Lesson 1
Part 1: Four Employment Classifications
IRC §3508(a)(b), where do you fit?
Four Employment Classifications
IRC §3508(a)(b), where do you fit?
The Internal Revenue Code sorts every working person into one of four boxes. The box you land in decides who withholds your taxes and who controls your working day. Section 3508 draws the lines.
An independent contractor works without direct supervision and controls the means and the methods of finishing the task. An employee works for someone who dictates the result and also dictates how the result is reached. A statutory employee is an independent contractor whom the statute treats as an employee for Social Security and Medicare taxes only, and for nothing else. A statutory non-employee is a worker the statute writes into non-employee status by name.
Real estate licensees are statutory non-employees. That is why this course opens here and not somewhere more interesting.
The consequence reaches your first commission check. Nobody hands you a W-2. Nobody withholds a dollar. The check that arrives is the gross figure, and the tax on it is money you are holding for somebody else.
Hypothetical. Two people sell houses out of the same office. One is paid a salary and told to be at her desk from nine to five. The other is paid only when a deal closes and sets her own hours around her clients. The first is an employee whatever the office calls her. The second is where the statute expects a licensee to be.
NOTE: The exam separates the four classifications with two questions and only two: who directs the work, and who remits the payroll taxes. Run any fact pattern through those two questions and the box falls out.
Licensees are statutory non-employees
REMEMBER: What are the two questions that sort a worker into one of the four boxes, and how do you answer them for yourself?
Three Conditions for Statutory Non-Employee Status
IRC §3508(a)(b), ALL three must be met
Statutory non-employee status is not automatic and it is not permanent. Section 3508 sets three conditions and all three have to be true at the same time.
First, the individual holds a real estate license. Second, substantially all pay for the work is tied to sales or output rather than to the number of hours worked. Third, the work is performed under a written contract stating that the licensee will not be treated as an employee for federal tax purposes.
The written contract is the condition that gets lost. It has to exist, it has to be signed by both parties without duress or undue influence from either side, and it has to be reviewed every twelve to fifteen months so that it still describes the office you actually work in.
Hypothetical. A broker pays a new salesperson five hundred dollars a week for her first three months so she can cover rent while she builds a pipeline, and none of it is tied to a closing. That is pay for time, not pay for output. The second condition fails and the classification fails with it.
Miss any one of the three and the licensee may be reclassified as an employee.
CAUTION: The review is part of the rule, not housekeeping. A contract signed once and left in a drawer stops describing the relationship it was written for.
License, output pay, written contract
REMEMBER: Your own independent contractor agreement, when was it last reviewed, and does it still describe how you actually get paid?
Tax Treatment
Same work, very different paychecks
The same work produces two very different paychecks depending on which box you are in. This is where the last two screens stop being theory.
As an independent contractor you receive a 1099-MISC from the broker when you are paid $600 or more in the year. No federal tax is withheld. No state tax is withheld. No Social Security and no Medicare are withheld. There is no workers' compensation and no disability coverage. You pay self-employment tax yourself, and you may file Schedule C to deduct the expenses of doing business.
As an employee you receive a W-2. Federal and state taxes come out of every check. Social Security and Medicare come out of every check, and the employer pays half of the FICA bill. Workers' compensation and disability cover you. You cannot file Schedule C for that work.
The employer's half of FICA is the line new agents never think about. As a contractor there is no employer half, because there is no employer paying it for you.
Hypothetical. Two licensees are credited with the same gross commission over the same year. The employee's tax was taken out of each check as it was paid. The contractor received the whole amount as it was paid and still owes the tax on it in April. Same production, very different April.
NOTE: A question that lists "the broker pays half of your FICA" among the conditions for contractor status is testing whether you can tell a feature of employment from a condition of the statute. The employer half belongs in the W-2 column and nowhere else.
Nothing is withheld; the tax is yours
REMEMBER: Which of the two columns describes your own arrangement, and who is holding the tax money between now and the day it is due?
Independent Contractor, New York Law
NYCRR §175.21 & §175.23
Federal tax law says what a statutory non-employee is. New York law says what your broker still owes you and what your broker has to keep.
Section 201(6) of the New York Workers' Compensation Law sets out the characteristics of the broker and independent contractor relationship: substantially all compensation paid for output rather than for hours, and a written contract executed by both parties without duress or undue influence.
19 NYCRR §175.21 is the supervision rule. A broker's supervision of a salesperson consists of regular, frequent and consistent personal guidance, instruction, oversight and superintendence over the brokerage business the broker conducts.
Read those two together. The broker must supervise you. The broker must not control you the way an employer controls an employee. Supervision is guidance and oversight. Control is dictating the means and the methods. The line between them is the line your classification sits on.
19 NYCRR §175.23 is the records rule. A licensed broker keeps records of every one- to four-family sale or mortgage transaction for three years: names and addresses of the parties, the price, the deposit, the commissions, and the disposition of every payment made. The Department of State may ask to see them.
CAUTION: The three-year clock and the supervision standard are the broker's obligations, not yours. They are on your exam anyway, because your license lives inside your broker's compliance.
Supervision is required; control is not
REMEMBER: Say the difference between a broker supervising you and a broker controlling you, in one sentence, out loud. If you cannot, read §175.21 again before you move on.
35 hours per week
× 50 weeks per year, the service a salesperson must show to qualify for a broker license
Selecting an Employing Broker
You're interviewing them, too, ask the right questions
Before you practice real estate you have to choose a broker to hold your license. It is the first real business decision of your career, and it is made in an interview where you are the one being charmed.
You are interviewing the broker as much as the broker is interviewing you. Walk in with the questions written down.
Local firm or franchise
Branch offices
Sales, leasing, residential
Commission split and fee schedule
How leads are generated and shared
Duties assigned to agents
MLS membership
Start-up and training fees
Expectations in the first year
Formal training and goal support
Office policy manual
Four of those decide your income. The commission split and the fee schedule tell you what you keep. Lead generation tells you whether you are joining a business or building one from nothing inside somebody else's office. Start-up and training fees tell you what the first months cost before a single closing. Expectations tell you how long you have before the conversation about production changes.
