The Course · Supplement Beta

Income Tax Issues in Real Estate Transactions

Principal residences, capital gains, the 1031 exchange and depreciation, explained well enough to know when to send the client to a CPA

In this chapter

  • The principal residence Apply the $250,000/$500,000 exclusion, the ownership-and-use test, and the deductions for taxes and mortgage interest.
  • Capital gains Compute adjusted basis, realized gain, short- versus long-term treatment and depreciation recapture.
  • Like-kind exchanges Explain §1031 eligibility, the qualified intermediary, boot, and the 45- and 180-day deadlines.
  • Financing and depreciation Describe the tax treatment of points, refinancing, home-equity interest, low-income housing credits and straight-line depreciation.

Lesson 1

The Principal Residence

The Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 and the deductions that make owning cheaper than it looks

The Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997

Section 121 and the exclusion on the sale of a principal residence

Start with what this chapter is not. It is not tax advice, and you are not going to give any. Tax law changes every year. Dollar amounts move, brackets move, deadlines move, and the rule that was right for a client last spring can be wrong for the client sitting in front of you now. Your job in every screen that follows is to recognize that a transaction has a tax side, name the issue out loud, and send the client to a tax professional before anybody signs anything.

Everything in this first lesson runs from one federal statute. The Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 rewrote how the federal government taxes the sale of a home, and it did it by replacing a deferral with an exclusion. Those two words carry the whole idea. A deferral postpones the tax to a later sale. An exclusion forgives it outright. Work out which one you are looking at and most of this screen takes care of itself.

Before 1997, sellers deferred gain only by buying a more expensive home within two years, plus a one-time $125,000 exclusion after age 55. The Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 replaced both with an exclusion any homeowner can use repeatedly: up to $250,000 of gain on the sale of a principal residence ($500,000 for a married couple filing jointly) is simply not taxed.

Read the old rule again and notice what it cost a seller. Under the rollover, the gain was never forgiven. It rode along into the next house, hidden inside a lower basis, waiting for the day the owner finally sold and did not buy again. A seller who traded up for thirty years carried thirty years of gain into retirement. The 1997 Act ended that arithmetic for most homeowners. Gain that fits inside the exclusion is gone, not parked.

The exclusion is not automatic. Section 121 of the Internal Revenue Code sets a test with two halves and the seller has to pass both. The ownership half asks whether the seller owned the home. The use half asks whether the seller lived in it as a principal residence. Both halves are measured against the same window, the five years ending on the date of sale, and the seller has to satisfy each of them for at least two years somewhere inside that window.

The seller must have owned the home and used it as a principal residence for at least two of the five years before the sale, the two years need not be continuous, and only one spouse must meet the ownership test while both must meet the use test for the $500,000 amount. The exclusion may be used once every two years. A partial exclusion is available for a sale forced by a job change, health, or unforeseen circumstances before the two years are up.

One detail in that rule catches people who think they already know it. The home does not have to be the seller's principal residence on the day of the sale. A seller who moved out a year ago, rented the house for a while and is selling it now can still pass, as long as two years of use sit somewhere inside the five-year window. The question is always the window. It is never the moving date.

The exclusion is also limited by how often it is used. A seller who claimed it on a different home too recently cannot claim it again on this one. That limit is what stops a taxpayer from running a string of short holds and calling each one a principal residence. It is also the first thing to ask a client who mentions, in passing, that he sold a house not long ago.

The Code carries exceptions for sellers pushed out before the time is up. Three categories cover them. A change in place of employment, which the IRS accepts automatically when the new work location is at least 50 miles farther from the home than the old one. Health, which means a move to obtain or provide the diagnosis, cure or treatment of a disease, illness or injury, or to care for someone who has one, including a move closer to a recognized treatment facility or to a climate that eases a condition. And unforeseen circumstances, which the textbook lists as involuntary conversion through eminent domain, disaster, death, cessation of employment, divorce and multiple births.

An exception does not hand the seller the whole exclusion. It hands over a share of it, and the share is a fraction. The numerator is the shortest of three periods, counted in months: the time the seller owned the home, the time the seller lived in it inside the five-year window, and the time since the seller last used the exclusion. The denominator is twenty-four, the number of months in the two-year period. Multiply the exclusion amount by that fraction and the answer is the amount available on this sale. A seller seventeen months in gets seventeen twenty-fourths of it, which on a short hold is often more than enough to swallow the entire gain.

There is a rule for a surviving spouse, and it comes up more often than new agents expect. When one spouse dies, the unmarried survivor may still sell under the joint exclusion amount, provided the couple met the joint ownership and use requirements immediately before the death and the sale happens within two years of it. Two years is a short window for a grieving client who is not thinking about tax at all. An agent who knows the rule exists is the reason that client hears about it in time.

Depreciation is the one thing the exclusion will not cover. A seller who converted part of the house to a home office and depreciated it took a deduction in those years. The exclusion does not reach that depreciation. The Code bars the exclusion from the part of the gain equal to any depreciation allowed or allowable after May 6, 1997, which means depreciation the owner took or was entitled to take. That amount is recaptured and taxed when the home sells. The same is true of a rental or a vacation home the owner depreciated before moving in. The principle underneath it is short. A taxpayer does not get the benefit of the same dollar twice.

A loss on the sale of a personal residence is not deductible at all. The house is a personal asset, and the tax code does not let a taxpayer write off the decline in value of a personal asset. Sellers who took a beating in a soft market ask about this every single time, and the answer does not change. Gain on a home can be excluded. Loss on a home is simply the owner's loss.

The last piece of this screen sits on the buying side. Retirement money is normally locked up, and pulling it out early triggers a penalty on top of the income tax. The Code opens one narrow door for a first-time homebuyer.

A first-time homebuyer, meaning anyone who has had no ownership interest in a main home in the two years before buying, may withdraw up to $10,000 (lifetime) from a traditional IRA for a home purchase without the 10% early-withdrawal penalty; income tax still applies. The money has to be spent on the purchase within 120 days, and the home can be the main home of the IRA owner, a spouse, a child, a grandchild, or a parent or other ancestor. Roth IRA contributions can always be withdrawn tax-free. Once a Roth account has passed its five-year period, up to $10,000 of earnings used for a first home comes out free of both the penalty and the income tax.

Hypothetical. Your buyer is thirty-four, has rented her whole adult life, and is short on the down payment. She has a traditional IRA left over from an old job. The exception may let her reach that money without the early-withdrawal penalty, and it will not save her the income tax on the withdrawal. Say exactly that much and stop. Then send her to her accountant with the question written down. You have named the issue. You have not priced it.

This screen reaches your business more directly than any other in the chapter. Sellers make listing decisions on it. A seller who is a few months short of the two years may be better off waiting, and a seller who moved out three years ago may be running out of window without knowing it. You are often the first person who hears the dates, because you ask how long they have owned the place before you ask anything else. Hear the dates, spot the issue, and route it.

CAUTION: The figures on this screen are federal law as it stands in 2026. The exclusion amounts, the penalty-free IRA figure and the qualifying rules have all been changed before and can be changed again. Have the client's tax professional confirm the rule and the number that apply to the actual sale.

NOTE: The exam tests this rule with a date and a relationship. Two of the last five years of ownership and use, once in any two-year period, one exclusion amount for a single seller and a larger one for a married couple filing jointly. A question that offers five years of ownership, or offers the larger amount to two friends who bought together, is testing whether you read the words around the number.

Own two years, live two years, exclude

REMEMBER: Your seller bought two and a half years ago and moved out last summer for a job upstate. Which half of the test is he relying on, and what is the one date you need from him before you say anything at all?

