The Course · Chapter 3 Beta

Chapter 3: Law of Agency 2 - Disclosure and Listing Forms

§443 Disclosure · Listing Agreements · Buyer-Broker Agreements

In this chapter

  • Spot the trigger Know when agency disclosure must happen, first substantive contact, and which events start the clock.
  • 2 Master the 443 form Use New York's disclosure forms correctly, and explain what the form does NOT do.
  • 3 Name the players Distinguish the six §443 relationships and the fiduciary duties each one owes.
  • 4 Compare listings Tell exclusive right to sell from exclusive agency and open listings, and why net listings are illegal.
  • 5 Paper the buyer side Structure buyer-broker, rental, and cooperation agreements with the required elements.
  • 6 Survive the curveballs Handle a refusal to sign, a mid-deal change of relationship, and Regulation 175.7.

Lesson 1

Part 1: In this session

What you'll be able to do

In This Session

What you'll be able to do

Every agency relationship in New York leaves a paper trail, and this session is about the paper. Two kinds of document do two completely different jobs. Confusing them is the most expensive mistake a new licensee makes, and this chapter exists to stop you making it.

The agency disclosure form required by Section 443 of the Real Property Law tells a consumer which relationships are available and which one you are offering. It signs nobody up for anything. The brokerage agreement does the other job. A listing agreement with a seller. A buyer-broker agreement with a buyer. A rental listing with a landlord. That is the contract that creates the agency relationship and sets the terms you get paid under.

Both documents land on the table in the first hour of your first appointment. Get the order wrong and you have collected confidential information from somebody who never learned who you work for, and you have no signed paper saying otherwise.

This session also covers the moments those documents were written for, and nobody enjoys any of them. A consumer who will not sign. A firm whose buyer client wants to see that same firm's listing. Money offered to you by another party to the transaction. None of that is unusual. All of it is decided by paper you either created at the start or did not.

Six things to carry out of this session.

Spot the trigger

Agency disclosure is due at the first substantive contact. You will learn which events start that clock with a seller, which events start it with a buyer, and why hosting an open house starts it whether you planned on it or not.

Master the 443 form

You will learn what the form says, which transactions it covers, which ones it does not, and the words printed across the top of it in large bold type. Those words are the single most tested line in this chapter.

Name the players

Six relationships run through Section 443, and five of them are boxes on the form. Seller's agent, buyer's agent, broker's agent, subagent, dual agent, and dual agent with designated sales agents. You will learn what each one owes, and which one leaves the principal answering for somebody else's conduct.

Compare listings

Exclusive right to sell, exclusive agency, open listing. You will learn who gets paid under each one, what New York requires every exclusive listing to contain, and why a net listing is not an option here at any price.

Paper the buyer side

Buyer-broker agreements, exclusive right to rent agreements, and the cooperation terms that decide what a broker from another firm takes home. You will learn the three things a buyer-broker agreement has to state before it is worth anything.

Survive the curveballs

A consumer who refuses to sign. A relationship that changes in the middle of a deal. Money offered to you by somebody who is not your client. You will learn what Section 443 and Regulation 175.7 require of you in each of those moments, and how long you keep the paper afterward.

One document discloses, the other creates

REMEMBER: Before you read on, answer it out loud. Which document creates the agency relationship, and which one only describes the choices?

Why Disclosure Exists

Who does my agent really work for?

For most people the purchase or sale of a home is among the largest and most important financial decisions of their lives. Most of those people are not informed about the legal and financial details of the transaction and are not prepared to handle them. You are. That gap is the reason agency disclosure exists.

Every state requires licensees to disclose the nature of the agency relationship a potential client is entering. The point is informed consent. The consumer learns what fiduciary duties are owed, and by whom, before any confidential information changes hands. The consumer also gets a real choice about what kind of relationship is acceptable.

The New York Department of State treats this as central. Consumers are entitled to know who represents them and what being a client actually gets them. So New York requires written disclosure of the agency relationship in residential transactions, on a form the state writes.

Disclosure does three jobs at once.

Informed consent

The consumer knows who represents whom before confidential information is shared. A seller who tells you the lowest number he will take, and a buyer who tells you the highest number she will pay, are both handing over the one fact that decides the negotiation. They are entitled to know where that fact is going.

Agent protection

A written disclosure form protects you against a claim that one thing was said and another was done. Two years after closing, memory is not evidence. A signed form is.

Accountability

The same paper makes you answerable if the Section 443 requirements are not met. That cuts against you, and it is supposed to. A rule nobody can check is not a rule.

Notice who the rule is aimed at. It does not ask the consumer to work out who the agent represents. It puts the duty on the person with the superior knowledge, which is you, and it puts it there before the consumer has said anything worth protecting. Individuals with superior knowledge and ability in the field of real estate are not to take advantage of consumers. That is the whole policy of Section 443 in one sentence.

Underneath all of it sits one distinction that decides everything else in this chapter.

A client is a person you represent. You owe a client the full set of fiduciary duties, and that relationship is created when the client and the broker sign a brokerage agreement. A customer is a person you work with. You owe a customer honesty, fairness, good faith and reasonable care, and you do not represent them. No signed brokerage agreement means no client.

Hypothetical. A buyer walks into your open house on a Sunday and tells you she is pre-approved to $800,000 but would go to $850,000 for the right house. She has signed nothing. She is a customer. That number is not confidential information you are holding for her. It is information you now hold as the seller's agent, and the seller is the person you owe disclosure to.

That example is uncomfortable, and it should be. It is exactly the situation Section 443 was written to prevent, by making you say who you work for before the sentence leaves her mouth.

Change one fact and the duty inverts. If that same buyer had signed a buyer-broker agreement with you the week before, the number she just said is confidential information you protect, and the seller becomes a party you deal with honestly and do not inform. Same words, same Sunday, opposite obligation. The document decides, and the consumer has no way of knowing which document exists unless you tell her.

NOTE: Client and customer are not degrees of importance and they are not about how much you like somebody. They are about whether a brokerage agreement was signed. The exam tests that one fact and nothing else.

Disclose before the confidence, not after

REMEMBER: Think of the last person you spoke to about property. Client or customer, and which piece of paper decides it?

The 443 Disclosure Form

Real Property Law, Article 12-A, §443

The first thing to notice about the New York State agency disclosure form is printed across the top of it in large bold type, and it is five words long.

THIS IS NOT A CONTRACT

The 443 form does not create an agency relationship. The brokerage agreement creates the agency relationship. The form advises the consumer of the nature of the relationships available and the rights and obligations each one creates, helps the consumer make an informed choice, and tells the consumer plainly that without a signed brokerage agreement they are not represented as a client of the licensee.

Students confuse the two documents because both get signed and both go in the same file. The difference is what the signature means. On a brokerage agreement, the signature is agreement to terms. On the 443 form, the signature is an acknowledgment of receipt. The consumer is confirming that a piece of paper was handed over, and nothing else.

Statutory basis

The requirement is found in Article 12-A, Section 443 of the New York State Real Property Law. The 443 disclosure forms must be presented word for word, exactly as they appear in the law. You do not shorten the form, you do not summarize it on your own letterhead, and you do not improve the wording. The state wrote it and the state means it to arrive intact.

Coverage

Written disclosure is required in all residential real property transactions, including multi-family buildings, condominiums and cooperative apartments. Before 2011 the requirement reached only residential property with one- to four-unit dwellings, and condos and co-ops sat outside it. They are inside it now.

The law does not cover vacant land, even where a dwelling is expected to be built on it. A buyer who intends to put a house on the lot is still buying a lot, and the 443 form is not required for that sale.

Hypothetical. A seller lists a two-family house in Mount Vernon, a studio co-op in Manhattan, and four acres of empty land in Dutchess County, all with you, all in the same week. Two of those three listings require the 443 form. The four acres do not, and they do not acquire the requirement because the buyer says he intends to build.

Two versions

There are two separate disclosure forms. One is for the buyer and the seller, DOS-1736-f. The other is for the landlord and the tenant, DOS-1735-f. Same structure, same purpose, different parties named throughout. You pick the form by the transaction, not by preference.

Recordkeeping

Section 443(3)(d) puts two duties on you once a form is signed. Give the consumer a copy of any signed 443 disclosure form. Keep a copy of the signed acknowledgment for not less than three years. Three years is the floor, not the target.

Read what is retained. The signed acknowledgment. Not a note in the file saying disclosure was made, and not your calendar entry for the appointment. The reason three years matters is that a complaint to the Department of State does not arrive the week of the closing. It arrives long after everybody involved has stopped remembering the day clearly, and the only version of the day that still exists is the one in the file.

Presenting the form takes less time than explaining why you did not. Hand it over, walk the consumer down the relationship boxes, say which one you are offering and why, check that box, and ask for the acknowledgment. The whole exchange is a few minutes at the start of a relationship that will last months.

CAUTION: Coverage is the trap on this screen. Vacant land is outside Section 443, and a condominium or a co-op is inside it. A question that hands you a buyer purchasing a building lot is testing whether you learned the exception or guessed at it.

Condos and co-ops yes, vacant land no

REMEMBER: Say the five words at the top of the form. Then say which document does create the agency relationship.