The rest decide whether you learn anything. A written policy manual, real training and a broker who will sit down with you are worth more in your first year than a better split.
A large firm brings image, prestige and contacts. A small firm brings a niche and closer service. Only you can decide which one fits the business you intend to build.
Hypothetical. Two offers on your desk. A sixty-forty split with a desk fee, a written policy manual, and a broker who reads every contract with you for your first year. An eighty-twenty split with no fees, no manual, and a broker you will see at the holiday party. The second pays more on every deal you close. How many will you close in year one? You do not know that number yet, and that is exactly why the questions matter more than the split.
CAUTION: The independent contractor agreement is part of this interview, not paperwork you sign afterward. Ask to read it before you commit to anything.
Interview the broker before you sign
REMEMBER: If you walked into an interview tomorrow, which three of those questions would you ask first, and what answer would make you walk out?
Real Estate License Law
The foundation of your career
That settles the tax side of your license. You are a statutory non-employee. You are supervised but not controlled. Nobody is withholding anything on your behalf.
The rest of this chapter is about the license itself. Who issues it. Who is allowed to hold one. What it permits you to do, what it forbids, and how you lose it.
Every rule that follows exists for one reason: to protect the public from dishonest dealings with brokers or salespersons. When a rule looks fussy, ask which member of the public it protects. The answer is usually obvious, and it is usually the exam answer.
The license exists to protect the public
REMEMBER: You are about to meet three agencies, three license categories and six classes of broker license. Before you read on, which one do you already know you will hold?
Lesson 2
Part 2: Department of State (DOS)
Who regulates real estate in New York
Department of State (DOS)
Who regulates real estate in New York
Three bodies share the regulation of real estate in New York. The exam expects you to know which one does what, and the three are easy to confuse because they sit inside one another.
The Department of State is the agency. Its chief executive is the Secretary of State, who administers the licensing, examination, education and compliance provisions of Article 12-A of the Real Property Law, the rules of the Board, and the rules of the Secretary of State.
The Division of Licensing Services sits inside the Department of State and does the work. It licenses, registers or regulates thirty-two occupations. Real estate brokers and salespersons are among them, alongside apartment information vendors, apartment sharing agents, real estate appraisers, notaries public and home inspectors. Its stated mission is to protect the health, safety and welfare of consumers.
The New York State Board of Real Estate was created by Article 12-A itself. The Board advises and assists the Secretary of State, and, except where a matter is delegated to the Secretary, the Board has general power to promulgate rules and regulations affecting brokers and salespersons. The Board advises and writes rules. The Board does not issue your license.
When the Board or the Secretary writes a rule, the rule lands in the New York Codes, Rules and Regulations. The real estate rules are in Title 19, Chapter 5, Subchapter D. That is where §175.21, §175.23 and §175.25 live, and it is why they are cited the way they are.
NOTE: Article 12-A is the statute. Title 19 of the NYCRR is the regulation. The Legislature wrote the first. The Department of State wrote the second. A question that asks where a rule comes from is asking you to tell those two apart.
The Board also has authority over unlicensed people who perform activities that would otherwise require a license. Being unlicensed does not put you outside the reach of the license law. It puts you inside it without the protection of a license.
DOS licenses; the Board writes rules
REMEMBER: Which of the three issues your license, which one advises the Secretary, and is Article 12-A an agency or a statute?
Three License Categories
Every NY licensee holds one of these
New York issues three categories of real estate license. Every licensee in the state holds exactly one of them.
A real estate broker is any person, firm, limited liability company or corporation who, for another and for a fee, commission or other valuable consideration, lists for sale, sells, exchanges, buys or rents real estate, offers or attempts to negotiate any of those, or collects rent for the use of real estate. Brokers supervise and are responsible for the associate brokers and salespersons they sponsor.
An associate real estate broker is a licensed broker who chooses to work under the name and supervision of another broker. The supervising broker signs the association statement. The associate broker keeps the right to hold a separate broker's license, registered as an individual, a partnership, a trade name, an LLC or a corporation.
A real estate salesperson performs the acts of a broker, but only while associated with and sponsored by a licensed broker. A salesperson may never work independently in any capacity. Not for rentals. Not after two good years. Not for a broker who simply agrees to pay a commission.
Associate brokers and salespersons do much the same work day to day. Each must identify themselves by the license they actually hold.
An associate broker may be designated as an office manager under the name and supervision of another broker, and must have been active as a licensed associate broker for at least two of the four years before the appointment. A salesperson cannot manage an office.
CAUTION: The sponsorship requirement is the most heavily tested idea in this chapter. Every version of the question "when may a salesperson act alone" has the same answer. Never.
A salesperson never works alone
REMEMBER: Say the difference between an associate broker and a salesperson in one sentence. Then say the one thing an associate broker may do that a salesperson may not.
Six Classes of Broker License
Each class has its own DOS code
Broker is one category, but the Department of State issues it in six classes, each with its own code. The class describes the shape of the business, not the level of skill.
Class 35, individual broker. The broker conducts business under their own name. This class permits no association with a firm or company.
Class 30, associate broker. The broker works under the name and supervision of another licensed broker.
Class 37, trade name broker. A sole proprietorship doing business under a business name rather than a personal name.
Class 32, partnership broker. Two or more brokers conduct business under a partnership name. Each individual must be a licensed broker and each must submit an application.
Class 31, corporate broker. The brokerage does business under the name of a corporation. The broker must be an officer of that corporation, and must have been an officer before licensing. Corporate officers cannot be licensed as salespersons or associate brokers within the corporation. They must be licensed as brokers.
Class 49, LLC or LLP. A member or manager who completes the requirements for broker licensure conducts the brokerage under the LLC or LLP name.
NOTE: Class 31 carries the trap this screen is really about. An officer of a corporate brokerage cannot hold a salesperson's license inside that same corporation, and the officer status has to come before the licensing, not after it.
The class describes the business
REMEMBER: You will choose a class the day you apply for a broker's license. Which one fits the business you intend to run, and what does that class stop you from doing?
