule was not material, and it was not for the Court to determine whether a standard commission schedule served a worthy end. The decision also affirmed that a business selling services, as opposed to goods or products, is not excluded from a charge of restraint of trade.
1969 · Prince George's County
In December of 1969 a civil action was filed in the United States District Court for Maryland charging the Prince George's County Board of REALTORS®, Inc. with violating Section 1 of the Sherman Antitrust Act. The Board had about a thousand agents in Prince George's and the surrounding counties, and it operated a multiple listing service that most of its members joined. It required members to submit their residential listings in the county to the MLS using a recommended fee schedule.
The complaint alleged that the Board's activities raised commission rates and maintained them at an artificial and non-competitive rate, eliminated price competition, and denied sellers the right to use the services of agents at competitively determined rates of commission. It was treated as a test case on whether Section 1 of the Sherman Act reached the activities of a local board of real estate brokers. It settled with a consent decree, a binding agreement through which the accused party consents to change its behavior while admitting no misconduct.
1972 · Long Island Board
Local boards once commonly used mandatory commission schedules for their members, including the splits offered to cooperating brokers. In the 1972 case of U.S. v. Long Island Board of REALTORS®, Inc., a consent decree similar to the last one resulted. The Board had a recommended fee schedule that all ethical brokers were expected to follow, and the MLS, which was then a committee of the Board rather than a separate entity, set the split on MLS listings. The Department of Justice sued, and the Long Island Board agreed to end the practice of providing recommended commission and cooperating broker split schedules.
1974 · U.S. v. Foley
In United States v. Foley, at 598 F.2d 1323, a federal grand jury alleged that an unlawful agreement had been reached when real estate broker John Foley announced to fellow brokers at a 1974 dinner party in Montgomery County, Maryland that he intended to raise his commission rates from 6 percent to 7 percent. A discussion about the rate change followed, and within the next several months most of the other defendants adopted a 7 percent rate.
All defendants were found guilty of violating Section 1 of the Sherman Antitrust Act, which is a felony. They appealed, arguing among other things that there was insufficient evidence that a conspiracy existed. In the months before the dinner they had each independently contemplated raising rates, they said, though they conceded they had not raised them out of fear of losing business to firms charging 6 percent. In 1979 the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit upheld the convictions, construing Foley's announcement as an invitation to conspire and the subsequent action of the other competitors as an acceptance of that invitation. An inference of conspiracy can be drawn even where the other competitors had each already decided independently to adopt the policy, but had not yet done so.
Put the four together and the lesson is uncomfortable. No signature was needed. No penalty clause was needed. In Foley, one man talking at a dinner and other people going home and acting was enough for a felony conviction that a federal appeals court refused to disturb.
NOTE: Two of these four carry most of the exam questions. NAREB is the per se rule and the holding that selling services is still trade. Foley is the invitation and the acceptance, and it is the one that attaches the word felony to a conversation at a party.
No signature is needed to conspire
REMEMBER: In NAREB the Board imposed no penalty for charging less. Why did that fact not save them, and which of the four cases would you cite to a colleague who says a lunch conversation cannot be a conspiracy?
Penalties for Antitrust Violations
Who brings the case, what a court orders, and what it costs
Violating a state or federal antitrust law is a serious offense, and more than one office can come after you for it. The United States Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission may file civil lawsuits against violators of federal antitrust laws. A state's attorney general may file civil suits to enforce both state and federal law, so a single arrangement can be attacked from Washington and from Albany at the same time.
Initial responses to a civil suit
A cease and desist order is an administrative agency directive to stop the offending activity. Injunctive relief is a court-ordered prohibition against a particular act, as opposed to a judgment for money, and it is often imposed for violating a cease and desist order. Both of them put an agency or a court between you and the way you were doing business, before anyone has calculated a dollar of damages.
PENALTIES UNDER THE SHERMAN ANTITRUST ACT
Felony
conviction
A Sherman Act § 1 violation is a felony.
$350K
maximum fine
For individuals.
$10M
maximum fine
For corporations.
3 years
Maximum imprisonment.