Timing of Disclosure

First substantive contact

The goal of telling a consumer about every available relationship is informed consent about how confidential information will be handled and shared. That goal only works if the telling comes first. So the law fixes a moment, and the moment is the first substantive contact.

First substantive contact is generally the point at which the licensee meets face to face with the prospective client or customer. Disclose as early as you can. Disclosure cannot wait until an offer to purchase is being prepared, and it cannot wait until anybody is comfortable. It comes before any confidential information can be shared.

Substantive is the word doing the work. A wave across a parking lot is not substantive contact. A conversation about what somebody is trying to buy, what they can spend, or what a house is worth is substantive, and it can happen in ninety seconds on a doorstep. If the conversation has turned into business, the contact has turned substantive.

With a seller

Present and sign the form before you deliver a comparative market analysis and before you enter into a listing agreement. The comparative market analysis is the trigger people miss. By the time you are talking about what the house is worth, the seller is telling you why he needs to sell and how fast. That is confidential information and it is already moving.

With a buyer

Present and sign the form no later than the first of these events. Showing the buyer property. Meeting an interested buyer at an open house. Submitting an offer to buy or lease real property on the buyer's behalf. Whichever one happens first is your deadline, and it is a deadline, not a suggestion.

At the very latest

The agency disclosure form must be presented and signed before the broker enters into any listing agreement or any buyer-broker agreement. That is the outer limit. If a brokerage agreement is signed and no 443 form was ever presented, the sequence is broken and no later signature repairs it.

That ordering is the point most fact patterns turn on. Disclosure first, brokerage agreement second. An agent who signs a listing over coffee on Tuesday and brings the disclosure form to the closing in March has the sequence exactly backwards, and bringing the form along at all does not fix it.

Hypothetical. You are covering a colleague's open house in Queens. A couple walks through, likes the kitchen, and the husband tells you they have to be out of their rental by August and will stretch to make it happen. You have not handed them anything. The open house was the trigger, the trigger passed at the front door, and you are now holding information you had no right to receive in silence.

The fix is not complicated. The form goes on the table by the door. You hand it to everyone who walks in, you explain in one sentence who you represent at this house, and you ask for a signature on the acknowledgment. That takes twenty seconds and it meets the timing requirement.

Build the habit around the trigger rather than around the appointment. The form lives in the folder you take to every listing appointment and in the stack you carry to every open house. A licensee who has to go back to the office for a form has already decided to present it late.

NOTE: Exam questions about timing are written to sound reasonable. When the offer is prepared. At the contract signing. At closing. Every one of those is too late, because every one of them comes after confidential information has already moved.

Disclose at the first substantive contact

REMEMBER: Name the three buyer-side events that start the clock. Then name the one seller-side event most licensees forget.

Two Forms, One Job

DOS-1736-f and DOS-1735-f

New York publishes the disclosure in two versions because a sale and a rental have different parties. The content tracks almost word for word. What changes is who is named.

DOS-1736-f is the New York State Disclosure Form for Buyer and Seller. The licensee checks one relationship from the seller's column or one from the buyer's column, and the licensee's name and brokerage are written in above those columns.

The signature page of the form has two blanks that are filled in before it goes across the table. The printed name of the licensee who is providing it, and the printed name of the company, firm or brokerage. Then the sentence that follows those blanks says the licensee is a licensed real estate broker acting in the interest of the seller, or of the buyer. That is the line where you commit to a side, in writing, in front of the consumer.

Seller's Agent

Buyer's Agent

Broker's Agent

Dual Agent

Dual Agent with Designated Agents

DOS-1735-f is the New York State Disclosure Form for Landlord and Tenant. The same five boxes appear, with landlord's agent and tenant's agent in place of seller's agent and buyer's agent. Broker's agent sits on either side on both forms.

Both forms carry a section underneath for advance informed consent to dual agency, and advance informed consent to dual agency with designated sales agents. Both end with the acknowledgment of receipt, signed and dated by the consumer.

Two sentences on the form are worth reading to a consumer out loud. The first says that throughout the transaction the consumer may receive more than one disclosure form, because the law may require each agent assisting in the transaction to present one. The second says that if the consumer needs legal, tax or other advice, they should consult a professional in that field.

That second sentence is the state drawing your professional boundary for you, on your own form, in the consumer's hands. A real estate agent is a person qualified to advise about real estate. Not about taxes. Not about title.

Hypothetical. A tenant asks whether the rent on a two-year lease will be deductible on her taxes, and whether the lease clause about subletting is enforceable. You are holding a form that already tells you how to handle both questions. You are qualified to advise about real estate. You tell her to ask an accountant and a lawyer, and you write down that you told her.

NOTE: Expect multiples. A consumer receiving three disclosure forms in one transaction has not been handed the same paper three times by mistake. Three agents assisted, and each one disclosed.

Pick the form by the transaction

REMEMBER: A landlord hires you to fill a vacancy in a two-family house. Which form number goes on the table, and which two boxes are you choosing between?

The Six Relationships

What each one is and what each one owes

Section 443 recognizes a set of relationships, and the disclosure form puts five of them in its boxes. Learn them as a group, because the exam tests them against each other rather than one at a time.

Each one answers two questions. Who does this person represent, and what does this person owe the party on the other side? Keep those two questions in front of you and the list stops being vocabulary.

Seller's agent and landlord's agent

A seller's agent is engaged by a seller to represent the seller's interests, and does that by securing a buyer for the seller's home at a price and on terms acceptable to the seller. The seller's agent owes the seller reasonable care, undivided loyalty, confidentiality, full disclosure, obedience and the duty to account. A seller's agent does not represent the interests of the buyer. A landlord's agent does the identical job on a rental, securing a tenant at a rent and on terms acceptable to the landlord.

The definition reaches further than the listing agent alone. A seller's agent may be the listing agent acting alone, or an agent acting in cooperation with the listing agent, or an agent acting as the seller's subagent, or an agent acting as a broker's agent to find a buyer.

Buyer's agent and tenant's agent

A buyer's agent is engaged by a buyer to represent the buyer's interests, and does that by negotiating the purchase of a home at a price and on terms acceptable to the buyer. The buyer's agent owes the buyer the same six duties the seller's agent owes the seller. A buyer's agent does not represent the interests of the seller. A tenant's agent does the same work on a lease, negotiating the rental of an apartment or house at a rent and on terms acceptable to the tenant.

Broker's agent

A broker's agent cooperates with, or is engaged by, a listing agent or a buyer's agent from a different firm, to help that agent locate a property to sell or to buy. The broker's agent has no direct relationship with the buyer or the seller. The principal cannot give instructions or direction to the broker's agent, and because the principal cannot direct that conduct, the buyer and the seller do not have vicarious liability for the acts of the broker's agent. The listing agent or buyer's agent does direct the broker's agent, and so the listing agent or buyer's agent carries that liability instead.

Vicarious liability means one person is held responsible for the acts of another. It is the reason this distinction is on the form and on the exam.

Hypothetical. A cooperating agent from another firm shows your listing and tells the buyer the roof was replaced last year. It was not. If that agent was engaged as a broker's agent, your seller does not carry liability for the statement, and the agent who engaged the broker's agent does. If that agent was a subagent of the listing broker, the analysis runs differently, and the seller is exposed. One label, two very different afternoons.

Subagent

A cooperating agent who accepts the listing broker's offer of subagency. Unlike a broker's agent, this DOES create vicarious liability for the seller.

Dual agent

A dual agent is a broker acting as the buyer's agent and the seller's agent in the same transaction, or as the tenant's agent and the landlord's agent in the same transaction. A broker may do that only if both parties give informed consent in writing. A dual agent cannot provide the full range of fiduciary duties to either side.

Dual agent with designated sales agents

Where the buyer and the seller give informed consent in writing, the principals and the dual-agent broker may designate one sales agent to represent the buyer and another to represent the seller. A designated sales agent is a licensed salesperson or associate broker, working under the supervision of the broker, assigned to represent one client in a transaction where a different client is also represented by that same broker. Each designated agent advocates for one side in the negotiation. Their names are written onto the form.

The limit travels down the chain. A designated sales agent must explain that, like the dual agent under whose supervision they function, they cannot provide undivided loyalty.

Lay the six out in a row and a pattern appears. The first two are full representation of one side. The third and fourth are help arriving from outside, and they differ only in who directs the helper. The fifth and sixth are one broker on both sides, and they differ only in whether individual salespeople were named to advocate. Every question about relationships is really a question about who directs, who represents, and who consented.

CAUTION: Broker's agent and subagent look similar on paper and are opposite in consequence. Read any question about a cooperating agent twice, and find the sentence that tells you who is directing the work.

Six relationships, two sides

REMEMBER: Which relationship leaves the seller answerable for a cooperating agent's conduct, and which one leaves the seller out of it?

Lesson 2

Part 2: Fiduciary duties

What an agent owes the client: OLD CAR

Fiduciary Duties

What an agent owes a client: OLD CAR

A client gets fiduciary duties. Six of them, and the disclosure form lists them by name for the seller's agent, the buyer's agent, the landlord's agent and the tenant's agent alike. The initials spell OLD CAR, which is how most licensees keep them straight.