General Licensing Qualifications
Salesperson vs. broker, what it takes
Two sets of requirements, one for the salesperson and one for the broker. The differences are numbers, and the exam likes numbers.
For a salesperson: at least 18 years of age. 77 hours of approved coursework. Pass the New York licensing exam. A $65 fee for each two-year term. Compliance with the child support obligations set out in General Obligations Law §3-503. And no disqualifying conviction.
For a broker: at least 20 years of age. 152 hours of coursework, the 77 salesperson hours plus 75 broker hours. Pass the broker exam. Two years as a licensed salesperson, or three years of qualifying experience. 3,500 experience points, or 5,250 where the claim rests on equivalent experience. A $185 fee for each two-year term.
U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident.
The conviction bar is narrower than people assume. No person is entitled to a broker or salesperson license who has been convicted, in New York or any other state, of a felony, or of a felony or misdemeanor sex offense or sexually violent offense, unless that person has received an executive pardon, a certificate of relief from disabilities, or a certificate of good conduct from a parole board removing the disability.
The salesperson application asks for your name and residence address, the name and business address of the broker you will associate with, that broker's statement of association and signature, your acknowledgment regarding child support, proof you attended and completed an approved program of at least 77 hours, and proof you passed the written salesperson's examination.
CAUTION: The sponsoring broker's signature is part of the application. You secure the broker before you file, not after. That is why the screen on choosing a broker came before this one.
18 and 77 hours; 20 and 152 hours
REMEMBER: Age, hours, fee, term. Say the four numbers for a salesperson, then the four for a broker, without looking back.
The NY Licensure Examination
What to expect on test day
Everything to do with the exam runs through eAccessNY, the state's licensing management system. You register there first, and registration takes a few minutes.
Once registered you can schedule a broker or salesperson examination at an exam center, pay the $15 examination fee by credit card, see your results, and manage renewals from the same account. You must make an appointment. Walk-ins are not permitted. Exam sites are listed on the Department of State website.
All applicants are fingerprinted at the test site prior to taking the exam.
Bring a silent calculator and a government-issued photo ID. Acceptable forms are a driver's license, a certificate of U.S. citizenship, a United States INS-issued ID, a United States passport, or a state-issued ID.
The salesperson exam is multiple choice and is drawn from the 77-hour prelicensing curriculum. A passing score is 70 percent. Results are reported only as pass or fail and are posted to your eAccessNY account. No dictionaries are permitted, because Article 12-A requires a fair knowledge of the English language.
Fail it and you may take it again as many times as you need, paying the $15 fee each time. A passing result does not expire the day you get it, but it does not wait forever either, so apply for the license while the result is current.
If you need testing modifications, do not schedule the exam online. The Department of State handles accessibility information and testing modifications by telephone at 518-473-2731.
NOTE: You must complete the 77 hours before you apply for the license. You do not have to complete them before you take the exam. The questions come from the course either way, so taking it early is a decision about confidence, not about eligibility.
Appointment, $15, 70 percent, pass/fail
REMEMBER: Everything on this screen happens before you are licensed. Which step are you on today, and which one could you finish this week?
What Requires a License
Acting for another, for compensation, in any of these is illegal without one
Article 12-A draws the line with three elements, and all three have to be present at once. You act for another. You act for compensation. And the act is one the statute lists. Remove any one of the three and no license is required.
The listed acts are these. Offering or listing real estate for sale. Buying or offering to buy real estate. Offering or selling any real property. Renting or leasing. Selling or purchasing real estate at auction. Performing any business regarding condominium and cooperative property. Selling a business where the real estate transferred is greater than the business itself. And showing or discussing any real property with anyone.
The last one catches people. Showing a property is a licensed act. Discussing a property with a prospect is a licensed act. Neither becomes clerical work because the person doing it is called an assistant.
Hypothetical. A neighbor asks you to find a tenant for her two-family house and offers you a month's rent for the trouble. You are acting for another. You are acting for compensation. Renting is on the list. All three elements are present and you need a license.
Change one fact. The two-family house is yours. You are dealing with your own property, you are not acting for another, and no license is required. Change it again. You find the tenant for your neighbor as a favor and take nothing at all. The compensation element is gone and the license requirement goes with it.
CAUTION: Performing these acts for another, for compensation, without a license is a misdemeanor under Article 12-A. It is not a paperwork problem and it is not a fine you absorb as a cost of doing business.
For another, for compensation, listed act
REMEMBER: Run the three elements against the last favor you did for a friend involving an apartment. Did all three line up?
Lesson 3
Part 3: Licensing Exemptions
Persons who do NOT need a real estate license
Licensing Exemptions
Persons who do NOT need a real estate license
Six groups may act in real estate in New York without a license. Learn them as a list, because the exam tests them as a list, and because the exemption usually turns on one narrow fact rather than on who the person is.
Attorneys admitted to practice in New York. The exemption is broad but it has a limit worth knowing now. An attorney who establishes a brokerage and hires real estate salespersons must obtain a broker's license. What the attorney does not have to do is take the prelicensing courses or take the New York licensing exam, and the attorney is exempt from the license renewal requirements.
Building supervisors and maintenance workers. The exemption covers people hired as employees of an owner, not independent contractors, who perform tasks on the owner's behalf such as collecting rent or showing apartments. Employee status is the whole exemption. Change that one fact and the exemption disappears.
Persons acting under the judgment or order of a court. Administrators, executors, guardians and trustees in bankruptcy. The court order is the authority; the license law steps aside for it.
Property owners. A person dealing with their own property may engage in a real estate transaction without a license. This is the element from the last screen, restated as an exemption: an owner is not acting for another.
Public officers acting in their official capacity.
Tenants' associations and nonprofit corporations. Residential neighborhood and rural preservation companies authorized by the commissioner of the New York Department of Housing and Community Renewal, or by the New York City Housing Authority, to manage residential property owned or managed by the state or the city. New York City adds its own exemption for tenant associations and nonprofit corporations that enforce housing maintenance codes on City-owned or City-managed residential property.
