The Course · Chapter 2 Beta

Chapter 2: Law of Agency 1 - Agency Relationships

Who you work for, what you owe them, and how everyone gets paid, fiduciary duties, forms of agency, compensation, and termination.

In this chapter

  • How agency is created Express, implied, ratification, and estoppel, plus the phrases that create agency by accident.
  • 02 Fiduciary duties: OLD CAR The six duties you owe a client, and the lawsuits that follow when one slips.
  • 03 Customers & third parties Honesty and fair dealing, puffing vs. fraud, and the self-dealing trap.
  • 04 Forms of agency in NY Single, dual, designated, subagency, broker's agent, and who carries the liability.
  • 05 How everyone gets paid Commissions, splits, referral and franchise fees, and why net listings are illegal.
  • 06 How agency ends Six exits, one duty that never dies, and the agency you cannot revoke.

Lesson 1

Part 1: In this session

What you will learn

In This Session

Who you work for, and what that answer costs you

Agency is one of the hardest subjects in this course. It is also the one that touches every working day you will ever have. Every conversation you have with a buyer, a seller, a tenant or a landlord happens either inside an agency relationship or just outside one. Knowing which of those two you are standing in, at the moment you open your mouth, is most of the job.

This chapter answers one question from six directions. Who do you work for? Here is the order it comes in.

How agency is created

Fiduciary duties: OLD CAR

Customers and third parties

Forms of agency in New York

How everyone gets paid

How agency ends

Agency gets created four ways. Express, implied, ratification and estoppel. Only the first one can involve anybody signing anything. The other three can happen while you believe you are simply being helpful, and one of them can grow out of the words you use at an open house without thinking about them.

A client is owed six fiduciary duties. Obedience, loyalty, disclosure, confidentiality, accountability and reasonable care. They spell OLD CAR, and that is how you will remember them on exam day.

A customer is owed something different and much smaller. Good faith, honesty and fair dealing. Part of this chapter draws the line between an opinion you may offer all day long, a misrepresentation that costs somebody money, and fraud that can cost you your license and more than your license.

New York allows several shapes of agency and you have to be able to name the one you are in. Single agency. Dual agency. Dual agency with designated sales agents. Subagency. The broker’s agent, which is a New York answer to a New York problem. Each one moves the liability to a different person, and this chapter follows the liability.

Then the money. Commission is negotiable, it is earned at a moment the law defines, and it splits between two brokerages and their agents on the way to your pocket. Referral fees and franchise fees come off it. Net listings are illegal in New York and you need to know why.

Then the ending. Six ways an agency relationship stops, one agency that a principal cannot revoke at all, and one duty that outlives every ending on the list.

Two more chapters of agency follow this one. Chapter 3 is the paperwork and Chapter 4 is the rest of the disclosures and the antitrust rules. Three chapters on one subject tells you how much of your working life the state expects it to occupy.

NOTE: The textbook calls agency one of the most challenging subjects a licensee meets, and the reason is that it is invisible. A listing agreement you can hold in your hand. An agency relationship created by conduct leaves nothing to hold, and the first time anybody names it out loud is usually in a complaint.

Six questions, one answer: who do you work for

REMEMBER: Think of the last time somebody asked you about a house. Were you working for them, with them, or neither? By the end of this chapter you should be able to answer that in one word and say what created it.

What Is Agency?

Agent, principal, customer, and the words that create a relationship

Agency is a relationship of trust created when one person gives another person the right to represent him in dealings with third parties. That is the whole definition and every word in it is load-bearing. Representation. Dealings with third parties. Trust.

Agency is consensual. Both sides enter it willingly. A buyer or a seller hires a licensee to represent them in a transaction, and an agency relationship exists from that moment.

Three words name the three people in the room, and the exam uses all three.

Agent: the licensee

Principal: the client

Customer: a third party

The agent is the person authorized to represent another in dealings with third parties. The principal, also called the client, is the party who granted that right of representation. The customer is the third party to the transaction, the one the agent works with but does not work for.

The relationship between an agent and a principal is a fiduciary relationship. That means a relationship of trust and confidence in which one party owes the other a higher standard of good faith than either of them owes to anybody else in the deal. The fiduciary role is the role of an advocate. You are not a neutral party once you take it.

An agent owes a client duties that an agent does not owe a customer. That single sentence is the reason this whole chapter exists. Everything else is detail hanging off it.

Representation is a real job and not a label. It means giving advice that serves one side. It means arguing for a number. It means holding what you were told and using what you know in the direction of one person. A licensee who does all of that for a buyer, and then describes himself as neutral, has described something that did not happen.

Which means the words you use matter more than new licensees expect. Calling somebody “my client” in an email, or introducing a buyer as “my buyer” at an open house, can imply a relationship that has not been established. The person hearing it does not know your intentions. They know what you said.

Hypothetical. You meet a buyer at an open house on Saturday. You have no agreement with her of any kind. On Monday you email a colleague about “my buyer from the weekend.” Nothing in that email created an agency relationship on its own. It is the kind of habit that builds a record pointing the wrong way if she later claims you were representing her.

The habit worth building instead is naming the relationship out loud, early, in ordinary words. You work for the seller on this house. The buyer is welcome to your honesty and to every material fact you know, and she is not getting your advice on what to offer. Saying that takes ten seconds and it settles a question that otherwise gets settled by a hearing officer.

CAUTION: Client and customer are not interchangeable words with different shades of politeness. They are two different legal positions with two different sets of duties, and using one when you mean the other is how licensees talk themselves into relationships they never agreed to.

You work FOR a client, WITH a customer

REMEMBER: Name the three parties in your last real estate conversation. Which one were you, and which one was the other person?

Where Licensees Get Sued

Why agency law is written the way it is

Agency law exists to protect consumers in real estate transactions. It does that by setting strict rules of conduct for anyone who represents another party. The rules look fussy until you see the list of things that go wrong without them.

Six causes of legal action come up again and again in agency cases.

Failure to disclose agency

Breach of fiduciary duty

Conflicts of interest

Insufficient knowledge

Undisclosed self-dealing

Misrepresentation

Failure to disclose the agency relationship means nobody was told, in time, who represented whom. Breach of fiduciary duty means the client’s interests were mishandled in dealings with a third party. A conflict of interest most often means one licensee tried to represent both the buyer and the seller in the same deal without proper consent.

Insufficient knowledge is the one nobody expects to be sued over. It means the agent did not know what was owed to a seller or to a buyer. Not knowing is not a defense. You are held out to the public as the person in the room who knows.

Self-dealing means the agent was buying or selling for his own account and did not say so. Misrepresentation means false or misleading information reached somebody who relied on it, and it counts whether you meant it or not.

Notice what the six have in common. Every one of them is a failure to tell somebody something, or a failure to know what you were supposed to know. None of them requires you to steal anything. That is what makes agency the area where careful, well-meaning licensees get into trouble.

Hypothetical. A new salesperson shows a Queens two-family to a buyer she met at an open house. She likes the buyer. She tells him what she would offer, what she thinks the seller will take, and that she will “get him the best deal.” She is the seller’s agent. In fifteen minutes she has moved through three of the six items on that list and has not told a single lie.

The protection runs both ways. Agency law protects consumers, and the licensee who follows it is the hardest licensee in the state to sue.

NOTE: Every one of those six can be breached on a good day with good intentions. None of them requires a lie. That is the point of this chapter.

Six ways to get sued, none needs a lie

REMEMBER: Read the six again. Which one would be easiest to commit in your first month, and what habit would stop it?

Fiduciary Duties: OLD CAR

Six duties, owed to the principal and to nobody else

Fiduciary duties are the benchmark of expected performance for an agent acting on behalf of a principal. There are six of them. They are owed to the principal only. To everyone else in the transaction you still owe fairness and honesty, and that is a different and much shorter list.

The six spell OLD CAR. Learn the mnemonic now and it will carry you through the exam and through the rest of this chapter.

Obedience

Loyalty

Disclosure

Confidentiality

Accountability

Reasonable care

Obedience. Follow all legal and reasonable instructions from the client. An instruction that is illegal is not an instruction you follow.

Loyalty. Put the principal’s interests above those of every other person, including your own.

Disclosure. Pass on to the principal all facts and information you obtain that could affect the principal’s decisions.

Confidentiality. Never reveal confidential information and never take advantage of it for personal benefit.

Accountability. Money received in an agency relationship is received on behalf of the principal. Account strictly for every amount.

Reasonable care. Use reasonable care, skill and diligence in everything you do on the client’s behalf. You are viewed as a professional and an expert.

A fiduciary is a person in a position of trust who is held by law to high standards of good faith and loyalty. The word is older than real estate. It is the same standard the law puts on a trustee holding somebody else’s money and on a lawyer holding somebody else’s case. When you take a listing you step into that category, and the law does not soften the standard because the job came with a commission attached.

Your client rides in the front seat. Every duty on that list is owed to the person in the front seat, and to that person only. The next four screens take the six duties apart one at a time, because the exam tests them individually and because the practice questions come from the same place.

The six describe one rule from six angles, and most breaches you will read about break two or three of them at once.

Hypothetical. An agent learns on Tuesday that a comparable house one street over sold $30,000 above what her seller is asking. She says nothing, because a fast sale suits her calendar. She has breached disclosure by keeping a fact that affects the client’s decision. She has breached loyalty by putting her convenience first. She has breached reasonable care by failing to do the one thing she is held out as knowing how to do. One silence, three duties.