Obedience

Loyalty

Disclosure

Confidentiality

Accounting

Reasonable care

Obedience means you follow the client's lawful instructions. Lawful is the working word. A seller who tells you to keep his home off the multiple listing service is giving you an instruction you obey. A seller who tells you to keep a particular buyer from seeing it is giving you an instruction you refuse, and the reason why arrives later in this course.

Loyalty means undivided loyalty. The client's interests come ahead of your own and ahead of everybody else's, including your own commission. This is the duty that dual agency cannot deliver, which is why dual agency needs written consent.

Disclosure means full disclosure to your client of everything material you know. If you learn the buyer will pay more, your seller learns it. If you learn the seller will take less, your buyer learns it. Which one of those sentences applies to you depends entirely on whose brokerage agreement you are working under.

Confidentiality means you protect the client's private information, and it outlasts the transaction. The seller's motivation, the seller's bottom line, the buyer's ceiling, the reason for the divorce. None of it travels.

Accounting means you account for money and documents that pass through your hands. Deposits, keys, copies of signed forms. You can say where each one is.

Reasonable care means skill and care in performing the duties of the agency. You are held to what a competent licensee would have done, not to what you personally felt like doing that week.

Accounting is the duty new licensees underestimate because it sounds like bookkeeping. It is not. A deposit check sitting in your desk drawer over a long weekend is a failure of the duty to account, and it is the kind of fact that turns a commission dispute into a licensing complaint.

The other side of the table is owed something too, and the disclosure form spells it out. Toward the party you do not represent, you exercise reasonable skill and care in performing your duties. You deal honestly, fairly and in good faith. And, as a seller's agent, you disclose all facts known to you that materially affect the value or desirability of the property, except as otherwise provided by law.

A buyer's agent dealing with a seller owes the mirror image of that third duty. Disclose all facts known to the agent materially affecting the buyer's ability or willingness to perform a contract to acquire the seller's property, where those facts are not inconsistent with the fiduciary duties owed to the buyer.

NOTE: Honesty is owed to everyone. Loyalty is owed to one. A question that offers you the answer no duty at all is owed to a customer is offering you the wrong answer every time.

Six duties to the client, honesty to all

REMEMBER: Say OLD CAR, then say the three things you owe the party you do not represent.

Dual Agency

Both sides of the same transaction

Dual agency is one broker acting for the buyer and the seller in the same transaction, or for the landlord and the tenant. It is legal in New York and it is narrow.

Written consent comes first. A real estate broker may represent both the buyer and the seller only if both the buyer and the seller give their informed consent in writing. Informed is doing as much work in that sentence as written. Consent from somebody who does not understand what they are giving up is not informed consent.

So the explaining is part of the job. An agent acting as a dual agent must explain carefully to both the buyer and the seller that the agent is acting for the other party as well. The agent should also explain the possible effects of dual representation, including that by consenting to it the buyer and seller are giving up their right to undivided loyalty.

The duties shrink. In a dual agency situation the agent will not be able to provide the full range of fiduciary duties to the buyer and the seller. A buyer or a seller should carefully consider the possible consequences of a dual agency relationship before agreeing to that representation.

Designated sales agents narrow the damage without repairing it. With informed written consent, the broker may name one sales agent to advocate for the buyer and another to advocate for the seller. The two agents advocate. The broker is still a dual agent, and undivided loyalty is still off the table.

The obligations of a dual agent are also subject to any specific provisions set out in an agreement between the agent and the buyer and the seller. That is the form telling you the written agreement can narrow the role further. It cannot widen it back into full representation of both sides, because that is the thing dual agency structurally cannot deliver.

Hypothetical. You have listed a house and your own buyer client asks to see it. You can do that, with informed written consent from both, and you should know what you are about to stop doing. You will not advise the seller on how low to go. You will not advise the buyer on how high to bid. The two people who trusted you most are now the two people you can say the least to.

CAUTION: Acting for both sides without the written consent of both is undisclosed dual agency. It is not a paperwork lapse and it is not cured by good intentions. It is the violation that ends licenses.

Consent in writing, from both, in advance

REMEMBER: Name the one duty a dual agent cannot deliver, and say who has to agree in writing before the dual agency starts.

Advance Informed Consent

Permission collected before you need it

The 443 agency disclosure forms allow an agent to obtain advance informed consent to dual agency, and advance informed consent to dual agency with designated sales agents. Both appear as a section on the form, underneath the relationship boxes.

Advance consent gives the agent permission to act as a dual agent for that consumer without having to go back later and present a second agency disclosure form if the agency relationship changes. It is collected at the beginning, when nothing is at stake, precisely so that it is not being collected in the middle of a negotiation when everything is.

On the form

Advance informed consent to dual agency. One broker may represent both sides if that situation later arises in the transaction.

Advance informed consent to dual agency with designated sales agents. If that box is checked and the situation arises, one named sales agent is appointed to represent the buyer and another named sales agent is appointed to represent the seller. The two names are written into the blanks on the form.

Then the acknowledgment of receipt, signed and dated by the buyer or the seller.

Read the designated-agent section closely, because it has blanks in it. One blank names the sales agent appointed to represent the buyer. Another names the sales agent appointed to represent the seller. Those names are written in at the time of consent, and a consumer consenting to designated agency in advance is consenting to a structure, with the individuals identified when the situation actually arises.

Sam and Kim, in practice

Sam is a seller's agent for a client at ABC Realty. Kim is a buyer's agent for a different client at the same firm. Kim's buyer asks to see Sam's listing. Two clients of one broker are now on opposite sides of one transaction, and that is dual agency whether anybody planned it or not.

If both clients checked the advance consent box when they signed their disclosure forms at the start, the showing goes ahead. The consent already exists. Sam and Kim can be designated to advocate for their own clients, because the principals agreed to that in advance and in writing.

If either client left the box unchecked, everything stops. Nobody shows anything until the broker has explained the situation to both clients and obtained informed written consent from both. That conversation is harder in the middle of a transaction, which is the entire argument for collecting the consent up front.

Advance consent matters most at a firm large enough that in-house matches are routine. If your office lists a hundred homes and represents a hundred buyers, some of those buyers will want to see some of those homes. Handling that as a surprise each time is how offices end up with undisclosed dual agency by accident.

The conversation at the start sounds like this. You explain that the firm represents both buyers and sellers, that a buyer client may one day want to see a listing the firm holds, and that if that happens the firm cannot give either side undivided loyalty. Then you explain the designated-agent version, where one salesperson advocates for each side under the broker's supervision. Then you let the consumer decide, and you check the box they chose, not the one you would prefer.

Advance consent is not a trick and it is not a formality. You are asking a consumer to agree now to something that reduces what they are owed later. Explain it that way, in those words, and let them decide.

CAUTION: Never pre-check the advance consent boxes before the consumer sees the form. A box ticked before the conversation is not informed consent, it is a signature collected under a false impression, and the form in the file becomes the evidence against you rather than for you.

NOTE: Advance consent saves a second form. It does not save the explanation. The duty to explain dual representation and its effects belongs to the moment the dual agency actually happens, not only to the moment the box was ticked.

Every form generated along the way stays in the file. The original disclosure form, and any subsequent disclosure forms produced by a change in the relationship, are maintained by the broker for at least three years.

Ask at the start, not at the showing

REMEMBER: Your buyer wants to see a listing held by the agent at the next desk. Which box on the original form decides whether you make the appointment or make a phone call?

Refusal to Sign

§443(3)(e) and the sworn declaration

Agents are urged to get the consumer's signature and the date after presenting the 443 disclosure form and checking off the appropriate relationship and acknowledgment. Realistically, those elements are optional. You cannot force anyone to sign anything, and the form is not a contract.

That is a strange sentence to find in a licensing course, so read it twice. The presentation is mandatory. The signature is not something you can compel. The law solves that gap not by excusing you, but by giving you a second document to produce instead.

So the law tells you what to do instead. If the seller, buyer, landlord or tenant refuses to sign an acknowledgment of receipt of the 443 disclosure form, Section 443(3)(e) provides that the agent shall set forth under oath or affirmation a written declaration of the facts of the refusal.

Because the declaration needs specifics, make good notes at the time. The time, the date, and the reason the consumer gave. You will not remember it accurately in three weeks and a declaration sworn under penalties of perjury is not the place to approximate.

People refuse for ordinary reasons. They want their attorney to see it first. They have been told never to sign anything at a first meeting. They think it commits them to using you. The last one you can answer on the spot, because the answer is printed at the top of the page in large bold type. The first two you do not argue with. You document.

Five steps, in order. Note the time, the date and the stated reason for the refusal. Complete the declaration under oath or affirmation. Attach a true copy of the actual disclosure form you presented, not a blank one. Give a copy to your broker and keep one yourself. Then file it where you can find it in three years.

The broker maintains the declaration for not less than three years. Once the declaration is complete you may proceed to show the property. That is the point most students miss. A refusal to sign does not stop the transaction and it does not stop you working. It changes what goes in the file.