In addition, the Clayton Act provides that any person whose business or property has been injured by anyone violating these antitrust laws may sue and recover triple the damages, plus any reasonable attorney fees. Triple damages are what make a private antitrust suit worth bringing, which means the plaintiff across from you may be the discount broker you agreed to freeze out rather than a government lawyer.
There is one more cost that never appears on the list. A felony conviction bars a person from holding a real estate license in New York. The fine ends. The prison term ends. The bar on the license does not end with either of them.
CAUTION: The dollar figures on this screen are set by federal statute and Congress has revised them over time. Learn the structure the exam tests: a Sherman Act §1 violation is a felony, individuals and corporations face different maximum fines, and the Clayton Act adds treble damages plus attorney fees on top.
Felony, fines, prison, triple damages
REMEMBER: Which two federal offices may file the civil suit, and which Act lets the broker you boycotted collect three times what you cost her?
Chapter Summary
The six things to carry out of this chapter
Six ideas ran through this chapter, and four of them are about the difference between what you may keep quiet and what you must say. Run through them once before the quiz.
Stigmatized property
A stigmatized property is undesirable to many buyers because of a past event rather than because of its condition. Under §443-a those events are not material facts or defects, so sellers and licensees are not required to disclose them, and that includes the HIV or AIDS status of an owner or occupant. No cause of action arises from the silence and the Department of State cannot discipline you for it. A buyer may still submit a written inquiry, and a seller may still decline to answer it.
Pre-contract disclosures
Four notices come before a binding purchase agreement. No utility electric service and an electric or gas utility surcharge, both under §242, both delivered before the seller accepts a purchase offer. Uncapped natural gas wells the seller has actual knowledge of, under §242(3), disclosed before the contract is entered into. And the agricultural district disclosure notice under §333-c, which goes inside the contract of sale itself.
Megan's Law and SORA
Megan's Law was adopted federally in 1996 and required the states to build their own notification schemes. New York's is the Sex Offender Registration Act of 1996, administered by the Division of Criminal Justice Services. Courts have held that real estate licensees are not obligated to disclose the presence of registered offenders near a property being sold, and Glazer v. LoPreste is the New York case that says so. Point the buyer at the public registry, and never actively conceal what you know.
NYC bedbug disclosure
New York City landlords must tell a new tenant in writing whether the apartment or the building had a bedbug infestation in the past year. It is done on form DBB-N from the Division of Housing and Community Renewal, furnished to every tenant signing a vacancy lease, under §27-2018.1 of the Administrative Code.
The Commission Escrow Act
Section 294-b of the Real Property Law lets a broker secure a disputed commission that was already earned, by having it deposited with the county clerk out of the proceeds of the sale. It works only where the brokerage agreement carries the required statement in clear and conspicuous bold face type, only a licensed broker may file the affidavit of entitlement, and the broker has sixty days to initiate action and six months to initiate legal action.
Antitrust
Price fixing, group boycotting, market allocation and tie-in arrangements are the four presumed violations, with disparaging the competition sitting beside them as a fifth risk. Discussing commission rates with a competitor is potentially a violation on its own. Commission rates are set independently by each broker, so there can be no standardized rate among competitors or among the members of any organization.
One thread ties the six together. Every rule in this chapter is an answer to the same question, asked in six settings. What does this transaction require me to say, and what does the law allow me to leave alone? Section 443-a answers it for a stigma, §242 and §333-c answer it for a parcel, Glazer answers it for the neighbors, §27-2018.1 answers it for a City rental, §294-b answers it for your own money, and the antitrust laws answer it for every conversation you have with a competitor.
Four disclosures, four violations
REMEMBER: Cover this screen and name all six headings from memory. The one you cannot name is the one to reread before you take the quiz.
You Be the Judge
The Bay Ridge Blunder, a graded issue-spotting case
Everything in this chapter arrives in real life the way it arrives below. It arrives as an ordinary week, in which a busy agent keeps making small decisions that each feel reasonable at the time, and every one of those decisions has a statute sitting quietly behind it. Issue spotting is the skill of reading that week and naming what each decision broke. It is the skill the state exam tests through fact patterns, and it is the skill that keeps a license.