NOTE: Read every exemption question twice. The facts will usually change one word, employee to contractor, own property to a friend's property, under court order to on behalf of the family, and that one word is the answer.
Six exemptions, each on one narrow fact
REMEMBER: An attorney hires two salespersons for her new brokerage. Which part of the exemption still protects her, and which part has just stopped?
Continuing Education
Required every two-year renewal cycle
To renew, a licensee completes 22.5 hours of approved continuing education in the two years before renewal. The total is the number people remember. The breakdown inside it is the number the exam asks about.
Within those 22.5 hours the coursework must provide at least three hours on fair housing or discrimination in the sale or rental of real property, two hours of cultural competency, two hours of implicit bias, one hour of recent legal matters, and one hour of agency law, two hours of agency at a licensee's first renewal.
That accounts for nine of the 22.5 hours, or ten at a first renewal. The rest is yours to choose from approved coursework.
Attorneys admitted to the New York State bar who hold a real estate license are exempt from continuing education. The attorney who hires salespersons still needs the broker's license.
CAUTION: Failing to complete continuing education in the time allowed is itself a ground for suspension or revocation. It sits on the same list as fraud and commingling, and the volume of business you did is irrelevant. The requirement attaches to the license, not to your production.
22.5 hours, nine of them mandated
REMEMBER: Name the five mandated subjects and their hours. If you can only name the total, you have learned the easy half.
Keeping Your License Current
Everything runs through eAccessNY
A license is not a certificate you frame. It is a set of continuing obligations, and the Department of State does not accept excuses for missing one.
The license and pocket card are prepared and issued by the Department of State in cooperation with the Department of Motor Vehicles. The pocket card carries a photo, your name and your business address, and for a salesperson the name and address of the affiliated broker. Carry it at all times and produce it on demand. A licensee who cannot produce the pocket card when asked is in violation of the license law and is subject to reprimand and even suspension. A lost or destroyed card is replaced for $10.
The broker's license must be displayed at all times. A salesperson's license does not have to be displayed, but it must be kept somewhere safe and accessible.
Renewal comes every two years and runs online. About three months ahead the Department of State sends the renewal notice to the sponsoring broker, and the license can be renewed from that point until it expires. Submitting online is not the same as being approved; the Department reviews the application for completeness and qualification.
Miss the expiration date and a two-year grace period opens. You may renew during it. You may not practice real estate during it. Let the grace period lapse and you retake and pass the exam and complete the continuing education before you are licensed again.
A broker who relocates a principal or branch office notifies the Department of State within five days of the new business address, for the broker and for every licensee working under that broker. The filing is done through eAccessNY and costs $10 for each license associated with that address. A broker who fails to notify the Department of a change of address risks suspension.
A branch office is any physical location other than the main office kept for business use and for meeting clients or customers on a regular basis. A broker may maintain any number of branch offices in New York, and every one of them needs its own branch office license at $185. A branch may be supervised by the licensed broker, by a representative broker of the corporation or partnership, by the manager of an LLC, or by a duly appointed office manager.
When a salesperson leaves a broker, the broker files a termination of association online. There is no fee for the termination. The new sponsoring broker then files the change of association, which costs $20. Approval is not automatic; if approved, a new license is mailed to the new business address.
Dual licensure is holding more than one license at a time, a broker who also wants to be an associate broker at another firm, or a salesperson who wants to work with more than one broker. It is permitted. Each licensee who is dual licensed must obtain a statement from each sponsoring broker acknowledging the other licensure.
The broker pays $185 for each two-year term and the salesperson $65.
CAUTION: Three of the obligations on this screen run on a clock: five days for a change of address, two years for renewal, two more years of grace. Two of those clocks end your career if you sleep through them.
Carry the card; watch the clocks
REMEMBER: If you moved office tomorrow, who files, within how many days, and what does it cost per license?
Reciprocity
License recognition across state lines
Reciprocity is an agreement between states to accept each other's licensees, by recognizing the out-of-state course credits or license level rather than making the licensee start over.
New York's reciprocity list: Arkansas, Colorado, Connecticut, Georgia, Massachusetts, Mississippi, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania and West Virginia.
The agreements are not identical and the differences are tested. Arkansas and Massachusetts are broker only, and require two years of licensure, current, with business and residence in that state. Oklahoma covers broker and sales but also requires two years. Connecticut, Pennsylvania and West Virginia require current licensure only. Georgia and Mississippi require current licensure and that the license was obtained by passing that state's own exam. Colorado covers brokers and associate brokers, and a Colorado associate broker submits a salesperson application with a $50 fee alongside the certification and consent form.
Every applicant needs the same four things: a current certification from the real estate commission that issued the license, dated within six months; a completed application; a signed irrevocable consent form; and the fee.
The irrevocable consent form is the one that matters. Signing it subjects the out-of-state licensee to the jurisdiction of the courts of the State of New York. That is the trade. New York recognizes your license, and in exchange New York can reach you.
An out-of-state licensee is not required to keep an office in New York. A reciprocal salesperson must be sponsored by the home-state broker, and that broker must hold a current New York broker's license. An applicant for a corporate broker's license files as a foreign corporation with the New York State Corporations Bureau.
NOTE: The sponsorship rule closes the loop back to the three license categories. A salesperson never acts alone, and crossing a state line does not change that.
Certification, application, consent, fee
REMEMBER: A Pennsylvania salesperson wants to show a Brooklyn listing. Name the two things that must be true before she can.
Other Real Estate–Related Licenses
None require a broker or salesperson license, watch for conflicts of interest
Five other kinds of license touch real estate in New York. None of them requires a broker's or salesperson's license, and none of them is a substitute for one. They are on the exam because you will work beside these people, and because holding two of them at once creates a conflict of interest you have to manage rather than ignore.
An apartment information vendor furnishes information about the location and availability of residential property. The license fee is $400 per year.
An apartment sharing agent arranges and coordinates meetings between owners who want to share their housing and the people who would share it. The license fee is $400 per year.
An appraiser estimates the value of real property. There are four levels: New York State appraiser assistant, licensed real estate appraiser, certified residential appraiser and certified general appraiser. The term is two years. The assistant fee is $250 per term and every other level is $300 per term.