NOTE: Watch for exam answers that hand a fiduciary duty to a customer. Loyalty to a customer, confidentiality for a customer, obedience to a customer. All three are wrong for the same reason. The six belong to the principal.

Six duties, one direction: toward the client

REMEMBER: Say OLD CAR out loud and name all six without looking. Then say which of the six survives after the relationship ends.

Obedience and Loyalty

The two duties tested every working week

Obedience and loyalty are the two duties you will be tested on by real clients as well as by the exam. They come up in ordinary requests that sound reasonable until you look at them closely.

The duty of obedience says the agent must follow all legal and reasonable instructions from the client. A seller asks that his home not be shown this week because of a sickness in the family. That instruction is lawful and it is reasonable. You obey it. A buyer instructs his broker to conceal his name when the offer goes in. That instruction is lawful too. You obey that as well.

The limit is built into the duty. A principal cannot ask an agent to perform any act that would be illegal. A seller who tells an agent not to show the house to a minority has given an illegal instruction. The broker must reject it. The broker may also be able to terminate the agency relationship over it.

Read that last one carefully, because the licensing exam tests it. The answer is never obey. The answer is never obey quietly and write a note in the file. The answer is refuse, and you may walk away from the listing.

CAUTION: Obedience is not a defense to a fair housing violation. A licensee who follows a discriminatory instruction has committed the violation personally. The seller’s instruction does not transfer to the seller the liability for what you did.

The duty of loyalty says the agent must always put the principal’s interests above those of other persons, including the agent’s own. Work your hardest to serve the best interests of the principal. Never work for anyone adverse to the principal’s interest. Never work for your own interest against your principal.

Loyalty has a direction, and the direction flips depending on who hired you. A seller’s agent tries to obtain the highest price and the best terms available. A buyer’s agent tries to obtain the lowest price. Same skills, opposite targets, and you only ever aim at one of them in a given transaction.

Obedience has a second limit built into the word reasonable. A seller who asks you to hold showings for a week has made a reasonable request. A seller who asks you to hold showings for a week and then to tell every caller the house is already in contract has asked for something else, because that instruction requires you to make a false statement to third parties. Test an instruction twice. Is it lawful? Is it reasonable?

Loyalty also has an active side that new licensees miss. An agent must tell the principal things that can be done to increase the selling price of the property. Repairs. Clean-up. Minor changes. Knowing that a thousand dollars of paint and landscaping would move the price and saying nothing is a failure of loyalty, not a business judgment.

Loyalty on the buyer’s side looks different and asks the same thing of you. A buyer’s agent who knows the seller is under pressure uses that. A buyer’s agent who would rather not annoy a listing agent she works with every month, and softens a low offer for that reason, has quietly served her own convenience at her client’s expense. Nobody will ever see it happen. It is still a breach.

Case in Point. An agent lists a house and sees immediately that a few inexpensive improvements would raise what it sells for. He says nothing to the seller. The house sells at the lower number. He buys it himself, makes exactly those improvements, and resells it at a profit. He used a superior knowledge of real estate for personal gain instead of the principal’s gain. That is a breach of loyalty and of good faith, and the fact that the seller agreed to the price he was offered does not cure it.

The agent may never take advantage of his position to profit at the principal’s expense. That sentence covers more ground than it appears to. It reaches the deal you steer toward a friend, the lender who thanks you quietly, and the listing you buy yourself.

Loyalty is also the duty that decides where you may not be at all. Never work for anyone adverse to your principal’s interest. Taking a second listing on a nearly identical house two doors down, and saying nothing to either seller, puts you in a position where doing your best for one of them costs the other one a sale. That conflict has to be on the table before you take the second listing, not after.

Obey the lawful; refuse the illegal

REMEMBER: A seller tells you to keep the house off the market for a week, then tells you who not to show it to. One of those you obey and one you refuse. Say which, and say why in one sentence.

Disclosure to Your Client

Five things the principal must hear from you

The duty of disclosure says agents must pass on to the principal all facts or information the broker obtains that could affect the principal’s decisions. All facts. Not the helpful ones, not the ones that move the deal along. Five categories cover most of what this means in practice.

Material facts about the property. A material fact is one that a reasonable person relies on when making a decision. A broker should be prepared to disclose known material facts about a property, such as its location in a flood zone or a structural defect. Title problems belong in the same category.

The property’s true value. When trying to win a listing an agent may be tempted to inflate the value of the property. A high number makes a seller more willing to sign an exclusive listing. It is also a breach of the duty to act in good faith. Tell sellers a property’s true value. Point out what you know about the title or the property that may affect its worth. Suggest the inexpensive repairs that could raise the selling price. If new comparable sales appear during the listing period and they change the valuation, the seller has to be told about those too.

All offers to purchase. Even if an offer seems unacceptable, the agent must present it to the principal. The principal decides whether an offer is acceptable. The agent does not. You present the offer even when accepting it would mean a smaller commission for you, because your first loyalty is to the principal and not to your own paycheck.

There is exactly one way out of that, and it is narrow. If the seller told his agent in writing, explicitly, not to present any offers below a stated amount, the agent could legitimately not present an offer below it. In writing. Explicitly. A conversation over coffee is not that instruction.

The buyer’s financial condition, if known. A seller’s agent must tell the seller all the facts he knows about a buyer’s financial position. Assets. Income. Credit rating. The source of the down payment, which matters if it is a loan from friends rather than savings. The form of the earnest money deposit. All of it matters more when the contract is contingent on the buyer obtaining financing, because that is the term most likely to sink the closing.

Compensation from a third party. If you are receiving compensation from someone other than your client as part of a transaction, that fact has to be disclosed to the principal. Undisclosed, it becomes a secret profit: a financial benefit an agent takes from a transaction without authorization from the principal and without informing the principal that the benefit was kept.

Hypothetical. You list a house in Yonkers and the seller mentions in passing that the basement took water in a storm two years ago and the sump pump has been replaced since. That is a material fact about the property. It goes to buyers. The fact that the seller is selling because his hours were cut is confidential and stays with you. Same conversation, two categories, and the difference is what the fact is about. The building or the person.

NOTE: The all-offers rule is a favorite of exam writers because it is easy to make it sound reasonable to withhold. The offer is insulting. The seller said not to bother him. Another offer is coming Friday. None of those change the answer. Present the offer unless a written instruction says otherwise.

Every offer goes to the client, every time

REMEMBER: A lowball offer lands at nine on a Sunday night and you know the seller will be angry. Who decides whether it gets rejected, and what is your job before that decision?

Lesson 2

Part 2: Fiduciary duties in action

Confidentiality, the duty that never dies

Confidentiality

The one duty that never expires

All information given to you by the client, and all information you gather about the client from any other source, has to be kept confidential. The reason is plain. An agency relationship in which the client has to guard what he tells his own agent is worthless to him.

An agent must never reveal confidential information to others and must never take advantage of it for personal benefit. Four things in particular stay in the vault unless the principal gives you written authorization to let them out.

Why the seller is selling. A job loss, poor health, a pending divorce. Motive is leverage, and it is leverage against your own client.

That the seller will actually accept less than the listing price. This is the one that slips out at open houses, usually in a friendly voice, usually with the words “between us.”

Negotiating strategy and motivation of any kind, on either side of the table.

Personal and financial information learned during the relationship. That information cannot be used later against the principal either, including in negotiations over some other property you list for a different client years afterward.

The duty of confidentiality lasts forever. It does not end when the deal closes and it does not end when the agency relationship ends. Every other fiduciary duty on the OLD CAR list stops when the relationship stops. This one follows you.

There is one exception that needs no consent from the client, and only one. A court order. When a court orders the release of confidential information in a licensee’s possession, it must be provided in accordance with the order, and it goes only to the party or parties named in the order. Nobody else.

Confidentiality does not cover everything the client would prefer kept quiet, and this is where licensees get confused. A known structural defect is a material fact about the property and it gets disclosed. A lien on the title gets disclosed. The seller’s wish that a defect stay hidden is not a lawful instruction, so obedience does not protect it and confidentiality does not either.

Sort it with one question. Is this fact about the person or about the building? Facts about the person, his reasons, his money, his deadline, his marriage, stay in the vault. Facts about the building go out to anyone who needs them to make a decision.

CAUTION: A former client is still a confidentiality client. Using what you learned about a past seller’s finances to press him in a later transaction is a breach even though the listing expired years ago, and a written release from the former client is the only thing that changes it.

Confidentiality outlives the agency

REMEMBER: Name one thing a past client told you that you would now have to carry for the rest of your career. That is what this duty actually asks of you.

Accountability and Reasonable Care

Their money, and your standard of skill

The duty of financial accountability recognizes a simple fact. Money received in an agency relationship is received on behalf of the principal, not on behalf of the agent. It was never your money. The agent acts for the principal, so the agent has the duty to strictly account for any amount received.

Which means the money goes somewhere specific. Unless the buyer and seller have agreed otherwise, or a prevailing law or regulation says otherwise, the broker must put the money into a separate trust account so that the principal’s funds are not mixed with the funds of the brokerage.

Mixing them is commingling. Commingling is a breach of the agency relationship. It can result in legal liability and it can cost the broker the license. The amount does not matter and the intention does not matter. A deposit that spends a weekend in the wrong account has been commingled.

Strict accounting means you can say where every dollar is on any day anybody asks. What came in, from whom, on what date, into which account, and what happened to it after that. A broker who cannot produce that answer has failed the duty whether or not a cent went missing.