Work it in this order. Read the story once through for the story. Then read it a second time one sentence at a time, and after each sentence ask a single question. Did somebody owe a duty here, and to whom? A duty runs to a client, to a customer, to a tenant, to the public or to the Department of State. If no duty is in play, move to the next sentence and lose no time on it.
Then run the sentence against the checklist this chapter gave you. Was a competitor in the room, and did anything get agreed? Was a price, a territory, a firm or a required vendor the subject of it? Was there a disclosure this deal owed before the offer was accepted, or before the contract was entered into, or inside the contract itself? Was a lease signed in New York City, and by whom? Did money move at a closing, and under what agreement? Five questions, asked sentence by sentence, will find almost everything in a fact pattern this size.
Here is the method on a fact pattern that is not the one below. An agent tells a seller that her firm and two others have agreed to stop quoting anything under five percent, then writes the sales contract on a parcel in an agricultural district with no notice in it. Act one. A competitor was in the room, a price was the subject, something was agreed. Price fixing, a per se violation under the Sherman Act. Act two. A disclosure was owed inside the contract itself. The agricultural district disclosure notice under §333-c, missing. Two acts, two rules, one line of analysis each. That is the whole technique.
Name each one the way a grader can score it. Say the act, then say the duty, statute or rule it breaks. Marco agreed with a competitor to do X, which is a per se antitrust violation of a named kind. Marco failed to give notice of Y before Z, which §242 or §333-c requires. Two words of statute beat two sentences of outrage every time, and a right answer with no rule attached earns you nothing.
One more instruction, and it matters. Not everything Marco does below is wrong. One of his acts is lawful, and it is lawful because a New York statute you read earlier in this chapter says so in as many words. Find it and mark it as lawful. Marking a lawful act as a violation is its own mistake, and in the field it is the mistake that makes an agent disclose what the law told them they could keep.
Marco, a salesperson at Harbor & Vine, meets a broker from a rival firm for lunch. “Everybody's at six,” he says. “Let's both stay there and stop undercutting each other.” Over dessert they agree Marco's firm will work north of the parkway and the rival will take everything south. They also agree that neither office will show listings from FlatFee Homes, “because you'll never make a dime on their side.” Back at the office Marco tells a seller, “Don't list with FlatFee, nobody works their listings anyway.”
Marco lists a house in an established agricultural district and writes the contract without the agricultural district notice. The same week he takes a listing on a parcel he knows has an uncapped natural gas well behind the treeline; he says nothing, figuring the buyer's inspector will find it. On a third property he accepts a purchase offer without ever giving written notice that the parcel carries a gas utility surcharge. When a buyer asks whether anyone died in one of the houses, Marco declines to answer.
On a walk-through Marco spots dark spotting along a mattress seam and peeling paneling in a Brooklyn rental. He rents the unit on a vacancy lease anyway, hands the tenant no bedbug form, and tells his seller, “Say nothing, it's not material.” To a buyer client he writes an exclusive agreement conditioned on using Apex Home Inspectors, “or I don't submit your offer.”
When a seller refuses to pay at closing, Marco pulls the brokerage agreement, it has no bold-face escrow language anywhere, and files an affidavit of entitlement to commission with the Department of State under his own name and salesperson license number.
12 violations are buried in this story
, plus one lawful act planted to catch you out.
How many can you spot?
Write your list before you check anything. Number the acts, put the duty or the statute beside each one, and mark the single lawful act as lawful. Then count. If you have fewer than twelve, go back to the paragraph you moved through fastest, because a short list almost always means a skimmed sentence rather than a missing rule.
When you have your list, open the answer key and compare it line by line. Read the ones you missed back into the screen they came from in this chapter, and read the ones you called wrongly twice. The missed issues tell you which screen to reread tonight. The wrongly called ones tell you which rule you learned as a slogan instead of as a rule.
CAUTION: Do not stop at twelve names. Your grade here comes from naming the duty, statute or rule behind each act, and the same skill is what the state exam is measuring when it hands you four answers that all describe the facts correctly and only one of which names the right rule.
Spot it, name it, cite it
REMEMBER: Before you start, say out loud which of this chapter's six topics you would bet appears most often in the story. Then check yourself against your own list when you finish.