A home inspector inspects real property, usually for the buyer. The license requires 100 hours of coursework, 40 hours of supervised field work, and a passing score on a New York State examination. The fee is $250 for a two-year term.
Mortgage banker and mortgage broker licenses are treated fully in the Mortgage Basics session.
CAUTION: The conflict is the point of this screen. A licensee who is also the home inspector, or the appraiser, or the apartment information vendor on the same transaction is standing on both sides of a number the client is relying on. Disclose it, or decline one of the two roles.
Five license types; one conflict
REMEMBER: You list a house and your brother-in-law is the home inspector the buyer hires. What do you say, and when do you say it?
Advertising Rules
19 NYCRR §175.25
Advertising means the promotion and solicitation of licensed real estate activity, and the definition is deliberately wide: mail, telephone, websites, email, electronic bulletin boards, business cards, signs, billboards and flyers. If it promotes the work, it is an advertisement and §175.25 applies to it.
Every advertisement placed by a broker must indicate that the advertiser is a broker and must give the broker's name and telephone number. An advertisement that does not is a blind ad, and blind ads are illegal in New York.
Every advertisement that says property is in the vicinity of a geographical area or territorial subdivision must name the area or subdivision the property is actually in.
A business card is an advertisement. It must carry the name and address of the brokerage as licensed by the Department of State, or of the branch office if that is where you are associated; your full name as licensed; the type of license you hold, written out as licensed real estate broker, licensed associate real estate broker or licensed real estate salesperson; and the firm's business telephone number. Anything else you add, titles, specialization, accreditations, must be true and not misleading. A home email address or cell number may appear, noted as a residence number, and not used in a way that would make your home a branch office.
Websites created by associate brokers, salespersons and teams are permitted, provided the supervising broker has authorized them and they remain under the broker's supervision while they are live. Every page of the site must carry the information required of any advertisement, and the homepage should link to the broker's or brokerage's website where one exists.
Case in Point. Broker Judy puts a sign in front of a client's home carrying only a phone number. She has not said she is a broker and she has not given the brokerage name. A passer-by reads the sign as a sale by the owner. That is a blind ad and it is illegal.
NOTE: Blind ads are tested two ways. One is the sign that hides the broker. The other is the ad built to imply for sale by owner. Both are the same violation: the public cannot tell it is dealing with a licensee.
If it promotes the work, it is an ad
REMEMBER: Look at your own business card, or the one you will print. Are all four required items on it, spelled the way your license spells them?
Lesson 4
Part 4: Unlicensed Real Estate Assistants
Useful help, as long as nothing they do requires a license
Unlicensed Real Estate Assistants
Useful help, as long as nothing they do requires a license
An unlicensed assistant can take a great deal of work off a licensee, and the work they take off is exactly the work that does not require a license. That sentence is the whole rule. Everything below is the Department of State applying it.
An assistant may answer phones and take messages, arrange appointments, write advertisements for the broker's approval, prepare flyers for open houses, compile comparative market analysis material, and assemble documents for closing.
An assistant may not discuss real estate with customers or clients, and may not show any property, for sale or for rent. Both are licensed acts under Article 12-A, and calling the person an assistant does not unlicense the act.
An assistant may be paid directly by the broker or by the salesperson. Payment may be hourly or salaried. Payment may not be based on completed transactions. An assistant compensated on the basis of closings must be licensed.
Hypothetical. Your assistant sits at an open house while you are at a closing across town, hands out the flyer he wrote and you approved, and takes names for you to call. Everything there is clerical until a visitor asks what the sellers would take, and he answers.
CAUTION: The two lines an assistant crosses most often are the same two the Department of State watches. Showing a property when you are double-booked, and being paid a bonus when a deal closes. The first is unlicensed practice. The second converts the whole arrangement into one that required a license from the start.
Clerical work, hourly pay, no showings
REMEMBER: Write down the three things you would most like an assistant to take off your desk. How many of the three are licensed acts?
Running a Brokerage: Rules to Know
Place of business, money, and what happens when a broker dies
A broker's license comes with obligations about where you work, how money moves, and what happens to the business when the broker is gone. These are broker rules. You are learning them as a salesperson because your own license depends on your broker keeping them.
Every licensed real estate broker must have and maintain a definite place of business within New York State, and must conspicuously post a sign on the outside of the building, large enough to be readable from the sidewalk, showing the name and the business of the licensed real estate broker. Where the office is in an office building, apartment building or hotel, the name and the words "licensed real estate broker" go in the space provided for posting the names of occupants, and the mail box does not count.
A broker who maintains more than one place of business applies for a supplemental license for each branch office, at the same fee as a broker's license. Each branch is under the direct supervision of the broker, a representative broker of the corporation or partnership, the manager of an LLC, or a duly appointed office manager.
A broker's principal residence does not become a place of business only because the residence telephone number appears on a business card.
No real estate salesperson may receive or demand compensation of any kind from anyone other than the licensed broker with whom the salesperson is associated, for any service rendered in appraising, buying, selling, exchanging, leasing, renting or negotiating a loan on real estate. The money reaches you through your broker or it does not reach you.
No broker may pay any part of a fee or commission to a person for help in a real estate transaction unless that person is a licensed salesperson regularly associated with the broker, a licensed broker, a person regularly engaged in the real estate brokerage business in another state, or someone exempt from the license law. That is the kickback rule, and it is written as a prohibition on the broker, not on the person receiving the money.
No person, partnership, limited liability company or corporation may bring or maintain an action in any court of this State to recover compensation for services in buying, selling, exchanging, leasing, renting or negotiating a loan on real estate, without alleging and proving that they were duly licensed on the date the cause of action arose. Earn a commission without a license and there is no court in New York that will hear you ask for it.
When a broker who was the sole proprietor of the office dies, the license may be used after death by the duly appointed administrator or executor, in the name of the estate, under authority granted by the surrogate, for not more than 120 days from the date of death, and only to complete unfinished transactions already in negotiation before the death. The license is endorsed with the word "deceased", the date of death, and the name of the administrator or executor. The 120 days may be extended once, on application to the Secretary of State for good cause, for up to another 120 days. A license expiring during that period is automatically renewed and continued, and no fee is charged.