Deductions for Homeowners

Property taxes, mortgage interest, and where the rest of the money goes

Two tools show up all through this chapter and students mix them up all the way to the exam. A deduction reduces the income the tax is computed on. A credit reduces the tax itself, dollar for dollar. A thousand dollars of deduction saves the taxpayer whatever their rate happens to be. A thousand dollars of credit saves a thousand dollars. Homeowner tax breaks are almost all deductions. Keep the two words apart now and the low-income housing screen at the end of this chapter will be easy.

The homeowner deductions exist on purpose. Congress wrote several provisions into the tax code to encourage home ownership, and the textbook groups them into four. Property taxes paid are deductible for a taxpayer who itemizes. Interest paid on a mortgage is deductible. Interest paid on a home equity loan used to improve the property is deductible. And retirement money can be reached for a first home without the early-withdrawal penalty. Those four are the shape of the subject, and the rest of this screen is the detail inside the first three.

A homeowner deduction is also worth nothing until it is itemized. Every taxpayer gets a choice between a standard deduction and the total of their itemized deductions, and they take whichever is larger. A homeowner whose mortgage interest and property taxes add up to less than the standard deduction gets no benefit from either one. That is not a technicality. It is the reason a client can buy a house, pay property taxes all year, and see no change at all on the return.

Property taxes come first because every homeowner pays them and every homeowner asks about them. Paid property taxes are deductible if the taxpayer itemizes. What has changed, and changed recently, is how much of the total a taxpayer is allowed to count.

State and local taxes, meaning property tax plus either income tax or sales tax, are deductible by itemizers up to a combined cap. The 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act created the cap. The 2025 reconciliation act, Public Law 119-21, raised it to $40,000 for 2025 and $40,400 for 2026, and it rises one percent a year through 2029. In 2030 it drops back to $10,000. Married taxpayers filing separately get half. Higher earners lose part of the cap: it shrinks by 30% of modified adjusted gross income above $505,000 for 2026 ($500,000 for 2025), but never below $10,000. In high-tax New York suburbs the cap, not the tax bill, often limits the benefit.

New York gives that limit more work than almost any other state. A Westchester or Nassau homeowner pays property tax and New York income tax, and the two together can run past the cap. A high earner is hit twice, because the phase-down can shrink the cap all the way to the floor. The practical result is that the deduction stops scaling with the tax bill. Two clients with very different tax bills can end up with the same deduction. When a buyer asks you what the tax write-off will be worth, that is the point at which you hand the question to an accountant.

Mortgage interest is the other large one, and it is defined by what the borrowed money did. Home acquisition debt is a mortgage a taxpayer takes out to buy, build or substantially improve a qualified home. The loan has to be secured by that home. Two conditions, both required. A loan secured by the house that paid for a boat is not acquisition debt. A loan that paid for an addition but is secured by some other property is not acquisition debt either. What the lender calls the product decides nothing.

Interest on acquisition debt, money borrowed to buy, build or substantially improve a first or second home, is deductible on up to $750,000 of debt ($375,000 married filing separately) for loans taken after December 15, 2017. Loans taken on or before that date keep the older $1,000,000 limit ($500,000 married filing separately), and a refinance of one keeps it up to the balance refinanced. The 2017 Act set these rules to expire after 2025; Public Law 119-21 made them permanent. Interest on a home-equity loan or HELOC is deductible only if the proceeds buy, build or substantially improve the home that secures it; interest on equity borrowed to pay off credit cards or buy a car is not.

Tracing is the skill inside that paragraph. The tax treatment follows the money, not the name on the note. A home equity line drawn to build a dormer is acquisition debt because the dollars went into the home that secures the loan. The same line drawn to pay off a credit card is not, because the dollars went somewhere else. One borrower, one loan, two different answers depending entirely on where the money landed.

Refinancing sits in the same logic. Interest on a refinanced loan stays deductible when the new loan replaces the previous one with an amount equal to or less than the previous loan. That is the clean case and most refinances are the clean case. The moment a borrower takes cash out, the new dollars have to be traced like any other borrowing, and the answer depends on where the cash went and nowhere else.

Second homes and vacation homes get the same two deductions the first home gets, with one extra rule sitting on top. That rule turns on a day count, and the count belongs to the owner.

A second home shares the acquisition-debt limit with the first. If it is rented fewer than 15 days a year the rent is tax-free and the home is treated purely as a residence; rented more, and personal use exceeding the greater of 14 days or 10% of rental days makes it a mixed-use property whose expenses are allocated and whose losses are limited. The $250,000/$500,000 exclusion never applies to a home that was not the principal residence.

Work the mechanism rather than the number. Rent a second home for a short enough stretch and the tax code ignores the rental entirely. The income is not reported. Property taxes and mortgage interest are still deducted the way they would be on any second home. Cross the line and three things happen at once. The rent becomes taxable income. The operating expenses become deductible. And every expense has to be allocated between the days of personal use and the days of rental use.

New York has a lot of owners standing on that line. A house near the beach rented for a season. A cabin upstate rented for a few weekends in the fall. A second home rented to visitors during a festival week. Most of those owners have never heard of the day count. You are not the person who counts their days and you are not the person who files their return. You are the person who tells them the count exists before they list.

Allocation is the mechanism doing the work once the line is crossed, and it is simple division. Count the days of personal use. Count the days of rental use. Split every expense that serves both, the taxes, the interest, the insurance, the utilities, the repairs, in the same proportion. The rental share becomes a rental expense. The personal share stays personal and follows the personal rules. Losses from the rental side are limited when personal use is heavy, which is the point of the limit.

One more limit belongs on this screen. The principal residence exclusion from the last screen never applies to a home that was not the seller's principal residence. A vacation house is not rescued by being lovely and long-held. A rental is not rescued by having been in the family. If it fails the ownership and use test, the gain is taxable gain.

Conversions run in both directions and both of them raise questions above your pay grade. An owner who moves into a former rental has a property with depreciation already taken against it. An owner who moves out and rents the old house starts depreciating it and starts the clock on the ownership and use window at the same time. Neither client should hear an answer from you. Both should hear that the conversion has a tax consequence and that the consequence is worth a phone call before the moving truck.

That leaves the costs homeowners assume are deductible and are not.

Homeowners insurance, principal payments, utilities, repairs and improvements on a personal residence, and closing costs other than points are not deductible, improvements instead add to basis, which reduces the gain at sale. Tell clients you are not a tax advisor and point them to a CPA; the DOS syllabus expects you to recognize the issues, not resolve them.

Notice where that money actually goes. A new roof on a personal residence buys no deduction this year. It adds to basis. Basis is the number subtracted from the sale price, less the costs of selling, when the house sells, so a larger basis produces a smaller gain and a smaller tax on the sale. The money is not lost. It is postponed, sometimes for decades. That is exactly why the receipts matter, and it is why the next lesson is about basis.

Hypothetical. Your seller tells you he spent a fortune on the house over eighteen years and wants to know what he can write off. Nothing, this year, on a personal residence. The roof, the boiler, the kitchen and the deck were never deductions. They were additions to basis, and basis is about to do its work in one shot when the house sells. Ask him whether he kept the invoices. If the answer is no, that is a conversation for his accountant today and not on the day of the closing.

There is a selling habit to break before you pick it up. New agents like to quantify the tax benefit of owning. They tell a buyer the write-off will cover a piece of the payment, and they do the arithmetic out loud at the kitchen table. Do not do it. You do not know the buyer's filing status, you do not know whether they will itemize, you do not know their rate, and you do not know what Congress will do to any of these figures in the years the buyer holds the house.