Accountability covers paper as well as money. Give the principal copies of all signed documents. Maintain the transaction documents that state law and regulation require you to keep. Chapter 1 covered the broker’s three-year record-keeping rule; this is the client-facing half of the same obligation.

Copies of everything signed is the habit that saves you later. A client who has the signed disclosure, the signed listing and the signed offer in his own email cannot credibly say a year afterward that nobody told him. You gave it to him and he has it.

CAUTION: The commingling question on the exam is usually dressed up to sound harmless. Held over a holiday weekend. Returned on Monday. Moved for convenience because the trust account was at a different bank. All of those are commingling. Client funds go into the separate account and they stay there.

The duty of reasonable skill, care and diligence sets the standard you are measured against when something goes wrong. Agents must always use reasonable care, skill and diligence when acting on behalf of a client. The agent is viewed as a professional and an expert, which is exactly how the client sees you and exactly how a court will.

A form filled out incorrectly could cause problems for a client. A law misunderstood could do the same. If a client loses money because of an agent’s incompetence or carelessness, the agent can be held liable for negligence. Negligence is an unintentional breach of a legal duty. Nobody has to prove you meant any harm.

Hypothetical. An agent fills in the wrong date for the mortgage contingency on a contract rider. The buyer misses the deadline by four days, the seller declares him in default, and the deposit is at risk. Nobody lied and nobody stole. The agent is exposed anyway, because a client lost money through an agent’s carelessness, and that is the definition of negligence.

Every licensee is held to a minimum standard of competence. An agent who claims expertise in a special area, property management or appraisal for instance, is held to a higher standard than that. Claim the specialty and you are measured against the specialty.

Which is a reason to be careful about what goes on your business card and your website. Advertise yourself as a commercial leasing specialist and a court will measure your commercial leasing work against a specialist’s. Chapter 1 made the point about advertising being true and not misleading. This is the same rule arriving with a price tag.

So the safest thing you can say in your first year is that you do not know. A licensee should never take on tasks beyond his ability or claim expertise where he has no special training or skills. When you are out of your depth, tell the client to seek advice from a lawyer, an accountant, an appraiser or another expert. It protects the client and it protects you.

MINIMUM COMPETENCE

Valuing property

Clarifying the principal’s needs

Discovering pertinent facts

Best effort to sell or find

Negotiating offers and counters

Explaining contracts plainly

Meeting contract deadlines

Recommending expert advice

Those eight are the floor, not the ceiling. Discovering pertinent facts covers the property, the neighborhood and the parties to the contract. Explaining contracts means explaining their purpose and effect in simple terms while never practicing law without a license, and the distance between those two is narrower than it sounds.

Describing what a mortgage contingency clause does is explaining a contract. Telling a client whether he should waive it is advice about his legal rights. Chapter 1 listed practicing law without a license among the grounds for losing yours. Reasonable care and that prohibition meet on this exact line, and when you are unsure which side of it you are on, the answer is to name a lawyer.

Their money in a separate account, always

REMEMBER: A buyer hands you a $10,000 check on a Friday night. Where is it by Monday morning, and whose name is on the account it is sitting in?

Scope of Authority

Special, general, universal, how much power was handed over

Agency relationships are classified by the scope of the authority the principal grants to the agent, usually through a written contract. Three levels, and authority grows as you go down the list.

A special agent has limited authority to perform a specific task or conduct a specific transaction. This is generally a short-term relationship. A broker contracted by a client to sell a house is a special agent. A special agent does not have the power to bind the client to a contract. A special agent may also be called a limited agent.

That is where almost every real estate licensee lives. One task, one transaction, no authority to sign for the client. You bring the offer to your seller. You do not accept it on his behalf.

A general agent is authorized to represent the principal in a broad range of matters as specified, often as part of a long-term relationship. A property manager is the standard example. So is the relationship between an employing broker and his affiliated licensees, because the broker gives general authority to those licensees to conduct real estate business on the broker’s behalf.

A general agent has ongoing authority across a defined area rather than a single job. A property manager collects rents, signs leases, hires contractors and handles complaints, month after month, within whatever the management agreement allows. Inside your own office the same structure is running, with your broker as principal and you as the general agent of the brokerage business.

A universal agent is authorized to do anything and everything that can be lawfully delegated to a representative, including signing contracts. A universal agency is usually created by the granting of a power of attorney. Real estate licensees are rarely universal agents.

You will meet universal agency from the other side of the table. A seller living in Florida grants a power of attorney to his brother in Brooklyn, and the brother signs the contract and the deed. Your client is still the seller. The brother is the person who can bind him, and you should see that power of attorney before you rely on it.

NOTE: The exam likes to ask which kind of agent a listing broker is. The answer is special agent, and the reason is the one thing a special agent cannot do. Sign the contract for the client.

Special, general, universal: authority grows

REMEMBER: You hold a listing and your seller is on a plane. The buyer wants an answer in an hour. Can you accept for him? Which kind of agent are you?

What You Owe Everyone Else

Customers, third parties, and the self-dealing trap

Anyone other than the agent and the principal in a transaction is a third party. You hold a listing agreement with a seller. The buyer who walks into your open house is the customer and the third party. What you owe that person is real, and it is not the OLD CAR list.

An agent owes third parties a duty of good faith, honesty and fair dealing. An agent does not have a fiduciary relationship with a third party. In most cases the agent is not required to advance the third party’s interests. The duty of loyalty to the principal actually prohibits it.

Honesty in a real estate transaction means disclosing information you are obligated to disclose and avoiding misrepresentation or fraud. Honesty requires a licensee to disclose material facts to a customer in a timely manner. Timely means while the customer can still act on it.

Being honest with a customer does not require you to disclose information that is confidential in the agent-client relationship. The two duties do not collide as often as new licensees fear. Confidential information is what your client told you. A material fact is what is true about the building.

Which gives you a sentence you can say to any customer without breaching anything. You represent the seller. You will answer every question about the property honestly and you will not withhold anything you know that would matter to her decision. You will not advise her on what to offer, and you will not tell her what your seller will accept. Customers almost never object to that. They object to finding it out later.

The word timely is doing work in that rule as well. A material fact disclosed after the contract is signed was not disclosed in a timely manner. The test is whether the customer still had the chance to act on it, and a disclosure that arrives at the closing table has failed the test no matter how complete it is.

Case in Point. A licensee representing a seller knows that the paneling in the basement is covering up structural damage to the foundation. That is a material fact. It requires disclosure to the buyer customer. The seller’s wish that it stay quiet does not change the answer, because concealing a known structural defect is not a lawful instruction.

Then the other half of this screen, which is about you. Licensees should disclose in writing, to both clients and any third parties to the transaction, any interest they may have in a property. The disclosure alerts everyone to a possible conflict of interest. Failure to do it could be considered illegal self-dealing.

In writing. To both sides. Before the interest becomes visible some other way.

Case in Point. A broker’s wife uses her maiden name to submit an offer on one of the broker’s listed properties. The offer is well below the listing price. The broker tells the seller what a good offer it is. The name on the offer was designed to hide the relationship, and the recommendation came from a person who would benefit from the sale. That is illegal self-dealing.

One more piece of the same rule. When you sell or lease real estate that you own yourself, disclose your licensee status before entering into an agreement of sale or lease. The other party is entitled to know that the person across the table does this for a living.

That applies whether or not you are acting as anybody’s agent in the deal. Chapter 1 established that an owner dealing with his own property needs no license, and that is still true. It does not make you an ordinary owner. You hold a license, the other side does not, and the disclosure exists so nobody is negotiating against a professional without knowing it.

An interest is also broader than ownership. A commission you would earn on the buyer’s next purchase, a share in the LLC making the offer, a family member on either side of the table, a lender who pays you for referrals. If you would gain from the outcome, name the gain in writing to both sides and let them decide what to make of it.

CAUTION: Self-dealing rarely looks like theft from the inside. It looks like a good deal you happen to be close to. If you or anyone connected to you stands to gain from the transaction, put it in writing and give it to both sides before anybody signs.

Honesty to everyone, loyalty to one

REMEMBER: Your brother wants to bid on your listing. What goes in writing, who gets it, and when does it have to be in their hands?

From Opinion to Fraud

Four points on one scale, with liability rising

Violations by licensees very often take the form of misrepresentation or of nondisclosure of material facts that could affect one of the parties to a transaction. Four words mark the scale, and the liability rises as you move along it.

Puffing

Misrepresentation

Constructive fraud

Actual fraud

Puffing is a superlative statement about the quality of a property that should not be taken as an assertion of fact. “Probably the best view in the county.” It is extravagant opinion. Because of its non-factual and exaggerated nature, no reasonable person would rely on it when deciding to buy property, so it generally does not fall under fraud at all.

Misrepresentation is false or misleading information. It shows up three ways. In documents, such as altered pay documentation or false information on an application. In misstatements, such as telling a buyer a property is three acres when it is not. In omissions, which means failing to mention or disclose something, such as neglecting to disclose a lien on the property.

Constructive fraud is what misrepresentation becomes when somebody gets hurt by it and there was no intent to deceive. Misrepresentation may occur through carelessness or negligence. Licensees can still be held liable for negligent misrepresentation if they should have known a statement to be false. When someone is harmed as a result, even with no intent to deceive, it may be considered constructive fraud.