NOTE: Three of the rules on this screen are about money and all three point the same way. Compensation flows through the broker. Fees are not shared with the unlicensed. An unlicensed claim is not enforceable. If a question puts money in a salesperson's hand from any direction other than the sponsoring broker, that is the violation.
Money flows through the broker
REMEMBER: A buyer hands you $500 in cash at the closing table and calls it a thank-you. What do you do with it, and why?
Suspension & Revocation
Acts that can cost you your license
Real Property Law §441-c is the disciplinary section. Under it the Department of State may revoke or suspend a license for such period as it deems proper, or instead impose a fine payable to the Department of State.
The grounds run long, and they fall into groups. Misstating information on the license application. Violating any provision of Article 12-A. Making a false promise to induce someone to sign a contract. Fraud or fraudulent practices. Demonstrating untrustworthiness or incompetency. Failing to complete continuing education in the time allowed.
Misrepresentation appears three ways, and the third is the one that catches honest people. Intentional misrepresentation is a false statement of a material fact. Intentional concealment is failing to disclose a material fact. Negligent misrepresentation is a false statement about a material fact the broker did not know, but should have known, to be false.
Money grounds. Commingling the money or property of a principal with the broker's own, instead of maintaining a separate special bank account used exclusively for those deposits, deposited as promptly as practicable. Paying kickbacks to unlicensed persons. Failing to remit funds held for a client. Receiving compensation from more than one party without the others' consent. A salesperson demanding or receiving compensation from anyone but the sponsoring broker.
Listing and competition grounds. Placing or removing a sign without the owner's consent. Offering property for sale or lease without the owner's consent. Interfering with a property already under exclusive listing with another broker. Net listing agreements, where the seller sets a net figure and the broker keeps the excess as commission. Exclusive listing agreements with an automatic renewal clause, which New York prohibits. Soliciting in a cease-and-desist zone. Accepting the services of another broker's licensee without that broker's knowledge.
Records and disclosure grounds. Failing to keep the three-year records on one- to four-unit sales and mortgages. Failing to provide a duplicate original of an instrument to the parties. Retaining information on termination of association instead of turning it over. Failing to provide the list of multiple listing service participants where the broker is an MLS member. Failing to advise buyers and sellers of the rights and obligations of the agency relationship. Self-dealing: a broker may not buy property listed with him, or acquire an interest in it, without first making his true position clearly known to the listing owner, and must disclose an interest before buying for a client or selling property he owns an interest in.
Practicing law without a license, and violating any discrimination law in the sale, rental or advertisement of housing or commercial space.
Untrustworthiness is the widest ground on the list and it is deliberately wide. In Matter of Gold v. Lomenzo, 29 NY2d 468, 329 NYS2d 805, 811 (1972), the Court of Appeals said the Legislature intended the Secretary of State to be vested with a wide discretion in determining what should be deemed untrustworthy conduct. Conduct unrelated to your real estate activities can still be the basis of a disciplinary proceeding.
Penalties: suspension or revocation · fine up to $1,000 · misdemeanor (up to $1,000 + 1 year jail). Appeal via Article 78 proceeding under the CPLR.
Untrustworthiness is the widest ground
REMEMBER: Pick the three grounds on this screen you could commit by accident in your first year. What habit would prevent each one?
From Complaint to Hearing
How the DOS disciplines a licensee
Anyone who believes a licensee has violated Article 12-A, or has not dealt fairly or honestly, may file a complaint with the Department of State. The Department may also start an investigation on its own.
Once a complaint is filed and found to be within the Department's jurisdiction, the Department is obliged to begin an investigation promptly. It notifies the licensee in writing and seeks a response. Where no response comes, an investigator is assigned.
Before the Department revokes, suspends or fines a licensee, it notifies the licensee in writing of the charges at least ten days before the date set for the hearing, which is held before an administrative law judge. The licensee may be heard by counsel. Where the licensee is a salesperson or associate broker, the sponsoring broker is notified of the charges as well.
The outcome is a reprimand, a fine of up to $1,000, a suspension, or a revocation. Violation of the license law is itself a misdemeanor, punishable by a fine of up to $1,000 or a year in jail.
An appeal from a Department determination is taken by an Article 78 proceeding under the Civil Practice Law and Rules. That is the route for appeals against state agencies generally, not a procedure peculiar to real estate.
Three decisions show how far untrustworthiness reaches. In Eich v. Shaffer, 136 AD2d 701, 523 NYS2d 902 (2nd Dept. 1988), a finding that the licensee had violated his duties as an insurance broker was held a sufficient basis for finding him untrustworthy as a real estate broker. In Dovale v. Patterson, 85 AD2d 601, 444 NYS2d 694 (2nd Dept. 1981), revocation was upheld where the licensee regularly submitted fraudulent contracts and loan applications to banks to obtain larger mortgages than he could otherwise get. In Fogel v. Department of State, 209 AD2d 615, 619 NYS2d 104 (2nd Dept. 1994), the Department properly denied renewal of a salesperson's license on the basis of a prior conviction for sexual misconduct.
Read those three together and the pattern is plain. None of the conduct required a real estate license to commit. All of it reached the real estate license anyway.
CAUTION: If a broker's license is suspended or revoked, every salesperson under that broker is suspended too. A salesperson in that position may change association or wait for the suspension to lift. After a revocation, the licensee waits one year before reapplying.
Ten days' notice; Article 78 on appeal
REMEMBER: Your broker is suspended on a Tuesday for something you had no part in. What is your licensing status on Wednesday, and what are your two options?
Property Condition Disclosure
Article 14, required for 1–4 unit residential sales
LAW THROUGH MARCH 19, 2024
This screen is the rule as it stood before March 20, 2024. It is here because contracts signed before that date were written under it, and because the change it was replaced by only makes sense against it. The current rule is on the next screen.