The safe version of the same conversation is shorter and it is honest. Owning a home carries tax benefits, the main ones are the property tax and mortgage interest deductions, the benefit depends entirely on the buyer's own return, and their accountant can run the numbers in an afternoon. That sentence sells just as well as the wrong one and it does not put your license behind a figure you invented at a kitchen table.

CAUTION: The figures on this screen are federal law as it stands in 2026. The state and local tax cap changes every year through 2029 and drops back in 2030 under the statute itself. The acquisition debt limit and the home equity rule are now permanent, which means they stay until Congress changes them again. Do not quote a number to a client. Name the rule, and have their tax professional confirm the figure for the year of the transaction.

NOTE: The trap is the home equity loan. The exam will offer a home equity loan or a line of credit and ask whether the interest is deductible. The answer is never yes or no on its own. It depends on what the proceeds paid for and whether the loan is secured by the home the proceeds improved.

Trace the dollars, not the loan name

REMEMBER: A client tells you she pulled fifty thousand out of her house last year. What is the only question you need to ask before you have any idea how the interest is treated?

Lesson 2

Capital Gains

Basis, holding period, the three kinds of income, and depreciation recapture

Computing the Gain

Amount realized minus adjusted basis

One formula runs this entire lesson and it is worth memorizing before anything else. Gain equals amount realized minus adjusted basis. Every tax question about a sale is really a question about one of those two numbers. Sellers think the gain is the sale price minus what they paid. It never is, and the gap between those two calculations is where clients get surprised.

Basis is the accounting figure used to determine capital gain or loss after a sale. It starts at what the owner paid and then it moves. It is not a fixed number and it is not the purchase price. An owner who believes basis is frozen at the contract price from the day of purchase will overstate the gain or understate it, depending on which adjustments he forgot.

Basis starts at the purchase price plus acquisition costs (title insurance, legal fees, transfer taxes, survey). Add capital improvements, a new roof, an addition, a kitchen renovation, and subtract depreciation taken on any business or rental use. The result is adjusted basis.

Basis moves in three ways and only three. It goes up by the acquisition costs paid to get the property in the first place. It goes up again by capital improvements made while the owner holds it. And it goes down by depreciation taken on any business or rental use of it. Run those three motions in order on any property and the number at the end is the adjusted basis. Run them for a personal residence and there is usually no depreciation to subtract, which is why the third motion surprises the home office client.

The improvement side is where records decide the answer. An improvement is work that adds to the property rather than work that keeps it running. A new roof, an addition, a kitchen renovation. The owner's accountant makes that call, not you, and the accountant can only make it from documents. Which is why the practical rule is the same for every client, on every property, every time. Keep the invoices.

Amount realized is the other half of the formula and it is not the sale price either. It is the sale price reduced by the costs of selling. Commission, transfer tax, legal fees. The seller never had those dollars, so the tax code does not treat the seller as having realized them.

Amount realized is the sale price minus selling expenses: commission, transfer tax, legal fees. Gain = amount realized − adjusted basis. Bought for $400,000 with $12,000 of closing costs, added a $60,000 kitchen, sold for $850,000 with $50,000 of selling costs: adjusted basis $472,000; amount realized $800,000; gain $328,000. A married couple who lived there five years excludes all of it. A single owner excludes $250,000 and reports $78,000.

Walk that example in words and it stops being arithmetic. The purchase price plus the closing costs paid at purchase plus the kitchen gives the adjusted basis. The sale price minus the selling costs gives the amount realized. Subtract the first from the second and the difference is the gain. Then, and only then, does the principal residence exclusion come off. The exclusion applies to the gain. It has nothing to do with the sale price, and a client who thinks otherwise is thinking about the wrong number entirely.

The burden of proving basis sits on the taxpayer, not on the government. An owner who cannot document a renovation cannot add it to basis, and the gain gets computed as though the renovation never happened. Twenty years of small improvements with no paperwork is twenty years of tax paid on money the owner already spent. Tell every buyer at the closing table to open a folder and keep every invoice for work done on the house. It costs them nothing and it is the most useful piece of tax hygiene you will ever hand a client.

Two more words belong on this screen and they are easy to confuse. Realized gain is the gain the formula produces. Recognized gain is the part of it the taxpayer actually reports and pays tax on. On a principal residence the exclusion sits between them: subtract it from the realized gain and what is left is the recognized gain. That is the order lawmakers wrote and the order the exam follows.

The exclusion does not carry forward. When the exclusion is larger than the realized gain, the recognized gain is zero and the leftover exclusion is simply lost. It cannot be banked, rolled into the next house or saved for a future sale. A seller with a modest gain uses a fraction of the exclusion and the rest evaporates. Sellers hear the exclusion amount and think of it as a balance in an account. It is not an account. It is a ceiling on one sale.

The other number the tax code cares about is time. Appreciation is the increase in value of an asset over time, and appreciation by itself is not a taxable event. A house can double in value over twenty years and generate no tax at all while the owner lives in it. Capital gains and losses are generated when a capital asset is sold, and nothing that happens to the value in between matters until there is a sale or an exchange. Once there is a sale, the holding period sorts the gain into one of two categories, and the two are taxed very differently.

Property held one year or less produces short-term gain taxed as ordinary income at rates up to 37%. Held more than one year, the gain is long-term and taxed at 0%, 15% or 20% depending on income, plus the 3.8% net investment income tax for high earners. New York State taxes all capital gain as ordinary income. Losses on a personal residence are never deductible; losses on investment property are capital losses that offset gains plus $3,000 of ordinary income a year.

Twelve months is the line and it is a hard one. Held for a year or less, the gain is short-term. Held for more than a year, the gain is long-term. There is no partial credit and there is no rounding. An investor who sells at eleven months has a short-term gain taxed at ordinary rates, and an investor who waits a few more weeks has a long-term gain taxed under the preferential rules. When a client asks whether to close now or in six weeks, that is the question underneath, and it belongs to their accountant.

The code also sorts assets, and the sorting is less obvious than it looks. A capital asset is something owned for the long term, and the familiar examples are land, buildings and machinery, along with stocks, bonds and collectibles. The code then pulls several categories back out. Property held for resale in the normal course of business, which is inventory. Trade accounts and notes receivable. Depreciable property. And real estate used in a trade or business, which the code files under Section 1231. A rental building is not a capital asset in that technical sense, and it still reaches its own gain calculation through its own rules.

CAUTION: The federal rates and the capital loss allowance given earlier on this screen are current law as of 2026, and the 2025 reconciliation act made the 37% top rate permanent. New York's treatment of capital gain is state law and changes on its own schedule. Teach a client the formula. Do not quote them a rate. The client's tax professional confirms the numbers for the year of the sale.

NOTE: Read every gain question in this order. Adjusted basis first. Amount realized second. Subtract. Exclusion last. Questions are written to reward the student who computes in that order and to punish the one who reaches for the exclusion first.

Gain is amount realized minus adjusted basis

REMEMBER: Your seller paid a commission, a transfer tax and an attorney at the closing. Which side of the formula do those three costs land on, and what do they do to the gain?

Three Kinds of Income, and Getting the Depreciation Back

Section 469, the passive loss rules, and recapture

The IRS does not treat all income the same way, and for an investor the classification is not a label. It decides which losses can be used and which ones sit idle. Taxpayers are required to sort income into three broad categories, and rental real estate lands in the one with the tightest rules.