Actual fraud is an intentional misrepresentation or concealment of a material fact for the purpose of inducing someone to act. The misrepresentation is a deliberate act, or it is committed with reckless indifference to the truth. Reckless indifference belongs in that sentence. Not caring whether the statement is true can be enough.

Either constructive fraud or actual fraud may lead to civil penalties, and actual fraud may lead to criminal penalties, where it causes harm to another party.

Take one fact and walk it down the scale. “This is a lovely big yard” is puffing. “The lot is a third of an acre” when the survey says a quarter acre is a misstatement, and it is misrepresentation. If the buyer relied on the size, paid for it and was harmed, and you never checked the survey you had in your own file, that is constructive fraud. If you knew the real number and said a third of an acre anyway to close the deal, that is actual fraud.

Omission sits on the same scale and it is the one licensees fall into most. Saying nothing about the lien, the boundary dispute, the open permit or the assessment is failing to disclose information, and failing to disclose is a form of misrepresentation in its own right. You do not have to say a word to commit it.

NOTE: “I didn’t know” can answer a charge of actual fraud, unless you did not care whether the statement was true. It does not answer constructive fraud. Should have known is the standard on the negligent half of the scale, and you are held out as the expert. That is why the two middle boxes catch honest people.

Liability rises as the scale moves right

REMEMBER: Take a sentence you might say about a listing and move it one step along the scale. What extra word would turn your opinion into a misstatement of fact?

Opinions and Puffing

When sales talk turns into fraud

As a general rule a seller or an agent cannot be sued for misrepresentation if the statements were merely extravagant opinions that build up the property’s benefits. That is puffing, and the law leaves room for it because buyers expect it and discount it.

The textbook examples sound like every open house you have ever attended. This is probably the best view in the county. The landscaping is the most beautiful I have ever seen. The living room is so comfortable you will never want to leave. This is the prettiest house in the neighborhood. This kitchen is fabulous, you will cook better meals than the finest restaurant.

None of those is a fact. None of them can be checked. That is precisely why they are usually safe. A reasonable person would not rely on any of them when deciding to buy property.

Fraud takes two elements, and puffing normally fails both. To prove fraud it is necessary to prove that the statement was made with intent to deceive, and that someone relied on the statement to make a decision. Intent plus reliance. Without both, the statement stays on the safe side of the line.

Two things move a statement across the line, and both of them are about you rather than about the words.

The first is expertise. A court may allow recovery based on opinions stated by an expert who was hired to give advice because of his superior knowledge. You are the expert in that room. Your opinion carries a weight a stranger’s opinion does not, and a jury knows it.

The second is belief. Someone who states an opinion he does not actually believe may also be held liable. Say the roof looks fine to you while you privately think it is finished, and you have made a false statement about what you believe. That is a fact about your own mind, and it is one you got wrong on purpose.

Which is why a real estate agent should be very cautious about offering unsubstantiated opinions. Praise the light and the layout all you want. The moment the subject turns to the roof, the foundation, the boiler or the zoning, stop giving opinions and start giving facts, or send the buyer to somebody who inspects for a living.

There is a simple test you can run in the moment. Could somebody be hired to check this? Nobody can be hired to check whether a living room is comfortable. Somebody can be hired to check the age of the roof, the capacity of the electrical service, the depth of the lot and whether the finished basement was permitted. Anything checkable is a statement of fact when you say it, whatever tone you say it in.

The second test is about the word you would use afterward. If a buyer repeated your sentence back to you in a deposition, would you want to say “that was my opinion” or would you want to say “that was accurate”? Sentences that need the first answer should never be about anything that can be measured.

CAUTION: Puffing about a defect is not puffing. “This basement is bone dry” sounds like enthusiasm, and it is a factual claim about water. If you know about the cracks behind the paneling, that sentence is a misrepresentation of a material fact.

Praise the view; do not appraise the roof

REMEMBER: Write down three things you would say to sell a house you love. How many of the three could be checked by a home inspector?

Lesson 3

Part 3: Creating agency

Four ways the relationship is born

How Agency Is Created

Express, implied, ratification, estoppel

In real estate brokerage an agency relationship is generally formed through a written or oral contract between the broker and the principal. That is expressed agency, and it is the most airtight and preferred method of creating any agency relationship.

Written beats oral for two reasons. A written agreement is more easily enforceable, and it spells out the expectations of all parties in the relationship. When a dispute arrives eighteen months later, the written agreement is the only version of the conversation that still exists.

An agency can also be created by the words or actions of the principal or the agent indicating that they have an agency relationship. That is implied agency, and it is created without anybody deciding to create it.

Hypothetical. A buyer calls a brokerage and asks if someone will show her a house the firm has listed. The broker shows her that house and two others as well. From the broker’s actions the buyer could assume she is being represented by the brokerage. Nothing was signed. Nothing was refused either.

New York courts do not easily enforce implied real estate agreements. That is not comfort. It means the fight over whether the relationship existed is a fight, and you will be in it.

PHRASES THAT CREATE AGENCY BY ACCIDENT

My seller

My buyer

I have a property

I have a buyer

I am working for you

I will work hard for you

I will do my best for you

I am on your side

Each of those is a phrase a licensee should be cautious about using when no relationship exists or is intended. They are not magic words and none of them creates an agency by itself. They are the sentences a customer quotes back when she explains why she believed you were her agent.

Agency by ratification is the later confirmation or approval of an act that was not authorized when it was performed. An agency relationship can arise after the fact this way, with no specific agreement ever having been made.

Hypothetical. A licensee, with no listing and no authority, advertises a neighbor’s house and brings her a buyer at a good price. The neighbor had authorized nothing. She accepts the offer anyway, takes the deal and treats the licensee as her agent through the closing. By approving the act after it was performed she has ratified it, and the relationship exists from that approval onward with the duties that come attached.

Estoppel is a legal doctrine that prevents a person from asserting rights or facts inconsistent with earlier actions or statements, where he failed to object to another person’s actions or to attempt to stop them. Estoppel makes it legally impossible to deny the agency. Watch it happen, say nothing, take the benefit, and the law will not let you claim afterward that there was no agency.

Hypothetical. A seller knows a licensee is showing his house, answering questions about it and telling buyers he represents the seller. The seller sees the signs, reads the emails and says nothing for six weeks. When the commission comes due he announces there was never any agreement. Estoppel is the doctrine that stops him. He had every chance to object and he took the benefit instead.

Ratification and estoppel share one consequence. By ratifying the relationship and accepting the rewards, both client and agent must also assume the responsibilities, even though there was no formal agreement. You take the duties along with the commission.

That cuts against the licensee as often as it cuts for him. An agency you never meant to create still carries the full OLD CAR list from the day a court says it started. You do not get the duties of a customer relationship because that is what you thought you had.

One related term the glossary carries is ostensible agency, which occurs when an agent is perceived as the principal’s fiduciary by a third party and the principal does not declare otherwise. Silence again, on the principal’s side this time.

CAUTION: Three of the four ways an agency is created do not require your signature and two do not require your intention. The only one you fully control is the express agreement. Get it signed, and get it signed early.

Only express agency is one you chose

REMEMBER: Which of those eight phrases have you already used this month? Who heard it, and what do they think you agreed to?

Agency Inside a Brokerage

Who is the agent when the agent is a company?

A real estate brokerage is a company formed by a licensed real estate broker for the purpose of conducting or assisting with real estate transactions. Listing property for sale. Bringing buyers and sellers together. Negotiating transactions. Leasing property. Managing property.

A brokerage firm can be owned by a single licensed broker, which is a sole proprietorship, or by more than one licensed person, as a partnership or a corporation. Chapter 1 covered the six classes of broker license those forms map onto.

Here is the part that surprises people. The client hires the brokerage, not you. When you take a listing, the agency relationship that gets created runs between the broker and the seller. The agreement is the broker’s agreement. Your name is on it as the person who did the work.

A listing agreement, and a buyer or tenant representation agreement, is treated as an employment contract, and signing one creates the agency relationship. When a salesperson takes a listing, the salesperson is acting on behalf of the broker. Any agreement the salesperson helps put together is an agreement between the broker and the seller, or between the broker and the buyer. Your signature on it is the broker’s reach, not your own.

An employing broker may grant authority to any number of affiliated licensees to act as his agents in carrying out the business of the brokerage. When the broker does that, those affiliated licensees become subagents of the broker’s clients. You are an agent of your broker and a subagent of your broker’s client, and you owe fiduciary duties to both.

Which answers a question new licensees ask constantly. Whose client is it? The answer is the brokerage’s, and you owe that client the full OLD CAR list as a subagent of the broker’s principal. Every other licensee in your office owes the same client the same duties, on a listing they may never have seen.

An agent’s authority always comes from the principal. Inside a brokerage the principal is the broker. Which is why responsibility runs back up the same line the authority came down.

§ 442, REAL PROPERTY LAW

When a licensee acts within the scope of authority, the broker is legally liable for those acts, vicarious liability. Under §442, the broker answers for a licensee's deeds only if the broker had knowledge of the offense. Liability can also flow upward to the principal.

Carry the idea inside that rule. Vicarious liability means one person is responsible for the actions of another. In a brokerage it means your broker can be called to answer for what you did, and the knowledge requirement is what decides whether he is.

Hypothetical. A salesperson at a small firm misstates the square footage on a listing sheet and a buyer relies on it. The salesperson is liable for her own statement. Whether the brokerage is liable alongside her turns on the broker’s knowledge and on the supervision rules Chapter 1 covered. Liability can also move upward from the broker to the principal, which is the thread subagency picks up a few screens from now.