The Property Condition Disclosure Act sits in Article 14 of the Real Property Law. Except as provided in section 463, every seller of residential real property under a real estate purchase contract must complete and sign a property condition disclosure statement and deliver it, or a copy, to the buyer or the buyer's agent before the buyer signs a binding contract of sale. A copy signed by both seller and buyer is attached to the purchase contract.
Nothing in Article 14 prevents the parties from making their own agreements about the physical condition of the property, including a sale "as is".
$500
credit to the buyer at transfer of title if the seller fails to comply. Knowingly false statements expose the seller to claims.
The disclosure is not required on fourteen kinds of transfer. A transfer under a court order, including a probate transfer during administration of an estate, a writ of execution, a transfer by a trustee in bankruptcy or debtor in possession, a transfer by eminent domain, or a transfer decreed for specific performance. A deed in lieu of foreclosure or a transfer in satisfaction of the mortgage debt. A transfer to a beneficiary of a deed of trust. A foreclosure sale after default. A sale under a power of sale after default. A transfer by a mortgagee who acquired the property at such a sale or by deed in lieu. A transfer by a fiduciary administering an estate, guardianship, conservatorship or trust. A transfer from one co-owner to other co-owners. A transfer to the transferor's spouse or to lineal relatives. A transfer between spouses or former spouses under a divorce, annulment, separation or property settlement. A transfer to or from the state or a governmental entity. A transfer of newly constructed residential property never inhabited. A transfer by a sheriff. A transfer under a partition action.
If a seller later learns something that makes a disclosure statement already given materially inaccurate, the seller delivers a revised statement as soon as practicable, though never after title transfers or the buyer occupies, whichever comes first.
NOTE: The agent has duties of her own here. A listing agent must timely inform each seller she represents of the seller's obligations under Article 14. A buyer's agent, or the seller's agent dealing with an unrepresented buyer, must inform that buyer of the buyer's rights and obligations under Article 14 before the buyer signs a binding contract. An agent who performs those duties has no further duty and is not liable to any party for a violation of the article.
Deliver before the buyer signs
REMEMBER: You are the listing agent. Name the one sentence you must say to your seller, and the one you must say to an unrepresented buyer.
Property Condition Disclosure, 2024 Update
The $500 escape hatch is gone
For two decades the Act offered the seller a choice that was not really a choice. Deliver the disclosure statement, or skip it and give the buyer a $500 credit at closing. Most New York sellers took the credit and never filled out the form.
$500
credit in lieu of disclosure, the standard practice from 2002 to 2024.
REPEALED
effective March 20, 2024
The law today. Sellers of one- to four-unit residential property must complete and deliver the property condition disclosure statement before the buyer signs the contract. There is no credit alternative. Real Property Law §465 was retitled from "Remedy" to "Liability", and the form grew from 49 questions to 56, adding flood-zone, flood-insurance and flood-damage disclosures.
The retitling is the part to carry into practice. Under "Remedy" the statute told you what the buyer got when the seller did not disclose. Under "Liability" the statute tells you what the seller owes for what the seller said. The form is no longer something to be bought out of for $500; it is a signed statement a seller can be held to.
The flood questions are the new part of the form. A buyer who is told nothing about a property's flood history is the buyer those questions were written for.
CAUTION: The licensee does not complete this form. You inform the seller of the obligation, you inform the buyer of the right, and you let the seller answer the 56 questions in the seller's own words. Filling it in for a seller is not a favor. It is your signature on somebody else's knowledge.
No credit; the form is mandatory
REMEMBER: A seller tells you to mark a flood question "unknown" when you both know the basement flooded last spring. What are the two separate problems with doing it?
Lesson 5
Part 5: Unauthorized Practice of Law
Duncan & Hill Realty v. Dept. of State (1976)
Unauthorized Practice of Law
Duncan & Hill Realty v. Dept. of State (1976)
Judiciary Law §478 prohibits the practice of law by non-attorneys, to protect the public from legal advice given by people never trained, examined or licensed to give it. Section 484 adds that no natural person may receive compensation, directly or indirectly, for preparing deeds, mortgages, assignments, discharges, leases or any other instruments affecting real estate, unless admitted to practice. Violating either is a misdemeanor under §485. The Department of State treats it as grounds for discipline in its own right, separate from anything a court does.
The case that draws the line is Duncan & Hill Realty, Inc. v. Department of State, 62 A.D.2d 690, 405 N.Y.S.2d 339 (4th Dept.), appeal dismissed 45 N.Y.2d 821 (1978). A broker who was not an attorney prepared documents containing detailed mortgage terms he had devised himself. The court upheld the Department's finding of untrustworthiness and incompetence under Real Property Law §441-c.
The court drew the line where a licensee can see it. A broker may not devise the detailed terms of a purchase-money mortgage, or any legal term beyond the general description of the property, the price, and the mortgage to be assumed or given. Nor may a broker give an opinion on title, on contract terms, or on anything that would be taken as legal advice.
What you may do is fill the non-legal blanks on a form approved by a joint committee of your county's bar association and realtors association: names, dates, the closing location, a description of the property, the price. You may not develop legal terms on it.
The court also gave brokers a way to protect themselves, and it costs one sentence. Make the document subject to the approval of the respective attorneys for the parties. The Department of State adds that the contract should state plainly that it is legally binding and recommend that the parties consult their own lawyers before signing.
CAUTION: An approved form does not make you a lawyer. You may not give legal advice, may not discourage a party from consulting their attorney, may not add provisions unless the whole contract is made subject to each party's attorney's approval, may not charge a separate fee for preparing a contract, and may not share in an attorney's fee. Preparing the contract is incidental to the sale, not a service you sell.
Always recommend buyers and sellers consult an attorney. Judiciary Law §478 / §484, violation is a misdemeanor.
Fill the blanks; never write the terms
REMEMBER: A buyer asks you across the kitchen table whether the mortgage contingency clause protects her. Say out loud the sentence you would actually use.
CHAPTER 1
Key Takeaways
Statutory non-employees, Licensees are treated as independent contractors for federal tax purposes, provided the three IRC §3508 conditions are met: a license, pay tied to output rather than hours, and a written contract reviewed every twelve to fifteen months. New York adds its own layer: the broker must supervise you under §175.21 without controlling you, and must keep the §175.23 records for three years.