Active income is income received from services performed. Wages, salaries, commissions, bonuses and other payments for services rendered. Profit from a trade or business the taxpayer actively participates in. Gain on the sale of assets used in an active trade or business. And income from intangible property where the taxpayer played a significant role in creating the property. The thread running through all of it is the taxpayer's own labor.

Portfolio income is what money earns when it is working without the owner. Interest, dividends, annuities and royalties not derived from the ordinary course of business. Gain or loss from disposing of property that produces portfolio income or is held for investment. A savings account, a dividend-paying stock, a bond. The owner is not working. The capital is.

Passive income is defined in Section 469 of the Code, and it covers two things. Any trade, business or income-producing activity in which the taxpayer does not materially participate, which is where a limited partnership interest lands. And all rental activities, subject to exceptions. Read that second half twice. Rental activity is passive by definition, whether or not the owner is at the building every weekend.

Active income is wages and business income the taxpayer materially participates in. Portfolio income is interest, dividends and capital gains. Passive income is income from rental activity and businesses in which the taxpayer does not materially participate. Passive losses can offset only passive income, with an allowance of up to $25,000 of rental loss against other income for taxpayers who actively participate and have adjusted gross income under $100,000 (phased out by $150,000), and a full exception for real estate professionals who spend more than 750 hours and more than half their working time in real property trades.

The reason the classification matters is that losses stay in their bucket. Passive losses can generally be used only to offset passive income. An investor with a rental loss and a large salary cannot simply subtract one from the other, because the salary is active income and the loss is passive. Investors learn this the hard way and they usually learn it in April.

A loss that cannot be used is not destroyed, though. Unused passive losses are carried forward and offset future passive income. They wait. And there is one event that releases them. When a taxpayer ceases to engage in the passive activity, all current losses and everything carried forward may be used against active and portfolio income. An investor who has been stockpiling suspended losses for years gets them all in the year the property is finally disposed of.

The two exceptions to the rental rule are worth restating as mechanisms. The first is for the real estate professional, and it is demanding. More than half of the taxpayer's personal services in trades or businesses have to be performed in real property trades in which the taxpayer materially participates, and the taxpayer has to perform more than seven hundred fifty hours of service in those trades as a material participant. Meet it and rental losses stop being trapped.

The second exception is broader and it is the one most small landlords rely on. It does not require the taxpayer to be a real estate professional at all. It allows a deduction of a limited amount of rental losses against other income, it phases out as adjusted gross income rises and disappears entirely at the top of the phase-out range, and it requires two things of the taxpayer. Active participation in the activity. And ownership of ten percent or more in value of all interests in the activity during the tax period.

Now the operating side. Two numbers come off the same building every year and they are not the same number. Cash flow is the money left after all expenses are paid, including the loan payment. Debt service is that loan payment, the principal and interest owed each period on the mortgage. Taxable income is a different figure entirely, because the tax code ignores the principal half of the debt service and allows a deduction for depreciation that costs the owner no cash at all.

Taxable income from a rental = gross rents − operating expenses − mortgage interest − depreciation. A building with $60,000 of NOI, $28,000 of interest and $14,546 of depreciation shows $17,454 of taxable income even though cash flow after debt service was higher, depreciation is the deduction that shelters the difference.

Follow that formula one line at a time and the trap in it is obvious. Gross rents come in. Operating expenses come out. Mortgage interest comes out, and only the interest, because repaying principal is not an expense at all. Depreciation comes out last and it is the only line on the list that costs the owner nothing this year. What is left is taxable income, and it can sit far below the money that actually landed in the owner's bank account.

The same computation explains adjusted gross income, which is the number the IRS uses to run most of the thresholds in this chapter. Adjusted gross income is gross income minus the deductions the code allows against it, and the tax system taxes higher levels of income at higher rates. That is why the rental loss allowance described earlier on this screen phases out as income rises. The allowance is aimed at ordinary landlords, and the phase-out is how the code keeps it aimed there.

A tax shelter is any method used to reduce taxable income, and with it the tax paid. Income-producing real estate is the classic one, and depreciation is the reason. The owner writes off part of the building every year without writing a check for it. In a good year the shelter turns a property that put money in the owner's pocket into a property reporting very little income, or none. That single mechanism is what investors mean when they call real estate a tax shelter.

Depreciation is a loan, not a gift, and the sale is when the government collects. Every dollar of depreciation allowed or allowable came out of basis. Allowed or allowable counts the dollars the owner deducted and any dollars the owner was entitled to deduct and skipped. A lower basis means a larger gain when the property sells. The code then reaches into that larger gain, finds the part depreciation created, and taxes that part under its own rule instead of the ordinary long-term rule.

When investment property is sold, the gain attributable to depreciation allowed or allowable ('unrecaptured §1250 gain') is taxed at a maximum 25% rate rather than the 15–20% long-term rate; the rest of the gain is ordinary capital gain. Sold for $900,000 after ten years of $14,546 annual depreciation on a $500,000 purchase, $100,000 of it land: adjusted basis $354,540; gain $545,460 (before selling costs), of which $145,460 is recaptured at up to 25% and $400,000 at long-term rates.

The principle is the same one from the home office in the first lesson. Recaptured depreciation most commonly arises on an asset used for business purposes when the asset is sold. The owner already took a benefit from that asset in a prior period. The taxpayer does not get to benefit from the same expense twice, so the earlier depreciation comes back into income when the asset is sold. Every investor client you will ever have is surprised by this, and every one of them should have heard about it years earlier.

None of this makes you the investor's accountant, and none of it should. What it makes you is the person who can hear a client say the rental loses money every year and knows to ask follow-up questions. Who else is on the deed. How much time the client puts into the building. Whether there is other real estate work in the client's life. You are not answering those questions. You are collecting them for somebody who can, and an investor client notices the difference immediately.

CAUTION: The recapture rate, the loss allowance, the income thresholds and the hours test are current federal law as of 2026, and Congress can change any of them. The mechanism is what stays put. Depreciation lowers basis, a lower basis makes a bigger gain, and the depreciation portion of that gain is taxed on its own terms. Have the client's tax professional confirm every number before it reaches a decision.

NOTE: Two classification questions show up constantly. Rental income received by an owner who does not materially participate is passive income, not portfolio and not earned. And the maximum federal rate on the depreciation portion of the gain, unrecaptured §1250 gain, is 25%. That sits above the 20% top long-term rate and below the 37% top ordinary rate. Learn where it sits relative to the others and the answer choices sort themselves.

Losses stay in the bucket they were born in

REMEMBER: Your investor client has carried a suspended rental loss for six years and is finally selling. What happens to that loss in the year of the sale, and what happens to the depreciation he took along the way?

Lesson 3

Like-Kind Exchanges Under §1031

Defer the whole gain by trading investment property for investment property, on a strict clock

Like-Kind Exchanges: What Qualifies and Who Holds the Money

Section 1031, boot, and the qualified intermediary

An exchange lets an investor move money from one property into another without stopping at the tax window. Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code allows a taxpayer to sell an investment property and buy another in its place without paying tax on the proceeds of the sale. The investor walks into the second purchase with more buying power, because the dollars that would have gone to tax are still in the deal. That is the entire reason anyone puts up with the paperwork.

The Code sets conditions and every one of them has to hold. The transaction has to involve the sale of one property and the purchase of another, not merely a sale. It has to be structured as a tax-deferred exchange, meaning taxable gain is deferred to a later date rather than reported now. The property given up and the property received both have to be held for use in a trade or business or for investment. And the properties have to be like-kind.