Vicarious liability is also why brokers supervise the way they do. Chapter 1 set out the supervision standard in 19 NYCRR §175.21, which calls for regular, frequent and consistent personal guidance, instruction, oversight and superintendence. A broker who is answerable for your conduct has every reason to look at your files, and a broker who never looks at your files is a broker to be careful of.

Many brokerage firms join franchises for name recognition and for services on a nationwide or global network. The franchisee pays for the right to use the trade name of the franchise and its operating procedures. The broker still owns and operates the firm.

A franchised office is independently owned and operated. The sign on the door belongs to a national company. The brokerage under it belongs to the broker who licensed it, and your agency relationships run to that broker and to nobody in a head office in another state.

Franchise membership costs money and the money comes out of commissions. A brokerage associated with a franchise company is required to deduct a franchise fee from the brokerage’s earned commission before any of the proceeds are distributed to individual agents. Before the split, not after it.

NOTE: When you interview brokers, ask what the franchise fee is and get the answer documented in your employment agreement. A fee taken off the top changes what a sixty-forty split is actually worth, and new licensees find that out on their first commission check.

The broker holds the client; you hold the work

REMEMBER: Your client signed with your brokerage. If you moved firms tomorrow, who keeps the listing, and why?

Single Agency

One broker, one client, never both

Single agency is the most basic form of agency. One broker represents just one party in a specific transaction, the buyer or the seller, but never both. It leaves little room for confusion about who represents whom, which is exactly why it remains the cleanest way to practice.

The broker owes all fiduciary duties to the client, whether the client is the buyer or the seller. The other party to the transaction is simply a customer. One direction for loyalty, one set of OLD CAR duties, no balancing act.

The same structure runs on the rental side. A landlord’s agent is engaged by the landlord and owes the landlord the fiduciary duties. A tenant’s agent is engaged by the tenant and owes them to the tenant. Read every rule in this chapter with the pair sale and rental in mind, because New York treats the two the same way here.

A seller’s agent is engaged by a seller to represent the seller’s interests. The task is to secure a buyer for the seller’s home at a price and on terms acceptable to the seller. A seller’s agent owes all fiduciary duties to the seller, subject to whatever specific provisions the agreement between the agent and the seller sets out.

The agency relationship between a broker and a seller is created with a listing agreement. Chapter 3 takes the listing agreement apart form by form.

A seller’s agent does not represent the interests of the buyer. That does not mean the buyer gets nothing. A seller’s agent must deal fairly and honestly with a buyer in good faith, exercise reasonable skill and care in performing the agent’s duties, and disclose all facts known that materially affect the value or desirability of the property, except as otherwise provided by law.

Read the last phrase of that list closely, because students skip it. Value or desirability. It is wider than defects. A pending assessment, an open violation, a planned road, a lapsed certificate of occupancy. If you know it and it would change what a reasonable buyer thinks the house is worth or how much he wants it, it goes to the buyer even though the buyer is only a customer.

A buyer’s agent is engaged by a buyer to represent the buyer’s interests, by negotiating the purchase of a home at a price and on terms acceptable to the buyer. A buyer’s agent owes all fiduciary duties to the buyer, and the seller is simply a customer.

Buyer’s agents must deal fairly and honestly with a seller. They do not represent the seller’s interests, so they should perform their task as diligently as they would if they were personally buying the property. That is the standard the textbook sets and it is a good one to hold yourself to.

A buyer’s agent carries one disclosure obligation running the other way. Disclose to the seller’s side all facts known that materially affect the buyer’s ability or willingness to perform a contract to acquire the property, where disclosing them is not inconsistent with the fiduciary duties owed to the buyer.

Ability to perform is the phrase to hold on to. A buyer whose financing is thin, whose approval rests on a condition he has not met, or who needs to sell his own house first, carries facts that materially affect whether the contract will close. Those facts are a different category from what he is willing to pay, and burying them costs a seller a market season.

The agency relationship between a broker and a buyer is created with a buyer-broker agreement, which also establishes how the buyer’s agent will be paid. The buyer might agree to compensate the broker directly with a flat fee, a percentage of the sales price, or any other form of compensation the buyer and the broker agree on.

MLS MATH Buyer agrees to pay her broker 4%. The listing broker offers 3% to buyer's brokers through the MLS. The buyer owes only the 1% difference.

Work that arithmetic once and the mechanism is yours. The buyer-broker agreement can say the buyer gets credit for any commission the seller pays her broker, so the buyer owes only the difference between what she agreed to pay and what arrives from the other side. Brokers representing buyers often earn their commission that way rather than out of the buyer’s own pocket.

NOTE: In the past, traditional agency was generally reserved for the seller and buyers were left to fend for themselves. A buyer who contacted a broker to help find a home often assumed that broker represented her when he did not. That assumption is exactly what the disclosures in Chapter 3 are there to prevent.

One client, one direction, no tightrope

REMEMBER: You are the seller’s agent and the buyer asks you what she should offer. Answer that question in your head. What can you say, and what would you be giving away?

Subagent or Broker’s Agent

Two ways to cooperate, two very different liabilities

Most deals involve two brokerages. One holds the listing and one brings the buyer. The second brokerage can come into the transaction in more than one role, and the roles are not interchangeable. Follow the liability and the difference becomes obvious.

A subagent is anyone given authority by an agent so that the subagent can assist in carrying out the principal’s orders. Subagency can be created when the listing broker, with the seller’s approval, makes a specific offer of subagency through a multiple listing service.

Any broker who accepts that offer of subagency becomes an agent of the listing broker and a subagent of the seller. So do all of that broker’s affiliated licensees. As a subagent to the seller, that broker and his licensees owe the seller all of the same fiduciary duties that the listing broker and his licensees owe the seller.

The advantage to a seller who offers subagency is reach. The property is likely to be seen by more potential buyers through the actions of more brokers. More brokers marketing the house is a real benefit and it is why subagency existed in the first place.

Then the catch. Brokers have vicarious liability for their affiliated licensees. Sellers have to be made aware that subagency creates vicarious liability for them as well. With subagency the seller can be held responsible for the actions of the listing broker, and also for the actions of any subagent, in the event of misrepresentation or any act that causes damage to third parties.

Read that again with a client’s eyes. Your seller can be answerable for something said by a licensee at a brokerage he has never heard of, working for a firm he never hired, about a house he is trying to sell.

Hypothetical. A subagent from a firm across town tells a buyer the boiler is two years old. It is eleven years old and nobody checked. The buyer closes, the boiler fails, and the buyer sues. The subagent made the statement. The listing broker can be reached through the chain. And the seller, who never met that licensee, is exposed because subagency put that licensee in his own chain of authority.

To address the issue of vicarious liability, New York State recognizes the concept of a broker’s agent. That role exists for this problem and for no other reason.

A broker’s agent is an agent from another brokerage firm who cooperates with, or is engaged by, a listing agent to assist in finding a buyer for the seller’s property. On the other side of the deal, a broker’s agent may be engaged by a buyer’s agent to assist in finding a property for the buyer to purchase.

A broker’s agent looks like a subagent in three ways. The broker’s agent cooperates with the broker to market and sell the property, or to find a property for a buyer. The broker’s agent owes all fiduciary duties to the listing broker’s client. And the relationship must be offered in the multiple listing service with the client’s consent.

The key difference is that a broker’s agent is not a subagent of the client. The client therefore has no vicarious liability for the broker’s agent or for any of that firm’s affiliated licensees. The broker who made the offer of cooperation does have vicarious liability for the broker’s agent. The risk stops at the broker.

One more difference follows from that. The client cannot give instructions to a broker’s agent, because the two of them have no direct relationship. Instructions travel through the broker who engaged the broker’s agent.

Which is a fair trade for the seller and worth explaining to him in those terms. He gives up the ability to direct the cooperating broker. He gets to stop carrying that broker’s mistakes. A seller who understands the trade usually takes it.

NOTE: Both roles owe full fiduciary duties to the listing broker’s client. The duties are not the difference. The difference is who is answerable when one of those duties is breached, and that is the answer the exam wants.

Same duties, different person holding the risk

REMEMBER: Your seller asks whether cooperating brokers can get him sued. Answer in two sentences, one for subagency and one for a broker’s agent.

The Cooperative Transaction Map

Who is whose agent, from the seller down

Everything in the last three screens fits into one picture, and the picture is a chain. Authority flows down from the principal. Liability can flow back up. Work through it once slowly and the exam questions on this stop being hard.

Start at the top. The seller is the client and the principal. The buyer, in this picture, is a customer of the seller’s side and nothing more.

The listing broker is the agent of the seller client. The listing broker is also the principal of everyone below: of his own affiliated licensees, of any subagents, and of any broker’s agents.

All salespersons affiliated with the listing brokerage are agents of the listing broker and subagents of the seller client. That includes you when the listing belongs to your firm. Full fiduciary duties to the seller, even on a listing you have never visited.

A subagent brokerage is an agent of the listing broker and a subagent of the seller client. It is also the principal of its own affiliated licensees. Those licensees are agents of the subagent, subagents of the listing broker, and subagents of the seller client. Three labels on one person, and all three carry the seller’s duties.

A broker’s agent firm is an agent of the listing broker and the principal of its own affiliated licensees. Its licensees are agents of the broker’s agent and subagents of the listing broker. Read the end of that sentence again. The chain stops at the listing broker. Nobody in the broker’s agent column is a subagent of the seller.