The declaration itself is short. It identifies you and your firm, states that you presented the disclosure notice required under Section 443 on a named date to a named person, attaches a true copy of the actual disclosure form you presented, states that you told the consumer New York law required you to request the acknowledgment, states that the consumer refused, and records the reason given.

DECLARATION · §443(3)(f)

"I, ______ , affiliated with ______ , presented the disclosure notice required under §443 to ______ , who refused to sign the acknowledgment when presented. The reason given was: __________ ."

Sworn under penalties of perjury.

Hypothetical. A seller in Yonkers reads the form, decides it looks like a contract, and says he signs nothing until his attorney sees it. You explain that it is not a contract. He still declines. You write the declaration that afternoon, attach the copy you handed him, and give a copy to your broker. Nothing about the listing appointment changes. You have simply documented the one thing that would otherwise be missing from the file.

The alternative is what the practice case at the end of this chapter is built on. An agent shrugs, files nothing, and three months later there is no record that disclosure ever happened at all. At that point the absence of a signature and the absence of a declaration look identical, and both look like an agent who never presented the form.

Do it at the earliest point following the substantive contact, not at the end of the transaction. The declaration is a statement about a day, sworn under penalties of perjury, and it is worth exactly as much as the accuracy of the details in it.

CAUTION: A refusal to sign is never a reason to refuse to work with somebody. Telling a consumer that you cannot show them anything without a signature is a misstatement of the law, and it puts the one document that protects you into the middle of a fight.

No signature means a sworn declaration

REMEMBER: A buyer declines to sign at your open house. Name the five steps you take next, and say how long the broker keeps the declaration.

Brokerage Agreements

The contracts that do create agency

Sellers and buyers, landlords and tenants, secure the services of a real estate professional using a brokerage agreement. These are employment contracts. They establish the agency relationship between the consumer and the broker, and between the consumer and the other licensees affiliated with that broker.

Now notice who is not a party to the contract. You. The agreement is binding between the client and the broker only. The salesperson is commonly referenced in the document, and the salesperson is not a party to the business relationship. When you take a listing you are acting on behalf of your broker, the agreement runs between your broker and the seller, and you are the broker's subagent in it.

That is not a technicality about signatures. It decides who the seller can sue, who owes the fiduciary duties, who holds the file, and who the commission is payable to. It is also why a salesperson cannot take a listing to a new firm. The listing was never yours.

New York prescribes no specific form for brokerage agreements. Brokers may use their own form, or a form furnished and endorsed by members of a professional trade organization such as a local association of REALTORS. The sample contracts referenced in this session come from the Multiple Listing Service of Long Island and are used for illustration only. Your office will hand you the forms it uses, and you should read them before you ever use one in front of a seller.

No mandated form cuts both ways. It means the agreement in your hand may differ in real ways from the one another office uses down the street, and the differences will be in the clauses that decide money. Read your own office's listing form end to end once, on a quiet afternoon, before a seller ever asks you what a paragraph means.

A listing agreement is a contract between a seller and a broker stating the conditions under which the broker will be paid a commission on the seller's property. The seller hires the broker to procure a buyer. In exchange for the broker's services the seller compensates the broker as negotiated. Most things in that agreement are negotiable, and here is what gets negotiated.

Authority

Who inside the brokerage has authority to represent the seller in dealings with third parties.

Cooperation

Whether the seller will allow subagents or broker's agents to work on the property.

Term

The start date and the expiration date of the listing. New York has a rule about that date and the screen after next is built on it.

Price

The list price the property goes to market at.

Compensation

The commission, and the portion of it payable to any cooperating broker.

Marketing

The marketing techniques the seller allows. Yard signs, open houses, photography, and where the listing may be published.

Negotiable means negotiable. The rate is a term between this seller and this broker. It is not set by a board, an association, a multiple listing service or a custom, and a licensee who tells a seller otherwise has said something that is both untrue and dangerous. The law behind that comes later in this course.

Hypothetical. A seller asks why the rate is what it is. The honest answer is that it is what this brokerage charges for this service and it is a term he is free to discuss. The answer that gets licensees into serious trouble is that it is the going rate, or the board rate, or what everybody charges. None of those three sentences is true, and the board rate describes an agreement that would be illegal if it existed.

CAUTION: You will hear listings described as mine. They are not. Every obligation in the agreement belongs to your broker, and so does every dollar of the commission until your broker pays you.

The broker is the party; you are the subagent

REMEMBER: A seller asks you to lower the rate on the spot. Whose decision is that, and who is the other party to the contract you are holding?

Listing Agreements

Three legal types and one that is not

There are several types of listing agreement. Each one sets out the rights and obligations of the parties, and each one answers the same question differently. Under what circumstances does this broker get paid?

Three of them are lawful in New York. One is not. Learn all four, because the illegal one shows up on the exam and, occasionally, in a seller's suggestion at a kitchen table.

Exclusive right to sell

The property is listed with only one broker. The agreement grants that broker the exclusive right to represent the seller in the sale of the property, and it provides that the broker is compensated if the broker, the seller, or any other person or entity produces a purchaser in accordance with the terms specified in the listing agreement.

Read the list of who might produce the buyer. It includes the seller. Under an exclusive right to sell, the seller who finds his own buyer at his own kitchen table still owes the commission. Most brokers prefer this contract because it gives the greatest opportunity to earn a commission. No matter who sells the property, the listing agency has earned its fee.

Exclusive agency

An exclusive agency listing also gives one broker the exclusive right to represent the seller. The difference is one sentence long. The listing broker is compensated only if someone other than the seller finds the buyer during the term of the agreement. The seller reserves the right to sell the property himself, or to sell or lease it to any specifically exempted persons, and to owe nothing when he does.

Open listing

An open listing is a non-exclusive arrangement. The seller allows any number of brokers to show the property and no single agency has the sole authority to market it and earn the commission when it sells. If the property is sold, a broker is entitled to a commission only if that broker is the procuring cause of the sale. Procuring cause means the agent primarily responsible for bringing the sale about, by introducing the buyer to the property or by negotiating the agreement. If the owner sells to someone no broker generated, the owner owes nobody anything.

Be wary of open listings. Very rarely will a seller sign any form expressing the agent's role, which leaves you with no written record of what you were hired to do. Some brokers do not accept open listings at all. Check your brokerage policy before you take one, not after.

Hypothetical. The same house, three listing types, one outcome. The seller finds his own buyer at a block party. Under an exclusive right to sell the commission is earned and owed. Under an exclusive agency the seller owes nothing, because the person who found the buyer was the seller. Under an open listing the seller owes nothing to anyone, because no broker was the procuring cause. Nothing about the house changed. The paper changed.

The net listing is the fourth arrangement and it is not available to you. The seller names the amount he needs to net, the property is marketed, and the broker keeps everything the sale brings above that figure as compensation. Net listing agreements are not permitted in New York.

You can see why without being told. The broker's interest under a net listing runs directly against the seller's interest in the price, and the duty of undivided loyalty cannot survive that arrangement for a single afternoon.

The arrangement also hides its own worst case. A seller who names a number too low never learns what the property was actually worth, because the only person who knows is the person keeping the difference. That is self-dealing with a contract wrapped around it.

CAUTION: A net listing does not become legal because the seller suggested it, because the number is generous, or because everyone agrees in writing. If a seller proposes it, the answer is that New York does not allow it, and then you offer him one of the three that it does.

Who finds the buyer decides who gets paid

REMEMBER: Under which listing does a seller who sells his own house still owe a commission, and under which one does he owe nothing?

Lesson 3

Part 3: Exclusive listings · ny rules

The fine print New York insists on

Exclusive Listings: New York Rules

What every exclusive has to contain

There is no mandated listing form in New York, and there are still requirements. They attach to the two exclusive listings, and they exist because those are the agreements that tie a seller to one broker for a fixed stretch of time.

A definite termination date

Exclusive right to sell and exclusive agency listing agreements must include a definite termination date. No listing agreement may be extended or renewed automatically. All listing extensions must be renewed in writing.

Automatically is the operative word. A clause saying the listing continues month to month until the property sells is the clause New York forbids. If the listing is going to run longer, the seller agrees to that again, in writing, with a new end date. A blank termination date is not a favor to a seller who does not want to feel rushed. It is a defect in the agreement.

A definite termination date means a date. The fifteenth of June. Not until sold, not ninety days from acceptance, not open. If the listing is working and both sides want to continue, the extension is a written amendment with a new date on it, signed by the seller, and the form your office uses for that is the report of change in listing.

Explain the difference

In New York, all listing forms include a statement explaining the difference between an exclusive right to sell and an exclusive agency. Brokers are required to disclose the difference between the two so that the consumer is properly informed of the distinction. Sellers must initial or sign near each of the explanations to prove they were given the explanations and the choice.

Two sets of initials on a listing form is the evidence that the conversation happened. It is worth doing properly rather than pointing at the paragraph and saying sign here. A seller who initials an explanation he did not understand has been given a signature line, not a choice.

The explanation is short enough to say out loud. Under an exclusive right to sell, the brokerage is paid whoever finds the buyer, including you. Under an exclusive agency, the brokerage is paid unless you find the buyer yourself. Then stop talking and let the seller ask the question he is already forming.