That third condition is the one that decides most cases. The test is about how the property is held, not what it is.

Real property held for investment or productive use in a trade or business, residential rentals, commercial, industrial, unimproved land not held by a dealer, hotels and motels, and leaseholds with 30 or more years remaining. Since 2018 only real property qualifies. A principal residence, a vacation home used personally, dealer inventory (flips) and property outside the United States do not. 'Like-kind' is broad: an apartment building for raw land, a warehouse for a tenant-in-common interest.

Like-kind is read broadly. Generally any real property can be exchanged for any other real property regardless of the improvements on it. A parking lot for an office building. Farmland for a row of storefronts. Since the 2017 Act, only real property qualifies, for exchanges completed after December 31, 2017. Equipment, vehicles and artwork no longer do, and that narrowing carries no expiration date. The two properties do not have to resemble each other in size, use, quality, age or location, as long as both are in the United States. What they have to share is the owner's purpose in holding them, and that purpose is investment or productive use in a trade or business.

The categories the syllabus names are worth reading as a group, because they are the everyday inventory of an investment brokerage. Residential rentals, commercial and industrial property. Unimproved land, as long as the owner is not a dealer holding it for resale. Hotels and motels. And leaseholds with a long enough term left to run. On a leasehold the remaining term is the whole question. A lease with decades left behaves like an ownership interest. A short lease does not.

The holding purpose is also what disqualifies the flipper. Property held for resale in the ordinary course of business is inventory, and inventory is not held for investment no matter how much it looks like an investment from the outside. A buyer who purchases a house meaning to renovate it and sell it within months is a dealer in that house. Personal-use property, inventory, partnership interests and securities are all outside the section, and so is a principal residence.

An exchange does not make the gain disappear. That sentence is the one clients most need to hear, because many of them believe the opposite.

The exchange does not erase the gain; it defers it. The realized gain is what a sale would have produced; the recognized (taxed) gain is limited to boot received. The old basis carries into the new property, so the deferred gain is taxed when the replacement is eventually sold, unless it is exchanged again, or held until death, when heirs receive a stepped-up basis.

The technical name is a nonrecognition provision, and it describes the mechanism exactly. The realized gain or loss usually never disappears. It carries over into the new asset by riding inside the basis. If the taxpayer actually wants to recognize a gain or a loss, the transaction has to be structured as a sale instead. That is a real choice in a year when an investor has losses to absorb, and it is a choice their accountant makes.

The Code gives a workable way to compute the basis of what the taxpayer receives. Start with the adjusted basis of the like-kind property surrendered. Add the adjusted basis of any boot given and any gain recognized on the exchange. Subtract the fair market value of any boot received and any loss recognized. What is left is the basis of the like-kind property received. Amounts already taxed get added back, because taxing them twice would be wrong. Amounts not taxed get deducted, because the owner already has the benefit of deferring them.

Deferral compounds, and that is why serious investors keep doing this. Each exchange puts the whole equity to work in the next building instead of sending a slice of it to the government first. An investor who exchanges three times over a career has had that slice earning money the entire time. The gain is still there, riding in the basis, and an investor who exchanges and then holds until death leaves heirs who take the property with a stepped-up basis. That is the strategy behind every investor who tells you he never sells.

The holding period carries over too, and investors like this one. The time the taxpayer held the old property counts toward the holding period of the new one. A client who owned a property for five years, exchanged it, then held the replacement for three years has an eight-year holding period in the replacement. Boot is treated separately. The holding period for any boot received starts on the date of the exchange.

Which brings up boot, the word every exchange conversation eventually reaches.

Anything received that is not like-kind, cash, a reduction in mortgage debt, personal property, is boot and is taxable to the extent of the gain. To defer everything, buy replacement property of equal or greater value, reinvest all the equity, and take on equal or greater debt (or replace debt relief with cash).

Boot does not destroy an exchange. Boot makes part of it taxable. Receiving boot generally triggers a recognized gain equal to the lesser of two numbers: the fair market value of the boot received, or the realized gain on the transaction as a whole. An investor who takes a little cash out of a large exchange pays tax on the cash and defers the rest. Debt relief works the same way, which is why an investor who trades down into a smaller mortgage can owe tax without ever seeing a dollar of cash.

One rule that ends exchanges has nothing to do with the properties. It has to do with who touches the money. Assistance from a qualified intermediary is required for a Section 1031 exchange, and the reason is constructive receipt. The moment the taxpayer has the right to the funds, the taxpayer has received them for tax purposes, and a sale followed by a purchase is just a sale followed by a purchase.

The taxpayer may never touch the sale proceeds. A qualified intermediary, an independent exchange company, not the taxpayer's attorney, accountant, broker or relative within the prior two years, holds the funds and acquires the replacement. Constructive receipt of the money, even for a day, kills the exchange.

The intermediary does real work. A qualified intermediary prepares the documentation for the exchange, receives, holds and distributes the funds connected to it, and advises the participants on compliance with the treasury regulations and rulings that govern the transaction. In a delayed exchange the intermediary is the only thing standing between the seller's proceeds and the seller's hands, and the documents have to be in place before the relinquished property closes, not after.

Here is the part to say out loud to a client. Qualified intermediaries are not required to be bonded, insured, licensed, audited or regulated. Anyone can hang out a shingle. Your client is about to hand a stranger the entire proceeds of a sale on the strength of a contract, and nothing in the license law guarantees that the stranger is solvent tomorrow. Help the client research the intermediary carefully before the choice is made. After the wire goes out is too late.

Related parties get their own restriction. Two related parties, as the Code defines the relationship in Section 267(b), may conduct a like-kind exchange, and then neither may dispose of the property for a period of two years. Dispose of it inside that window and the postponed gain is recognized on the date of the disposition. Exchanges between family members and between commonly controlled entities happen more often than people expect, and this is the rule that turns a clever family transaction into a tax bill.

Run the whole section back through one sentence before you leave it. An exchange is a sale and a purchase that the taxpayer never stood between. Break that and there is no exchange. The taxpayer sold a property and bought another one, which is two ordinary transactions and one tax bill. Everything on this screen, the eligibility test, the intermediary, the documents signed before the first closing, exists to keep that sentence true.

CAUTION: What qualifies for an exchange has been narrowed by Congress before and the rules for related parties, holding periods and boot are all federal law subject to change. Nothing on this screen is a substitute for a tax professional's opinion on a specific transaction. Your role is to spot the investor who should be asking the question.

The taxpayer never touches the money

REMEMBER: Your investor wants to exchange a rental duplex for a piece of raw land and asks whether the two are similar enough. What is the actual test, and what single fact about the land would disqualify it?

The Exchange Clock

45 days to identify, 180 days to close

Exchanges rarely fail on eligibility. They fail on dates. An investor who qualifies in every other respect loses the whole deferral by missing a deadline, and there is no relief for a near miss and no mercy for a good reason. Two clocks run, they both start at the same moment, and the person most likely to be watching a calendar in this transaction is you.

The first clock is the identification period. Within it the taxpayer has to name the replacement property, in writing, to the intermediary.

Within 45 days after closing on the relinquished property, the taxpayer must identify replacement property in writing to the intermediary, up to three properties of any value (three-property rule), or any number whose total value does not exceed 200% of the relinquished property (200% rule). Weekends and holidays count; there are no extensions.

Identification has to be specific enough that a stranger could find the property from the document. A street address. A legal description. Something unambiguous. It goes to the intermediary, not to you, not to the accountant, and not into a folder on the investor's desk. An investor who has walked a dozen buildings and written nothing down has identified nothing at all, and the clock does not care how sure he is about which one he wants.