That is the entire point of the broker’s agent role, drawn as a picture. The duties owed to the seller are the same in both columns. The liability the seller carries is not.

Count the seller’s chain in a real deal. Listing broker, one. Four salespersons at the listing brokerage, five. A subagent firm, six. Three salespersons at the subagent firm, nine. Nine people owe your seller obedience, loyalty, disclosure, confidentiality, accountability and reasonable care, and your seller has met two of them.

Now run the same deal with a broker’s agent instead of a subagent. The listing broker and his four salespersons still owe the seller everything. The broker’s agent firm and its salespersons owe the seller’s interests their full fiduciary effort through the listing broker, and none of them is the seller’s subagent. The seller’s exposure stops at his own broker.

Two rules read the map. Authority always flows down from the principal, because an agent’s authority comes from the person who granted it. Liability can flow back up the same line, which is what vicarious liability means.

Every box on the seller’s chain owes the seller full fiduciary duties. Not a reduced version, not honesty only. A salesperson at another firm, working under an accepted offer of subagency, owes your seller the same confidentiality and the same loyalty that you do.

And one line does not move. The buyer is a customer here. Good faith, honesty, fair dealing and the disclosure of known material facts. No loyalty, no confidentiality, no obedience.

The map has a mirror image. Everything above is drawn from a listing. Draw it from a buyer-broker agreement and the buyer sits at the top as the client, the buyer’s broker is his agent, that firm’s salespersons are subagents of the buyer, and a broker’s agent may be engaged to help find a property. Same shape, other side of the table.

NOTE: Exam questions on this map almost always ask you to count. How many people owe the seller fiduciary duties in a cooperative sale with one subagent firm. Everybody in the seller’s chain, which is the listing broker, his salespersons, the subagent firm and its salespersons.

Authority flows down; liability flows up

REMEMBER: Draw the chain for your own office on a piece of paper. Where does your name sit, and whose client are you a subagent of right now?

Dual Agency

One agent, two adversaries

A real estate agent may represent both the seller and the buyer in the same transaction, or both the landlord and the tenant. That is dual agency. A dual agent owes fiduciary duties to both sides at once.

Which is a problem, and the textbook names it plainly. Both parties are adversaries in the transaction. The seller wants the highest price. The buyer wants the lowest price. One person cannot pursue both of those at the same time.

So the law takes something away from each client to make it workable. Each client gives up the undivided loyalty of his or her agent. That is the trade, and it is the sentence the client has to actually understand before consenting.

A dual agent must remain neutral at all times. A dual agent must be careful not to disclose confidential information to the other party, especially about price and negotiating strategies. What a dual agent may not withhold is material facts and defects. Those still get disclosed.

Think about what neutrality actually costs you in the room. You cannot tell the seller that the buyer would go higher. You cannot tell the buyer that the seller would take less. You know both numbers and you carry both of them in silence, advising neither side on the one question each of them most wants answered.

Critics of dual agency rightly point out that the arrangement carries an inherent conflict of interest. Dual agency is illegal in some states. New York permits it, and permits it on one condition.

Dual agency in New York State requires the informed written consent of both clients. Informed means they understood what they gave up. Written means it exists on paper. Both clients means neither one alone is enough.

Consensual dual agency can work as long as everyone stays sensitive about protecting confidential information that could favor one client over the other and unintentionally compromise the transaction. That takes attention every day of the deal, not a signature at the start.

Brokers decide whether their brokerage will practice dual agency at all. If a firm does, the company practice should be to tell sellers when the listing agreement is signed that dual agency is a possibility, and to tell buyers when the buyer-broker agreement is signed that dual agency would occur if the buyer becomes interested in one of the firm’s own listings. That advance consent protects the broker and the affiliated licensees from claims of undisclosed dual agency. Chapter 3 covers how the consent is obtained and documented.

Undisclosed dual agency occurs when both principals in the same transaction are represented by the same broker without full disclosure to, and approval from, both principals. It can happen without anyone intending it. A seller’s agent shows a listing to a buyer client before confirming whether both the buyer and the seller consented to dual agency, and it has already happened.

The consequences are not small. Failure to disclose dual agency, whether intentional or unintentional, violates New York license and agency law. It jeopardizes any commission due. It may call for rescission of the deal. It leaves the broker open to a civil lawsuit.

Count what is at stake in that list. The commission you already earned. The transaction your clients were counting on. Your standing with the Department of State. And a civil claim brought by whichever client decides he was the one who got the short end of a loyalty nobody could deliver.

CAUTION: It is no defense to claim that dual agency was done with good intentions to help both the buyer and the seller. Good intentions are the usual explanation and they have never worked.

Written consent from both, before you show

REMEMBER: Your buyer client wants to see a house your own firm has listed. Name the thing you check before you unlock the door.

Lesson 4

Part 4: Dual agency with designated sales agents

The in-house compromise

Designated Sales Agents

The in-house answer to dual agency

Dual agency situations arise most often in in-house transactions. One agent of a brokerage represents the seller client. Another agent in the same brokerage represents the buyer client. Both agents work for the same broker, so the brokerage is on both sides of the table.

Dual agency with designated sales agents came about to deal with the complications that creates. When two agents within a single brokerage represent both parties, clients could argue that their negotiating ability is weakened, because the agents and the broker are all dual agents. Nobody in the building is purely on their side.

New York allows a broker to appoint specific designated agents to represent the interests of, and advocate for, the buyer client and the seller client in negotiating the transaction. A designated sales agent is a licensee named by the sponsoring broker to represent either the seller or the buyer, or the landlord or the tenant, in an in-house transaction.

The broker appoints the designated agents. The clients do not appoint them and the agents do not appoint themselves. That appointment is the act that creates the arrangement, and it is one more reason the broker stays in the middle of it from beginning to end.

The brokerage stays a dual agent

Agent A advocates for the seller

Agent B advocates for the buyer

When both parties are clients of the brokerage, designated agency provides the best representation available to both the seller and the buyer. Two advocates, each one negotiating, is a better outcome for the clients than one neutral agent trying to serve two masters.

The relationship requires the informed written consent of all parties. Same standard as any dual agency, because this is still a dual agency.

And it has limits that have to be stated plainly to the client. If designated agents are appointed, the brokerage continues as dual agent representing both the buyer and the seller in the same transaction. The broker must still supervise the designated agents. The parties will not have full fiduciary duties available to them as they would in a single agency.

The fiduciary duty of undivided loyalty cannot be delivered by the designated sales agent or by the broker. Not by either of them. A designated agent who tells a client otherwise has misstated the arrangement the client is consenting to.

The designated agents should refrain from disclosing any personal information they obtain, provided that doing so does not violate their duty to deal fairly and honestly with a customer. That is the tightrope the arrangement leaves behind after it has removed the bigger one.

Hypothetical. Two agents in the same Bronx office. One has the listing, one has the buyer, and the buyer falls in love with that listing. Without designated agency the whole brokerage is a dual agent and neither client gets an advocate. With designated agency, appointed by the broker and consented to in writing by both clients, each client gets somebody arguing for their number. The broker still sits above both of them and still cannot take a side.

CAUTION: The exam trap here is the sentence that sounds generous. “Each designated agent owes his client the full, undivided loyalty of a single agency.” That is wrong. Undivided loyalty is the one thing designated agency cannot restore.

Two advocates, one dual agent brokerage

REMEMBER: Explain designated agency to a seller in three sentences, and make sure one of them says what he is giving up.

How the Commission Works

Negotiable, earned at a defined moment, split on the way down

Commission is the primary source of compensation for a brokerage. It is typically a percentage of the transaction amount, though compensation could be a flat fee, an hourly rate or some other consideration entirely. Nothing about the form is fixed.

The rate is negotiated between the client and the broker at the time the written agreement is made. Whatever terms the broker and client agree to should be clearly spelled out in writing. Not just the amount. The timing at which it will be paid belongs in writing too.

Payment of a broker’s commission may be made dependent on any lawful condition. A listing agreement may say the commission is due once the seller signs a binding contract with a buyer. It may say the commission is due only if the sale actually closes. That is a negotiable point in the brokerage contract like every other point.

Unless the parties agree otherwise, the traditional consensus sets the moment the commission is earned. A listing broker is entitled to a commission when a ready, willing and able buyer is found and a meeting of the minds occurs between the buyer and the seller on all terms. Found and agreed. Not closed.

Ready, willing and able means a buyer making an offer to purchase on terms acceptable to the seller and having the financial ability to complete the purchase. All three parts. A buyer who wants the house and cannot fund it is not an able buyer.

Some listing agreements include an “as, if and when” clause. It says that the earned commission, which is payable when the buyer and seller come to terms, can be deferred until the transaction closes. The commission is still earned at the earlier moment. Payment is what moves.

Which matters when the deal falls apart on the seller’s side. If the seller then defaults, the broker is entitled to the earned commission. The clause delayed the payment. It did not undo the earning.

A broker can accept compensation from both the buyer and the seller, with the informed consent of both parties. Both. Taking money from two sides without telling either one is the money version of undisclosed dual agency.

Being paid by one side does not settle who you represent, and that is a confusion worth clearing up early. A buyer’s agent is often paid out of the listing broker’s commission and still owes every fiduciary duty to the buyer. Representation is created by the agreement. Compensation is a separate negotiation, and the exam will hand you a fact pattern that mixes the two.