Disclosure is not a menu

Brokers are not required to offer both options. A brokerage may take exclusive right to sell listings only, as a matter of office policy, and many do. The duty is to explain the difference so the consumer is informed. The duty is not to sell something your office does not offer.

Rentals mirror sales

An agent's relationship with a landlord or a tenant works like the relationship with a seller or a buyer. A broker may work for, or work with, either side. Brokers list property for lease or rent using agreements very similar to sale listings. The exclusive right to rent agreement, like the exclusive right to sell, compensates the broker when a suitable tenant is found and a lease is signed, regardless of who introduced that tenant to the property.

And the disclosure rule follows. The New York 443 agency disclosure form must be presented and signed at the first substantive contact in a rental exactly as it must in a sale. The form number changes. Nothing else does.

Rentals move faster than sales, and that is exactly why licensees get the timing wrong on them. A tenant who views three apartments in one afternoon has had three substantive contacts, and the form belongs at the first one.

NOTE: Two items on an exclusive listing decide whether it is valid and whether it is fair. The termination date, and the two sets of initials next to the explanations. A question that hands you a listing missing either one is handing you the answer.

Definite end date, no automatic renewal

REMEMBER: A seller asks you to leave the end date open so neither of you feels pressured. Say the sentence you would use to explain why you cannot.

When the Commission Is Earned

The compensation clause, read closely

Open a sample exclusive listing contract to the compensation paragraph and you find three things. What the commission is. How it is shared. And the conditions that make it payable.

The commission is stated as a percentage of the selling price, or as a flat dollar amount, or in the case of a rental by separate agreement. The sharing is broken out by the role the cooperating broker plays. A cooperating broker who is a seller's agent takes one figure. A cooperating broker who is a broker's agent takes another. A cooperating broker who is a buyer's agent takes another. Each is written into its own blank.

Three blanks for three roles is not decoration. The seller is agreeing, in advance and in writing, to what a cooperating broker takes depending on which side that broker ends up working for. A seller who never discusses those blanks is agreeing to them anyway when he signs.

Then comes the part worth memorizing. The total commission is earned and payable under any of the following conditions. Any one of them is enough.

Ready, willing and able

The broker or a cooperating broker produces a buyer ready, willing and able to purchase the property on the terms and conditions set forth in the listing. Note what is absent. A closing. The clause turns on producing the buyer, not on the deal reaching the table.

Ready and willing describe intent. Able describes money. A buyer who wants the house and cannot finance it is not able, and a buyer who can finance it and keeps hesitating is not willing. All three words have to be true at the same time for the condition to be satisfied.

Meeting of the minds

Through the efforts of the broker or a cooperating broker, a buyer and the owner reach agreement upon all the essential terms of a transaction. Agreement on the essential terms is the event. The word essential is doing real work there.

Sold during the term

The property is sold or rented during the term of the agreement, whether or not the sale or rental is a result of the broker's efforts, and even if the property is sold through the efforts of the owner or any other broker or agent not acting under the agreement.

Procuring cause

The broker or a cooperating broker is the procuring cause of the transaction.

The third condition is the exclusive right to sell, written out in contract language. It is also the sentence an unhappy seller will read back to you in a year. Explain it at the listing appointment, in plain words, before it is a dispute.

This screen is also about your own pay. Your commission comes from your broker, out of the fee this clause earns. A licensee who cannot say when the fee is earned cannot tell a client anything useful about the most contested paragraph in the agreement.

Hypothetical. You list a house in Rockland County on an exclusive right to sell, and six weeks later the seller's cousin buys it without ever meeting you. The sale happened during the term. Condition three is satisfied and the commission is earned. Whether you feel you did anything to deserve it is not one of the four conditions.

Turn the same facts into an exclusive agency listing and the answer changes. The seller found the buyer himself, an exclusive agency pays the broker only when someone other than the seller finds the buyer, and nothing is owed. Condition three is the exclusive right to sell written into the clause, and an exclusive agency listing cannot carry it. The listing type decides which conditions the clause can contain.

NOTE: Earned and paid are not the same moment. The clause says when the commission is earned. When it is actually paid is a separate term, and in a sale it is ordinarily at closing.

Any one condition earns the whole fee

REMEMBER: Name the four conditions without looking. Then say which one a seller is most likely to argue about.

Listing Protection

The commission that outlives the listing

A listing ends on its termination date. The work you did during it does not evaporate that morning, and neither does the buyer you introduced. That is what a broker protection clause is for.

Most exclusive brokerage agreements contain a broker protection clause covering a certain period after the agreement expires. The clause provides that the broker is still entitled to a commission if the property is sold during that specified period and the buyer is someone the broker negotiated with during the listing term.

The clause exists to stop one specific maneuver. A buyer sees the house in month four, both sides wait out the listing, and the deal closes in month seven with nobody paying the broker who introduced them. Without a tail period that is a workable plan, and eventually everybody in the state would learn it.

In the sample contract the language runs like this. The compensation is paid to the broker if the owner enters into a contract of sale, or actually sells the property, within a stated number of days after the termination of the agreement, to any person who has been shown the property during the term of the agreement.

The trigger

The owner contracts to sell, or sells, inside the tail period, to a buyer who was shown the property while the listing was alive. Two facts have to line up. The timing of the sale, and the identity of the buyer.

The carve-out

The clause does not apply if the owner has in good faith relisted the property with another broker after the expiration of the agreement and before negotiations with that buyer began. A seller who genuinely moves on to a new broker is not trapped by the old one. Good faith is the test, and the order of events is the evidence.

The language varies from form to form and the variation matters. Some clauses reach any person the broker negotiated with. Some reach any person to whom the broker has exposed the property. Exposed is broader than negotiated with. Read the clause on the form your office actually uses, because those two words describe different lists of people.

The length of the tail is a blank on the form, which means it is negotiated like everything else. Thirty days, ninety days, a hundred and eighty. The number belongs in the conversation at the listing appointment, alongside the rate and the termination date, and not in a surprise a seller discovers after expiration.

Best practice

Always provide the seller with a written list of the prospects you introduced to the property. Do it at the end of the listing, in writing, and keep a copy. If the seller is not aware that the buyer is someone the broker worked with, the seller may not have to pay the commission.

That last sentence is where new licensees lose money they had already earned. The protection clause does not enforce itself. It relies on somebody being able to prove, months later, that a particular buyer walked through that house on a particular day while you held the listing.

Hypothetical. You hold an exclusive right to sell on a two-family in Albany for six months. In month five you show it to a couple who decide it is too small. The listing expires. Seven weeks later the same couple change their minds and buy it directly from the owner. Your clause runs ninety days and reaches anyone shown the property during the term. You are owed the commission, and the only question that will be argued is whether you can show they were there.

Hypothetical, with the carve-out this time. Same listing, same couple, same seven weeks. The difference is that the day after expiration the seller signed with another brokerage in good faith, and the couple approached that new brokerage before any negotiation with the seller began. The clause does not apply. The seller moved on in good faith before the buyer came back, and the order of those two events is what decides it.

CAUTION: Handing the seller a prospect list at the end of the listing is not an accusation and it is not a threat. It is the routine closing step of a listing file. Treat it as routine and it stays routine.

The same list is useful even when nothing goes wrong. It tells the seller, in writing, exactly what the marketing produced. A seller who can see the work is a seller who relists with you.

The tail clause protects buyers you can prove

REMEMBER: Your listing expires Friday. What do you send the seller, in what form, and what do you keep?

Buyer Agency Agreements

The same logic on the buyer's side

An agency relationship between a buyer and a broker is created with a buyer-broker agreement. It is a written agency contract between a buyer and a real estate broker stating that the broker will be paid a commission when the buyer purchases real estate.

The same employment contract goes by several names. A buyer representation agreement. A buyer brokerage agreement. A buyer-agency contract. A buyer listing. A right to represent agreement. The name on the top of the form tells you which office printed it and nothing else.

The contract does two things. It grants the broker the right to represent the buyer in the purchase or lease of property. And it makes the buyer responsible for ensuring the broker is compensated when a purchase is made according to the terms of the agreement.

A buyer-broker agreement can be exclusive or non-exclusive, and it should include three things. The agreed basis or amount of compensation and the time of payment. The duration of the agency relationship, clearly set forth. And the duties of the buyer's broker.

Those three are the required elements and they are worth memorizing as a set. Compensation. Duration. Duties. A buyer-broker agreement missing any one of them is an agreement with a hole in the part that will be argued about.

The compensation term deserves its own conversation. The agreement makes the buyer responsible for ensuring the broker is compensated when a purchase is made according to its terms. Whether any part of that fee is covered from the seller's side is a separate negotiation, recorded in the listing agreement between that seller and that listing broker. The buyer signs a document that says what the buyer owes. Explain it in those terms and nobody is surprised at the closing table.

Exclusive buyer-agency agreement

The buyer is legally bound to pay the fee to the agent regardless of who finds the property. This is the buyer-side twin of the exclusive right to sell listing, and it carries the same consequence. A buyer who finds a house on a Sunday drive still owes the fee under the terms of the agreement.