The period is counted in plain calendar days and nothing pauses it. Weekends count. Holidays count. A closing delayed by the other side's attorney counts. This is a statutory period, not a contract deadline, so nobody in the transaction has the power to extend it, and there is no provision for a taxpayer who was close. An investor who spends the first month of the period deciding whether to exchange at all has spent most of it.

The two identification rules exist to give the investor a choice between breadth and precision. Three properties of any value is the simple path and it is the one most investors take. The alternative lets the investor list as many as he likes on the condition that their total value stays inside twice the value of what he sold. Pick one rule and stay inside it. Break both and the identification fails, and a failed identification ends the exchange even if the investor closes on a perfect property a week later.

The second clock is the exchange period, and it has a wrinkle that catches people at the end of the year.

The replacement must close within 180 days of the first closing OR by the due date of the taxpayer's return for that year, including extensions, whichever comes first. A December sale therefore may need a filing extension to get the full 180 days.

Read that rule again and find the words doing the work. Whichever comes first. The one hundred eighty days is a ceiling, not a promise. Through most of the year the one hundred eighty days arrives before the return is due and nobody thinks about it. For a sale that closes late in the calendar year, the filing due date can land well inside the exchange period and cut it short. The fix is a filing extension, and an extension has to actually be filed. Nobody gets it by wishing.

In an ordinary exchange, the kind where the old property sells first, both clocks start at the same event, and the event is the transfer of the relinquished property. Not the replacement closing. Not the day the investor signs with the intermediary. Not the day he first sees something he likes. The day the old property transfers. That is the single thing investors most often have backwards, and an investor who believes the clocks start at the replacement closing believes he has all the time in the world.

Not every exchange runs in the usual order, and the rules accommodate two variations.

In a reverse exchange the replacement is bought first and parked with an exchange accommodation titleholder until the old property sells, same 45/180-day clock, running from the parked purchase. In an improvement exchange, exchange funds build improvements on the replacement before the taxpayer takes title.

A reverse exchange solves a timing problem rather than a tax problem. It is useful when the taxpayer has found the property he wants, or when the seller of that property wants to close quickly, and the taxpayer is not yet able to transfer the property he is giving up. Buying first and selling second is the natural order for the deal and the unnatural order for the statute, so the replacement is parked with a third party until the old property moves.

An improvement exchange answers a different problem. Sometimes the replacement property is worth less than the property given up, and the gap would come back to the taxpayer as boot. Building on the replacement closes the gap. Exchange funds pay for improvements to the replacement property before the taxpayer takes title to it, so the value the taxpayer finally receives matches what was given up. It is a construction project running inside a tax deadline, and the deadlines do not move for weather.

Hypothetical. Your investor client sells a small rental in August and spends September looking. On the forty-third day he emails his intermediary a street address and a block and lot for one building, and nothing else. He has used the simple identification path and he has one property on the list. If that deal falls apart in October he has no second name to fall back on, because the identification period closed on the forty-fifth day. That is the conversation to have with him in early September, not in October.

Which leaves the question this screen is really for. What does a licensee actually do in an exchange.

Recognize the investor who should be asking about §1031, write exchange cooperation language into the contract, calendar the 45th and 180th days, and connect the client with a qualified intermediary and a CPA before the relinquished property closes. Never hold exchange funds in the brokerage escrow account.

One line in that list is a bright line for you. Never hold exchange funds in the brokerage escrow account. The funds have to sit with the intermediary. A broker who takes exchange money into escrow has handed the taxpayer constructive receipt of the proceeds and destroyed the deferral, and has done it while holding somebody else's money in a regulated account. That is a tax disaster for the client and a license problem for the broker in the same stroke.

The rest of the work is calendar work and contract work, and it is ordinary. Exchange cooperation language goes into the contract so the other side agrees to cooperate at no cost to itself. The intermediary is engaged before the relinquished property closes. The forty-fifth day and the one hundred eightieth day go on your calendar and on the client's. None of that is tax advice. All of it is service, and it is the kind of service investor clients remember.

CAUTION: The identification and exchange periods are set by federal law and federal law can change them. Confirm both deadlines with the qualified intermediary and the client's tax professional for the specific transaction. Calendar what they tell you, not what you remember from a course.

NOTE: Exam questions reverse the clocks on purpose. Identification is the shorter period. Closing on the replacement is the longer one. Both run from the closing on the property given up, and the longer one can be cut short by the tax return due date.

Both clocks start at the old closing

REMEMBER: Your client closes the sale of his relinquished property on a Friday in late November. Which two dates go on your calendar before you leave the closing, and what is the one filing that may need to happen to protect the second one?

Lesson 4

Financing Rules, Low-Income Housing and Depreciation

Points, refinancing, the credit that builds affordable housing, and the straight line

Points, Closing Costs and Refinancing

Which costs deduct now, which spread out, and which add to basis

A dollar spent at a closing goes to one of three places. It deducts this year. It spreads across the life of the loan and deducts a little at a time. Or it adds to basis and waits for the sale. Every closing cost a client asks about lands in one of those three, and this screen is about telling them apart. Get the sorting right and you will answer most client questions correctly without ever giving tax advice.

Start with what a point is. A point is a fee for obtaining financing and it is also a form of prepaid interest, paid up front by a borrower to lower the interest owed on the payments that follow. Each point is generally one percent of the total loan amount. Because a point is interest paid in advance, the tax question is never whether it is interest. The question is always when the borrower gets to deduct it.

On the purchase of a principal residence, the answer can be all at once.

Points paid to buy or build a principal residence are deductible in full in the year paid if they are customary in the area, computed as a percentage of the loan, and paid from the buyer's own funds (seller-paid points are deductible by the buyer, who reduces basis by the same amount). Points on a second home or investment property are amortized over the life of the loan.

The IRS sets out conditions for deducting points in full in the year paid, and a loan has to satisfy all of them. The loan is secured by the home the borrower lives in most of the time. Paying points is an established business practice in the area where the loan was made. The points paid are not more than the points generally charged in that area. And the borrower uses the cash method of accounting, meaning income is reported in the year received and expenses deducted in the year paid, which is how nearly every individual files.

The rest of the conditions are about the closing itself. The points were not paid in place of amounts ordinarily stated separately on the settlement statement, such as appraisal fees, inspection fees, title fees, attorney fees and property taxes. The buyer paid the points at or before closing without using funds borrowed from the lender or the mortgage broker. The loan is used to buy or build a principal residence. The points were computed as a percentage of the principal amount of the mortgage. And the amount is clearly shown on the Closing Disclosure as points charged for the mortgage.

Seller-paid points are the wrinkle inside that list. The points may be shown on the Closing Disclosure as paid from either the buyer's funds or the seller's funds, and the buyer is the one who deducts them either way. The buyer then reduces basis by the same amount. Nothing is created out of nothing. The buyer takes the deduction now and hands it back at the sale in the form of a smaller basis and a larger gain.

Refinancing changes the answer, and it changes it for a reason a client can follow.

Points on a refinance are amortized over the loan term, $3,000 of points on a 30-year refinance deducts $100 a year; the unamortized balance deducts in full when the loan is paid off or refinanced again. Cash-out refinance proceeds are acquisition debt only to the extent they improve the home; interest on the rest is personal interest and non-deductible.