DOS regulates, The Department of State, through the Division of Licensing Services, issues and regulates licenses under Article 12-A of the Real Property Law. The Board of Real Estate advises the Secretary of State and promulgates rules, which land in Title 19, Chapter 5, Subchapter D of the NYCRR. The statute and the regulation are different things and the exam asks you to tell them apart.
Three categories, six broker classes, Broker, associate broker, salesperson. A salesperson may never work independently of the sponsoring broker, in any capacity, for any reason. The broker's license comes in six classes, and the class describes the shape of the business rather than the level of skill.
Three elements make an act licensed, For another, for compensation, and on the statutory list. Remove any one and no license is required. The owner exemption is the same test seen from the other side: an owner is not acting for another.
Renewal = 22.5 hrs CE, Every two years, including at least three hours of fair housing or discrimination, two of cultural competency, two of implicit bias, one of recent legal matters, and one of agency law, two hours of agency at a first renewal. Miss the renewal and a two-year grace period opens in which you may not practice. Miss that and you retake the exam.
Money flows through the broker, A salesperson takes compensation from the sponsoring broker and nowhere else. A broker shares fees only with the licensed or the exempt. An unlicensed person cannot sue for a commission in any court in New York.
Untrustworthiness is broad, Real Property Law §441-c gives the Secretary of State wide discretion over what counts, and conduct with nothing to do with real estate can still cost you the license. Penalties run from reprimand to revocation, with a fine to $1,000, and appeal lies by Article 78 proceeding.
Disclosure is mandatory now, Since March 20, 2024 the property condition disclosure statement must be completed and delivered before the buyer signs. The $500 credit alternative is repealed. You inform the seller of the obligation and the buyer of the right, and you do not fill in the form.
One chapter, one habit: ask who is protected
REMEMBER: Which of these eight could you not explain to a friend over coffee right now? Go back to that screen before you take the quiz.
THE FINAL QUESTION
The Matter of Hudson Gate Realty, Inc.
Everything up to here was rules. This is the part of the job the rules do not do for you.
In practice nobody hands you a violation with a label on it. You get a set of facts, most of them ordinary, and the skill is noticing which one is not. That noticing is part of competency, and incompetency is one of the grounds a disciplinary hearing can turn on.
Work this one the way you would work a file. Read it once for the story. Read it again with a pen, and mark anything that made you pause even slightly, without deciding yet whether it is a violation. Then go back to the rules.
Read carefully. Some of these facts decide the case. Some are traps. They are not labeled.
Sal holds a corporate broker license (Class 31) for Hudson Gate Realty Inc., where he is an officer. His Brooklyn branch shares the main office’s license, “no point paying $185 twice.”
The branch is run by his cousin Doreen, an associate broker active 3 of the last 4 years, designated as office manager.
Tina, a salesperson at the firm, is an attorney admitted in New Jersey. She never took the 77-hour course: “Lawyers are exempt.”
Tina’s independent-contractor agreement was signed 26 months ago and never looked at again. She receives a $2,000 monthly draw, and Sal requires attendance at Tuesday sales meetings, “that’s me supervising you, it’s the law.”
Tina’s unlicensed assistant Marcus hosts open houses when she double-books, hands out flyers he wrote himself, and confides to visitors, “between us, the seller will take less.” He earns $50 per open house, plus $500 whenever one leads to a contract.
The listing is a 3-family in Sunset Park that Sal co-owns with his brother. The lawn sign reads “FOR SALE BY OWNER, call Sal, 555-0100.”
Sal completes the disclosure statement himself, marking the flooding question “unknown.” The basement drywall is new because of last spring’s flood. Tina knows. The buyer’s attorney shrugs: “If he lied, my client just takes the $500 credit at closing.”
The buyer, Priya, is a Pennsylvania-licensed salesperson. Her PA broker, who holds no New York license, collects 25% of the commission as a referral, which Sal pays without hesitation.
After closing, Sal sends a $250 gift card to the home inspector who “kept the report light.” A month later, a fired ex-salesperson mails the DOS an anonymous letter describing all of it, adding that Sal was disciplined by the Insurance Department in 2019, and that Tina was once behind on child support.
NOTE: This case is for your own practice and is not graded. The graded issue-spotting activity for this chapter is a separate case with its own facts, scored on twelve keyed issues. Do this one first, the point is the instinct, not the score.
Notice first, decide second
THE QUESTIONS
How many issues can you find?
A
Spot every issue. Go back through the nine facts and list every legal issue you can identify, licensing, supervision, tax status, advertising, disclosure, compensation, discipline. Name the rule each one implicates. Don’t argue outcomes yet; just find them. (We count at least fourteen. Your class may find more.)
B
Sort them into three piles. “Clearly a violation.” “Clearly legal.” “Cannot tell from these facts.” The third pile is the one that matters, for each item in it, what missing fact would move it to pile one or pile two?
C
Find the traps. Some facts were planted to look like violations but aren’t; at least one looks harmless and isn’t. Which detail did you dismiss too quickly, and which one did you accuse too quickly? (Start with the FSBO sign, the PA broker’s 25%, Tina’s bar card, and Doreen’s appointment.)
D
Question yourself. Pick the single issue you were least confident sorting. Argue the other side of it out loud. If you can’t, did you actually spot an issue, or just recite a rule?
Work the four in order. Question A is recall and most students do well on it. Question B is where the licensees separate from the students, because sorting demands you name the fact you are missing. Question C is the one that costs people their licenses in real life, because the fact dismissed too quickly is the one that turns out to be the violation. Question D is the only one that tells you whether you understood the rule or memorized it.
CAUTION: If your answer to any issue is a rule number with no facts attached, you have not spotted an issue. You have recited a rule and hoped it fit. The Department of State's determinations turn on facts, and so does every question you will see on the exam.
When you are done, open the graded activity for this chapter. Different facts, twelve keyed issues, and the same skill.
Name the fact, then name the rule