Exclusive-agency buyer-agency agreement

The broker is entitled to compensation if the broker is the one who locates the property and brings about the sale. With this agreement the buyer can find a property on his own without being obligated to pay a fee. It is the buyer-side twin of the exclusive agency listing.

Open buyer-agency agreement

The agreement permits the buyer to deal with a number of other agents. The buyer pays only the agent who finds the house. It is the buyer-side twin of the open listing. The buyer is free to work with everyone at once, and you are paid only if you are the one who finds the house.

Buyers ask why they should sign anything at all. The honest answer is that the agreement is what makes them a client. Without it they are a customer, owed honesty and fairness and no representation, and the person showing them houses is working for the other side of every transaction they walk into.

Hypothetical. A buyer signs an exclusive buyer-agency agreement with you for six months. In month two she calls to say she is in contract on a house she found through a friend of her brother. Under that agreement she owes you the fee according to its terms. Whether you enforce it is a decision for your broker. Whether she understood it when she signed is a decision you made, at the table, two months ago.

NOTE: A buyer-broker agreement never states the seller's bottom line, because the buyer's broker does not have it. That is confidential information belonging to the seller and the seller's agent. An exam question offering it as a required element is offering you the wrong answer.

Compensation, duration, duties

REMEMBER: Name the three required elements. Then match each of the three buyer-agency agreements to its listing-side twin.

Working With Other Brokers

Cooperation, the MLS, and the office exclusive

Almost no transaction is worked by one brokerage alone. A second broker brings the buyer, and how that second broker gets paid is decided long before the buyer exists.

Cooperating brokers

Listing brokers negotiate with the seller to determine how much of the commission, if any, the seller is willing to pay a selling or buyer's agent. Those terms should be included in the listing agreement. The seller is the one agreeing to it, at the listing appointment, in the document the seller signs.

The offer of cooperation is commonly published through the MLS, promising the stated share to a cooperating broker.

A cooperating broker can be several different things. A subagent or broker's agent of the listing broker. A buyer's agent from another firm. A dual agent from the listing firm. Or any other broker who is a member of the multiple listing service and sees the listing. The label decides the duties, and the duties are the ones you learned with the six relationships earlier in this chapter.

Work the labels from the seller's side of the table. A subagent of the listing broker is working for your seller. A buyer's agent from another firm is working against your seller's position in the negotiation, and the buyer that agent brings is owed only the duties you owe any party you do not represent. A broker's agent is helping you, under your direction, and the liability for that help is yours and not your seller's. Three people can walk the same buyer through the same door and owe three different sets of duties.

All cooperating brokers should be prepared to disclose any relationship they might have with the seller prior to showing the property. That is the 443 form again, arriving from the other direction. The buyer standing on the porch is entitled to know whether the person unlocking the door works for the seller.

Prior to showing is the deadline, not after the offer and not at the contract. A cooperating broker who has not sorted out and disclosed the relationship before the door opens has run the same red light as a listing agent who waits until closing.

Office exclusive

Most brokerages keep forms and addendums for specific issues arising out of their brokerage agreements. The office exclusive certification is the one you will meet first. It addresses the seller who does not want his home on the multiple listing service, for whatever reason.

Such a provision prohibits the agent from including the property in the MLS. That is a lawful instruction from a client, and a lawful instruction requires obedience. Explain the benefits of the MLS, explain what the seller gives up by staying off it, and then obey the seller's wishes. Obedience is one of the six duties and this is what it looks like in practice on an ordinary Tuesday.

Obedience has a boundary and it is worth naming here, because the office exclusive is the place new licensees first meet it. You obey lawful instructions. An instruction to keep a home off the multiple listing service is lawful and you follow it. An instruction to keep certain buyers from seeing the home is not lawful, it is not obeyed, and the reason arrives in the fair housing session of this course.

Document the instruction either way. The office exclusive certification exists so that, a year later, nobody has to rely on anybody's memory of what the seller wanted.

Report of change in listing

The form that documents amendments to a listing contract. A price reduction, an extension of the term, a change to the marketing terms. The listing is a contract and a contract is amended in writing, not by a phone call and a note in the system.

Withdrawal form

The form that takes the property off the market before the listing expires. Withdrawing a listing and terminating a listing are not the same act, and the paperwork your office uses will distinguish them.

Most brokerages keep addendums beyond those three, for issues specific to their own brokerage agreements. Learn which forms your office has before you need one. The moment a seller asks you to change something is a poor moment to discover that a form exists for exactly that and you have never seen it.

None of these forms are prescribed by the state. They are the brokerage's tools for keeping a contract accurate while a transaction moves, and they exist because a listing agreement that no longer describes reality is worth very little to anyone.

Hypothetical. A seller in Westchester tells you at the listing appointment that his employer must not learn the house is for sale. He wants no sign, no MLS, and showings by appointment only. Every one of those is a lawful instruction. You explain what staying off the MLS is likely to cost him in exposure and in price, you record the instruction on the office exclusive certification, and you follow it.

CAUTION: A cooperating broker is not automatically your subagent and is not automatically the buyer's agent. Ask, and get the answer on the 443 form. The assumption that the other agent works for the buyer has cost sellers real money.

Cooperation terms go in the listing agreement

REMEMBER: Name every kind of cooperating broker. Then say which form you reach for when a seller cuts the price.

Regulation 175.7

19 NYCRR 175.7: disclosure of compensation

Regulation 175.7 of the New York Codes, Rules and Regulations does two things, and the second one is the reason licensees get disciplined under it.

It is short, and it outranks your convenience. Learn it as two sentences you could recite in an elevator.

Say who you act for

The regulation reiterates the agency disclosure obligation found in Section 443 of the Real Property Law. The agent makes clear for which party he is acting. That duty does not depend on a form being handed over. It is a standing obligation attached to the way you conduct yourself in a transaction.

Take one payment, unless everybody agrees

The regulation limits compensation from more than one party in a transaction, except where full disclosure is made and consent is granted by all parties. Money from a second source is not forbidden. Money from a second source that the parties do not know about is.

Now the part that separates this regulation from everything else in the chapter. The requirements to make your relationship clear, and to take no undisclosed and non-consented compensation from more than one party, are not limited to residential transactions. They apply to all real estate transactions.

Section 443 and its two forms reach residential property. Regulation 175.7 reaches commercial buildings, industrial property, vacant land, leases and everything else you will ever touch. Wherever you practice, the compensation rule travels with you.

Hypothetical. You represent a buyer, you refer her to a mortgage broker, and after the closing the mortgage broker sends you a referral fee. Nobody told the buyer. Nobody told the seller. The size of the payment is not the issue and neither is the quality of the referral. The issue is that a party to the transaction paid you and the people you were working for did not know.

CAUTION: A payment arriving from a lender, an inspector, a contractor or a title company is compensation from another party in the transaction. Disclose it to everyone and obtain consent, or decline it. Quiet money is the fact pattern that ends careers.

175.7 follows you into every transaction

REMEMBER: You are selling a warehouse, so no 443 form applies. Which of your duties just changed, and which one did not?

Lesson 4

Part 4: Mid-transaction

When the relationship changes mid-deal

When the Relationship Changes

Mid-transaction dual agency

Agency disclosure takes place at the earliest substantive contact with a prospective client. From the moment you first meet that buyer or seller, there are several occasions in a transaction where the original agency relationship could change.

Nothing about the original disclosure is wasted when that happens. It was accurate on the day it was made. What changes is that it stopped being accurate, and an agency disclosure that has stopped being accurate has to be redone rather than relied on.

The typical reason is an in-house transaction that leads to dual agency. Sam is a seller's agent for a client of ABC Realty. Kim is a buyer's agent for another client at the same firm. Kim's buyer wants to see Sam's listing. That sets up a potential dual agency that did not exist five minutes earlier, assuming neither Sam nor Kim obtained advance consent for dual agency at the start.

When a dual agency situation arises, the principals and the broker have four standard options.

Dissolve the buyer relationship

The broker could end the relationship with the buyer, who could then find another firm or represent himself.

Dissolve the seller relationship

The broker could end the relationship with the seller, who has the same two choices.

Become a dual agent

The broker could become a dual agent for the buyer and the seller, with informed written consent from both.

Designate sales agents

The broker could become a dual agent and designate Kim and Sam to advocate for the buyer and the seller respectively, again with informed written consent from both.

If the buyer and the seller both want to continue with their current representation, changing the agency relationship is permissible, and there are three steps. Each agent reviews the disclosure form with the client. Each agent discusses the revised relationship. And each agent obtains informed written consent for the new relationship from all parties.

Review, discuss, consent. In that order, with each client separately, and with the consent captured in writing before the showing rather than after the offer. The review is not a formality. You are putting the form back in front of somebody who signed it weeks ago under a different set of facts, and walking them through what is different now.

Once disclosure has been fully made and the parties have agreed in writing to the dual agency relationship, it is consensual dual agency. That is the name for the lawful version of working both sides, and the word consensual is carrying the whole weight.

As with the original disclosure form, the broker must maintain all subsequent 443 agency disclosure forms for at least three years. Every new form generated by a changed relationship goes into the file on the same clock as the first one.