Amortizing a cost means spreading it evenly across the years the loan is expected to run and deducting one slice each year. The logic is the same logic behind depreciation. The benefit of the payment reaches across many years, so the deduction reaches across them too. The compensating rule is the one borrowers forget. When the loan is paid off or refinanced again, the slices never taken come due all at once and deduct in full in that year.

There is a partial case worth knowing. When part of the refinanced proceeds is used to improve the primary home and the loan meets the first six of the IRS conditions, the points attributable to that improvement can be deducted in the year paid, and the remainder is deducted over the life of the loan. One refinance, two treatments, split by where the money went. Tracing again, and the taxpayer carries the burden of showing it.

Interest on a refinanced loan keeps its deduction when the new loan replaces the previous one with an amount equal to or less than the previous loan. Most refinances are exactly that. A cash-out refinance is the case that needs thought, because the new dollars have to be traced on their own.

A home-equity loan or HELOC used to add a bedroom is acquisition debt within the $750,000 cap; the same loan used for tuition or a boat is not deductible. Home-improvement loans secured by the home follow the same test. Keep records showing where the money went, the burden is on the taxpayer.

Home improvement loans and construction financing follow the same test with one extra limit. Once the IRS conditions are met, points and interest paid to finance home improvements and new construction are deductible. For new construction, the IRS treats a home under construction as a qualified home for up to twenty-four months, and only if it becomes the owner's qualified home when it is ready for occupancy. A build that drags past that window stops producing the deduction the owner was counting on, which is a reason to raise the question early with a client building from the ground up.

Prepayment penalties belong in the same conversation. A homeowner who pays a mortgage off early is often charged a penalty for doing it. That penalty can be deducted as home mortgage interest, provided it is not a charge for a specific service performed or a cost related to the mortgage loan. The test is what the charge is actually for. A penalty for early payoff is interest in substance. A fee for preparing a document is a fee for preparing a document.

That leaves the largest group of closing costs, and it is the group clients are most often wrong about.

Title insurance, attorney fees, recording fees, transfer taxes and survey costs are not deductible; they are added to the buyer's basis or subtracted from the seller's amount realized. Prepaid interest and property-tax prorations are deductible in the year of closing by whoever pays them. Mortgage insurance premiums (FHA, VA, Rural Housing Service and private mortgage insurance) on acquisition debt were not deductible for 2022 through 2025; Public Law 119-21 makes them deductible again as mortgage interest for 2026 and later years. The deduction drops 10% for each $1,000 of adjusted gross income over $100,000 ($500 and $50,000 married filing separately), so it is gone once income passes $109,000.

Two items at a closing do deduct in the year of the closing, and both are ordinary. Prepaid interest is interest, and interest on a qualified home is deductible, so the days of interest collected at the table deduct that year. Property tax prorations are property tax, and property tax is deductible by the party who actually pays it, so each side deducts its own share of the year. Whoever pays takes the deduction. That is the whole rule.

The document that settles most of these questions is the settlement statement. The Closing Disclosure names each charge and says who paid it, which is why the points rules point at it directly and why an accountant asks for it before answering anything. Your practical contribution to a client's tax year is small and real. Make sure they leave the closing with the statement, and tell them to give it to whoever prepares their return.

Put the three destinations back together. Points on the purchase of a principal residence can deduct now. Points on a refinance, on a second home or on investment property spread across the loan. Title insurance, attorney fees, recording fees, transfer taxes and survey costs add to basis for a buyer, or come off the amount realized for a seller. Same closing, same pile of receipts, three different tax lives, and the client's accountant needs the settlement statement to sort them.

Investment property sorts the same three ways with one difference in emphasis. A buyer of a rental building does not add every closing cost to a personal basis and forget about it. Those costs go into the depreciable basis and come back as deductions across the recovery period, which is the subject of the last screen in this chapter. Same receipts, same three destinations, and a very different schedule on the way out.

Hypothetical. Your buyer paid points on her purchase and refinanced two years later, paying points again. She wants to know why her accountant treated the two differently. The first set bought a principal residence and met the conditions, so it deducted in the year paid. The second set bought a lower rate on a refinance, so it spreads across the term. And if she refinances again before the term runs, whatever is left of the second set deducts in full that year.

CAUTION: The rules on this screen follow IRS Publication 936 and the Code as they stand in 2026. The deductibility of points, mortgage insurance premiums and interest on particular kinds of loans has changed repeatedly and will change again. Every one of them is for the client's tax professional to confirm against the current rules.

Deduct now, spread out, or add to basis

REMEMBER: Your seller is closing next month and will pay a transfer tax, an attorney and a commission. Which of the three destinations do those costs go to, and which number on the gain formula do they change?

Low-Income Housing Incentives and Depreciation

A credit, a deduction, and the difference between them

Come back to the distinction from the second screen, because this screen puts both tools side by side. A deduction reduces the income the tax is computed on. A credit reduces the tax itself, dollar for dollar. That is why Congress reaches for a credit when it wants something built and a deduction when it wants an activity encouraged. Affordable housing gets the credit. Ordinary investment property gets the deduction.

The federal government offers incentives for the development and financing of low-income housing because the arithmetic does not work without them. A building costs what it costs to construct. Rents restricted to what lower-income households can pay will not service the debt on that cost. The credit fills the gap, and it fills it by handing investors something worth more than a deduction.

The main incentive has a name every agent in New York should recognize on a term sheet.

Created by the Tax Reform Act of 1986, the LIHTC (IRC §42) gives investors a dollar-for-dollar federal tax credit over ten years for building or rehabilitating rental housing that reserves units for tenants earning 50–60% of area median income for at least 30 years. New York's Division of Housing and Community Renewal allocates the credits; developers sell them to investors for equity, which is why most new affordable housing in the state is LIHTC-financed. New York also offers a state credit (SLIHC) and property-tax abatements such as 421-a's successor programs in New York City.

A project qualifies by meeting an occupancy and rent test, and there are three versions of it. At least twenty percent of the units have rents affordable to, and are occupied by, households with incomes no greater than half the area's gross median income. Or at least forty percent of the units are affordable to, and occupied by, families with incomes no greater than sixty percent of it. A third version, income averaging, lets at least forty percent of the units qualify on the average of income limits the owner designates. Any one version qualifies the project. None of them requires the entire building to be affordable, which is why mixed-income buildings are common.

The credits reach a building through the states. Each state receives an annual pool of credits based on its population, and the state awards them to investors and developers through a competitive process. The developer usually does not keep the credits. The developer sells them to investors for cash equity, and that equity is what closes the gap between what the building costs and what restricted rents can support. The credit is a financing tool disguised as a tax provision.

Two credit rates attach to different kinds of cost. The larger annual credit, set by statute at not less than 9 percent, applies to the cost of constructing new buildings or substantially rehabilitating existing property. The smaller one, not less than 4 percent, applies to the cost of acquiring or rehabilitating existing property. Credits are generated over a ten-year period, and the investors keep them only if the units are built, leased and maintained as affordable housing throughout a fifteen-year compliance period. The owner also commits to an extended use period that runs at least fifteen years past the compliance period, which is where the thirty years in the tax credit summary earlier on this screen comes from.

This matters to a salesperson more than it looks. New York has a great deal of this housing, and the units carry income restrictions, rent restrictions and eligibility rules that survive a change in building ownership. An agent marketing a unit in one of these buildings is marketing a restricted unit. Read the offering documents, and send the buyer's questions about their own eligibility to the managing agent and to counsel.

The other half of this screen is the deduction every investor counts on. Depreciation is the recovery of the cost of a capital asset over time, by expensing a set portion of it each year. The reason the code requires it rather than a single write-off is smoothing. If a business could expense an entire office building in the year it bought it, income would swing violently from one year to the next and the tax would swing with it.