Now the salesperson’s side of it. To be eligible for a sales commission an individual must have an active real estate license and be affiliated with a broker. The commission split negotiated between a broker and an affiliated salesperson should be documented in the employment or independent contractor agreement, which is the same document Chapter 1 told you to read before you sign it.

A salesperson can receive the agreed share of the commission only from his or her employing broker. There is one exception. A salesperson may accept compensation from a broker with whom they are no longer associated, where they were licensed with that broker at the time the commission was earned.

Here is how the money actually moves, using the textbook’s own figures. ABC Realty lists a property and negotiates a 7 percent commission with the seller, who agrees to allow 3 percent to go to a broker’s agent or a buyer’s agent. Selling Agent Ann of XYZ Realty finds a buyer and the property sells for $200,000.

The seller pays a commission of $14,000 at closing to Broker Ben of ABC Realty. ABC keeps 4 percent, which is $8,000, and passes 3 percent, which is $6,000, to XYZ Realty. Each firm splits its share fifty-fifty with its agent under the terms of that firm’s employment or independent contractor agreement. Broker Ben keeps $4,000 and Listing Agent Sue receives $4,000. Broker Lou keeps $3,000 and Buyer’s Agent Ann receives $3,000.

Follow the direction of travel, because the exam asks about it. The full commission reaches the listing broker first. The listing broker distributes to the cooperating broker. Each broker then pays his own affiliated licensees. Money never jumps a step.

The listing broker generally negotiates with the seller to determine how much of the commission, if any, the seller is willing to pay a subagent, a broker’s agent or a buyer’s agent. It is common for a listing broker to include such an offer of cooperation in the multiple listing service.

MLS OFFER OF COOPERATION

The listing broker's MLS offer tells cooperating brokers exactly what they'll earn, and it can differ for subagents vs. buyer's brokers.

The practical point for a cooperating broker is that the offer tells him what the work is worth before he does it. Read the offer on every listing you show, because it is the only place that number appears before a contract exists.

NOTE: A salesperson paid directly by a seller, a buyer, a lender or a cooperating brokerage has been paid by the wrong person, whatever the amount and whatever the reason. Compensation reaches you through your employing broker.

Earned at the meeting of the minds

REMEMBER: A deal collapses because your seller refuses to close. Was the commission earned? Say what you would look for in the listing agreement before answering.

Net Listings, Referral Fees, Franchise Fees

One arrangement that is illegal, and two that are not

The terms of compensation can be whatever the broker and the principal negotiate. A percentage of the sale price is the most common. There are other ways a broker can be compensated, and one of them New York does not allow at all.

With a net listing the property owner agrees to accept a stipulated amount, and no less, upon the sale of the property. The broker retains all money over the seller’s net figure as compensation. The seller names his number and the broker keeps the spread.

Net listing agreements are illegal in New York State. That is the rule and there is no version of the arrangement that survives it.

The reason is the incentive it creates. Net listings could lead to charges of fraud by a seller who did not understand the listing terms, or who feels misled by a licensee who suggested a listing price well below market value. Suggest a low net, sell at market, keep the difference. Such action could also be a breach of the agent’s duty of loyalty to his client.

Hypothetical. A seller owns a house worth $520,000 and does not know it. The broker proposes a net listing at $470,000. The house sells in nine days for $515,000 and the broker keeps $45,000. Nothing about that is a commission the seller agreed to in any informed way, and that is precisely why New York removed the option.

Referral fees, sometimes called finder’s fees, are a different thing and they are legal. A referral fee is paid from one broker to another broker for directing a buyer or a seller to a real estate agent in that brokerage.

The limits on referral fees are narrow and worth memorizing. Brokers may not pay a referral fee to an unlicensed person. They may pay a referral fee to another broker who is duly licensed in their own state, or who holds an equivalent real estate license in another state or country. Broker to broker, and the receiving broker must be licensed somewhere.

Two more conditions. Referral fees may only be paid where there is reasonable cause for the payment, meaning an actual introduction of a client has been made. And the person being referred must provide informed consent. Referral fees are legal in New York, paid only to the broker, and only with that consent.

CAUTION: A hundred dollars to a friend who sent you a seller is a referral fee paid to an unlicensed person. The size of the payment is not the issue and calling it a gift does not change what it is.

Franchise fees come out of the same pool. Brokerages associated with a franchise company are required to deduct the franchise fee from the brokerage’s earned commission before any of the proceeds are distributed to individual agents. It is taken off the top.

When you interview brokers, ask what the franchise fee is. Get the number documented in your employment agreement so there are no misunderstandings later. Chapter 1 put that question on your interview list for this reason.

Put the franchise fee together with the split on the last screen and you can read any commission statement you are ever handed. The gross commission arrives at the listing broker. The cooperating broker’s share leaves. The franchise fee comes off the brokerage’s share. What remains is what your split applies to, and the difference between the number you were quoted at the interview and the number on the check usually lives in those two deductions.

Net listings are illegal in New York

REMEMBER: Somebody offers to send you three sellers a year for a cut. What do you need to know about that person before you can say yes at all?

How Agency Ends

Six exits, one you cannot revoke, one duty that survives

An agent’s authority to act on behalf of the client ends when the agency ends. Six circumstances end it, and the exam wants you to be able to sort a fact pattern into the right one.

Completion or accomplishment of purpose. The reason for the agency relationship ends, so the relationship ends with it. The house sold. The buyer bought. This is the most common ending of all and the one nobody argues about.

Expiration of the terms. Where an agency agreement is for a limited term, either a period of time or a set expiration date, the agency automatically ends when the term expires. Most commonly the expiration date is established by a listing agreement or a buyer-broker agreement.

Operation of law. An agency relationship ends automatically, as a matter of law, if certain events occur. Either party dies or becomes incapacitated. Either party goes bankrupt. The subject property of the agency is destroyed or condemned. The broker’s real estate license is revoked. Nobody has to do anything for these; the ending happens on its own.

Mutual agreement. Agency is consensual, which means it rests on the consent of both parties. If both the principal and the agent want to end it, they can agree to terminate at any point. When an agency is terminated by mutual consent, neither party is liable to the other for breach of contract. It is the best and most correct way to end an agency early.

Renunciation. When something granted is later given up or rejected, it has been renounced. The agent is the one who walks. If the agreement is open-ended, with no specific termination date, a party may renounce at any time with no obligation. If there is an end date, as in a listing agreement, the renunciation may be a breach of contract, making the agent liable to the principal for damages.

Revocation. The withdrawal of something granted or offered is a revocation. The principal is firing the agent. Principals may revoke agency power at any time, though they may incur liability for doing it. For open-ended agreements, a principal has to reimburse the agent only for expenses incurred. For agreements with ending dates, a principal may be liable to the agent for damages for breach of contract.

Renunciation is the agent leaving. Revocation is the principal firing the agent. Two words, two directions, and the exam will use both in the same question. Both of them are voluntary acts by a person, which is what separates them from the three endings that happen on their own.

There is one agency a principal does not have the right to revoke. An agency coupled with an interest means the agent has a financial or security interest in the property that is the subject of the agency. If a listing agreement provides that the real estate broker will invest money to improve the property, the seller cannot revoke the broker’s agency.

A second picture of the same idea. One co-owner authorizes the other co-owner to sell the property. The agent there owns a piece of the thing being sold, so the authority he was given is more than a favor the principal can withdraw at will.

An agency coupled with an interest is also not terminated by the death, the incompetency or the bankruptcy of the principal. Three of the operation-of-law endings simply do not reach it. The agent has money in the ground and the law protects that.

Ending the agency does not always end the money question. Chapter 3 covers the broker protection clause, which can entitle a broker to a commission after a listing has expired in defined circumstances. Note it here so you do not read expiration as the end of every obligation in the agreement.

One duty survives all six endings. Even when the agency relationship ends, it is necessary to maintain the confidentiality of all information received during the relationship. Every other duty stops at the exit. Confidentiality keeps going.

NOTE: Sort the six by who acted. Nobody acted in completion, expiration and operation of law. Both parties acted in mutual agreement. The agent acted in renunciation. The principal acted in revocation. That single question answers most termination items on the exam.

Six exits; confidentiality uses none of them

REMEMBER: A seller calls and fires you three weeks into a six-month exclusive. What is that called, what may he owe you, and what do you still owe him?

Key Takeaways

Six things to carry out the door

Clients get OLD CAR. Obedience, loyalty, disclosure, confidentiality, accountability and reasonable care, owed to the principal and to nobody else. Customers get good faith, honesty and fair dealing, plus the disclosure of known material facts. Know which of the two you are talking to before you open your mouth, because every rule in this chapter branches off that one answer.

Disclose, and keep disclosing. The agency relationship itself. Material facts about the property. The property’s true value. All offers to purchase, every one of them. Any personal interest you have in the deal. Any compensation reaching you from a third party. Six categories, and the licensee who discloses all six is very hard to sue.

Get it in writing. Express agency, written, is the most airtight and preferred way to create an agency relationship, and New York courts do not easily enforce implied real estate agreements. Written consent is what makes dual agency lawful here. A written instruction is the only thing that lets you hold back an offer. Net listings are illegal in New York no matter what anyone writes.

Follow the liability. Affiliated licensees are agents of the broker and subagents of the broker’s client. Subagency extends vicarious liability to the seller for brokers he never hired. A broker’s agent owes the same fiduciary duties to the listing broker’s client and stops the liability at the engaging broker. Same duties, different person carrying the risk, and that distinction is New York’s own.