Count the forms in a transaction where the relationship changes once. The buyer's original. The seller's original. And a new form for each of them reflecting the dual agency. Four documents, all retained, and all of them capable of being produced years later.

Notice what is not on the list of options. Continuing quietly with both clients because the firm is one company and everybody means well. That is undisclosed dual agency, and it is the single fastest way a competent licensee loses a license.

There is one more move available that students often miss. The broker may change the relationship with one side and continue with that person as a customer rather than a client. The buyer stops being represented, is owed honesty, fairness, good faith and reasonable care, and is told exactly that. It is a real option and it is only honest when the person affected understands what they just gave up.

CAUTION: The moment to raise this is before the showing, not after the offer. Once a buyer has toured a house and fallen for it, a conversation about giving up undivided loyalty is no longer a free choice for anybody in the room.

Review, discuss, consent in writing

REMEMBER: Name the four options. Then name the three steps required if the answer is to keep both clients.

Documenting Interactions

The habit that settles disputes

New agents should make a habit of documenting their interactions with clients and customers. Keep a log of all activities from the time the relationship begins. Conversations on the phone and in person. Copies of e-mails and text messages. Note the purpose of each interaction, in any form of documentation you are comfortable with, as long as your broker allows it.

This is the least glamorous screen in the chapter and it is the one that decides disputes. Every other rule you have learned here produces a document. Documentation is what proves the document existed, arrived, and was explained.

When you are working for a buyer specifically, four things belong in the file.

Buyer specifications

Any form used to determine the buyer's specifications and criteria. Location, size, price range, style of home. This is the record of what you were actually asked to find.

Showings and reactions

Dates and addresses of every property presented to the buyer, along with the buyer's comments and reaction to each one. This is also the list that proves a broker protection clause months later.

Appointments

Records of appointments kept, and of appointments canceled. Cancellations are part of the story, and they are usually the part somebody disputes.

Referrals

Information you provided regarding lenders, inspectors and other professionals. What you recommended, when, and what you told the buyer about the recommendation.

Good records illustrate the natural flow of events that lead to a real estate transaction. Often, the agent with the most reliable records will prevail in a dispute. A lack of detailed records cuts the other way. Thin records may imply the relationship was not maintained, leaving the buyer no choice but to seek a relationship elsewhere.

A log entry does not need to be long. A date, who you spoke to, what it was about, and what was decided. Four lines written the same day beat four paragraphs reconstructed a year later, because the value of the record is not its length. It is that it was made before anybody knew there would be an argument.

The habit is easier than the catching up. Five minutes after the showing, while you are still in the car, is the whole discipline.

Ask your broker what the office requires and where the records live. Some firms run everything through a transaction management system, some keep paper files, and some do both. Your records are part of your broker's files, which is why the broker sets the format.

NOTE: Text messages are records. So are the ones you send at nine at night from your own phone. Write every one as though it will be read aloud by somebody who was not there.

Records also protect the client, which is the part worth remembering when the habit feels like paperwork. A buyer who was told about a defect on a Tuesday, and can prove it, is a buyer who was properly served.

The agent with the best records usually wins

REMEMBER: Could you reconstruct last week, address by address, from what you wrote down? If not, start tonight.

Key Terms

Say each one in one breath

Twenty-one terms carry this chapter. Read each one, then close your eyes and say it back in your own words before you move to the next.

Do not skim them. Most of these words appear on the 443 form itself, in front of a consumer who is going to ask you what one of them means, and the answer needs to arrive in your own sentences rather than the statute's.

Agency disclosure form. The form required by Section 443 of the Real Property Law, advising a consumer of the agency relationships available and the rights and obligations each one creates. It is presented word for word as the statute writes it. It is not a contract and it does not create agency.

First substantive contact. The moment agency disclosure is due. Generally the first face-to-face meeting with a prospective client or customer, and in every case before confidential information is shared. With a seller, before the comparative market analysis. With a buyer, no later than showing property, meeting an interested buyer at an open house, or submitting an offer.

Client and customer. A client is a party you represent, owed the full fiduciary duties, under a signed brokerage agreement. A customer is a party you work with, owed honesty, fairness, good faith and reasonable care, and nothing more. The signed brokerage agreement is the only thing that moves somebody from the second column to the first.

Principal. The party the agent represents in the transaction. The person who grants another the authority to represent him in dealings with third parties. In a listing the principal is the seller and the broker is the agent. The word also describes a party to a transaction generally, so read it in context before you answer a question built on it.

Listing agreement. A written contract between a seller and a broker stating the conditions under which the broker will be paid a commission on the seller's property. It is an employment contract, it creates the agency relationship, and it runs between the seller and the broker.

Buyer-broker agreement. The written agency contract between a buyer and a broker, granting the broker the right to represent the buyer and making the buyer responsible for the broker's compensation under its terms. It states the compensation and time of payment, the duration of the agency, and the duties of the buyer's broker.

Exclusive right to sell. One broker, and the commission is earned no matter who produces the buyer. The broker, the seller, or any other person or entity. Brokers prefer it because it gives the greatest opportunity to earn a commission.

Exclusive agency. One broker, paid only if someone other than the seller finds the buyer during the term. The seller keeps the right to sell the property himself, or to any specifically exempted person, and owes nothing when he does.

Open listing. A non-exclusive arrangement. Any number of brokers may show the property, and only the procuring cause of the sale is entitled to a commission. An owner sale generated by no broker pays nobody.

Net listing. The seller names the amount he needs to net and the broker keeps everything above that figure as compensation. Net listing agreements are not permitted in New York. The arrangement sets the broker's pay against the seller's price, which is the one place undivided loyalty cannot survive.

Broker's agent. An agent who cooperates with, or is engaged by, a listing agent or a buyer's agent from a different firm to help locate a property. No direct relationship with the principal, no instructions from the principal, and therefore no vicarious liability for the principal. The engaging agent carries that liability.

Dual agency. One broker acting as the agent for both sides of the same transaction. Permitted only with the informed consent of both parties in writing. A dual agent cannot provide the full range of fiduciary duties to either side.

Designated agency. Dual agency with designated sales agents. With informed written consent, the dual-agent broker names one sales agent to represent the buyer and another to represent the seller, and the names go on the form. Neither designated agent can provide undivided loyalty.

Undisclosed dual agency. Representing both principals in the same transaction without full disclosure to, and approval from, all parties. It is the violation this entire chapter is built to prevent. It usually happens by drift rather than by decision, when an in-house match arises and nobody stops to collect consent.

Consensual dual agency. Dual agency after disclosure has been fully made and all parties have agreed in writing. Either the broker and all the licensees act as dual agents, or each principal has a designated agent while the broker acts as the dual agent.

Broker protection clause. The clause providing that the broker is still entitled to a commission if the property is sold during a stated period after the listing expires, to a buyer the broker negotiated with or exposed to the property during the term.

Nonsolicitation Order, DOS order barring solicitation of listings in designated areas.

Regulation 175.7. The NYCRR rule requiring the agent to make clear for which party he is acting, and limiting compensation from more than one party in a transaction except with the full disclosure and consent of all parties. It applies to all real estate transactions, not only residential ones.

Vicarious liability. One person held responsible for the acts of another. It is the concept underneath the broker's agent definition, and it is why the form spells that relationship out at length. The principle tracks direction. Whoever gives the instructions carries the liability for how they are carried out.

Procuring cause. The agent primarily responsible for bringing about a sale, by introducing the buyer to the property or by negotiating the agreement. It is the sole basis for a commission under an open listing, and one of the four conditions in an exclusive listing's compensation clause.

Informed consent. Agreement given by someone who understood what they were agreeing to and what they were giving up. Written consent from a consumer who was never told that dual agency costs them undivided loyalty is a signature, not consent.

Say them, do not reread them

Every one of these terms except the nonsolicitation order is answered somewhere earlier in this chapter. If a definition here is the first time a term has made sense to you, the screen it came from is the screen to go back to, because the definition is the summary and the screen is the reason.

REMEMBER: Which two of these twenty-one could you not explain to a client at a kitchen table right now? Go back to those screens.

Key Takeaways

Eight things to carry out the door

Eight ideas hold this chapter together. Read each one and check whether you could say it to a consumer without looking it up, because that is the form the test will take in practice long after it stops taking the form of a multiple choice question.

One creates, one discloses. The brokerage agreement creates the agency relationship. The 443 disclosure form only describes the relationships available and records which one you are offering. The words at the top of the form say so in large bold type. You, the salesperson, act on behalf of your broker and are not a party to the contract, which is why the listing belongs to the firm and the commission is payable to the broker.

Disclose at the first substantive contact. With a seller, before the comparative market analysis and before the listing agreement. With a buyer, no later than showing property, meeting an interested buyer at an open house, or submitting an offer. In every case, before any brokerage agreement is signed and before any confidential information moves. Give the consumer a copy of the signed form and keep the signed acknowledgment for not less than three years.

Know what Section 443 covers. All residential real property transactions, including multi-family buildings, condominiums and cooperative apartments, which came inside the requirement in 2011. Not vacant land, even where a dwelling is expected to be built there. Two forms, DOS-1736-f for buyer and seller and DOS-1735-f for landlord and tenant, presented word for word as written.