Straight-line depreciation assumes an equal amount of the asset's price is expensed each year of its useful life. The same deduction every year, no front-loading and no acceleration. Only the improvements on property held for business and investment purposes can be depreciated, and for this purpose the code sorts investment property into two classes. Residential rental. And nonresidential, which in practice means commercial.

The Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System requires straight-line depreciation of real property: residential rental property over 27.5 years and non-residential real property over 39 years, using a mid-month convention in the first and last year. Only the improvement depreciates, allocate the purchase price between land and building using the assessor's ratio or an appraisal. Land improvements such as paving and landscaping depreciate over 15 years; appliances and carpeting over 5.

One word is doing two jobs in this chapter and it is worth separating them now. In appraisal and in ordinary speech, depreciation means a loss in value for any reason. In tax, depreciation means a scheduled recovery of cost that has nothing to do with what the building is worth. A property can appreciate every year of an owner's holding period and be depreciated every one of those years at the same time. The market value rises. The tax basis falls. Both are true and neither one affects the other.

That split is exactly why recapture exists. The owner has been writing down the cost of a building that was going up in value, so at the sale the gain is larger than it would have been and part of that gain is the depreciation coming home. An investor who understands the split is never surprised at the closing. An investor who thinks depreciation tracked a real decline in value always is.

Land is never depreciable, and the reason is the definition of depreciation itself. Depreciation recovers the cost of something that wears out over a useful life. Land does not wear out. Because land cannot be depreciated, any part of the purchase price attributable to land has to come out before the depreciable basis is computed. Skip the allocation and the owner is depreciating dirt, and that is a position no accountant will sign.

Computing depreciable basis starts with what was paid and then adjusts. Assuming debt raises the basis above the cash the buyer actually put in, because the buyer is on the hook for the whole price and not just the down payment. Settlement costs go in: survey fees, title insurance, legal fees and recording fees. Improvements or impairments between the purchase date and the date the property is placed in service adjust the figure again. The number an owner depreciates is rarely the number on the contract.

Allocating between land and building is the step owners skip, and there are two ordinary ways to do it. One is the assessor's ratio: the local assessment roll already splits the assessed value between land and improvements, and the same proportion can be applied to the purchase price. The other is an appraisal that states the two values directly. Either way the allocation is a documented position, not a guess, because it sets the deduction for decades to come.

The first year and the last year are partial years, and the convention that handles them is the mid-month convention. The code treats the property as placed in service in the middle of the month it actually went into service, no matter which day of the month that was, and it treats the disposition the same way. An owner who buys in October does not get a full year of depreciation in the year of purchase, and an owner who sells in March does not get a full year in the year of sale.

Improvements to either class are depreciated over the improvement's own useful life rather than the building's. New carpeting does not get stretched across the life of the building it sits in. It is depreciated on the rules for a five-year asset, because five years is about what carpeting lasts. The same logic sorts appliances, paving and landscaping into their own recovery periods. Those shorter-lived items can now be written off in full in the first year as bonus depreciation, for property acquired after January 19, 2025, under the 2025 reconciliation act. The building never qualifies, because bonus depreciation is limited to property with a recovery period of twenty years or less.

Here is what all of that produces on a real building.

A $1,200,000 mixed-use building with land worth $300,000 and a ground-floor store: the residential portion (say 70% of $900,000 = $630,000) depreciates at $630,000 ÷ 27.5 = $22,909 a year; the commercial portion ($270,000 ÷ 39) at $6,923, $29,832 of annual deduction with no cash outlay.

Work through what that actually gives the owner. The deduction is real and the cash outlay is zero. Nobody wrote a check for it. The building simply got a year older on paper and the owner's taxable income dropped. The cost arrives later. Every dollar of that deduction comes out of basis, so the gain at sale is larger by the same amount, and the portion of the gain depreciation created is taxed under the recapture rule from the fourth lesson. Deduct now, settle up at the closing.

That is also the number an investor asks you for on a first showing, and it is the number to refuse politely. An agent who quotes an annual depreciation deduction has allocated the price between land and building, decided the class of the property, and taken a position on the placed-in-service date, all on a sidewalk. Hand the investor the purchase price, the assessment roll split and the property class, and let an accountant build the schedule. You have given them everything they need and nothing you cannot stand behind.

Which is where this chapter ends, and it ends on the same note it started on.

Tax law changes yearly and every client's situation differs. Your obligation is to recognize when a transaction has tax consequences, a sale short of two years, an investor selling without an exchange, an inherited house, a rental converted to a residence, and to say, in writing, 'consult your tax advisor.' Giving tax advice you are not qualified to give is a breach of reasonable care.

Say the sentence and then put it in writing. I am not a tax professional, and you should have your accountant review this before you sign. It takes five seconds, it protects the client, and it protects your license. You are not paid to know the answer. You are paid to know there is a question, and to get it in front of somebody who can answer it while the client can still do something about it.

CAUTION: The set-aside tests, credit rates, compliance periods and recovery periods on this screen are current federal law as of 2026, and every one of them has been amended before. New York's own programs and abatements change with state and city legislation. Confirm each figure with the client's tax professional and with counsel before it reaches a decision.

NOTE: Two numbers from this screen are tested more than anything else in the chapter. Residential rental real property is recovered over the shorter period and nonresidential over the longer one, and land is never recovered at all. A question that puts a small apartment building on the nonresidential schedule, or that includes land in depreciable basis, is testing exactly those two facts.

A credit cuts tax; a deduction cuts income

REMEMBER: Your investor bought a small apartment house and wants to know his annual write-off. What is the first number you would have to separate out of the purchase price before anyone could compute it, and who computes it?

Check yourself

11 questions on this chapter. Pick an answer to see whether it is right and why.

Key terms

Principal residence exclusion
The $250,000 ($500,000 joint) exclusion of gain on the sale of a home owned and used as a principal residence for two of the last five years.
Adjusted basis
Purchase price plus acquisition costs and capital improvements, minus depreciation taken.
Acquisition debt
Debt incurred to buy, build or substantially improve a residence; interest is deductible on up to $750,000 for post-2017 loans.
Passive income
Income from rental activities and businesses in which the taxpayer does not materially participate; passive losses generally offset only passive income.
Depreciation recapture
Taxation of the gain attributable to prior depreciation deductions at a maximum 25% federal rate on sale of investment real property.
Like-kind exchange
A §1031 transaction deferring gain when investment real property is exchanged for other investment real property through a qualified intermediary within 45/180-day deadlines.
Boot
Cash, debt relief or other non-like-kind property received in an exchange; taxable to the extent of gain.
Qualified intermediary
An independent party who holds exchange proceeds and acquires the replacement property so the taxpayer never receives the funds.
Low-Income Housing Tax Credit
IRC §42's ten-year dollar-for-dollar federal credit for building or rehabilitating rent-restricted affordable housing, allocated in New York by DHCR.
Straight-line depreciation
Equal annual cost-recovery deductions over 27.5 years (residential) or 39 years (non-residential) on the improvement only.

Practise this chapter

Flashcards (free) Practice exam

Read Chapter 20 in the Book

The Book comes with the Salesperson pass ($39 for 3 months).

A study course, in beta. This is not a New York State Department of State approved qualifying course, and the time you spend here does not count toward the 77 hours you need for a salesperson license. Take the 77-hour course at a DOS-approved school; use this to learn the material and to review it. · Powered by License to Earn LLC