Dual agency needs informed written consent from both clients. Each of them gives up undivided loyalty to get it. Designated sales agents give each side an advocate, and the brokerage stays a dual agent the whole time. Undisclosed dual agency violates New York license and agency law, jeopardizes the commission, may unwind the deal, and can be done entirely by accident.

Confidentiality is forever. Every other fiduciary duty ends when the agency ends. This one survives completion, expiration, operation of law, mutual agreement, renunciation and revocation. Without the client’s written consent, the only thing that opens the vault is a court order, and then only to the parties named in the order.

Two chapters follow this one and they are both agency. Chapter 3 takes up the disclosure form required by section 443 of the Real Property Law, the listing agreements and the buyer-broker agreements. Chapter 4 takes up the other disclosures New York requires and the antitrust rules that govern how brokers may and may not talk to each other about money.

Four pairs of words to keep straight before you go. Client and customer, which decide what you owe. Renunciation and revocation, which decide who walked away. Subagent and broker’s agent, which decide who carries the risk. Puffing and misrepresentation, which decide whether a sentence was safe to say. The exam lives in those four pairs.

And one habit that covers most of the chapter. Write down who you represent, tell the person in front of you who you represent, and do it before the conversation turns into advice. Almost every disaster in this chapter started with somebody who never said it out loud.

The next screen is a story with twelve things wrong in it and one thing that only looks wrong. Work it before you take the quiz.

NOTE: If you remember one sentence from this chapter, make it this one. The duties you owe depend entirely on who your principal is, and the time to settle that question is before the conversation, not after it.

Know who you work for, then act like it

REMEMBER: Six takeaways. Close the screen and say them back in your own words. The ones you cannot say are the screens to reread before the quiz.

You Be the Judge

The Maplewood Mess, twelve violations and one legal distractor

Rita of Homestead Realty lists Sal's Maplewood colonial for $500,000. Sal tells her, over coffee, nothing in writing, “don't even show me offers under $480K.” A week later Rita quietly tosses a $450K offer in the drawer.

At an open house she tells a buyer, “Best view in the county! And between us, Sal's divorce is getting ugly, he'll take way less.” She adds that the basement is “bone dry,” though she's seen the paneling that covers the cracked foundation. “I'm on your side,” she tells the buyer, who is a customer. “I'll get you a great deal.”

Rita's cousin offers $455K through an LLC; Rita urges Sal to grab it without mentioning the family tie. She shows the house to her own buyer client without checking whether anyone consented to dual agency, deposits that buyer's earnest money in her personal checking account “just for the weekend,” and accepts a $2,000 “marketing thank-you” from a mortgage lender she steers buyers to, telling no one.

When the listing expires, Rita suggests relisting as a net listing: “You take $470K, I keep the rest.” She also mails her unlicensed gym buddy $500 for sending her a new seller, and uses what she learned about Sal's finances to squeeze him in a deal on his next house.

Twelve violations are buried in that story. One act in it is perfectly legal and is there to catch you. Read it again and list what you find before you read on.

Work it the way a hearing officer would. Take each thing Rita did, name the person she owed something to, and name the duty or the rule that says so. Client or customer first, then the duty. The order matters, because half of what she did is only a violation once you have established that Sal was her client.

Here is the walkthrough.

One. Rita withheld the $450,000 offer. The duty of disclosure requires the agent to present all offers to the principal, and the principal decides what is acceptable. The only escape is an explicit written instruction not to present offers below a stated amount. Sal’s instruction was given over coffee with nothing in writing, so the escape does not apply.

Two. She told a buyer that Sal is divorcing and will take far less. Why the seller is selling and the fact that he will accept less than the listing price are the two textbook examples of confidential information. Releasing either one requires the principal’s written authorization. She also handed away her own client’s negotiating position, which is a breach of loyalty in the same breath.

Three. She said the basement was bone dry knowing that paneling covers a cracked foundation. Structural damage is a material fact. Honesty requires disclosing material facts to a customer in a timely manner, and a deliberate statement to the contrary, made to induce someone to act, is where misrepresentation turns into actual fraud.

Four. She told a customer “I’m on your side” and promised to get him a great deal. That is one of the phrases a licensee should be cautious of using when no relationship exists or is intended. It misstates who she works for, and it is the kind of conduct from which an implied agency gets argued later.

Five. Her cousin’s offer came in through an LLC and Rita never mentioned the family tie. Licensees must disclose in writing, to clients and third parties alike, any interest they may have in a property. Failure to do that could be considered illegal self-dealing, and this is the textbook’s own scenario with the names changed.

Six. She urged Sal to grab that offer. An agent must put the principal’s interests above everyone’s, including her own, and must never take advantage of her position to profit at the principal’s expense. Recommending the family offer over a better one is a breach of loyalty independent of the failure to disclose it.

Seven. She showed the house to her own buyer client without checking whether anyone had consented to dual agency. Undisclosed dual agency occurs when both principals are represented by the same broker without full disclosure to and approval from both. It can happen unintentionally, and that is exactly how it happened here.

Eight. She put the buyer’s earnest money in her personal checking account for the weekend. Money received in an agency relationship is received on behalf of the principal and belongs in a separate trust account. Mixing it with personal or brokerage funds is commingling, and commingling can cost a license.

Nine. She accepted $2,000 from a mortgage lender she steers buyers to and told nobody. Compensation from anyone other than the client must be disclosed to the principal. Undisclosed, it is a secret profit: a benefit taken from the transaction without authorization and without telling the principal it was kept.

Ten. She proposed relisting as a net listing at $470,000 with everything above it hers. Net listing agreements are illegal in New York State, because they invite exactly this. Suggest a below-market net, sell at market, keep the spread.

Eleven. She mailed her unlicensed gym buddy $500 for sending her a seller. Brokers may not pay a referral fee to an unlicensed person. Referral fees run broker to broker, to a broker duly licensed here or holding an equivalent license elsewhere, and only with reasonable cause and the referred person’s informed consent.

Twelve. She used what she learned about Sal’s finances against him in a later deal. Confidential information learned during an agency may not be used later against the principal, even after the relationship is terminated. The duty of confidentiality lasts forever, and without a written release from Sal only a court order opens it.

And the distractor. “Best view in the county” is puffing. It is an extravagant, non-factual opinion that no reasonable person would rely on when deciding to buy property, and it generally does not fall under fraud at all. Everything around that sentence was a violation. That sentence was not.

Notice where the twelve cluster. Four of them are failures to disclose something to somebody. Two are confidences that left the room. Two are money in the wrong hands or the wrong account. Two are relationships Rita never settled before she spoke. One is loyalty steered toward her own family. One is an arrangement New York does not permit at all.

Notice also how few of them needed a bad motive. Rita probably thought the $450,000 offer would waste Sal’s time. She probably thought the weekend in her own account was harmless because she meant to move it Monday. She probably thought the cousin’s offer was a fine offer. Intention does not appear anywhere in the rules she broke.

Two of her acts would also have been avoided by paperwork she could have had on file before any of this started. A written instruction from Sal about minimum offers would have made item one lawful. Written consents to dual agency from both clients, taken at the listing and at the buyer-broker agreement, would have made item seven lawful. Chapter 3 is about getting those signatures at the right moment.

NOTE: Count how many of the twelve Rita could have avoided by saying one true sentence at the right moment. About half of them. The expensive part of this chapter is almost never the thing you did. It is the thing you did not say.

Twelve violations, one harmless opinion

REMEMBER: Pick the three you missed on your first read. Go back to the screens that teach them before you take the quiz.

Check yourself

11 questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see whether it is right and why.

Key terms

Fiduciary
A relationship of trust and confidence in which the agent must act in the principal's best interest; the source of the six OLD CAR duties.
Principal
The client who hires an agent to represent them in dealings with third parties and to whom fiduciary duties are owed.
Customer
A third party in the transaction who is owed honesty and fair dealing but not fiduciary loyalty.
Commingling
Mixing client funds (deposits, escrow) with the broker's or licensee's own funds; a breach of accountability and grounds for license discipline.
Puffing
Exaggerated, non-factual sales opinion on which no reasonable person relies; distinguished from misrepresentation and fraud.
Subagent
A cooperating broker who accepts the listing broker's offer of subagency and owes the seller full fiduciary duties, making the seller vicariously liable for the subagent.
Broker's agent
A cooperating broker engaged by the listing (or buyer's) broker, not by the client; the client has no vicarious liability for a broker's agent.
Dual agency
One broker representing both buyer and seller in the same transaction; legal in New York only with the informed written consent of both.
Designated sales agent
In an in-house dual agency, the salesperson the broker appoints to advocate for one client while the brokerage remains a dual agent.
Net listing
A listing in which the broker keeps any sale proceeds above a stipulated net to the seller; illegal in New York.
Agency coupled with an interest
An agency in which the agent holds a financial interest in the property; the principal cannot revoke it and it survives death or bankruptcy.
Ready, willing and able buyer
The traditional point at which a commission is earned: a buyer prepared to buy on the seller's terms with the financial ability to close.

Practise this chapter

Flashcards (free) Practice exam

Read Chapter 2 in the Book

The Book comes with the Salesperson pass ($39 for 3 months).

A study course, in beta. This is not a New York State Department of State approved qualifying course, and the time you spend here does not count toward the 77 hours you need for a salesperson license. Take the 77-hour course at a DOS-approved school; use this to learn the material and to review it. · Powered by License to Earn LLC