Exclusives have rules. An exclusive right to sell and an exclusive agency listing must include a definite termination date, and no listing agreement may be extended or renewed automatically. Every extension is renewed in writing. Every New York listing form explains the difference between the two exclusives, and the seller initials or signs near each explanation. Brokers are not required to offer both. Net listings are not permitted in New York at all.

Protect the commission you earned. Most exclusive agreements carry a broker protection clause covering a period after expiration, for a buyer the broker negotiated with or exposed to the property during the term. It does not apply if the owner has in good faith relisted with another broker before negotiations with that buyer began. Hand the seller a written list of the prospects you introduced, or you may never collect.

Regulation 175.7 travels with you. Make clear for which party you are acting, and take compensation from more than one party only with the full disclosure and consent of all of them. Unlike the Section 443 forms, it is not limited to residential transactions. It applies to every real estate transaction you will ever work, which makes it the one rule in this chapter that has no exceptions to memorize.

Know the relationships and what separates them. Seller's agent and buyer's agent represent one side completely. A broker's agent helps from outside the firm under the direction of the agent who engaged it, which is why the principal carries no vicarious liability for what it does. A dual agent works both sides and cannot deliver the full range of fiduciary duties. Designated sales agents give each side an advocate and still cannot deliver undivided loyalty.

Handle the curveballs on paper. A consumer who refuses to sign gets a written declaration of the facts of the refusal, sworn under oath or affirmation, with a true copy of the form attached, a copy to your broker, and three years in the file. A relationship that changes mid-transaction gets a review of the disclosure form, a discussion of the revised relationship, and informed written consent from all parties, with the new forms kept the same three years. And document everything in between.

Every one of those eight comes back to the same instinct. The consumer in front of you does not know what you know, and the paper is how you close that gap honestly. Disclosure is not a hoop the state makes you jump through before the real work starts. It is the first piece of the real work.

Eight rules, one instinct: get it in writing

REMEMBER: Which of these eight could you not defend to a hearing officer with a document in your hand? That is the one to reread.

Where to Snoop

Reading a fact pattern for the paperwork

Everything up to here was rules. This is the part of the job the rules do not do for you.

Nobody in practice hands you a violation with a label on it. You get a story, most of it ordinary, and the skill is noticing the one detail that is not. In an agency case the detail is almost always a piece of paper that is missing, late, or signed by the wrong person.

That noticing is the skill the Department of State is really measuring when it looks at a licensee's conduct, and it is the skill the graded activity in this chapter scores. It is also, more usefully, the thing that keeps you out of a hearing room in the first place.

So read a fact pattern the way you would read a file. Once for the story. Again with a pen, marking anything that made you pause, without deciding yet whether it is a violation. Then go back to the rules. Five places are worth looking every single time.

What §443 does and does not cover

Check the property type first. Residential, including multi-family, condos and co-ops, is inside the statute. Vacant land is outside it. An agent who says the form does not apply to co-ops is wrong, and an agent who insists the form is legally required on a building lot is wrong in the other direction. Both errors show up in exam questions because both show up in offices.

Then check what the statute does not do even where it applies. It does not create the agency relationship, it does not commit the consumer to anything, and it does not excuse anybody from the duties that come with the box that got checked. A fact pattern where somebody waves the form around as if it were a contract is a fact pattern with a violation in it somewhere.

What is missing in writing

Look for the document that should exist and does not. A disclosure form never presented. A refusal never declared. A handshake where an agreement should be. A relationship that changed with no new form in the file. An absent document is the easiest violation to prove and the easiest one to overlook, because nothing in the story draws attention to it.

Ask the same question about copies and retention. Did the consumer get a copy of what they signed? Is anything being thrown away before three years are up? A file that is complete today and empty in eighteen months is the same problem arriving late.

The listing agreement terms

Read the term, the rate and the structure. Is there a definite termination date, or a blank, or an automatic renewal? Is the seller keeping everything above a net figure? Was the difference between the two exclusives explained and initialed? Was the rate presented as negotiable or as somebody else's decision?

Each of those questions has a screen behind it in this chapter. A blank termination date and an automatic renewal are both prohibited. A net listing is not permitted in New York at all. The explanation of the two exclusives has to be given and initialed. And the rate is a term between this seller and this broker, described honestly or not at all.

Who is representing whom

Name every licensee in the story and say out loud who each one works for. Then check whether the parties were told. Two agents from one firm on opposite sides of one deal is dual agency, whatever anybody calls it, and the only question is whether informed written consent exists.

Watch for the relationship that was never papered. A buyer who asks an agent to represent her and gets a handshake is a customer, not a client, however warmly the handshake was meant. An agent who then behaves as though she were a client has created an expectation the paperwork does not support, and every duty in the story is now in dispute.

Who is paying whom

Follow every dollar to its source. A commission from the seller is ordinary. A payment from a lender, an inspector or a title company is compensation from another party in the transaction, and Regulation 175.7 wants full disclosure and the consent of all parties before it is accepted.

Ask when the parties learned about each payment. Money disclosed in advance and consented to is a business arrangement. The same money, the same amount, accepted quietly at a closing, is the fact that turns an ordinary file into a disciplinary matter.

Work the case below with those five headings beside you. Write down the issue and the fact that creates it, in that order. A rule number with no fact attached is not an issue you spotted. It is a rule you recited.

Read it twice before you write anything. Then sort what you found into three piles. Clearly a violation. Clearly fine. Cannot tell from these facts. The third pile is the one that teaches you something, because for every item in it you have to name the missing fact that would move it into one of the other two.

FINAL CHALLENGE · ISSUE-SPOTTER

The Open House Caper

Saturday, 10 a.m. Dana, a salesperson at Hudson Realty, hosts an open house at a Brooklyn condo listed by her teammate Marco. Buyer Priya wanders in, falls in love, and shares her absolute top budget and her must-close-by-June deadline. Dana hasn't presented any form. “Paperwork later,” she smiles, “disclosure forms don't apply to condos anyway.” Priya asks Dana to be her agent; they shake hands on it, nothing in writing, and Dana shows her three more homes that afternoon. Backstory: when Marco took the listing, seller Mr. Okafor refused to sign the 443 acknowledgment. Marco shrugged and moved on, nothing written, nothing filed. The listing agreement lets Hudson Realty keep everything above $700,000, and it renews automatically each month until the condo sells.

Priya offers $760,000 through Dana while Marco negotiates for Okafor. No new forms are presented; no written consents are collected. At closing, Dana quietly accepts $2,000 from the mortgage lender she had recommended to Priya. One more thing: Okafor asks Marco to sell his vacant lot upstate, and Marco insists a 443 form is legally required for that too.

Your move: at least EIGHT violations, and one thing Marco got wrong in the other direction, are hiding in this story. Find them all.

NOTE: This case is for your own practice and is not graded. The graded issue-spotting activity for this chapter is a separate case with its own facts and its own keyed issues. Do this one first. The point is the instinct, not the score.

One last warning, and it is the one that costs licensees the most in real life. Some of the facts in the story are planted to look like violations and are not. Accusing too quickly is its own kind of failure, and an agent who cannot tell the difference between a rule broken and a rule that simply does not apply is not yet safe in front of a client.

Name the fact, then name the rule

Check yourself

10 questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see whether it is right and why.

Key terms

Agency disclosure form (§443)
The statutory form (DOS-1736 sales, DOS-1735 rentals) advising consumers of available agency relationships; it is not a contract and must be kept three years.
First substantive contact
The moment agency disclosure is due, generally the first meeting, and always before confidential information is shared or any brokerage agreement is signed.
Advance informed consent
The checkbox on the 443 form by which a consumer consents in advance to dual agency or designated agency, avoiding a second disclosure if the relationship changes.
Exclusive right to sell
A listing under which the broker earns the commission no matter who produces the buyer, including the seller.
Exclusive agency
A listing with one broker in which the seller keeps the right to sell on his own without paying a commission.
Open listing
A non-exclusive listing any number of brokers may work; only the procuring cause earns the commission.
Procuring cause
The broker whose efforts started the uninterrupted chain of events that led to the sale.
Broker protection clause
A tail-period provision entitling the broker to a commission if the owner sells, after expiration, to a buyer introduced during the listing term.
Buyer-broker agreement
The contract creating buyer agency; must state compensation and timing, duration, and the broker's duties.
Office exclusive
A seller's lawful instruction to keep the listing off the MLS, documented by certification; the agent must explain MLS benefits and then obey.
Regulation 175.7
19 NYCRR rule requiring licensees in every transaction type to disclose whom they represent and to accept compensation from more than one party only with all parties' informed consent.
Nonsolicitation order
A Department of State order barring the solicitation of listings in designated areas, typically to stop blockbusting.

Practise this chapter

Flashcards (free) Practice exam

Read Chapter 3 in the Book

The Book comes with the Salesperson pass ($39 for 3 months).

A study course, in beta. This is not a New York State Department of State approved qualifying course, and the time you spend here does not count toward the 77 hours you need for a salesperson license. Take the 77-hour course at a DOS-approved school; use this to learn the material and to review it. · Powered by License to Earn LLC